China's Land Price Slump

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The new indices of housing land prices in China show that the market has regressed to where it was five years ago, Wharton's Joseph Gyourko says. More: http://knlg.net/1yye43v 📂 Finance & Accounting;Real Estate 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Our Guest today is uh Professor Joseph jerko from the Wharton real estate department and we're going to talk with
  2. him about the latest changes in Chinese land prices Joe thank you so much for joining us today thanks for having me it
  3. was a while ago that we had done the the first piece about the the China China land index that you have developed with
  4. some of your colleagues uh can you tell us the latest update from the Warton chingua and US Chinese res residential
  5. land price index I I sure can and the latest data are from the third quarter of 2014 so they're hot off the presses and
  6. there are two interesting things about the data number one is we saw a 6.5% decline in real land prices across
  7. the 35 cities in our index so that's the first significant decline in some time it takes the price index level back
  8. about five quarters ago I think the second thing that I think is potentially more interesting and maybe forboding for
  9. what might happen in China is the decline in the quantity of land sales from local governments in the 35 markets
  10. we track to private developers who want to build residential complexes that number is down
  11. 44% that takes us back to levels of transactions volume we saw 5 years ago not five quarters ago so the very large
  12. decline in transactions volume more much more modest but a real decline in prices
  13. what factors do you think are driving these changes in China's land prices I think a couple uh number one is growth
  14. is slowing China's not in a recession they're I don't believe they're going to go negative but remember they've dropped
  15. from 10% annual price growth to 7 a half now with many people wondering are they
  16. going to go even lower well think about how many housing units you need if you're can to have 10% growth in your
  17. economy versus 7.5 in the United States we would love to have 7.5% growth but it's 25% below the 10 they were having
  18. so I think what's happening is developers were building and buying land for 10% growth they got seven and a half
  19. and you no longer need as much I think that's by far the most important factor I think another Factor that's out there
  20. and we'll know more about this is the of the year when we report our city level indexes is that different cities look to
  21. be doing very differently so inside China there's an awareness that ship building and steel have excess capacity
  22. so markets with a lot of ship building and steel production activity I suspect are going to decline more than others so
  23. I think there are two factors going on uh what do you expect going forward let's say in the next uh few
  24. quarters I wish I knew so I that's why we're doing the index so I'll know what I suspect is we're going to see
  25. variation at the city level um that's number one I think we'll find that some cities are doing just fine and other
  26. markets are not doing so fine and we have 35 in our index so we should be able to see a lot of variation across
  27. markets and across the countries we don't just track Beijing and Shanghai and guango on the coasts of the of the
  28. country um the second thing I think look for our changes in policy it's clear in
  29. our data if you look at our index that Chinese government policy can move the housing market so there was a similar
  30. decline in transactions volume in 2008 in the financial crisis and it was rapidly turned around by Chinese
  31. government stimulus policy we see a very large decline in transactions volume recently the question and I think what
  32. we ought to look for is are we going to see a change in policy I don't know um but it's happened in the
  33. past I kind of doubt it but I don't know but that's I think we need to look at what the Chinese government's going to
  34. do going forward great and just one last question based on what the data show what do you think uh are some of the
  35. implications for uh investors and real estate developers well I think real estate developers clearly inside China
  36. are becoming more cautious that's why you're seeing the drop in transactions volume in the US and in most other
  37. countries I've studied drops in transactions volume precede or lead drops in prices so I suspect they're
  38. looking at those same studies and going we're worried about price drops and they're worried about shorting up their
  39. Capital structures to make sure they're safe if there is a further downturn I think that's what people are are trying
  40. to figure out um is the quantity drop a predictor of price drops and it has been
  41. in other countries Joe thanks so much for speaking with knowledge at whorton my pleasure
  42. [Music]

Brief Summary

Professor Joseph Jerko discusses the decline in Chinese land prices and its implications for investors and developers.

Key points

  • Decline in Chinese Land Prices. A significant 6.5% decline in real land prices across 35 cities is noted.
  • Cautious Developers. Developers are worried about price drops, leading to a decline in transactions volume.

Related episodes