The U.S. Housing Market Has Homeowners Stuck

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW With interest rates and mortgage rates high, homeowners have been reluctant to sell. What will it take to turn the U.S. housing market around? Wharton professor Lu Liu discusses what policy changes may be needed to break mortgage lock-in, which is restricting real estate inventory.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the fact that an individual does not put their house up for sale basically causes these Ripple
  2. effects for other people who depend on the market being liquid um and that uh certainly can affect
  3. people's ability to move to a certain place to find the right house right there may be um
  4. certain types of housing as single family housing may be particularly difficult to obtain and that's
  5. what you certainly need if you want to relocate for a job far away we think of that as like an
  6. important externality which is why policy should look into it in the first place is that these are
  7. not individual decisions that the individual can resolve they may actually affect lots of other
  8. sellers and buyers welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through
  9. the minds of Wharton faculty I'm your host Dan Looney and in each episode we'll be diving deep
  10. into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted
  11. and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today well we have seen a very active
  12. housing market in the last few years obviously the impact of the pandemic and now what's going
  13. on with the economy and within the housing market there's been something called mortgage lockin it
  14. basically started when we were during the pandemic and we saw interest rates and mortgage rates sink
  15. to down around 3% but then as we've come out of the pandemic and now into the economy we see now
  16. mortgage rates more around 7% well in many cases people who have that 3% rate don't want to give
  17. it up for a new home or they're going to have to pay 7% and that brings an interesting Dynamic to
  18. the housing market as we move forward pleasure to be joined here in Studio by L Leu who's an
  19. assistant professor of Finance here at the Wharton School great to see you thanks for coming in thank
  20. you so much for having me this is just it's such a unique Dynamic I think when you talk about housing
  21. in general that when this first happened it almost felt like it was opening a door to opportunity
  22. for so many uh homeowners back a couple years ago so the low rates certainly did right so um
  23. there's an image that's been that's been going around of mortgage lock in as golden handcuff
  24. so the fact that you've got a 3% rate locked in is good for you it's golden right it's a golden thing
  25. to have but the issue that we're discussing today is that it also locks you into your current house
  26. so people have not been moving they've not been selling their house and that can lead to issues uh
  27. down the line and as we see today and so that can have an impact not only with the individual who
  28. owns the home but when you think about as you said them not moving maybe they're not changing jobs
  29. then that has an impact on the companies that they are either working for or potentially would be
  30. working for absolutely um it has it has an impact on uh on possibly firms and hiring and moving it
  31. also has an immediate impact on the housing market itself so you as you know somebody with a 3% rate
  32. locked in you don't want to put your house up for sale but actually the market functions much better
  33. when people when there is a constant kind of coming and going of inventory coming up for sale
  34. so that other people who want to move to where you live can also move there and so I think the
  35. the fact that we've not seen that the fact that housing transactions have basically dropped by
  36. 30% relative to last year um housing transactions have fallen off a cliff they're almost at post
  37. crisis basically Pro great financial crisis levels means that um new home buyers as well as people
  38. who would like to move actually also find it very difficult to find a house that's up for sale so
  39. how do we turn that around and get us back towards a more normal housing market where you have a lot
  40. of that trend transactional movement so that's a great question and challenge I think for policy
  41. makers today um so if you remember the State of the Union addressed by the Biden Administration
  42. actually proposed because they saw it as such an issue that first time buy buyers cannot enter
  43. the housing market um they proposed a $10,000 tax credit to people who own starter homes so defined
  44. as people who own an um relatively low priced homes in a given County um and and when we when
  45. we looked at that proposal I think one challenge is that there's basically um a housing ladder in
  46. the housing market so if you own a stter house and the Biden Administration gives you $10,000
  47. to sell it you need somewhere else to move you want to buy from someone right and that someone
  48. is likely right if you're moving up if you're in a starter home and you you know you want to
  49. expand your house you may be moving into a more expensive or a larger house and so you are likely
  50. to buy from someone who's likely also locked in also got a 3% mortgage right and so how are you
  51. going to convince them to sell to you well maybe you're going to agree to pay a higher price right
  52. and so part of that tax credit is going to go to people with larger homes that's one way to split
  53. it and the other the other challenge there is that we think 10,000 US dollars is probably not large
  54. relative to how valuable the low rate is for you so we estimate that on average for the average US
  55. morgage borrower that's about the the the fact that you've got a three or 4% rate locked in on
  56. average is worth to you about 50,000 us so 10,000 is is maybe not enough to convince one person to
  57. to sell let alone two um so that's one challenge obviously we're also not saying you should just
  58. raise the tax credit and just throw money into the housing market right these kind of subsidies can
  59. be inflationary right by themselves and so there's there's an additional challenge with policy trying
  60. to stimulate the housing market without causing inflation which would be entirely uh counter uh
  61. counteractive because um that that would cause rates to stay higher for longer and lock people
  62. in for even longer so that's a real there's a real policy conundrum how much do you think then that
  63. that the the run that we've had on inflation the last couple years has played a role into
  64. this I mean obviously there's the component of the price runup we've seen in properties over the last
  65. couple years as well people that you know had a house valued at $300,000 pre pandemic probably saw
  66. what between 50 and $100,000 depending on the size of the house extra value in their home in just a
  67. couple of years that's right so that's certainly um there's there's you know there's been pandemic
  68. factors in the past that I think have led to an increase in inflation I think going forward the
  69. challenge the policy challenge for for instance monetary policy makers is the idea of raising
  70. rates right which is why mortgage rates are so high today the goal was to dampen inflation yeah
  71. but what we just discussed these are in the labor market as well as in the housing market these are
  72. actually two factors caused by lockin that may if anything be inflationary right we're not putting
  73. our houses up for sale we're also not buying but I think there's it seems to the lack of liquidity
  74. and and inventory seems to generate upward price pressure so house prices have remained really
  75. remarkably High given that rates are so high as well as yeah maybe you have to compensate
  76. for instance firms and and workers right to in in order to move maybe you have to maybe
  77. you have to offer um part of the compensation package you may have to entice someone to pay
  78. a bit more so there's I think risks around lockin where the policy maker policy has raised interest
  79. rates but actually there may be effects that are inflationary coming coming through lock in what's
  80. interesting right now is you know we're looking at rates at around 7% and I think people are trying
  81. to figure out where that sweet spot is that'll really start to drive a lot of activity you know
  82. do you do you need to get rates on average down closer to 6% 5 and a half whatever that number is
  83. in order to have people thinking okay now I feel like that level of value between the mortgage I
  84. have and the one I would take is close enough where I don't feel like I'm I'm putting myself
  85. in a bind that's certainly true I don't think there's a magic number even though maybe people
  86. have these kind of thresholds in mind like I'm looking I'm waiting for it to hit 5% yeah what
  87. we would say as economists is basically like it's very difficult to time exactly when rates come
  88. down and rates they they may stay higher right there that's that's been a surprise in the latest
  89. inflation news um and so you shouldn't you should make you should make your decisions based on your
  90. personal circumstances and so um there's obviously um typically there's an option to refinance if
  91. rates come down so that's a way to if you even if you had to take out a mortgage rate today
  92. at higher rates you can refinance down obviously there's a cost involved with that and you have to
  93. make sure there's no prepayment penalty so that's maybe like more practical advice but you should
  94. definitely not try to time the market I think that's I think that's very difficult to do given
  95. that yeah given that we we don't see a super clear path well and and I guess to a degree the market
  96. that a person is in has to factor in here as well when you think about you know the value of a home
  97. in Montana or Utah or North Dakota is going to be a lot different most likely in many cases to
  98. what you know we see here in Philadelphia or New York or Chicago and that to a degree I guess also
  99. brings me to the question about if there is kind of an incentive put forward by the government to
  100. try and ease this lock in is it better to have it at the federal level or do you need to have some
  101. combination with the state and local governments coming in as well because of that difference in
  102. cost and value absolutely so that's that's what we're hoping to tackle and new research is try
  103. to kind of model the housing market with this kind of housing ladder and different types of
  104. Housing and different prices in different regions so you may have to really finely calibrate any
  105. such intervention an alternative intervention that we also want to highlight and I think p
  106. push promote of going forward is um there are actually ways in which you can unlock
  107. the market through mortgage contracts so you so in some countries it is actually possible
  108. to take your mortgage with you when you're moving the rate and exactly take the rate with you take
  109. the rate exactly take the mortgage and the rate with you and the friction right now in the US is
  110. that basically you as the you as the borrower you could you would ideally want to go to your
  111. bank and maybe renegotiate and ask them for you to Port the mortgage or maybe take some part
  112. of the rate uh keep some of that with you when you're as you're moving and but that's typically
  113. not possible because um mortgages are securitized and sold to mortgage backed Securities investors
  114. and so you typically end up negotiating with the mortgage serer and there's been you know
  115. some some evidence following the financial crisis and and some um kind of case studies these days
  116. of how difficult is it they typically don't have to write incentives to renegotiate with
  117. you there's not that much in it for them right and so I think if the government were to step in
  118. it could certainly um incentivize maybe provide um some benefits uh in in terms of and allowing
  119. services to renegotiate on the component of relocation or the lack thereof because of of of
  120. the mortgage lock in where do you think are are the biggest impacts that we're seeing so in our
  121. research we certainly found that moving far away and across state actually if anything um is is
  122. a little bit more affected by mortgage lockin so you and and that obviously means part of it could
  123. be that maybe the benefits of moving far away are a little bit more uncertain you have to you know
  124. maybe take your entire family with you and there's uncertainty around that and so giving
  125. up something for sure which is your low rate for something that's much more uncertain in the future
  126. say like right like future um a better paid job that's going to pay you a lot more money actually
  127. in into the into the full future but maybe that's difficult to trade off with sort of a certain low
  128. rate that you have right now so that that could certainly have medium and longer run effects um
  129. on productivity on yeah firms being able to hire the right workers yeah um and obviously
  130. the the kind of opportunities um that that people take but would you think that like something like
  131. around hiring the right workers and that component of lock in that we expect this I guess to a degree
  132. to be somewhat cyclical that we're going to work our way through this as we move forward then that
  133. potentially the impact in the labor markets with companies it is it is it the potential of being
  134. somewhat cyclical and maybe even a little bit more short-term the impact that you would see
  135. with companies and work workers I mean if you look at the aggregate data you we don't see a
  136. lot of evidence um that that people have trouble hiring um the the labor market has been quite
  137. strong so we haven't seen it in the immediate data so the kind of question for the economy
  138. whether this will have me maybe more medium-term um detrimental effects will depend on whether a
  139. given worker who's locked in is very difficult to substitute and that may differ very much across
  140. different Industries so maybe you have very very particular skills but you're not willing to move
  141. then a firm that really requires your skills will have trouble and may do worse as a result
  142. of that on the other hand if most people who are locked in can be replaced by people who renting
  143. who people who are still mobile who don't have a mortgage then maybe the aggregate effects are
  144. a little bit more muted so that's that the jury I think is very much still out on the kind of Labor
  145. reallocation does the question around lack of inventory does that factor into this to a degree
  146. as well I certainly think so so I think that as I was saying earlier the fact that an individual
  147. does not put their house up for sale basically causes these Ripple effects for other people
  148. who depend on the market being liquid um and that uh certainly can affect people's ability to move
  149. to a certain place to find the right house right there may be um certain types of housing as single
  150. family housing may be particularly difficult to obtain and that's what you certainly need if you
  151. want to relocate for a job far away we think of that as like an important externality which
  152. is why policy should look into it in the first place is that these are not individual decisions
  153. that the individual can resolve they may actually affect lots of other sellers and buyers this may
  154. be a hard question to ask because I think a lot of people would say you know we've been in this
  155. kind of mortgage lock in now for a couple years at this point is this something that we should
  156. expect that is going to have Ripple effects longer term in the housing market right now most of these
  157. households have locked their rates in for 30 years so they can technically they could stay in place
  158. and keep their 3% mortgage for up to 30 years and so the potential of having long run effects
  159. is is certainly there um and what we've seen over the last year I think to the end of the last year
  160. there was a lot of enthusiasm I think slightly unwarranted uh and a push for for lower rates
  161. given that inflation had subsided but I think if anything some of the markers that we're seeing
  162. today May point to some upside risks for inflation and so I think it's very difficult to predict how
  163. long interest rates are going to stay high and while that's happening people are basically in
  164. this gridlock that they're not they're kind of waiting and maybe is kind of not wanting to to let
  165. go these these currently currently low rates and that obviously causes a lot of pen up demand house
  166. prices are high for instance for in particular for first-time buyers and families who want to
  167. own a house that that obviously kind of pushes back all of their life decisions in a way if that
  168. really is what what's keeping you what's a big um barrier for you to enter the housing market and
  169. so the longer that subsides every kind of month and year will count because these are things that
  170. are going to these this is going to be like pend up demand and kind of um distortionary effects uh
  171. that could be quite large for many people and I guess to a degree it also buts butts up with the
  172. fact that we're in a cycle right now where younger Generations weren't looking to buy that they were
  173. waiting longer to buy that first home so that's the dynamic that probably has factored in a little
  174. bit to this as well exactly so I think that's certainly what people have said that during the
  175. pandemic there was a lot of people for instance like moved in with their parents to actually save
  176. for a down payment so what people have observed is that there's actually a huge cohort of people
  177. who are looking to buy and looking uh to to buy a house for the first time they're forming a
  178. new household because they've paid they saved for a down payment and they kind of entered a
  179. market that had high prices uh High mortgage rates and low inventory right and so I think
  180. there's a general sentiment that people are upset about this constellation it's basically facing a
  181. triple set of challenges which is why I think um policy wanted to Signal the the kind of State of
  182. the Union Address I think signaled that they heard that there were people who who were facing these
  183. issues but obviously yeah the question is how do we design these policies to actually be effective
  184. great to have you in here thanks very much thank you very much thank you uh Lulu who is assistant
  185. professor of Finance here at the warden school thank you for listening to the ripple effect we
  186. hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave
  187. us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School

Brief Summary

Mortgage lock-in is affecting housing market liquidity and job relocations, with potential policy solutions discussed.

Key points

  • Mortgage Lock-In Dynamics. Low mortgage rates create a 'golden handcuff' effect, limiting mobility in the housing market.
  • Policy Challenges in Housing Market. Proposed tax credits may not be enough to stimulate housing transactions due to existing low rates.
  • The Ripple Effect of Housing Decisions. Individual housing choices can impact the broader market, affecting many buyers and sellers.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes