The Bond Market Is Sending a Warning to the Fed

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE The bond market is putting new pressure on the Federal Reserve as long-term yields climb and investors question the Fed’s approach to inflation.

Wharton Professor of Finance Nikolai Roussanov explains why Kevin Warsh’s recent comments unsettled markets, why the Fed’s “reaction function” matters, and how rising yields could eventually force the Fed to act.

The conversation also explores the tension between monetary and fiscal policy, including Treasury efforts to push long-term rates lower and why those efforts could work against the Fed’s strategy. With inflation, energy prices and government deficits all complicating the outlook, can the Fed preserve its credibility and still get inflation back to 2%?

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, the role of Fed Chair for Kevin Warsh is getting an early challenge as the bond market
  2. is seeing yields hit levels not seen in the last 20 years. The challenge is that Warsh
  3. wants to hold the 2% inflation target and rising yields in his mind mean fiscal tightening is
  4. underway and that will lead to lower inflation without actually having to impact interest rates.
  5. So how will Warsh deal with all of this right now? Plus as well, there is the component of
  6. what he is saying and what he is not saying about the process. Wharton Finance Professor
  7. Nick Roussanov joins us to discuss what lies ahead. Nick, great to catch up with you again.
  8. How are you, sir? Hi, Dan. I'm great. Thanks again for having me. Once again. And so let's start with that 2% target rate and whether or not it is still feasible with
  9. everything that's going on in the economy to expect the Fed to actually get to 2% at some
  10. point in the future. And I say this because as all of this has been going on and me as a journalist,
  11. I've wondered whether or not it ended up we would see it be 2.3% or 2.5% be that magic number down
  12. the road. Right. It doesn't, of course, have to be the magic number, but I think the market has
  13. expected for a long time that the Fed would do what it takes to get it as close to 2% as they
  14. can and kind of stay within the reasonable range. And it's not impossible. Inflation
  15. slowly has been creeping down over the last few years. And yes, the Iran war has kind of thrown
  16. a bit of a wrench into that. Oil prices have been volatile. But we know that energy prices generally
  17. are kind of the more volatile component of inflation. And that's part of the reason that
  18. the Fed typically focuses on the core. And the spillover from energy to core is not always kind
  19. of direct. However, if these inflationary pressures in energy continue, that will, of course,
  20. eventually make it way into the core as well. And of course, the other side of it is the AI
  21. buildup, which has also been driving out costs kind of across the board has also been contributing.
  22. But again, as we've seen in the most recent reading, inflation has softened a little bit.
  23. So there is hope that we'll get there the keys for the Fed actually to do what it's supposed to do
  24. to ensure that. What kind of impact then is the most recent run on the bond markets happening
  25. to all of this component? Right. So this is where it gets interesting, because what
  26. happened at the last FOMC meeting or after Kevin Warsh's press conference is that the market really
  27. got spooked by his language. He not just didn't commit to a path of rates. We sort of knew that
  28. that was not his thing. He was going to step away from forward guidance. But he just gave a lot of
  29. very vague talk about, yes, he's committed to bring inflation to target. He'll do what it takes.
  30. But what actually that would be and what are the goalposts that he's trying to hit? Are they
  31. shifting? That's, I think, created a lot of uneasiness. He's talked in the past about his
  32. trimmed mean inflation, which works slightly differently from what we normally use. It's a
  33. little it shows up a little bit softer. And I think there's a lack of commitment to what people
  34. call a reaction function rather than necessarily just path of rate. How will the Fed react if
  35. numbers come in at a certain level for employment and inflation? I think that's what gave the
  36. markets the uneasiness that drove much of that run up in rates that we saw following that press
  37. conference. And you're also talking about a time where the announcement by Scott Besant to want to
  38. increase the buybacks as well, using that as a tool as part of this process to be able to kind of
  39. ease some of the fears. Right. So so so here it's it's almost like they're working across purposes
  40. because Kevin Walsh said, well, I don't necessarily have to raise the rates at the short end because
  41. the market is already doing it for me on the long end. As long yields are rising, that is putting
  42. brakes on the consumer. Eventually that will put brakes on investment. And that by itself will help
  43. help kind of keep inflation in check. Now, it's first of all, it's getting it a little bit
  44. backwards because the reason that the rates rose is because of this extra uncertainty injected
  45. by the Fed not committing to the path of short rate. But be that as it may, Besant trying to put push rates down, of course, will undo whatever disciplining
  46. effort that Walsh was hoping to extract from the bond market. Right. So now the bond market is not
  47. doing his job. Now he has to do his job. Now he actually has to react at the short end of the Fed
  48. funds. Right. And so the two are kind of working at cross purposes now. So far, the Besant action
  49. hasn't been that effective. The yields went right back up the day after, basically. So we'll see.
  50. It would take quite a bit of an intervention to sustainably push down long maturity yields,
  51. but it's not impossible in principle. We know that PQE sort of worked. It didn't work maybe
  52. a whole lot, but it sort of worked to push rates down. That was done by the Fed. The Treasury could
  53. in principle do something like that. But of course, its ability to do so is limited because the deficit
  54. is what it is. Right. So there's nothing you can do about it without cutting the deficit.
  55. But what's interesting is that you also have Kevin Walsh trying to remake the Federal Reserve with
  56. the committees that he announced a few weeks ago and looking at how they should be looking at data.
  57. There's been conversation for a while of whether or not the Fed is too backward looking in terms
  58. of making the decisions going forward. And so he believes these committees will help the Fed kind
  59. of take a different path for the longer term future. I think it's always good to reevaluate
  60. how things are done and whether the best process is being followed going forward. So, you know,
  61. he's a new man in charge and he wants to do things his way. And part of that is maybe breaking with
  62. a little bit of kind of status quo groupthink that maybe exists at the Fed. And, you know,
  63. again, reevaluate the process. I think that by itself is just fine. Perhaps they can come up
  64. with a better process. But in the end, the data is what it is. And the markets see what the markets
  65. see. Yes, the Fed maybe has some data that is not easy, but ultimately the market is the
  66. accumulator of all information in the world. And we see that the bond market is not happy with
  67. this language and the bond market is not happy with where things are going, both on the monetary
  68. front and the fiscal front. And something, at least on the monetary side, we kind of know what
  69. has to be done. Inflation fighting credibility has to be preserved. And that may help keep the
  70. long bond yields in check somewhat to the extent that is possible, given the fiscal situation.
  71. What does this mean then for Wall Street? And is Wall Street getting a little bit of a different
  72. view now of what Kevin Walsh is trying to do as he moves forward? And Wall Street is going to have
  73. to react to that. Yes, I think there is definitely re-evaluation of what monetary policy will look
  74. like in the near future. I think he lost a little bit of credibility at the last meeting. Now,
  75. subsequently, inflation did come in a little bit softer. Employment numbers came in not particularly
  76. strong. So that buys him a little bit of time to re-establish that credibility. And maybe
  77. that there were some hints of that at the time of the FOMC meeting. And that's why they were
  78. devoted the way they voted. But again, if we see a pickup in inflation numbers and he still doesn't
  79. react with anything other than very vague words, I think the market will punish him. And I think
  80. the yields will rise even more. Great to have you with us today, Nick. Thanks very much for
  81. your time today. All the best. Of course. Thank you very much. Thank you. Nick Roussanov,
  82. who is a professor of finance here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Kevin Warsh faces challenges with inflation targets and rising bond yields, impacting market confidence and future monetary policy.

Key points

  • Warsh's Early Challenges. Kevin Warsh faces significant challenges as Fed Chair with rising bond yields and inflation targets.
  • Market Reaction to Warsh's Language. The bond market reacted negatively to Warsh's vague commitments during his press conference.
  • Re-evaluating Monetary Policy. Wall Street is reassessing its view on monetary policy under Warsh's leadership.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes