How Morality and Obligation Intertwine.

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

There's more that should go into decision-making than personal benefit, particularly when injustice is in play, says Wharton’s Brian Berkey. More: http://knlg.net/1LXsSO5 📂 Leadership 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I work on various uh related issues having to do with our individual obligations of justice uh in particular
  2. in non ideal conditions in unjust conditions. So uh examples of issues that I've written about include our
  3. obligations to um redirect a portion of our income to people who are victims of injustice. uh obligations to take
  4. considerations of justice into account when we're making decisions like uh what career we're going to go into or um how
  5. we're going to operate our businesses, uh things like this. One sort of key theme of my research is
  6. that our obligations uh in particular in non- ideal conditions are quite a bit more extensive than most people tend to
  7. think. So I think for example that we can be obligated to take considerations of justice into account when we're
  8. deciding for example what career we're going to pursue. So that uh it's not necessarily morally permissible to
  9. choose whatever career would most benefit you or you know the one that's your most preferred of the available
  10. options. unjust conditions in particular can make it the case that uh if one is overall a beneficiary of injustice that
  11. they can have obligations to um make choices that are not for example legally required within the system. Um but that
  12. um would better advance the aims of justice if they were to choose one way rather than another. And this applies I
  13. think across a broad range of domains. So for example, how we spend our money uh again what careers we pursue, how we
  14. operate our businesses um and um and other areas as well. The applications uh in most cases are a
  15. little bit indirect, right? So what I suggest is that um people in their private lives, in their roles within
  16. companies uh and elsewhere uh are obligated to take considerations of justice into account in deciding uh what
  17. they're going to do with their resources with you know the uh you know the business that they're running. if they
  18. have sort of multiple options in terms of um you know what kinds of practices to adopt or what areas to sort of enter
  19. into or things like this. Um but uh my research is abstract enough that um there are no kind of direct takeaways.
  20. So I don't say things like you know um actual person X is obligated to do this particular thing, right? I sort of try
  21. to argue that certain kinds of considerations are relevant and have to be taken into account by people who are
  22. making decisions um that many people think are um not the kinds of things that individuals are obligated to um
  23. consider when making decisions like what career to pursue or uh or something along these lines.
  24. One thing that I've been thinking about is um the conditions in which uh private group actions within the
  25. economic sphere that are aimed at promoting justice are permissible or impermissible. So consumer boycott is
  26. sort of one example of this. Um so if we think that we can pursue some important
  27. justice related aim through uh organizing some kind of collective boycott effort um what conditions do we
  28. have to meet in order uh for that sort of effort to be permissible in a say liberal democratic society. Um I'm also
  29. working on several papers um about issues related to climate change. So, um, one issue that I've been thinking
  30. about is, uh, whether historical emissions make a difference, uh, with regard to what we're obligated to do
  31. now, who's obligated to do what to, um, for example, mitigate the negative effects of climate change in the future.
  32. Um, and I'm also hoping to think about uh think more about the the obligations of businesses to contribute to the
  33. effort to mitigate climate change. [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode covers justice obligations in career choices, business practices, and climate change responsibilities.

Key points

  • Obligations of Justice. Exploring our moral responsibilities in unjust conditions and how they influence our choices.
  • Justice in Career Choices. Discussing the moral implications of career decisions in the context of justice.
  • Consumer Boycotts and Justice. Examining the conditions under which collective actions like boycotts are permissible.

Related episodes