Does the Aetna Pullout Mean Obamacare Is in Trouble?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Does Aetna’s exit from Obamacare mean the program is failing? Not likely -- and other insurers seem satisfied, says a Wharton expert. 📂 Health Care Management;Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I'd like to welcome Robert field to knowledge at Wharton Robert is a professor of health care management at
- Drexel University also a law professor and he is also a lecturer of health care management here at Wharton and we're
- here to talk today about news that's been out recently about Obamacare which could cause some to have questions about
- its viability and that's because some very high-profile insurers have announced that they're withdrawing from
- the program or at least largely withdrawing I guess the poster child for that would be Aetna and they're
- withdrawing they say because of sustaining substantial losses and so you we've seen some headlines that suggests
- that Obamacare's on the ropes is on this kids it's in a death spiral and I'm guessing that things aren't quite that
- extreme so we asked Robert to come in and give us his views on what might really be going on right well it seems
- as though whenever Obamacare gets a cold the experts say it's pneumonia and it's
- on its deathbed and and all is lost I don't think we're anywhere near that situation right now do we know five or
- 10 years from now where things will go of course not but for right now it's still functioning and a few things we
- need to remember number one of the 20 million or so people who are now insured who were not before Obamacare most of
- those have gained insurance through Medicaid and the recent announcements of the insurers have nothing to do with
- Medicaid and even if the exchanges went away Obamacare would mean new insurance for millions and millions of people in
- terms of the exchanges volatility in a brand new insurance market like this is to be expected Obamacare is not unique
- this is hardly the first time that we've tried something like this Romney did it
- in Massachusetts in 2006 Bush did it in Medicare in 2003 when he beefed up Medicare Advantage which is a choice of
- private plans on a structured market and he did the same thing with Medicare prescription drugs where you go to a
- website and choose a and their government subsidies and it determines what kind of coverage you can
- get so we know this kind of mechanism can work we also know that it takes a few years for the market to even itself
- out so this this is not the death throes of Obamacare could we could I ask you to
- give us a brief explanation of what an exchange is how it works in this case so then when we get into details it will be
- more clear sure so if you are an individual who does not get covered through your employer or not old enough
- for Medicare you're not poor enough for Medicaid you go to a website and every year between november and january you
- can select an individual policy in a manner that's similar to Travelocity or Expedia you see a choice of options and
- they have different deductibles and copays and premiums and networks and you decide which one works for you and
- different companies presumably and in most areas different companies in many areas now it's only going to be one
- company however each company has a number of different plans okay so you may not have your choice of companies
- but you will still have a choice of different plants okay and I understand that in some counties because I think
- this is done on a county-by-county basis that there's I we're down to one insurer
- but you're suggesting that even there you've got a choice of class right so the significance of there being one
- insurer is you have less market competition and it's gonna be harder to hold down prices so those people may
- well pay more but they will still have a choice of different kinds of plans different deductibles copays networks of
- providers and so forth I mentioned Aetna which is I guess the the highest-profile
- company that's a talking about pulling out of most of the exchanges that was above them but not all of them right and
- it was citing some pretty big losses almost a half a billion dollars I believe other companies have cited some
- pretty big numbers as losses and so this is I guess the grist for saying that things aren't working so well and and
- they may be they may be heading into a downward spiral could you but that but then there's this other wrinkle with
- that now where it was good oh she a ting I should say it was attempting to merge with humana i
- believe it was right and the Justice Department was putting the kibosh on that right and so they somehow i don't
- know threats the right word but they they suggested that if that was not approve then maybe they weren't going to
- be so interested in participating continuing to participate in certain exchanges so could you explain that is
- that like a kind of form of blackmailers or some might say well you I guess you could call it that you could call it a
- negotiating strategy if you wanted to be kinder Etna and Humana have wanted to merge the bigger insurer would have more
- market power the Justice Department has been concerned about that market power and threatened to challenge the merger
- in court and back in July aetna told the Justice Department that if they went through with that aetna would withdraw
- from most of the exchanges so they would say you're worried about lack of competition we're going to show you lack
- of competition we're just going to pull out so it calls into question whether these losses were really so
- unsustainable or whether this is a litigation strategy right so but in fairness were they saying that that they
- were losing money and this merger would allow them to not lose money and therefore if it wasn't approved they
- would have to pull out because they were losing money or how did they actually phrase it yeah they didn't say that they
- would stop losing money they said that they would pull out of the exchanges or are they implied that they would so it
- was it was more a tit-for-tat and and the merger deal was not approved and they did in fact pull out well it's it's
- for the court to decide at this for still not okay but they pull that they do not pull out of every market they
- stayed in a few and United that pulled out of many markets before that stayed in a few which means it preserves their
- right to come back in at a later date so it suggests they haven't given up on the
- whole law of course they aren't the only big insurers in the market there are others who are seen to be doing very
- well thank you is that right Kaiser base in California hydrobromic hazard Permanente has tended to do quite well
- now their plans are mostly available in California in the but they actually double down on their
- efforts and they're going to be expanding their market presence many of the Blue Cross plants around the country
- have been doing okay almost all of them participate and then there are some other smaller jurors that have been
- doing all right so it's not Universal deathbed throughout the country it tends to be focused on certain companies in
- certain areas another point you make in in your blog and I know you've written about these things is that in general
- these insurance companies are doing very well with government programs their profit margins are very good on Medicare
- and Medicaid could you just talk about the the bigger picture of insurance and government programs sure so our private
- insurance industry depends to a large extent on government programs under Medicare about thirty percent of the
- beneficiaries get their coverage through a private insurer and under Medicaid in
- every single state coverage is administered by private companies and that's a huge profitable line of
- business for them so if you take that and subtract out the Obamacare losses they're still doing very well through
- the government if we were to link the Medicaid expansion with the Obamacare exchanges the insurer's would still be
- coming out ahead on the ACA another point that you make is that some of this I think you alluded to this at the
- outset some of this is actually kind of hiccups for a program that's still fairly new and and finding its feet and
- that some of the problems that we're seeing will likely work themselves out A or B could be fixed without a lot of
- difficulty if if certain changes were made whether they can be made politically or not is a separate
- question but could you talk about those two things yeah so some of the changes we could make and this could be done at
- a state level is to sell the insurance companies you can play in the Medicaid expansion if you also play in the
- exchanges so it might mean you're going to make a little less money in total but
- the Medicaid business is worth it and that way we can make sure that they stayed in the exchanges and
- another idea which depends a lot on the outcome of the presidential election is to have what's called the public option
- to have a government program that would compete in the exchanges with the private companies so we know that each
- area would have at least two plans the surviving private plan and the government plan and we could see which
- works best but guarantee that there will always be a fundamental choice and some
- price competition and competition is it fair to say that medicare has a public option which is for a while it was the
- only option but now there's as you say you can go through private insurance so that's kind of a mixed system that
- wasn't it yeah very much so so if you think of traditional Medicare as you said it really is a public option and it
- is close to what's envisioned for the public option under the ACA the private side has been quite profitable quite
- popular almost a third of beneficiaries use it it's really a model for what the ACA would look like if there were a
- public option and then individuals could choose which way they want it to go and
- just a backtrack a little bit I believe that you have written that a lot of the losses that we're seeing were
- anticipated because there's an experience with other programs such as Romneycare that some of them will
- ameliorate they will they will go away as the system matures A or B as I say they could be they could get a fixed
- they could get a patch so I think that's an important point is that this this wasn't wholly unexpected what we're
- seeing right right there were a few mechanisms in place to mitigate the potential losses from this new market
- world one of them was risk Carter's so companies that did better than expected would put some money back into the
- kitties some of them that did worse would get money out of the kitty and the funding for that was blocked in Congress
- so that mechanism hasn't work in fact there's a lawsuit pending right now by insurance companies to try to get back
- some of that money if the idea was that it's hard for them to set premiums now having experience we didn't have a
- market like this prior to 2014 and it takes a few years in insurance to figure out what's what another aspect of this
- is that the losses for the insurer's they say are because the risk pool is sicker more people are getting care than
- they anticipated one of the reasons for that is because Obamacare has been successful in other ways they had
- anticipated when they passed a lot a lot of insurers would drop coverage and they
- would throw a lot of their employees into the risk pool well fewer employers than expected of drop coverage in fact
- employers have been adding coverage rather than subtracting it since Obamacare went into effect so all of
- these healthy working people are not in the exchanges and then we have the young
- people who are staying on their parents policies who are not in the exchanges so
- it's sort of like a balloon you push down one side and it pops up somewhere else we succeed on the employer side in
- the young adult side but it pops up in terms of a sick or risk pool in terms of the overall working of the law therefore
- it doesn't mean it's a failure it means that we need to get the balloon into shape rather than popping it and on the
- young adult side this is I guess the provision that allows children to stay on their parents policies until they're
- 26 whereas it used to be for those children with a college that they were covered until college and then went off
- roughly age 22 so as though as that group moves through and becomes 26 I guess that will start to add more
- healthy people into the pool for those that aren't on an employer right right so presumably if those people do go into
- the risk pool if they don't even employ the provides coverage yes it would increase the healthy contingent in that
- risk pool one other aspect of this though is that the law and the administration of it have been very
- lenient about enforcing the mandate that everyone buy coverage and a lot of people have slipped through the cracks I
- have preferred to pay the penalty or have not paid the penalty and haven't been caught so another way to address
- this is to be more vigilant about making sure that everyone buys in does that require new laws and
- regulations or is it simply enforcing what's on the books most of it could be done by enforcing ones on the books and
- I think Obama has been trying to tread a line if he's too vigilant there's going
- to be pushed back in more political resistance to the law but if he doesn't enforce it then we have the problem that
- we've got we're healthy people stay out of the risk pool so at this point I think if the law is going to thrive the
- balances do you push the other way in terms of being tougher on people who choose to remain uninsured anything else
- we should know about this while we have you in front of us it seems as though as
- I was saying the bad news about Obamacare gets plastered on the headlines we forget that we now have
- somewhere between 10 and 20 million people who now have insurance who didn't before now often those are not great
- policies but it has been a lifesaver for some we have shown that it can be done and going forward we have opportunities
- to fix it and to this day we really don't have a replacement plan a viable replacement plan out there and until we
- do it's either scrapped the guarantee of coverage or go ahead as we have been we
- don't yet have a third option so we will see the politics of the new Congress and
- the new president whether the mindset is to try to fix things or just push over the sand castle and go back to where we
- were thanks for coming in particular very much you
Brief Summary
Robert Field discusses Obamacare's challenges, insurer withdrawals, and potential solutions for improving the health care system.
Key points
- Obamacare's Viability Under Scrutiny. Recent insurer withdrawals raise questions about Obamacare's future, but experts argue it's not doomed.
- Insurance Companies and Government Programs. Despite losses in Obamacare, insurers are thriving in Medicare and Medicaid markets.
Episode highlights
- Obamacare's Viability Under ScrutinyRecent insurer withdrawals raise questions about Obamacare's future, but experts argue it's not doomed.“Obamacare is not unique; this is hardly the first time we’ve tried something like this.”1:55Oct 6, 2016
- Insurance Companies and Government ProgramsDespite losses in Obamacare, insurers are thriving in Medicare and Medicaid markets.“Insurance companies are doing very well with government programs; profit margins are strong.”7:12Oct 6, 2016
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





