A New Approach to Making Career Choices

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton professor G. Richard Shell's new book, Springboard: Launching Your Personal Search for Success, encourages readers to embrace major transitions in life. πŸ“‚ Management;Human Resources

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi my name is David Heckman I'm here with Professor Richard shell to talk about his new book springboard Richard
  2. welcome thank you Dave first question Richard you're really well known for your work in negotiation and persuasion
  3. so why write a book about success well Dave it's um it's been a long journey um the
  4. the the materials on success actually preceded the materials on negotiation and persuasion I've been interested in
  5. success probably since I was in my 20s and um it also feeds into a real passion I have which is in all my teaching to
  6. help students and Executives uh bring more self-awareness to their uh practice whatever it is and the subject of of
  7. success allows me to do that really directly here at Wharton you teach three very different audiences is about the
  8. topic of success and challenge them to think about what is success that being our warten undergrads our mbas and our
  9. senior Executives in our Advanced Management program what do you see as the differences in the way that the
  10. audience reacts to the question um well that's a that's a great question they they're they're at very different stages
  11. of life and so each one of those groups has a sort of different question in their head when you ask them what do you
  12. mean by success so for an undergrad they're standing right on the on the edge of adulthood and uh very anxiously
  13. awaiting the real world after um you know doing school for 16 years and for them it really is the first time to
  14. encounter what their life goals might consist of uh that sort of begin thinking about family begin thinking
  15. about career begin thinking about how to balance those things and I think uh in asking that question for them I'm able
  16. to in some ways set their minds at ease that they don't have to answer that question all at once and that their
  17. lives are kind of more like an experiment than uh a test uh for the NBAs it's a little bit further down the
  18. road and I think they have a more career directed Focus to that question they're
  19. all thinking very very directly about the kind of professional Niche that they're seeking and what kind of success
  20. that may uh that may hold for them and then for the executives it's uh it's it's much much different the senior
  21. executives are much more mindful of issues like family uh of issues like work life balance and uh the kind of
  22. mentoring that they can do for other uh people little younger than they are and help those younger people think about
  23. what a meaningful career might look like or how they can uh carve out a life that
  24. will make uh sense to them so at some levels I'm teaching the executives how to be coach Es as much as I am opening
  25. up a new subject for them many people in our culture are chasing success goals of
  26. Fame and Fortune yet you in your book sort of say that they could be traps uh what do you mean by that and how does
  27. your how does your book help the reader to find success for themselves um well the the the culture
  28. one of the points I make in the book is that whether we like it or not our surrounding culture is going to create a
  29. lot of expectations for us and when you filter that culture through the prism of
  30. a family and where how you grow up and where you grew up and the peer group that you grew up around you're going to
  31. have almost a hypnotic effect on what uh people think they ought to be pursuing and with the media that we have and the
  32. uh celebrity culture that we have it's very very common to see people unconsciously adopt um a frame of
  33. reference that if they're not famous they're not successful if they're not wealthy they're not successful and to uh
  34. even when they know better continue to behave in ways that give them this sort of underlying sense of dissatisfaction
  35. if they're not famous or Rich enough so a lot of what I do in the book and in the teaching that I do is to try to give
  36. people a chance to gain a little perspective on that and that means looking at the sources of those early
  37. messages that they may have internalized uh and giving giving them a chance to make a few more choices about
  38. whether uh that sort of impulse toward U getting recognition or the impulse toward making another
  39. $100,000 uh when they have choices about using their time other ways um whether they you know whether they can gain more
  40. control over that I mean part of what I do is try to substitute uh new goals for
  41. the for the more automatic ones that our culture provides and so instead of Fame
  42. I try to get people to start thinking about gaining respect that means a smaller audience of people who know you
  43. better and uh giving uh you a sense of satisfaction from Gaining the respect of that group as opposed to recognition
  44. from people you don't even know and when it comes to the money side of things I try to emphasize whatever your needs are
  45. that would relate to Financial Security for you and your family and not just a status score card that uh people
  46. sometimes slip into when they just start counting their uh their bank account uh
  47. zeros at the end of their net worth so I think part of it is helping people wake
  48. up that realize that they're being unconsciously influenced and the other is to provide them with a more
  49. thoughtful alternative that when they think about it actually is something they'd much rather pursue in the US
  50. declaration of independence Thomas Jefferson penned the words that we have the inali a right to the to life liberty
  51. and the pursuit of happiness should he have edited those Wars to be the the pursuit of personal
  52. success um I don't know that the founding fathers had the word success in their um normal vocabulary happiness was
  53. though and I think it's interesting if you look back at that um at that event in our founding because the original
  54. text said life liberty and the pursuit of property and then Jefferson edited out
  55. property wrote the word happiness over it and I think it's a lot of cultural commentators think that that single uh
  56. editing changed the course of American culture because the word happiness is very
  57. ambiguous I think it meant one thing to Jefferson he was a stoic uh philosopher he followed a very strict regime in his
  58. life uh and uh got his Joy from gardening and from uh from intellectual Pursuits we've interpreted I think to me
  59. uh longer times at casinos and uh and more uh more elaborate Vacations so so one of the things I try to do in the
  60. book is give people a chance to think more deeply about what happiness actually means and it turns out it means
  61. three different things the research shows it's it's a kind of momentary emotion that is something that people
  62. feel that's a good feeling but it's also a kind of positive evaluation when you look back on a period of time time and
  63. consider whether your efforts have been uh rewarded with some kind of achievement but it's then finally a kind
  64. of satisfaction that comes with almost a spiritual dimension of awe of appreciation of nature of a sense of
  65. connection to Nature and the world and maybe even a deity and those kinds of Happiness feelings I think are the
  66. deepest of all and so when you speak of Pursuit of Happiness it's probably some mix of all those three things uh but
  67. it's not I don't think the the sort of simple metric uh that uh that most people
  68. consider in your book uh you describe an experience where you went to a conference about happiness and uh a wise
  69. Angel arrived and he said that happiness is just three things good health meaningful work and love you have that
  70. you're happy was he missing anything uh relative to success as you would Define it well uh the guy I called the wise
  71. Angel was really just a senior citizen who wandered into a Wharton seminar The Faculty were giving on the relationship
  72. between income and and the and the emotion of happiness and I called him the wise Angel because he was dressed in
  73. working man's clothes he really didn't belong in the setting and the question uh that he posed to the presenter was
  74. about as unacademic uh a concept cep of Happiness as you can find but but very deeply felt and in many ways very wise
  75. so I think uh good health is certainly a very com important component of well-being and meaningful work is
  76. something I talked great lik about in the book because that's something I think that's well worth understanding
  77. and pursuing and love of course is the foundation for all everyone's personal life if you're going to sustain any kind
  78. of uh meaningful life so he had a lot uh captured with that but I think one of the things he missed that most people
  79. think of when they think of success is some sort of notable achievement uh and um I think you know I think that people
  80. get a lot of satisfaction from achieving something significant that they try to set out and that whether or not it's
  81. recognized that's a sort of cherry on top uh I think your um your sense of satisfaction comes from doing things
  82. well that are important to you uh when they recognized that's uh that's sort of an extra benefit for that but I think
  83. achievement is something that most people would consider pretty important when you get to the concept of con of
  84. success compared with just the concept of Happiness great uh another thing you mentioned in your book is the tradeoffs
  85. between success and happiness and now we live in a world that says can't we have
  86. both uh I you know I I believe that um there's only 24 hours in a day uh we each only get to live live roughly
  87. 32850 days in a year uh or of in a lifetime of uh 90 years and how you choose to spend that most precious asset
  88. time uh does involve trade-offs uh I think if you're going to be pursuing momentary happiness for example uh then
  89. you're probably uh going to be not uh working at the sweat of your brow uh in uh some very labored way or some
  90. important achievement that you're trying to uh accomplish and by the same token um you know there are moments when if
  91. you're doing the right kind of work you can have both a very strong sense of achievement and a very powerful and
  92. fulfilling sense of satisfaction so it is the case that there's some things that we do where we hit a sweet spot and
  93. we can feel both very positive emotions and also accomplish a great deal but I think you know the other half of that is
  94. uh you have to choose how to spend your time and um and I think some people overdue the achievement side and they
  95. don't remember that they own intellectual well-being and their emotional well-being is something their
  96. family is something that they need to nurture and other people um sort of uh focus on their personal lives and at the
  97. end of the day may feel some frustration that they didn't achieve as much as they
  98. would have liked I think your book uh makes it very clear that success is definitely a journey and not a
  99. destination can you tell us a little more about your discovery of your own personal
  100. success well that's what my students always want me to talk about I have them write a paper on what
  101. is success and they say well Professor sh what's your theory of what success is and I'm I always resist it because I
  102. don't want them to uh to sort of copy the teacher uh I think it's their responsibility to come up with their own
  103. ideas I mean for myself I think um I had a very um uh strong crisis in my post colle years I was a a son of a general
  104. in the Marine Corps who was the head of a college a Military College Virginia Military Institute I became a pacifist
  105. uh as a result to the Vietnam War so I had a very very uh rupture ruptured event in my uh young adulthood uh
  106. breaking with all my family traditions my grandfathers had both been in the military too actually in your book you
  107. used the word that you cut the narrative story of your life right and I thought that was very powerful it's a very
  108. powerful description to describe what what you were going through yeah and and I think when you're whenever you face a
  109. crisis like that and in my case I really had to just um you know do 180 degree turn from everything I'd assume success
  110. meant because I was at the time enrolled to be a naval officer in college I was going to graduate from college and go in
  111. the Navy and to turn 180 degrees away from that toward uh being a pacifist and protesting the war that we were in at
  112. that time it just it just makes it very difficult for you to remember who you are and so for me that crisis uh really
  113. ended up putting me on a journey uh where I just uh stopped uh working I I left the country I traveled for a couple
  114. of years I um just you know went on a quest uh to see if I could figure out you know who I was and what I need
  115. needed to do next and so the book tells that story it's a it's a longer story than I have time to tell here but it's I
  116. think I think we are in some sense defined by the conflicts we've overcome and that um that story happens
  117. to be the conflict I overcame and they gave me the seed of my passion for this subject but I challenge students I
  118. challenged Executives to look into their own lives and identify the crisis that have defined them and to draw strength
  119. from that and to draw direction from that and I think that's a that's one very good way to make some constructive
  120. use of the you know difficult times that you've had great when you wrote uh springboard who did you have in mind as
  121. being your audience or your reader that's a great question because it's a very tough one I um I thought at
  122. the beginning that I was going to write this book based on the course that I teach which is a pretty simple idea I
  123. have a course I'll write a book um when when I when I started getting into it though I realized that uh the course I
  124. teach is very intimate it's very interactive there's a lot of writing and my resp responding to their writing and
  125. so with an audience that's reading a book then you can't see the audience uh I suddenly realized I had uh I had a
  126. different uh problem to solve in writing it and as I wrote it I actually began realizing that it wasn't just students
  127. that I was writing for that's my typical audience as a teacher but really anyone who finds themselves
  128. at a point in life where they need to make a transition and it could be a student who's transitioning to adult
  129. life after undergraduate studies it could be a graduate student who's transitioning to professional level
  130. after Graduate Studies but it could also be someone who's facing a crisis because
  131. they have to change their career and retool their goals and rethink who they are with respect to their work could be
  132. someone who's uh just coming off of a personal crisis and they have to think about who they are after a divorce or
  133. after the death of a loved one or finally people who are coming into their retirement years and they have to you
  134. know really consider what they're going to do with their life after they stop their uh sort of identified career so I
  135. think it really is relevant for anyone who's asking the question what should I do with my life
  136. next in at the end of the book uh you give a pretty good bibliography of other recommended readings and you acknowledge
  137. that there's many other books on the market about success what's different about
  138. yours well that that's another uh that was another crisis uh for me as I wrote the book because I think over the time I
  139. drafted it I wrote about five different kinds of books Each of which was one of the success types of books um so maybe
  140. by process of elimination I wrote something that's different but my I think at the end I intended uh and I
  141. discovered that what I was writing was not a book about How to Succeed like me and not a book about the one true path
  142. to success which you might read if you wrote a you know read a book on goal setting or you read a book on uh Follow
  143. Your Passion or the many different kinds of one true answer kind of books my my goal in writing this book was really to
  144. help each reader discover for themselves their own authentic legitimate deeply felt goals
  145. with respect to what assess means and then look inside and assess the strengths their personality their
  146. motivations their skills as to how they can best utilize what God gave them to go ahead and Achieve that success which
  147. they themselves had defined so it really is a book about the reader as opposed to
  148. a book about either me or some uh set of uh you know Flawless answers to the question how to
  149. succeed as you work across this variety of audien beginning with undergraduate students through senior Executives what
  150. do you see as their biggest obstacles to figuring out their path to success fear I think it's uh when I look into
  151. the eyes of undergraduates who are facing their first job after graduation um they are very very anxious
  152. that they make the exactly right choice the first time out uh and a lot of what I do when I
  153. speak to them individually is say look um relax just do something that interests you and then use your early
  154. working life as an experiment to learn more about who you are as you work and what might interest you and what skills
  155. you have and even senior Executives uh when occasionally I run into one who uh is uh at one of these transition points
  156. and they usually come up to me during a break in our courses or at lunch or something and they want some uh extra
  157. counseling some extra chance to chat and what I really see is fear and anxiety that some very defined part of their
  158. life that they ve they know very well that they're masters of is coming to an end and they look out into the future
  159. and they they feel this sort of um black hole in front of them as to what what's
  160. going to happen next what what should I do and um so my effort in the book and in my courses is really to reassure
  161. and to provide encouragement uh to be thoughtful um be a little Fearless take some courage and
  162. uh put yourself in motion you know there's a um if you if you follow professional ice hockey which my wife
  163. and I occasionally do uh there is a very good practice uh if you're trying to score uh in an ice hockey game uh and
  164. basically the advice is keep shooting uh and good things happen if you're in front of the net and you're
  165. swinging away trying to get the puck into the net and I think life's like that uh you know get out there and just
  166. keep shooting and uh and things happen people respond new avenues open up uh and uh and you get a chance to find A
  167. New Path um in your book you devote a fair amount of pages to a former student now entrepreneur named Eric Adler can
  168. you tell us a little bit about why he's so special well Eric Eric when I was writing the book and I was casting about
  169. for uh role models that I myself consider successful um Eric's uh name came right
  170. up front in my mind I taught him before I actually conceived the negotiation course I taught Eric negotiation and I
  171. taught him uh another core course and while he was an NBA student I got to know him he was a had been a high school
  172. teacher for eight years before he came to Wharton so he's sort of a non-traditional Wharton student um he
  173. then while he was at Wharton um got very excited about a traditional business career in
  174. Consulting uh and um and left Wharton to pursue that and I had never really thought that was the direction that he
  175. would end up in or that I was hoping he would end up in but you know people take
  176. their own path and I was happy to see that he you know was engaged but then a year or so later uh I caught up with his
  177. story and he had moved to Washington DC he had become very dissatisfied with his
  178. consult uh career just wasn't working out and so he had had the courage to um to quit and
  179. I I think um he then went on to go back and knit together all the pieces of his life that allowed him to be the most
  180. successful person he could be his parents were entrepreneurs he decided he wanted to be an entrepreneur he had a
  181. background in education secondary education so he started looking for how to pursue uh a business in secondary
  182. educ ation and he ended up creating a whole set of model um Public Schools but they're boarding schools for low-income
  183. students they actually live residentially and he succeeded in finding a model to actually um uh get
  184. those kids which who would otherwise not even graduate from high school and he has 100% of them going to top colleges
  185. so he really put together all the pieces that uh I see as going into uh the word
  186. success as I Define it he created his own goals he looked into his own past found his own strengths found his own
  187. experience and came up with an original conception to how to implement that and I think his life indicates the sort of
  188. trial and error experimental model rather than you know you you you go around the marry around and you get the
  189. brass ring and you know game over you're successful you mentioned one word in your description of Eric uh that sounds
  190. to me like it began with some level of dissatisfaction yeah and do you think that's key
  191. absolutely I think I think that's one of the dangers of over um focusing on happiness uh happiness is this if you
  192. think of that as the end State you know oh I'm I have to be happy uh you're going to miss a lot because it's from
  193. your dissatisfaction it's from your unhappiness that you often get the motivation to do something new something
  194. better something more interesting something more uh educational for you um you you know have to be willing to be
  195. unhappy in a relationship in order to find a better one you have to be unhappy in a current job in order to take the
  196. plunge and seek a better one uh and so I think there's a lot of power in negative
  197. emotions that uh at least if they're not overly negative for too long uh are overlooked in uh the modern culture's
  198. sort of fascination with the whole idea that you know success equals happiness what do you see as the biggest aha
  199. moment that students have at the end of the success class I think well for under the
  200. different audiences have different ahas I think the undergraduates have a big aha because they suddenly realize this
  201. is something they get to Define and they've been in the business of checking boxes all through their lives to go to
  202. Great high schools to go to you know take SATs to get into a great school and college and and maybe even recruit into
  203. great firms for their first job after college but I think they really uh begin feeling empowered when they realize U
  204. that uh this is an opportunity not something that they have to fear and that the future is something they get to
  205. shape and Craft um so I think that can be a big aha moment for them uh I think for the older people uh I think the AHA
  206. comes with validating for them that life is uh little bit more uh nuanced uh and
  207. Rich than just their career achievements we I was teaching a course for Bankers here on campus about a month ago uh
  208. there were 250 Bankers uh for uh the stonier business school here on campus and um I was making a point about uh
  209. sort of when you achieve someone else's goal in life you recognize it because you don't feel any satisfaction from
  210. having achieved it and this guy in the back raised his hand he said you know Richard that's exactly right I've been
  211. trying to get promoted for the last three years and a month ago I got promoted but I didn't feel any
  212. satisfaction from it and I I'm I'm beginning to realize that I wasn't the the the promotion wasn't really my own
  213. goal uh so I think the older folks sometimes suddenly realize that you have to live your own life and sometimes you
  214. have to take a little time off to craft what your own goals are and not just end
  215. up feeling empty when you achieve something everybody else wanted you to achieve one other question around person
  216. person ality and style do you see a correlation between certain personalities and styles and success in
  217. other words do you have to have a certain style and personality to be successful or is Success really an
  218. option for anyone well of course back to the premise you get to define success for yourself so um so I think it's uh
  219. whatever personality you have that will probably affect how you define it and then that's the life you get to live so
  220. um I think if you looked at individual aspects of success there probably are some
  221. correlations um for example um uh people who achieve more are probably more conscientious uh they're more
  222. self-disciplined uh they're more uh you know likely to follow through on the other hand people who are U happier and
  223. they have more positive emotions they have more sense of satisfaction uh those people often are are those who are a
  224. little bit more emotionally intelligent more self-aware and maybe more open to novel experiences and uh not try not not
  225. so interested in controlling everything about their environment so those are personality traits they probably give
  226. you aptitudes for experiencing some dimension of success but I think no matter what your personality is you get
  227. to define the balance that you will uh call success for you and so I think you know that that's the that's the unique
  228. aspect of it you you get to make your own adventure Richard thanks so much for your time and thanks for writing the
  229. book Thank you Dave I appreciate it [Music]

Brief Summary

Professor Richard Shell discusses his book on redefining success and self-awareness across different life stages.

Key points

  • The Nature of Success. Richard Shell explains how success varies across different life stages and audiences.
  • Redefining Happiness. Richard discusses the deeper meanings of happiness beyond material success.
  • Facing Fear in Transitions. Richard addresses the fears students and executives face during life transitions.
  • The Courage to Quit. He left a consulting career to pursue entrepreneurship, creating schools for low-income students.
  • Aha Moments in Class. Students realize they can define their own success, empowering them for the future.
  • Redefining Success. Success isn't just about happiness; it's about defining your own goals and path.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes