Analyzing China's Residential Land Prices

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Finance & Accounting;Real Estate

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we are speaking today with professor joe jerko of the wharton real estate department
  2. uh joe thank you very much for joining us today it's a pleasure to be here so you uh
  3. uh have collaborated with your colleagues at the national university of singapore and qingwa
  4. university in china on a really pioneering project where wharton worked with these other
  5. universities to create indices of housing land prices in china could you begin by telling us
  6. what are some of the most significant takeaways sure sure and these are real price
  7. indexes for land values in china not housing but the land underneath the housing
  8. the takeaways are as follows number one at a national level there has been remarkably strong price
  9. growth in land values it works out we have eight years of data from 2004 through the first half of 2013
  10. and the average annual compounded price growth is just over 16 per year so it's really a strikingly large number
  11. um and that's the aggregate over all of china there is a lot of variation across regions and cities however in
  12. that sense china's somewhat like the united states it's a very big country and you do not get the same price growth
  13. everywhere at the city level beijing has been growing astronomically strong 22 percent
  14. average annual compound growth rate since 2004 markets like gian very very different
  15. four to eight percent in some of the central and western cities of the country so it's not one size does not
  16. fit all in chinese land markets so as you looked at all the data what was the biggest surprise for
  17. you i i'm not so sure i was surprised by any i expected high price growth rates one of the things that's clear is you
  18. can't continue to have 16 per annum growth because prices will go to infinity fairly quickly if you have another
  19. decade of that but i don't know that i was surprised by that i think what i probably surprised me
  20. most is how varied the results are across cities now what implications would you say
  21. your findings have for international residential developers who may be interested in
  22. opportunities in china i think you have to be worried about how high the price growth has been in
  23. the past and you have to carefully consider how long you think it can continue at its present very high
  24. trend rate into the future you just have to be cautious this is not advice that there's an obvious bubble
  25. that there's going to be a crash because i don't know that for sure what i think
  26. i do know for sure is i will be very very surprised if we have another eight years of 16
  27. per annum compounded growth i'd like to come back a little later to the 16 number uh which i think works out to
  28. almost 200 percent over the course of your study correct uh but but for now you know just to set
  29. the background uh can you help explain for our audience a little bit about how china's land market differs from
  30. uh the market in other countries and what challenges did that pose for you as you went about your
  31. research sure china's really very unique in this sense if you study and look at housing prices
  32. across the world including in the united states you never see land values you don't see
  33. vacant land being sold in the data so what you see are house prices which the price of my house or your house
  34. in a price index is the sum of the land value and the improvements the building itself
  35. china's different the communist party of china owns all the land in urban areas the local governments do
  36. so if you're a developer mukul and you want to put up a private residential complex you have to purchase the land
  37. from the local government and what you purchase is actually a land lease you purchase the rights to use the land
  38. for up to 70 years in residential for residential development which is what our index is all about we
  39. only cover land sales that are going to be used for residential development not other commercial development
  40. so the prices we're reporting and the indexes we're reporting are technically those for leasehold
  41. estates now the way it works in china is the developer makes a one-time lump sum payment for the use
  42. rights of up to 70 years and we treat that one-time payment as the sales price now we we think that's a pretty
  43. reasonable assumption largely because the usage rights are for multiple decades and as many of the listeners here will
  44. recognize the present value of anything 50 to 70 years from now it's pretty close to zero
  45. so we think that's a good assumption now in 25 years that may not be such a good
  46. assumption because you may be near the end of some of these usage rates but that's
  47. what makes it very very different in china china's virtually unique as far as i can tell
  48. in that respect and and what challenges did that pose as you went about your research well
  49. there were many challenges one is data accumulation in china is very very difficult
  50. um in i'm sure the government the central government has much data that they don't release
  51. and aren't going to release the academics like me or my co-authors so what we did was to essentially scrape the
  52. websites of the local land use authorities there was a national law passed more well over a decade ago that required the
  53. posting of the winning bidders in land auctions so and it also required that the land be transacted by a visible
  54. auction was an anti-corruption move as you can imagine before this law came into being or could be all
  55. types of side payments between developers and local officials so we have a number of people who
  56. literally scrape the websites of the 35 local land authorities from whom we collect
  57. data and you might imagine a bunch of students graduate students and undergrads particularly in beijing who
  58. are cleaning the data and making sure it makes sense so let's come back now to to the
  59. question of the rate of growth means as you said 16 percent a year 200 percent over the course of the of of
  60. eight years um just to put those numbers in perspective do we know how those kinds of price
  61. increases compare to housing land price increases in other countries and what are some of the factors driving
  62. that increase in china we cannot directly compare them to land prices in other countries simply because
  63. we do not see land value measured consistently in other countries a couple of comments
  64. though on this one in an eight-year period for prices to go up 200 percent is really quite extraordinary very
  65. extraordinary it's much higher than the government's published data on housing prices which leads me to
  66. believe they're really understating the house price rises because land's got to be a big component
  67. of value in china that's number one so it's got to be high the other thing if you go to my website
  68. and download the data which by the way everyone can do just on on my website we we welcome people to
  69. look at and study and use the data as they will you will see a couple of different periods in other words this 16
  70. figure you and i have been discussing it's not a smooth rise up so just i i wrote down a couple of
  71. notes the first really big increase in aggregate land values in china occurred in 2007.
  72. literally in three quarters from the first to third quarter of 2007 real land values in aggregate across the
  73. 35 cities we're tracking rose 71 percent just in that nine month period now following that dramatic rise
  74. real prices fell 34 until the first quarter of 2009 and then you ask about the factors driving
  75. some of this series from 2009 to the end of 2010 prices more than doubled they went up 108 percent according to
  76. our index in real terms that period coincides with the great chinese stimulus so it's pretty clear there are a number
  77. of drivers some of this is government policy related but some of it is clearly demand side
  78. related which is there is an incredible move from rural areas into urban areas in china so demand is
  79. very very strong and in some of these areas although this is the subject of future research
  80. it's unclear how much new supply is actually being created the my two co-authors and
  81. i are working on a project to measure supply in these markets now so i'll have more to say on that you know
  82. sometime next year hopefully but clearly there's a lot of demand but you look at these data in the series
  83. government policy matters in china it matters a lot to their local land markets no i think that sounds very reasonable
  84. apart from the stimulus did you see any other political factors at work um only not in our indexes so the
  85. indexes are just created from the data when you look at the nature of how households in china think about
  86. owning many of them pretty clearly view it as a store of value in a way that you and i don't in the
  87. united states which is my house i own a home because it provides shelter for me and my family
  88. my kids get to go to the school district in which my house is located and the like in china investment
  89. restrictions are much more severe than they are in the u.s the typical household there could not
  90. diversify by buying the s p index and the like so for them a lot of households i think
  91. pretty clearly are buying because they view this as a good store of value a hedge
  92. and and the like so there are different motivations in china than there are for most u.s households
  93. in particular i see uh you also referred to earlier the fact that uh house prices in beijing uh
  94. in the beijing area land prices land prices in the beijing area increased much faster than other parts of the country
  95. what explains some of these regional variations i i think a couple of things one we do know that demand growth that
  96. is in migration to beijing and particularly some of the east coast cities is very very strong so partly its demand
  97. what i also suspect but don't know and again this is the future research is that it's probably harder to build in
  98. some of these coastal markets but we actually don't have good measures yet about how much new supply is coming on
  99. in each of these markets but like i said hopefully in a future date you'll have me back for
  100. another interview and we'll be able to say something about that my economics gut is it's both supply and
  101. demand we can pin down demand we can't yet pin down the contribution of the supply side to
  102. that remarkable growth right now one really fascinating phenomenon in china's housing market
  103. that i've heard people talk about is that developers acquire land from the government as you explain right
  104. and then they just go ahead and build without really estimating what the real demand is from consumers
  105. and this has led to the creation of these so-called ghost cities with a lot of houses with
  106. no one living in them uh did did you take some of these factors into account and and and what do you think of this uh
  107. phenomenon one it the phenomenon definitely exists you can see it documented their news
  108. teams that show you these ghost cities but in the 35 markets we covered there aren't ghost cities per se in
  109. these in these markets so we're looking at believe it or not china has well over a hundred i believe cities or
  110. urban areas with more than a million people we're looking at 35 large ones the ghost cities phenomena is not a
  111. major issue in in them you don't see entire developments or swaths of beijing for instance that are vacant
  112. so that's well that phenomena clearly exists in some parts of china it tends to be in outlying areas and not
  113. in the major markets so in other words it didn't affect your data and didn't have
  114. an impact no we don't we don't really see that phenomena a lot we're looking and trying to
  115. measure vacancy rates believe it or not there's no published vacancy rate series in china
  116. it's one of the things we're trying to do in current research we've looked first at beijing there's
  117. not a lot of vacancy in in beijing in other words it doesn't look like they're just ghost
  118. developments throughout that city at all now maybe we'll see them in some of the
  119. other 34 markets that we track but thus far we we just don't see that in the markets we're did you find any
  120. evidence of a land bubble in china well i i i don't know what a bubble is per se i find it i
  121. i don't believe you can have another eight years of 16 per annum growth so that means the
  122. bubble i don't know it means prices are very high um they're high relative to incomes of
  123. the people buying the housing units that the developers are putting up on these plots of land
  124. so i'm a firm believer you cannot have this level this trend rate of growth continuing
  125. i don't know whether it's a bubble it's back to my advice to developers and investors you have to be very cautious
  126. look at the local demand and supply fundamentals i think there are some markets where they clearly
  127. still make very good sense and others where i'd be really worried about the sustainability as you look to
  128. the future what impact do you think that the economic slowdown that we see these days
  129. in china that could have on land prices well i again it's going to come through both supply
  130. and and demand i'd be more worried about supply effects that is developers not cutting back
  131. sufficiently on development to accommodate the lower trend growth rate i i suspect there's going to still be
  132. rural in-migration into urban areas in china because the income differences between a
  133. factory job in wuhan or qingdu even off the coast and being a you know a farmer are very
  134. very high and you're going to see that movement the question is has the trend growth
  135. rate in china slows will you see development slow enough to accommodate it so i think the biggest
  136. risk will be from over supply in markets and like i said that we we don't have good measures of oversupply yet
  137. although that's something we all need to be thinking about going forward uh you spoke earlier about some future
  138. research uh what's the next phase of your study going to be and what we're looking at
  139. next in china so a couple of things one we will continue to update the indexes every quarter
  140. will update the national index the city and regional indexes only come out every
  141. six months or every year that has to do with data availability issues so that's one we'll continue to update
  142. this and number two near to my heart and to all of our the whole research team is trying to get a handle on how much
  143. new supply has been created and how much you need given that it looks like demand growth
  144. while still going to be substantially positive in china china's not going to go negative
  145. but the difference between seven to eight percent growth and 12 percent growth is a lot so the the next big project
  146. is what has to happen to supply to make the market stay sane or be seen in a world where trend demand
  147. growth is 50 to 60 percent of what it used to be right and in conclusion joe this if you if there
  148. were some ceos of international real estate companies who asked for advice about china and the land market
  149. there uh what would you tell them well i tell them what you have learned so far one just be very careful um the data in
  150. china are hard to come by and it's hard to create stuff so make sure you're looking at
  151. real data and good data and then you know just be realistic on what you think demand growth is going to be and as
  152. carefully as you can try to measure the supply competition because one of the things we learned in
  153. the us is its supply matters not just demand god joe thank you so much for speaking
  154. with knowledge at work my pleasure thank you you

Brief Summary

Professor Joe Jerko discusses land price growth in China and implications for international developers.

Key points

  • Pioneering Project on Land Prices. Wharton collaborates with universities to create land price indices in China.
  • Remarkable Growth in Land Values. China's land values have seen an average annual growth of over 16%.
  • Caution for Developers. Joe warns international developers to be cautious about high price growth.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes