How AI and Rising Costs Are Reshaping Family Roles

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Rising costs, shifting labor markets, and AI are changing how families operate, and who carries the burden. Corinne Low, Wharton Associate Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy, explains how economic pressure and persistent gender inequality are impacting working mothers and reshaping household roles.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#ai #economics #workingmothers #futureofwork #publicpolicy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Certainly, we know that the economy is going through a bit of a rough patch with persistent
  2. inflation, higher gas and food prices, and a bit of a softer labor market. So how are those elements
  3. impacting families and maybe more importantly, working mothers? Corinne Lowe is an associate
  4. professor of business economics and public policy here at the Wharton School. Corinne,
  5. great to catch up again. Great to see you, Dan. So yeah, you said it all. I mean, American families
  6. are feeling what I call the squeeze, which is about not just money, but also time, because
  7. what they're finding is, you know, costs are rising. They feel like they need to put more
  8. time into their careers. The demands that we place on parents have increased. The time we spent
  9. parenting has doubled across the span of a generation. And at the same time, childcare costs are rising. So a lot of families are saying, you know, we can't afford not to have
  10. somebody in the labor market. But at the same time, it's hard for us to afford the childcare
  11. for somebody to go and work. So, you know, they're in kind of a catch-22. And really, for women who are working mothers, you and I have talked over the last few years
  12. about the financial gap between what men are paid and women are paid. If you're a single
  13. working mother, and you have all of these dynamics going on, and you throw in inflation and all these
  14. other components, it has to be one of the most challenging times that they have had, and maybe
  15. even more so than what we went through with the pandemic. Yeah, that's right, because when you
  16. think about what it costs to work, obviously you work to earn money, but what does it cost to work?
  17. Well, that's gas in the car, and gas prices right now are astonishing, right? And that's
  18. childcare. And childcare, you talked about inflation, the cost of childcare has actually
  19. outpaced the cost of inflation. So childcare has actually increased more rapidly than the already
  20. punishing rate of inflation. And so, you know, absolutely, that is putting the squeeze on working
  21. mothers. And then when you get to the fact that women are paid less than men, if you are a, you
  22. know, single working mom, you're supporting a family on that salary, you know, it's very, very
  23. difficult. And that's why I actually think it's so important. You remember the New York Times
  24. article a while back that was like, are women ruining the workplace? And that's why I think
  25. it's so important that we reframe because so much of the discourse has treated women's work as
  26. though it's some kind of kind of like optional hobby. Like, you know, women are doing it for
  27. feminism. They're doing it because, you know, they want to for their own self-fulfillment. But
  28. millions of women are supporting American families. They're not working for fun. They're
  29. working to put food on the table. They're working to keep the lights on. And that's what gets lost
  30. when we talk about this dynamic as though it's optional. It's not optional. It's something that
  31. is so essential that we make possible and that we figure out how to bring those costs down
  32. so that families can continue to thrive. Well, and then there are also the components,
  33. not only what they are dealing with in their jobs, in their careers, but what they're dealing
  34. with at home as well, because a lot of the data says that working mothers are still contributing
  35. a lot, maybe even more so than their husbands if they're married or their partners, in the home
  36. setting in terms of, you know, keeping everything kind of running, setting the doctor's appointments,
  37. the banking dynamics, you know. So you add that on top of it and it's even more challenging.
  38. That's exactly right. So thanks for saying it for me so I didn't have to. You know, that's my paper,
  39. winning the bread and baking it too, that even women who are breadwinners, women who are the
  40. ones who are bringing home a significant paycheck and maybe even the sole earner in a household,
  41. they still do more. If they are married to a man, they still do more at home. They still do twice
  42. as much cooking and cleaning as their lower earning male partners. And that's one of the
  43. notes I want to make as we look at broader economic trends and economic change. And AI
  44. is really shaking up the labor market and it is shaking up our idea of who is going to be a high
  45. earner, because you might have a couple where he is a computer programmer, she's a nurse, maybe he
  46. out-earned her, right? But if those jobs go away, that earning dynamic might shift because healthcare,
  47. very AI-proof industry, because it's about care, it's about being at the bedside. And so she's
  48. still going to be bringing home that paycheck. And the question is, is he ready to evolve into
  49. a new role of actually doing more at home? Is it too early to truly understand what kind of
  50. impact that AI is having or will have in the future on the careers of working mothers?
  51. I do think it's too early to understand, because I think, personally, I think what we're going to
  52. see is that even though some women's jobs are going to be displaced by AI, I actually think
  53. that a lot of the sectors that women work in, as I said, such as teaching, such as healthcare,
  54. of course, those aren't all the jobs that women do. Women are professors like me, women are lawyers,
  55. women are all sorts of things. But some of the sectors that women work in are more AI-proof
  56. than some of the sectors that men work in. And as a result, as I said, I think what's really
  57. interesting is thinking about, are we prepared to rescale men, to reconsider gender roles in light
  58. of potentially women's earning power within the household getting stronger over the next few
  59. decades with the rise of AI? How has the work-from-home component played into the equation
  60. now? I mean, you and I talked about this during the pandemic and how it could potentially have
  61. an impact on women's careers. You've also written about the motherhood penalty. But how is that
  62. dynamic of work-from-home kind of evolving, do you think? Well, we have seen a lot of companies are trying to drive return to office, right? And the reason
  63. is because so much research shows that there's things that happen when we are together,
  64. in terms of idea sharing, in terms of innovation, that just don't happen the same way at home. And
  65. so a lot of companies are also considering hybrid models. And that's why, you know, I have
  66. been encouraging firms to think, you know, if I want return to office, if I want the benefits of
  67. being together and synchronous, does that need to be, you know, 8 a.m. till 9 p.m.? Or can I get
  68. those benefits, you know, from 10 to 4, of kind of core hours where we try to be in office, but then
  69. let people, you know, take care of other things and let people kind of be more flexible for that
  70. second part of their workload? And so I think that's some of the things companies might want
  71. to consider. But when we think about work from home, you know, what's interesting is, I think,
  72. because when you're in the office, you're connecting with other humans. And that's the
  73. piece that AI can't replace. I do think people should be thinking, if I am in a work-from-home
  74. job, I should be more worried that I'm more replaceable. The less human contact that I have,
  75. right, the more that I actually need to be concerned about the long-term trajectory of
  76. this job category. So I think we should be looking for ways to create more human connection, but we
  77. also shouldn't be sacrificing the very real need to do care labor and to do other types of
  78. production, like home production, in our lives. And so that's about setting those boundaries on
  79. those in-office times and not expecting it to kind of bleed into all hours. So you mentioned
  80. a moment ago about men maybe adjusting how they are thinking about work and the workforce.
  81. But larger scale, since we've had the pandemic and now we have this period of time,
  82. it made me wonder if families in general are thinking about and looking at ways where they
  83. potentially are tweaking their lifestyles longer term. Because I think a lot of us believe that
  84. while we're in this period of time now, there's probably another crisis that's going to come
  85. around the corner, maybe a year, two years, three years, whatever it is down the line.
  86. And so I'm wondering if we're almost going through a little bit or getting ready for
  87. more transition in our lives. Yes, I do think that we are looking at a period of economic
  88. turmoil ahead. And I think, again, from a gender perspective, since that's what I study,
  89. to be ready for that, you have to be ready to have either partner earn more, to have either
  90. partner be the one who's stepping up their hours in the labor force. And I think what makes us
  91. ready for that is being flexible in those gender roles. Is it being OK for dad to be the one to do
  92. pickups if suddenly mom's career is more promising? Is it being OK for dad to be the one who's doing
  93. the grocery shopping and the cooking? But the other thing is just from a personal finance
  94. perspective that American families should be thinking about right now, making sure that they
  95. have those emergency funds, making sure that they have those plans in case they do get laid off.
  96. And just thinking through that scenario, because you want to think through it before
  97. it gets to you. So thinking, what would I do if I got laid off from my job? What places would I
  98. apply? Are my contacts active? Have I reached out recently and had some coffee chats with people
  99. in my industry or in adjacent industries I'm interested in? So I think we can all afford to
  100. do a little bit of saving, not just of money for a rainy day, but saving up in terms of our
  101. contacts, our human capital, our relationship capital so that we are prepared for a period
  102. of turmoil. How are companies reacting to all this? Because you and I, I remember talking a while back
  103. about, you know, companies adapting to a degree to the work from home and people having to deal
  104. with all the other dynamics in their life. As long as they were able to get their work done,
  105. they may be working more of a fractured workday, but they're still putting in their eight hours.
  106. Maybe it's over the course of 12 hours. So are companies more receptive now than even before
  107. the pandemic about the dynamics of everything that's going on in people's lives right now?
  108. Well, I think we see two opposing forces, right? One is that the pandemic did teach us that we
  109. can do a certain portion of our work asynchronously. So in the data, we do see a lot
  110. more work from home. We see a lot more hybrid models. People who even have in-office jobs
  111. are not going to the office five days a week. They might be going more like four days a week. So
  112. we just learned that some of this can happen over Zoom, but we also learned that there's some stuff
  113. that is not replaceable and we don't want everybody working from home. And that's why a lot
  114. of companies have been doing return to office, right? But the opposing force, along with the
  115. firms learning and potentially becoming more innovative in their structures, the opposing
  116. force is the soft labor market. And when you have a soft labor market, firms have more bargaining
  117. power. And so we just saw Zoom and Deloitte cut maternity leave. And this is the first time we've
  118. heard of a big cut like this. What we've been hearing is firms adding benefits, firms saying
  119. that they are increasing their benefit package. Now Zoom and Deloitte, two major companies,
  120. come out and say, you know what, we're scaling it back. We're cutting back the number of months
  121. we offer for maternity leave. We are cutting back on who is covered. Certain categories of
  122. employees are going to have fewer months than others. And I think the reason that they can do
  123. that is because of the soft labor market. And so those two forces are going to be fighting each
  124. other, where on one hand, companies were making progress, but now they sense an opportunity that
  125. says, wait a minute, you know, jobs are in demand. We can afford to spend a little bit less to recruit
  126. and retain our employees. Corinne, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much.
  127. Thank you, Dan. Always a pleasure. Thank you. Corinne Lowe, Associate Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy
  128. here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Corinne Lowe discusses inflation's impact on working mothers and the evolving dynamics of family roles in the workforce.

Key points

  • The Squeeze on Families. Families are facing rising costs and demands, leading to a challenging economic squeeze.
  • The Cost of Working. The cost of childcare is outpacing inflation, complicating the decision for working mothers.
  • Gender Roles in Transition. The rise of AI may shift traditional gender roles in the household.
  • Maternity Leave Cuts. Zoom and Deloitte have made significant cuts to maternity leave, impacting working mothers.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes