How Retailers Can Cope with Slowing Growth

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guest today is Marshall Fisher from the operations information and decisions
  2. department at Wharton and we're gonna talk with him about a new study that he has just published in the Harvard
  3. Business Review with two of his co-authors Vishal Gore and herb Klein Berger about lifestyle stages in the
  4. retail industry Marshall welcome to knowledge at Wharton and thank you so much for joining us thank you Michael
  5. it's pleasure to be here as always so I wonder if we could begin by telling us a
  6. little bit about how the idea for this story came about so gosh my co-authors and I have worked with retailers for
  7. long time maybe 20 years and back in the mid 90s when we started working with each other it's all the successful one
  8. or many of the successful ones were category killers that had been founded in the 70s and we're still growing at a
  9. hugely rapid rate you can think of Home Depot staples Urban Outfitters long list
  10. of retailers that was the iconic success of the time still pretty young still an
  11. innovative format still rapid growth and I remember wondering you know eventually
  12. we could add Walmart to that list eventually this this can't go on forever I looked at Walmart's growth rate in
  13. their first 20 years it was 43 percent per year compound annual growth rate I did a little calculation as to what
  14. their revenue would be now today had they kept growing at that rate and the answer was like the revenue would be
  15. more than tripled the world's GDP so it's obvious that you eventually run out of places to put stores or if you're
  16. even an internet retailer growth the rapid growth depends on attracting new customers there's a finite number of
  17. people in the world so you're gonna have to slow and my co-authors and I wondered
  18. then why you know do you curl up and given how much emphasis is placed on top line growth it's it's glamorous it's
  19. cool it's everybody likes it so what happens when it inevitably slows how did you go about conducting your study so we
  20. got we Vishal being our data analytics guy collected data on gosh several hundred publicly traded US retailers and
  21. we narrowed that down to 37 retailers that had been continuously in business for a 22-year period ending in 2015
  22. because we were doing the study we actually ended in 2014 because we were started this in 2015
  23. took a couple years and we updated it on and as a group they'd been growing at around 15% and in the last five years
  24. that growth had slowed to four and a half percent so they'd all gone through this life cycle of rapid growth to
  25. maturity and most of them had kind of languished as their stock had been flat in the last five years but there were a
  26. handful that were really rocking the example was Foot Locker had experienced single-digit growth in the last five
  27. years but total stock market return of 33 percent per year which is kind of the S&P oh and for a five-year
  28. period that's that's remarkable growth and the question is of course if this is a group of handful of people that are
  29. rocking and I think off the group of 37 there were 17 right that sort of that forged that that that were successful
  30. how did they do it so first of all they we defined successes five-year total stock market return that exceeded the
  31. S&P 500 return so 17 were above 20 they did a couple things they stopped or greatly slowed their rate of opening new
  32. stores and got and by the way the winners and losers had essentially the identical growth rate top-line growth
  33. rate the winners got that growth mostly through existing stores whereas the less
  34. successful group got their growth mostly by opening new stores so you can think about which is easier opening a new
  35. store or somehow getting your customers to you know drive more traffic and more sales through existing source first
  36. things much easier much easier to open a new store not trivial but a lot easier but which is more creative to earnings
  37. it's the comp store sales because you're leveraging an investment you've already
  38. made in your existing store so where each other is called comparable store sales growth is incredibly enhancing to
  39. profit well what's interesting to me is even the opening new stores as easier it's also probably much more expensive
  40. it's much much and and so going back to the title of your study what's driving this addiction to growth even though
  41. people realize that they did it they're driving growth right at the cost of the right yeah exactly
  42. um and just to re-emphasize the point you made about opening stores has a cost associated with it when Walmart was
  43. growing at 43% they were opening stores at about the same rate forty three percent and their profit was growing
  44. about forty three percent so what are they doing they're running their business through a copy machine there is
  45. turning out more and more copies of the exact same business they did some enhancements to the business model but
  46. for the most part you're just scaling okay that's a great game to play as long as you have enough places to put new
  47. stores to play that game eventually you're putting stores in less desirable locations you're cannibalizing existing
  48. stores and so suddenly you open X percent new stores and revenue doesn't grow by X percent it grows by something
  49. a little smaller than X percent and then what happens is your expenses are growing faster than your revenue which
  50. is eroding eroding your earnings why is it so hard to let go of that cuz I thought the most interesting finding was
  51. not the formula for success which is drive comparable store sales once Bob Marshall from McDonald's had been a vice
  52. president with McDonald's they were one of the successful to reach others I talked extensively with Bob an
  53. interesting guy he said look the formula for success is scale until you run out of geography and then drive comp store
  54. sales until you run out of ideas so the scaling by opening new search that's pretty much an execution game if you if
  55. I would be with a Walmart exactly if they're constantly on their iPhone I mean they're working like demons Sun up
  56. to summon Sun said whether to do lists they're executing because that's the open star game the driving comes since
  57. you kind of be more thoughtful that's an idea game they're very different games if you not to pick on Walmart or
  58. something like I am because I have great admiration for them but if you are playing the execution gain they famously
  59. disdain hiring from the Ivy League you know and we don't need those highfalutin Ivy League types that's a different kind
  60. of talent then if you're figuring out ideas I can tell you what some of them were for driving additional sales
  61. through your store so it's a different game requires different talent I think in general the popular world the
  62. business commentators like growth it's a positive simple story and understand this idea that oh yeah
  63. we're not growing the top-line all that much but we figured out all these smart ways to grow our bottom line that maybe
  64. sounds a little like financial engineering to people in their ice-class over so whether it's the financial
  65. investment world the stock market analysts consultants they all like to talk about the growth story so it's it's
  66. a kind of addiction I think and also if you've been opening stores and that's been your modus operandi you've got a
  67. whole group within the company whose job is to is to open stores you would have to you know fire that group or curtail
  68. them so there's a infrastructure in most retailers both emotionally and physically and external forces leading
  69. that way that make their first thought when growth slows to redouble their top-line growth there's kind of a denial
  70. period I understand and all there were many of our successful retailers Home Depot McDonald's would be a couple
  71. examples they went through a period of maybe five years where they pushed growth beyond the point where it was
  72. there to be profitably had and had at some point say wait a minute this isn't working we got to change our game in
  73. changing the game how do you make the transition from a mindset that is focused on execution execution to a
  74. mindset that's focused on ideas how do you do that so what step one I think is to accept reality so you need to collect
  75. metrics sales per store for example or you must do the successful induced return on invested capital so for a new
  76. store there's an investment there's a return which is the profit on the sales you need to
  77. slow or stop opening new stores when that number goes the wrong way so that's step one I think is simply look around
  78. you and assess the effectiveness of what you're doing then um there's a different
  79. set of projects you've got to put on your capital budgeting list which are things that drive comparable store sales
  80. through your existing stores example footlocker got a install the device this is one of like 20 or 30 things they did
  81. because it's called a scan gun we all know what the Shu process it's like you go in him told sales assistant what
  82. you're looking for he goes to the backroom he brings out two or three parachute try them on maybe one doesn't
  83. fit one you like don't like the color and he goes back and forth to the back room typically five six trips it takes a
  84. long time and meanwhile you're leaving the customer sitting there so Foot Locker put in place the scan gun that
  85. would let the sales associate while he's in front of the customer know exactly what's in stock in the back room of that
  86. store neighboring stores or on the internet so he could have a more helpful conversation with the customer on what
  87. they've got that might be more what you're looking for and could have an assistant bring those shoes shoes out to
  88. them so that ended they estimated two percent to store sales not a huge number but you do twenty or thirty things like
  89. that all of those taken investment just as opening a new store takes an investment so I would say in your
  90. capital budgeting process you start looking at not just new stores as investments to drive top-line but things
  91. you can do within the stores like technology in addition to Foot Locker you also mentioned Home Depot and and
  92. McDonald's right as retailers that did very well have any examples of some of the ideas that they implemented to
  93. two more intensively attractive stores yeah and other ones I put on that list or Macy's Dillard's and Kroger
  94. so Home Depot did private label they conceived and added private label products to their stores they you
  95. leverage the Internet omni-channel Macy's had a concept they called their mom strategy was an acronym my Macy's
  96. was the first time omni-channel was the second so my Macy's was localizing assortment
  97. by store you think about what are the call-out factors of production and restore it's the assortment you offer in
  98. what quantities at what price and what staffing levels do you have in the store all of those things do this in my
  99. research you can measure you'll see variation over time and staffing levels for example you can measure correlate
  100. that you can do the same thing with price with what's happening to revenue measure the impact of changing your
  101. price on revenue or changing staffing levels in this store and a particular hour on revenue so all those things can
  102. be optimized McDonald's did menu additions added things to their menus Croker used analytics a lot in their
  103. stores give you an example they they know I don't have traffic on earth so they know when people are entering the
  104. stores they also a POS status so they know when people are leaving this store and they know typically how long it
  105. takes someone to shop in the store so they started this may sound low-tech but it had a big impact
  106. they started forecasting when people would show up at the cash register and then staffing to that forecast cut the
  107. wait time I think to check out from remember right something like 3 minutes to 10 seconds so that drove one or two
  108. percent comparable store sales right you look at all of these things any one thing
  109. is a little bit of blocking and tackling it looks not that dramatic but one or two percent plus sales if you're doing
  110. 20 or 30 things like that becomes big big news that that's how the total stock market returned
  111. of the 17 retailers had followed this approach over the period 2011 2015 was twenty percent significantly above S&P
  112. 500 the the other group 20 retailers that continued to rely mostly on opening new stores their total stock market
  113. return was 2% so factor of 10 difference between the successful retailers and the
  114. less successful now one of the stories we often hear in the media is that retailers are doing badly and repeatedly
  115. we hear news stories about you know retail chains going bankrupt and and and so the overall narrative seems to be
  116. that blick brick-and-mortar retail is doomed because of the internet to what extent do you buy into that narrative or
  117. is it too simplistic it's too simplistic our our story I guess would be a little
  118. more nuanced to said first of all we think that assuming a consistent situation for the entire retail industry
  119. is obviously silly you've got new startup retailers lots of them that are still in the high-growth days you've got
  120. some retailers that probably their reason for existing is gone away and they are going to go out of business but
  121. I think what we learned is that a segment of retailing bricks and mortar retailers that have gone through a life
  122. cycle of high growth in a row in maturity that segment is struggling because they're for the majority of them
  123. are following the wrong strategy and by the way this applies not just to retailers but I think any company or
  124. countries need to adjust their strategy at different points in their life size so China was high growth for once their
  125. economy opened up in 1979 dad you know a huge growth through basically labor costs to arbitrage well wage rates have
  126. gone up in China double digits which is good that's what the Chinese government wanted but eventually you can you can't
  127. play that game anymore so their growth has slowed they got to play a different game
  128. so retailers companies countries I think all need to adjust their strategy over time as they start with high growth and
  129. inevitably see that growth not decline but slow slow so we're not talking no growth ken Hicks from footlocker come in
  130. and he said I can leverage as little as two percent revenue growth so he can live with two percent same with Macy's
  131. but not zero or or negative we had with us right now the CEOs of some companies that are up against this slowing growth
  132. phenomenon what advice would you give them to do they should deal with it well recognize that it's a change that so
  133. I've talked about retailing we're opening stores is the growth in store instrument or the most commonly used one
  134. and their change would be to shift to doing investments in technology or process changes within their stores to
  135. drive comparable store sales growth other companies non retailers I think would have to think through what is that
  136. logical shift in strategy so we talked about China what they're doing is some shifting out of low-end manufacturing
  137. they don't want to be the t-shirt maker of the world anymore and focusing on innovation branding and selling within
  138. the internal economy and there's some Chinese companies emerging that are a different breed from the factory owners
  139. that made Footwear an apparel in the 80's 90's and even the last decade so that so that's another example of the
  140. largest by population country in the world going through this same transformation interesting what
  141. surprised you most about this study that's an interesting question that there that you can be phenomenally
  142. successful that the successful group put up 20% stock market return over a five-year period Oh
  143. phenomenally successful that they all followed a pretty consistent strategy that it was when I would talk to people
  144. about how do you grow your earnings when your top-line growth slows coming answer
  145. would be will its cost-cutting right it wasn't cost-cutting it was asset leveraged so it was a different strategy
  146. than we thought of so those were all surprised is the biggest one though is just how many companies have this
  147. addiction to growth and it took us a long time to come to that title but it was slowly dawned on us when we looked
  148. at even the successful companies that went through periods of denial Home Depot McDonald's and how hard it was for
  149. them to make the transition and in fact would ask you one last question Marshall
  150. did any questions come up during the study that you would like to address through future research and if so what
  151. would that be I think maybe it would be interesting to see the degree to which this applies to internet retailers
  152. because even though they don't open stores they do acquire customers and just as there's finite space for stores
  153. there's finite customers in the world I think it'd be interesting to think about how it applies lifecycle
  154. idea to companies other than retailers or to countries Marshall thank you so much for talking
  155. with knowledge thank you Michael it's always a pleasure [Music] you

Brief Summary

Marshall Fisher discusses retail growth strategies and the importance of enhancing existing stores over opening new ones.

Key points

  • Retailers' Growth Strategies. Fisher reveals insights from his study on successful retailers and their strategies.
  • Transitioning Mindsets in Retail. Fisher emphasizes the need for retailers to shift focus from expansion to innovation.
  • The Addiction to Growth. Marshall Fisher discusses the retail industry's obsession with growth and its consequences.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes