NIL, Student Athlete Endorsements & the Future of the NCAA

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Can student athletes profit off of their own name, image, and likeness? Wharton’s Ken Shropshire weighs in on NIL and its impact on sports since a historic Supreme Court ruling brought it into the limelight in 2021. This episode is part of the "Back to School" series.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney_ It's a very uneven system that seems— seemingly is playing out where high-level football players, high-level basketball
  2. players seemingly are getting a lot of the attention and the resources from that. And some of the other athletes in other
  3. sports are not getting it. - Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of
  4. Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney. And in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the
  5. groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings resonate with the
  6. world today. - Well, as students gear up for the new school year and fall sports start to get back into session, we're going
  7. to spend some time today exploring the dynamic world of athletic endorsements. Pleasure to be joined here in studio by
  8. Ken Shropshire, Professor Emeritus of Legal Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School. He is also
  9. Senior Adviser to Dean Erica James. How are you, my friend? - I'm doing great, Dan, how are you? - Well. Okay, so
  10. I'm doing well. But this topic of endorsements and NIL obviously has taken the world of athletics, college athletics,
  11. by storm the last couple of years. We're about, I think, almost three years from when we first started to hear NIL
  12. really hit our language. What kind of impact do you think it's had in that three years, and to the positive or to the benefit
  13. of the overall collegiate athletic experience? It has had a huge disruptive impact, which I don't know if
  14. we gauge as positive or negative yet. It's an appropriate change. It's an appropriate disruptive change
  15. to have dollars that are coming into the system, to the labor that's produced it. And also, in some sense, you know, you're not
  16. giving these student athletes something new. It's something they really have the right to that the NCAA had taken away,
  17. this right to make money off of your name, image and likeness, which— which is sort of the beginning of what this thing
  18. was. It's evolved into something a little bit different than just what we think about. You referenced endorsements. It's
  19. turned out to be something a little different than what we contemplated it was going to be when these conversations first
  20. came, came into effect. - I'll get into the— what's going on at the college level. But I think
  21. there's also the component I wanted to talk to you about, about the expectation of what student athletes coming from
  22. high school going into college really should start to think about. Because it's a very uneven system that seems—
  23. seemingly is playing out, where high-level football players, high- level basketball players, seemingly, are getting a lot of
  24. the attention and the resources from that. And some of the other athletes in other sports are not getting it. And so I think the
  25. perception of what a student or what a parent should expect for their par— for their student, going into this
  26. situation, is important to talk about. That's right. And it's gonna vary to some degree, institution
  27. by institution. How important are the— especially in this Olympic year— how important are some of these Olympic sports to
  28. a school? Like swimming, gymnastics, whatever, which are not revenue-generating sports, for the most part, anywhere. But
  29. they may be part of the cachet of the school. And there may be a special interest in getting some elite athletes and
  30. providing some extra dollars to those recruits that are in that space. The traditional places where we think about this,
  31. with elite football players, elite basketball players, basketball men and women— you know, those kind of
  32. make a little bit of sense to people in terms of, you know, if there's a star player, and somebody wants them to endorse
  33. something, they should be able to get paid for that. Even with the Olympic sports, we start— thought in the beginning, "Well,
  34. you know, these kids can go home and give tennis lessons or swimming lessons. And they should be able to get paid for
  35. that. Or they can participate in these camps that are organized by the schools. And they should get paid for that." This— this
  36. NIL space, though, has become something completely different from what was originally contemplated. There was some original
  37. legislation in California that made this distinction between endorsement, licensing NIL, versus this idea of— the best way
  38. to phrase it is recruiting NIL. Just paying someone outright to join an institution. And that's where we'll see a
  39. little bit of the break where some schools say, "Yeah, we want to pay to recruit the swimmer, we're going to pay to recruit
  40. the gymnast," where some schools will say, "Well, you're not bringing any money in. So we're not looking to provide any of
  41. these dollars from these things called collectives to those students." - Then the question becomes,
  42. what should we expect to see play out in the years ahead, in terms of the investment from these
  43. collectives? Which, to a degree, it does feel a little bit like the old days of the under-the- table payments. You know, back
  44. in the day. You and I both well know, of— Neither of us received them, because— - No, no, no. We never got that.
  45. But the booster support that used to be there. And— and it feels a little bit like that, but maybe a little bit more
  46. structured. Because you have this quote-unquote "collective" component around it.
  47. Yeah. So the collectives have become exactly that. What is really above board old school booster payments to athletes
  48. that schools desire to recruit out of high school, that they want to retain— because of the transfer portal. They don't want
  49. their student athletes to leave. So we'll just make these payments to keep these students as part of— you know, Old, Great
  50. University, whatever— whatever it might be. So that's not what people contemplated this was going to be. But what happened
  51. when California, Florida, all these states began to pass legislation saying NIL is okay, the NCAA, for whatever
  52. reason— partly because there was a Supreme Court case, the Austin case, that said "You know what? You better allow some more
  53. revenues to go to these student athletes," the NCAA kind of froze. And then institutions started doing what they wanted
  54. to do, because there was no regulation by the NCAA. And that's when it flowed over from this whole idea of licensing to
  55. this idea of, "Hey, we can just give money to bring in student athletes that we want." - And the state law
  56. or regulation becomes that much more important in terms of what you can and can't do. And maybe what we will
  57. see play out in other states over the next several years. And it also makes me wonder, you know, again, are we seeing another
  58. layer to the control of the NCAA being whittled away because of this? We are. And the other piece that we are starting to see— well,
  59. some would surprised if it does happen— because the conversation's been going on for a while. Congress— Senator Cory Booker and others kind of—
  60. Senator Blumenthal, others leading the way. We need federal legislation to cover this. So we have this patchwork. Now it's
  61. about 27, or eight states that have regulations. We have the NCAA coming in every now and then. And this is a classic spot, as a—
  62. as a lawyer, where we understand federal legislation is to come in and make this kind of controversial issue uniform
  63. across— across the states. But the problem, I mean, as important as you and I might think it is because it's sports, there's a
  64. lot of other things going on in the world that Congress should be focused on, rather than how do we take care of these issues
  65. regarding athletes and payments? I was thinking about this the other day. But when you look at
  66. what has played out, I think there's also a case to be made that there's a "benefit"— and I use the term in air quotes— for
  67. the individual, for the student athlete, in the understanding of what this process is, and— and the component of their brand.
  68. Because I don't think it was discussed, you know, as much in years past. And it's probably something that most student
  69. athletes didn't even consider. That they actually have a brand that has some value, depending on, you know, where you are. And
  70. that's an important lesson to understand as you move forward and move your way through college and into the
  71. business world. No, that's exactly right. We do a program here at Wharton for NFL athletes. We started doing it again this year. It brought
  72. 36 athletes. One of the topics we have is understanding your brand. And the great professor Americus Reed comes in and talks
  73. to them about this value. And for some of them, it's the first time the light bulb's going off that "Hey, the way that I am
  74. projected out there may match with a company or some endorser, whoever. So I have to be cognizant of how I am out there."
  75. Now wouldn't it be great, or— you know, maybe, maybe not— the younger you start with thinking about that, the stronger your
  76. brand is, and the stronger you are in thinking about those kinds of issues, and being able to monetize them. So some of what
  77. started early on as NIL began to flurry— I know at Tennessee, Texas A&M, a couple other schools, they did
  78. incorporate instructors from their business schools and otherwise to talk to student athletes about this. Another
  79. piece that came into play, kind of related to what you're saying, is the idea of financial literacy, fluency. And so a
  80. number of investment companies joined schools to kind of deliver this info— you know, what do you do if you get $400
  81. extra a month, what should you do with it? Yeah. Right. Right. And it becomes that much more important for the— for the growth
  82. of the— of the college student. - Right. If you channel your 18-year-old Dan self,
  83. 400 extra a month, what are you gonna do with it? The answers probably are not— - That was— back in 1985, that that could be a dangerous question.
  84. I think also, do you have to look at this from how it could potentially impact high school athletes? Because there's even
  85. more of a conversation about the component of your name, image and likeness, as these young individuals are in high school.
  86. And obviously, there's the component of social media, everybody's on social media, and you're promoting yourself and
  87. things that you're doing on those different platforms. It makes me worried of how much farther this path goes. - Right.
  88. - In terms of the connection around NIL. Yeah. I tell people in this— in the sports space, the younger
  89. this athlete gets, the more we should be okay with being paternalistic. The more we should be okay with thinking, is
  90. this really the right thing for this young person to have? For example, as a eighth, ninth grader, to have businesses
  91. approaching them about having these relationships. Is— what kind of requirements can we have in there to make sure it goes
  92. through parents? All these things, the younger they get. But, you know, the idea where, push back when
  93. people are disturbed by, is, you know, everybody should have the right to make as much money as they can by legal means,
  94. especially from their name, image and likeness. So that's where we have to be careful. But I think it is okay to think
  95. about having more concern for how these— these young people are treated and what they learned in this process. - So
  96. then, what do you think is the path, then? I mean, is there a path to truly find a scenario that works for everybody? And
  97. you know, there is the benefit. - Right. - But you're also doing it in a landscape where the structure is complementary to
  98. the individual as well. - Yeah. Here's— here's what I think, in the end. So there are laws in
  99. place. For years, there have been laws in place, especially in California and New York, for regulating child actors, and,
  100. kind of the old Mickey Rooney stories and Judy Garland, how do you make sure these kids get their money in the end? So
  101. those regulations are— you know, they have never been perfect, as we— we've seen some kids grew up and— but— but they're
  102. tried and true, and probably the best that we're going to have. And at the higher end, the idea of— you know, there was one kid
  103. that was offered, apparently, you know, $14 million to come to Florida or Miami or one of the schools and, you know, ended up
  104. accepting nine somewhere else and didn't get paid that so he— lawsuits and all. The market will— this is a very Wharton answer.
  105. The market will eventually settle out. There's a lot of crazy stuff going on now. But if you— if you let the Wild Wild
  106. West take place for a while, and you let legislators try to figure out, "Where can we play in this? Oh, yeah, we have these
  107. existing laws, let's put these in place." And maybe there's some overlay of federal law that comes into play. But it's— but
  108. it's going to take time. But in the end, what we have is, the myth of amateurism has been exploded. - Yeah. - The idea that—
  109. that athletes should not receive revenue for their athletic ability at some age. All that's been pretty much blown out of
  110. the water. And, you know, with these Olympic Games coming up, it does remind us, again, why were we so concerned about
  111. keeping college athletes from receiving compensation when every other commercial we see, during the Olympics is
  112. one of these Olympic athletes that's out there performing? - It makes you wonder where we're headed with this in general,
  113. over the next handful of years, as this becomes more and more the landscape. Because I— you know, I'm a dad that's got three
  114. teenagers, two of which who might very well have a chance of playing college athletics. But I want to make sure that they're
  115. in a good framework, good set. And I think this also puts more pressure on the parents to really make sure that they have
  116. the framework in place so their— their young Johnny or Jane is prepared for this component of the college
  117. experience. Right? - And as parents— parents have to be in this. - Yeah. This this— it's not— this is another one of these things that,
  118. it's not— not easy. But it's important to allow it to move forward because it's going to
  119. take us to a better place than we were before than saying, absolutely, you can't receive anything.
  120. Is this the part of the downfall, then, longer term, of the NCAA as we move forward here?
  121. The NCAA— somebody told me years ago when I first got to Wharton, a professor had done some work, wrote a great, great book on the
  122. NCAA. And I talked to him. And this wasn't in the book. He said, "You know, in the end, the one thing the NCAA does great is runs
  123. championship tournaments." - Right. - So let us continue to find ways for the NCAA to focus on that. I mean, they lost the College
  124. Football Championship already. - Yeah. - But the basketball tournament, all these other tournaments, different
  125. divisions. They do a great job. So— so there's some level at which— and you almost compare the NCAA with, you know, the NFL,
  126. the League office is great at putting together schedules. - Right. - But don't— don't have them do
  127. the day to day running of a team. So— so there's— there's some— there's some movement that needs
  128. to take place. I don't think the NCAA is going away completely at any point. - Yeah. This association kind of setting for
  129. college sports is important. But there's a lot that they should not be involved in. - So it
  130. sounds like you're fairly optimistic on— on— well, and that's— that's a tough question, I think right now, because of
  131. all of the issues around the NCAA and around college. I mean, we're talking about a time where you have conference upheaval,
  132. and, you know, you don't know where you're going to be playing and all these different components, that, you know, if
  133. we can have some level of confidence about this component of college athletics moving forward, then at least we're
  134. taking at least one step in the right direction. - We're headed to a better place. Ivy sports, which have never had
  135. this big money problem in the modern era— but parenthetically, this was the place where the problem did exist historically.
  136. That— that sport is as exciting as it's been. And guess what the— the SEC and the Big 10 are as exciting as they've been, and
  137. there's plenty of upside for them. And they're gonna have a lot more money there, where the Ivies are gonna be kind of where
  138. they are. - Great seeing you again. Thank you. Ken Shropshire, who is Professor Emeritus in Legal
  139. Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School. - Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this
  140. episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring
  141. you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Ken Shropshire discusses the impact of NIL on college athletics and the evolving landscape of athletic endorsements.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Exploring the impact of NIL on collegiate athletics with Ken Shropshire.
  • NIL Disruption. NIL has had a huge disruptive impact on college athletics, changing the landscape.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes