Medicare Advantage Plans: Who Benefits When the Government Pays More?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
KNOWLEDGE AT WHARTON ARCHIVES: When the U.S. government pays more for medical services — as it does for Medicare Advantage — does the quality of those services improve? Not much, says Mark Duggan, a Wharton business economics and public policy professor. That was a key finding that he and co-authors Amanda Starc, a Wharton health care management professor, and Wharton Ph.D. student Boris V. Vabson came to in their recent research paper, “Who Benefits When the Government Pays More? Pass-through in the Medicare Advantage Program.”
In this interview, Duggan explains the study’s findings and some of the policy implications. He notes the increase in competition generated by higher Medicare Advantage payments “doesn’t seem to translate into better benefits for consumers.” The study could have implications for Medicaid, managed care and other government health care spending, Duggan says. It shows there may be many opportunities to cut programs, with minimal adverse impact on consumers, and then use the money saved where it may provide more efficient benefits.
More on this interview: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/medicare-advantage-offer-much-advantage/
#medicare #medicareadvantage #healthcare 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- in my research I examined the effect of the generosity of government payments to
- health insurers for a program known as Medicare Advantage uh the paper is actually jointly authored with a Wharton
- another Wharton faculty member Amanda Stark and with a Wharton PhD student uh Boris vson and essentially what we're
- trying to figure out is when the government pays Health insurers more to provide Medicare recipients with
- Healthcare how much of that additional money ripples through to consumers in the form of better coverage so just at a
- at a high level uh the Medicare program there are 52 million people enrolled in it in the US the vast majority are 65
- years old and up uh but there are some people who who qualify for being disabled now for about 30% of those 52
- million they opt out of what's called traditional Medicare and instead select into one of these private insurance
- plans so the other 70% are in traditional Medicare where if they go to the hospital or a physician the
- government directly pays the hospital or the physician for their care it's fee for service traditional Medicare
- Medicare Advantage which is what we're studying in that program the government just cuts a check per person per month
- to a health insurer and the health insurer then coordinates and finances that person's care and so this is a
- really big program it is 30% of all Medicare recipients and it's grown a lot it's more than doubled over the last
- eight or nine years and there is there have been many studies comparing it with traditional Medicare so for example are
- people getting better quality care if they're in Medicare Advantage than in fee for service or uh are they uh do
- they have better health outcomes Medicare Advantage fee for service there been very little work that has asked as
- you pay these plans more how much does quality rise if at all and what other things happen um and this is a really
- important issue because a key feature of Obamacare is uh calls for a reduction in
- the payments to these plans there's going to be pretty significant reductions to their reimbursement over
- time we actually don't have much evidence on what will happen as a result of that so we have a number of key
- findings and I'll just sort of run through the big ones so one is that when the government pays Health insurers more
- many more Health insurers enter the market so it's kind of uh on the one hand great
- for incumbent Health insurers because they get paid more but on the other hand potentially not great because they're
- going to see more competition for Medicare recipients so that is uh you know one big effect that we find
- additionally we find that more people enroll in Medicare Advantage when the government pays the plans more
- essentially the reason there is that as the plans get more money it becomes profitable to to advertise and Market to
- still more U Medicare recipients um but then we you know the most of the study focuses on the quality of coverage
- in let's say a high reimbursement regime versus a low reimbursement regime and to
- get to look at this we um exploit a quirk in the government's methodology for payment essentially counties that
- are grouped in metropolitan areas with a population of 250,000 or more typically
- get about 105% more than otherwise identical counties in Metro areas just underneath 250,000 so that turns out to
- be a really big difference in how much the plans are reimbursed and we exploit that and telescope in on do we see
- higher quality coverage in the places with more generous reimbursement than in less and we look at a number of
- different uh kinds of quality um some having to do with financial characteristics like what kind of
- deductibles and co-pays do people have others having to do with the breadth of people's provider networks are they able
- to easily see a physician or a specialist or Primary Care person uh additionally uh uh what are what's
- their overall satisfaction with their plan and what sorts of services are covered so we try to look at a broad set
- of quality indicators and our findings indicate that we see more insurers enter and we s see more people enroll and we
- see more advertising expenditures but we actually don't see much better quality when you pay plans more and so I think
- that this is um and and so what we what we uh the the question then naturally arises where does the money seem to go
- and in a sort of final empirical analysis we try to see how much of it ripples through to profits of Health
- insurers and we see that quite significant in uh share of it does so this has uh imp you know this is um to
- us you know an important area to be studying because there are going to be so many changes to how Medicare
- Advantage plans and other government healthc care is is is reimbursed how generously it's reimbursed in years
- ahead and so you know we've sort of made some progress on that front it's not this isn't the last word on this issue
- but it is um we think uh you know an important uh piece of evidence for for policy makers to weigh as they're
- thinking about can we cut reimbursement to these plans or not so a Medicare recipient in choosing between
- traditional Medicare and a Medicare Advantage plan will weigh a number of factors so neither one is likely to
- dominate the other one so on the one hand traditional Medicare is going to tend to have more providers in the
- network so it most Physicians most hospitals contract with traditional Medicare however a private insurer May
- contract with some Physicians perhaps very high quality Physicians who don't contract with traditional Medicare and
- additionally the Medicare Advantage plan May provide additional benefits above and beyond what traditional Medicare
- covers so just as one example many of the plans have historically offered things like gym memberships or Vision
- Care and these are additional uh uh benefits above and beyond what traditional Medicare covers so their
- premium will sometimes be slightly higher than traditional Medicare but that is partly because uh they sometimes
- offer these additional benefits above and beyond traditional uh Medicare so there it is there's no simple comparison
- because each insurer can tailor the sort of level of benefits that it offers um as a
- function of the characteristics of of people so human might offer a plan with Vision Care in one County but without
- Vision Care in another County it might offer a plan with a deductible of you know n Dollar in one place and two n
- Dollar in another place so it just it depends they really have uh you know a fair amount of flexibility to tailor
- their benefits across the counties but they have to at least provide a level of benefits as as generous is traditional
- Medicare they can't undercut traditional MediCare at least on paper first key takeaway is that firm's
- decision to enter a market is highly responsive to how much the government pays so when the government pays more
- for medic Private health insurance through Medicare uh more insurers compete to offer that coverage so that
- is one really important key take away a second is that at least given the many quality
- measures that we can look at we don't find a ton of evidence that paying plans substantially more uh leads to much
- better equality and this you know there's a lot of research in uh Health economics and related areas trying to
- figure out when we pay more for medical care in this country how much do we get in return for it and there's conflicting
- evidence on that but within Medicare Advantage we don't find a huge payoff on the margin and so you know takeaway as
- we think about the Affordable Care Act being phased in and reductions in the generosity of reimbursement to the plans
- I think uh you know there's been a lot of concern that those reimbursement Cuts would um harm consumers a fair amount
- and our evidence suggests that um those effects may not be so great not not to say that they would be zero but they're
- certainly not the case that for each dollar you reduce uh reimbursement into the plans a full dollar is being um uh
- taken away from consumers in the form of the uh quality of their coverage so I'd
- say those are the three key takeway I think it was surprising to me how responsive insurers were to uh
- receiving 10 a half% more in reimbursement so we estimate that in a typical Market there are about four
- insurers operating uh let's say in in the the somewhat smaller counties and as soon as you pay them 10 a half% more
- that increases to about six insurers so it's a 50% increase in the number of number of insurers offering coverage I
- think that was surprising to me it was also surprising to me though that with that additional reimbursement it we
- didn't see a a big Improvement in quality and there we're talking about billions of dollars in additional
- government spending as a result of this somewhat higher reimbursement in um in the places with a population of 250,000
- or more so was s somewhat surprised to see so little of the benefit passing through to consumers in the form of
- better benefits um those would be my two biggest surprises the key implication for
- business is that as let's say the level of reimbursement for some government service whether it's Health Care
- defense uh infrastructure or what have you as the level of payment as as the level that the government will pay for
- that increases uh the number of firms that are going to compete for that is going to grow so I think that is one uh
- important implication that there's sort of a a positive and a negative in in terms of uh G getting more generous
- reimbursement for the government um for consumers I think that it is uh important to sort of follow the money
- and to think about when the government is paying more for some benefit whether it's education or Healthcare or
- something else it's important to sort of think about is that additional money passing through in the form of let's say
- better schooling better healthare or what have you and so I think it is um it's useful to for anyone uh for any for
- anyone who's on one of these programs or a taxpayer who's funding them to think critically about what are we getting for
- that extra little bit that we're paying because governments are constantly uh making decisions about how
- much to allocate to this area versus that area versus another area and I think it's uh incumbent on everyone not
- just the people who are on the programs but but taxpayers and others uh to think
- critically about where we get the biggest bang for the buck in uh in what the government is
- doing there are a number of changes that are coming in that will take effect over
- the next several years uh as a result of the Affordable Care Act better known as
- Obamacare um and chief among them is a reduction in the re generosity of reimbursement of Medicare Advantage
- plans that's a a big part of the financing for the expansion of health insurance coverage uh that made it uh
- lowering the deficit overall I think that um the concerns that many have had about the adverse effects of those
- reimbursement reductions on consumers um I I'm uh I think those are somewhat less problematic now than I
- would have before embarking on This research now so I I so so far the the reductions in reimbursement to these
- plans have already been delayed twice so one set was supposed to take effect last
- April another set this April and the government has uh to some extent sort of pushed off somewhat those reimbursement
- cuts um out of partially out of a fear of what that would mean for Medicare recipients and I think that our evidence
- suggests that those um the the the the costs of those uh reimburse cost for consumers might be um might not be so
- great after all turns out that more than one in three us residents is insured by
- Medicare or another government Health Care Program so one example of that is Medicaid which also ensures more than 50
- million people in the US and it turns out that more than 2third of Medicaid recipients are enrolled in a form of
- managed care that is somewhat similar to Medicare Advantage so uh in which basically Medicaid is a state
- administered program and it primarily provides health insurance for lower income Americans um and so as with
- Medicare Advantage in Medicaid many state governments pay a fixed amount per member per month to an insurance company
- that then coordinates and finances care uh for recipients and I think our findings for Medicare Advantage um
- suggest that now we didn't study Medicaid so I hesitate to extrapolate from one program to another but to the
- extent that the Contracting details are similar in Medicaid as in Medicare seems
- plausible that the level of reimbursement to these plans um you know changing it either up or down may not uh
- have a huge effect on Medicaid recipients so I think this is and this is just more generally I mean the US
- spends vastly more on medical care than any other country on the planet as a share of our economy there's no one
- close and I think partly because of that it's sometimes not so surprising when we look
- at what what we're getting for that last $100 or last $500 on the margin we often
- find not much and so I think that the Medicare Advantage uh findings may have implications for Medicaid managed care
- but just government spending on Health Care More generally that on the margin we're already spending so much more than
- other places that there there are a lot of opportunities to cut with minimal impact on minimal adverse impact on
- consumers well this uh paper was um itself featured in the news a couple of times and and uh but very recently just
- a week or two ago the um the federal government decided to hold off on part of the reduction in Medicare Advantage
- reimbursement that was called for in the Affordable Care Act and I think uh you know and they had uh I think
- there were well-intentioned con uh reasons for that um a concern that if they paid the plans less uh fewer people
- would end up enrolled in the plans and those who were enrolled would see lower quality I think uh our research is
- pretty relevant for that it was a pretty big news item because it's an example there have been a number of things in
- Obamacare that have been delayed uh in one way or another it's another example of of such a uh such a delay uh and I
- think that our research suggests that when the time comes and policy makers are ready to implement some of those
- reimbursement Cuts uh that the the the impact for consumers may not be uh that negative I think there's a general view
- that as uh the government pays more for health care or for many services that this is likely to benefit
- uh the people enrolled in the program the people attending the school the people driving on the road or what have
- you and so I think that um to the extent there is some conventional wisdom it may
- be that reductions in let's say Medicare spending will harm Medicare recipients and you know I I don't want us we're not
- going to extrapolate to all components of Medicare but at least in this pretty big part that rep that accounts for 30%
- of Medicare recipients um I think our findings pretty pretty clearly indicate that um uh paying somewhat less uh
- doesn't necessarily harm consumers and conversely paying somewhat more doesn't necessarily benefit consumers all that
- much uh and I think that's important because the country is going to Grapple with some pretty difficult decisions
- maybe not tomorrow maybe not next year but in the not too distant future given the demographic changes about how we're
- going to reform Medicare Medicaid and Social Security and I think more evidence about what are the implications
- of either paying less in Medicare uh uh or you know other other changes in entitlement programs that
- will make them somewhat more fiscally sustainable I think more of that kind of research is going to be
- important I think there's been a fair amount of work comparing Medicare Advantage with traditional Medicare
- there's been much less work asking the question how much better Does Medicare Advantage become as we pay health
- insurers more so I think that's something that really different helps to differentiate our research from other
- studies and sort of also tries to drill down and understand how companies are impacted by more generous payment from
- the government when the government offers to pay more for a product in this case health insurance for Medicare
- recipients what we see is companies respond to that they enter somewhat more aggressively but surprisingly
- surprisingly to us the increase in competition that's generated by that addition additional payment doesn't seem
- to translate into better benefits for consumers so um I think it is uh it you it it's not like this will be the last
- uh research written on this topic but I think really understanding in the US Health Care System what we get on the
- margin for additional spending is really important because it's it's a huge junk
- of the economy and it's going to grow uh bigger and bigger as as a result of demographics and other factors
- so one thing we're eager to know is who are the firms who are sort of on the bubble for entering the Medicare
- Advantage um Market versus not entering so there are some insurers that seem to operate whether reimbursement is
- generous or somewhat stingy um but then there are these sort of marginal firms that come in when uh when the government
- pays somewhat more and I think understanding who these firms are and or do they offer a somewhat different
- different level of quality perhaps lower level of quality than the incumbent firms that might help us to understand
- better why we're uh reaching the the the conclusions that we are how the the incumbent firms differ from the firms
- that are on the bubble from entering um that's one area we'd like to work on additionally in related work I would
- like to perform similar similar analyses for the state-based health insurance exchanges so a big part of Obamacare is
- uh the setup of we've heard about healthcare.gov uh through which about 35 States uh enrolled people for their uh
- Insurance exchanges and then in other 15 states kind of did their own exchanges um and these are brand new
- marketplaces um that through which more than 7 million people have enrolled for health insurance and so I think a
- another area that I'm eager to do work on that will sort of build in this area is to understand what determines uh how
- many firms are entering these exchanges different markets in these exchanges and
- how those decisions about uh what how the those decisions by Health insurers influence the quality of coverage that's
- available and the level of premiums so I think some Geographic markets are benefiting from a from uh the presence
- of many different Health insurers uh whereas others have just one or two so there are parts of the US entire states
- that are served by just one or two Health insurers and I think uh it will be important to understand are uh those
- consumers being short changed relative to their counterparts in in places with somewhat more competition and I think
- that this isn't exactly related to the Medicare Advantage stuff but it it essentially trying to understand how the
- design of a government Marketplace a government administered Marketplace um what effect that has on the quality and
- price of a very important product which is health insurance [Music]
Brief Summary
Higher Medicare Advantage payments increase insurer competition but do not significantly improve coverage quality.
Key points
- Government Spending on Healthcare. The U.S. spends vastly more on healthcare than any other country, yet the returns are often minimal.
- Medicare Advantage Insights. Research reveals that increased government payments lead to more competition but not necessarily better care.
Episode highlights
- Government Spending on HealthcareThe U.S. spends vastly more on healthcare than any other country, yet the returns are often minimal.“What are we getting for that last $100 or last $500 on the margin?”14:07Jun 20, 2014
- Medicare Advantage InsightsResearch reveals that increased government payments lead to more competition but not necessarily better care.“Paying more doesn’t necessarily benefit consumers all that much.”16:38Jun 20, 2014





