What's Up with the Stock Market?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1f8GyIA

After delivering an extraordinary 32% return in 2013, the U.S. stock market has had a shaky start in the New Year. But Wharton finance professor Jeremy Siegel says corporate earnings are strong and the U.S. economy is likely to grow at a healthy rate in 2014. Siegel say stocks are not overpriced relative to earnings, but bonds are a risky play as interest rates rise. 📂 Finance & Accounting;Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Jeff Brown for knowledge at Wharton and today once again we have Wharton Finance Professor Jeremy seagull
  2. with us for a few minutes and thank you again for being with us happy to be here
  3. Jeff well it's late January and everybody's getting their statements year end statements from 2013 and seeing
  4. the stupendous gains they made in the stock market getting ready to pay taxes on them and now all of a sudden we seem
  5. to be falling off a cliff the uh S&P 500's down about 3% uh year-to date after being up 32% last year what is
  6. going on well it shows you how used to gains we are after up 32% we call down 3% off a
  7. cliff I I regard it as a little bump uh uh no bull market goes up in a straight line I mean OB obviously I mean uh we
  8. haven't had a correction for which is defined as a 10% uh decline in the market for uh you know
  9. at least two years which is pretty remarkable now I don't think this current reaction is going to move that
  10. far but uh again um bull markets in fact many many technicians say it's healthy for a bull market to have this
  11. correction because it sort of blows off the excess bullishness that uh sometimes
  12. a company's Rising prices well what has triggered this now why now not a month ago or a month from now well I mean
  13. ostensibly it was the Emerging Markets you know people are saying uh again the tapering um you know the truth is of
  14. course was the tapering was announced in December so if markets are at least even
  15. partially efficient why is it reacting four weeks later to something that we knew in December uh you know we had a
  16. very disappointing labor market report uh uh earnings are coming in so so so uh actually the percentage that our
  17. beating earnings uh at least at this point are is actually a little bit more than average but the beat is a little
  18. less and some of the forward guidance isn't too good that's been a little disappointing because we know that the
  19. second half of 2013 had better economic growth in uh the first half so uh we many of us thought that maybe the fourth
  20. quarter would surprise us more on the upside but it's still early let's let's wait until we get more data on that so
  21. in some ways it just looks like people are looking for an excuse to sell and take some of those immense profits from
  22. last year you know the people talked about the bullishness in the market one of the indicators that I look at that
  23. monitors Market sentiment uh is called investors intelligence which for 50 years has been looking at bulls and
  24. bears and indeed my my indic has reached 20year highs uh uh just recently right after January when you know everyone's
  25. saying hey there's nothing in the way of this bowar you gotta get a little wor when when we uh we get to that
  26. particular Point uh because historically uh bull markets have climbed the wall of
  27. worry there's always oh I'm worried about this I'm worried about this that's one reason I'm out of the market um I
  28. don't think this bull market is over I still think there's there's there's room to go one of the things I'm curious
  29. about is that that we're beginning the tax season and a lot of people of course are sitting on big gains from last year
  30. I'm curious is is Raising cash to pay your taxes factor in this well only if they sold remember uh
  31. so uh if if they didn't sell one of the nice things about capital gains is you you can let them ride until you want to
  32. so it has to do with how much of that was was sold I I I don't think so uh you know taxes are really due in April of
  33. course if you pay quarterly you had to come up already with that January uh payment so I think it's more of of just
  34. the the fact that it got a little bit overbought a little bit over optimistic and they're using the bump of the
  35. problems in Argentina the problems in Venezuela turkey I think as more of an excuse uh than anything to uh to to take
  36. some profits when you uh open the hood and look inside at things like the PE Ratio and and and other gauges that
  37. you'd like what do you see okay what what I see is that our traditional gauge which is using the S&P 500 earnings
  38. against its level um is very close to its historical average very close to the average of the post World War II period
  39. around 16 16 and a half yes on the basis of of 2013 earnings we're at around 17 right now although it's come down a
  40. little bit in terms of that it's a little bit above but it's been my thesis for more than a year now that uh this
  41. Market is going to go above its historical mean and the reason for that is the low interest rates with so little
  42. competition from other asset classes in my opinion that would lead to a somewhat
  43. higher valuation so to me I think this bull market is going to 18 to 19 times earnings which is another probably 10
  44. 12% in in prices higher than they are today higher than they are today yes by when the end of the year well I I say
  45. that uh of course it's it's a fool whoever predicts short run in the market uh again you know we could go even much
  46. higher I remember on one program you know people say well you know I said we could go to 20,000 everyone said oh Dr Z
  47. are you predicting 20,000 no that would be overpriced unless we have Gang Busters economy in 2014 and 15 but uh we
  48. all know that uh you know stocks are often in a range of 20 25% of fair value and sometimes they even get outside of
  49. that range so I think fair value on the Dow is something like 18,000 18,500 uh but obviously uh again uh it
  50. doesn't move in a straight line to to those levels you mentioned uh tapering and of course this debate over tapering
  51. has been going on since May I believe when is it going to start first are we uh placing our bets now or later is it
  52. built into the market so on and so forth but now it has has begun and I'm wondering uh what effect you see there
  53. the the argument was that all of this money from the FED is propping up stocks uh take it away stocks will fall I have
  54. maintained that the biggest myth of the market in 2013 was that the bull market the 30%
  55. plus gain was all due to Fed pumping in uh uh money into the economy uh QE in other words I said hey guys you
  56. know on the basis of earnings alone and valuation relative to Alternatives I can
  57. completely uh attribute this rise in prices I don't need QE I think QE has I mean it certainly doesn't hurt I'm not
  58. going to say it hurts but I think it's way too overemphasizes its contribution to the
  59. great bull market that we've seen over the last uh two years years it really is the fading of the fears of another
  60. collapse that 2008 2009 brought on as the years go on we see these risk premiums go down oh you know there isn't
  61. going to be a currency collapse this municiple collapse a commercial mortgage collapse I all of a sudden people are
  62. saying you know the economy may not be great but I don't have those Primal fears that so dominated the market 2009
  63. 10 and 11 and the FEDS plan to reduce its Bond buying program is a pretty slow process and then uh it will be well done
  64. before they get around actually raising short-term interest rates are you comfortable with the pace at which these
  65. things are I am and even that pace isn't in uh isn't in stone I expect them to continue on the1
  66. billion uh uh tapering uh at uh at this week's meeting um despite the bad employment report report that we
  67. had however let me let me say if the markets go down further and we get some um further poor data surprisingly low
  68. data uh I would say that there's a very good chance at the March meeting now that that is if this occurs for them to
  69. Halt the tapering uh and I don't expect that to happen I I think we're going to see a re
  70. acceleration of the recovery but but again no one should think that uh you know this pace is in stone it isn't um
  71. uh uh it can respond any way to what actually happens in the economy and we're just days away from the handoff
  72. from Ben bernacki to Janet Yellen is that a significant event it it is for them obviously but does it matter to the
  73. markets well I I think the markets have now reconciled themselves uh are are certainly they're factoring that in uh I
  74. I I mean I think Janet Yellen is competent I think she is a very very good choice I do think she's on the
  75. doish side I think there's no question that push comes to shove but she's also a good listener and she's a very smart
  76. woman and she's not and she knows that the FED has a inflation Target and it's not going to violate that inflation
  77. Target by any significant amount so uh again you know she is only just like Bernan and Greenspan before him they are
  78. only one vote of 12 on the open market committee and so there's no veto power uh certainly they they hold sway uh
  79. their argument and their position is certainly important but uh I don't think the bank presidents who have had no
  80. qualms about speaking out when they are concerned about uh uh inflation of or over stimulus uh they they will
  81. certainly have their uh voices uh felt if they think that Yellen is moving too much to the doish side how does the
  82. economy look to you is it getting stronger as it seems to be I still think so despite you know the fact that we you
  83. know again had that uh poor employment report for for uh the last month um in you know December I I think we have a
  84. chance for three and a half% plus even in GDP growth for 2014 um uh again the better markets the
  85. better I think finally the the balance sheets of the consumers with the rise of the housing market the rise of the stock
  86. market has now pretty much repaired itself and that should give a boost to consumer confidence um that could also
  87. boost business Capital spending which has been also very very sluggish uh and with housing moving up to I think over a
  88. million units at an annualized rate on a monthly basis I think that that has the
  89. capability of giving a 3 and a half% or plus economy now again that certainly may not happen and I have been over
  90. optimistic on economic growth over the last two years but I think the stars are better aligned for such a um an
  91. acceleration in this year one of the elements of consumer confidence of course is jobs and whether you think
  92. you're going to lose your job or your chances of getting one if you have you think the job situation is going to
  93. improve well I I think the fear of losing your job has been gone down for five years we've seen the unemployment
  94. go go down from 10% down to 6.7% so uh uh and we have seen net hiring by firms it's always going to be
  95. present um and uh there's there's always firms that are going to be cutting back
  96. but you know 200,000 jobs and in the private sector actually the the job growth that we got um over the last 12
  97. months even with that PO December report uh has been fully as month much as we had in
  98. 2003 four five and six uh before the crisis occurred it's a little bit less than we had in the booming uh you know
  99. uh 2000 uh period 1990s to 200000 period but still the growth has been decent so
  100. I I think the labor Market's going to be fine and that that's the private Market
  101. one of the problems is government government cutbacks have been hurting these overall numbers question about it
  102. I mean this is the first time really ever that we've had a sustained uh actual slightly negative on
  103. average balance of government numbers government was always adding 30 and 40 if it wasn't the federal it was the
  104. state and local uh boosting it I mean Bernan has made that in some of his speeches uh you know again toward the
  105. end of his term saying this recovery given the contraction of government um has actually uh not been
  106. uh that bad and so if we you know assume that government's contraction will slow
  107. we're not going to have the uh uh sequestering that we had before um not quite as severe the movement towards
  108. that I mean it's it's going to stay in place but it's that contraction is going to be gone uh that would neutralize the
  109. government as being a decidedly negative factor uh and let the private sector carry the economy forward
  110. uh unemployment upwards of 6% is the kind of thing that used we used to look at with absolute horror and and I
  111. suppose many of you still do but if you break down the number uh it's not that bad among those with college degrees
  112. it's really people with less than college and less than high school that are making up it's always the truth
  113. that's you know that is always been the case the better educated the much lower the Unemployment uh rate is the Fed now
  114. regards about 5 a half% to be 5 355 to be the long run unemployment rate now if we were talking in the 60s we'd
  115. probably say it's three and a half to four but various factors have raised that over time um uh so I say five and a
  116. half so at 67 we're only we're between one and one and a half percentage points above what the FED thinks is the the
  117. long-term unemployment rate many of the people who Lo who have less education and lost their jobs uh during the crisis
  118. may have lost jobs sooner that they would have lost over the years anyway as things change I'm just I guess really
  119. concerned are they ever going to get those jobs back you know that the job market is
  120. changing it's changing even for some trained people with the rise of Technology being able to substitute uh
  121. for it uh you know the low- skill jobs I don't think are coming back I mean um uh
  122. there's just tooo much too many people around the world and with technology and communication being so easy to bring
  123. that to the four that they can take over those low skill jobs and produce the goods and ship them or even do the
  124. services by uh uh you know remote telephone centers that we have uh in in the less developed countries all sorts
  125. of services are are going to be outsourced so you have to find your Niche about you know what kind there's
  126. always gaps in Services it's always areas where the people who are gaining from the technology want to spend I mean
  127. there's been a restaurant boom people younger people are are enjoying going out I mean these are these are the type
  128. of service areas that are expanding and there and there will be others so again it's a dynamic economy but the old
  129. factory job even with manufacturing stabilizing uh the old manual labor job except maybe in the
  130. healthc care area where people might have to have some you know personal uh uh assistance uh is is probably not
  131. coming back let's switch for a second and look at the bond market and the the of course when interest rates go up
  132. people don't want those older bonds that pay less and so you can lose money on your bonds uh is that something we need
  133. to worry about today and how does that work into an Investor's thinking about asset allocation in a portfol
  134. well think of what happened last year I mean we had a bad Bond Mar Rising interest rates and a really good stock
  135. market now I think this stock market will be good this year not as as good as last year but that was certainly
  136. spectacular I think we can see a 10 to 15% return at the end of this year for stocks I still think you're at big risk
  137. with bonds even though this first two or three weeks have been great for bonds bounced back from just over 3% on the
  138. 10e down to 27 uh with this uh you know a little bit of a pull back on risk the Emerging Market crisis which I think uh
  139. stimulated a little bit of oh my God I remember 1997 maybe you remember Jeff that the Asian crisis remember that
  140. really whacked the market and I think a few of the older Traders and those with a little bit more gray hair like we have
  141. said oh just a minute I hope this isn't the start of that um and I think that that that's causing a little bit of that
  142. anxiety we're seeing in the the market today so uh ending with something practical the investor who has just
  143. finished 2013 with big gains in his stock a portion of his portfolio is thinking now about reallocating
  144. rebalancing as they say should they be looking uh to get back to their original goal or should
  145. they be saying the bond market is a little too scary maybe I won't allocate as much to bonds what do you do I mean I
  146. still don't think bonds are going to be offering really positive return long-term bonds you certain you can get
  147. the interest rate but at interest rates of 3% the price Falls 3% and you've wiped that out I still think it's going
  148. to be negative returns for bonds we know it's zero for money markets not much change going to be this year maybe 2015
  149. a little more but but not this year and your alternative still and if you want income as we've been saying for so long
  150. there are very good dividend paying stocks that are yielding 3 4% there are many dividend mutual funds funds
  151. exchange traded funds Etc that specialize in that and you're going to get that growth because Dividends are
  152. growing 10 to 12 to 14% a year one of the strongest dividend growths we've actually seen Jeff uh and uh in terms of
  153. increases and uh most analysts that I talk to expect it to continue in 2014 so you're basically optimistic
  154. about the economy and basically optimistic about the stock market not too keen on bonds that summarizes it
  155. yeah and that was pretty much 2013 but again always reminding and no bull market goes up in a straight line you
  156. have to get through these uh Corrections that uh will always be part of uh the stock market all right well we'll come
  157. back in a few weeks or a month or so and see uh what's happening then thank you very much thank you jff
  158. [Music]

Brief Summary

Jeremy Siegel analyzes stock market corrections, tapering effects, and economic forecasts for 2014, urging investors to favor dividend stocks over bonds.

Key points

  • Market Corrections Explained. Professor Jeremy Seagull discusses the importance of corrections in bull markets.
  • Optimism for Economic Growth. Seagull expresses optimism for a strong economy in 2014, citing improved consumer confidence.
  • Bonds vs. Stocks. A discussion on the risks of bonds versus the potential of dividend-paying stocks.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes