Going Cold Turkey Off Carbon Addiction

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'd like to welcome read hunt to knowledge at Wharton today read is the CEO of a company called Coalition for
  2. green capital that's a nonprofit corporation and I think the title suggests what it's about but he's also
  3. formerly a chairman of the FCC the Federal Communications Commission that was in the mid 90s under President
  4. Clinton so I'd like to start out asking you about your ebook which is titled zero hour time to build the clean power
  5. platform and you right in there you have an interesting provocative first sentence I thought which is that modern
  6. life rests on two electromagnetic wave platforms knowledge and power the power platform is where the knowledge platform
  7. was in 1993 would you explain the thinking behind that so you're suggesting that where we were with
  8. computer technology in that sort of thing back in the early 90s is where we are with the power platform or green
  9. energy perhaps that's exactly right let's go on a little time travel trip at least in our imagination take with you
  10. on this trip you're of phone or your computer or your television set and go back 20 years and it won't work and
  11. that's because the communications platform of 20 years ago has been completely overhauled I don't want to
  12. digital everything that was analog is not digital that's true for television that's true for cellular phones all the
  13. standards for all the communications equipment everything is completely different how did that happen one
  14. trillion dollars of investment in the United States in about 10 years roughly 1995 the 2005 we completely rebuilt as
  15. an economy and as a society the knowledge platform who made those investments oh those investments were
  16. made by lots of different people some of them became very very rich some of them
  17. lost all their money one thing we know is that that tremendous wave of investment increased the average income
  18. for every quintile in the an economy it's the only decade since the 1950s in which every quintile in the
  19. American economic ladder has seen its income go up so economically was a very good thing and of course for
  20. productivity gains and for changing life as we know it was very very good what I'm saying is that it we're at the exact
  21. same starting point with respect to the other electromagnetic waves those that give us electricity so this is very
  22. interesting and provocative and I think that one of the key things that that you
  23. talk about in the book and one of the key idea is about how to get from here to there is that this idea of a green
  24. bank is that right yes uh you know what is a bank a bank takes deposits and it makes loans a green bank would be a bank
  25. that gets money from somebody and then loans money out to clean energy projects who's that somebody well uh in the case
  26. of the states where our nonprofit is now working the state of Connecticut the state of New York the state of
  27. California the state of Vermont the state is contributing capital or planning to contribute capital to a
  28. green bank and then the money is being loaned out in the state of New York they just loaned out several hundred million
  29. dollars to private investors who are putting in even more money for a total of about a billion dollars of capital to
  30. go into clean energy markets so the idea is that the state which I guess could be
  31. on the federal level contrite now we're talking on a state level would invest money and it would either make money or
  32. break even in this bank presumably so there's really at least over the long term though cost to taxpayers perhaps
  33. something initially but that that money would be paid back that's exactly right okay so but it takes the government to
  34. participate because why there's no profits at first and so there's no interest by any company to do something
  35. like this is that the idea i'm not quite but here the reasons reason number one is a most clean energy projects are
  36. unfamiliar to most commercial banks they're not in the business already of loaning to people for putting solar
  37. panels on their roof they're not in the business of loaning to a community to build a community solar farm that maybe
  38. isn't very big but would serve a town or or or a small city so they're not adept
  39. at evaluating what the risks might be and they don't know how they just don't have anyone on staff that does risk
  40. analysis and number two since the great recession began in 2008 2009 many many banks have worried a great deal about
  41. their own balance sheet and they've been averse to taking on risks in lending so
  42. that's further inhibited their willingness to get into clean energy lending as a as a category a third
  43. problem is that many clean energy projects are kind of small you want to put solar on your roof and maybe is a
  44. twenty-thousand-dollar project a big commercial bank would say you know that's a home improvement loan that's
  45. not the kind of loans we make go somewhere for a home improvement loan but when you go somewhere for a home
  46. improvement loan they don't consider solar on the roof to be a home improvement loan all this can change but
  47. if we want to get the clean energy markets growing quickly and we do if we want to deal with climate change then
  48. the state wants to step in and say well I'll just kind of nudge it here at the beginning but I'm not going to do
  49. anything unless the private sector is going to join up with me and provide a lot of the money to so think of the
  50. state or the government is being the leader but not leading to much just getting in basically getting in the
  51. water and saying to the commercial lenders the water is fine come on in that's what we've seen happen in
  52. Connecticut which is the oldest state greenbank it's three years old and we have found that for every dollar of
  53. state lending we attract about ten dollars of private sector lending and how many dollars in projects have been
  54. committed so far in Connecticut which is not a very big stage right it's about it's almost three hundred million
  55. dollars and that's 43 million people in the state and what kinds of projects is this green bank funding what is this 300
  56. million funding two things in particular one is what we call the whole building overhaul that might be a strip mall
  57. where they put solar on the roof and they exchange the windows single paint windows for double pane windows and
  58. maybe there's a fuel oil boiler that's replaced in you know some central location so it's a whole building
  59. overhaul and then that lending is put on the tax bill by provision in the state statute and as I said the Connecticut
  60. green bank will make the initial loan but later the private sector will come in and be part of the lending structure
  61. so the building becomes more valuable and the occupants pay a lower amount for electricity and eventually the taxpayers
  62. are made whole what's what's the break even on something like that in other words at what point you know how many
  63. years the idea do you pay back the loan and then after that you're actually quote-unquote making money bit by saving
  64. money on energy well the Connecticut green bank doesn't make any loan unless the net present value of the savings is
  65. greater than the amount of money invested everybody wharton knows what that means right it means you have a net
  66. present value positive number at the very beginning otherwise we don't put the money in at the beginning at the
  67. very beginning its net present value positive now the payback will vary between four and seven years meaning the
  68. cash shot will have come back in that time period and then after that time period it's all gravy okay I think
  69. that's a financial term Frankie you asked me what projects that's it that's probably our number one example okay the
  70. number two example is distributed solar on residential roof tops did were there any other efforts to promote solar on
  71. rooftops taken I'm just familiar with complaints about in the u.s. in general compared to a place like Jeremy that
  72. there's just a lot of regulation that slows down the ability to get get these things
  73. rolling fast which is what you're trying to do with the funding did they do anything about regulations in
  74. Connecticut yeah we have been trying to slim down the permitting process which can take a long time or it can cost a
  75. lot of money yeah and we do that through a project called solar eyes so the Connecticut green bank goes to a town
  76. and it says to the mayor if you promise that you will expedite the permitting process then we will loan money in bulk
  77. to everybody in your town and then the mayor says that sounds like a pretty good deal if I cut the red tape I get
  78. some of the green and we say that's absolutely right that's interesting because i know in germany a permit can
  79. take two or three days i think last time i looked right here in this country I they'd the averages months Germany
  80. shouldn't Merman II was ahead of the United States and pretty much every other country and in the Western world
  81. in terms of expediting permitting but Germany made I say this with respect for their motives Germany made a big mistake
  82. consoler which is that they decided that the way to grow a solar industry was to
  83. have a guaranteed price that was very very high called a feed-in tariff and the problem with that is your the
  84. government is buying the electricity and then giving it to the consumer at a lower price than the government is
  85. paying that's a buy high sell low strategy that's true in governments and in business as a way to eventually go
  86. out of business so when that's not what we're talking about in Connecticut we're
  87. talking about in Connecticut and in the other states what you said earlier making the taxpayer whole having the
  88. consumer be getting cleaner and cheaper electricity so this is innovative financing in the positive sense that's
  89. right yeah but it's you know not unusual governments play a big role in financing
  90. roads and bridges and public schools and the host of other facilities in the social landscape so having governments
  91. extend their role to a modest degree into changing the energy platform of the United States from
  92. carbon and expensive to clean and cheaper I don't think it's asking governments to do something unheard of
  93. and I can't help noticing the parallel between what happened in the IT world which is that it was actually the
  94. government jokes notwithstanding that invented the internet and you know provided the basic research that led to
  95. the internet as it does in lots of areas like medical research pharmaceuticals and all that a lot of the basic research
  96. is paid for by the government and then companies come in and figure out how to commercialize you know in the IT world I
  97. would say that you can credit or blame the government for two big things number one as you said the initial research
  98. into the technologies that ultimately gave birth to the internet as a commercial phenomenon that initial
  99. research was paid for by the taxpayer a long time ago a Defense Department wasn't it yep and when the taxpayer was
  100. paying for that research the taxpayer you mean everybody else we didn't really have any idea what would happen and
  101. neither did the experimenters who were doing the work that's the first of two things the second thing was done during
  102. the Clinton administration and here's what it was the government decided that the internet could borrow the existing
  103. infrastructure the telephone network for free and so the early days were that you
  104. would unplug your telephone line from the back of the device called the telephone and you'd plug it into your
  105. computer at no charge there were a bunch of other regulatory measures like that but the collective decision in the
  106. Clinton administration was let's let the existing infrastructure be used by the usurpation revolutionary change oriented
  107. new technology that's what we need to do in energy we need to have the grid be borrowed for free by the distributed
  108. solar people and the other new technologies let's say we did that because look at you talked initially
  109. about how much change has happened in 20 years so let's fast-forward 10 or 20 or
  110. 30 years ahead with clean energy what percentage of US energy do you think would be delivered via green methods
  111. whether you know alternative methods whether its wind solar water you know whatever it might be okay well hold on
  112. to your hat because actually I've spent a lot of time crunching the numbers with
  113. people if the solar distributed solar industry today is about one percent market share of energy it's reasonable
  114. to think that that can double every 12 months doubling every three months gets you to a very big number in 10 or 20
  115. years very very big number it's also reasonable that the wind sector in the United States can be ultimately about
  116. twenty to twenty-five percent of the total energy sector you put those two things together and the majority of all
  117. electricity in the United States can be made by the Sun and the wind and that's within how many years um it depends on
  118. how fast growing you actually think it all could be with the appropriate array of state where even let's say a
  119. mid-level scenario right oh I would say a decade a decade the reason the decade it could be the majority of electricity
  120. is that right an electricity provides what percentage of our power well well good way to think about it is the
  121. transportation is about a third and all the rest is some electricity used in some particular wank so for example
  122. electricity is used in industrial processes or it's used in lighting or it's used in some cases in heating so
  123. there's lots of ways that electricity mmm sneaks into the usage patterns but more or less transportation as a third
  124. or forty percent in the rest is driven by electricity and even that transportation could be largely electric
  125. right well what if we if we really wanted to run you know tell an optimistic story about electricity which
  126. I think we should want to do then I think that what the way to think about it is that in about two and a half years
  127. when the electric vehicles that come into the mark will be priced at around 40 thousand
  128. dollars then you'll see a tremendous increase in the percentage of annual vehicle sales that is attributable to
  129. electric cars so this is seems so much more optimistic or quicker than the kinds of numbers that you usually hear
  130. it's time to be optimistic a lot of things have changed in the last three or four years that have given rise to
  131. optimism one is an eighty percent drop in the cost of solar panels that should give rise to optimism the other thing is
  132. the innovative business models by solar installers and by other clean energy companies I do want to say this there's
  133. one fundamental obstacle which is the existing energy industry is carbon based and the existing energy industry is not
  134. going to be a big huge winner if the clean energy industry substitutes for its role in the economy that's that's
  135. what happens in business somebody wins and somebody's place is taken how do how how would advocates of green energy
  136. overcome that huge obstacle Oh consumer demand there are two ways to overcome it
  137. one is you get the government to tell everybody thou must buy clean energy and if we have to deal with climate change I
  138. guess we might have to imagine that but there's this easier way in a market driven economy you delight the consumer
  139. you please the consumer you make the consumer clamor for the better deal if I went to anybody in the United States and
  140. said could I just give you electricity that is cleaner anyone's going to say yeah but is it cost more suppose I say
  141. it's cleaner and cheaper who's going to say no to this and this is what's very doable is what you're saying even on a
  142. large scale it's totally doable on a large scale it's the secret of SolarCity just to give you an example of a company
  143. Solar City could you just give us a brief well solar city is the rocketship story of solar installers but it's being
  144. emulated by other companies all across the country and unlike a lot of other Americans I opened up an envelope
  145. home just last week and it said would you like to meet somebody from SolarCity because you know if you have a high
  146. enough credit score will give you a clean electricity off your roof and it'll be cheaper than you're paying from
  147. the grid this is not a bad offer could you give us just a quick idea of what you thought about the us-china climate
  148. agreement it's a historic agreement in there are two reasons reason number one when the president united states and the
  149. leader of China President Obama and she have a handshake understanding about reducing carbon emissions 20 by huge
  150. huge numbers in less than will in about a decade when that happens the two countries the two economies that are
  151. responsible for forty percent of all global emissions have taken a step farther toward the necessary clean
  152. energy future than any other country or any other region of the world that's a really big deal now we are leaders with
  153. China and everybody else should step up in every other country and match our promises that's reason number one reason
  154. number two what the president said in Beijing is that the United States would increase its goal of cutting emissions
  155. by fifty percent over the previous stated goal in other words he's now saying that in just 11 years will reduce
  156. emissions by twenty-seven percent approximately it's a very very big number it puts us done a very ambitious
  157. path but one in which it actually is possible for Americans to have cheaper and cleaner electricity
  158. you

Brief Summary

Reed Hunt discusses clean energy investments and the role of green banks in transforming the U.S. energy landscape.

Key points

  • The Role of Green Banks. Green banks are essential for funding clean energy projects, bridging the gap for private investment.
  • US-China Climate Agreement. A historic agreement between the US and China aims to significantly reduce carbon emissions.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes