Women & Work: Does Your Biological Clock Have a Price? | Corinne Low – Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW: In this episode of the Ripple Effect podcast, Wharton’s Corinne Low shines an economic spotlight on gender bias by sharing valuable insights from her research on reproductive capital. That’s a phrase she’s coined to describe the economic value of fertility and the trade-offs that women face when choosing between investing their careers or their families.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 1:07 - What inspired Prof. Low’s research? 3:21 - Defining ‘reproductive capital’ 6:19 - Assigning value to reproductive capital 11:18 - Navigating economic trade-offs 15:17 - Understanding employer perspectives 18:29 - Placing value on caregiving time

PODCAST OVERVIEW: Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. well something that women bring to the table is producing something of economic value as well and that's women's
  2. reproductive Capital that women actually are bringing to the table this ability to procreate and create other human
  3. beings and this is a tremendous source of value in society because the same way economists are fundamentally concerned
  4. with how do we make all this stuff that we consume well people all across the world want to have children and so being
  5. able to create children is a really important form of capital in society welcome to the ripple effect the podcast
  6. that takes you on a journey through the minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be
  7. diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton
  8. professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today we'll be covering a diverse
  9. range of topics bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life into work so get
  10. ready to dive into new ideas with the ripple effect [Music] so Corinne what was it that that had you
  11. thinking about studying gender bias in the workplace in the first place well I think that's that's a big
  12. question I think the main thing that I'm interested in studying is I'm interested
  13. in studying the economics of being a woman and what sort of makes that unique and challenging and also
  14. special and um and so you know I wanted to really study the issues that were facing women
  15. with the same seriousness that we apply to the rest of you know economic science and so yeah I think it
  16. wasn't so much starting with the perspective of gender bias but starting with the perspective of you know if
  17. economics is the science of maximizing subject to constraint subject to scarce resources what are those unique
  18. constraints that women are facing what is that maximization or optimization problem look like from a woman's
  19. perspective and how can we use the same tools that we use to study how firms make decisions
  20. um and how consumers make decisions to understand the sort of um unique spectrum of decisions that women need to
  21. make yeah and so research like this is I mean it's being talked about this issue
  22. is being talked about a lot uh in society in general so doing research on these areas becomes very important as we
  23. look to see where the development lies yeah I think that's exactly right and I think you know one of the things I hope
  24. to accomplish with my research is that when we talk about these issues I think as I said we can't talk about them in a
  25. separate domain from economics and I wanted to bring together the cutting-edge science of Economics with
  26. these issues that affect women's lives because you know a lot of what economists do is study how people make
  27. decisions and I think women are people and women make decisions you know economic decisions as well and decisions
  28. have big economic consequences and so I hope I'm giving some language um such as by introducing the term
  29. reproductive capital and giving some language to the economics of women's decisions
  30. um to bring them kind of out of this domain of kind of treating them as like a separate set of issues that we would
  31. address through a separate set of tools and kind of um bring them back into this domain of
  32. economic decision making and maximization and optimization so if you can can you explain what
  33. reproductive Capital really is yeah sure so this is a term that I came up with when I was in grad school and
  34. um you know we talk about human capital and so well we'll start from the beginning
  35. which is just you know the term Capital typically means you know material things
  36. of worth that can be used to create other things of value right so we talk about firms making a trade-off between
  37. capital and labor and so they're deciding how much do I want to use workers how much do I want to use
  38. machines okay well economists came up with this term human capital which is the fact that
  39. skills that human beings have can be used to create things of economic value as well and so it's not just you know
  40. that a machine can be a form of capital but actually that you can have human capital and that's going to produce
  41. value and so we talked about education as investing in human capital so then I realized that while something
  42. that women bring to the table is producing something of economic value as well and that's women's reproductive
  43. Capital that women actually are bringing to the table this ability to procreate and create other human beings
  44. which is pretty fantastic and this is a tremendous source of value in society because the same way economists are
  45. fundamentally concerned with how do we make all the stuff that we consume right how does all the the consumer goodies
  46. that we want how do those all get manufactured and what's the optimal way to do that how do we create Financial
  47. Services Etc well people all across the world want to have children and so being able to
  48. create children is a really important form of capital in society and so I wanted to acknowledge that and coin this
  49. term to demonstrate that this was the source of economic value and I wanted to deliberately create that parallelism
  50. with human capital because one of the things about reproductive Capital that I highlighted my research is that it's
  51. time limited it depreciates like all forms of capital depreciates but reproductive capitalism is very
  52. specific and unforgiving schedule which is that you know as women aged into their late 30s and 40s they go through
  53. um a reproductive decline eventually menopause and so that time Horizon of reproductive Capital creates a
  54. fundamental trade-off between investments in human capital which are going to be worthwhile because you can
  55. Market those skills and get some economic returns that way versus investing and using your reproductive
  56. capital and having a family and producing children and that's not something you're going to Market in
  57. general so it's not going to ever be assigned this dollars and cents value on the traditional Market but it actually
  58. is something that's tremendously economic value economically valuable and we see that through people's choices
  59. people's choices to invest their time and money in children we see that children are something that people value
  60. and therefore we as economists should be concerned with how do they get produced
  61. were you able to determine a a level a value that really Associates what that reproductive Capital can mean to a woman
  62. as they're not only trying to have a family but also trying to build out their career
  63. yeah so that was something that was really important he was kind of trying to look at this as an economic trade-off
  64. and I said you know what there's the personal value that you put on having children and you know it's going to be
  65. hard to quantify that but we know that that's there and that's something that is talked about a lot in the media and
  66. it also has been talked about a lot in the in the research literature right that you know women are kind of facing
  67. this trade-off with their biological clock and they you know value having kids and this is something that they
  68. don't want to have to give up on um but what they didn't see is really trying to
  69. put an economic value on it and so to do that I turn to a type of Market where reproductive Capital has value and
  70. that's the marriage market so I thought you know if I can show that this actually affects women's perceived value
  71. on the marriage Market I'm going to be able to put an economic value on this um resource of reproductive capital and
  72. so what I did is I actually used a study where I randomly assigned age and income
  73. to dating profiles and then I had men rate these women's dating profiles with randomly assigned age and income and
  74. what I found is that for each year that a woman ages after age 30 she has to earn an additional seven thousand
  75. dollars a year to get the same rating in this experiment and because the age and the income are
  76. randomly assigned I can attribute it to you know it really is just that age that's driving this whereas if I use
  77. data from the world or from you know a dating site where I saw who was interested in whom I wouldn't be able to
  78. separate out the fact that somebody who's older has a lot of other things going on in her life right somebody
  79. who's older might be more likely to be divorced they might have a different photo they might have a different career
  80. but here I was randomly assigning the age and so I'm holding that profile constant and one person is seeing her at
  81. 35 and somebody else has seen her at 36 and that I'm able to Value what does that extra year mean and I found that it
  82. was worth the equivalent of seven thousand dollars of annual salary and that was showing that men really valued
  83. reproductive capital from their potential partners and then the way I was able to show that this is actually
  84. about fertility and reproduction of rather than other dimensions of age was that I found that there was not this
  85. preference for men who already had kids from a previous relationship and there wasn't this preference from
  86. men who didn't have good knowledge that there was a fertility decline between ages 30 and 40. so if they thought oh
  87. that's not something I have to worry about until like 45 or later they didn't have the same preference where they
  88. showed declining ratings over that 30 to 40 time span um and it also showed it was Stronger
  89. for people who wanted a more serious relationship who wanted to get married and who wanted to have kids whereas if
  90. you thought this was because you wanted somebody who was young and fun and cool to go drinking with you might think the
  91. people who are looking for a more casual relationship would actually have that stronger preference for younger age but
  92. it was actually the people who wanted to get married and wanted to have kids who
  93. showed this strong preference and so therefore I attribute this preference to the market value of fertility and it's
  94. not the traditional Market where we're able to put you know a price on it because it's going to be sold but it is
  95. a type of Market where you're making these trade-offs between all these different possible traits in your
  96. partner and one of the things that makes a woman more attractive on the marriage
  97. Market is bringing reproductive Capital to the table and so of course it has personal value whether or not you're
  98. able to have kids in this trade-off you might be making with your career but I wanted to show that there was a real
  99. economic cost to it as well so that for women if they were thinking about making
  100. an investment you know let's say their manager says I want to send you on this assignment to Asia and it's going to be
  101. really good for your career but you're going to have to work 80 hours a week and you know be totally 100 focused on
  102. you know launching this new team and that's going to cause you to say okay this is gonna delay my timeline for
  103. maybe getting married or having a family it's gonna increase my earnings it's gonna so it's gonna be good from a human
  104. capital right but there's going to be an appreciation in my reproductive Capital
  105. she's facing an economic trade-off there where you know there's value that she could be making and money she could be
  106. earning by making this investment but there's an economic loss for making it as well and so I wanted to put in those
  107. terms to show that this isn't just a personal decision this is an economic decision and surrealistically for a lot
  108. of women this is a a decision that they have to make in terms of their career slash in in correlation with their
  109. personal life uh in order to see what they value the most at that particular time
  110. yeah but I think you know it's not just about what they value it's about them sort of maximizing this economic
  111. equation where these are two things that are both valuable and you know she has to make a trade-off between them and so
  112. I think you're absolutely right that the issue here is that um both things are valuable and in some
  113. ways our society is not set up so that you can have it all at once right and so that's kind of exactly the policy
  114. recommendation that I would make is you know we can make this trade-off easier for women if we make it more possible to
  115. do both things at once and we make there be less of a trade-off between maximizing your human capital and
  116. maximizing your reproductive capital so with this information now how do you think that this impacts the the
  117. consideration of women when they're thinking about planning their careers or they're thinking about planning their
  118. lives what do you think the the the the the the the background is there well I think this is something that
  119. women think about and this is something that women sort of inherently know and it's kind of hard for people who are not
  120. women to maybe believe that because it's not something that they've been faced with all their lives but I have this
  121. paper about Israel making IVF free and what we see is that when ivf's made free you know from a naive perspective you
  122. might think okay that's going to impact the women who are like you know between 35 and you know early 40s who haven't
  123. had children yet and now they're going to be able to use IVF to have children but we actually see a tremendous impact
  124. on young women who are looking forward and planning their life and now they know that this technology is going to be
  125. available to them later in life and so they make the decision to delay marriage they make the decision to finish the
  126. degree they make the decision to break off the relationship that was only so so and maybe you know play the field a
  127. little bit more and wait for somebody else we see them increasing their representation and getting graduate
  128. degrees at Fields such as um being doctors and lawyers and um professors and things that require
  129. these long-term Investments and so we see young women making decisions in anticipation of how
  130. this reproductive time Horizon is changing based on the introduction of this new technology and so I think this
  131. is something that women know is a real constraint and they inherently plan around and they think about it and they
  132. talk about it um when they talk about it with their with their mentors and you know they map
  133. out their careers relative to this reproductive constraint and so as much as in some ways maybe my research is
  134. depressing and I'm showing oh now you have this other constraint to think about but it's also going to affect your
  135. appeal on the marriage market and it's kind of worth this much on the marriage Market I hope that it also makes women
  136. feel seen because they've been making this trade-off they've been facing this fundamental
  137. you know Catch 22 of like you can't do both you can't have it all and you know it can be crazy making to feel like okay
  138. I feel like there's this big issue that I'm dealing with and you know yet it's the responsibility is all on my
  139. shoulders and it's treated as something that's like because of me because I want
  140. a family because I you know value this now I'm the one who's kind of stuck in this bind and I wanted to tell and show
  141. women no this is a real economic constraint you're facing and you're facing it because
  142. you uniquely are in possession of something that's super economically valuable reproductive capital and you're
  143. trying to figure out how to maximize the value of this depreciating asset that you're holding and this other asset that
  144. requires your time to invest in it which is your human capital so how do you think then does this impact employers
  145. with their thought process about the structure of the company and what to expect moving forward and also because
  146. this is obviously part of a of a public policy debate going on in our country right now as well about what policy
  147. makers need to be thinking about around this yeah so I hope that um that firms and
  148. policy makers don't just invest in um fertility extending technology I think that that is
  149. kind of not solving the fundamental problem and so sometimes that's the solution we see firms reach for is that
  150. they say like okay we'll pay for our employees to freeze their eggs right but that's not solving this trade-off that's
  151. just kind of kicking the can down the road and it's kind of acknowledging if you're a firm that's doing that you're
  152. and you're not doing other things you're saying okay I'm not going to work to make this more sustainable for you to
  153. balance career and family I'm just going to ask you to wait and do it later after
  154. we've sort of gotten the value that we want to out of you right and so you know I think that it's great if firms want to
  155. pay for egg freezing but they can't stop there right I don't want to just move it
  156. further down the line because then women are going to be facing that trade-off that can't work forever so women are
  157. just going to face that trade-off when the time comes so I think what I would look for instead is
  158. that we truly place value as a society on reproductive capital and on caregiving
  159. and acknowledge that the time required for caregiving has not declined you know over the past 20 years
  160. and yet we have way more women in the labor force and we have way fewer households that are set up to have just
  161. one primary earner and one person who's able to do a lot of the home production and caregiving and focus exclusively on
  162. that and so all employees are kind of looking for more flexibility and more ability to
  163. kind of do this caregiving work and you know have their families and prioritize that in their lives because the
  164. structure of the American household has changed it's by and large two earners and we need to adjust to that so I think
  165. that's one thing that I would say is just um for firms to understand that that time spent on caregiving has not
  166. been declining and in fact it's been increasing so since the 1990s we've been spending more time with our kids because
  167. in this new economy and this is um was first documented in a paper by Raymond Ramey called the Rugrat race but in this
  168. new economy where our children's human capital is such a determination a determinant of their future success
  169. parents are investing a lot more time with their children and we understand a lot more that the time we put in results
  170. in the outcomes that they have and the achievements that they have later in life and so parents are doing a lot more
  171. intensive parenting and that's not something that you can solve with a machine so throughout
  172. um the 20th century we saw time at home be replaced by machines like dishwashers and washing machines
  173. and so for a little while it got easier to do the work at home because we had technology but technology can't replace
  174. our time spent with children and so what we've seen over the past 25 years is that time going up when we
  175. look at surveys like the American time use survey we see people spending more time on caregiving not less time on
  176. caregiving and so that's not going away and so it's something that firms fundamentally need to address and so
  177. that's my first big message to firms is think about caregiving as work that all of your employees have to do and figure
  178. out how that fits in with the work that they need to do for you and my second big message for firms which is I think
  179. part of that is rethinking flexibility to mean not just flexibility during the work day but
  180. flexibility across the life cycle so during the work day it's kind of part of that first big message is you know we've
  181. recognized like Zoom is a great technology that we can use to like you know not necessarily require people to
  182. be in the office when their kid is homesick right or you know breaking up their face time so that you know you
  183. don't need to stay at the office till 8 pm and Miss family dinner maybe you go home at five have did when your kids get
  184. out of daycare you have dinner with your family and then you log back on after they're asleep and you know get that
  185. last hour or so of work in so that's flexibility across the work day and I think that's something we need to invest
  186. in but the piece that I think is new with this understanding of reproductive capital and it's kind of specific
  187. schedule of decline which is that it really depreciates most rapidly during a woman's 30s which is the same time her
  188. human capital tends to increase in value and we see salaries going up the most is that we need flexibility across the
  189. life cycle so we need to say why is it that the typical career path is you get your MBA and then immediately you jump
  190. on the partner track at the consulting firm or at the investment bank or that high investment period And whatever firm
  191. you're in where you're expected to put in you know 75 hours a week when you're in your 30s and that's the
  192. time when reproductive capital is declining is there a way to build in flexibility across the life cycle so
  193. that women can make some of these Investments earlier or later and be able to have more time to actually maximize
  194. the value of their human capital and the reproductive capital and as we see people's working lives extend into their
  195. 70s there's no reason why women shouldn't be able to make some of these big investments in their 40s and be able
  196. to have the type of high-powered careers um that we see women dropping out of because firms too often force them to
  197. choose Korean great to have you with us today thanks very much thank you so much Dan always
  198. thank you for listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to
  199. subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School

Brief Summary

Corinne Low discusses reproductive capital and its economic impact on women's career choices and family planning.

Key points

  • Reproductive Capital Defined. Women bring reproductive capital to the table, a unique economic value in society.
  • Economic Trade-offs for Women. Women face a trade-off between career advancement and family planning.
  • Impact of IVF on Young Women. Making IVF free influences young women's life choices and career paths.
  • Caregiving as Essential Work. Recognizing caregiving as a crucial part of employee responsibilities can reshape workplace policies.
  • Rethinking Flexibility in Work. Flexibility should extend beyond the workday to accommodate life changes, especially for women.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes