Why Companies Are Making Layoffs in 2025

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In this episode of Wharton Business Daily, Wharton Professor Matthew Bidwell talks with host Dan Loney about recent job cuts. Starbucks announced plans to cut approximately 1,000 corporate jobs, aligning with a broader trend of corporate layoffs in early 2025. Government data indicates that overall layoff levels remain historically low despite recent increases. They discuss how companies use layoffs to streamline operations, particularly at the start of the year when financial reviews and restructuring occur.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#layoffs #jobcuts #jobmarket #labormarket #jobsreport ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, Starbucks recently announced that it was cutting around 1000 members of its corporate workforce, and
  2. that has been a trend so far here in the early part of 2025 with numerous other companies also focusing on corporate
  3. layoffs. But the question is, why? Pleasure to be joined right now by Matthew Bidwell, who's Professor of Management here at
  4. the Wharton School. Matthew, great to catch up again. Good to see you. You know, it's interesting, because we hear
  5. about layoffs a lot, especially in the beginning part of the year. I don't know if we necessarily hear about it in the
  6. corporate perspective. So give us your— your read on what we're seeing play out here in these first few weeks of the new year.
  7. Sure. I mean, so first off, just— I was digging through the data yesterday. So the government produces its JOLTS data on
  8. layoffs just to see kind of what's the trend. Historically, they're very low. And so we are seeing this news on layoffs
  9. coming through. They— they've moved up a little bit over the last year. But if you look at kind of— the kind of last 20
  10. years or so, we're still in the world of pretty low layoffs. But they are constant. I think for quite a while they've been a
  11. regular tool that corporations use. They— it's kind of a, you know— somebody who's not very good at dieting. Kind of that
  12. sense of, they kind of— they go on a crash diet, or "We've got to trim all the excess and kind of really get ourselves back on
  13. track." And then they start hiring again. And after a while, they kind of go, "Oh, no, no. This has all gone wrong." So we
  14. seem to go through these cycles. So maybe, yeah, maybe this is like dry January for corporations or something like that, where they
  15. kind of say— and it is— I mean, there is a— there's definitely a tendency, I think, in all organizations, to— for
  16. administrative bloat. No matter how much we want to avoid it, there's always more work to do and— so you hire more managers.
  17. There's more things that they kind of see need to be done, and so on. So you can see why every now and then, organizations do
  18. kind of want to pause and say, "Okay, we added a whole lot of activities. Which of these do we still really need? And are there
  19. kind of places where we think maybe we— we've invested a lot of things that we no longer need?" So, it happens.
  20. Is there more focus, then, this time around? Because it seems like it is geared towards corporate layoffs. And obviously you will
  21. see a lot of layoffs in— in various elements of business. I saw one CEO called this an unprecedented kind of move. Is
  22. it unprecedented? Or maybe not so much? I don't— I don't see it as unprecedented. I mean, I think
  23. it's been kind of a common mantra over the last 10, 20 years, "We're taking out middle management. We're taking out
  24. administrative bloat." If you're not doing corporate layoffs, you're doing layoffs of frontline workers, and then
  25. you've got to start explaining, why are we cutting stores? I mean, in some ways, certainly, if I'm an investor, that worries
  26. me, right? You come in, you say we're laying off the front line. Okay. So that means less revenue is coming in. That's bad. You
  27. say we're laying off corporate. You know, we have the sense of, "Oh, it's overhead, it's bloat." I don't think all corporate is
  28. overhead and bloat. There's a real risk, when you lay that off, that you do a lot of damage. But I think it— it's certainly a
  29. more comforting message, I think, for external stakeholders. "We're not— we're not damaging kind of the core business or cutting
  30. into the core business. It's other things." Is there a component of this also that, with all the dynamics
  31. of the workplace and— and remote work and some of these other dynamics— that we're seeing kind of a repositioning, maybe, to a
  32. degree, going back to what we saw before the pandemic, of what companies expect in terms of the employees being in the office,
  33. of the performance component as well maybe even being focused on a little bit more also?
  34. I mean, I certainly wouldn't be surprised if during these layoffs, kind of where people are starts to play a role. I
  35. mean, again, if you actually look at the statistics rather than the news stories, you get a very different picture of remote
  36. work and return to office. So, kind of data from badge swipe systems suggest that office occupancy still hasn't risen
  37. much above 50%, and it's been hovering around that level for the last two years. There's a survey by Nick Bloom and colleagues
  38. at Stanford that asked people where they worked last week. That seems to show kind of the proportion of total days being
  39. worked in the office. Again, it's been bopping around between about 26 and 30% for the last two years. So yes, I think it—
  40. it's in people's minds. The labor market has softened. We went through a period in '21-'22 where you just couldn't hire
  41. anybody, where there was so much competition, and where CEOs felt they had no choice but to give their workforce whatever they
  42. wanted. Now, when you look at kind of numbers of job openings, they're back down to pre- pandemic levels. And so I think
  43. those CEOs that never really liked this idea, they are seeing kind of, "Okay. Now's my chance to actually— actually bring people
  44. back into the office." So I think it may play into some of these calculations. I'm not sure it should, but it may.
  45. Talk also about the timing component of doing this in January. Because for many corporations, their calendar
  46. year or their fiscal year will end December 31. Are— are companies conscious of, you know, making these types of
  47. moves, especially at the end of the year and around the holidays as well? It's a good question. I don't know. Yeah, I
  48. could imagine doing it just before Christmas probably doesn't lead to fantastic headlines. I mean, a lot of companies, also, they
  49. make a lot of their money in the holiday period. I don't know what that looks like for Starbucks, for example, but you
  50. know, if you're anywhere close to retail, consumer, you don't want to mess with anything during the— the end of the year.
  51. You kind of want to make sure you're— you're at your peak. This is going to be a quieter time of year. And so if I'm going to do—
  52. if I'm going to do big reorganizations, big layoffs, I probably want to be doing it around now, when generally
  53. there's kind of less— less pressure to deliver revenue instantly. - Is the expectation that— and you mentioned that this is somewhat
  54. of a pattern— that this is a pattern that— that continues? That corporations, you know, believe that this is the way to
  55. handle these types of situations at this time of the year? Yeah. I mean, I certainly think we've always seen layoffs. We
  56. will continue to see layoffs. There's good and bad, right? I mean, every layoff is destructive to the people
  57. involved. And I will say kind of the research on the effects of layoffs is deeply depressing, right? In that I think it often—
  58. there's kind of really long-term effects on— negative effects— on people's earnings. But, you know, we have a dynamic economy,
  59. or the creative destruction and so on. Corporations will build up certain areas, and over time, they will decide that those
  60. investments are not paying off and they want to cut back. And so that happens. I'm not sure corporations are always as
  61. thoughtful about this as they should be. I've been very depressed over the last few years. Kind of— you saw, post-
  62. pandemic, particularly with some of the tech and consulting firms. They kind of hired everybody in sight, and then
  63. turned around within about six months and went, "Whoa, we've got too big. Let's lay everybody off again." I kind of think a little
  64. more forethought would would be helpful here. It is the case— I mean, corporations used to kind of— pre-1980s, corporations
  65. avoided layoffs at all costs. They have become a bit more common, particularly among the white collar workforce. I still
  66. think you— they're not something you want to do lightly. But on the other hand, the world changes. What businesses need
  67. changes, so we're going to continue to see these. Matthew, great to talk to you again today. Thanks very much.
  68. Good to see you. Thank you. Matthew Bidwell, Professor of Management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Starbucks cuts 1,000 jobs as corporate layoffs trend continues, reflecting changing workforce dynamics and economic pressures.

Key points

  • Starbucks Layoffs. Starbucks announces cutting around 1000 corporate jobs, reflecting a trend in early 2025.
  • The Layoff Cycle. Matthew Bidwell discusses the cyclical nature of corporate layoffs and their impact.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes