Debora Spar on Women's (Impossible) Quest for Perfection

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Read the full story here: http://knlg.net/1iIHcO3

In her book Wonder Women: Sex, Power, and the Quest for Perfection, Barnard College president Debora Spar challenges the hyper-perfect image of "having it all." 📂 Leadership;Human Resources

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Deborah Spar president of Barnard college and author of the book Wonder women sex power and
  2. the Quest for Perfection Deborah thanks for being with us today pleasure thank you so you draw a lot about a lot on
  3. your own experience in the book including the opening scene where you describe the moment that you realized
  4. that you were having it all can you describe that and some of the realizations that stemm from it so this
  5. is one of these really horrible awkward moments that somebody probably shouldn't
  6. put in a book but I I did nevertheless and and the book starts with this um rather sad moment when I'm in the ladi's
  7. restroom at LaGuardia Airport rushing to catch a plane and using a breast pump in
  8. the stall and it really was that moment where light bulb went off and and I you know realized you know somewhat
  9. ironically that this was having it all this was what it was actually like to have a family and be a mom and have a
  10. career and be a working woman and you know I realized that growing up when I imagined My Life as a working as a
  11. working woman this was not the image I had and yet this was the image that I was living and one of the things that's
  12. been interesting to me is um all of my male friends who've read the book uh particularly when they read it in draft
  13. form said oh please don't include this scene because it's just too embarrassing and yet every woman who's read the book
  14. says I was there and I think there there is something about these horrible breast
  15. pumps that it it it is actually something that by almost by definition every working mother has to encounter
  16. and she encounters it at a at had a very vulnerable moment in her life and in her
  17. career because it it is these moments when you when you realize that you're juggling and it's
  18. hard because you do say I guess one of the other things you say in the book is that the feminine ideal that you were
  19. just talking about that you saw when you were growing up was the Charly girl in the perfume ad who she you know her hair
  20. is perfect she's managing her children she's managing her work and everything's going perfectly how do you think that
  21. cultural image has evolved I mean what do you think is sort of the Charlie girl of today's generation and what are the
  22. impacts that she is have that that image is having well sadly I think we've made
  23. no progress and and May in fact have has have slipped back in some scary ways because I think if you look at the
  24. images today whether they be in magazines and movies on on television shows career women are glamorous uh
  25. they're always beautiful they're actresses they're models um they you know they may have children and you know
  26. we we may see some depiction of of balancing Acts but but they still look like movie stars
  27. and and they still manag to pull off the kids and the career and you know certainly if you read magazines um
  28. you're always getting a very sort of glamorized uh view so every female politician or CEO that does that you do
  29. see in a magazine is always made up and buffed up and and we see a be beautiful uh photo of her in her home which almost
  30. always has been staged by an entire team of interior decorators before they do the the photos so we're still see seeing
  31. these these hyper perfect images of working women and and we're also seeing still um these hyper perfect images of
  32. of women as Homemakers you know women who are delighted to be vacuuming their house or doing the laundry so sadly I
  33. mean we we don't we actually see fewer of the Roseanne bars if you will the women really struggling um with working
  34. life so I I wish there were more progress in this area but I don't see much MH and I was also um when I was
  35. reading the book I was remembering a college friend of mine recently had a baby and she remarked I think it was on
  36. Facebook that you know multiple people after she had her baby said oh are you going to stay home and when she said
  37. that she didn't plan to they were saying oh I'm just you know I'm amazed that you
  38. can juggle it all and that you're doing that and then nobody asked her husband either of those questions and it kind of
  39. made me wonder like what to what degree these constant discussions of can we have it all are we having it all how
  40. much are they actually perpetuating the problem well I hate the phrase having it
  41. all it's it's a hor phrase I don't know who created it but we we need to banish it from our vocabulary because it sets
  42. an expectation that is fundamentally impossible no one has it all and if the standard is all then by by definition
  43. we're we're we're all going to fall be below it we're all going to fail and it's also deeply gendered because when's
  44. the last time you saw anyone asking a man whether he has it all you know we just don't do that and and that's really
  45. this this um this new subtle but but very dangerous double standard that I talk about in the book that you know
  46. even in very casual conversation we make very different assumptions about how men
  47. will be parents and how women will be parents and they do perpetuate not only the stereotypes but they perpetuate a
  48. guilt because your friend probably is already starting to feel some levels of guilt you know maybe I should be staying
  49. home um maybe they think I'm Wonder Woman and I'm actually not whereas her male husband just is sort of getting on
  50. with his life without these added levels of complexity mhm and yet I mean there has been a lot of talk in the past year
  51. or so um first of all stemming from the article written by anarie Slaughter arguing kind of that institutions have
  52. put a lot of roadblocks in the way for women in terms of rising up the ranks and then also from the leanin book by
  53. Cheryl sanberg saying that you know women sometimes are maybe creating their own roadblocks in some ways I mean what
  54. do you where do you fall in that well I between those two books I fall smack in the messy middle um because because I I
  55. think the issues that women face are partly of their own making and partly of societal making but are mostly just
  56. complicated and um that's not a need answer but I think it's the accurate answer and if you think about this
  57. historically we had the same social structures for hundreds if not thousands of years and they essentially worked you
  58. know the man's job was to have a job and earn money and provide for his family and the woman's job was to bear children
  59. uh be faithful to the man and take care of the home in Marxist terms it was a perfect division of labor we turned this
  60. division of labor upside down for all the right reasons to provide women with equality and opportunity and and
  61. Liberation but we haven't really come up with a workable substitute for it and the work of the home the work of of
  62. child care has not gone away and so we really are left with quite a complicated situation and I think it would it's
  63. actually unrealistic to believe we would have solved it in just two generations which is what we have so I think now we
  64. start and we need to have men being part of this conversation we need to start conceiving of substitutes of new social
  65. structures and they won't be quite so simple as women trying harder because that doesn't address the problem and I
  66. wish they could be as simple as saying let's have better State subsidized child care but I don't think that's going to
  67. happen instead I think we need to change our expectations not that women can't be
  68. totally ambitious or competitive but they have to realize that all is a bad idea um men need to come up with new
  69. models of fatherhood and I think we're starting to get there but men face stereotypes as well you know we still
  70. don't have a great and if think about media where's the media hero of the the great dad who's also running a
  71. corporation you know we W with a working wife in anything that seems even vaguely
  72. realistic we need to change how our Public Schools function so that they make they make it easier for working
  73. parents we need to change how our organizations treat parents um so so it's it's a messy set of solutions I
  74. think we can get there um but I think we have to realize that there's nothing simple about this we are going through a
  75. major revolution in social structure and there are no easy solutions during revolutionary times now A lot of I mean
  76. at least a lot of the conversation is in the media at least or maybe in what you
  77. know people are hearing about in the mainstream is being you know it's coming from Academia where you are or where em
  78. Slaughter is or was or it's coming from maybe the CEO's office or the you know one of the
  79. executive office where Cheryl Samberg is so what is that I mean what does that mean for I mean like low-income women or
  80. middle income women I mean is it easy to tell how can you tell a low-income woman
  81. that she needs to relax when it might be very hard for her to relax when she's doing it all I I think um this is a
  82. really important question and I don't think we spend enough time sort of being honest about this question I think part
  83. of it is that all women face certain issues that cut across race and socioeconomic status and age and I think
  84. that's the issue of expectations so a poor woman of color who's a single mom faces massive expectations you know far
  85. greater than the ones I face you know she still is supposed to look look pretty and be sexually attractive and
  86. take care of her kids and bring home money and do it on her own so the expectations cut across but the workplac
  87. um environments and the workplace problems are quite different and I think we have to be honest in saying the kinds
  88. of things will work for women who are trying to become CEOs are very different from the women who are working 40-hour a
  89. week Blue Collar jobs they both have problems but they're very different problems for the blue collar pink collar
  90. Workforce um we have to think about pay Equity we have to think about uh more flexible and more generous maternity
  91. leaves we have to think about um cheaper and more accessible child care for the women who are in the higher paid um uh
  92. sort of hoping to be CEO or or more corporate jobs the issues there are less about maternity leave
  93. and more about balance and remaining competitive in the workplace the issues there are more about whether or not
  94. women can take time off and then come back into the workforce um the issues are about embedded sexism in terms of
  95. how people are promoted through the ranks so I think there's a certain political correctness and we in which we
  96. try to lump all women together and I I think that's actually blinding us to the fact that we we really need to think a
  97. little bit more sectorally about what will help women um and also of minorities who face some of these same
  98. uh obstacles in different different sectors of the workforce I mean I definitely feel that there has been some
  99. admission in these discussions you that there are some professions that are more
  100. conducive to say having you know achieving that work like a fairly good work life balance than others I guess I
  101. wonder I mean is that okay I mean is it okay that maybe banking isn't one of them or should there be changes to make
  102. it so it would be or is there is that just not reality I think part of it is not reality I mean I think if if you're
  103. talking about running anything whether it be a bank a hospital a television station a university these are not
  104. 40-hour flexible Work Week jobs you know if you're running an organization it's a
  105. 247 job that doesn't mean women can't do those jobs but it means that the women who do do those jobs or aspire to those
  106. jobs have to um either not have children or have Partners who pick up the burden
  107. of the child care or have parents or in-laws who are very deeply involved in the child care or who manage to have
  108. their children very early in life and then move into those jobs so I think women can do them but I think we need to
  109. be we need to be honest that there are certain kinds of jobs that will never be part-time Flex time easily manageable I
  110. also think that it's good to be honest and particularly in talking to young women and young men that if they if they
  111. really are committed to having an active enjoyable professional career and a working spouse and a couple of kids that
  112. there are some professions or some Fields within professions that will give them that flexibility and I don't see
  113. that as as stepping back or leaning out or opting out or whatever verb you want to use I see it as just being practical
  114. um you know in my own case I was ready to go into the Foreign Service I had gotten in I was ready to go um and then
  115. something in the back of my mind just sort of triggered the thought that gee you know the it's going to be harder to
  116. have a family and a husband in the Foreign Service and I don't know that I ever sort of sat down and worked out the
  117. math but I went into Academia instead um which has given me uh a lot of flexibility and a lot of control over my
  118. own productivity now what would you say I mean one of your pieces of advice to wom
  119. in the book is that they kind of should relax and realize that the only Wonder Woman is flying around in the invisible
  120. plane somewhere that's right and Magic bracelets right and to sort of focus on what work instead of trying to have it
  121. all but I guess I would think I mean I think I know too that sometimes that's a lot easier said and done I mean how what
  122. are some ways that how can we really divorce ourselves from kind of this need to be everything to everyone because I
  123. really do think it is kind of instilled in us very early on like you said it is deeply instilled although I think there
  124. is a moment right now that that that these conversations are occurring these books are coming out and I think they're
  125. healthy and I think you know I'm seeing myself and I'm seeing other people sort of catching
  126. ourselves um from falling into sort of saying and believing silly things like the things you were talking about what
  127. people are saying to your friend oh you you know I don't know how you how you do
  128. it all that's a silly thing to say to somebody Nobody Does it all um like feeling compelled you know to constantly
  129. dress up when you're going out to have coffee with your friends um like constantly feeling that the house has to
  130. be perfect um constantly feeling that you have to bake cookies every single time for this for the school bake sale
  131. so I think I think you know I don't mean to trivialize it but I think every little step we can take to sort of lower
  132. the the stress level and be more realistic I I think it's very important for women who are in positions of some
  133. prominence to be more honest about the trade-offs they've made about the mistakes they've made about the hard
  134. times they have you know if we're all out there selling our perfect lives we're we're really just perpetuating a
  135. myth um for the next generation of women and that kind of makes me wonder like I
  136. wonder how much do you think maybe social media has almost perpetuated that because it's sort of one of those things
  137. that you see as everybody's out to kind of create their brand on that no matter what it's horrible I mean I you know I I
  138. don't spend that much time on social media but I'm hearing more and more from younger women that social media is not
  139. only perpetuating these these stereotypes but is exacerbating them because you know nobody puts ugly photos
  140. on their Facebook page you know everybody puts themselves doing something wonderful looking beautiful
  141. with with glamorous people and jam from scratch exactly exactly table yeah you know and
  142. this is this is you I think people realize that it's perpetuating all of these bad things but it it it really is
  143. I think sort of a dangerous slope we're we're running off here now one thing I thought was interesting in the book is I
  144. mean you're really upfront about basically how you've kind of fallen into some of this stuff about how you know
  145. you are just as guilty of this as maybe the rest of us are how important was it for you to be that honest in the book I
  146. mean to go through your beauty regimen I mean to write about these things and just be very
  147. out there with you know I'm I'm doing this too this is happening too um you I've never written a book like this
  148. before I'm I'm a old school academic I've written serious uh non-fiction academic books so this was really tough
  149. um to get up the nerve to write but but there was an interesting thing that happened to me a number of years ago in
  150. the um the Wall Street Journal asked College presidents to write their own admissions
  151. essays and I whipped out something I had written in just a horrible moment several years earlier when I was having
  152. one of these terrible days where my husband was out of town and my kids were sick and the cat brought home a half
  153. dead chipmunk it was just a horrible day but I wrote about it and what was so interesting to me was I got an
  154. overwhelming response to this silly little essay because it struck a cord with women and I was bombarded with
  155. women saying oh my God I'm so glad you described my day and I actually realized that there was a power in telling these
  156. you know goofy crazy messy stories from my life and so I started experimenting with that that mode of Storytelling in
  157. the book and it did it did I think it was therapy for me first of all to sort of put some of this stuff on paper but
  158. but I think it it worked at some level and I think it what I've heard from many readers of the book is that it sort of
  159. validated some of their own struggles and um and that's been that's been a good thing for me to hear it was it was
  160. scary to put some of this stuff out there but I think what I'm what I'm what I began to understand when I was writing
  161. and and have definitely understood since the book's coming out is that everybody
  162. has these stories everybody has the breast pump everybody has the moments when they're ready to kill their husband
  163. and their hair is horrible and they're you know blowing the presentation cuz their kid had the croo last night and I
  164. think the more we can get these stories out there without turning this into you know a you know a massive you know SOB
  165. sobbing event it just normalizes um the image of Wonder Woman which is which is a much better place uh to be than
  166. perpetuating this myth of perfection great Deborah thank you so much for being with us today it's been great
  167. thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Deborah Spar discusses the challenges of modern motherhood and societal expectations in her book, "Wonder Women."

Key points

  • The Reality of Working Mothers. Deborah shares her personal experience of motherhood and career, highlighting the struggles of working women.
  • Deborah Spar on 'Having It All'. Deborah Spar challenges the notion of 'having it all' for women, emphasizing the unrealistic expectations it creates.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes