Creating Jobs: Is Small Beautiful?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A study on small and medium enterprises in India demolishes some myths about job creation. 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. well I've always been interested in the role of government policies in promoting
  2. uh well-being so India in particular is an interesting case because there have been extensive regulatory changes and
  3. policies to try to make people better off but the kinds of regulations that India has directed towards small and
  4. medium Enterprises are typical of the kinds of policies that many countries actually have for their small and medium
  5. firms so it's a more General and important question so the key findings for This
  6. research which as you mentioned is co-authored with uh Shanti nataraj and Leslie Martin the key finding of that
  7. research is that the promotion of small and medium Enterprises by reserving certain
  8. products only for them didn't have the expected results so the idea behind the Indian government's policies which were
  9. known as smallscale reservation was to take a large number of products maybe thousand products and only small and
  10. medium Enterprises could produce them um so this was tried to Foster these small
  11. firms so it was expected that by removing those policies which the Indian government did in the 2000s they got rid
  12. of all of them we would have thought that actually firms would suffer and wouldn't grow as quickly the result is
  13. quite surprising what the result shows is that on net employment and wages actually grew faster once these
  14. restrictions were removed what our research shows is that employment generation is really um
  15. focused on either young firms New firms or larger Enterprises and you might wonder why is it that employment is
  16. being generated in India by these younger firms or these larger firms when conventional wisdom suggests that it
  17. would be small and medium Enterprises would be the source of of growth well we think that the reason we're getting
  18. these unexpected findings is because um essentially young firms are really the key innovators in India probably in
  19. other countries as well and so it's youth that's really important and also larger firms have the
  20. connections needed to enter the market they have the connections needed to be able to access Capital knowledge and a
  21. well educated worker so when you think about it it actually seems almost obvious in the end that it's the young
  22. larger firms that are more likely to generate employment growth we think that our research really
  23. has much broader applications although of course India is an extremely important country we think this research
  24. is also relevant to many other countries including countries like the united states and countries like France and
  25. many other countries which really promote small and medium Enterprises uh so in fact we know that
  26. this research is relevant because our research is also linked to other Recent research that's been done for example in
  27. the United States by John Al Wanger at the University of Maryland his research along with his co-authors also shows
  28. that in the US case it's the younger larger firms that are generating more employment the advantage of our research
  29. is that we actually have what's called a natural experiment the elimination of a
  30. regulatory framework which allows us to look at before and after which uh other researchers have not been able to
  31. exploit to understand um this problem so the policy implications are that if you want to promote employment
  32. growth then restricting the product the the production of certain goods for certain size firms is not the way to go
  33. the way to go would be to encourage entry by younger firms um or to encourage larger Enterprises and that's
  34. more likely to yield the kind of outcomes that governments are looking for for so there's a perception among
  35. economists among policy makers that that small is beautiful what our research suggests is that that is clearly not the
  36. case if you're trying to maximize employment growth if you want to maximize employment growth you really
  37. want to focus on the younger firms but that's not to say we shouldn't be promoting small and medium Enterprises
  38. the best way to promote them is basically not to discriminate against them so don't make it harder on small
  39. and medium Enterprises to enter in because we want new Enterprises but explicit policies to encourage being
  40. small are not a good idea so tax holidays that are only focused on small and medium Enterprises for example are
  41. not a good way to go that's what our research suggests so I'm very excited about uh an
  42. ongoing research project also on India where we are looking at the effects of hundreds of regulations to try to
  43. improve the environment in India there have been many different regulatory changes some of them mandated by the
  44. Supreme Court others done at the state and local level and we're particularly interested in trying to identify what
  45. kinds of changes uh either through regulations or price changes can make firms behave in a cleaner more
  46. environmentally friendly way um so that's our that's our ongoing uh project uh on India I'm also doing a number of
  47. other research projects on China looking in particular at the success of their industrial policies which is an area
  48. that I find uh particularly important [Music]

Brief Summary

Indian policies favoring small firms hindered employment growth; young and larger firms drive job creation instead.

Key points

  • Unexpected Findings on Employment Growth. Research shows that removing restrictions on small firms led to faster employment growth in India.
  • Youth and Larger Firms Drive Growth. Younger and larger firms are key innovators and sources of employment in India.

Related episodes