Corporate Boards Taking the Lead

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1e0KgjF

Lenovo has just announced plans to acquire IBM and Motorola businesses for a total of more than $5 billion. Of the IBM deal, Wharton management professor Michael Useem, co-author of Boards That Lead: When to Take Charge, When to Partner, and When to Stay Out of the Way, says Lenovo's board of directors "has helped that company go from a company we have never heard of 15 years ago to the number one personal computer maker in the world." Useem, who is also director of Wharton's Center for Leadership and Change Management, recently sat down with Wharton lecturer Robert Borghese, a corporate attorney in private practice with offices in New York and Philadelphia, to discuss his new book, co-authored by Ram Charan and Dennis C. Carey. In this interview, Useem explains why monitoring is no longer the only responsibility of the board, where board directors should draw the line in their leadership of organizations and where some companies and boards are getting it right, including Lenovo. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi my name is Bob Bazi and I'm here today with Mike Yim Mike is a professor of management and the director of the
  2. center for leadership and change management here at the Wharton School we're here with Mike to talk about his
  3. new book uh boards that lead which he recently co-authored with ram Chiron and Dennis KY Mike thanks for being with us
  4. today Bob good to be here so Mike what led you to uh write a book on board leadership well Bob uh corporate
  5. governance has been a topic of great interest uh for many people including myself for a number of years and joining
  6. with my colleague Ram shiron who is a very high-end consultant and Dennis kery who's the vice chair of corn Ferry which
  7. is a very large executive Search firm he's worked on many board searches we got into a dialogue on what
  8. exactly is happening in boards these days board rooms and as we thought about our own experience lots of research
  9. evidence coming out uh concluded that uh a good way to rethink what boards do is
  10. to uh take the premise that they have to monitor and they do that pretty well much better after sarbanes Oxley and
  11. Todd Franks these two legislative acts to strengthen the hands of boards of directors gotten pretty good at
  12. monitoring but increasingly directors are also exercising a kind of leadership function in the boardroom and with top
  13. management and as we drew Upon Our experience and um all three of us have been in boardrooms that sort of thing we
  14. uh did inductively conclude that uh good for all of us to rethink what boards do
  15. from not just monitoring which is what they're required to do but to also see boards as helping the company to be
  16. going where it's got to get to called that leadership so Mike give us a little bit
  17. of a historical perspective on the role that boards have played over time and how that role specifically is evolved
  18. over time Beyond just the monitoring function to more of a leadership function if we go way back boards were
  19. aptly described I think by uh again a professional colleague Jay lorch on the faculty of the Harvard Business School
  20. with the title of a very well-known book which was Boards of directors pawns or potentates and he had a bit of a
  21. question mark there but his conclusion was historically 30 40 years ago boards tended to be pawns they had become
  22. passive they were really under the thumb of the chief executive they met uh had a great
  23. lunch together and all went home but with the rise of big institutional investors the California pension fund
  24. Fidelity Black Rock uh these days hedge funds as well uh the pressure coming from
  25. investors for directors to not be pawns to get in there and uh keep Management's
  26. feet to the fire to avoid Mal feance think Enron uh and on the affirmative side to get great growth at a reasonable
  27. degree of risk that boards move from that pawn rle to a much more active monitoring role and we can see that in
  28. all kinds of Statistics we got a bunch of them in the book on the background of directors how boards are organized
  29. virtually all major standard and Po's 500 boards for example now have an independent audit committee an
  30. independent govern governance committee and independent compensation committee independent meaning they're not under
  31. the thumb of the chief executive they actually have that relationship turned around and with that rise especially in
  32. the last 10 to 15 years a more call it more Vigilant monitoring function pushed by the big stockholders out there uh
  33. reinforced by legislation coming out of the early uh part of the last decade after the Enron failure
  34. uh boards in a kind of an unanticipated way and a kind of an almost unplanned way began to exercise more leadership
  35. and what we mean by that is that directors now often coming from Top management positions themselves many
  36. former CEOs for example occupy boardrooms now when they come into a board meeting they are helping the top
  37. executive think through a spin-off an acquisition they're helping a top executive think about how do I develop
  38. top talent here so I got a great replacement uh once my day is up and with all that being said and kind of all
  39. put together in a package we ended up entitling this book boards that lead now implicit in that is boards also monitor
  40. on behalf of stockholders that's the deal set forward by the SEC and the New York Stock Exchange we all want that to
  41. happen but in addition because of this quiet historical and profound transformation we think boards now
  42. increasingly are at the plate helping the company to go where it out to get to substantively that pretty much sums up
  43. with the statement boards that lead so Mike um one of the issues you identify in the book is the tension between
  44. exercising leadership and crossing the line into executive prerogative what advice would you give board members to
  45. make sure that they strike the right balance good way to keep this point in mind is on key issues the board the
  46. directors have to be at the table and they have to be driving the issues so the tenor at the top the commitment to
  47. ethics and integrity the central idea that drives the firm compensation for the top people in all these areas
  48. directors are number one and that's their job that's their calling having said that what is not
  49. their calling in fact not their place to go to at all we put it you know when to
  50. stay out of the way as our phrase for that are the operations that uh a top executive
  51. team are cons is concerned with every day uh getting products into the stores running a supply chain research and
  52. development these are really the prerogatives of top management and not for the board to be concerned with a
  53. good way to keep that point in mind is to remember the challenge of spelling the word banana you've got to know when
  54. to stop when you start spelling that word and in a boardroom you've got to be very self-conscious about knowing where
  55. to stop many companies that we describe and observed for this book have developed devices uh sometimes written
  56. documents here are the issues that have to go to the board and here are the issues that have to stay out of the
  57. boardroom typically it's more formal than that but there are a number of call them governance and management and
  58. Leadership devices that help boards get their leadership function done without micromanaging The Firm okay so if what
  59. we're looking for or boards that lead how can shareholders do a better job of identifying the right type of board
  60. leaders motivating them compensating them things like that well it's a really timely question because we're going into
  61. proxy season as sometimes is called this over the next four or five months is when most companies have their annual
  62. meeting and what of course that means is this is when investors stockholders elect their board of directors and it's
  63. a very timely issue to think about because as you are looking if you're an investor at the slate put forward now to
  64. let's say serve as directors of American Airlines or City Bank or Proctor and Gam
  65. you do want directors who are terrific at appreciating what it takes to deliver total shareholder return stock
  66. appreciation and dividends now there are 100 issues within that that you have to
  67. be very mindful of to ensure that top management delivers value to the stockholders that's job number one as a
  68. director but job number two is to fulfill this leadership obligation and for that uh we recommend
  69. in the book for example that uh investors investment managers those who are most responsible for placing money
  70. in big companies whether at a a college endowment or a big money management firm
  71. like Vanguard or Fidelity that they take a close look at the directors are these
  72. people good at leading Enterprise do they have a background in top management of another large Enterprise do they have
  73. a record of being able to work with others after all a board really is a team of 10 to 12
  74. people and thus making a judgment call as we come into proxy season now new slated directors up for election or
  75. typically reelection really good to take a hard look at who is on that slate can
  76. they monitor can they lead and then the flip side of that in our view that is the great obligation
  77. of the what's usually called the nominations and governance committee within the boardroom to pick people who
  78. keep the feet to the fire of top management who know how to do that but also bring content to the table to help
  79. top management get its job done okay and if the board is leading who's monitoring
  80. the board we all have a boss it's a good way to put it so top management is monitored
  81. by the board the board and we need to strengthen this is ultimately monitored by shareholders after all the board is
  82. elected by stockholders that's the arrangement uh it's a fairly weak electoral system and that as we know
  83. most slates with some exceptions rare exceptions have uh 12 people up for typically reelection for 12 seats and so
  84. if you're nominated you're almost always going to be elected by the stockholders
  85. there are exceptions to that uh having said that big investors that do get more of a
  86. voice when they approach a company they do get their phone calls answered uh have an obligation like
  87. that's the way we put it to uh communicate directly with directors to ask those two tough
  88. questions are you monitoring and are you leading and so in that sense directors ultimately are responsible to the
  89. stockholders and should be that that's that's our free enterprise Arrangement Mike Warren Buffett often
  90. points out that in the tight community of corporate directors comedy the notion that there should be courtesy in the
  91. boardroom toward other directors toward the executives um often prevails the notion that you don't want to rock the
  92. boat that's a powerful force in a boardroom um and sometimes it's one that has to be resisted what advice would you
  93. give board members to you know while at the same time exhibiting comedy also uh asking tough
  94. questions Bob I think to pick up in your phrase there we want both we want civil
  95. behavior in the boardroom of course and typically if you look at the 10 11 or 12
  96. directors in the boardroom uh they've had 20 30 years of experience and working with many people
  97. and they are very effective in working directly and collaboratively having said that if the people in the room already
  98. agree let's say with the chief executive or kind of cow into agreeing with the CEO or with other directors they might
  99. as well not be in the room they are there to bring their own judgment their own experience and in that sense even though
  100. there can be a pressure to Comedy to not say what you really think uh in our observations of how
  101. boards operate increasingly over the last 10 or 15 years a new Norm is developed if comedy prevailed many years
  102. ago back in those Pawn days uh today uh directors look a scance on other directors who don't say much who
  103. don't bring a weighty point of view into the room and uh thus quick summary on that
  104. one Bob is we want again the 10 to 12 people on average that are in that boardroom to bring that monitoring uh
  105. judgment cult uh into the room but also bring their best judgment as a leader of
  106. Enterprise as to what should be done even if others don't agree with that I guess in conclusion Mike can you give us
  107. some examples of boards that have done a good job of executing on their leadership role and maybe some boards
  108. that haven't well here's a board to pick one out some time ago that really made the difference
  109. actually in all of our Lives if we go back to 1996 and 1997 uh Alpha was on its last legs Steve
  110. had gone some years earlier had been kicked out quite a few years earlier and a uh a former chief
  111. executive of DuPont now serving on the Alpa board uh began to ask very tough questions of the chief executive so
  112. think about that non-executive director asking very tough questions of the chief
  113. executive the chief executive then 9697 was I guess I'll put this in a charitable way sanguin about the future
  114. of Apple thought I was doing well but when the non-executive director asked the CFO privately what do you really
  115. think the CFO said we're heading off a cliff they got into the numbers and it was true and so the chief executive
  116. sorry the non-executive director on the board the former CEO of DuPont said we've got a problem he began to ask
  117. around if anybody might want to purchase Apple they approached Dell computer Michael Dell famously said forget it why
  118. don't you just close shop and return the money to your stockholders so the non-executive director uh modestly paid
  119. at that time called up Steve Jobs and says Steve why don't you come back and help us out Steve said no way but this
  120. non-executive director persisted looking for leadership and was ready to help a new leader come in to
  121. turn this company from where it was U kining off a cliff to a different direction finally persuaded Steve to
  122. rejoin the firm when Steve Jobs came back into the company in 97 fully it had a market
  123. value of about $2 billion and when Steve passed away not so long ago he because of the intervention of
  124. the board to pick a great leader and then to work with that leader over some years that firm went from a
  125. two billion market value to a one point more than $700 billion so here for us anyway is an example quite now quite
  126. some time ago of a board that wasn't just there to keep an eye on management to tell them deliver shareholder value
  127. but here was a board and this particular member who took in a very active leadership role to bring that firm back
  128. to health to pick another firm just very briefly here uh was just announced that
  129. uh Lenovo the great Chinese PC maker uh is acquiring for over2 billion doar a major division of
  130. IBM and this in a sense uh is the second such purchase back in ' 05 Lenovo also bought uh a division the
  131. personal computer division of IBM at that point for a little less than $2 billion uh we know that company well
  132. I've talked with uh some of the directors I spent time with the chief executive and unequivocally the board of
  133. Lenovo not just top management has helped that company go from a company we've never heard of 15 years ago to now
  134. the number one personal computer maker in the world so it's to hulet Packard it's top Dell it's
  135. by far number one in China and now it's number one in the world partly because of the great strategic insights of the
  136. people that built the company as Executives but also very importantly because of the leadership that the
  137. directors brought into the company Mike um in the last minute or so one or two points that you'd like to leave us
  138. with m would say number one if you are a director good to think of what you're doing both as a defender of shareholder
  139. value and as a leader of the company if you're an investor good to look at directors do they bring a lot to the
  140. table both to monitor for shareholder value and to lead strategically if you're a top executive who do you want
  141. on your board you want people that can do both and as Executives move into the top ranks coming up through their own
  142. ranks increasingly I believe a quality of their own leadership will be to work extremely well with their board to draw
  143. the best from the board in their own leadership Mike thanks very much thank you Bob
  144. [Music]

Brief Summary

Mike Yim discusses board leadership and governance, emphasizing the balance between monitoring and guiding management.

Key points

  • The Shift in Board Dynamics. The transformation of boards from passive to active leadership roles is explored.
  • Boards That Lead. Mike Yim discusses the evolving role of boards from monitoring to leadership.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes