"700 Reasons to Quit"

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management;Health Care Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this was a study led by my colleague scott halpern funded by the national cancer institute
  2. in which we enrolled smokers from cvs from around the country who were employees
  3. and we put them into one of five different groups one group was simply a control group
  4. that got free nicotine patches and other aids to help them quit smoking another group got the same free
  5. pharmacologic aids plus up to eight hundred dollars based on quitting smoking success
  6. successfully a third group got an opportunity to put a hundred fifty dollars of their own
  7. money at risk if they were successful in quitting smoking they would get an additional 650 dollars so they'd get the
  8. same 800 if they were not successful they would forfeit the 150 and then we had two group based
  9. incentives one in which people were pooled and had the chance to collaborate the other in which people were pooled
  10. and had the chance to compete and potentially win larger rewards there were three main findings to the
  11. research the first is that we were able to replicate earlier work done by our group among employees at general
  12. electric in which we found roughly a tripling of smoking cessation rates at six months
  13. and that was pretty exciting because as a researcher you're always hoping that when you find
  14. important results that those can be substantiated in other studies and the findings here were very similar to
  15. what we had found initially at ge a number of years ago so that that was point one
  16. second point was that those who are given the opportunity to put their own money at risk and who
  17. chose to do that did phenomenally well about 52 percent of them actually quit smoking and this was all biochemically
  18. confirmed the rub was that only about 14 percent of those offered the opportunity to put
  19. their own money at risk chose to do so so on net that was less effective than simply
  20. giving people a standard incentive in which if they quit smoking they would get up to eight hundred dollars
  21. we also found that putting people in groups was not significantly more effective
  22. than just offering them an individual incentive and this was important because there's a
  23. lot of buzz out there about making programs social and people often assume that that will
  24. automatically make the program more effective in this case i want to add the important
  25. caveat that we put people together in groups who did not know each other but giving those people an opportunity to
  26. collaborate did not significantly increase the rate of smoking cessation a lot of employers offer incentives for
  27. healthy behavior about 85 percent of employ large employers in the us offer incentives for healthy behavior of one
  28. kind or another but there's two big limitations to how this is commonly done commonly this is done by adjusting
  29. people's premiums and by adjusting them in the future and there's two reasons why from a
  30. behavioral standpoint that's not so likely to be effective one is that by tying these incentives to
  31. premiums it makes them relatively invisible so if i give somebody a discount on their premiums
  32. that's typically added to your paycheck it's direct deposited in the bank and it's thereby rendered relatively
  33. invisible so you can have an incentive of several hundred dollars that the employee may not even realize is being
  34. deposited in their account and from a mental accounting standpoint that's a very bad thing to do because you
  35. obviously want to make these incentive dollars as effective and as visible as possible
  36. the second issue is the time sequencing a lot of times what employers do is they
  37. give these incentives through premium adjustments next year or at the end of this year
  38. and when you're trying to change somebody's behavior given that humans are wired to focus on the here and now
  39. that's not a very good strategy what this study does is it provides a new path forward that i think really
  40. highlights two key things one is that taking these incentives out of the premiums making it more visible
  41. makes them much more effective so as i mentioned there's roughly a tripling in smoking cessation rates from having this
  42. very visible incentive available to employees the second is that offering employees an opportunity to put some of
  43. their own money at risk for those employees who are willing to do it can be very effective and what's very
  44. exciting about this study is the follow-up in terms of what cvs health is planning to do
  45. they are offering all their employees starting next month through a new program called 700 reasons to quit
  46. an opportunity to put 50 dollars of their own money at risk if they're successful at quitting smoking at six
  47. months and at 12 months they will actually match that with 700 so it's a fourteen to one match and the
  48. idea is to really make it attractive to people to participate for a fairly minimal contribution of seven hundred
  49. dollars all smokers would then have the opportunity to win an additional seven hundred dollars and the hope there is to
  50. really tie into a lot of what we found through this study get high rates of participation and then
  51. among people who participate really high success rates in quitting and i think that provides a new paradigm
  52. for employers to think about where these programs can be much more effective than they've typically been
  53. through simply adjusting people's premiums in the future one thing that surprised us a bit was
  54. that despite offering matching dollars of six hundred fifty dollars for everybody who put a hundred
  55. fifty dollar deposit down that only about fourteen percent of people were willing to do that i think that
  56. highlights a number of important elements of human nature people are very reluctant to
  57. part with their own money we know that from lots of other contexts in life and it appears that 150 dollars was just
  58. too high a bar for people in terms of getting them engaged in in this decision to try to quit smoking now
  59. that's one of the reasons i'm so excited about the new cvs program 700 reasons to
  60. quit because by having this lower bar of 50 dollars i think the potential and also a much
  61. bigger match of 700 dollars for the 50 dollars i think the potential rates of engagement are going to be very high
  62. because that's a very attractive proposition we have to keep in mind that about 70
  63. percent of smokers in the us want to quit only three to five percent per year are
  64. able to but part of it is trying to make it very attractive to smokers to try to quit now and i
  65. think the new cvs program has a real chance to do that i think there's several important
  66. lessons to draw one is that we we can do better than we're doing now in terms of helping people quit smoking
  67. clearly offering people free pharmacologic therapy is a good idea i don't think any
  68. medical professional would disagree with the notion that we want to lower the barriers to access to evidence-based
  69. therapies as much as possible but it's important to highlight here that the standard incentive arm roughly
  70. tripled smoking cessation rates over and above what was achieved with free pharmacologic therapy
  71. so we can do much better than we're doing the other important point to recognize
  72. is that study after study has indicated that having a smoker who's an employee probably costs an employer
  73. three to six thousand dollars extra a year in terms of higher health care costs and lower rates of productivity higher
  74. rates of absenteeism so offering an incentive of eight hundred dollars or something in that ballpark to employees
  75. should be financially a no-brainer because it really offers the opportunity to both
  76. help your employees get healthier and help the employer from an economic standpoint
  77. one of the common perceptions people have is that by making programs social they'll
  78. automatically be more effective and this study provided some pretty good evidence that putting people in groups
  79. doesn't automatically lead to higher quit rates i suspect that if we had been able to put smokers together with other
  80. people they knew they might have been able to achieve higher rates of success but in creating a program that we
  81. thought had the potential to be scalable we by design groups people who didn't know each other together because that
  82. way you could just enroll people's individuals you didn't have to have people enroll in groups of four or
  83. groups of five which would have made things much more challenging and it's important to note that putting
  84. people in these groups of five and offering them a chance to collaborate was not effective at increasing their
  85. smoking cessation rates there are a couple of things which really set this research apart from many
  86. of the other studies that have been done the first is that this is actually the largest study that has ever been done of
  87. financial incentives and smoking cessation within an employer population so we have a lot more statistical power
  88. to find differences if they exist a second reason is that this was done in very close collaboration with one of the
  89. largest employers in america cvs is the 12th largest employer in the united states
  90. and by working closely with them we were able to tie this in using their communications infrastructure and
  91. conduct a study which i think much better reflects the real world application of these kinds of programs
  92. than if this were an academic study done in an academic setting a third reason uh that this is i think
  93. relatively unique is we tested several different incentive designs head to head and i think that's very important
  94. because a lot of employee benefits managers they often seem to think about incentives yes no
  95. and it's very important to recognize that how you design these programs has a huge impact on how effective they are
  96. you know an incentive is not an incentive a dollar is not a dollar it all depends
  97. on how these programs are designed how they're delivered that has a big impact on how effective they are and this
  98. provides very nice comparative effectiveness research data that can be used by employers and
  99. benefits managers in thinking about the kinds of programs they should design and what exactly those look like
  100. one of the most important findings from this study is that among people who are given the chance to put some of their
  101. own money at risk smoking cessation rates as i mentioned were phenomenally high about 52 percent
  102. but only about 14 of people agreed to do that one of the key areas going forward for future research is how
  103. to increase that 14 percent so in a follow-up study we're doing we're looking at that and in essence having
  104. our sponsor agree to put the money up front for all employees who are smokers and then seeing can we engender the same
  105. kind of quit rates among people who now have this money at risk but where all of them
  106. are participating in that loss aversion type incentive arm so that's i think one
  107. of the key questions going forward is if you increase the participation rates in those kind of programs
  108. can you really increase the quit rates accordingly and that's going to be a central question for future research
  109. you

Brief Summary

Scott Halpern discusses effective smoking cessation incentives for CVS employees, highlighting financial rewards and the importance of visibility in programs.

Key points

  • Exciting Findings on Smoking Cessation. The study replicated earlier work, tripling smoking cessation rates at six months.
  • Incentives and Engagement. Participants who put their own money at risk had high quit rates, but few chose to do so.
  • Behavioral Insights on Incentives. The study highlights the importance of making incentives visible and immediate.
  • New CVS Program Launch. CVS Health plans to launch a new program offering financial incentives for quitting smoking.
  • Future Research Directions. Future studies will explore increasing participation in financial incentive programs.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes