New Work and Family Choices for Men and Women

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Baby Bust: New Choices for Men and Women in Work and Family, by Stewart D. Friedman, founding director of the Wharton Work/Life Integration Project, reveals the surprising results of a 20-year study into men's and women's changing views on work and family. 📂 Management;Human Resources

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Stu fredman professor at Wharton and author of the new book baby bust new choices for men
  2. and women in work and family welcome Stu thanks Jeff it's great to be here it's great to be uh here with you again and
  3. in this conversation that's been going on for for decades but is really highlighted I think in the discussions
  4. uh happening today in this new book of yours you raised some provocative issues about work and family MH uh for today's
  5. students and also for uh Generations it joins a conversation uh that's been going on for
  6. a long time and you know recently we've seen comments from Amry Slaughter from Cheryl Sandberg uh the actions of
  7. Marissa Meyer what as I read this book I really felt like you were compelled to write it sort of what compels you on
  8. this topic well uh there's a both a personal reason and a professional one I originally got into this topic area when
  9. my first son was born Now 26 years ago and uh when I met him for the first time I was uh overwhelmed by this question
  10. that I just couldn't get out of my head and that was what am I going to do to make the world a safe place for him to
  11. grow up in which was a question that I hadn't really thought much about before I met him um but I couldn't stop
  12. thinking about it and so when I got back into my Wharton classroom about a week or so later later um I I frame the
  13. question in a slightly different way for the students uh future Business Leaders
  14. of the world how are you thinking about the development not so much of talent in
  15. the Next Generation but of people uh and what does that mean for you professionally as well as personally in
  16. your own life and how are you going to figure out how to do that in in your own world and and that created quite a stir
  17. in the class because first of all they had prepared a case on motivation and reward systems and I had put that aside
  18. for the day and they weren't very happy about that but uh some people were quite
  19. upset about the fact that I was talking about family and kids uh others were upset because they didn't really want to
  20. hear about my personal life uh but quite a few were really grateful and interested in the questions that I was
  21. challenging them with as I just started to rant on this issue completely unprepared uh
  22. and they turned the question around to me and said well you know I don't know what to do why don't you tell us since
  23. you're the professor right uh and so that began a conversation that's now been going on for almost three decades
  24. now uh that I've had with students alumni and Business Leaders government officials all over the world so it
  25. started as a as a very personal question for me uh but it very soon became one that I could see uh was was important to
  26. my students uh to our school uh and to our our businesses and our society and so I I began a research program to try
  27. to answer some of those questions that's fantastic and and I I can absolutely relate we think about uh our own lives
  28. as professionals but also as parents you know and I I know I sit across from you
  29. as a father myself um you're a father you have uh you have two sons and a daughter and so this this isn't just an
  30. mic exercise definitely not it's very personal who do you really hope reads this book um and who might it be
  31. difficult for well so one of the things that we started to do with the Wharton work life integration project which we
  32. started in 1991 was to survey uh students and alumni so uh the class of 1992 undergrads we asked almost
  33. all of them responded to hundreds of questions about their lives their careers their values their aspirations
  34. their hopes their dreams um and that became the the basis for this book uh when 20 years later uh we asked the same
  35. questions of the class of 2012 and went to explore what we could discover about how things have
  36. changed um and what just popped off the the screen as we were looking at the initial findings was this this result uh
  37. in response to the question do you plan to have or adopt children yes probably not sure probably not or no in 1992 78%
  38. said yes in 2012 42% said yes yeah I scratched my head and thought is can that be right and it was uh so then the
  39. question was why and that's what the book tells the story of is is why that has uh changed so much the interest in
  40. having children or planning to have children and uh how it's different for men and for women and so as you pointed
  41. out at the start the conversation has changed new voices have entered the conversation there are new Norms
  42. evolving among young people and senior people about how to integrate the different parts of life in a way that
  43. work when I first started asking these questions it was it was very strange to be a man asking questions about work and
  44. family it was almost all women uh you know exploring that question but being a man at
  45. Wharton uh talking about families and kids it uh it made me kind of uh different and strange and so I got a lot
  46. of attention as a result just because of you know who I was not so much what I was doing but uh in terms of the quality
  47. of it uh and and that brought um a lot of interest in what we were doing here at Wharton and and it's it's something
  48. that uh you know the school um is was highly supportive of uh and being in the Vanguard of of uh interest in this topic
  49. now how is it that uh that that it's become difficult for some people to talk about I think the the most challenging
  50. audience uh or the most challenged audience would be uh Business Leaders and and social policy uh makers because
  51. what's what we observe in the data is that people's attitudes and values have changed but our our social institutions
  52. and our government policies and our business practices haven't they are still built around a model of family
  53. that has a single earner uh with with a mom at home taking care of the kids and that's just not the norm anymore so I
  54. think it's most challenging for those people who have uh you know the most responsibility for thinking about the
  55. direction of those of those institutions um so the the really striking statistic
  56. that you know you open the book with and you talk about um this big decline in the percentage of people who you know
  57. percentage of our undergraduate students who want to have children or are sure they're going to have children um is
  58. there a gender difference in that response no no it's exactly the same for men and women so so 78 79% men and women
  59. 92 and then 42 43% for men and women in in 2012 I'd like to dig into some of the
  60. findings yeah right and what you really discovered about men and about women from from your surveys and your
  61. conversations one of the things that you note is that you're really seeing a change in life priorities among men can
  62. you describe what that what that change looks like over these last 20 years uh men are somewhat more focused
  63. on career and a little bit less on family and that's that's the general Trend there um at the same time more men
  64. who are interested in becoming fathers are interested in being more involved as fathers uh and they don't see themselves
  65. as the sole bread winner anymore uh in '92 the Gen xers the men in that era were still of a mindset that
  66. was pretty traditional uh but today's men we don't see that uh they expect their spouses to
  67. be full-time engaged in careers uh they also expect to be working a lot more hours men and women
  68. so the the average number of expected hours per week has gone from 58 hours per week in ' 92 to 72 in 2012 that's 14
  69. hours per week more right uh but most importantly young men today expect more conflict between work and family and
  70. that's one of the big Inhibitors of their willingness to commit to being parents because uh it it it's they don't
  71. see how they can do it uh in addition uh the to the extent that they carry a lot
  72. of student debt that's another factor that um constrains men in their willingness to think about the prospect
  73. of having children it's not that they don't want it so much although that has gone down some the the the idea of being
  74. a parent it's how do I make it happen uh in in light of all these uh new pressures sure sure and and you talk in
  75. the book about students today and I I think this applies to both men and women they don't expect permanence they're
  76. leaving they're leaving college and going out into the work world uh and they have a different view of career
  77. paths can you describe that a little bit yeah uh was quite striking uh now this is the generation that were uh in their
  78. very formative years during 911 uh and that had a profound impact on them and the class of 92 and this came
  79. through very powerfully in the interviews that we did um but in addition uh as has been noted by many
  80. people studying uh the millennial generation they are much more mobile uh much less you know committed to
  81. organizations uh and and this particular class 2012 they entered College uh as is
  82. the Great Recession hit so their sense of um insecurity about their economic Futures is particularly acute uh and all
  83. those factors lead them to be um more interested in moving faster uh into career tracks that are going to give
  84. them security the next question I'd like to ask you is about about women yes so one of the things that really stood out
  85. to me was this change in perception among young women as they're leaving college that it used to be selfish to
  86. want a career right and now they feel like it's selfish to want children I mean in the conversations
  87. that you're having with them um how are they how do they deal with um that kind of perception that kind of sentiment
  88. well one of the pieces of what I see as good news in this story is that uh more people women and men are willing and
  89. able to say I don't want to have children and for women I especially I see this as a kind of social progress in
  90. in human evolution uh every generation prior to the current one uh you know women have been you know normatively
  91. sanctioned to think of themselves as mothers you know there's almost a a mind March into motherhood through throughout
  92. history that that question hasn't really been raised today young women are saying
  93. I don't feel a need to do that got it it's an opening up of choices in some exactly that's why the subtitle is new
  94. choices uh it's not just new constraints and and this this there's good news in this I think now at the same time there
  95. are many people who want to have children men and women who because they don't have support from their
  96. organizations from our society and these are questions I get into in the recommendations um you know can't figure
  97. out how to make it work uh but then there are those who are choosing not to and for good reasons they don't want it
  98. and I see this as progress that people are able to choose uh to not become parents because not everybody wants to
  99. nor should everyone become a parent sure and that that's mirrored as you note in
  100. the book by um by national Trends as well right about uh the average number of births per family um and and just
  101. what's happening within population Trends within the country yeah the uh the downward Trend in uh becoming
  102. parents uh you know over the last 20 years our data kind of reflects National Trends sure all right not just not just
  103. Wharton students absolutely what what else feels really important to you um about you know we're talking about women
  104. um for a little bit here what feels really important to you about changing perceptions um for women today versus
  105. this study 20 years ago women seem to be more realistic about what it's going to take to be successful
  106. in their lives uh and they're more interested uh according to our study in um friendships in networks and in being
  107. respected uh in their work and in their lives they're also more interested in doing work that has uh positive social
  108. value they want to help others uh more than the prior generation and one of the Striking
  109. findings uh that we observed is that the more uh that you wanted to be engaged in
  110. providing social value through your work the less likely it was that you would become a mother so it's almost as if uh
  111. there's a competition between serving the family of humanity versus the family that you might create uh with your own
  112. children sure and and this links to other work that you've done I mean I know within your book Total leadership
  113. you think about the self right you think about the family the career and the community so for um for
  114. men and for women what advice do you have um to move away from an either or mentality either family or career to one
  115. where you can integrate both of them right so in the uh in the recommendations uh in the book um baby
  116. bust I address what do we need to do as a society what do we need what organizations need to do and then what
  117. can individuals do and what we have found with this total leadership program that's also a course here that uh has
  118. been over subscribed for years now there's a lot of young people who are interested in it and tackling the
  119. question of what does it mean for me to be real to to clarify what matters most to me in terms of my values my vision of
  120. the kind of leader I want to become the kind of world I want to create to be whole who are the most important people
  121. in the different parts of my life and what do they really need for me and how can I serve them well and then to be
  122. Innovative to be continually experimenting with how things get done and I reserve a special section at the
  123. end of baby bust for how these uh issues and this method can be used by young men
  124. who uh I find are very confused uh because there is a we're in a moment in history where uh things are changing and
  125. changing fast and the models that they grew up with are different than the models that they want to create and so
  126. the the total leadership approach essentially uh helps you to see what matters most to you and then to figure
  127. out how to take creative action uh that's within your control uh that helps you to align your actions with your
  128. values in a way that serves the people around you that you care about sure and what the experiments are that people do
  129. uh to um to practice and to develop this mindset are uh in pursuit of what I call
  130. four-way wins small actions that you can take that demonstrably improve your work
  131. your home your community and yourself and by trying to do that in the laboratory of our course you develop new
  132. insights about what's possible in terms of how to integrate the different parts of your life in a way that works for all
  133. of them and by practicing that and seeing what's possible and usually what people discover is that they have more
  134. control and more um sense of agency and capacity to bring the different parts together they realize that uh that they
  135. can do that in in you know as they as they grow in in different uh parts of their career different stages of their
  136. career got it got it thank you thank Youk and one of the things that you talked about within the book um you presented
  137. this metaphor right which which also resonates to me as I think about establishing managing boundaries
  138. integrating life you talked about the double dutch metaphor right you can't actually jump two ropes at once um and
  139. you point to people like Richard Fairbanks from Capital One or John Donahue from eBay um what did you see in
  140. their lives and in their careers uh that could resonate with today's graduates these are two of many many
  141. examples that are out there that give a lie to the myth that you have to sacrifice everything in order to be
  142. successful in your career uh what I have seen time and time and time again in my
  143. own life and in the people that I study and work with and consult with is that um people are more successful in their
  144. careers to the extent that they don't divest of the of their lives their families their communities their
  145. personal lives you mind body and spirit but in fact they are more successful in their careers to the extent that they
  146. invest in those other parts that there's Mutual gain to be had and these these two executives are just two of many
  147. examples uh that I've been studying and that I'll be writing about in another book next year that I hope we can talk
  148. about um uh so but the common myth there is that you have to give up everything and it's just not true now that's not to
  149. say that you know sacrifices aren't needed and that you know there's there's pain and disappointment of course we all
  150. face that U but what is possible and what I'm hopeful about and what the results of the baby bust um research
  151. tells us is that uh because men and women are now more aligned in their views about what it takes to make life
  152. work uh especially dual career relationships we're seeing a lot more experimentation a lot more working
  153. together men and women private Public Partnerships in creating models that are different than the ones that you and I
  154. grew up with uh and uh demonstrate that it it doesn't have to be a zero sum game
  155. and that uh there are different models of career and of family that can work um but it's a long slow process cultural
  156. change is a slog and it takes years and years and years and years and it happens
  157. in part through the stories that we tell right well I want to return and we started this conversation uh and you
  158. said look policy makers organizational leaders they're some of the folks that you hope are reading the book um and
  159. that they're also the ones responsible for leading this kind of change that you're talking about uh in the in the
  160. last chapter of the book you have recommendations yeah um so could you talk about some of those recommendations
  161. if you're a CEO if you're leading Human Resources practice um how can organizations start to change to support
  162. um these kinds of four-way winds integrated lives it's such an important question uh
  163. and and it's not just organizations it's social and educational policy and then it's what individuals can do but for
  164. organizational leaders uh the key is uh making flexibility real uh and using the
  165. power of digital Communications technology to enable uh real exibility in terms of where when
  166. and how work gets done and most importantly today in 2013 to um to make Heroes of the people who are successful
  167. in in figuring out new models for how to get work done and that is going to help
  168. us overcome the stigma of flexibility which a number of researchers uh Joan Williams Shelley Carell and others are
  169. writing about and talking about and demonstrating is still very very real for men and for women uh for for taking
  170. you know flexible work options it's it's stigmatized in most organizations and you you overcome that you help to
  171. overcome that by uh demonstrating that uh flexibility works and the best way to do that is to tell individual stories of
  172. people who are successful in both their work and in the rest of their lives whatever matters most of them whether
  173. it's family or you know social issues or religious you know whatever it is it's not just about kids um and and that's
  174. that's that's an important function that that businesses can play in addition to
  175. providing uh you know flexible uh benefits and other kinds of policies but the real issue is culture and cultural
  176. change and uh again the models that are promoted as valued will make it E make it easier for um for others to see ah
  177. well if Jeff can do that well maybe can try that uh so long as it's going to help the company and me so it can't be
  178. just about me and my kids and my needs and you know my emotional state it's what changes can I make that work well
  179. for me and for our organization so steu you've you've been at this for for 20 plus years right
  180. thinking about the work life work life balance the work life integration project that you've LED here at the
  181. school um this is obvious a topic uh that you are that you're deeply connected to that you're passionate
  182. about um where does it go from here you mentioned I mean some of the things that
  183. you'll be doing going forward but where does the research go well one of the things we want to do is to uh mine the
  184. data that we collected about the class of 1992 to learn more about how they have evolved and how they see their
  185. futures um and then I'm expecting that in 2032 we'll we'll survey that class uh to see what they're thinking uh and and
  186. we'll be doing more um you know on going research of of Wharton students in alumni to just continue to track their
  187. values and their interests in in the different parts of their lives uh what I'm most excited about now is uh tonight
  188. we are launching uh the student Advisory board for the work life integration project and we've got a couple dozen
  189. students at all levels in both MBA and undergrad who are really eager to uh help use this research as a platform and
  190. really as a catalyst for creating a new kind of conversation on our college campus and in other college campuses to
  191. invite and um inform young men and women to start to talk about what these issues
  192. mean for them now because it's clear that the sooner uh we engage in real conversation about what our interests
  193. are uh men and women in shaping and leading the kind of lives we want the much more likely it is that uh that
  194. those dreams will be f F filled because no one's going to hand it to these kids they're going to have to forge it
  195. themselves they're going to need our help uh and I think it starts with uh with dialogue informed by research
  196. [Music]

Brief Summary

Stu Friedman discusses changing attitudes toward parenthood and work-life integration in his new book, "Baby Bust."

Key points

  • The Baby Bust Phenomenon. A significant decline in the desire to have children among young adults is explored.
  • Changing Perspectives on Parenthood. Young women now feel it's selfish to want children, reflecting a shift in societal norms.
  • Flexibility in the Workplace. Organizations must embrace flexibility to support integrated lives for employees.
  • Launching Student Advisory Board. A new initiative to engage students in work-life integration discussions.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes