How Wealth and Education -- Not Access -- Drive Healthy Food Choices

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Policy makers need to focus on spreading awareness of healthy foods among low-income and low-education households, suggests new research by Wharton’s Jessie Handbury. More: http://knlg.net/1G7Y8gk 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. in this project that I've been working on with Coors from the USDA and Princeton we've
  2. been looking at to what extent different households across the US bu different food products particularly focusing on
  3. how healthy are the food products that these different households are buying what we're interested in here is how
  4. different or how more or less healthy the food product products that high income more educated households are
  5. buying relative to low income less educated households and the goal of This research is to not just document those
  6. disparities but to try to think about the role that access to Food Stores plays in generating those disparities
  7. we've seen a number of government policies Government funding going towards subsidizing the entry of
  8. supermarkets into areas that are underserved in this regard so these areas have commonly known as food
  9. deserts and uh our goal in the paper is to think about to what extent will eradicating food deserts actually have a
  10. you know a positive impact in terms of improving the healthfulness of the products that your lowi income low
  11. education households households are buying and and closing the gap between High income High educated households and
  12. low- income low educated ourselves in terms of how healthy the food products that they're eating um
  13. are so the first takeaway is uh pretty simple it's just that we see pretty large disparities and differences in
  14. terms of what households at the higher end of the socioeconomic spectrum and the lower end of the socio economic
  15. spectrum are buying we uh use a lot of data looking at what individual households are
  16. purchasing and uh we merge that data with a data set that describes how healthy each of these products are this
  17. enables us to calculate an index that represents how healthy are the food products being purchased over the course
  18. of a month by a household and what we see is we see big differences in these healthfulness indexes between High
  19. socioeconomic status households and low socioeconomic status households olds so we see in particular that
  20. households with the um higher income so in the top Ts for income relative to the
  21. bottom tsal for income or the top toile for Education versus the bottom tsal for
  22. Education are actually purchasing food products that are about 40% closer to the USDA recommend
  23. recommendations for what households are recommended to spend on different food categories um then households in um that
  24. are lower in educational income so then when we you know take a step back and we
  25. think about well why do these differences exist and we try to link it to um looking at differences in access
  26. to food products there what we find is that we find that access actually plays a very
  27. small role in generating generating these differences so what we do there is we think about well we see this 40% gap
  28. between High soci economic status and lo economic status households when we're looking at households that live uh you
  29. know in different locations across the us but what if you look at different households with different socioeconomic
  30. characteristics that are living in the same location because presumably these households are going to have access to
  31. the same retail environment so they'll live down the road from the same Supermarket for example and so when we
  32. look at the disparities that exist between households that are living in the same location and presumably have
  33. access to the same um retail environment we see that most of the disparities actually persist they're just as large
  34. they're slightly smaller but they're almost as large as the dispares that we saw when we looked at the differences in
  35. what's purchased by households that live in different locations so what this suggests is it s suggests that um that
  36. access actually isn't playing a large role in generating these disparities in the first
  37. place perhaps the most surprising uh result that we found was uh to do with the the fact that we look separately at
  38. how high and low income households um differ in their food purchases and how more and less educated households differ
  39. in their food purchases and what we found is we found that the differences along the education Dimension right much
  40. larger than the differences that we observe along the income Dimension and particularly the differences along the
  41. education Dimension are much more persistent when you control for Access and the differences across the income
  42. Dimension so essentially what that means is that it means that when you have two
  43. households living in the same location that are of different income types right they're going to be purchasing more
  44. similar products than house olds um with the different income types that live in
  45. different locations however when you look at two households living in the same location that are more and less
  46. educated say you have a college educated and a high school educated household um
  47. those different households are going to purchase just as different products as they might if they lived in different
  48. locations so what this goes to suggest which I found quite surprising was uh that perhaps when you think about
  49. differences in the healthfulness of products that people are buying you hear a lot about income as being sort of the
  50. big factor um that differentiates households there but the disparities are actually larger and more persistent when
  51. you're looking at households with different education levels so one of the reasons that we
  52. embarked on this research agenda was uh the fact that we're observing state local as well as the federal government
  53. embarking on these policies to subsidize the entry of of food stores into different neighborhoods so you know to
  54. the extent that these policies are being aimed at reducing disparities in what households are consuming by reducing the
  55. disparities in what households have access to our result suggests that the policies won't necessarily be so
  56. effective if they're only just targeting entry of food stores so the key takeaway
  57. for these policy makers is to think not just about can we put a new grocery store you know nearby you know all of
  58. the different households in the US but what's in that grocery store um what prices are being offered and what's
  59. driving different households to purchase different products once they're in the store so there are other policies that
  60. potentially need to be paired with the grocery store entries such as perhap perhaps subsidizing at the prices of
  61. healthful food products or putting them displaying them more prominently in stores to encourage households that
  62. perhaps don't have a taste to buy those products to try them out and uh um to become more aware of
  63. them so the research has been done to date thinking about differences in Access and the role that improving
  64. access might play in improving the healthfulness of food products that households Buy has been on a much
  65. smaller scale than our study so um the research has been done has been thinking about when one Supermarket for example
  66. enters in a neighborhood of New York you know the researchers will go and they'll
  67. survey households that were shopping in that neighborhood before the supermarket
  68. entered and then after the supermarket entered and comparing their their food purchases what we're doing is on a much
  69. larger scale we're thinking about how these uh the entry of food stores changes the consumption of households
  70. all across the US so uh our results are much more generalizable in terms of thinking about how the average household
  71. might respond to supermarket entry rather than just thinking about how a household in a particular neighborhood
  72. might respond to supermarket entry so this paper and our results here have uh really
  73. uh left open the question of what actually does Drive most of the disparities in terms of what households
  74. are buying so if we have households that are shopping in the exact same store buying very different food products we
  75. see systematic differences between High socioeconomic status households and low socioeconomic status households and what
  76. they're buying in spite of them having access to the same food products and the same prices available to them the
  77. question is then why they buying different products so we have two main hypotheses here both of which been have
  78. been discussed in the media previously one is that you have a low soci economic status households not having the money
  79. enough money to spend on healthful food products perhaps healthful food products
  80. cost more in the supermarket they take more time to prepare and that means that low-income households are potentially
  81. priced out of purchasing these food products another hypothesis is that these different
  82. households have different tastes perhaps due to different social norms perhaps they grew up buying different food
  83. products eating different food products so they're just they don't like healthy foods and they prefer to eat unhealthy
  84. Foods so the question is which of these explanations explains more of the differences in what we observe and the
  85. reason this is important is because if we actually want to come up with a policy that's going to you know shorten
  86. or reduce the gap between what these different households are purchasing is going to that policy is going to look
  87. very different if the differences are driven by differences in tastes versus differences
  88. in affordability and so if it's differences in affordability you might want to think
  89. about taxing unhealthy Foods or subsidizing healthy foods whereas if it's differences in tastes then perhaps
  90. some of these policies such as um um improving uh the uh um the access within stores of healthful food products making
  91. them more prominently displayed or education campaigns to perhaps try to shift social norms um amongst lower
  92. socioeconomic households towards buying healthier foods [Music]

Brief Summary

Household food purchasing disparities are influenced more by education than access to stores, challenging existing policy approaches.

Key points

  • Impact of Food Deserts. The study explores whether eradicating food deserts improves healthfulness of food products.
  • Disparities in Food Purchases. Research reveals significant differences in food purchases between high and low socioeconomic households.
  • Education vs. Income Disparities. Surprisingly, education level impacts food choices more than income level.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes