How J.D. Power III Transformed Auto Industry

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1hnLn1t

In 1968, J.D. Power III took the radical step of soliciting customer feedback about cars through consumer surveys. In a recent interview, Power discussed the company's origins with Wharton's John Paul MacDuffie. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. john paul mcduffie from the management department at the wharton school i'm here with
  2. jd power the third or j david power also known to his friends and everyone else as dave
  3. power he has been our special guest at a conference of the mac institute for management innovation on the theme
  4. of disruptive technologies what happens when they meet tightly integrated systems dave
  5. brought his own disruptive impact to the auto industry through the company he ran that bears his name
  6. which delivered to the public reports on the quality of automobiles publicly and with the best and the worst
  7. identified so i'm here to talk to dave about his career based on a new book that has been
  8. published about him so dave welcome to wharton thank you john paul so the career that you've had started with
  9. a number of experiences uh after you graduated from wharton i forgot to mention your wharton grad
  10. yes and then you started your own firm so it's it's a it's almost a modern uh career path when i think about what
  11. my students say they say i want to work for a while and then i want to start my own business so
  12. tell us some of the things that really brought you to that decision you graduated from wharton and you decided
  13. to go to the auto industry why was that because 14 of all uh jobs in the united states in
  14. the 50s were due to the automobile industry and i thought that gave me plenty of chance to
  15. make of a name for myself in that industry now you you went to ford but uh they they they didn't put you in the
  16. automotive division right off tell us about that i was a marketing major and they put me into finance
  17. so-called training program which was on-the-job training and i learned a hell of a lot it was uh
  18. just uh an industry the tractor industry was uh starting to go downhill fast because of
  19. the mechanization of the farms with bigger equipment the little tractors no longer
  20. had a place and you were doing auditing so you got to look at how the dealership
  21. system worked which again wasn't what you expected but uh probably had an impact because you ended
  22. up studying dealers the rest of your career yes i audited the dealers after a sales contest
  23. i arrived just after the contest was over and they suspected that they were getting credit
  24. for vehicles that tractors or implements that they hadn't sold yet and we had to go around and cross-check
  25. them that was an experience that gave me uh really uh hands-on uh reactions of people when they get caught
  26. sure the uh the next step for you was out of ford and into the market research business for a while so
  27. tell us tell us about what you learned from that experience well i i wanted to get out of
  28. finance and ford wouldn't transfer me so i ended up with marplan the market research arm of mccann
  29. ericsson and they had just won the buick and gmc account okay and so we started doing a
  30. lot of research for them market research and you learned a few things about how market research was done that you didn't
  31. necessarily like right right i had a situation where i was representing buick division
  32. in this meeting they were they had a big project million and a half dollars at that time
  33. was huge yeah and we were uh told to measure the effective effectiveness of the advertising of
  34. all of the general motors divisions so we had to create a questionnaire to do it and
  35. the first day we got to question 1a through 1b at lunch and then came back and it was we didn't even
  36. reach question 2. wow we had about 40 people in the room trying to agree on the way the question
  37. should be so the customer really controlled very tightly what data could even be
  38. collected yes and and and that data came back just to that customer yes yes it was uh uh
  39. if you did work for one car company you had to remain captive to that you couldn't work with
  40. any other car company the same way it was with the advertising company advertising
  41. so i uh you know i i know that that became a important principle for your business
  42. that you would you would be independent and and and not be uh be captive in that way
  43. uh you worked for mccullough company that made chainsaws uh that is a very interesting part of
  44. that experience which i just taught you about listening to the customer yes we've when i
  45. was in mar plan in los angeles we conducted a study for their client which was mcculloch and it was interesting because
  46. what i found is that they were still doing their forecasting based on the number of trees that were going to be
  47. cut down in the pacific northwest and the uh trees in the southeast uh the pine trees that uh were made pulp
  48. yeah and uh they forgot about the casual user that was just the family uh chainsaw and the
  49. trees trees don't buy the the home version of the chainsaw right and we opened up a whole new uh
  50. view of what they had to do and the they after i finished the study they asked the officials at mccain
  51. erickson if they could offer me a job as director of corporate planning and since they were the client
  52. they said okay and that's how i got to uh be an employee of mcculloch my colleague and i remember uh
  53. from the book that another thing you learned is that the they basically were applying the same
  54. standards they apply to their professional chainsaws to the home equipment so it was
  55. built to operate 200 hours a year and these folks were probably only using it five or six five or six hours
  56. yes completely over engineered you might have seen that a few times in the auto industry too
  57. yes so sometime around there some friends came to visit and you decided to start your own firm so tell
  58. us about that yes my classmate at wharton came into town from rochester new york
  59. with two other young fellows all three of them had their mbas and were going out to start a new company this is
  60. in 1968 very early 68 and they uh said that they had quit their jobs and they all had
  61. good jobs uh general electric uh um oh kodak kovacs and xerox and i said what are you doing
  62. and he said we're going to measure the meters at homes uh via satellite and this is back in 68 we
  63. only had one or two satellites up there then and i said that's crazy and they said well if we don't make it
  64. we'll get another job and i thought about it and i went home and talked to my wife about it and she said
  65. you should start your own company so great that's how we did it yeah and your wife was an
  66. important partner in the business from the start right and uh we had child labor
  67. rights they'll never let me down now that's right it's a wonderful uh image from the book of as the surveys
  68. are being sent out to the to the consumers yeah your four kids are taping carefully taping the shiny
  69. quarter on each one to make it's that extra bit of incentive to get the response face up right
  70. yes the head had to be square i'm sure yeah and we got perhaps the first uh double-sided scotch tape ah which was
  71. important too yeah exactly speeded up the process it did yeah so uh you of course started with direct
  72. mail surveys you have with the auto industry uh this resource which not every country
  73. has which is uh this third party rl poke which which registers every new vehicle and uh you i heard you say
  74. something about the response rate you got it it something that would amaze most market researchers
  75. these days first few surveys that we did we got close to 50 percent response rate
  76. and it ran uh 30 to 50 percent uh consistently because people wanted to talk about
  77. their cars yeah some of them sent back uh handwritten notes and copies of invoices and with circles on
  78. them and yes they were so wrapped up about that we collected those about 10 of them uh included something
  79. like that even photographs of the paint fading or the trunk lid leaking and so we would send them
  80. on to the manufacturer as we told them in our cover letter that we would do that
  81. and we lost sight of what the manufacturers did with them some of them got more than
  82. others had you already resolved to publicly disclose the data on all the manufacturers
  83. with the no not the surveys not not at that time and it was supposed to be confidential okay
  84. but uh when we did the mazda rotary engine survey we found a problem with it the first
  85. uh 2000 buyers and um the o-ring was uh failing at uh once it hit 30 000 miles and the o-ring kept the
  86. cooling system from leaking out or leaking into the engine and it just uh started failing and
  87. they'd have to take the whole engine out of the car to replace it wow so yeah this was the this was the wankel
  88. engine which was greeted as quite innovation and it was also saved improved gas gas mileage and one of the
  89. car companies that subscribed to it the survey results released it to the wall street journal
  90. ah not you no but a competitor basically we had to uh they called me first and we
  91. um said how did you get a hold of it and the editor said we have our sources and it was from detroit so i knew it was
  92. one of the big three they uh really said they were going to do an article and i said well
  93. i'd like you to have the benefit of my balanced press release on this and he said okay get it to us right away
  94. at the at the moment there was no such press release right but you set out to write it immediately
  95. i sat sat down and immediately wrote it on a pad and we had to find a way of getting
  96. it right to detroit yeah and we ended up finding somebody with a telex machine in the gals center and we were on
  97. the front page sure the following day and uh that's when you learn the the power of the press
  98. essentially to sort of amplify your data and and get the message across it went viral and we were in uh just
  99. about every newspaper radio and tv station yeah uh for a week yep so looking at the present day and at the future a
  100. bit uh let me ask you two questions one is about new technologies so uh often executives and engineers in the
  101. auto companies say you know if we're slow with new technologies the customers complain
  102. because they want the new functionality but if we put it in and it doesn't work perfectly the first
  103. time or doesn't work perfectly every time or we have trouble learning it then then they're really grumpy about it
  104. and ford is uh in the news these days for uh quality complaints about sync and myford touch
  105. mercedes had the issue with the s-class it's it's a repeated story and it would show
  106. up in your surveys of course so what's what's your what are your thoughts on the the challenges
  107. from both the automaker and the consumer side of bringing this new technology in i think
  108. there's about um five or ten percent buyers want that advanced information okay the 90 that don't
  109. are the ones who complain so do you think the automakers are too responsive to those lead
  110. lead users yes uh-huh so okay so they get out ahead of themselves i guess another issue is that each
  111. company really does their own thing right so there's there's there's virtually no standards for these
  112. things as we see in computers or and multiple car house sold right now very common yeah they have different
  113. brands and they have to adapt to the electronics in the particular car they're driving and who wants to learn
  114. who wants to learn three different systems yes yeah no it's a it's an industry that's always been resistant to
  115. standardizing at the industry level they wanna control it handheld that they use all the time when they get
  116. in the car that's better than sure using what at least now yeah than what is in the
  117. car yeah yeah um i know people say sometimes that the auto companies missed a chance to get
  118. people using car phones because they were slow to install them but if you imagine once you got a
  119. physically installed car phone and how slow how fast the technology moved and how
  120. infrequently you replace your car you can imagine how quickly that car phone would have seemed very
  121. very clunky yes let me ask you about the future of dealers again remembering that
  122. that uh dealers have been an important part of your business right along uh you stirred some controversy uh
  123. in the early 2000s with a prediction that uh you know the traditional dealership
  124. might its days might be numbered there was a threat from uh more of a big box model
  125. or a large mega dealer model there might be threats from other kinds of things like direct sales through the internet
  126. um tell us a little bit about uh will it cause controversy and what you think now
  127. about a decade later caused quite a bit of controversy and uh i think it was the
  128. idea that uh well i know it was because they cut out my introduction part explaining why i was saying oh that
  129. was going on and it they didn't sound good i was going uh at the end i said if they
  130. uh didn't like uh what i was saying they should talk to walmart and that set a button off uh
  131. and uh the dealers were all upset yeah as you look at what's changed in the last 10 years do you do you still
  132. predict a a threatened future for the traditional auto dealer or have they adapted
  133. in in good ways well they're adapting in one way that is good i guess for the dealers is they're
  134. consolidating there were 50 000 dealers in 1950 okay franchise new car dealers uh today there's 17 000
  135. wow and so about a third and obviously much higher sales and autonation and uh group one and other consolidators
  136. uh are taking up uh several thousand dealers into their fold and they aren't truly dealers any longer
  137. when they do that sure what about the whole issue of direct sales uh from the manufacturer to the customer
  138. through the internet that's there are these state laws that mostly prohibit that yes
  139. do you see those going away or is the dealer bobby there are two i i think the lobbying is
  140. very difficult for dealers today what has happened is the consumer has more information than the dealer
  141. yeah yeah and they control the market yeah and then it's going to be determined by them
  142. and it's going to be determined uh what the manufacturers have to build to remain
  143. competitive it's the dealer in charge this change has happened over the last 10 years
  144. and it's only going to get more and they get instant information it's amazing the customer yeah and they
  145. don't want to sit down and haggle the price or what have you they want it done so that they're going
  146. to demand change do you support the efforts of tesla's ceo elon musk to uh to break those laws and get uh the
  147. possibility of direct sales i know he's challenged the law in texas and in new york state i um i believe
  148. that uh the laws are not reasonable and uh they were developed in the 1950s when
  149. there were a lot of dealers and it was just to give the dealers some say with the manufacturers
  150. who were dictating everything and so they got that covered and now their their value to the whole operation of
  151. selling the vehicles is uh diminished and uh now they're saying they should still be
  152. in force yeah and i don't think they're going to be able to hold up on it and so
  153. we see more changes coming down the route okay my last question then uh another uh look into the crystal ball uh at the
  154. conference today we are hearing about uh autonomous vehicles and uh the you know the self-driving car
  155. uh is is this uh a trend that you think consumers will want like you say maybe consumers don't
  156. always want this latest functionality but there's a lot of claims about better safety of course as well as some
  157. of the convenience of not having to to give as much attention to driving yeah well i i think that
  158. maybe for the average driver they'll accept it but it takes the fun out of driving and
  159. that's a story for the automotive enthusiast yes uh but uh i think it's it's going to
  160. be in the our future yeah and uh you'll still perhaps be able to override the yes i'm sure that's right you'll be able
  161. to speed limit and so forth one of our speakers uh got a laugh when he said most male drivers say that they would
  162. like a system like that for their wife and their kids but not for them so well thank you very much dave it's a
  163. great pleasure to have you here to have a chance to talk to you and uh again your book was a marvelous read
  164. about a a a fascinating career thank you you

Brief Summary

J. David Power discusses his career and insights on disruptive technologies in the auto industry with John Paul McDuffie.

Key points

  • Disruptive Technologies Conference. Dave Power discusses his impact on the auto industry and his career journey.
  • Starting a New Company. Inspired by friends, Dave shares how he decided to start his own firm in 1968.
  • The Mazda Rotary Engine Issue. Dave reveals a major flaw in the Mazda rotary engine that led to significant media attention.
  • The Future of Auto Dealers. Dave discusses the evolving role of auto dealers and the impact of direct sales.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes