Diversity at Work: How Diversity in Leadership Improves Boards | Stephanie Creary — Ripple Effect

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton’s Stephanie Creary talks with Kenneth Shropshire about her research into the importance of diverse corporate boards and what companies often get wrong when they go about diversifying them.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 3:37 - The current state of DEI 7:03 - The need for BIPOC board leaders 11:44 - Mitigating risk with diverse boards 14:15 - Do most firms prioritize diversity? 19:17 - Why is board diversity important?

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

In honor of Juneteenth, the Ripple Effect podcast is showcasing a special series of conversations on equity and opportunity, diving deep into the complex issues of racial inequality, bias, and representation within organizations. This special will be led by guest host Kenneth Shropshire, faculty director of Wharton’s Coalition for Equity and Opportunity.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#dei #diversity #inclusion #corporategovernance ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. for a very long time boards were not asked to be representative of the people who they served the the communities in
  2. which they operate or their larger stakeholder base so kind of like the government when the government doesn't
  3. represent the people the government starts making all sorts of decisions that don't always reflect the needs of
  4. all the people welcome to a special edition of the ripple effect I'm Dia Loney in honor of
  5. Juneteenth this month senior advisor to the dean for the Coalition of equity and
  6. opportunity Kenneth Shropshire will be your special guest host in each episode this month Ken and Wharton faculty are
  7. focusing on the critical themes of diversity equity and inclusion we'll be covering a diverse range of topics
  8. bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you could apply to your life and work so get ready to dive into
  9. this special edition of the ripple effect with guest host Ken Shropshire while the topic of diversity Equity
  10. inclusion has so many different facets to it one though is how Corporate boards are thinking about these topics as we
  11. move forward pleasure to be joined by Stephanie Curry who's an assistant professor of management at Thorne school
  12. and as well our friend Ken Shropshire of the Wharton School and Ken let me start
  13. with you because the larger scale the role that the board has in really kind of getting this process set and roll
  14. becomes a very important one doesn't it really does so the board can apply pressure
  15. can move forward regulations or or whatever new standards a company might want but we see a lot of this in a lot
  16. of different areas we might see it in cyber security or whatever else and boards can be silent on this or they can
  17. go full speed ahead and make it their major issue so so I'm anxious to speak with Stephanie about her extensive work
  18. in the space and to see if we can help leaders out there and board members out there on doing better well and as I said
  19. Stephanie has uh just a wealth of of knowledge in this area so I will let you two have your conversation a pleasure to
  20. be joined Stephanie having you back on the show thanks for your time today Stephanie my good friend yes
  21. this is so this is the uh the old and and the relatively new um I have become uh great friends and
  22. colleagues in our short time of knowing each other and Stephanie before we talk about
  23. boards as a primary focus I I was thinking about you know kind of the old school new school like kind of thinking
  24. about this and you know before me there's you know emancipation reconstruction equal
  25. protection um even before me too or the kind of the World War II kind of activities that
  26. took place and then you got Brown versus Board you've got the the Civil Rights kind of
  27. laws that cut happened in the in the early 60s then we've got the affirmative action kind of moment and then we have
  28. the uh retrenchment from affirmative action we have kind of negative period and then
  29. George Floyd was kind of this moment forward where are we now this whole Dei spaces where it's we're
  30. characterizing everything which could be a whole nother show about what we should
  31. characterize this whole Space is but but where where are we now and and then we'll talk about board so yeah so Ken
  32. we're in a we're in a really interesting time I think if you were to ask me this
  33. question in 2017 when I arrived at the Wharton School I would tell you that the students who I teach who you know you
  34. had taught and believe that we didn't have a race problem in America still and certainly that wasn't a problem race
  35. wasn't an issue that we need to discuss outside of the U.S borders and so that was six years ago and so I would say
  36. that there had been previously a lot of indifference amongst uh citizens in the U.S around the world is certainly
  37. amongst companies in taking up topics of race so I would say if you were to dry a
  38. graph based on the things that you talked about there's sort of an uptick at key key points in time key moments
  39. around civil rights legislation Etc and then I would say 70s 80s 90 keep I think we would start to see like a
  40. down swing in the numbers of activities that corporations were engaging around this topic schools Etc and and so you
  41. know the interesting part is uh the the first movement if you will was around 2014 and 2016. um I always talk
  42. about that as the first black lives matter movement when we actually thought that the black lives matter movement was
  43. sort of some extremist group right we didn't have a lot of clear unders and I say we uh meaning you think that on
  44. average citizen didn't have an understanding of what these issues were they didn't understand why people were
  45. talking about police brutality Etc so we started to see some interest in in 2014
  46. and 2016 in the general population obviously Colin Kaepernick started kneeling we didn't think that was a
  47. great thing back then um and then 2020 happens and then it's the sort of this explosion of interest
  48. in talking about racism systemic racism which was something that was I would say
  49. new in our vocabulary as everyday citizens um and then we saw an explosion of interest in this topic outside of the
  50. U.S and not necessarily talking about America can black lives they were talking about Japanese lives and
  51. Nigerian lives and people who were from historically marginalized ethnic groups in their country so you know sum it up
  52. where we are is um in a place where there's a heightened attention to this topic we still don't
  53. all agree on whether or not racism is an issue or how to address it but I would say that for people like yourself and
  54. myself who study these topics it's a good time to be studying and talking about it because there is significant
  55. interest in knowing more and learning what we can do now that's that's a great catch up and it is I mean it's it's
  56. horrible horrible phrasing on your part though it's a great time to be studying this I guess it's it's not great that
  57. we're studying it I guess so it is a fantastic time for people that are interested in trying to trying to solve
  58. these these issues and leaders really play a role in this and and this gets us to to boards and thinking about what
  59. boards do with companies why do we care to get to it directly why do we care about and I want to be specific about
  60. the diversity that we're talking about why do we care about more blacks and Latinos on boards as well as other
  61. diverse groups what what difference does it make in the context of what we're talking about what is it what can
  62. companies do and then what can boards do to make companies do that so I'm going to tell you what the ideal
  63. is and then I'm going to tell you what I actually study because these are two different things right
  64. so the ideal is is that boards act as strategic advisors to their firms but also as people who monitor the firm's
  65. activities and help the firm to make sure that it's complying with all that's expected of them from a variety of
  66. stakeholder groups so that's compliance monitoring on the one side and the other
  67. side it's a strategic uh position strategic advisory position so so on a good day what we want a board to be able
  68. to do is to help the firm understand its customer base the communities it operates in and to really understand how
  69. its products and services can help to solve the needs met and unmet needs of people in who who are
  70. part of the stakeholder Network right on the one hand on the other hand as as corporations they do have
  71. responsibilities to the societies that allow them to exist so here here in the U.S publicly traded companies have you
  72. know relationships with with the government right and the government especially in heavily regulated areas
  73. like or Industries like Finance expect for the firm to be following um whatever regulations it has set forth
  74. so this gets back to representation when the board is not representative of stakeholders doesn't understand the
  75. needs of stakeholder groups we have a problem and so for a very long time boards were
  76. not asked to be representative of the people who they serve the the communities in which they operate or
  77. their larger stakeholder base so kind of like the government when the government
  78. doesn't represent the people the government starts making all sorts of decisions that don't always reflect the
  79. needs of all the people so the ideal is that we have a diverse board in this case a racially diverse board that also
  80. represents the interests and perspectives of people from a variety of racial groups so that's the ideal is
  81. that these boards will raise issues that are pertinent to the livelihoods of various stakeholder groups and they will
  82. make sure that the CEO the management team understands in the activities that they engage in how how to address these
  83. stated groups needs but that's not what I study what I study is uh why and how why boards do not do that right why uh
  84. diversity or diversifying a board has been so problematic um why is it that even if you have a
  85. diverse board they may not necessarily uh engage in activities that meet your needs or my needs
  86. um and so yeah I think it's a it's a conversation that you know I hope to continue to build through my own
  87. research I think the conversation about board diversity has spent a lot of time focusing on getting a more diverse board
  88. will help us to perform better without fully understanding what the mechanism is that would explain that
  89. um but it is an important question but it also requires us to not just focus on uh diversity for diversity's sake but to
  90. understand uh that the people who are on the boards are still people we want them
  91. to make decisions that are helpful for us all okay so let me probe a little bit more than as someone who sits on a
  92. public board and thinks about this issue a little bit of financial board yes correct Financial work and whatever
  93. whatever I am uh trying to be anybody wants to be on a board the smart question is always
  94. well what's in the best interest of the shareholders I mean that becomes the ultimate kind of stakeholder question
  95. and and a lawyer said all the legal cases you go to Delaware courts in the end was that board member acting in the
  96. best interest of the shareholders and often and you may tell me too often that goes to share
  97. price Share value that that's how you translate what's what's in the best interest how does that conflict or how
  98. does that meld with this idea of issues that are important with regard to Dei our investors of the company yeah so
  99. so in the last few years a big institutional investors like BlackRock and State Street and Vanguard have made
  100. the topic of board diversity one of their greatest priorities and when you read their position papers they they
  101. speak a lot about you know the potential for enhanced financial performance from
  102. in from increased board diversity they cite all the academic research on this topic they cite consulting firms
  103. research on this topic but beyond that what they talk about is risk which you can appreciate as a lawyer the language
  104. of risk and the language of risk comes uh is one such that if we don't know um our neighbors and understand what
  105. their needs are if we are missing um targeting our products and services to certain communities if we are not
  106. following and complying with the regulations that are um you know know given to us to abide by
  107. as it relates to particular racial groups then we might have a problem that might hurt our financial performance and
  108. so while there's a lot of the conversation around how do we increase you know our Market size and and
  109. generate Revenue by being able to gain entry into diverse markets there's that whole conversation lately the
  110. conversation has been about risk mitigation and that's something that shareholders care about is losing money
  111. because we haven't uh effectively monitored all of the costs so even if you don't have the bottom
  112. line information about this will help you be more profitable as a board member be aware that there
  113. may be other externalities that will come at you and cost the company money which will impact the bottom line yeah
  114. you don't act positively in these ways and this and this gets captured not only in this Dei kind of conversation but
  115. also in the ESG conversation the the S the S of the ESG conversation how you mentioned some big name
  116. companies Enterprises that are aware of this and highlighting this how Universal is that understanding now in
  117. in your work in your conversations uh are you enlightening companies yeah to the broader concern or is it
  118. something that that seems to be in the atmosphere yeah so so before coming to Wharton I was a
  119. professor at Cornell and one of my students who ended up uh you know working with me in a variety of research
  120. projects uh moved on to State Street um as state tree Global advisors and he works in the unit that has put out all
  121. this guidance to firms on uh what they should be doing initially it was around gender diversity several years back and
  122. then more recently was around racial diversity so Ryan and his team and I have had a number of conversations
  123. they've interviewed me in a number of other uh people who you probably know who are on boards
  124. um to talk about like what does this conversation look like what's an Institutional Investor's role in it and
  125. because Ryan was my former student he has come to Wharton and he has actually come in and sat in on my diversity
  126. classes and actually taught our students and the interesting thing is we have another student at the Wharton School in
  127. a in a in our MBA program who used to work in Ryan saying role at Vanguard and so this past fall it was interesting to
  128. hear them talk about uh their shared responsibilities around meeting with board chairs and helping them to
  129. understand why this topic was important and why they should continue to keep topics around diversity racial Equity
  130. gender equities at the top of their conversation so I would say from the perspective of big institutional
  131. investors yes there's certainly a lot of attention now they're not the only investors but they do tend to hold I
  132. mean think about as Ryan explained to me think about your you know we don't have
  133. a 401k we have a 4013b but you think about your retirement plans and who's managing that money those are the folks
  134. those are the entities that are going and meeting with board chairs to say hey what are you doing with people's
  135. retirement monies and are you paying attention to ESG and Dei and racial Equity um how is the company doing and is the
  136. board actually doing its job to hold the company accountable so from our perspective or from my my perspective
  137. when I see the big institutional players doing so much of this work I think that
  138. it's um you know it's an indicator that of its prominence but you know in my own
  139. daily activities working with my former student who's obviously a professional doing you know amazing work around this
  140. and then meeting people in our own MBA class who have also taken up the role the last thing I want to say about this
  141. is um you know when you were talking about history and and I started thinking about
  142. Generations I'm a generation xer right so I'm kind of in between I would say a generation of of one type of activism
  143. and another type of activism and Ryan he is oh he he will Define himself as a white American male which I find super
  144. fascinating um given I think about who traditionally tends to take up these issues Ryan is
  145. also in his late 20s as our is the average age of our MBA students and the NBA student who was also taking up this
  146. issue around racial Equity at Vanguard was a white female and so for me as a generation excerpt watching who's
  147. actually doing this work and who's trying to hold the boards accountable it's not people who look like you and me
  148. can there's absolutely people who are in their late 20s and white Americans who have strong
  149. um sentiments around this Topic's important and that's that's the question I want to ask you before we start to
  150. close out because I was in the New York Times recently there was a discussion about a new dictionary that skip Gates
  151. you know in real estate test coming out on the African-American language some stuff and it's got all these terms that
  152. I kind of chuckled to myself as I heard heard some of them that are not broadly known to the rest of the world but but
  153. the one that may or may not be in there is as you were saying this I was thinking about good white folks and he
  154. kind of has framing like this yeah and when I think about that and this is you know within the culture
  155. white folks that are doing good stuff that are down kind of as you're describing
  156. so so knowing that knowing that that can happen going back to the beginning of this conversation
  157. how important or what kind of signaler is the diversity of the board that this work will actually be done and we can't
  158. can't the board be people by good white folks or Ryan and as we're describing this
  159. and how important is it just as a as a proxy to have a diverse board yeah it's certainly a question that I'm asked a
  160. lot especially now that we have this new generation that has done a lot to begin
  161. to understand the lived experiences of other people so that is so important and I will talk about these folks as allies
  162. right a whole lot of my work including my work on board diversity the academic side of it is looking at allyship and
  163. how that happens and and how that works and why that's important on board so it is so important that allies like Ryan
  164. and and this this student who's award an NBA student exists and that they are talking about these issues but that's
  165. not a replacement or that's not a substitute for people who actually come from these communities have these
  166. backgrounds have these experiences who are reflective of these subsets um you know there is I don't want to
  167. call it a Nuance because that sounds like marginalizing the experience but there's a difference there's a
  168. difference experience that you have when you walk around um in that body in a black body in an
  169. African-American body in the U.S and you navigate the professional Workforce and
  170. heck when you navigate what it's like to be a board member often one of you know
  171. 13 right one person who is underrepresented and the other 12 for example might be all white there's a lot
  172. more that comes with that than can be just I think subsumed by somebody who just learned about it from talking to
  173. other people but Ally is important but people who have the lived experience the shared experiences of navigating these
  174. companies are important as well that said I want to say that just because you're black doesn't mean that you have
  175. the same lived experience as another black person and so in my research what I try to talk about is
  176. um you know understanding that um when we're thinking about board diversity um we are trying to actually capture not
  177. just the brown person or the black person on the board and we're talking about racial diversity we're trying to
  178. capture the perspective and so let's say for example um I probably get in trouble when I say
  179. this it is great if everyone on our board got their MBA from the Wharton School right lots of us would be really
  180. really really happy um and so sometimes what happens is people say well we need another woman
  181. and we need another black person let's look and see who else graduated come to Wharton MBA program
  182. so while that's nice it actually hasn't truly created uh in in many cases the diversity that the board is seeking
  183. because that network is small they are they've probably been taught very similar ways of thinking about
  184. businesses um and so I think one of the next stages for companies today is when they're
  185. thinking about recruiting a diverse board to step outside their alma mater Network right to step outside their
  186. client network and to really try to find people for the board who are not only on
  187. the surface difference because they have different color skin or they have a different gender identity or whatnot
  188. um it's also to think about you know when we're recruiting a diverse board we want everyone to bring different things
  189. to the table and that's where I think the the set of opportunities are for boards today
  190. so Stephanie it's so exciting to speak with you it's so reminiscent of your professor David Thomas who started
  191. the ward in school with me so many years years ago so I am glad to have his presence here in in your form in your
  192. unique way it's uh it's also just just the big takeaway for me is this idea of thinking about the task of a board
  193. member demographics being important I also also think about this is not shouldn't leave this is the last thought
  194. but if you just just reverberated with me as you said it I think about uh excuse the politics of this but I think
  195. about what Thurgood Marshall was stepping off the court and he was asked whether or not his replacement needed to
  196. be black and he said essentially you know if it's a black snake or a white snake it still bites I mean he wanted
  197. somebody that had the presence to make the decisions in the court that we're looking out for the interest
  198. of civil rights matters in a way that he did no matter who that who that person was and colorful The Guiding Light so I
  199. appreciate every everything I've learned from you today thank you so much thank you for listening to the ripple
  200. effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  201. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School

Brief Summary

Kenneth Shropshire and Stephanie Curry discuss the importance of diversity in corporate boards and its impact on decision-making and stakeholder representation.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect: Juneteenth Edition. In this special edition, we explore diversity, equity, and inclusion with expert insights.
  • The Role of Corporate Boards. Understanding how corporate boards can better represent diverse communities and stakeholders.
  • The Importance of Representation. Discussing why diverse boards are crucial for understanding stakeholder needs.
  • The Importance of Diverse Perspectives. Diversity on boards goes beyond race and gender; it’s about varied experiences and ideas.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes