Israel's Economy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi I'm Bruce Brownstein senior fellow at the Wharton SEI Center and I'm here with
  2. professors Vin dean of the Arison School of Business and the tiamson school of Economics at IDC
  3. herzelia Professor exin is visiting at Wharton this semester and is the author of several books and is the former
  4. deputy governor of the Bank of Israel where he successfully navigated Israel through the financial crisis welcome
  5. Professor Einstein thank you thank you for having me uh Professor Einstein uh we'd like to cover a host of things but
  6. the first thing we' like to find out is how's the Israeli economy doing today overall well the Israeli economy now is
  7. growing lower than most of the than uh in the past in the past actually the Israeli economy has been growing above
  8. 5% before the crisis and during the crisis only one uh two quarters of negative small growth but actually got
  9. out and succeed to grow back into a four 5% uh now as World Trade uh become lower
  10. uh from all Dimension especially uh Europe and even the US is not doing that great and Asia uh the export sector
  11. which was the key engine of growth in the Israeli economy uh slow down a bit uh that's uh actually have to emphasize
  12. that the Israeli economy is very resilient to shocks uh we had several geopolitical uh conflict
  13. uh including minor Wars in Lebanon in Gaza and the economy responded very quickly overcoming those shocks and
  14. that's from several reasons first of all and foremost the very uh vibrant and high-tech uh oriented export sector uh
  15. the second is a very stable and uh uh I would say responsible government policies in actually through all the
  16. period where uh debt and deficits are Skyrocket in all economies including the US the Israeli uh budget has been under
  17. uh manage good management and uh debt to GDP continue to decrease uh in addition
  18. uh we have actually a surplus uh during the war during the recession in 2009 and
  19. 2010 uh they found uh extensive uh um reserves of gas uh gas has start uh pumping into the economy in a much lower
  20. price energy cost went down significantly electricity cost went down significantly and Israel actually has a
  21. uh large source of energy coming from these gas Wells uh just 100 kilometers from the shore uh and in addition to all
  22. that a very stable monetary policy uh and that's actually very important not only monetary policy but very stable
  23. Financial uh system uh well functioning Banks uh High saving uh individuals uh and actually the only main problem is
  24. that with a very low interest rate and actually not very effective government policies housing prices Skyrocket uh
  25. since 2008 and cause a big burden especially to the younger population who have to buy uh new housing so you
  26. mentioned that the government gets some of the credit for the success uh so who and what areas of the government has
  27. made this possible well in fact uh I would say that a big change uh in uh providing overall uh stable economic
  28. conditions started already with the Chiron government in the beginning of 2003 uh and Benjamin Nan at that time
  29. the Finance Minister they brought the government into a very responsible uh low deficit and low expenditure growth
  30. and uh size of the government relative to the economy dropped significantly uh in particular expenses
  31. on defense dropped significantly the stability provided very low interest rate and with a very uh stable oriented
  32. uh price stability oriented uh policy that we had since 2004 and even before uh interest rate went down and therefore
  33. the debt to GDP went down and therefore expenditures on on uh interest payment of the government went down dramatically
  34. uh with much po government and a growing economy throughout uh the decade uh that
  35. started at 2003 had a small downward in 2009 but back to gross in 2009 and 11 in particular 10 to 11 uh we
  36. actually had a debt to GDP to decrease from almost uh 95% of GDP to today is uh something around 68% of GDP and still
  37. continue to be very stable where the rest of the western world that to GDP are growing dramatically and cause a lot
  38. of internal instability in Europe even in the US it's a big problem and so although it's not perfect
  39. it seems that relative to global economic conditions Israel is doing okay Israel is doing uh okay very stable I
  40. mean I I would say that uh another thing that we have to emphasize is employment
  41. Israel employment rate and unemployment ment rate are uh better than the US uh the participation has increased
  42. dramatically we still suffer from s segments like uh female Arabs and uh Ultra Orthodox men don't work as uh we
  43. expect them but if we look at the whole total economy uh we have done a huge change a huge transformation with uh
  44. which was actually led by government policies started in 2003 but continued throughout the period with changing the
  45. government and changing econom ecomic conditions uh we are below 5% of unemployment which is the lowest ever in
  46. Israel among the lowest among Western economies and we have a very high employment rate and very high overall
  47. participation rate which has not been uh count down so overall that side of the economy is excellent what is not doing
  48. very well is the productivity we are really lagging in productivity quite significantly from Europe and the the US
  49. in the Dom domc economy not in the high-tech sector and um this low productivity in the domestic economy and
  50. the high sector which is blooming uh generate uh wide uh income distribution taking into consideration also the hike
  51. of uh almost 50% increase in the housing prices uh and enhance the inequality problems that generat some social unrest
  52. and that's actually the main challenge of the government today is take taking control of the housing sector taking
  53. control of the uh of the inequality and in particular enhancing the productivity
  54. of the low skill and medium skill uh individual those who enter to the market and those who coming with low skill like
  55. the Arab population and the uh Ultra Orthodox who don't uh get maybe the right uh uh I would say education
  56. background and uh and knowledge how to deal in a modern and uh changing environment
  57. to really push up productivity and get their wages going up okay so on the housing issue if you had a magic wand
  58. what would be the solution to the housing issue the the housing issue comes all of it from uh a problem of
  59. supply of land uh the government has a huge uh uh share how how big how big a share well overall people put the 97%
  60. but it is more in the areas which supposed to be urbanized where we built it's around 80 % some location it's 50%
  61. 60% but other location it's 100% And the government has been very uh inefficient
  62. in uh regulating the whole planning uh and and the economy is growing most people don't understand that Israel is
  63. among the highest population growth in all Western economy so if you go to countries which are as developed as
  64. Israel which have GDP per capita above $30,000 we are the highest growth economy we are growing almost 2% a year
  65. uh just the US is growing now 7% a year so oneir and the and the planning of uh development of new housing has not been
  66. uh adjusted to this large grow of population it's true that a lot and a lot of this is among uh the lowest uh uh
  67. income groups and that's actually is a challenge uh to deal with it but but the one point it's a it's but it's a huge
  68. one is to really reorganize the planning and making more land available for uh development and more land available for
  69. urbanization uh of the growing population uh that has been neglected totally in the last uh 15 years and we
  70. are and the young people paying the price and the price is huge mhm okay so uh how about the tech sector well uh the
  71. strongest part of uh Israel is the high Tech sector the high-tech sector is built basically on the shoulders of
  72. young Innovative smart Israelis who are uh having actually a very strong educational system although on the
  73. average we don't do as great but if you look at the top one uh the the main problem of the culture is a culture of
  74. innovation Innovation is not only mathematics and not only school it's a culture of thinking uh how to make
  75. things better in all dimension in Social in uh in technology and biotech and uh and uh in
  76. is the advantage of of discontent yeah and uh and that that is an an Innovative Society so there is a culture of that
  77. this culture also exist uh when the top individuals uh finish High School uh they go to the Army a large percentage
  78. of them actually going to the intelligence unit where they basically going into incubating and learning how
  79. to uh invent uh new methods of uh related to Army activities but it's really given them a very strong uh
  80. background on Innovative uh uh using computers using new programming using the high memory using the speed using
  81. the imaginary world of this new technology and uh when they leave the army they actually in the army they
  82. provide a huge infrastructure structure of uh knowledge uh for the Army on all Dimensions from intelligence uh to
  83. methods of protection to methods of security and to method of uh intelligence and uh when they go out of
  84. the army uh they are basically uh start going into the Innovative sector and when you look at uh Israel there are
  85. almost uh 2,000 startups uh just around uh a radius of uh 100 kilometers uh around the center of
  86. Tel Aviv uh and uh it's probably one of the most Innovative uh economy on this Dimension only in the last uh year there
  87. were um IPOs of uh corporations uh who went out and uh were bought by either larger corporations or by uh by
  88. themselves start producing in uh all the areas that require new applications and
  89. uh new methods of uh uh in the era of uh Innovative society and do a couple of names of either entrepreneurs or
  90. companies come to mind that are your favorites well I think one of them is uh for example is ways uh which uh grew up
  91. to be a leading under Google Google both ways ways is a introduce a new method of
  92. how to navigate G GPS of cars uh that's uh uh in particular uh there are many others that I don't remember all the
  93. names but they are in advertisement in Securities uh we have a corporation that actually checkpoint that grew up also
  94. from the intelligence in the Army which is a leading company in all the important issues of U providing
  95. Securities uh and cyber security actually become a huge uh area of uh Innovation activities and there are many
  96. small and mediumsized companies that merge into this uh growing industry so you're a Gil schwed flan or Dr darit D I
  97. mean I am I don't I mean I fan of uh many people I think the key point is that it's really provides uh a huge uh
  98. uh a huge success and uh and um investment in new ideas that provide both individual gain for the people who
  99. are working in this but also for uh the entire Society on on on a range of uh uh
  100. products including biotech uh Israel some people like Jacob RTO which were initiating the stand to basically save
  101. thousand and million maybe of Life uh it's another example that started in the early '90s but the range is uh is uh is
  102. huge and and how about financial Capital uh is patango doing a good job job or jvp and and what do you think of our
  103. crowd well uh I think many people uh know about Israel actually it's worldwide it's not only the funds we
  104. have now people coming from China people coming from Korea people coming from uh
  105. the US people coming from Europe and uh actually they realize it's really the people it's the people in Israel who has
  106. this uh knowledge who has this ambition who has this drive and this uh sector H doesn't suffer from uh the excess
  107. regulation of for example the what we discussed before the real estate sector this sector is completely free it's uh
  108. basically uh all uh export oriented in fact the Israeli economy provide a lot of export oriented uh subsidies I would
  109. say tax incentives in uh in many Dimension and since there are no uh restrictions on the uh forming the the
  110. company and uh selling the company and uh being uh recognized worldwide and there are some uh advantages like the
  111. Academia the strong Academia the strong knowledge uh and uh the the the preparation I mentioned in terms of the
  112. army of the workforce uh or in addition uh the universities we have uh about five departments in computer science
  113. which are uh almost all of them are top 20 in the US so they uh have a uh top professors and they teach them all the
  114. upto-date methods which are changing all the time and that's that's all echosystem uh Pro Hightech um has
  115. generated I would say relative to the size of the economy but even not just relative to the size of an economy of 8
  116. million and a half people relative to the world it become kind of what we call called the startup Nation or if I want
  117. to say uh we say silicon uh Wy meaning that W is a is a valley in Arabic and uh the Silicon uh taking from the US West
  118. Coast uh location creating the second largest cluster outside of Silicon Valley yeah yeah okay so to summarize
  119. the challenges and opportunities you see over the near and long term for Israel well I think uh the main challenge I
  120. mentioned this uh before is uh the uh large inequality within Israel uh which is to some extent has been stabilized
  121. and reduced in the last few years due to the increase in employment uh however it
  122. can decrease the inequality quite further by really uh improving the productivity of uh the new workers who
  123. are coming from a population that does not have the access uh to the high-tech sector so the challenge is to take some
  124. of these people and train them to be also in Hightech sector but also to take all the what I call the uh domestic
  125. economy and make it more uh productive more efficient reduced regulation reduced the uh increase the availability
  126. of Housing and reduce the uh prices uh does uh uh actually uh the current Finance Minister put on his agenda I
  127. hope to see him actually fulfilling uh his promises by reducing housing prices increasing productivity of the low
  128. skills and uh decreasing inequality more competition we have a lot of domestic uh
  129. Goods which are very expensive uh compared to the world we can really work on more competition and reduce it uh we
  130. haven't been very uh good on regulating our new uh gas wells in making them uh actually pumping the gas out and getting
  131. it internal to the Israeli economy and and probably exporting them so we should really improve uh the bureaucracy and
  132. the local regulation such that uh the knowledge and the ability and the incentives of the local people to really
  133. push the economy forward would not be blocked by a lot of uh government inefficiency
  134. [Music]

Brief Summary

Professor Einstein discusses Israel's resilient economy, government policies, high-tech sector, and challenges like housing and inequality.

Key points

  • Resilience of the Israeli Economy. Professor Einstein explains how the Israeli economy has bounced back from crises.
  • Low Unemployment Rate. Israel's unemployment rate is at an all-time low, showcasing economic strength.
  • Challenges Ahead. Despite successes, challenges like inequality and housing prices remain.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes