Do Workplace Wellness Programs Actually Work?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton Professor Iwan Barankay explores the effectiveness of workplace wellness programs, highlighting findings from randomized controlled trials. He discusses how programs like fitness incentives have not shown to increase productivity nor reduce healthcare costs. He explains that further research is needed to look into the efficacy of mental health wellness offerings, given employees' high levels of stress.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#WorkplaceWellness #CorporateWellness #EmployeeWellness #EmployeeWellbeing #WellnessPrograms ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. There have been a number of um rigorous studies, randomized control trials um that tested uh with a comparison group,
  2. a control group to see whether those that were offered a program actually changed their behavior and had different
  3. outcomes. So changing their behavior meaning you know whether they said that they eat better or exercised more or
  4. took part in like preventative care and outcomes is like you know whether they actually have lost weight or stopped
  5. smoking had a lower risk for a heart attack which is like a core uh target of these programs and also whether they
  6. report less absentism higher productivity and lower health costs. Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the
  7. podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wargan faculty. I'm your host, Dan Looney, and in each
  8. episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have
  9. conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. So, when you think about wellness in the
  10. workplace, the topic of wellness programs is discussed quite a bit. Not just the companies who are providing
  11. them, but do they actually make a difference improving health outcomes? Pleasure to be joined here in studio by
  12. Ivon Barank who's associate professor of business economics and public policy as
  13. well as an associate professor of management here at the Wharton School. Ivon, it's been a while. Great to talk
  14. to you again. How are you? It's wonderful to see you too. Hello. Thank you. Uh, all right. So, what are
  15. companies trying to bring forward with this idea of bringing in wellness programs in the first place? Well, um I
  16. thought that you would give me an easier question first because there's no single
  17. clearly defined structure or approach to this. There's an overarching concern and
  18. motivation behind these programs, but there's no single definition. I think what these uh wellness programs are all
  19. about is uh some some form of a programmatic approach and with a focus on prevention with a focus on coaching
  20. uh to help people to steer towards more healthy behavior and um and that is in contrast to other programs that
  21. companies have that are more driven by legislation and administrative rules about workplace safety. Um and I think
  22. here the the big component here is not just that there's program that allows people to follow certain steps um that
  23. are then dedicated towards particular needs of each individual employees. So there's a back and forth between what
  24. employees want and what they need and also there's a big data component to it um which is like quite controversial but
  25. you know people's behavior is being tracked more than before and the program is tailored towards encouraging them to
  26. do that and sometimes rewards or sometimes punishments are attached to that as well. So for a lot of the
  27. companies there has to be a financial component tied to this with when you're thinking about the cost of healthare the
  28. way that has gone up uh in recent years uh and the way the fact that if somebody
  29. is not healthier they are obviously more likely to be uh spending money to fix or
  30. correct certain healthcare issues to begin with. Absolutely. I mean the idea of workplace wellness programs goes back
  31. decades um where we wanted to encourage people to really look after them themselves but there has been a big
  32. change with the affordable care act that uh specifically allowed a a big component of cost to be dedicated to
  33. these wellness programs. Um and that was a big change where now there was a legislative platform on which these
  34. programs could be built. Um over time the scenario became a bit more complicated when it came to data
  35. protection and disability care. But in general there's the much more foundation where companies can actually use costs
  36. and incentives related to these wellness programs compared to before. And um the
  37. the big question to me still is um you know what is when does wellness programs start and when do like amenities in the
  38. workplace end? amenities being, you know, tools or technologies or equipment that help people be more productive um
  39. help companies to attract and retain people and increase satisfaction in in the workplace. So are uh is the the
  40. component of that then just something that the company believes that they can have as an add-on and it is a benefit on
  41. top of traditional benefits that employees would have under their under their uh benefits package. Yes. I mean
  42. how does this work in a inside an organization or a company? I mean often they invite a consultant u to advise
  43. them on what to do. um if it is more sophisticated they actually do some surveying among their employees to get a
  44. sense of what they what they looking for what are their real needs and then they
  45. build a program around that. So say you know many times uh people who have to commute quite a bit they might find it
  46. difficult to uh to go in addition to the work and to be with the duties at home to go to the gym or to go for a run. So
  47. they might want to see whether there's a a gym at the workplace, which by itself
  48. is just an amenity, but then whether going to the gym is something that the company rewards or fosters. And here's
  49. an interesting additional component. Many times these wellness programs are are sought for by future employees as a
  50. signal that the company actually cares about them. They don't just want to squeeze the maximum productivity out of
  51. them, but they really care about whether they're doing well, whether they're happy at the workplace. Well, and and I
  52. guess off of that then when we went through the pandemic, we saw a greater focus on mental health as a component of
  53. this. Yeah, the co 19 really accelerated um a process whereby companies re-evaluate what kind of work needs to
  54. be done at at home and what can be done remotely. I mean we now know that zoom has become a much more mature platform
  55. where we can do much more work remotely. Now with that came an interesting challenge which is twofold. before we
  56. could really like measure people's behavior much more clearly uh because they're there in the workplace and we
  57. can supervise them. Sometimes this is possible with technology but you know when we go
  58. remotely what has happened is many companies now started to use devices of various sorts or like um other ways of
  59. tracking people's behavior. So if there's a program that encouraged people to walk more then people companies would
  60. give them like pedometers or an app that tracks how much they they walked but you
  61. know if it is more reward you know how can you actually make sure that they actually did it well I guess it becomes
  62. important then because when co was here and we were all working from home every day of the week I noticed it in my
  63. neighborhood and I'm sure in neighborhoods across the United States and around the world you saw more people
  64. out walking but it was because they had more time on their hands and they, you know, needed something to do. Now we're
  65. kind of back into this normal lifestyle and I wonder if people will continue to do it as frequently as they did it 5
  66. years ago. Yeah, that's a that's a very interesting question and I think the data is not quite there yet to tell us
  67. what has happened but yes, it is true. You know, if you didn't have to commute, you had a lot of time that you could
  68. dedicate to to walking or exercising. Um but it may also lead to situations where
  69. there's a strain on mental health because you're always at home, you're always in the same environment where you
  70. live and work and that is difficult to set boundaries. So there the shift has become much more towards uh supporting
  71. people with their mental well-being so that they are not burned out or that they just get irritated. Note if you're
  72. working remotely, you are isolated from others. So for a while you can perhaps tolerate uh you know the antiques of a
  73. supervisor because you think this is still a good company or good career to pursue but when you reach a burning
  74. point or a tipping point then you may no longer be willing to do that and then you might quit. Do companies enough
  75. companies look at and invest in the types of components to have in a wellness program so that you're getting
  76. the greatest benefit or is it somewhat that is as you may have suggested before kind of thrown out there as a bonus as a
  77. as a benefit to the employee. That's a great question and I think uh when I read the literature and also look at
  78. what companies do it is often not quite clear what the clear rational behind these programs are. So if you wanted to
  79. step back and be more academic about it clearly one component is just a human human capital theory idea. You know I
  80. invest in their health people are then healthier they are not absent and if they're healthier then healthare costs
  81. go down. So that's the rational behind it. But if you sometimes think about employee satisfaction, you know, then
  82. companies offer it because they want to make sure that people are happy and that
  83. they want to come there. And many times we see that um employees when they consider companies or which companies to
  84. go to, they highlight, oh, this company has these programs as well, right? But when we survey them later whether they
  85. actually use it, they often don't have time to use the gym or to make uh make use of their you know their uh you know
  86. their wellness programs because they're too busy working on their careers. So it
  87. mixes in the component of the company wanting to do whatever they can to keep the best employees in the company and
  88. going to whatever lengths they need to within reason to be able to do that. Yes. You know, this has been not just
  89. the Fed, but there was really like a a horse race uh in the market where companies offered more and more
  90. elaborate programs and signal to them like how in what comprehensive ways they can really pay attention to them and
  91. help them with their careers and uh but then when we come to the data and look at who who used what and whether it
  92. actually made a difference, it it becomes a much more nuanced picture. What do you think needs to occur then
  93. moving forward to make sure that we maximize the best components for the employees
  94. and for the companies as well. So I think with this question we are starting to talk a little bit more about you know
  95. what lessons can we draw from what companies has offered what companies have offered and whether these programs
  96. actually work. Um and here I think it is clear that we need to learn much more about what we can actually do that makes
  97. a difference to these uh employees. Um there have been a number of um rigorous studies, randomized control trials um
  98. that tested uh with a comparison group, a control group to see whether those that were offered a program actually
  99. changed their behavior and had different outcomes. So changing their behavior meaning you know whether they said that
  100. they eat better or exercised more or took part in like preventative care and outcomes is like you know whether they
  101. actually have lost weight or stopped smoking had a lower risk for a heart attack which is like a core uh target of
  102. these programs and also whether they report less absentism higher productivity and lower health costs. And
  103. here when we look at the two biggest most prominent studies from these randomized control trials, we see uh
  104. that there is slight evidence that the people report and have been shown to change their behavior somewhat, but
  105. there's no compelling evidence or no significant evidence in terms of outcomes that we care about like
  106. absenteeism, productivity, health care costs and and health risks. So these were for quite comprehensive programs.
  107. So to your question okay so given that the abroad program does not work are components of them working better right
  108. so this is where there has been a shift uh towards identifying specific uh uh approaches one was to work on people's
  109. fitness specifically uh encouraging them more either with financial incentives or
  110. through other peer pressure or or or workplace norms to go to the gym and we see that you know those programs
  111. increased muscularkeeletal strength and sometimes that translates into pro productivity but you can imagine that
  112. this is really really work specific. Um another key component of these programs which is something that I've studied a
  113. lot in my own research was about using financial incentives to specifically target certain behaviors. You know econ
  114. 101 says that you know people are lazy and they don't want to do stuff unless you give them an additional reward for
  115. doing it. So you have to overcome the inconvenience or the displeasure of doing something. So I've studied whether
  116. offering people financial incentives to take their statin medication which is like for people who are at risk of a
  117. heart attack whether this actually has an impact and I've done two large NIH funded randomized control trials and and
  118. and have replicably shown that those incentives actually have no impact on cholesterol levels. Now though there are
  119. some studies that show some benefits but even the studies that show benefits the
  120. interventions are not cost-effective. So we are still out on the quest to identify what are the components that
  121. work well. Now the latest candidate for these are really the wellness programs that focus on mental health because this
  122. is what people really say that they struggle with the stress they struggle with their motivation. You know why why
  123. should I apply myself? This is really so stressful and this is a clear candidate
  124. where more research has has to come about but again we lack the evidence that is actually effective at this stage
  125. but it is still a topic that will continue to be used researched looked at so that we can try and get better in
  126. terms of understanding what are the best types of programs to have the components to have
  127. in them so that you can have that that that stronger relationship ship between work and personal life so that the
  128. employee feels like they are getting the most from their benefits packages. Absolutely. I mean the big challenge
  129. that many employees face is to understand you know how can I um manage my life and achieve all the goals that I
  130. have uh for myself. But now with the remote work and also with the experience of covid many people um uh have not been
  131. able to develop a structure that allows them to identify goals and pursue them and manage their their life in an
  132. effective way. So they still look uh towards the company to help them in this process. So sometimes a simple task like
  133. you know optimally designing how you should spend your time during the week which is like the uh routine task that
  134. everybody has to do. But evidence shows that most people actually do not uh have
  135. a good way of structuring their week to get uh the most out of the time that they want to allocate that uh that they
  136. want to allocate to the company. Right? Great to see you again. Thanks very much
  137. for your time. It was a pleasure to talk to you again. See you next time. Thank you. Ivon Baron K, associate professor
  138. of business economics and public policy as well as uh management here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening
  139. to the ripple effect. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a
  140. review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Workplace wellness programs are discussed, focusing on their effectiveness and the impact of remote work on employee health.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast Introduction. Join host Dan Looney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton faculty.
  • Wellness Programs: Do They Work?. A deep dive into the effectiveness of workplace wellness programs and their impact on health outcomes.
  • Mental Health Focus Post-Pandemic. The pandemic has shifted the focus towards mental health in workplace wellness programs.
  • Challenges in Managing Work-Life Balance. Employees face difficulties in managing their lives and achieving personal goals amidst remote work.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes