Using Humor in the Office: When it Works, When it Backfires

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Humor, when used appropriately, can enhance status and perception of one’s competence in the office, according to Wharton research. More: http://knlg.net/2de8e4o 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. is there a place for humor in the workplace and what are the implications of using humor on perceptions of status
  2. and competence here to talk about the research on this topic are warten Professor Morris weitzer and Brad
  3. bitterly who is a doctoral candidate welcome thank you thank you so tell me about your research our research is on
  4. the relationship between humor and Status humor pervades our daily interactions yet it's been largely
  5. ignored by the prior organizational uh research in this work we look at how it can really significantly shape and
  6. influence the way we perceive others so when we look around we see a lot of we see some examples of humor going really
  7. well and it causing us to perceive the joke teller as being more confident competent and higher in status for
  8. example the night before Dick Costo joined Twitter as the Chief Operating Officer he sent out sent out a tweet
  9. that said first full day as Twitter coo tomorrow step one undermine CEO consolidate power now a year after he
  10. sent out that tweet he ended up becoming CEO of Twitter so we can see examples of
  11. where someone uses humor and they rise to the top of the hierarchy but we also see cases where people attempt to use it
  12. say a really inappropriate joke and just Plum it to the bottom and the focus of our work is is trying to understand what
  13. it is about humor that can cause someone to either rise or fall in status so what are your paper's key
  14. takeaways well one thing we find first as as Brad mentioned humor is risky so sometimes humor can single signal
  15. competence and confidence and increase our status but sometimes if we cross the line so humor can fail because it's
  16. inappropriate because it's just not very funny or because we overdo it so too much in those cases we signal low
  17. competence and that harms our status and in some cases we've seen actually people
  18. get fired because of it but we find is that whether or not the humor goes well or not the use of humor the tempted use
  19. always signals confidence that is I'm a confident person I'm telling a joke but the competence how competent I am really
  20. matters and that's what swings the use of humor from being effective or ineffective so how does someone get that
  21. characteristic of being humorous should they go out and take classes or what should they do well I
  22. think um since it is a really important skill set in our daily lives and a really important managerial skill I
  23. think it could help for people to try to take classes they could do improv classes um that could get them more
  24. familiar more comfortable with delivering a joke I think part of the difficulty to begin with is just trying
  25. to get that confidence that way you feel comfortable delivering it even appropriate
  26. jokes yeah I'd say also to add to that um it's also something we can look for in selection so when we screen people we
  27. might look for somebody that is at least comfortable with humor again we don't want the class clown but for somebody
  28. who's you know fasile with it it can really be a strategic Advantage so what conclusions of any
  29. surprise to you so I'd say one of the conclusions that particularly that I found particularly surprising was in our
  30. second study we found that someone who effectively used humor they were not only perceived to be more confident
  31. competent and higher in status they were even more likely to be elected as a group leader for a subsequent task so
  32. here we see humor not only influencing perceptions of one another but even influencing
  33. Behavior I'd say another important finding in our work is that we're really disentangling Confidence from status in
  34. a lot of Prior work people had found that people who are more confident project confidence are perceived to have
  35. higher status and here we show that with the inappropriate use of humor people can can project confidence but still
  36. come off so badly they actually lose status and what are some practical implications of your
  37. research so some practical implications first of all are that humor can be a really effective tool for increasing
  38. status and that people should be aware of this it compared to other methods of increasing status say um using Goods to
  39. Signal status a joke is free whereas a Louis Vuitton bag is extremely expensive um it can be uh if people realize the
  40. power of it it can be really effective but the other thing to keep in mind is as we said it's really risky and that
  41. people should be aware and in novel situations with unfamiliar others you might not have a good read on how your
  42. joke is going to be received and we even see professionals getting in trouble at
  43. times last month we saw Ellen degenerous send out a picture where she photoshopped herself on on usin bolts
  44. back and even though she meant it as a joke and this is someone that's really built their career on being able to
  45. effectively use appropriate humor there was some backlash for for the picture that we should be yeah should be careful
  46. and our work identifies the use of humor as something really important that is humor influences the hierarchies within
  47. our groups at work and at home and here rather than being some an inary or Superfluous Behavior we're arguing that
  48. humor should be taken seriously in so far as it can really help us navigate our social interactions and and
  49. profoundly influence our perception of of where we fit in in a hierarchy so what sets your research
  50. apart from other work in this area so one way that we set ourselves apart is we're the first to really
  51. experimentally manipulate humor to study how it influences uh status so we we ran a series of
  52. experiments where we presented uh participants with a situation where they were faced with an individual that
  53. either gave a serious comment or a joke and we found we were able to establish causality between humor and confidence
  54. confidence and Status the other area where we set ourselves apart is that we demonstrate that although confidence
  55. really does help us in our daily lives it's really good to be confident saying an inappropriate joke is such a strong
  56. signal of lower intelligence and lower skill it overpowers any of the benefits of confidence and causes a person to
  57. lose status so what will you do next as a followup to This research well we have an active program
  58. looking at humor in some other contexts like in negotiations we're also interested how
  59. how powerful we feel influences our inclination to use use humor so for example people who are powerful may be
  60. less inhibited in using humor people who are low in power may feel uncertain about their use of humor and it could be
  61. that we create a cycle where if powerful people are more likely to use humor and
  62. they get better at it and use it more effectively it might maintain a power hierarchy in a way that other things are
  63. sort of you know might might be harder just sort of break so we're going be to think about how how power and humor
  64. really interact [Music]

Brief Summary

Humor in the workplace can boost status but carries risks of misinterpretation and backlash.

Key points

  • The Power of Humor in the Workplace. Research shows humor can elevate perceptions of competence and status, but it's risky.
  • Risks of Humor. Using humor can backfire, leading to perceptions of low competence and even job loss.
  • Cost-Effective Status Signaling. Humor is a free tool for increasing status compared to expensive goods.
  • Humor's Serious Role. Humor profoundly influences social hierarchies and should be taken seriously.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes