Empowering Poor Students Through Knowledge
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
π ESG
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- our guest today is michael feinberg co-founder of the knowledge is power program
- kip foundation he launched kip in 1994 with his partner dave levin today almost 20 years later it has grown
- into a network of 141 high-performing schools in 20 states all over the u.s the network serves more than 50 000
- students most of whom are from low-income african-american or latino families mike thank you so much for joining us
- today thank you for having me here it's a pleasure now before you started kipp you taught
- third grade fifth grade for three years as part of the teach for america program
- could you tell me the story of your first teaching experience and how that led to the creation of kip
- sure actually i taught fifth grade for two years before starting the knowledge of power program
- in our third year uh we were 19 we were both 1992 teacher america corps members placed in houston and i was a fifth
- grade bilingual teacher teaching bilingual because i had a pulse there was such a shortage at the time
- dave was on another part of town teaching upper elementary as well and like all first-year teachers we were
- horrible teachers in fact i think that we probably gave everyone a run for the money for being the worst of the
- horrible teachers um we latched on to master teachers we learned how to teach you learn how to teach with
- apprenticeship the end of our first year we thought we were doing a pretty good job with our
- kids they loved learning they came excited about school and wanted to go to college and have a career we very
- naively thought we've done it on the k-12 assembly line we gave our kids a great fifth grade year opted to go on to
- bigger and better in middle school and that naive bubble burst about the second week into our second year of
- teaching when we watched our former kids start to just utterly fail and have the
- wheels come off in middle school and they were escaping school and joining gangs and doing drugs becoming parents
- alarming rates and the first was easy to blame the other schools and teachers and one night in late 1993 we had this
- epiphany that all that finger pointing was adding to the problem not contributing to a solution so we looked
- in the mirror we point the finger at ourselves we stayed up all night pouring our
- feelings of failure and frustration on the computer screen watch uh had you two oktong baby playing around repeat play
- and by about five o'clock in the morning we had the knowledge's power program kip
- on the computer screen and the premise of kit back then 20 years ago it is today is very simply there are no
- shortcuts if we're going to try to provide children with all the academic intellectual and character skills they
- need to do well not just in that grade level but in all facets of the k-12 college and the competitive world beyond
- then quit looking for the magic bullet let's just roll up our sleeves and get after it and so we started the knowledge
- power program thinking what can we do with fifth grade teachers everybody decided we were going to motivate kids
- to go to school from 7 30 to 5 4 hours on saturdays half the summer two hours of homework at night
- and we quickly realized one year was enough and so that's when we turned it into a school and now it's become a
- network of schools got it i'll come back a little bit to to to to the nature of the program but uh
- sticking for uh for now to the way you built kip what were some of the biggest challenges that you faced in
- the beginning and how did you overcome them the biggest challenge by far in the early years remains the biggest
- challenge today which is on any given day in any given hour in any given class period with any given
- student teaching and learning is extremely difficult it's everyone thinks that they know how to do
- it well because we've all got 13 14 15 years of experience in k-12 but actually being in front of a group of
- children and and and imparting knowledge for from your brain heart into the brain heart of a 5
- 10 or 15 year old is an extremely difficult both art and science to do now that and to do it at a high level is the
- most difficult part about this the the other most difficult part is simply getting people to believe having putting
- forth an idea for a program and then a school that's going to end mass help underserved children succeed in school
- and life at the highest levels of society most people think you have two heads when you first say that now we've
- come a long way since the early 90s and more people believed today than did 20 years ago but collectively we don't yet
- believe in a society that the achievement gap is something that we can overcome and that's what we
- are trying to demonstrate and prove every single day that it can let's go back to
- talking about the basic structure of the program uh the no shortcuts approach is this something that you started with
- or is it something that evolved over time and how is your your the the basic uh structure of of kip uh the
- education model evolved over the past 20 years right uh the basic structure still
- in place i think i think the the most innovative part of kipp over the years is that we didn't try to be innovative
- we just tried to block and tackle really well we focused early on ourselves on just what could we do to
- become great teachers and to this day that that's the focus it's great great teaching um any school in the world
- that's doing a great job i'd argue has two basic ingredients it's great teaching and more of it that's simple
- now easy to say hard to do but it's a simple formula if there's any secret sauce is how do you create the culture
- that's such a great positive culture that allows great teaching and more of it to happen
- but that basic structure of longer school day week and year and focus on great teaching and learning and having a
- culture of high expectations and focusing on not just inputs but the ultimate output which is getting our
- kids to go to and through college and have the freedom to do this for what they want to do those things were put in
- place from the very beginning and we're focused on executing on those things day
- in and day out the last thing i think i'd say that is there from the beginning is our core beliefs
- and i think one of our most central core beliefs is that promises to children are sacred
- because kipp is a choice public school we we sit in living rooms and kitchen tables talking to kids and parents
- saying if you choose to come to kipp we will do whatever it takes to help you come to we will we'll do whatever it
- takes to help you get to and through college that that's a pretty bold promise because we're not talking about what
- we're going to do for that kin family next week next month next year sometimes not even next decade we're promising
- what's going to happen in 20 years in some cases and we're on the hook and that's something that we feel more
- accountable to that sacred promise then any accountability plan any state or federal government can lay on us and i
- think that that's what gets us out of bed in the morning and that's what motivates us to do right by our kids and
- parents and our communities do the kids and the parents also make a similar promise and and and uh so is is your
- approach to select the most highly motivated uh kids and people we don't select our kids and parents they select
- us uh it's a it's a public open enrollment school which means anyone can can come
- if there's if more kids and parents want to come in space available we have to go
- to a lottery and the only kids who don't have to be in a lottery are the younger
- brothers and sisters so we do not get to do any kind of selection we just are a public school of of choice and whoever
- wants to come we it we are we are on the hook with that sacred promise to deliver and help them learn
- everything they need to learn to be set up for success in school and life so you serve about 50 000 students right
- now across the 141 schools that are part of your network how many students apply
- uh to become part of cap and uh and how many are you able to admit it varies region or region where i am in in
- houston where we now have 22 schools and 11 000 kids last year we had nearly 10 000 kids and parents apply to come to
- kipp we had room for 2 000. so we had a very uh difficult lottery where we were saying sorry no room to 80 percent of
- all the kids and parents who want to come which that's one of the things the thing that i wake up in the middle
- of the night kicking and screaming having nightmares about are how we're going to keep our sacred promise to the
- kids we're serving and when i'm not having a nightmare about that the other thing that's making me wake up at night
- are how are we going to continue to grow to serve those other thousands of kids and parents who are looking for another
- option and we're not able to deliver yet so we're trying to grow as fast as we can but as slow as we must to maintain
- quality great so that's that's a great approach i think uh balancing growth and and not
- compromising on quality uh is is is really tough but yeah i'm glad you're straddling that
- there's people that are amazed about our growth and how big we've gotten and we are very proud of having
- this high performing network of 141 schools and 50 000 kids but remember it we're about to celebrate
- our 20th anniversary in 2014. there was no growth for the first six years right and so and then when we started
- growing we the first thing we did we put in place a terrific school leadership training
- program with just a few fisher fellows our school leaders we were training and over the last two decades
- decade and a half we ramped it up to now we can be growing at 15 or 20 schools a
- year but this has not happened overnight nor did it even happen in a decade it's
- taken 20 years to grow this way so this is this is just slow and steady progress
- keeping a commitment staying on track and just executing day in and day out on a strategy
- so uh you you mentioned that for the first six years it was kind of not much growth and then at the sixth
- year there was a jump start was that the year when you partnered with uh uh the fishers uh yes
- at the gas or the founder co-founders of gap right so uh how did that come about so kip started the program
- and we had a chance to start it as a school both in houston then in new york city right dave levin's from new york
- city so he went we had both offers and being young and dumb we took both offers so dave started kipp academy in the
- bronx i stay in houston star kip academy there both with fifth grade we grew one year
- at a time our heads were down we were focused on our kids and delivering on sacred promises by 1999 they be our two
- schools became full-size fifth grade through eighth grade charter schools uh they were they were some of the highest
- performing schools in the respective communities of houston new york city people started visiting 60 minutes did a
- piece on our kids that opened up the floodgates we had people calling saying we saw that program on tv can we order
- 15 kips for next year please and we were saying let's go check inventory um and believing in teach for america and
- the mission of teacher america of one day all children should get a great education
- we start thinking so how do we leverage the success of this little tiny school in southwest houston and this little
- tiny school in the south bronx new york to greater good so we started asking people for help and advice on how to
- scale ideas and and scale success and we were fortunate enough to to get in touch with don doris fisher the founders
- of the capital navy that were very focused and passionate about ed reform in the united states and it was a it was
- a terrific match and and we created a new foundation together called kip foundation i want to call it the north
- shore cuts foundation but don is it a nonprofit yeah non-profit dot don knew more about brand
- names than me he said call it kip and we said yes sir and so we started kipp foundation in april of 2000 with the
- goal of finding amazing teachers who have a fire in the belly to do this work beyond the four walls of their classroom
- we would train them for a year in this fellowship the fisher fellowship to have them to get the business and leadership
- skills to complement their terrific instructional skills and from there help them start the school of their dreams
- and that's how we've been growing as we have for the past 13 years you've mentioned a couple of times the
- importance of passionate teachers what do you what do you think makes a great teacher
- and how do you identify the teachers who are the best fit for kip i think there are four things that make a teacher a
- great teacher first and foremost it's a teacher that that has a lot of knowledge
- and passion in the subject at the subject matter they're teaching they don't need to rely on the teacher's
- edition to teach they can bring a wealth of outside resources in the classroom and make the learning come alive and if
- they love history the kids will love history right second the teacher knows how to take all that knowledge and
- passion from their brain and heart and transfer it into the brain and heart brain heart of a five ten or fifteen
- year old which for some people is a gift for most of us mortals that's a skill which has to be acquired over several
- years to learn how to do that really well third we're looking for teachers who have the basic attitude of doing
- whatever it takes that they're they're going to be the constant not the variable and even though kids especially
- in from underserved communities come to school with lots of variables and lots of potential excuses why learning is
- difficult the teachers will try to be the constant not the variable for as much as possible
- and lastly to to avoid uh being the example of the the sports team that has the loaded with talent but
- never wins the championship you also have to have to have teachers that buy into the basic core beliefs and
- values of that school right it's possible to be a terrific teacher as i named but still not fit with the rest of
- the faculty and we need people who are going to be good teammates not just in their classrooms but in the teachers
- lounge in the locker room as well right um now so so so you partnered with uh the the fishers to to launch the create
- the kept foundation you took kept national uh what challenges did you face in scaling things up and how did you
- overcome them and what lessons did you learn uh you know for us if great teaching and more of it are the
- ingredients of grade school the critical path is the great school leader because that great the principal the
- principal or the school leader is going to be the one who's going to recruit the
- great teachers develop the great teachers retain the great teachers motivate the great teachers and so for
- us the most challenging part has been to recruit and select those amazing terrific leaders we've had in the last
- 13 years we've had over 5000 people apply for the fisher fellowship we've given out about 190 fellowships about 30
- people didn't make it through the fellowship so we're batting about a two to three percent acceptance rate
- um so god bless the fisher family and and many other funders who who've been who've been making this possible
- that's not a quota that's how many people we we've been able to successfully find to do this work
- and uh it's getting relatively easier as we've created this large footprint of schools more and more of our fisher
- fellows are our teachers who are developing over time to the leadership pipeline
- but finding these talented terrific school leaders and then keeping them because you know
- running a school these are like dog years right so it it it really you know i had a ponytail when i started um so we
- so it takes really just commitment and skill and hard work and tenacity and so finding these people and keeping them is
- the biggest challenge i have a question about your students and this is based on some discussions
- i've had with people in other countries who are trying to do similar work as you
- are doing here one of the things they've found is that although they may have a great program
- that that educates the kids in school when the children go back to the social and family environment
- sometimes it has the effect of undoing some of the good that has happened in school
- i wonder if you have ever faced that challenge and and uh have you ever how you've dealt with it we have families
- and we form great relationships with all of our families as part of this work we're
- partners with with our families and there are examples where the parents or grandparents almost feel threatened
- by their their child or grandchild suddenly learning more about the world than they
- have but that i would say is is more the exception to the rule just about every home i've been in and
- i've been over a thousand homes families are hungry for their children to to live the
- american dream and now that we're doing international work as well and we're in we're helping
- educators start these kip inspired schools in india and south africa and israel and chile and mexico i realized
- that the american dream is really a global dream it's hard it's hard to find parents who don't want their children to
- have a better life than them and they and parents deliberately realize or simply
- instinctively realize that education is the ticket for their kids to have a better life right i'm very fascinated by
- your overseas expansion can you tell me a little more uh about what were the challenges involved there sure
- uh for a bunch of years we've always had international educators knock on our door and ask for help
- and that traffic has increased in the last four or five years it's i think it's due to the the growth of of
- as teach for america has become teach for all and teach roles and i was in two dozen countries more and more of the
- alumni they finish their two years uh you know half of them want to go to grad school
- or goldman or mckinsey the other half want to stay in the classroom and stay in their schools and make a difference
- and they wind up knocking on our door and for a few years we when they first came and asked us for help and they
- would come and see what we were doing and say can you come to our country our answer was always sorry we haven't even
- fixed the state of arkansas yet we have a lot of work to do here um i like to give more hope so i told people look we
- can help you the way we help ourselves we focus on leadership training and if you have the skills or passion or you
- know someone in your country's got the skills and passion and there's resources to get them to united states come over
- here i'll sneak them in the side door of the fisher fellowship we'll train them in leadership with our fisher fellows
- have them stay in the u.s for a few months they can beg bro and steal all the great ideas
- because we we don't believe in intellectual property we give it away you know one one day all children um and
- then they'll go back to their country start a great school it won't be a kipp school but it'll be a kipp inspired
- school and they'll be part of our network and they'll have this cohort with the kipp school leaders and we'll
- learn and grow together um we didn't market it we just put the bait in the water and the israelis for the first
- country to take me up on it then then came the indians um then came the mexicans uh then the south africans and
- most lately the chileans um and where you know we we spun off a new nonprofit called the one world network of schools
- because there's such a growing line at the door so when people knock on kip's door we refer them to one world and the
- one world network of schools will help both do the do the training support on the back end help people
- start these schools and most importantly you know if we're this is going to grow
- when people first knock on our door they think they want to replicate kip what they really want to replicate is the
- kipp school leadership program i mean you know my indian friends don't talk about wanting to start
- with dozens or hundreds of schools they need thousands right there's a little bit of a scale issue in india right and
- so what they they don't have enough philanthropy and we don't have enough seats to train everyone in the united
- states so ultimately we have to replicate is the kipp school leadership program so there's an in-country place
- for teachers to get trained to start these breakthrough new transformative schools in country that's how you can
- scale this right it's fascinating how do you measure kip's success the ultimate outcome is did we deliver
- on our sacred promises to our children so have they did they get to and through college and now have the freedom to do
- this world what they want to do and so tracking from eighth grade which we do to be more transparent i could tell you
- 100 of my kids are going to college if i look at my class of 2013 but that's not those are not the same
- kids we started with so if i look at my eighth graders from a bunch of years ago
- and wherever they went to high school we tracked them all 85 to 90 percent are going to college
- and so far depending on the region 45 to 48 percent have graduated from college and
- we think about that in two ways you know compared to eight percent of low-income
- kids who graduate from college where five to six times the national average we celebrate that compared to 31 of all
- adults in the united states have a college degree we're a lot higher than that we celebrate that
- compared to 82 percent of top quartile income kid to graduate from college we're still well below that number so we
- still have an achievement gap and we are hungry to get better every day so what what are the main obstacles to
- closing that achievement gap and how are you tackling them several things first off is just
- continued rigor in pre-k through 12th grade and getting the kids for academic success to
- be ready for for college work and not need any remediation uh those numbers i gave you were all
- kids that we started with in fifth grade in a lot of cases didn't even have a high school and ended after eighth grade
- we've since started primary schools those oldest kids are now in eighth grade so starting in 2018 we should see
- the benefits of starting kids even younger but that that's that's part of it so it's the academic rigor
- secondly it's there's certainly financial issues both both direct and indirect direct is the cost of higher
- education is going through the roof it's difficult to afford indirect how do you deal with that
- help our kids just apply to lots and lots of scholarships and maximize financial aid as much as possible and
- also deal with the families because the indirect challenges with with finances our parents
- are sometimes pushing their kids to stop school and come back home and take an 8
- hour job to help the family pay rent or that kid to make tuition payments is working 40 hours a week in the mall
- which means that's 40 hours a week they're not studying the library so their grades suffer so so their
- financial aid package goes down as a vicious circle that's the financial bucket there is there's horrible college
- counseling in this country if it exists at all in some schools where kids who should be staying close
- to home go far away kids who should go to a small school go to a big school kids that get into two schools
- they're not given the data this school this they're both equally hard to get into schools same financial aid package
- this school's got a 62 completion rate this school's got a 28 completion rate why won't you choose this school where
- you double your chances of finishing just by going with the flow right things like that
- fourth are just all the challenges of being a first-generation low-income kid you can't call home and you can't you
- have a lifeline to get advice on how to climb the mountain to and through college and lastly are the non-cognitive
- skills which are being pioneered and studied here at the university of pennsylvania by martin seligman and
- angela duckworth about you know people are not going to graduate from college only because they can read write
- and think critically they also need grit they need self-control they need optimism right they they need they need
- zest they need when no one's born with those things they developed them over the years and so those are all the big
- buckets we have to work on both on the k-12 side and on higher ed side because higher ed has a responsibility as well
- and it's fantastic to see the university of pennsylvania be a leader on the higher ed sided community about
- making sure that we close the achievement gap and our first generation low-income kids in this country graduate
- at the exact same rate as all of our other kids well thank you for what you said about upenn
- but especially when it comes to funding their college education does your curriculum emphasize things
- like um awareness of personal uh finance or financial literacy or entrepreneurship
- or leadership to some degree or do you think that might help again be because we're focused on getting our kids to go
- to and through college and not just pass the state test our kipp through college
- team starts in middle school with teaching kids about what it's going to take to be
- prepared and set for success in college and life and so certainly leadership and personal finance and
- entrepreneurship are all part of that we need to develop in our kids you know with my favorite shirt in the kip team
- and family is kipp new york city has a shirt that shows the pie chart of the ingredients of kit and it says 49
- academics 51 character right and so uh and those numbers we're choosing very deliberately there's a lot
- beyond traditional tested subjects so we need to give our kids to set them up for
- success and i have one last question for you where would you like kip to be on its
- 25th birthday and what can we do to help you get there uh by our 20 i would love to be able to say
- that we we are we are knocking on the door closing the achievement gap and we're not just trying to get up to 50 of
- our kids going to and through college but we've we've blown past 60 percent we're getting close to 70 percent and we
- are proving the possible and by us doing so we've inspired our friends to do as well and the and the the excuses are
- ending because the daily excuses end our days of solutions are going to start and as a
- result i would love to see that our 8 000 kid wait list in houston shrink with without us without maintaining quality
- and has shrunk because the other schools have gotten better so the kids and parents stop want to come that's what
- i'm hoping to get to by 25th would be fantastic and anything we can do to help you get
- today yeah definitely you can a few things first off penn has been a leader on on the most
- competitive higher ed side and the ivy league side of helping whether it's kipp kids and
- other kids from high performing schools local neighborhoods come here and succeed here that proves it possible
- right then and there and having more and more kids come here and be successful helps get more believers to believe in
- the potential of all of our children and that's huge secondly uh the things that the university can can
- be doing to partner with k-12 and give feedback down to us of where the holes what still are our kids not doing well
- on day one that we could fix in 12th grade 10th grade 8th grade 4th grade pre-k to get themselves more success
- and lastly it's about great teaching and more of it so having the the terrific faculty here
- at penn continues to help teachers sharpen the saw and develop the the teaching skills
- and the content skills they need to be great teachers is also a fantastic resource the university
- has been doing and i hope does more of in the future well mike good luck to you and thank you
- very much for speaking with knowledge at wharton thank you for having me here go
- quakers you
Brief Summary
Michael Feinberg discusses KIPP's growth, challenges, and commitment to underserved students' success in education.
Key points
- The Birth of KIPP. Michael Feinberg shares the story of how KIPP was created after a challenging teaching experience.
- Sacred Promises. Feinberg emphasizes the commitment KIPP makes to its students and families.
- Challenges in Scaling. Feinberg discusses the difficulties faced in scaling KIPP and the importance of great leadership.
- KIPP's Vision for Global Education. KIPP aims to train international leaders to create transformative schools in their home countries.
- Tracking Success Rates. KIPP tracks students from eighth grade to college, boasting impressive college admission rates.
- Closing the Achievement Gap. KIPP is focused on closing the achievement gap for low-income students by addressing key obstacles.
Episode highlights
- The Birth of KIPPMichael Feinberg shares the story of how KIPP was created after a challenging teaching experience.βWe looked in the mirror... and by about five o'clock in the morning, we had the knowledge's power program.β2:24Nov 12, 2013
- Sacred PromisesFeinberg emphasizes the commitment KIPP makes to its students and families.βPromises to children are sacred.β6:02Nov 12, 2013
- Challenges in ScalingFeinberg discusses the difficulties faced in scaling KIPP and the importance of great leadership.βFinding these talented terrific school leaders... is the biggest challenge.β15:11Nov 12, 2013
- KIPP's Vision for Global EducationKIPP aims to train international leaders to create transformative schools in their home countries.βThey'll go back to their country and start a great school.β18:13Nov 12, 2013
- Tracking Success RatesKIPP tracks students from eighth grade to college, boasting impressive college admission rates.β85 to 90 percent are going to college.β20:09Nov 12, 2013
- Closing the Achievement GapKIPP is focused on closing the achievement gap for low-income students by addressing key obstacles.βWhat are the main obstacles to closing that achievement gap?β20:40Nov 12, 2013
Tension
50/ 100Some tension


