Understanding the Housing Affordability Crisis in Today’s Housing Market

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton real estate professor Ben Keys breaks down the housing affordability crisis, exploring how mortgage rates, supply and demand imbalances, and financing challenges are reshaping the housing market.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

#housingmarket #homeownership #mortgage #realestatetrends ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Yeah. Well, we're in an affordability crisis when it comes to uh to the residential housing market. Um many
  2. households are paying an extraordinary fraction of their income towards housing expenses, whether that's rents or or
  3. whether that's their their mortgage uh their mortgage payments. And um in a piece I wrote for the Aspen Economic
  4. Strategy Group with Vincent Raina um that came out in November, we outlined a list of potential solutions for dealing
  5. with affordability. Um, but ultimately it comes down to an imbalance in supply and demand. Uh, we simply don't have
  6. enough uh affordable housing units in the cities where people want to live. Welcome to the Ripple Effect, a podcast
  7. that takes you on a journey [music] through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Looney, and in each
  8. episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking [music] research that Wharton professors
  9. have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. We have seen the real estate market have
  10. quite the up and down ride the last few years. Home prices soared of course during the time of the pandemic and
  11. haven't lost a whole lot since. Meanwhile, the commercial market has had to deal with the work from home dynamic
  12. change how some companies think about their real estate footprint. So, what lies in the sector ahead? Pleasure to be
  13. joined [music] by Ben Keys, professor of real estate here at the Wharton School.
  14. Ben, great to catch up with you. How are you, sir? >> I'm doing well. Thanks for having me,
  15. Dan. Happy New Year. >> Happy New Year to you as well. It's interesting when you think about this
  16. industry right now, the word that seemingly comes up on so many different interviews in so many different places
  17. is seeing stability. Stability being that key word it seems like for 2026. Well, I think that's right. And and it's
  18. stable in the sense that we're not expecting big swings in in house prices, especially in the residential side of of
  19. the market. This is a market that is struggling on a number of different fronts. And I'm not sure if it's
  20. stability or or stasis or if it's stuck. Um, but all of those things uh ultimately lead to a similar pattern
  21. where we're going to expect national house prices to be relatively flat over the coming year. And those national
  22. house prices being flat are going to sort of hide a lot of interesting variation across the country. All right.
  23. So, we normally talk commercial and residential. Let me start with residential. Uh mortgage rates have come
  24. down a little bit. They're still higher than what we saw, you know, during the time of the pandemic. Uh we still have
  25. what's perceived to be a a fairly important shortage of properties. Uh these seem to be like two of the biggest
  26. issues out there right now. Yeah. Well, we're in an affordability crisis when it
  27. comes to uh to the residential housing market. Um, many households are paying an extraordinary fraction of their
  28. income towards housing expenses, whether that's rents or or whether that's their
  29. their mortgage uh their mortgage payments. And um in a piece I wrote for the Aspen Economic Strategy Group with
  30. Vincent Raina um that came out in November, we outlined a list of potential solutions for dealing with
  31. affordability. Um but ultimately it comes down to an imbalance in supply and demand. uh we simply don't have enough
  32. uh affordable housing units in the cities where people want to live. >> What are some of those ideas that you
  33. think are going to be important moving forward? >> Well, I think there are a lot of
  34. different proposals on the table. Some of those we're seeing from the administration just this week, sort of
  35. policy by tweet. Uh but if you if you think a little bit more substantively about about the challenges, it is really
  36. about supply. Um and uh and sometimes uh you know there are there are folks in the in the housing market that refuse to
  37. believe in the dynamics of supply and demand and the ways in which they play out. But ultimately affordability in the
  38. housing market is is is a function of supply and we need to make it easier to build. Um we need to ensure that
  39. construction financing is available um through the through the interest rate cycle and and broader business cycle. Um
  40. we need to do more to expand the the housing safety net. Um and I think we need to make home ownership a priority
  41. when it comes to um the challenges that um first-time buyers face in competing with uh with investors. So one of the
  42. things that has been a question in my mind for a long time is if you go back you know 60 70 years uh a lot of that
  43. affordability was assisted by the starter home. And it seems like we've done away with the starter home for the
  44. most part. you know that that property that you're just talking about that first property that somebody's looking
  45. to buy gets them indoor to home ownership and then they can live in that house for maybe 10 years whatever and
  46. build up to that next house. Now it seems like everything is $400 $500,000 and above and that's hard for a lot of
  47. people to consider to be a starter home. >> Absolutely. That first rung on on the
  48. housing ladder uh that you know gets your foot in the door to home ownership. It gives you an opportunity to build
  49. some equity and it also gives you a chance to access a neighborhood that you might not otherwise have been able to
  50. access. When it comes to school quality, when it comes to safety, when it comes to some other amenities, those are
  51. harder and harder to find. We are seeing a small decline in the size of new homes
  52. being built. So, new homes are shrinking just a little bit on average. But that said, I think your point is is a good
  53. one, which is um that the that most affordable tier of of housing is not what's being built. And a lot of that is
  54. a function of the high fixed costs of construction. It's difficult for builders to get uh approved. Um so to
  55. get permits um and zoning challenges, something we've discussed for a long time is a big barrier. When you raise
  56. those fixed costs, it means there's a higher hurdle to construction. We've also seen construction costs rise
  57. sharply um really over the last 10 years. um you know house uh con house housing construction costs are up about
  58. 60%. Over the last 10 years and that's a function of both materials, labor, land
  59. and everything in between. And now you add financing costs with high interest rates. And all of those things point to
  60. developers choosing to build at the high end rather than the low end. Well, you mentioned uh the uh policy by tweet. Uh
  61. there are obviously a couple of things in the most recent period that we heard from the administration. uh one being uh
  62. that you know people that are connected to the president buying uh mortgage back
  63. securities to maybe help uh lower rates, but the other thing was that President Trump brought up was corporate ownership
  64. in single family homes and trying to maybe ease that out a little bit. I I don't know where both of those
  65. components live. I don't know if you wanted to speak about either one of those, but the government seemingly is
  66. going to play a role in trying to alleviate some of these issues, isn't it? >> I I think that's right. What's clear is
  67. that the the problem has been diagnosed by the administration that we have an affordability problem. You know, maybe
  68. maybe the administration read my op-ed in the Hill this past week uh with my colleague Vincent Raina on on improving
  69. housing affordability. Um but they are throwing some ideas uh at the wall and seeing what sticks. The worry I is that
  70. a number of these these ideas are going to stimulate demand rather than supply. And what that means in the housing
  71. market is that's going to bid up prices. And so if we think about things like the
  72. the 50-year mortgage or um you know buying mortgage back securities to try to drive down the mortgage interest rate
  73. that is going to make um you know housing purchasing more accessible for those people on the margin who are you
  74. know feeling crowded out because of high interest rates. But at the same time there's going to be more of them bidding
  75. bidding for a scarce number of houses. And so there's going to be a portion of that that's going to be captured by the
  76. existing owners in the form of higher prices. It's hard to know exactly how how that all plays out, but I think, you
  77. know, if we're looking at the the spectrum of potential policy responses, I think doing things that are largely on
  78. the demand side are probably going to have unintended consequences. I'm much more excited with with policies that are
  79. going to stimulate supply. And some of those are really uh when it comes down to it about building new uh new housing,
  80. new construction, new units. >> But the the administration's proposal to to squeeze uh institutional investors
  81. out of the market is another you know potentially very controversial and you know potentially illegal uh proposal uh
  82. when it comes to thinking about um about solutions to get people into home ownership. If you think about the large
  83. institutional investors in the US, those that own, you know, a thousand uh homes
  84. or more, they represent only 1% of the US housing stock. And so on the margin at that scale, it's just not going to
  85. move the needle for the affordability issues in the country. But as we go further down and we think about the
  86. overall investor share in the market, it is on the order of 10% of all single family homes in the country are owned by
  87. investors. And so, you know, I think there are things that can be done through the tax code, um, through credit
  88. markets that that could, um, reduce the benefits of ownership for investors and and steer those more towards, um, owner
  89. occupied residences. But I think, you know, you know, fiat by tweet is certainly not going to get it done.
  90. >> And and we need to do something that that's far more um, thoughtful and um, and resilient to um, to to potential
  91. challenges in the court. >> What about the rate lock component? And that's something that we've talked about
  92. for several years now. I mean, when you, you know, got into the early days of the
  93. pandemic, so many people refinanced at 2 and 3/4, 3%, three and and a quarter% on
  94. their existing home. That allowed them to open up and and do home projects. And there's just not a want or a need for
  95. many people to move because of that. And that's the component that I I'm you know
  96. from a historical perspective I don't think we had prior to the pandemic. You can correct me if I'm wrong in that, but
  97. it it's a dynamic we're going to have in this mix for quite some time. It it is and and it's something we've we've been
  98. talking about for years now and will continue to talk about for years because over 50% of all outstanding mortgages in
  99. the US have interest rates below 4%. And so when we're talking about doing things
  100. to the mortgage back securities market that might move interest rates by 25 basis points, you know, from a little
  101. bit above 6% to a little bit below 6%. The majority of mortgages are below four and and most of those people are going
  102. to sit on those mortgages. um that is a you know one of the the the strongest performing um assets in their portfolio
  103. is is a below market mortgage and that induces people to stay in their homes longer than they otherwise would. I
  104. don't think we've seen this dynamic uh play out in really modern mortgage history in the US with this degree of
  105. lock in and I and I think what that ultimately leads to is many fewer homes on the market. it leads to to many fewer
  106. transactions and and it leads to these frictions when it comes to um people finding where they want to live. I think
  107. one more underappreciated piece of this is you know co really acted as a type of
  108. musical chairs in the housing market. There was a big opportunity where the music was playing interest rates were
  109. low and people reoptimized and a lot of that reoptimization was accelerated retirement or it was accelerated
  110. suburbanization. So people with young families moving to the suburbs, well the music stopped, interest rates uh shot
  111. back up and now those people are happy where they are. And so, you know, I think that that pulled a lot of
  112. transactions forward uh in time as well. And all of that leads to a more depressed housing market when it comes
  113. to transaction volume and when it comes to the availability of properties. I I mentioned the the uh the commercial real
  114. estate sector and let's spend some time on that right now. Uh this obviously an industry that has been impacted by the
  115. pandemic as well because of the dynamics of how companies have thought about their footprint. Uh employees working
  116. from home more often. Uh companies reassessing just how much real estate they want to have in the mix and that's
  117. leaving a lot of uh you know main street shops in some cases open and not being used. Yeah. I mean the just like with
  118. with the residential side of the market, this has been a gradual process. I think
  119. in some ways the financial crisis in 2008 sort of warped our brains into thinking that housing and real estate
  120. markets respond very rapidly um to changing conditions and in fact they usually respond very slowly. Mo most
  121. office uh leases are 10 years or longer. Um and so firms are only very gradually
  122. reassessing uh how much space they want to use. Um but we are seeing a big uptick in in office um to residential
  123. conversions and uh you know this year um we're going to see the Flat Iron Building in New York City um probably
  124. finish their conversion process um into into residential units and that's kind of the um you know the the the the
  125. leading uh I would say the leading example of a very famous building uh where this conversion is happening. And
  126. I think we are seeing it um play out in cities across the country where downtowns um emptied out of many of
  127. their office workers and now um there's a desperate effort to to bring foot traffic back to the city and some
  128. buildings are much more easy to to repurpose than than others. I think that it also as you alluded to has these
  129. knock-on effects for retail u depending on the foot traffic in some of these downtowns and some of the corridors have
  130. bounced back very quickly and others continue to struggle and that's really a function of the the industries and the
  131. dynamics city by city. One of the other hopes I guess was the fact that uh the ad current administration talked a lot
  132. about uh the repatriation of uh companies coming into the US uh taking over facilities, taking over factories
  133. and building out property from there. Uh that will probably happen to a degree, but would it happen enough where you're
  134. going to have a significant impact on the commercial real estate market as a whole? I I wouldn't think so given the
  135. the dynamics of work from home across industries, right? The industries that that I think they have in mind are much
  136. more about manufacturing and um and really about controlling supply chains. I think the the kinds of work from home
  137. dynamics is much more about um about office workers. Um and it's not office jobs that are that are in the discussion
  138. when it comes to to repatriation. So so I think those are you know slightly uh on two different tracks. I think you
  139. know office jobs you know we have seen firms kind of settling into a work from home that's uh that's some sort of in
  140. between uh model where you're in the office two three maybe four days a week. >> Yeah.
  141. >> And in that case if you're using you know your same offices three or four days a week you probably don't need to
  142. downsize all that much on on your office space. But there may be some ways in which you can use that space more
  143. flexibly or more creatively. and we're seeing firms uh making agreements that that allow them to do that with with
  144. more flexible agreements. Two final things I wanted to bring up. First one, rents. I know you have followed rents
  145. closely. It's been an important topic for you. Uh we've seen rents come down. That's obviously going to be a good
  146. thing whether it is uh residential or commercial moving forward. Where are we in terms of rents right now?
  147. Yeah, I think um good thing for the renters uh to see the rents coming down. I I think we're seeing um continue to
  148. increase supply uh of uh rental units in in many markets and and that's delivering on lower rents. We're seeing
  149. increases in concessions from landlords. So that means like uh offering free rent
  150. or um or some other kinds of perks to try to get people in the door. We're seeing big gaps between um the existing
  151. rents that that are being paid and the rents for for new renters in in a lot of markets. There's a big wedge between
  152. those. This is an opportunity where if you're a renter right now, it pays to shop around
  153. >> and see what's out there because if you've been in the same place for three or four years,
  154. >> um chances are that that the new renters in your building might be paying quite a
  155. bit less than than you are. So in the cities where where we've seen an uptick in construction especially since co we
  156. are seeing rents soften that in other places like in in Manhattan you know rents remain astronomical. So it it is a
  157. tale of of different markets for sure. What about the insurance industry and some of the concerns that they have had
  158. you know about some of the building areas about uh uh climate change a variety of different concerns. Insurance
  159. costs have obviously been a big problem for many people. >> Yeah. Insurance has been a big focus of
  160. my research over the last couple of years. We're seeing large increases in homeowners insurance over the last few
  161. years. And if anything in the commercial side, insurance has increased dramatically faster. It's just a much
  162. less regulated market. And and what we're seeing in this latest wave of research is that this is having an
  163. effect on house prices. is that the areas that have seen the sharpest increases in insurance, which tend to be
  164. those that are most prone to disaster risk, whether that's wildfires, hurricanes, or severe storms and and
  165. hail. Um those are areas where we are seeing house prices respond. Now, these are areas that have in general already
  166. seen house prices rise quite dramatically uh over the co housing boom, but we estimate that they would
  167. have risen, you know, maybe $20,000 more had it not been for uh for rising insurance costs. So, these insurance
  168. costs are are really a pocketbook issue for for households uh at the moment and it is affecting asset values in a very
  169. direct way. Let me finally touch on this. It's seemingly the topic that everybody talks about these days. Uh,
  170. are you seeing a a significant impact from AI in the real estate market right now?
  171. >> I think we're still in the early innings when it comes to AI in real estate and
  172. some of that is uh a question of of organizing often uh messy and complicated data sets whether that comes
  173. from um you know if you think about a multifamily uh owner who has information on rents and vacancies also information
  174. on expenses also interacts with their with their tenants. I think we're seeing AI at the sort of entering in where
  175. you'd expect to the lowest hanging fruit. So things like chat bots to to manage maintenance requests. I think
  176. that's kind of the early stages of this. But when it comes to really building out
  177. the functionality of AI for real estate investing, whether that comes to making portfolio decisions, um you know,
  178. purchase decisions, um or renovation decisions or or um or exit decisions, I don't think we're there quite yet. Um, I
  179. think there are some firms that are leading the charge, but it it's still very early stages when it comes to the
  180. interplay between uh between AI and real estate. But, you know, I'm teaching a course this this spring, starting next
  181. week, on real estate data analytics, uh, which which I think of as the, you know,
  182. the the the precursor to um to really embedding AI into the systems when it comes to real estate investing.
  183. >> Going to going to drag you kicking and screaming down that path, isn't it, Ben?
  184. >> Far far from it. We love we love data over here. There you go, Ben. Great to catch up with you again. Thanks very
  185. much. All the best. Look forward to talking to you throughout the year. >> Yeah, absolutely, Dan. It's always fun
  186. to be here. Thanks. >> You You got it. Ben Keys, professor of real estate here at the [music] Wharton
  187. School. Thank you for listening to The Ripple Effect. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't
  188. forget to subscribe and [music] leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the
  189. Warden School.

Brief Summary

Ben Keys discusses the housing affordability crisis and potential solutions in the residential market.

Key points

  • Affordability Crisis in Housing. Many households are paying an extraordinary fraction of their income towards housing expenses.
  • The Importance of Starter Homes. Starter homes are crucial for first-time buyers to build equity and access neighborhoods.
  • Rising Insurance Costs Impacting Housing. Increases in homeowners insurance are affecting house prices and affordability.
  • AI in Real Estate. AI is beginning to influence real estate, but we're still in early stages.
  • Teaching Data Analytics. A course on real estate data analytics is seen as a precursor to AI integration.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes