How Trash-talking Affects Performance
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Trash-talking is fairly commonplace, whether in sports, business or elsewhere. But how does it affect the targets of these insults? Wharton research has some surprising findings. More: http://knlg.net/2thqIKT 📂 Management;Human Resources 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- athletes do it CEOs do it people in the office and home do it what I'm talking about is trash-talking but how does it
- affect the people who are actually its targets here to talk about the issue are Wharton professor are Maurice Schweitzer
- and Wharton lecturer and research scholar Jeremy Yip welcome both of them have written a co-written a paper a
- research paper on this very issue and they're here to give us more details so tell us about the premise of your paper
- the premise of our paper is to provide were the first to provide an initial conceptualization of trash-talking
- and some empirical evidence of the interpersonal effects of trash-talking on competitive behavior so we often
- think about trash-talking in the forum of sports and politics but it features quite prominently in organizational life
- I'll give you an example that illustrates trash-talking in organizational life so you may be
- familiar with the London Eye to celebrate the new millennium the City of London constructed the London Eye a
- giant Ferris wheel that sits on the shore of the River Thames and while you may be familiar with the London Eye
- which might not know is that they had British Airways sponsored the construction in the final stages of
- construction as they erected the London Eye into place they encountered some technical difficulties Richard Branson
- the CEO of Virgin Atlantic Airways decided to capitalize on the misfortune of one of its key competitors and
- broadcasted a message intended to humiliate British Airways or be a he had Virgin Atlantic arranged a blimp to fly
- over the construction site of the London Eye with a giant banner that read be a can't get it up this public insult
- intensified a long-standing competition between British Airways and Virgin Atlantic and it's this style of
- aggressive communication in competition that we explore in our paper and that we'll discuss with you today so how
- would you define trash-talking we conceptualize trash-talking as competitive in civility that is uncivil
- remarks or aggressive communication that is expressed between competitors more specifically we define
- trash-talking as boastful comments about the self or insulting remarks about competitors that are delivered by a
- competitor typically before or during a competition what's interesting is that trash-talking also pervades corporate in
- America so I'll give you a couple of examples of CEOs trash-talking one example is from Dan Akerson who was the
- CEO of GM so when a christen was CEO of GM he announced that GM would be competing directly with the Mercedes
- c-class they were going to launch a car a rear-wheel drive car that would compete directly with the Mercedes
- c-class and when asked what he thought about Mercedes he said they call it c-class because it's very average John
- Legere is another example of a CEO who at t-mobile who ripped into one of his competitors AT&T when he said I see more
- honesty in a match.com ad than a tMT's coverage maps so these are just a couple of examples of CEOs engaging in
- trash-talking but we've also but the question came up how prevalent is trash-talking in the workplace and so to
- initiate our study we conducted a pilot study in which we recruited full-time office workers at fortune 500 companies
- and we asked them to recall an incident where they heard or said and a boastful or insulting remark at work while
- competing for resources or recognition what we found was that we received a variety of different incidences that
- they recalled but most interestingly we found that 57% of the employees indicated that trash-talking occurs on a
- monthly or more often than monthly that's a very surprising statistic so professor Schweitzer can you talk more
- about your pilot study and the six experiments that went into it sure so this this topic is really
- pervasive we see trash talking around us and what we set out to do is to look at
- the consequences of trash talking and in particular what happens to the person who is receiving this trash talking in
- another pilot story that we ran we found that people don't anticipate trash talking having a motivational effect but
- in fact very consistently in our studies we find that targets of trash talking become very motivated and on effort
- based tasks and we have people doing some pretty mundane things whether it's counting letters or moving sliders when
- people have to exert effort for something within a competition if somebody engaged in trash talking so
- you're a loser that dollars mine I'm going to beat you like a rented mule when people are the targets of these
- kind of messages what we find is that they become much more motivated they increase their effort and the
- performance goes up so so one one key finding of our work is that targets attract shocking become very motivated
- now we ran some other studies to show that sometimes to become even so motivated they're likely to gauge in
- unethical behavior to win so people care about is outperforming this person who's
- trash-talking them and they're willing to both expend constructive effort but also engage in unethical behavior to
- make sure they outperform their competitor so are there some constructive effects of or destructive
- effects of trash-talking well there are so in addition to these constructive effects when we wanted a creative task
- we found the trash Hawking is actually disruptive so it motivates us but it's also distracting
- and targets of trash-talking were less successful completing a creative task then were people who weren't targets of
- trash-talking so so that is trash-talking can be motivating to the targets but it's also distracting to the
- targets so how can we use your findings and apply them to our personal lives our
- work lives how can we make this practical well our work informs a number of practical implications I think first
- trash-talking is we can provide a prescriptive advice for potential and habitual trash talkers trash Chargers
- need to recognize that they may unintentionally be boosting their opponents motivation and performance so
- we encourage trash talkers to engage in deeper perspective-taking so that they are able to gauge what the
- interpersonal consequences are for the route behavior I think second we encourage managers executives and
- coaches to think carefully about when to expose their employees to trash talking
- we urge managers to deliberately and strategically expose trash talking to employees once they've considered what
- tasks that their employees are performing so in light of our findings when employees are working on routine
- tasks that require effort exposing them to a trash talking message that was said
- or broadcasted from their competitor may actually boost their performance but if
- that performance task is is more cognitively demanding and involves creativity then we would find that trash
- talking may actually diminish their performance and so managers need to be aware of the different effects on
- behavior that trash talking can have so what does trash talking do in cooperative settings well what's
- interesting is that trash line can be very destructive in a cooperative setting whereas it's motivating in a
- competitive setting in one of our studies we had people either cooperate with somebody or
- compete with somebody and these were Confederates paid research assistants who engaged in the same trash-talking
- behavior in both cases so they said things like I can't believe unpaired with you I can tell you're such a loser
- already and then they either performed a cooperative task or competitive task the
- exact same messages boosted performance in a competitive task but harm performance in a cooperative task so
- what contribution does your body of work add to existing academic theory in this
- in this in this area well our work I think connects to two important literature's one is the literature on
- competition and rivalry more specifically so Jeremy talked about British Airways and virgin and here
- trash-talking is part of that rivalry and competitive environment and we see trash-talking motivate people but also
- exacerbate exacerbate conflict we see rivalry as something that typically occurs over a long period of time with
- competed interactions but trash-talking is a way to fast-track that relationship
- so we can transform you know normal competitive behavior into a much more intense more rivalry like situation with
- trash-talking the second literature that we would connect this to is Lutron incivility and there's some very
- interesting work by christine poor and others looking at uncivil behavior in the workplace and what we do is we find
- that consistent with that prior work its destructive in cooperative settings so within your organization trash-talking
- each other is not very useful but in competitive settings it might have an interesting role to play and in some
- other emerging work that we have we're beginning to find that the trash-talking somebody else's group can actually have
- a bonding effect on our group so how will you follow up your research the curve work that we just described
- focused on the effects of trash talking on the target in dyadic interactions and
- some of the more current work that Maurice and I are carrying out investigates the effects of trash
- talking in group interactions it's valuable to understand the effects of trash talking between groups and also to
- understand the consequences for observers who are not necessarily targets in our current work we are
- investigating how people who are observers react to trash talking and whether that facilitates group cohesion
- and functioning so if we return to the example of Richard Branson which I opened with why did Richard Branson go
- to the trouble of spending all that money and time to have a blimp with the giant banner on it and float it over the
- construction site are there any benefits to doing that we hypothesize that employees in that situation may respond
- quite favorably to it and that they be maybe more likely to identify closely to their organization and so we've begun
- collecting data and testing that hypothesis wonderful thank you so much for joining us today thank thank you for
- more insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton UPenn edu you
Brief Summary
Wharton professors discuss the effects of trash-talking in competitive environments and workplaces, revealing its motivational and detrimental impacts.
Key points
- Richard Branson's Bold Move. Richard Branson used a blimp to trash-talk British Airways during the London Eye construction.
- The Power of Trash-Talking. Trash-talking can motivate competitors, but it also has disruptive effects on creativity.
Episode highlights
- Richard Branson's Bold MoveRichard Branson used a blimp to trash-talk British Airways during the London Eye construction.“Be a can't get it up!”1:53Jul 5, 2017
- The Power of Trash-TalkingTrash-talking can motivate competitors, but it also has disruptive effects on creativity.“Targets of trash-talking become very motivated and increase their effort.”5:50Jul 5, 2017


