Muhammad Yunus: Lifting People Worldwide out of Poverty - Full Interview

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

What began with a loan of $27 to 42 women in a small village 33 years ago has grown into a global microcredit movement that has changed the lives of millions of poor people around the world. Muhammad Yunus, founder and managing director of Bangladesh's Grameen Bank, was the guest speaker at Wharton's MBA commencement on May 17 and the recipient of an honorary doctor of laws degree during the University of Pennsylvania's commencement on May 18. Yunus spoke with Knowledge@Wharton about his successes, challenges and upcoming initiatives. πŸ“‚ ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guest today is muhammad yunus winner of the 2006 nobel peace prize and founder of the micro credit movement
  2. based on the idea of making very small loans to the world's poorest people thereby giving them the opportunity to
  3. raise themselves and their families out of poverty thank you for joining us thank you people often associate good
  4. works and worthwhile causes with non-profit institutions but you have emphasized that your model
  5. is a for-profit one not a non-profit one can you briefly describe that model and
  6. tell us why the distinction is so important to you well that's how we became i mean we are
  7. not trying to create a non-profit that was not our intention my intention was to
  8. persuade the bankers to lend money to the poor people so my struggle always with the bankers
  9. so initially i offered myself as a guarantor and then took the money from the bank
  10. and gave it to people so it was an extension of banks activity when we saw that it's working well and
  11. the banks were not as enthusiastic as we were we thought maybe we should have a separate bank created for this purpose
  12. and finally we did that in 1983 called grameen bank or a village bank so we became a bank because it is a
  13. bank's activity we lend money to the poor people and people sometimes refer to us as an ngo so we have to
  14. explain that we are not an ngo it's not that we are saying belittling ngo that they are not
  15. good i'm good it's not like that simply stating a fact that people get confused because we work with the poor
  16. people then it must be an ngo he said no we are a bank and it's owned by the poor people
  17. uh so the owners of the bank are the borrowers of the bank so that's the distinction that we want
  18. to make we clarify what we are well obviously grameen bank has grown dramatically over the
  19. since the time that you founded it i've read that you now have operations in more than 100 countries
  20. and you have 7 million borrowers in bangladesh alone but your success with grameen has led to
  21. a lot of other people entering the micro credit area some of them are commercial banks
  22. some are funded by venture capitalists how has that changed the micro credit model and can you explain
  23. you know some of the issues that have come up as a result of that yeah just a little clarification we
  24. work or at least the grameen idea has been working in almost all the countries of the world so it's
  25. now not right to say a hundred countries uh they're at microgravity so you're even more successful
  26. at least the idea has spread that whether they are big or small or successful or not that there
  27. are presences presence in all those countries and right now we are nearly eight million borrowers within
  28. grameen bank itself so that way grameen bank also has expanded within bangladesh yes lots of organizations
  29. have come come in and we have encouraged them to come in and to do the job ngos have done that in others than that
  30. when the world becomes popular the idea becomes popular many people want to join those kind of
  31. things so the word microcredit became very popular microfinance became very popular
  32. and those were not using these words before suddenly they started using it like agricultural banks around the world
  33. saying that we do microcredit never said that before so whatever they do whether they are
  34. micro credit or not this is a debatable subject because uh we define micro credit micro finance
  35. in a certain way like this is a credit and a financial service to the poorest people without collateral
  36. without guarantee uh and without any lawyers in the system so that has to be very
  37. clear in our work before we call it micro micro credit or microfinance and this is focused more on women
  38. poorest women so these are the aspects if you look at the agricultural banks for example
  39. most of the agricultural banks around the world require collateral you have to bring your land records or
  40. whatever it is similarly savings and loan association saying that we do microcredit
  41. cooperatives are saying we do micro credit uh those who are giving agricultural loans commercial
  42. banks are saying we are doing microcredit so we need to kind of clarify what is microcredit
  43. in its pure form rather than bring everything else and microcredit is always given to
  44. for income generating activity so whatever money you are taking you're investing it
  45. to create an income source for yourself there are many programs which give loans
  46. for buying consumer goods and they say we are doing micro credit they are giving money to
  47. buy refrigerator or buy television we say we do micro credit we say no sorry that's not microcurrent
  48. so we have to sort this out and another aspect that i want to draw attention to there are many
  49. microcredit programs going around and they're advertising themselves saying oh this is a great opportunity to make
  50. money there's a huge big field out there a lot of people and you give money and you make a lot of
  51. money and they encourage people who want to make money to join in and do that again we say look our purpose is not to
  52. excite people about making money and getting excited about that our purpose is to help people
  53. get out of poverty so everything you do uh the focus is not on profit marketing focus is on helping
  54. people to get out of poverty uh so those who are taking this as an opportunity to make money
  55. have to uh raise their interest rate to the extent that they make a lot of money
  56. so interest rate issue becomes a sensitive issue we are saying interest rates should be
  57. kept down as low as possible preferably to cover cost and if you want to make a little profit
  58. on top of it it should be very modest profit so that it doesn't look like this was
  59. your intention so those who are doing that using microcredit microfinance uh for uh
  60. making a lot of money uh we kept saying that these are not microcredit in the sense that we do it
  61. because we came here to fight out the loan sharks not become loan shots ourselves so this
  62. is they're moving into the direction of loan sharks so we want to disassociate disassociate ourselves from
  63. them so how do you tackle that does some regulation is that some regulation required and what kind of regulation
  64. should there be within bangladesh we have been talking about regulation we have created
  65. a within bangladesh government has created a microgrid regulatory authority with our
  66. suggestions they have done that so they will be looking into the interest rate issue transparency issue
  67. many people quote their interest rate in many many ways hiding the actual fact how much
  68. they are charging we said it has to be very transparent all interest rates should be expressed in a
  69. standardized form so that we can compare a and b who charges more or not or less this is something that they have
  70. to clarify right away and also to keep the interest rate as low as possible this is
  71. an encouragement regulatory authority should be put again and for personally i have been promoting
  72. the idea that true macro of credit interest rates should be within a particular range i said cost of fund at
  73. the market price plus 10 this is the green zone of micro credit interest rate you are legitimate you are doing
  74. excellent work if it is cost of fund at the market price plus 10 to 15 percent we say your
  75. interest rate is in the yellow zone you're on the high side but still will consider your genuine microcredit
  76. program and we encourage you to push yourself back into the green zone and it's the other one the cost of fund
  77. at the market price plus 15 and above then we say you're in the red zone meaning that you are too high and you
  78. are on the wrong side of micro credit you are moving into the loan shark zone you have spoken about the downside of a
  79. global globalized economy referring to it during the nobel peace prize ceremony in oslo as
  80. quote a dangerous free-for-all highway whose lanes will be taken over by the giant trucks from powerful economies
  81. even as bangladeshi rickshaws will be thrown off the highway end quote i'm assuming you're referring
  82. to the one-dimensional profit motive of these giant trucks that focus more on money than on social good
  83. but how do you think how do you think a scenario could could realistically be averted a
  84. global scenario and in fact isn't that somewhat desirable uh i was giving an image that
  85. globalization is like a multi-lane highway all the products are moving back and forth in many directions
  86. and everybody on the road carrying their merchandise and giving the idea that big countries
  87. big economies rich economies will have more merchandise to carry big trucks to carry
  88. and very powerful and take over the lanes and the small countries don't have space
  89. for themselves because it's all taken over by the big trucks and the big companies
  90. so i said if that image fits into the picture then we should have traffic rules so
  91. that little company and the little country little economy have their safe lanes where they're slow moving
  92. their carry little thing and very fragile but they move safely uh so the the big trucks don't take over
  93. everything so the and i'm saying that if we accept the traffic rules idea then we'll need traffic police so
  94. that these rules are obeyed and the idea is to have a traffic authority so that somebody has to say
  95. this is the rules of globalization that if you are a big company you cannot come
  96. to a weak economy and say i take over the whole economy they can because they have the money power
  97. so that will be wrong globalization in globalization both sides must be the winner
  98. and the whatever gain in the trade takes place it should be shared equitably just because i have the power i take out
  99. out of 100 i take 99.9 and give you 0.1 percent and say this is globalization i don't
  100. think that will be tenable that will be sustainable so we have to agree how much you should
  101. get and how much i should get although i could have taken over everything but by agreed
  102. principles we don't do that we give you some and we keep some and what that participation would be how
  103. division would be that would be the traffic police or the traffic authority will decide
  104. that this is how we should do that otherwise globalization will become i suggested that it will be an economic
  105. imperialism that big economy has taken over the small economies well one effect we see of globalization
  106. right now is what's happening happening in the world banking industry and why i find that very
  107. interesting is because if you were to look at grameen's own borrowers they're not just the subprime or are
  108. considered subprime but or even the sub subprime in spite of that growing repayment rates
  109. are 99 or so and you uh have never required a bailout uh from that perspective i wonder how
  110. you see this global banking crisis and what advice would you give to the ceos of institutions like
  111. citibank or bank of america about what they could do to salvage their operations
  112. it's a paradoxical situation right now because back 33 years back when i was trying to
  113. start this program in a tiny village with a few people and arguing with the bankers that this
  114. would be a good idea to give loans to the poor people their argument was that poor people are not credit worthy they
  115. will never pay back and so on so today 33 years later you can ask the same question who is creditworthy
  116. the answer obviously will be very different because is the poor who turned out to be the
  117. better credit worthy than the other category of people because the programs micro credit programs all over
  118. the world still function very well still their repayment is very high whereas the big banks and their big
  119. lending operations are in a situation of collapse is falling down so with this experience kind of
  120. contradictory experience that we have now we have to we have no other way but to redesign the
  121. whole system recognizing the fact the strength in this non-collateralized loans for the poor
  122. people and the weakness in the cholera right along for the rich people so we have to found find a ground where
  123. we can have a an inclusive financial system where nobody will be thrown out of the system uh not the
  124. poorest person not the homeless person or a beggar person nobody should be thrown out they can handle
  125. they have already shown examples so on and created a long-term credit um record that what
  126. they have done so this is one lesson from this to redesign the financial system another point i would like to make that
  127. this global crisis financial crisis uh is worst in our lifetime when the whole world is going through it
  128. while we look at the crisis part of it we forget this is also the greatest opportunity
  129. when the system is not working that's the time you unpack it and redesign it so that not
  130. only it works it works better than ever before uh unless we do that we'll be committing
  131. a big mistake so i i emphasize on the opportunity part of it while the crisis will take its time we
  132. take its course to get or get through it but we should be focusing attention and then start redesigning piece by
  133. piece where it needs to be fixed so that we don't have the same old system that we had before what qualities does
  134. one need to lead a microfinance institution and how are these different from the qualities needed for another
  135. type of organization uh one idea i was just mentioning that we came from the direction where we wanted to
  136. bring financial services to the poor people to help them generate income for themselves and gradually move out of
  137. poverty by doing that build confidence build experience and step by step take care of themselves and see that
  138. they can move on and get out of poverty so we would like to keep microcredit in that fashion
  139. in that mood not profit maximization mode because then you are not looking at people's condition you are looking at
  140. your own condition so you want to take out as much possible as possible to improve your financial strength and
  141. so on so that is i think number one requirement for microcurrent that you have the right
  142. kind of attitude and right kind of mood when you get involved with it that here i have come to use my talent
  143. my creativity my management skill to help people get out of poverty uh without losing money
  144. losing money pushes you into another direction it becomes uh to it pushes into itself into the
  145. charitable kind of programs micro credit is not a charity program micro credit is a business program but
  146. business with a social purpose and in a certain separate way i've called it a social
  147. business and defined it in a very clear terms what a social business like so ideally i would like my credit to be
  148. a social business where profit is zero for the person who has invested but the company can make profit profit
  149. stays with the company with the social objective in this case the social objective will be to help
  150. people get out of poverty but but in terms of individual leadership skills or organizational skills how do you nurture
  151. these within individuals in sacrament bank we didn't come in bank we just recruit people and
  152. let them learn by doing as apprentices with other older persons in the branches so it's
  153. not a classroom training which makes all the difference classroom training is a very small part
  154. of our training we simply introduce what we do and then let them figure out what how it
  155. is done and so on when they join brahmin bank for them as just a job they are looking for job not many jobs
  156. are available they got the job they're very happy they got the job they think now on
  157. i get i work and i get my salary so the intention of helping poor and all those things
  158. was not part of that job but once you start working with the poor people and get to know the system
  159. get to know the objectives of the system and gradually you are taken by it and more and more you feel
  160. inspired by it and all these ideas that yes my work helps people excites them it's a wonderful experience to be able
  161. to touch other people's life it's almost intoxicating experience once you have it
  162. you cannot get away from it you want to have it more because you see things are happening in people's life
  163. their children going to school the kid you saw a little kid running around in the village now you
  164. see he or she is in school and doing very well and talking about what he wants to be what
  165. he wants to be and you remember your own childhood that how you went through and how difficult
  166. it was for you now these kids are lucky kids they could have been they they are in school and some of their
  167. older students are now going to higher education and government bank gives them education loans and you say oh nobody
  168. gave me an education loan and my education finished after high school i couldn't
  169. proceed any further only job i could get is this one but i'm happy through my job i'm helping
  170. other kids to go to higher education becoming doctors engineers and university professors and so on so forth
  171. and that excites them that yes my service is useful one of the really interesting aspects of grameen's
  172. operations is the way you have been able to extend the concept of microfinance beyond just credit into
  173. areas such as health insurance i wonder if you could explain some of those activities
  174. and how they have evolved what some of your challenges have been we do not consider macro insurance or
  175. health insurance as outside the financial service so we take it as a part of our activity as a bank's
  176. activity we started with giving credit at the same time taking savings so it's always together savings and credit
  177. formed our basic tool and then we encourage them to go into other directions about the
  178. health and other issues and gradually we introduced insurance programs life insurance it was our first
  179. insurance program that we did and the loan insurance that we did and then we introduced the health
  180. insurance program and we saw that we can give the health insurance facility but how do we ensure
  181. they get the health service because the existing health service is not a very reliable health service
  182. we started creating uh health services through a separate company we created called grameen colon
  183. wellbeing through that we started setting up clinics in the villages with the professional doctor on the top of the
  184. clinic and then paramedics and the health workers with the pathological lab attached to it so that you don't have to
  185. go to the city for simple pathological testings and so on so everything is self-contained
  186. and today we run about 51 such clinics and on an average they make about 93 of the cost they cover another seven
  187. percent we can cover easily if we could retain the doctors in this clinics that became a big problem doctors don't
  188. want to stay in the village the way uh the kind of clinics that we operate in the villages
  189. so most of the time almost half or one third of the doctors are missing so that's why our popularity in the area
  190. is not as high as it should have been so now we are trying to redesign it do it in a
  191. different way trying to set up a program at the village level what we call grameen
  192. health management centers where our focus would be on prevention our focus is the healthy people first
  193. and then to the sick people and the sick people we say this is where we do the early detection
  194. and early treatment without relying on the doctors in the village so doctor will be in the city wherever
  195. they are we are trying to link the doctor and the patients through information technology mobile phone in bangladesh is
  196. everywhere like many other countries now mobile phone is a common phenomenon even in the poor
  197. families you'll see mobile phones very cheap so what we're doing and these phones are
  198. internet enabled phones it also carries the internet service so for internet service you don't have to
  199. worry every single piece of space within bangladesh can receive internet services
  200. through the mobile phone so we want to do the diagnostics and plug it into a mobile phone transmit all
  201. the images and all the data to the specialist doctor in the city who can analyze it and tell you what the
  202. problem is and talk to the patient on the mobile phone and some intermediary young
  203. girl who can go go between the patients and the doctors to carry on all these services
  204. so this is the new idea that we are promoting and the health insurance is a very
  205. popular one i must say provided we can guarantee that they get the services we promised
  206. is there a plan to extend this further with google we have been discussing with many
  207. partners already we have created a social business with intel corporation it's called grameen
  208. intel company in bangladesh and through that company we are bringing mobile phone services in the villages
  209. with healthcare software included into it their initial one that we are doing with that is a
  210. series of questions that we place before the pregnant mothers and the questions are designed in such a way
  211. by evaluating the answers the doctors can tell you whether she has a risky pregnancy
  212. say immediately you have a first choice that we have screened off one risky pregnancy
  213. then you can concentrate on that one and gradually we'll be moving into ultrasono
  214. bring the ultrasono in the family uh the house to do the image of the baby inside the home and transmit it to
  215. the doctor and the doctor can tell can fully confirm it that yes she has a problem and we can zoom in to
  216. that particular patient and so on so we'll be we'll be discussing with other companies like
  217. google uh i'll be in this trip i'll be meeting the google people to talk about it one of the idea that i'll be
  218. discussing with them is to how to capture all the patient data simultaneously as we meet the people
  219. talk to people all these comes in a way that you can put in a central server through google and you have a global
  220. patient data available and you can analyze them you can you can find out the incidence of each
  221. diseases how the treatment is working which treatment is working how they are improving and so on
  222. lots of information can come out of that there are many ways you can do that very simple now the
  223. technology is available uh it can be almost costless but at the same time extremely valuable
  224. information about the healthcare so we want to see excite google and others to get involved google already has a lot of
  225. healthcare related programs but we are trying to see how to extend the service into the
  226. area that we face and collaborate with them by basing your model on getting funds
  227. from the borrowers rather than getting say investment money from international investors
  228. does that give you enough money to to make as many loans offer as many services as you could or do you do you think that
  229. outside money actually could play a role as long as it doesn't dilute the primary
  230. focus which is social good and not making money within coming bank we are allowed to
  231. take deposits from everybody it's not related limited to the borrowers only it's just like a bank we can take
  232. anybody's deposits so that's open with incoming each of our branch is required to
  233. make enough deposit mobilize enough deposit to carry out all the lending they do so
  234. that branches don't have to borrow from the head office don't have to borrow from
  235. another branch so they are self sufficient with their money on top of it we encourage them to
  236. build up enough cushion of safe reserves of the deposits because of the problem of disasters we have very
  237. frequent disasters at time of disasters you can't get your money back but you need to lend money more money
  238. than you did before to get people out of the problem they have faced so we want to build up that cushion
  239. usually we recommend at least uh 30 and 33 reserves should be kept within that system
  240. today we have more than 30 percent reserve 37 is up in our all our in the whole of grameen bank some
  241. branches have more some branches have less but the average of 37 percent we have no problem
  242. with the deposits we have enough deposits in that so we the question of borrowing from
  243. outside never occurred to us because we have enough money and i keep telling people that um literally
  244. no matter where we live we live in an ocean of money but the problem is the poor people
  245. cannot take a seat out of it that's the problem shortage of money is not there so people have plenty of money
  246. they put in the bank people will be very happy to the branch came near their home because villages
  247. don't have branches of banks banks are all concentrated in the cities so if they have to put the money in the
  248. bank they have to go to the city and the town where the banks exist bank brands exist
  249. so grammy bank works in the villages so it's a very convenient place people withdraw their money from the cities put
  250. it there near home because it's handy they can go anywhere anytime they go one they want to pick up the money so we
  251. have enough of that money and we do not see any reason that it will ever dry out
  252. having said that what is the amount of deposit coming from the borrower themselves
  253. we lend out over 100 million dollars a month through grameen bank today out of that
  254. money uh nearly half of that money comes from the borrower's own deposits so it's quite a substantial amount of
  255. money the borrowers to put in and that money keeps growing because everybody's putting additional deposits every week
  256. so it keeps growing and growing so they they have their own savings account at the same time
  257. other people can put in money there sometimes we see that maybe in certain brands we have too much money
  258. that whether we should do keep that level of deposit without expanding the business we encourage them
  259. to expand the business rather than build up too much deposits you had referred earlier to the idea of
  260. a social business and you explained how that differs from a conventional business and one example of that
  261. is grameen denon foods what i find really remarkable is that you are able to produce
  262. uh power yogurt or shaktidoi for five cents for an 80 for for an 80 gram cup how can you explain
  263. how the economics of that works and whether that model is scalable yes very much because
  264. it's a business that's what the whole idea is should be running as on business principles that
  265. you have to cover your cost and generate some surplus so that the business can keep running
  266. but the idea of social business is investors have invested the money not for the benefit of their own it is
  267. invested to achieve a social objective in this case of grameen danone objective is to bring nutrition to the
  268. malnourished children what we have done we put all the micronutrients which are missing in the
  269. children in the yogurt and make it very tasty children love it they pay that five
  270. cents to buy a cup and if a child eats two cups a week and continues to do so for eight to nine
  271. months he or she gets all the micronutrients back and become a healthy playful child
  272. so that is the objective of the company so that is how it is done and others it's a
  273. cause it's a question of how much it cost milk costs how much processing costs equipments and
  274. distribution costs and so on once you're in social business lots of costs go down because you don't
  275. need to incur those costs for example you don't know any elaborate or fancy marketing
  276. because as long as people know what you're doing and they're interested in it but so you don't have to go until
  277. television or newspaper uh we are here and life is uh meaningless without eating uh uh shakti
  278. we don't say that we explain what it is as the people come and gradually the spreads
  279. and that's it so the marketing cost goes down and we have in our design we made it sure that the
  280. extra costs are cut off trimmed off for example we made it this very small plant so that
  281. you don't produce too much around your own plant there's enough consumers to bite rather
  282. than go at a long distance the idea is to cut down the cost of coal chain if you are producing in a big plant you
  283. have to carry all this to long distances and you need cold chain and cold chain is a very expensive item
  284. so we reduced that we eliminated that so our idea is to have many many many small plants all around
  285. the country so that you reach out to everybody this is number one plant which is already operating then we are
  286. getting ready for the number two plant we want to have about 50 plants to cover all the children in bangladesh
  287. and each one is self-contained each one makes money prof it will cover the cost and so on
  288. sometimes you get through difficulties like suddenly during the food crisis last year
  289. the milk prices jumped we couldn't maintain that price tag that we had on the product so we are
  290. wondering what we should do we came out to many kind of alternatives to keep the prices down
  291. at the same time without losing the micronutrients and so on so quickly we came out with the shock to
  292. drink so that the milk becomes less other elements becomes more water and other things but keeping
  293. that and have a good taste for it keeping the price lowest before but we are lucky milk prices went down again
  294. we continued and so on so we have to cope with those kind of fluctuations without
  295. losing the whole focus of the company in addition to uh grameen danone and intel i think you have a relationship
  296. also with basf for any malarial nets do you have any joint ventures or partnerships with other companies in the
  297. works yeah many countries many sorry many companies are coming up with ideas to work with us for social
  298. businesses and we're giving them ideas one already is in operation as a very important social business that we have
  299. right now is a grameen violia violia is the water company it's a french water company one of the
  300. largest water company in the world many of the u.s cities are served by violia for their water so we this giant company
  301. we persuaded them to create a tiny little uh water treatment plant in the villages of
  302. bangladesh to serve 50 000 uh people in the village because our problem is a big problem
  303. in bangladesh with arsenic in our water very high level of poison in the water and millions of bangladesh
  304. almost half the population of bangladesh bangladesh has a total of 150 million people
  305. so half the population is 75 million they drink water with high level of arsenic
  306. so we are putting up this company to supply clean violent quality water to every
  307. household in the village and they will be paying for it very small amount nobody will
  308. mind paying for that and it will cover all its cost and it will become a social business
  309. really it's not there to make money out of it but the fact that people are drinking
  310. poison every day now we can do this we can overcome that nothing is happening through any other program so we said
  311. let's move on and do that so this becomes another example of social business and
  312. once you can do that successfully for 50 000 people in the village you have developed
  313. a seed then all you need to do is to plant the seed in other places because each one is self-contained so
  314. you can do as many as you want and cover all the people so development of the seed is the most important thing
  315. in social business like gaming is a seed now you can take it you can take it anywhere in your
  316. country we have been already approached by india we have been approached by china
  317. they would like to have remainder known in china and india and some places because they have the same problem
  318. malnutrition is a very common problem so if this one works and health authorities
  319. are saying that yes this is a big problem and this works and we have invited gain
  320. global alliance for improved nutrition which is a big ngo based in geneva concentrates on the
  321. monitoring of the nutrition situation globally to monitor whether this is really true
  322. whether this is just a gimmick that we do or is a real are the children benefiting and the
  323. nutrition level is increasing and so on so you have the grameen denon and you have the grameen violia grameen intel
  324. and there are some in the pipeline and very interesting programs like one shoe company very big show company
  325. we have they approached us what can we do said well one i would say you have a theme and the
  326. theme would be your motto would be nobody in the world should go without shoes as a shoe company this is our
  327. responsibility make sure to do that so you come up with shoes that the poorest people can afford
  328. it's a good quality with your brand name so that it's not a second class third class thing
  329. so you take the ownership of that shoe and make it very cheap they like that idea then i suggested why
  330. don't you start with making shoes for under one dollar so you cover the people who can who
  331. never be able to use that brand name shoes in their lifetime ever but now every kids everybody will be
  332. doing that and so on so there are many in the pipeline basf is one already signed agreement will do the mosquito
  333. nets treated mosquito net and also nutrition sachet for pregnant women and malnourished women because women
  334. nutrition is uh again another area where uh it's not as satisfactory as you would
  335. like to be so this company would be producing that and and make it possible for everybody to
  336. afford that nutrition at the same time while we are having this nutrition supplement we'll be focusing
  337. on the diet itself because it's not forgetting about the diet and just going to the artificially taking the
  338. nutrients inside the body so we'll be also encouraging them to have right kind of food as they go on you've
  339. been dedicated to the microcredit concept long enough to be able to observe the children
  340. of that first generation of women that you helped going back to 1976 and the 27 dollars that you loaned to 42 women
  341. in a small village how are these children who are now adults doing are they creating jobs for other people are they
  342. starting their own companies are they adding societal wealth to the community and just by the very fact that these
  343. this new generation of of people still need help does that suggest that you have a long way to go
  344. with micro credit or how does that what does that say about the success of the movement
  345. microcredit is the first step you build up step by step many other things like insurance program savings program
  346. and many other programs around it we have encouraged the borrowers of grameen bank to send the
  347. children to school because they themselves are illiterate their their husbands are illiterate
  348. their parents are illiterate so we thought let's break that circle here send the children to school so that your
  349. children will be educated and they will be literate at least and we succeeded in doing that
  350. having all the children in school so that was a very happy kind of experience for us that uh
  351. not only we're giving them loans to the borrowers but at the same time we have helped them to send their children to
  352. school and then we saw lots of these children are doing excellent results in the
  353. schools some of them coming up at the top of the class so we kind of got thrilled by the
  354. performance of some of these kids coming from totally literate totally poorest family coming to the
  355. class with everybody else now he or she is in the top of the class so we thought this should be celebrated
  356. so we started introducing scholarships for all the top performing students and grameen bank gives over 30 000
  357. scholarships every year now it's growing it's 40 000 and so on every year because the number of children are
  358. growing then we saw many of these children coming close to higher education and they have
  359. difficulty in getting into higher education because they don't have the money to pursue the higher education but
  360. the quality-wise they're as good as anybody else so immediately we introduced education
  361. loans so that they don't have to worry about money so the money is our problem you
  362. concentrate in their education so we started giving education loans and helping them to
  363. higher education right now there are more than 35 000 students in under education loans going
  364. to medical schools engineering schools universities so almost in every single public
  365. university and public medical schools and engineering schools there are grameen children who are studying there so
  366. a whole wave of new children are going into that so they when i meet them they will
  367. always discuss an issue which is worrying them about the jobs after we finish our job can you help us
  368. find jobs and how am i going to find jobs for them so i started thinking about it
  369. and then giving them a new idea that maybe they shouldn't be thinking about jobs uh
  370. and we tell them look you are children from gaming families you are gaming children
  371. your thinking should be different than other children other than other people other children they worry
  372. about jobs you shouldn't be worrying about it you should be taking a pledge and repeat
  373. this pledge every morning you wake up and your pledge is i shall never seek job from anybody
  374. i'll create jobs this is my mission so you are not job seekers you are job givers so think in that
  375. terms because your mother you are a first unit child your mother owns a bank not many children
  376. have that fortune you have that fortune so your mother's bank has enormous amount of money so money is
  377. not your problem your problem is what you do with your money so think of what what you can do as you go into education
  378. and do that and then if you feel frustrated you cannot come up with an idea think about your mother what she did
  379. she didn't wait for anybody she took the money and went for a business herself she's an illiterate
  380. woman and along the way she was successful step by step she went on and sent you to
  381. school now you are in a higher education with her bank and what good is your education if you
  382. cannot do better than your mother if she can do it you can do much better that's that's the thing that you have to
  383. prove to yourself that what you your mother gave you a chance and you make use of it and the use is that you
  384. create a job for others so and start a small and expand it as you grow and bring in more people to help you to grow
  385. so you don't have to wait to finish the school and get a certificate in education
  386. when you use it for getting a job you need a certificate right you don't need a certificate when
  387. you go into business yourself so when you're in school you start the business at the same time continue with it so
  388. this is an idea that we are trapped and some of them are taking this idea and started borrowing from gaming bank
  389. and getting into business themselves to link what you just said to uh what we were discussing earlier about
  390. social business what kind of social businesses could you start around education and is grameen involved in any any such
  391. activities we along the health side what we have done we are in the process of finishing it
  392. this year we are starting a nursing college as a social business because nursing is
  393. a good profession we'll be giving nursing degrees to the young girls from grameen families
  394. so they're coming from the poor families going to nursing college and grameen bank will give the education loans
  395. so that they don't have to worry about money where the money is coming from and the college will cover its cost
  396. and they will get the jobs and will produce the nurses in a way that they'll be internationally
  397. acceptable level of education they're a big shortage internationally about the nurses
  398. there's a big shortage within the country so each girl will have a choice whether she will work in the country or
  399. should go outside so this is a social business and i said i don't have to limit myself to one
  400. nursing college i can have a series of nursing colleges they are paying for itself
  401. why can't you create as many as you want because there are millions of young girls waiting around sitting
  402. around doing nothing because they have no opportunities i can create some opportunities for them
  403. they change their life they change the society because now they go out of the village and they go
  404. out and work in their hospitals and so on and go outside the country and learn languages
  405. and so on so this is another example of social business we want to do a medical college in the same principle
  406. because medical college also can cover its own cost and produce doctors doctors with this different kind of
  407. orientation than they normally have and normally a doctor a student doctor is planning to
  408. when i finish my education i'll start my career and i'll make a lot of money and that's focus usually happens so this
  409. orientation will be that when i come out i want to make sure i can help the health situation in the
  410. country and focusing on the poor families so how do you do that kind of thing and having
  411. a very high quality of education so that you have international links you don't feel that you're left out
  412. because you concentrated on a certain kind of thing and you get involved with research of the
  413. health issues and so on so that's another social business could come out so education even in education you can
  414. use the idea of social business is there anything that's happened in the micro credit movement or in your own
  415. life as it relates to this to this work that has changed the way you view microcredit is there's something that
  416. said oh have you ever said to yourself oh i should do have done this instead of this
  417. or i should be doing this instead of this have any of your initial assumptions changed over the years
  418. some basic assumptions remain same we have expanded it lots of other things came we thought
  419. let's try this one and we tried it and it worked we felt happy about it um if you just look at the reflect what
  420. i have done if i have to do anything differently probably one area probably i would have done
  421. differently uh when we began in 1982 there's a tremendous amount of enthusiasm among the donors
  422. to give us money because we had a small project they wanted to help us and we were very reluctant to take money
  423. because we had plenty of money at that time because we were a small project we didn't need any money we had no idea
  424. about taking money but they kept on pressuring pressuring us and the central bank with which we
  425. were working and finally central bank yielded because they thought why not if they want to
  426. give money let's take some money it's a loan not even a grant from ifa international
  427. fund for agriculture development so in 1982 we took the external money before that we never had any external
  428. money and the donors other donors came in they wanted to give us more money so we thought why not once we have taken
  429. one we can take two we can take three we have started taking it and lots of money
  430. kept coming and we kept on expanding then one complaint kept coming saying that well
  431. grameen bank works because it gets a lot of money and that's what donors keeping it afloat
  432. i said no that's not true that's not what we were in we didn't need the money they gave the
  433. money so we took it so in 95 we decided not to take any money at all because we thought we can do it
  434. ourselves so from 95 on we never took any external money it's an entirely local money local thing
  435. so if you have to go back i would have changed that 82 decision never taken it never take any money so
  436. that that confusion was not created for a long time people said well the donor has to be there
  437. otherwise they cannot survive these are donor kind of uh supported program which stays alive
  438. i said that's a very wrong idea because that's not how we wanted to work and that's how to uh we never
  439. worked right so that's one change i thought i should have done i have one last question
  440. how do you define success just like any other case that whatever your objective was if you came to that
  441. your success it depends on what your objective was how do you relate it yes we made it
  442. in our case we wanted to bring credit to the poor people and the saving services to the poor
  443. people and people said it would never work we hope that it will work and it did and then say well it may work
  444. in one village it won't work for two villages we did they said maybe 10 villages it don't
  445. work if you grow big it will collapse you're stretching your luck too much we did
  446. so that is a success that even beyond what we imagined we never thought that we can
  447. continue uh with this such a repayment record years and years because organizations get weakened or
  448. as you grow big your management becomes a problem and this was a big worry for us as we
  449. grow can the quality of administration quality of management continue to grow with it or deteriorate
  450. it because you're not running it yourself anymore you're depending on hundreds and hundreds and thousands of
  451. young people who just came to know about it marginally knows about it we leave everything in their hands and
  452. the decisions but it worked and then say it may work in bangladesh it don't work outside
  453. so now as i said it's worked all over the country all over the world in many countries they said well our
  454. country is not like bangladesh we don't have such a huge density of population and not so
  455. much poverty concentrated in our population so in our country it won't work we said well you
  456. debate about your country in bangladesh give the task to us we go and do it for you and
  457. uh they accepted that many countries did that so we started doing that we did it
  458. in turkey we did in kosovo we do it in costa rica guatemala in china india many places to demonstrate those
  459. kind of things and we started one in new york city last year it's called grammy in america
  460. we do the same kind of work that we do in the villages of bangladesh and the beautiful results we have more than 600
  461. borrowers in new york city all women five-member group weekly repayment savings two dollars
  462. each week we have given loans to all of them an average loan is 2200 repayment rate is
  463. 99.3 percent no collateral nothing so it works uh i would say the id strength of the idea
  464. that it's not country specific or people of particular locations specific it's a global it's a human thing it's
  465. not something that works with one particular trait of character of a particular community
  466. thank you very much thank you thank you so much for joining us thank you well thank you for giving me this
  467. opportunity

Brief Summary

Muhammad Yunus discusses the for-profit microcredit model, its global impact, and the need for regulation in the banking industry.

Key points

  • Muhammad Yunus: A Visionary Leader. Yunus discusses the importance of a for-profit model in microfinance, emphasizing its role in empowering the poor.
  • Redesigning Financial Systems. Yunus highlights the opportunity presented by the global financial crisis to create a better system.
  • The Essence of Microcredit. Yunus explains that microcredit is a business with a social purpose, not a charity.
  • Grameen Health Management Centers. Introducing village-level health management centers focusing on prevention and early detection.
  • Grameen Danone's Social Business. Creating affordable yogurt with micronutrients for malnourished children.
  • Education Loans for Grameen Children. Providing education loans to help children pursue higher education.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes