Subsidizing Solar Adoption

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this research we are trying to do is to give an operational perspective to policymaking in particular for the
  2. adoption of solar panels research were working on in general for green technology it's common to see subsidies
  3. that will help the technologies take dick off faster these technologies are very expensive in the beginning and they
  4. need some sort of public support in order for them to become economically viable we see a lot of policies out
  5. there they have a certain target in mind lakin in European in you had twenty percent of renewable by 2020 California
  6. was thirty-three percent he had a million rooftop programs that they wanted to cover a million rooftops with
  7. solar panels in Germany and this is sort of the inspiration we started from so instead of trying to understand where
  8. these policies come from we're trying to understand given the policy with a certain target how do you get there in
  9. the most efficient whale in the cheapest way for the for the taxpayers and some of the things that we we found that it's
  10. important to consider the feedback loops in this market dynamics you have more solar panels being adopted that makes it
  11. cheaper for the next solar panel to be sold on average that makes it a more word-of-mouth being spread about tech
  12. technology and a good policy maker practice should incorporate these feedback loops when designing the policy
  13. the key takeaway from from this research is that you should take into account these feedback loops such as learning by
  14. doing and information diffusion when designing a policy and the outcome of the the optimal policy that you designed
  15. to achieve a certain target is not it's not trivial in the sense that you would not just make a lump sum of an
  16. investment in the beginning and let the the market figure itself out you actually observe a certain pattern of
  17. yes early subsidies do stimulated option but they also increase the impact of future subsidies right so there's a
  18. certain way you would like to distribute the subsidies throughout the time horizon in order to reach to your target
  19. in in in the most efficient way so a typical economics approach to understanding policymaking starts with a
  20. definition of what's the system welfare and we abstracted a bit from that we took a we went to the next level of
  21. decision-making which is okay suppose that I don't know what's the welfare but I just have a given target I assume that
  22. this is a target of adoption that I need to get there and it's it's hopefully motivated on some kind of welfare
  23. optimization right the society will be better off by some objective measure and when we developed this framework what we
  24. try to do is we try to back out what would be the optimal welfare a function that would justify the current subsidy
  25. path right historically we see in Germany a certain level of subsidies being given out and I would like to try
  26. to understand what sort of economic welfare measure would justify that given historical path and we were surprised to
  27. see that there is no such welfare function that we justified that history there is a way to show just using this
  28. framework that more subsidies would have been required in the beginning it was stronger a subsidy policy perhaps and a
  29. stronger phase out in the later stages of the program that's the indications that we have we we have to put a
  30. qualifier on that that we don't do a flu full empirical study of the German solar
  31. market we have very limited access to data we just use aggregate data for the yearly adoptions in the average levels
  32. of subsidy but it's a it's a small indication that we can try to measure the efficiency of a policy program and
  33. characterize that it's it was somewhat inefficient even without having a clear measure of welfare
  34. so the most practical implication is try not to be myopic that's the most important recommendations try to
  35. understand what our future implications of your policies today in the market dynamics a lot of policy sometimes has
  36. decided what is the level of the subsidy that we are going to do here let's try to give investor a certain rate of
  37. return and we'll hope that that gets us close to our target right but when you do this over years you have to
  38. understand that the early adopters will create an impact on future adoption and if you don't take that into account then
  39. you'll you're you're either miss your target or you're going to spend a lot more money than you should
  40. so companies need to also understand how learning happens in their industry and how it will affect future policy
  41. decisions so one of the most problematic things we have in the this area of of subsidy policies is the abrupt changes
  42. in subsidy policies that has something to do with some of the future research that I'm working on and trying to
  43. understand how changes in policy making affect the industry and vice versa right
  44. so there's a strategic interaction between how companies are behaving and how policymakers will respond and vice
  45. versa for consumers I think it's it's important for consumers to try to understand how to time the market a lot
  46. of consumers from anecdotal evidence we've seen that consumers are trying to wait for solar panels to be cheaper and
  47. they're not necessarily doing the optimal thing as well from what we have observed that like the rate of subsidies
  48. have been decreasing faster than the cost of the installation so in a way timing yourself into this market is not
  49. necessarily as as easy as you might think so we are doing a few other studies in
  50. other Smart Grid applications electric vehicles there's another small study we do where we use the application of the
  51. of the adoption of electric cars and it's a very similar type of market dynamics that's happening and the same
  52. lessons of you need to incorporate like learning by doing an information diffusion are also important to be
  53. considering in these situations you can also think about companies trying to acquire micro chair in a certain with a
  54. certain product right they do they do they'll have to think about it in a similar framework that with what we do
  55. in this paper and that's some of the the extrapolation from this paper that can go into other areas
  56. the actual subsidy program in Germany has taken a lot of flak and in the recent years for overspending at the
  57. time of crisis and that's something that needs to be taken with a grain of salt that they have developed a huge industry
  58. of solar installation and they've driven down the costs of installations way further down than other places like
  59. California for example and if you if you compare how they've done it it was through strong you know time timely
  60. interventions in the beginning and in this paper I talked about it perhaps could have been even faster in the
  61. beginning and slower later on and they've only started to do a more aggressive phase out in the last few
  62. years although they had a plan phase out today they could have done a little bit
  63. faster and avoided some of this perhaps criticism now the main criticism is that
  64. these solar panels that customers bought became too profitable for them and all the other ratepayers in the country are
  65. going to be paying huge penalty for for for the adoption of of these solar panels and it's it's hard to quantify
  66. how successful program is it's hard to quantify what are the other benefits that this industry that the merchant in
  67. Germany will have right an example of a country that had the not a successful program was Spain which started about
  68. the similar time was very aggressive into the into the market perhaps in some cases even more aggressive than Germany
  69. they had more solar irradiation so then then then Germany so could potentially be more efficient installed panels in
  70. Spain yet the industry was growing too fast and without developing a local manufacturing local technology and they
  71. go backed out and brought the entire industry to near collapse right so that's that's a clear lesson of like how
  72. not to do it right as opposed to what the Germany did in this paper we talked about these
  73. feedback loops like learning by doing an information diffusion and in the next few papers that we're working on we
  74. explore a few different parts of the market for example we look at how demanding certainty will affect the
  75. subsidy programs we look at how policy flexibility versus commitment will affect the industry all right for
  76. example say your policy making you have a certain target we were given deadline would you like to readjust your policy
  77. as you approach the target deadline to make sure that you you hit your target or would you like to commit the longer
  78. term policy and what we actually do show in that situation is that you would rather commit to a longer term policy
  79. because by commitment you do lose some flexibility in the long run but you you give a signal to the to the forms in the
  80. market that they need to put in their fair share and they need to absorb some of the risk when you when you're in your
  81. policy maker and you'll hold too much flexibility on your policy and you readjust your policy very often you send
  82. it back bad signal to the industry right so that's a new future direction of the
  83. research that we are currently working on you

Brief Summary

The episode covers solar panel adoption policies, emphasizing the importance of strategic subsidies and market dynamics for effective implementation.

Key points

  • Understanding Solar Subsidies. This research aims to provide an operational perspective on solar panel adoption policies.
  • Feedback Loops in Policy Design. Incorporating feedback loops is crucial for effective policymaking in renewable energy.
  • Lessons from Germany and Spain. Germany's approach to solar subsidies contrasts sharply with Spain's failed program.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes