What US Colleges Must Do To Survive

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

๐Ÿ“‚ Innovation

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Our Guest today is uh Pat Harker president of the University of Delaware and we're going to speak to him about
  2. the challenges facing uh higher education Pat thank you so much for joining us today at knowledge at Wharton
  3. well M it's great to be here so uh you've written this really thought-provoking paper and I wonder if
  4. we could start by looking at the costs of higher education and and why they seem to be soaring uh as University
  5. education a good investment today yes it's still a good investment but a lot of people are now questioning it right
  6. after the recession that we've gone through and people are coming out with $100,000 in debt they may not have the
  7. job a job at all or it's they're underemployed and so there's a lot of questioning the the evidence still says
  8. it's it's worth it but you can understand why people are questioning this today so what are some of the aren
  9. factors that are driving costs up and the uh uh and what have universities done to try and curb them well there's a
  10. lot of factors but if you look at the main factor it's low labor productivity as defined by an economist I have to be
  11. careful when I say this to a faculty member they say hey I'm productive what do you mean so I have to say is defined
  12. by an economist and this goes back to will Bal Mall's idea he published in 1967 Bal Mall's cost disease economies
  13. have sectors that have low labor productivity High labor productivity on average in inflation is a mix of those
  14. but the ones who have low labor productivity will always have inflation higher than the average right so so when
  15. we talk about productivity in in most Industries uh Information Technology often factors into the picture uh do you
  16. have a sense of what the impact of uh Innovation uh information technology has been on education sure but let me step
  17. back and not talk about education but think about Healthcare so we in higher education are not like healthcare and
  18. that we've consumed a lot of technology to improve quality but not really with an eye to reducing cost until recently
  19. right I mean once uh infl the healthcare reaches 25% of GDP people are start to say whoa let's let's think about this
  20. and we need to reduce costs we've done the same thing in higher education we put in new projectors new technology but
  21. we've really not fundamentally changed the way we educate and that I think is the key that technology alone is not
  22. going to solve the productivity problem technology enables new processes and those new processes will then deliver
  23. lower cost higher quality what might be some examples of that of lower cost higher quality I think what we're
  24. starting to see emerge are things like mukes so mukes can play a part of the role there we're starting to see a lot
  25. more problem-based learning Interactive Learning where students are learning by doing not by by being lectured to the
  26. old days and you think about forget Information Technology the way we tried to improve productivity in the past was
  27. to build 300 person lecture Halls right that does improve labor productivity whether it improves learning is really
  28. the question I raised in the paper that we've developed very efficient teaching machines and that's that's okay if
  29. teaching equals learning but it doesn't and it increasingly doesn't in this generation that is technology enabled
  30. and that's what we need to try to break and there are examples lots of examples of people experimenting with new
  31. learning modalities not necessarily new teaching modalities and I think there is
  32. a difference and it's a fundamental difference right uh and and then come back in a minute to uh you know the
  33. difference between teaching and learning but I'd go back like to go back to your
  34. paper for a minute uh where where you write there is both hope and fear that it Innovations will end the university
  35. as we know it and why why is that sure so so clay Christensen with disruptive innovation has been talking a lot about
  36. this in the case of higher education that the incumbent institutions us uh we think everything's fine and for those
  37. who are heavily owed it probably is for a while but for those who are not there are a lot of forces that are changing
  38. the market first the demographic decline in the United States so the college age
  39. cohort that we traditionally service is in Decline we're also seeing more first generation lower income students coming
  40. into high education so we can't charge what we used to charge and we also are now seeing in addition to all those
  41. forces we're starting to see the world wake up to higher education building new campuses in China building new campuses
  42. in India and so the flow to the US is starting to change as well so all that's gotten universities to start to think
  43. about well GE how do we become more productive right and and and one of the things you suggest in the paper is to
  44. shift the emphasis from teaching uh to learning right and and I wonder if we can talk about how the design of of the
  45. educational institutions can be changed so that the emphasis is more on the learner than on the teacher so let me
  46. give you a very specific example we opened up a new science building last summer and it's all based all the
  47. classrooms are based around the concept of problem-based learning the classrooms
  48. are 48 seat classrooms with two 24 seat Labs on either side students walk in for
  49. 2hour sessions they're learning some mix of biology and chemistry they don't know
  50. if it's biology they don't know if it's chemistry what they know is their problems are trying to solve that are
  51. related to biology and chemistry they work out the hypothesis immediately get out of their seats go into the
  52. laboratory and start to test solutions to the problems that were presented in the class and then come back very
  53. interactive very different than say the chemistry you and I took in college where we took a 300 person lecture and
  54. then later in the week we took a lab and the lab sometimes made no sense with respect to the lecture and we were
  55. supposed to figure it out problem-based learning changes all that that was an efficient way to teach right have the
  56. 300 person lecture and the laboratory separate this is really learner Centric really saying what's the most efficient
  57. way for students to learn that science and make it sticky right that not only do they learn it but they're not
  58. cramming it it stays with them because they discovered it themselves right and and and so do you think universities
  59. will be able to use these kinds of techniques so that they're no longer teaching factories as you call them yes
  60. I think what the only way to do that though is to take the material that is commod can be commodified right in other
  61. words it can be packaged up simple stuff basic calculus basic concepts and use other tools whether it's a moo or
  62. frankly you can go to Old School Technology a traditional textbook and do Competency Based testing on those things
  63. things students learning on their own and using class time in a much more active manner than we do today right so
  64. as we think about uh these changes that are required in education are there any lessons to be learned from other service
  65. Industries oh sure sure I mean one is there's always the great hope that technolog is going to save us all right
  66. it's not true again go go back to robotic surgery lots of evidence has come out in the last uh few years that
  67. in except for very few cases the robotic surgery for many different disease types
  68. is no more efficient than the traditional laparoscopic surgery with a surgeon's hands but try to be a hospital
  69. today without the robot so sometimes we just consume technology with no real benefit so we need to learn that we also
  70. need to learn that again it comes back to changing processes the way we do things I mean it's standard when new
  71. technology comes in that we try to lay technology on Old processes think of banking me used to be great fights in
  72. the banking industry which I studied extensively when I was here at Wharton that the the ATMs and the internet
  73. banking was going to destroy the bank because everything was about the branch and everybody's Focus was well it'll
  74. destroy the branch we can't let that happen well think about the analog in higher education all these new
  75. technologies are going to destroy the traditional classroom no it's just going to change what you do in that classroom
  76. just like internet banking and ATMs changed what you did in the in the branch one of the concepts that you
  77. explain in your paper is the customer efficiency right uh I wonder if we could explain what exactly that is and how it
  78. will change education sure so if you think about Services unlike manufacturing when you bought your
  79. Toyota or your Honda you didn't screw the bolts on the car right you bought the car you drive it the difference with
  80. a service any kind of service professional service healthare education is that the consumer is part of the
  81. production process right they're in there making it with you right if the consumer doesn't take their health
  82. seriously there's nothing a doctor can do if a student doesn't take their education seriously there's really
  83. nothing a professor can do so it's really focused on not making the system efficient from our perspective the
  84. provider but making the system efficient from the customer or students perspective so that they can be very
  85. effective in providing their own education because ultimately they have to educate themselves we just don't pour
  86. knowledge into their heads if if technology is just a tool why have so many educational institutions almost
  87. made it the Beall and end all of innovation and education yeah but again if you you think outside of Education
  88. lots of Industries have gone through this transformation right where technolog is going to revolutionize
  89. everything they realize it flopped then they get around to really rethinking the processes we got a lot of
  90. Legacy Concepts running around in our head about what works and what doesn't and so I don't think we're any different
  91. than any other industry particularly any other service industry we're in the process of this transformation some of
  92. that transformation frankly is being fueled by forces outside of higher education another Major Force or outside
  93. of traditional higher education is the fact that the Venture Capital flow into the higher education space is increasing
  94. in rapidly because they see an opportunity here remember it's not just the us around the world the middle class
  95. is emerging the first thing the middle class around the world wants is educate their children and the traditional
  96. campuses we can't build them fast enough or big enough to to educate in the traditional way and they see that
  97. opportunity and we as the traditional higher education institutions also need to think about that opportunity because
  98. part of our mission is to serve that global glal market so what role does the design of the curriculum play in this
  99. transformation and and and uh to to go one step further traditionally it's educational institutions that have
  100. defined what the curriculum should be in a learner Centric environment what role
  101. should the learner play in designing the curriculum that's a very good question so start with my my old colleague Bob
  102. zamsky who here at The Graduate School of Education at Penn now in his recent book checklist for change he says it's
  103. all about the curriculum it is so you think about the curriculum it's really the design it's really it really
  104. constrains what you can do so imagine the following scenario you're working at say o apple and your boss comes in and
  105. you're part of a product development team and they say we need the next big thing well what's the price point for it
  106. we don't know that would never happen they'd have to know at least what kind of costs
  107. we're talking about for the product that that they want to deliver think about how the curricula are developed in
  108. universities faculty committees come up with ideas they toss them over to the administration and they say make it so
  109. and without any concept of what that's going to cost that's all that also has to
  110. change what do you mean by ideation uh large frame pattern recognition and complex communication
  111. yeah so in a recent book from colleagues at MIT the second Machine age they talk
  112. about the fact that the machines keep coming right and Lites um notwithstanding we're not going to stop
  113. it anytime soon so they asked the question what do human beings do today and in the foreseeable future better
  114. than Computing technology and they come up with three things ideation truly new creative
  115. thinking not just combining ideas which a machine can do take a little of this a
  116. little of that come up with a new but truly new ideas if you were out of the box ideas right the second is large
  117. frame or large scale pattern recognition so machines can do a lot of pattern recognition but putting together
  118. technical social political economic cultural factors and to try to come up with a solution to an issue that's hard
  119. that's what we we human beings do and the third is complex communication machines are getting better and better
  120. communicating but still I'd still put for high-end sales a human being in front of another human being to sell
  121. because they read the nuances the non-verbal Communications it's those things that are very important for
  122. students to learn and you have to ask yourself then what percentage of our curricula are devoted to those probably
  123. not much and we then have to think about that in redesigning the curriculum for the
  124. future well there there's uh one other part of your paper that I found really fascinating which is uh uh deals with
  125. whether education institutions should encourage students to dream uh how and uh why and how uh should that
  126. happen so if faculty time is being used in a teaching Factory I'll call it where
  127. we're just crunching classes through and no times being used to help students faculty mentoring helping guiding
  128. students then The Faculty really can't help that student dream because they're so focused on the production engine of
  129. just teaching the classes and this changes people's lives I would not be doing what I do today if it wasn't for a
  130. faculty member John leapor who passed away recently in civil engineering at this University who took me under his
  131. wing in my junior year and gave me a chance to do research I never even knew that was a an
  132. opportunity that was available to me he opened up my world he helped me to dream
  133. in a very different way that's what I I talk about in this paper is freeing up the time to do the basic get the basics
  134. can be done in other ways enabled by technology and really changing the model so that faculty are spending more of
  135. their time on that kind of coaching the mentoring the dreaming with the students
  136. right know uh as as this education space goes through all these changes you referred earlier to the you know entry
  137. of uh more and more Venture Capital into this place uh there are some very interesting startups that are trying to
  138. deal with the same issues that uh you know the big established institutions are trying to Grapple with and one of
  139. them is minurva right I wonder if you could tell us a little bit more about minurva what its model is what its
  140. successes and failures might have been so far and what lessons that might have for other schools to learn from so
  141. manura is a startup it's started by a fellow Ben Nelson who's A Wharton undergrad Alum uh I full disclosure I'm
  142. on his Advisory Board along with several others including uh Larry Summers and Lee Schulman and Bob kery the former
  143. Senator but it's really Ben that's been driving this and he has Steve klin the former dean of social sciences at
  144. Harvard who's now joined him and Steve being a cognitive scientist has really developed a learning platform based on
  145. the what we know about cognition about learning we don't learn by sitting in a classroom half asleep we learn by active
  146. engagement Active Learning so the whole model is based around that there are physical campuses where students will
  147. live but their classroom will be their laptop with 18 other students where they can't take a break for 45 minutes
  148. they're engaged for 45 minutes in a very deep way so they're bringing in their pilot class to San Francisco this year
  149. to shake out the the software uh they have four classes they're teaching manura has part Competency Based so they
  150. have students will need to graduate with competency in two languages other than and their native tongue University won't
  151. teach that they're Rosetta Stone there are other tools out there to do that they're going to spend their time on
  152. those issues we talked about earlier ideation large frame pattern recognition and communication four classes formal
  153. reasoning empirical reasoning uh complex system so how all those factors intersect and multimodal
  154. communication critical reading critical writing notice it's a heavy dose of the liberal arts but not packaged in the way
  155. we typically do the liberal arts but it's helping students to really think critically what impact do you think
  156. these kinds of models will have on the will they truly succeed in disrupting the existing educational establishment
  157. they could um you know not only disrupt maybe not the traditional educational establishment as much
  158. as take up the growth that's going to be happening around the world right because
  159. if this model is more successful we can't build a lot of pen depends it's very expensive to build a university
  160. like this the manura model is scalable and scalable to serve that growing need around the
  161. world uh should universities consider Outsourcing services to one another and what
  162. implications might that have yeah that's a good question so we've been Outsourcing for a long time right
  163. textbook manufacturers still package up PowerPoint slides with their textbook they give instructors manuals with
  164. problems they a lot of Faculty around the world that just take the PowerPoint slides and the instructor's manuals and
  165. deliver the course auk is just a modern version of that but there's various forms of
  166. Outsourcing so you could do that or you could actually Outsource to a third party like for example manerva is doing
  167. to teach language the basics of language to a Rosetta Stone or like companies there's another form of Outsourcing
  168. though that I really worry about one of our missions particular as research universities is not only to generate
  169. knowledge but to sustain it to protect it to pass it on to Future Generations well some fields are
  170. cyclical right when I was a student here at this University in the 80s lot in 70s
  171. a lot of interest in Russian right not so much in the 90s and 2000s now it's actually coming back and so we need to
  172. maintain that capability but it's hard to do if you're a university administrator and you've got three to
  173. four students in a class studying Russian but why don't you use technology in a simple way to create virtual
  174. classrooms and consortia of universities so gather say in this case all the other
  175. ivys to teach low R so instead of having three four people we have three times eight in the classroom and now we can
  176. afford to keep that alive I think that form of Outsourcing has not really been done much there are places where it's
  177. been done and it's been done very successfully so clearly as as we've discussed there's a a huge amount of
  178. change that is required in higher education who do you think are going to be the primary change agents who will
  179. drive this change well the faculty have to believe in the change but don't they have the most to
  180. lose that's a good question they might or they also have the most to gain right it depends on right it depends on how
  181. you look at it so I know for example several faculty who have gotten deeply immersed in muks the massive open online
  182. courses and I asked one of them once uh who was visiting our campus I said why are you doing he's a friend of mine they
  183. said this is the future and I want to get ready for the future so not all faculty are going to do it but that like
  184. anything they're going to be early adopters ones who see what the future looks like and they want to be part of
  185. it you don't need a lot you just need a few to create the Skunk Works experimental lab to to prove the
  186. concept and I have one final question if you look five or 10 years out what changes do you see on the horizon uh for
  187. higher education uh what kind of action plans do you see universities having to put in place and
  188. if you're optimistic or pessimistic uh what are the reasons for that I'll start with the optimism and
  189. pessimism on both it depends on where you stand so I mean if you are a small College uh that or a state university
  190. non-research State University we're already seeing Moody S&P is downgrading the debt of these institutions saying
  191. you're not going to survive so there's concern if I was sitting there I'd be very concerned uh that either I can can
  192. I change quickly enough to make it uh I think for universities that are currently strong and robust uh like like
  193. any industry the win or take all Society does tend to exist so for those if they
  194. do the right things if they seiz the opportunities that are in front of them if they seiz the opportunities to change
  195. which is a very hard thing to to do right we as human beings don't like change fundamentally uh then they will
  196. do very well otherwise they may join the others in Decline and that's what I worry about because in the end of the
  197. day the higher education system in this country is the gem or one of the gems of
  198. the United States of America and higher education is critical to Economic Development and growth all around the
  199. world we've got to get this right thanks so much Pat really appreciate you speaking to knowledge
  200. word thanks M [Music] cool

Brief Summary

Pat Harker discusses rising costs, innovative teaching, and the future of higher education.

Key points

  • The Rising Costs of Education. Pat Harker discusses why higher education costs are soaring and the skepticism surrounding its value.
  • Innovations in Learning. Harker explores how technology can change education but emphasizes the need for new teaching methods.
  • The Role of Mentorship. Harker shares a personal story about how a mentor changed his life and perspective on education.
  • The Future of Education. A faculty member believes in preparing for the future of education through technology.
  • Concerns for Small Colleges. Moody's downgrades indicate that small colleges may not survive without change.
  • The Importance of Change. Universities must seize opportunities or risk decline in a competitive landscape.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes