Is College Football Becoming a Pro League?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE College football is changing fast. Are NIL deals, transfers, and expanded eligibility turning it into a professional league in all but name?

Steven Godfrey, college football journalist and co-host of Yahoo's College Football Enquirer, explains the financial forces reshaping the sport. He examines players weighing college earnings against NFL opportunities, the future of eligibility rules, conference power, coaching pressure, and which teams have the clearest path to a national championship.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics
  2. here on the Wharton Podcast Network. This is Cade Massey hosting this week with one of my three long-time collaborators.
  3. Eric Bradlow is my co-host for the day. Eric's sitting in his office in West Philadelphia.
  4. I'm coming to you from Austin. Our two collaborators, Shane Jensen and Audie Weiner
  5. are out doing Shane and Audie things. They'll be back as you guys know, some combination of us are here almost every week
  6. of the year, 48, 49 weeks of the year, and have been for more than 12 years now.
  7. We are recording on Tuesday afternoon. We're going to use our usual format, guests
  8. in the first half of the show. If you're watching, you know it's football season
  9. because Stephen Godfrey is here with us. We'll introduce Stephen in a moment. We're going to do him for the first
  10. half hour. We'll do open lines in the second half hour. Stephen is a long-time friend of the
  11. show. He's been doing shows during the season, but especially our preview, our college football preview shows
  12. for years now. He's our first college football guest of the year. Stephen, we're glad to have you.
  13. Thanks for being here. Thank you for having me, as always. It's kind of a little August tradition we
  14. got going now. We do. I love the August tradition. You guys can catch. I want to share some of the places
  15. you can catch Stephen's work. He is the longtime founder of Split Zone Duo. I hear him all the time on Yahoo's
  16. College Football Inquirer show, which I think is one of the best ones out there.
  17. Andy Staples and Ross Dellinger are the co -hosts on that, which gives me the bonus
  18. of hearing three guys with Southern accents talk about college football, which adds a little flavor.
  19. Stephen also has his Fandom Island podcast going. He does that with Ryan Nanny. It's a little bit more liberal take, wider
  20. ranging take on his show. He's got an innovation on that show. He's got words and numbers, numbers and words.
  21. Tell us about this new... Numbers and words. Numbers and words. Okay. Talk about that.
  22. So, yeah, so we launched Fandom Island, and we're in our second year. And the first thing that we wanted to
  23. do, kind of as career football or college football professionals, was to widen the breadth of
  24. what we would discuss, ask a question that exists within the paradigm of the sports world
  25. and leave it that broad. Our first episode, I believe, was about the financial future of the Live Golf Tour.
  26. And then I think our third episode was WNBA refereeing. So we really wanted to stretch.
  27. But what we found was we still have that hardcore audience that wants to know about
  28. the backup left tackle at University X, Y, and Z. And so what we've done is we've cordoned
  29. them off and say, like, all right, if you want to do this, we're going to come directly over here.
  30. So we have a new show called Numbers and Words, which is, you know, I've got a couple different takes on describing it.
  31. You know, I've said, hey, it's like auditing a 300 level class with an idiot, and
  32. I'm the idiot. It is an aggressive attempt at having an intelligent conversation about football.
  33. It's a lot of the usual suspects that we've had over the years, Parker Fleming, Bill
  34. Connolly. We're going to have our friend Dan Casey, who comes from a quantitative side.
  35. He's going to be on a couple future episodes. He's a couple coaches. I don't want to spoil who.
  36. He is. I mean, he has written multiple books from sort of the, I would say, the sort
  37. of the young schematic coaching perspective and has kind of made a living in media explaining
  38. and demystifying schematic concept for average fans. And so it's a little bit of, hey,
  39. let's take this jargon and unravel it a little bit. Let's introduce advanced concepts one at a time
  40. and let's get people better educated while also having an intelligent conversation about what's going on
  41. in the world of football. And it's high school, it's NFL, it's college, it's all of it.
  42. Like it doesn't necessarily have to be college football, but it's non-dogmatic. Okay.
  43. Stephen, one question that sounds so much like it's less focused on college football, but it
  44. sounds like your old podcast with podcasting played nobody with Bill Connolly. Yeah.
  45. Bill, old Bill Connolly shows back up. Okay. But what is the, why you, what is your connection?
  46. What is your interest? Because you always talk about you're the idiot. You didn't take math or whatever.
  47. And yet you're the guy that had that show with Bill, which was phenomenal. And now you're pursuing that angle again here.
  48. So what is, where are you coming from? I get really restless with sports content.
  49. I get really restless with sports journalism. So my background is obviously not quantitative.
  50. I don't, you know, I've made a thousand jokes on this show and others about being
  51. bad at math, at least in sort of a classroom setting. But I met Bill when we were on
  52. the same staff at Vox Media at SB Nation and often found myself translating Bill by
  53. being willing to ask questions that other people didn't want to, because one of the frustrations
  54. that I have with my journal, capital J journalism colleagues, is that there is this new
  55. thing in our generation and especially in the younger generation of journalists to act like you
  56. have all the answers. And that's not my job. My job is not to be an expert. My job is to ask questions and my
  57. job is to better educate the people who are listening, tuning in, reading, whatever the platform
  58. might be. And so I make a lot of jokes that are self-deprecating, but by doing so,
  59. I'm lowering the inhibitions of the people I'm talking to, and I'm lowering the inhibitions of
  60. the audience. Because if I'm willing to say, hey, I have no idea what you're talking about, right?
  61. And I say this like, and I say that a lot to people, or hey, let me, I'm pretty good at pattern recognition.
  62. I'm pretty good at predicting, especially when it comes to, in conversation especially, I don't know
  63. what that is, but I think it's just a long career of being a writer and a reporter and being on whatever hemisphere of
  64. the brain that is. So I'm pretty good at predicting conversational structure. And so when people revert back to the
  65. jargon, or I have a lot of people who are experts in some form of data analysis or just statistics or whatever, they get
  66. really kind of nervous and they want to come on and I've got this really complex
  67. thing, but like, it's, hey, slow down. We're gonna have a dinner party. All right?
  68. We're gonna have a dinner party and the audience is going to be here. I'm going to point to one side of
  69. the camera, and then you're going to be here. And my job is to make sure that everyone stays engaged at the dinner party.
  70. And good media is, that is the conceit. That is the goal. It is not that I look good.
  71. It is not that I am the smartest person in the world. I learned this embedding with college coaches early
  72. on in my career. Finally, I learned it the hard way, where I was sad as a... Real quick, you said embedding, you didn't say
  73. embedding, you said embedding like a German... No, embedding, E-M-B-E-D-D -I-N-G.
  74. I would, early on in my career as a young... When I got on the national beat, I was working for a dot-com at the
  75. time that didn't have the kind of like gilded credentials of a Sports Illustrated or an
  76. ESPN. So I made a lot of bets on non-traditional storytelling. So Alabama wouldn't give me access the way
  77. I wanted to, or the way maybe like SI would. So I would go to Alabama's homecoming opponent,
  78. Western Kentucky, and I would spend eight days with that coaching staff, trying to see what
  79. it looked like to prepare for Alabama. You know what's funny about that, Cade? I say that the GA that they stuck
  80. me with in the pool, in the desks, the week that that happened, is now the head coach at Oregon State, Jamarcus Shepard.
  81. So like these people all grow up. But I finally sat there. I remember sitting there one night, a veteran
  82. defensive coordinator named Lance Guidry has been everywhere. And he was talking about, oh, you know,
  83. we're going to do this and then we're going to banjo. I had full access, right? He's walking me through everything.
  84. And finally I said, hey, what is banjo? And in that moment, I thought like, oh, I'm gonna get kicked out of the club,
  85. but I'm not a football coach. It was never my job to learn it. It's like my job is to communicate complex
  86. systems and ideas to as wide an audience as possible so that the public can better
  87. understand them. And so when you, the moment, and I'm ranting now about journalism, but the moment you
  88. lay down your ego, it's the same device Shakespeare used. The idiot was always telling you the story
  89. in every Shakespeare, every Shakespearean play. There is an idiot in a comedy, especially,
  90. or tragedy, but mainly in the comedies, they are actually setting the pace of the narrative
  91. structure. And that's my job. So I'll gladly say, like, and by the way, I did fail math 267 at Ole
  92. I think three times. Part of that was because I didn't show up. I mean, it wasn't necessarily, it wasn't necessarily
  93. that stupid. It was because 22-year-old me was a little different. You had other things going on.
  94. I apparently did. Well, that's actually a revealing answer, because that posture is not the posture of a traditional
  95. journalist. And we certainly run it. We've seen it in lots of places, more hostility, somewhere between neglect and hostility towards the
  96. world. And you do have a different posture. I want to ask another media question of
  97. you. We'll eventually talk college football, but I did have another, a general thought coming into this
  98. conversation, thinking about the various podcast efforts you have now and have had over the years,
  99. and the number of shows you do with Dellinger and Staples and the match I'll cover.
  100. Talk about nerds. Well, how do you, how do you think about allocating your time across your whole professional
  101. portfolio, like writing versus podcasting now in 2026? How do you optimize that?
  102. How do you think about it? So we're doing a podcast right now, but we're on camera.
  103. Yeah. Okay. And none of us, none of us went to college for this. Right. None of us, none of us sought this
  104. out. Right. So the platform evolves at such a pace that I don't know if we'll ever keep
  105. up anymore. I was a magazine journalist. I was a print journalism magazine, emphasis English
  106. minor. Yeah. And I'm not that old. I'm not, it's not, I'm not talking about it. I stepped on campus in 1972.
  107. No, this was recently, like somewhat recently. I have three kids now, but the platform
  108. has evolved and you, you need to meet the audience where they're at. The evolution of podcasting specifically in both audio
  109. and video form have sort of conjured this parasocial dynamic. So a very dedicated audience that I'm a
  110. very appreciative of. And it's, but it changes the relationship. You can be a long time reader of
  111. a journalist or a writer, a columnist, analyst, whatever. I am with people in their most intimate
  112. moments. That sounds weird or funny, but what I've learned about podcasting is it's, it's, it's an
  113. extraordinary reach into their lives. It's jogging. It's that moment of silence.
  114. It's mowing the lawn. It's washing the dishes. It's sitting in the commute that they don't
  115. want to. It's, it's, you're alone with them. You're alone with them. Yeah. Yeah.
  116. Yeah. But for you. Yeah. And so that's the biggest difference. As far as balancing, some of it is
  117. just meeting the market, right? I have, like I said, I got three kids. They don't get any cheaper.
  118. I've learned. So it is running, trying to run a successful business. Becoming a business owner.
  119. That's also something they did not tell me what happened in journals. I would look, man, I was supposed to
  120. be making a very, very comfortable cushy six figure gig as a celebrated feature writer.
  121. And you know, a takeout writer, we used to say in the magazine world, that's what
  122. I was going to do. Six of those a year, win a bunch of awards, get that with a sport coat
  123. with the on my elbows. Um, and the fat expense account, you know, like, uh, like they did in the eighties
  124. and that there's a great book called the sports writer by Richard Ford, which is an
  125. exact, which is not exactly about sports journalism, but it describes this life.
  126. Oh, and like how much he got paid by the word. Good Lord. Uh, the world changed.
  127. The world changed is the answer. And again, to go back to ego, if you, I know a lot of my counterparts
  128. are like, I would never podcast. I'm a writer and I'm like, cool. I got a mortgage.
  129. And also the audience wants to be here. And the idea that we can't work in complex thought just because we're on a microphone
  130. to me is so short-sighted. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Uh, one other state of the world question
  131. as we wait in the college football, I was raised on college football in west Texas
  132. on the early Dallas Cowboys, pretty good years of long horns been going to games all
  133. my life. Uh, yep. In the same high school district as Friday night lights, all that stuff.
  134. I got it hard. Cool. So you're from like Odessa, Permian wet, like proper West Angeles, San Angelo, just east of
  135. high school district back in the day. But I think it's possible that at age 59, I'm beginning to care a little bit
  136. less than it's not just wisdom and maturity. I think it's the change. I wore, I think I might be carrying
  137. a little bit less and I'm sad about that. And I'm curious whether I might be representative,
  138. but like this stuff that hopefully is going to get, it hasn't been nipped in the
  139. bud, but hopefully it gets nipped eventually about professional players coming back.
  140. And I realized it's a five-year thing. It's like a moment, but still the fact that Lane Kiffin is out there actively recruiting
  141. professional players to come back and play college football, nevermind that their former Ole Miss players
  142. that are transferring from your alma mater to LSU, this is all just new levels of
  143. insanity. It's like, you know, it's like Veep was amazing as a sitcom for a while until
  144. the world passed it. And then Veep wasn't interesting. It's hard to watch Veep. So I was on an international flight two
  145. weeks ago and I, and you know, you're hitting the Delta thing and you're like running
  146. out of things to watch in eight hours. And I watched the first season of Veep, some of it, and you're, you're exactly right
  147. because it's, it, the, the pair, the writing is exceptional, but the parody doesn't hold.
  148. No, no. So then say the college football reality has passed any possible parody at this point.
  149. It's past it just like Veep. I feel like you're, I feel like you're tempting fate there.
  150. I am. Well, that's true. Because I don't, I don't know if we've hit the bottom. This is what I'm asking you.
  151. What's going to happen next? What's going to happen next? Go ahead. Things can calm down.
  152. So this specific instance that cropped up in the last 48 hours ish is actually a
  153. loophole in the process of closing. And it is the NCAA's fault. Here's why. The fastest way to explain this is the
  154. NCAA did not want to issue a waiver for that 2022 class when they were closing out the COVID exception and then that the
  155. six-year rule. And so we knew in the industry, this challenge was going to come legally from athletes.
  156. Between either the unlikely passage of the save college sports acts or whatever that stupid thing
  157. is called and or the advent of a proper collective bargaining agreement and or legislation at
  158. the conference level, it's enforced by the states. One of those things is going to stop
  159. the specific instance of a professional player in the NFL specifically going to these colleges back
  160. going back to these colleges because this is different than any of the myriad scandals that
  161. we've talked about. A scandal lowercase because I think it's very subjective. This is different than Brendan Soresby in Texas
  162. Tech. This is different than the NIL. This is different than the portal because this
  163. has public consensus against it. And none of those things did. I was on the side of player agency
  164. early, early, early on in my career to the point where I kind of got blacklisted
  165. by a couple organizations, you know, for writing about the bag man, all that kind of
  166. stuff. This is more similar to the Charles Bettiacco situation, was the basketball player that left the
  167. NBA's G League to go back to the university or attempt to sort of re-enroll at the University of Alabama this past basketball
  168. season. Unlike, let's say, Trinidad Chambliss petitioning and suing to get an extra year of eligibility where
  169. there was this really weird and sort of semantic interpretation of a medical redshirt season that
  170. he had at Division II Ferris State. There's no one side versus another here. The consensus that we see in our viewership,
  171. like on the Yahoo show, within the industry, amongst the executive leadership, within the agents, within
  172. the coaches, nobody likes this. No one likes this. And usually when you have a with enough
  173. at risk to stamp this out. Now, the NCAA has fumbled easier procedures before. I have faith in their inability.
  174. But this one feels like it's an open and shut case. So let me, Stephen, let me just ask
  175. a question about that. Yeah. Let's imagine part of the reason someone might do this, it could be because of NIL
  176. money, but it could be also to enhance one's professional career, maybe personal brand, etc.
  177. If at the end of the day, colleges, you just saw the big 10 said no. But if colleges don't like this and advertisers
  178. don't like this, why would a player choose to do this if this is going to be like, this is one of those people
  179. that went back. I'm not drafting them the second time. I'm an advertiser. They've got a stain next to them.
  180. I'm not going to pay them. Someone has to like this. It's a little bit more nuanced.
  181. It's very, very short sighted. So let's look at Xavier on Harris for a second. And everyone like Todd Monk and the head
  182. coach of the Browns is talking about like, hey, isn't this a screwed up world or
  183. whatever that quote was last week. So you have a tight end plays very well for Ole Miss last year in Lane
  184. Kiffin's offense. He's in camp with the Browns. I need to be clear because a lot
  185. of people are misinterpreting this in social media and also like this is the stuff I
  186. get at like the school pickup line now, like when I'm picking my kids, like people
  187. are like, what the hell? You know, kind of. It used to be like, when's Florida State
  188. going to the big 10? And now it's this. Florida State's not going to the big 10,
  189. by the way. I mean, they could. They're a great research institution. This kid got cut by the Browns, right?
  190. Yeah. There is a fine. There's an immediate short term financial opportunity. I would say that a tight end cut
  191. by the Browns indicates that his football career is short sighted. I don't think Eric, he would have another
  192. a second bite at the apple unless he did something truly phenomenal. I'm going to be honest with you from
  193. we were talking about this. We recorded the College Football Enquirer on Yahoo this morning.
  194. He may not be the best tight end on the roster if he clears and is eligible at LSU.
  195. This is a depth play. Kiffin is always I mean, he's a megalomaniac and he's, you know, probably textbook sociopathic.
  196. And I'm not I'm not being hyperbolic. Lane Kiffin. No, I mean, like I've been around the
  197. man like I've covered like I'm just I'm telling you, I'm up for explanations. So please, thank you.
  198. He's doing this. He's doing this for for a couple different reasons, but one of which right now is
  199. there's a there's a tremendous anxiety setting in because that roster is not ready for primetime
  200. and the expectation level in accordance with the finances for for Kiffin's first year at LSU.
  201. We're going to have it. We're going to have a rough time, guys. I'm not saying that this is a six
  202. win team necessarily, but it's not a 12 win team. And so he's betting in the short term
  203. on let's burn through the resources that I'm afforded here at LSU by getting guys that
  204. I'm veteran like that are veteran players for me who I there are known quantities in
  205. my system immediately. And let's let's also he's he said a couple of things recently about depth that you
  206. get the like I've been doing this long enough to know that when a coach is getting ready to prep his excuses and that's
  207. what it feels like. Yeah, so that so that I don't that tight end tight ends probably expected value is
  208. maybe close to zero. So why not go back to LSU? Maybe he can make money a great season,
  209. maybe gets NIL dollars or not. But then, you know, at least his odds of going to the NFL are higher than
  210. zero. Right. Eric, are you a Jets fan? Sure. Let's pretend. Okay. If I'm a Jets fan, I'm far more
  211. concerned with the Dante Moore situation during the NFL draft than I am with this.
  212. I get I get the unpalatable part of this. I do. Normally I side with player agency and their
  213. ability to make a living off of their athletic ability for as long as they can. But this is hitting a firewall.
  214. This is the third rail. This is the sort of point of no return of like, you know, playing in the
  215. NFL one day and going back. We don't like that. If I'm an NFL fan and if I'm an NFL GM and I've talked to I
  216. talked to an assistant GM who called me over the summer about this. They're kind of whining now.
  217. They're like our draft pool is getting older. The running backs have more tread on the
  218. tire or less tread on the tires. And my response to that is. Pay better, like if Dante Moore has a
  219. financial imperative to play one more year at Oregon, regardless, his draft stock was high.
  220. I want to be clear. This is not about a junior and I'm projected third. And if I if I really if I
  221. really knock the eyes out of this season, I'm going to be rejected first. No, no, no, no, no, no.
  222. It's the opposite. Dante Moore would have been a top five pick in the NFL draft.
  223. Right. And in a certain circumstance, he might have been the overall pick. He turned that down because the finances at
  224. Oregon made more sense. He could go win a championship. And like you can make a joke about
  225. the Jets or the Browns or like a sort of historically woeful franchise and not wanting
  226. to play for them. I get that. But I don't think that was the Jets part of it. I don't think had any bearing on Dante
  227. Moore. I think it was a it was smarter for him to have that bird in the hand. Let's say it was six million or seven
  228. million or whatever. That was more than the rookie season of a contract as a first rounder would have
  229. paid under that NFL PA negotiated rookie wage scale. That is more concerning if you're an NFL
  230. fan or an NFL GM. This is just some hysteria that I that I'm confident is going to go away.
  231. But I also don't want to like dismiss the the weirdness. So I live in Nashville the two nights
  232. ago. I took my two oldest kids to the Titans Seahawks game. Got really good tickets.
  233. Kids got to be like close to field level. It was as close they'd ever been to the speed and the physicality NFL game.
  234. That's why I went. I like I'm justifying that I went to a Titans preseason game.
  235. I feel like I kind of have to, you know, to keep my credibility. Yes. Terrible football.
  236. By the way, Seahawks twos annihilated the Titans ones. It is amazing to see the difference in
  237. talent. It's insane. There was a running back and I can't remember his name now.
  238. Hankerson, third string running back for the Seahawks that night. Doesn't matter.
  239. Right. Second, third quarter, we're eating popcorn. We're watching this. The guy has like 10 carries, you know,
  240. whatever. It's preseason. The next day he went to the he went into the transfer portal and it really
  241. hit me. It really, for whatever reason, I've covered this for a while, but I took my kids.
  242. One of my kids is kind of into the Seahawks and he's got his Jackson Smith and Jigba jersey and he's watching warmups.
  243. Okay. This is the Texas fan. So you gotta, you gotta do a better job recruiting.
  244. I don't know what's going on here. This is tough. Yeah, it is tough. He and then there's a player for the
  245. Seattle Seahawks, the defending world champions who sought it out to at least give this guy,
  246. I think he had like 10 carries in an NFL preseason game. And then, yeah, he's going to get caught.
  247. He might get picked up if it's 10 years ago, he's going to be on the practice squad, right?
  248. Maybe. Or he's going to bounce around. No, he played it. I think he played it like Oregon state.
  249. He's going to go and probably sign maybe low power for a group of six, whatever we want to determine the new PAC 12
  250. to be kind of. He might make a million and a half bucks. He might make 2 million bucks this year.
  251. 2 million might be on the high end, but like, you know, I guarantee you he makes at least six figures and I guarantee
  252. you it'd be more than sticking around on a practice squad. Yeah, right. And a better life probably as well.
  253. That's amazing. Okay. This is helpful. Even hearing your take on Lane is helpful.
  254. So thank you for all of that. Now let's talk a little bit of actual football. I'm going to hit you.
  255. Let's do some quick questions. And I realized that a number of my questions were big.
  256. This tells you how different the world is. My first four questions are all big 10.
  257. So rapid fire on big 10. Lincoln, do you believe in Lincoln Riley as SC back? I believe that this is the fulcrum.
  258. I believe this is the assessment year. And I believe as goes the SC season, so goes the coaching carousel.
  259. I can give you a much longer answer, but there is an aggressive evaluation underway at
  260. Heritage Hall. And if you had to bet, Stephen, God forbid, if you decide that seesaw goes.
  261. There are a lot of marriages at the top end of college football where the spouses
  262. are better off elsewhere right now. And one could imagine Lincoln going back to Lubbock in a certain situation.
  263. Wow. Okay. Interesting. All right. They've also got a tough schedule that can't be in his favor and the way people
  264. get evaluated, right? I mean, that's. I don't think he was a great cultural fit from jump, regardless of the status or
  265. the state of SC football, which I know was not great. And they suffer from a lot of nonsense.
  266. Like that's a, that's a, how do I say this nicely? It's not a functional work. Kade, you know what it is?
  267. It's Texas 15 years ago. It's worse. It's worse. It's Texas worse. Yeah. Okay. I'm glad somebody's got it worse.
  268. Follow up to that. Is there a counterfactual world where there's like, I don't know, a better coach that they
  269. can get? So I always think you there. Okay. Then. All right. I'll be honest with you, Eric, Jenko and
  270. the athletic director at SC hired Kaitlin to board Washington. And they love each other.
  271. And if there's one, it's not a bad coach. And if there's one thing, if there's one
  272. misrepresented asset or a misunderstood dynamic right now, it is that Kaitlin DeBoer is an exceptional
  273. head coach. But when you follow Nick Saban and the entire fundamental rules of the game change, you
  274. are never going to get your flowers. Right. Right. It was going to be bad enough without
  275. the games changing. And he got both of those changes. So beat the posse, as they say in
  276. West Texas. All right. More big 10 rapid fire expectations out of Penn State, your expectations for Penn State this
  277. year. They're a little bit off the radar. There's so many strong teams at the top
  278. of the big 10. They're a little below radar. But I wonder if they can surprise people.
  279. Yes. In the short term, I've always liked Campbell. I think this is the ideal big time
  280. job for him. I think FACT is a great quarterback. He's solid. And I think all of the problems that
  281. plagued the last iteration of that James Franklin swan song, it's the exact opposite dynamic in
  282. Happy Valley. I think the concerns that I might have would be longer term. And I would need to see like actual
  283. work product from the Campbell era in Penn State to even really apply concern to them.
  284. I like the hire a lot, which is hard to say usually when you have such a long and winding search because the search
  285. did not go well. The search, Penn State's done a good job, I think, obfuscating that in the offseason.
  286. But the search was bad. Yeah. But they got so lucky in the end. So just related to that, isn't the like
  287. when I think about Penn State and I'm married to a Penn Stater, isn't the skill level just an aggregate like less than Ohio
  288. State? And is there any short run world where that's not true? And is that gap a better way to
  289. frame it? Is the gap big enough that in some sense, let's be realistic about what Penn State
  290. can really do? OK, so the that you've hit upon the existential problem at Penn State for the last
  291. 25 years as we've entered the modern era, which is Ohio State is the measurement.
  292. And then you're trying to identify your deficiency. Is it financial? Is it personnel?
  293. Is it the combination thereof? Is it a leadership philosophy? Franklin for a long time traded very healthily
  294. on I don't think that's a word. We don't have this and that's why I lost this big game.
  295. Look at Penn State. He said this off the record. To every colleague of mine in the National
  296. College football scene author, it was immediately like look what they've got in Columbus.
  297. Look what they've got in Ann Arbor. That's what we need here. So you know the deep irony of that
  298. is he was really truly handed. I would say a comparable set of assets in 25 and then you saw the result.
  299. I think Franklin's better off as a disruptor. Sort of like you know he's much better
  300. off trying to doing the upstart bit than he is managing a legacy brand. Now that being said, Penn State had to
  301. learn some really hard lessons during the Franklin era. I think Campbell's going to be a better
  302. cultural fit there. Great. OK, another coaching change over the season in the Big 10 Cal Cunningham.
  303. Yes, setting aside maybe modest expectations for Michigan this year. How good is that fit and what are
  304. your expectations for Michigan going forward? This has been a great era for Big 10 football.
  305. Might it be the case that Michigan is actually going to step right up and be at the same level within the next year
  306. or two because of Whittingham? Yeah, so I'm really bullish on Whittingham because
  307. he was undervalued. I think by virtue of where he was, which is we have a geographic bias in
  308. this sport that is unlike anything else I've ever seen. I mean, it really is dumbest.
  309. It is to go back to Moneyball as a concept, right? When I'll just use the film because it's
  310. the most common example, like you're discounting an athlete on the way they look.
  311. In college sports, we so often discount the equity of a coach or the value of a leader, usually not so much an athlete,
  312. more in the coaching world. If they're out West, there's a weird invisibility West of the Rockies.
  313. I cannot explain it. I don't endorse it. It is the dumbest damn thing I've ever seen.
  314. I watch it at the coaching convention every year. Oh, he's a West Coast guy. What the hell does that mean?
  315. Does West Coast football not translate if you're in the Midwest or the South or the
  316. North? I don't understand it, but I think Whittingham has not received the level that he deserves
  317. of, I don't know, regard? And I think he's going into the perfect situation with a distressed asset in Michigan.
  318. The smartest thing here for Michigan to do, because they're also searching for an AD simultaneously,
  319. is to stop thinking that every Michigan created problem needs a Michigan solution.
  320. And they're finally breaking out of that sort of intellectual inbreeding of the Michigan man, the
  321. Michigan man. Go out and get the best player available, right? AD, best player available.
  322. Coach, dude from Utah who did not have any affiliation with the university, but is incredibly
  323. well prepared for this job. That's why I'm bullish on them. And also, I mean, there's no finesse or
  324. fancy way to say this. If you've watched Kyle Whittingham coach teams, they are exceptionally violent in the most effective way
  325. possible. Okay. Yeah. That sounds about right. Is there any chance he surprises this year,
  326. year one, with a questionable quarterback? No, I think they could go to the playoff.
  327. I mean, I think if there's the Mendoza line for playoff eligibility in the Big Ten,
  328. I think it's Michigan-USC floating at the line, for sure. Okay. Okay. I'm going to continue rapid-firing in the
  329. interest of time, but I got a- Is that a pun with the Mendoza line? It really isn't.
  330. I've been trained on that phrase as a kid. No, no. I know the other phrase, too.
  331. I was just asking. Mendoza line is, it was a, was he a Pirates player? I can't remember who Mendoza was now.
  332. I don't have- Could be, but batting 200, that's the Mendoza line. Batting 200, right?
  333. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I just always heard my dad say that when I was a kid.
  334. I was just referring to the- Yeah, but I was raised a Braves fan, so we're- I can also see what's next
  335. on Cade's list, so that's why- Okay. Oh, okay, okay. I'm going to skip. I'm going to skip.
  336. They've got enough attention, besides on, we don't need to do Indiana. Let's do SEC, outside of Texas and Georgia,
  337. who are kind of a consensus top two, who do you like best out of the next set of contenders?
  338. And you've already told us this, Mel. Non-Texas, non-Georgia? Non-Georgia, non-Texas.
  339. Oh, man. Cade, that's a good one. I have a lot of, to go back to the Mendoza line, I have a lot
  340. of on-the-cusp case studies for playoff inclusion. So it's a lot of questions about Oklahoma.
  341. I would put A&M above Oklahoma. The talent, the core of talent is still there at Ole Miss.
  342. They have kind of refit that offensive staff to provide as smooth a transition away from
  343. Kiffin and Weiss as possible, so you would include them. I spend more of my time in the
  344. SEC looking at new programs. Florida, Auburn specifically, I think Kentucky is going
  345. to be a really interesting study in the next two or three years. You like the new coach that much?
  346. I think Will Stein is great, but I think that Kentucky woke up and looked across
  347. the state line at a basketball rival and said, that's replicable. Oh, interesting.
  348. Okay. One of the funny things about the state of Kentucky is that historically, the only boosters
  349. who cared as much about football as basketball were just the far east Kentucky, the Cole
  350. contingent. You'd see these license tags in Kentucky that say, Friends of Cole. And over the last 10 years, as that
  351. relationship got really bad between the AD, Mitch Barnhart, and the former coach, Mark Stoops, football's
  352. importance and relevance started to really take hold amongst one of the signature basketball fan bases
  353. in all of America. And what I mean by that is the relevant, like you will survive the breaking apart
  354. of conferences and the inevitable march to a super league if you are good in football
  355. from a revenue and television standpoint. It is the strongest magnet to pull you
  356. out of a problem. Indiana knew this when they invested the way they did so aggressively.
  357. And I think Kentucky's kind of looking around and saying, well, we are in the Southeastern
  358. Conference. So it's just one to keep an eye on for two years. And I like the staff he assembled.
  359. Well, that's interesting in that you're emphasizing the importance of institutional support, which never has been
  360. more important in the age of- I ducked your question, though. Third best in the SEC?
  361. Yeah, basically. I think you're on A&M at the moment. Who can I make mad right now?
  362. Ole Miss. Ole Miss or A&M is where you came out. It's technically Alabama. Oh, you didn't mention Alabama.
  363. It's just the volatility of that situation in terms of institutional support for DeBoer is there.
  364. But the impatience of that fan base, and they just named, oh my gosh, this morning,
  365. it's not Austin Mack. It's the other kid that's more talented, allegedly, and apparently made it a very easy decision.
  366. They just named the starting quarterback there, Williams, I think, who's less experienced.
  367. There's gonna be a lot of inexperienced quarterback play in the SEC this year. So you're going to see volatility.
  368. So let me ask a related question to that. We've heard for years that it's hard for
  369. non-Power 2 schools to get non-conference games scheduled. But now that the playoffs have expanded, do
  370. you think A, we'll see more of that? And second, I was just thinking about last year's national championship game.
  371. How happy are you if you're Miami? Let all these other teams play real games during the regular season.
  372. We'll sweep up the ACC. Oh, Lord, Eric. No, I'm just saying the ACC, on average,
  373. is not as good as those other conferences. So all they have to do is win that ACC, maybe even come in second, probably
  374. not. But all they have to do is win that, then they're in. And then you know what?
  375. Then the real Miami can show up. Wouldn't you rather be them than Alabama right now?
  376. No, I think the ACC is like, you're just happy if you don't get food on your clothes when you eat, if you're the
  377. ACC. They can't even determine a conference champion. They were so desperate to not be picked
  378. apart in the last round of realignment that they made structural additions and decisions that are
  379. essentially impossible to govern. They've painted themselves into a corner in logistics.
  380. I believe they have approximately 41 teams now. But the problem is— From 41 states.
  381. That's the problem. The sport is so stupid. I mean, the two Bay Area teams are in the Atlantic Coast Conference.
  382. SMU was a really sharp addition. If we were to talk about the ACC for a second, actually, I think SMU is
  383. doing every single thing right, because their ambition and their capital are aligned.
  384. Back to institutional support. With their ambition. Yeah, they saw the opportunity.
  385. They were unabashed about it. They really pushed that thing forward. Absolutely.
  386. And yeah, I think, Eric, to your point, it is easier to a certain degree, but I think you're going to lose the benefit
  387. of that doubt in playoff seating. Because the flip side to Miami, who played really good defense when it mattered most in
  388. the postseason, the flip side is they were on, again, the Mendoza line, the cut line,
  389. of playoff inclusion. Remember, if you flip the Notre Dame-Miami result, we have a very, very different situation.
  390. So the problem with the coasting mentality for a Texas Tech or a Miami, you include
  391. maybe SMU, BYU, Clemson and Florida State are so down right now, I wouldn't include them
  392. at the moment. But the problem there is that you don't really have a mulligan. You don't really get to mount the argument
  393. that my four-loss schedule was worthy of inclusion to the postseason. Your margin for error is basically nil, especially
  394. in the Big 12. I was also going to ask you, Kate, I'm sure Massie, Peabody, or all the ranking
  395. systems have to think about this. Like, obviously, being in the top four of the playoffs is great because you get a
  396. bye. And so we think, yeah, for an ACC, they've lost. They've lost them all. No, they lost them all.
  397. Indiana won their bye last year, and that's it. Yeah. My only comment was, like, this is to
  398. Stephen's point. Miami may have a better chance of getting in, but a lower chance of being a
  399. top four. So on the one hand, they're in the dance. But on the other hand, they're not going
  400. to get a bye. So which way do the odds, in some sense, those two factors, in some sense, work
  401. against each other? Yes. So I'm just asking, though, even though they may have a higher probability of getting into
  402. the tournament, they may have a lower probability of getting a bye, which lower basically cuts
  403. in half at best their probability of winning the whole thing. That's all I want to know.
  404. Yes. And this is also where we have to incorporate the conversation about conference championships, because the
  405. irrelevance of the conference championship game is increasing. While the product might be good, Georgia-Texas
  406. was a banger, as the kids say. Ohio State-Indiana was must-watch television last
  407. year. And we know the market value because we've seen those individual games sold off by their
  408. partners. So we know what they fetch, and it's a lot. But the problem is, I think they're counterintuitive
  409. to a national championship campaign. If they're not counterintuitive, they are a tremendous
  410. nuisance. I would say a legit injury concern. Kade, that Georgia-Texas game two years ago
  411. was about the sort of, again, to use a scientific term, the thumpingest game that I've
  412. seen in a long time that didn't matter. Like the physicality of those lines on both
  413. sides against one another, and then the kind of wear and the injuries that I think
  414. affected. I mean, they affected Georgia more. The knockback out, right? Right. So they affect Georgia more going into the
  415. Sugar against Notre Dame that year. But I also think it's a drag on Texas. And I'm not the person who waves the
  416. SEC beats each other up flag. I think there's some, I don't love that as an excuse.
  417. That's become a blanket excuse for Indiana. And that's just not, that doesn't work.
  418. I'm sorry. The trouble is, it's probably true, but it doesn't work for everything.
  419. So that's the trouble. So people are so tired of hearing it. Yeah, I think it's an over-application.
  420. It's not a logical fallacy. I just think it's, I think it becomes a sort of knee-jerk reaction.
  421. Okay. Well, this, y'all are both on my last question, and we really do have to let Stephen go.
  422. But the last question is your championship pick. And I've settled in my, playing the quant
  423. for a moment, playing the base rate, playing the base rates, Eric, I have Eric's argument,
  424. which is, why wouldn't I just say Notre Dame, Miami, because they have the easiest rows.
  425. They're of the seven or eight most eligible teams. They're the only two that are outside of
  426. the power of two conferences with much easier roads. I buy that they have less room for
  427. error. But if I just had to pick, like, don't overthink it. Like, which one of these three monsters is
  428. going to come out of a Big Ten? Which one of the big two or four are going to come out of the SEC?
  429. Just go Notre Dame, Miami, and you're going to get one of them right. I don't believe in Miami as a returning
  430. entity quite as strong as it sounds like you guys do, at least in terms of making the championship game, because I do look
  431. back on that road in the playoff bracket last year, and I think a lot of things swing a certain way.
  432. I do think they're improving. They are better in terms of, like, if there's a war, they're better at quarterback considerably.
  433. Mints is going to allow them to develop, oh my god, their offensive coordinator, my name
  434. is blanked, is going to be a very hot coaching commodity. Almost got the two-lane job before Will
  435. Hall did. His name will come to me in a second. Um, but the best pick, if you were
  436. actually trying to guess correctly, is Notre Dame by virtue of the schedule, the experience, and
  437. then I think where they're at with skill positions and depth against the Big Ten champion.
  438. Not because the South has fallen, but because it's actually a little bit of an endorsement
  439. of what we just said, Cade. The middle class of the Big Ten got the memo the latest about the evolution of
  440. college football. So while the high end has profited and been very sharp, and in Indiana's case, very
  441. market savvy, sort of hacked the system or whatever they want to say, you have Ohio
  442. State, you have Michigan, you have Indiana right now. The middle class of the Big Ten are
  443. still five years away every time I talk to recruiting analysts. And I'm not, I think some will get
  444. there. Oregon, by the way, I would include in that top class. I left them off. And I do think Washington is sort of
  445. something to watch in terms of that playoff cut line. I don't think they're like a title contender
  446. necessarily. It's just, it'll be interesting to see how they receive the quarterback coming back, all that
  447. drama, another Lane Kiffin drama. I'm going to be really honest with you right now.
  448. You can still kind of knuckle down and plow through the back end of your conference
  449. schedule if you are a have in the Big Ten. You could be a little bit fresher. I do think it probably puts you in
  450. a pole position once you get into bracket seating, at least as we understand the current
  451. 12-team format. So the safest answer is a comprehensive evaluation of Notre Dame, inspiring some faith there, pardon
  452. the pun. And then the Big Ten champion data-wise, I think the sauce is out. The SEC has yet to deliver the 1
  453. -1-A sort of tip of the spear program in this 12-team format. I don't think you've seen the Kirby Smart
  454. Georgia of 22-23, because of the market pulling apart the five stars and dispersing it
  455. at Ole Miss, dispersing it at Oklahoma. That's the problem that they haven't solved for
  456. yet. Okay, just to put you on the point before we let you go, if you had to put your chips on somebody out of
  457. the Big Ten, you're going to team up against Notre Dame. I love the logic you just made.
  458. It makes perfect sense. It's a great structure. But you had to bubble one team up.
  459. A lot of people are on Oregon this year. People still have Ohio State number one.
  460. I can't believe they're not going to step back. But I can't believe Indiana is not going
  461. to step back. But who do you have? The safest pick is Ohio State. It is America's professional college football franchise.
  462. That's the safest pick in college football for the last 15 years. Absolutely, and they will continue to be so
  463. because of the way that they comport themselves. I give them that credit because of their
  464. program-building philosophies and because they're ruthless about analytics, because they're sharp enough and maybe cold
  465. enough to pull the Will Howard move, which then wins them the national championship two years.
  466. It helps win them the national championship. I don't think everybody immediately thinks of Will
  467. Howard on the 24th, but I think about Caleb Downs. But for fun outside of that, let's have
  468. a genuine conversation about Michigan if they're healthy because that style at Utah translates faster than
  469. people may understand for what Michigan is capable of and their current personnel.
  470. Did Bob Stoops win the national championship in his first year at OU? He surprised everybody.
  471. No, so 99 is his first year and they lost to my alma mater as the millennium hit.
  472. As the millennium hit, Cade, December 31st, 1999, they lost the Independence Bowl to Ole Miss.
  473. Oh, okay. So I must have the wrong year. They won the next year. The next year. It was year two.
  474. Okay. Yeah. I repress most things. I was about to say that's a convenient omission for a Texas man.
  475. Yes. Okay. So Michigan, that's intriguing. Super intriguing. That'd be fun. Okay.
  476. All right, Stephen, we have to let you go. Thanks for the time, man. Stephen Godfrey.
  477. Really appreciate. And you guys, chase him down. Phantom Island podcast. Words and numbers.
  478. The free feed will be out in two weeks. If you're a Phantom Island subscriber at phantomisland
  479. .show, you're going to get all that. The exclusive stuff. Plus like the coach gossip.
  480. But like we also have evergreen content. So Bill's going to come on and talk about the misrepresentation of scheduling strength in scheduling
  481. P4s. That's going to be this week's episode. All right. Sounds good. You also catch Parker Fleming up there occasionally.
  482. You can also catch Stephen on Yahoo's College Football Inquirer podcast, which is one of the
  483. absolute best college football podcasts out there. All right, Stephen. Thank you guys so much.
  484. All right. Thank you guys. That's been the first half of Wharton Moneyball. We'll be back with the second half after
  485. this break. Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half, or in this
  486. case, the last quarter of this week's show. We had a long first half with our friend Stephen Godfrey.
  487. Stephen graced us with 45 minutes on college football, our first college football guest of the
  488. year. And he's a great way to start this. It reminds me of last year. I think it was last year.
  489. He was explaining kind of Indiana to us and all that had happened when they recruited
  490. Cignetti over. And we had flashes of that in the first half of the show, Eric, where Stephen
  491. just goes into these long details about things that I didn't know and helps me understand
  492. things that I didn't know. Even though I pay a lot of attention to college football, it's delightful to get that
  493. chance. I love the discussion where it ended about the implications. And it was a question I was going
  494. to ask him. What do people not understand? Well, is it the statistics or the implications
  495. of them? But I loved his last discussion about the implications of the lack of depth in the
  496. Big Ten and its implications there. Because you can go really deep in the SEC and have a hard team to face.
  497. But the Big Ten, it's just not that way, which is why you have to give even extra points to the upper tier of
  498. the Big Ten. I thought that was a big discussion because it talks about both depth.
  499. But then it has. And then the part I love talking about is. And what's the implication of that?
  500. You can just measure team strength, but what does it mean? So I thought that was great.
  501. Yep. All right. Let's open it up a little bit. Just a quick programming note. We are now into our football windup in
  502. that we're going to have football guests for the next couple of weeks. We have a week zero this week in
  503. college football with a pretty light schedule. Then week one will be next week. We'll have guests again next week to talk
  504. college football. And then the week after that, we will dive into professional football.
  505. All right, Eric, what else around the world of sports has your eye right now? Well, I've been a baseball fan my entire
  506. life. And I was at a game Sunday that I've never experienced before. It was the greatest, not because of its
  507. implications, the way it happened. It was the greatest game I've ever been to. Literally.
  508. So I'll explain the situation for our listeners. So I was at the Phillies Cardinals game
  509. on Sunday. Here was the situation. Phillies were down 4-0 going into the bottom of the ninth.
  510. Harper leads off the inning with a double. There's now two fly outs. So we're talking about two outs, bottom of
  511. the ninth, down 4-0 with a man on second. Tell us something about who's on the mound
  512. for the Cardinals. I don't know the person, but are we scared of him? Is he good?
  513. Is it- It's their reliever. Top reliever's on the mound. Top reliever. And Harper is batting third or something?
  514. So they're at the top of the order? Second, third? Well, they're now down to number six in
  515. the order because Harper's third. So Arreaz flies out and I think it was Stott flies out.
  516. So they're now down to six. Riomuto is up. Okay. He's got an 0-2 count. Now, before the inning started, Fangraphs had the
  517. Phillies at 0.4%. Now that's before there's two outs and an 0-2 count. Right. Riomuto singles.
  518. It's now first and third. They let him steal second because that running's meaningless.
  519. The next guy walks. Okay. Now its base is loaded. But we're batting eighth now. The eighth batter is- Now the eighth
  520. guy is up. Okay. Mundo Sosa doubles down the line. Drives in three. We're still down four to three, by the
  521. way. Two outs. One man out. Then De La Cruz comes up, singles him home. Wow. And then Schwarber hits a 460-foot home
  522. run. No, he didn't. Schwarber finished it. He walked it off. It wasn't even- Oh, my God.
  523. Goes to extra innings. Now, I've never- Again, I want to say, three batters in that movie.
  524. And you were there. You were there. I was there. You were there for that. Two of my three sons and my wife.
  525. Absurd. Three times in that stretch, they were down to the last strike. Right. I've never seen anything like it.
  526. Eric, was it the same pitcher? They didn't leave the same guy in there for all that?
  527. Yes, they did. Same guy? Oh, my God. That's the part we were shocked. There was no pitching change.
  528. It was the same guy left in there. So look, whether it's one in 1,000 or one in 10,000, I'm pretty sure
  529. I saw one in 1,000 at least. And I've never seen a comeback like that in a game before.
  530. And this never- First of all, you know I've never left a game in my life. I certainly didn't leave the game.
  531. About a third of the people left in the ninth inning. I never leave. But I actually, my family and I, we
  532. sat there for 30 minutes after the game, just looking at the field. We could not believe what we had seen.
  533. Yeah. And so I think this is, you know, Adi talks about this all the time. I really do believe this might be one
  534. of the rarest events I'll ever see in sports. Seems reasonable. It actually seems reasonable.
  535. And great fun. Great fun that you were there. It's awesome. So that's what caught my eye this week.
  536. Oh, a lot of things caught my eye, but that was one of them. All right. Let me jump in with a couple.
  537. I'll start with one. The new FedEx playoff format in golf is interesting. And partly because we kind of, somebody tweeted
  538. about this in the last week or two. And we were like, yeah, we would love that. Somebody said, so FedEx playoff.
  539. That's what we're in the middle of right now. And last week they had the next to
  540. last, Wynton Clark wins the field of 50. They cut it to 30. And they're going to play it this weekend,
  541. the championship with no handicaps, no starting positions, various, just top 30 guys.
  542. Everyone's starting at the same level. And we'll go from there. That's new this year.
  543. But something tweeted in the last year. How great would it be if they, in the last 30, they went, or the last
  544. 32, if they want to tweak it up, they went match play. Because match play has got so much drama.
  545. And sure enough, this week, today, they just announced two years from now in 2028, they're
  546. going to play match play at the end of this tournament. They're going to change it up a little
  547. bit. Eric and I were just diving into the details here. Looks like they're going to, the first week
  548. will be 90. And they'll play a week that way. And that'll be the end of the season.
  549. Then the top 32 roll into a two week match play format. The first is eight groups of four, eight
  550. pods, if you will. It's kind of like round robin group play, group play in the world cup.
  551. And then the top two out of each of those pods come out for the final 16 man match play tournament on the final
  552. weekend. I think it's great. I think that's a great way to set the whole thing up.
  553. It'll just, it'll make it much more distinct versus the rest of the year. Yeah, I think, look, I think they went
  554. a little overboard. Do you remember? I mean, Kate, it's, you've talked about design
  555. for 12 and a half years on the show. And if you think about the way the FedEx playoffs was, none of us liked it,
  556. which is the top guy started at minus 10. And then, you know, some other guys, minus
  557. nine, then the 30th place guy, zero. And now they've gone to the other extreme. Scotty Shepler's clearly number one, and he has
  558. no advantage over, I'm making up if this is number 30, Ryan Fox or whoever it is.
  559. I think that's who it is. But nothing, no advantage. Come the last, no, that's maybe too extreme
  560. the other way. So this seems to be something in between in the sense that, you know, I mean,
  561. yes and no. I assume there's going to be a seeding. So that would be, that's what you're banking
  562. on. That's what it has to be. They have to be, you know, whether it's, I doubt it'll be deterministic.
  563. It'll be random within buckets of four. Because, you know, you don't want someone to
  564. say, I don't want to be in the group with Scotty. Therefore, I'd rather be the number seven in
  565. the world than the number five. Because this, that, you can't do that. But there has to be randomization within blocks
  566. of four. Like the top four get randomized, then the next four, then the next four.
  567. Just like group play in the World Cup. You presume that's the case. But what we don't know, and we have
  568. two years to talk about this, but the idea of spreading that match play out across
  569. two weeks is an interesting feature here. And I'm guessing, without knowing the details, the
  570. downside of match, of course, Eric, is that you're introducing much more randomness.
  571. I mean, the head-to-head matchups in golf is like wildly less based on true fundamental value than is 72 holes of stroke
  572. play. But it's more fun. It's more drama. So I suspect what they're doing in that
  573. first week of eight pods of four is something to add a little bit of sample size in there.
  574. So that the 16, that is the second 16 at least. But once you get to second 16, you're
  575. playing straight up match, I think. But the second 16 will be determined a little bit more truthfully than the first.
  576. The second 16 will be, what am I saying? The first cut will be a little bit more sample-based, truth-based than the final
  577. one. So what's interesting here also is, let's imagine there's two latent player abilities.
  578. One is stroke play ability, and the other is match play ability. How correlated do we think those are?
  579. You could imagine, for example, a very consistent player who's really good at stroke play because
  580. that's great. But in match play, you got to win holes, not tie holes. So I'm just wondering also, does this make
  581. us think a little bit differently on who the best player is? Because which best do you mean?
  582. Do you mean if they played a 72 -stroke play tournament? Or do you mean if they did match
  583. play? Yeah, I don't know if we've talked about this very much. We talk about Ryder Cup when it comes
  584. around, because that's the only real match play that we see people play. But I thought you were going to do
  585. something different there. I thought you were going to do a typical Eric Bradlow, choke, momentum kind of thing.
  586. So you could say, is there something different about match play? Because it's head-to-head, there's a different
  587. kind of pressure. Literally about, you know... You're talking about variance. You're talking about essentially...
  588. Yeah, variance. This is your favorite. You love variance. Well, and the beauty of match play, anybody
  589. who's a duffer like most of us are appreciates this. You know, there's no difference between losing a
  590. hole if you lost it by one stroke or four. You know, you have a quad on a hole, and it doesn't matter.
  591. And so for those of us who blow up occasionally, a high-variance golfer, there's less
  592. penalty because the score is just binary. Either one, or it's trinary, I guess, there
  593. are ties. So I like the idea that maybe high -variance golfers... I don't... Surely people have looked at this.
  594. We don't have much data to work with, but our high-variance golfers, conditional on the
  595. quality of golf or the underlying stroke play average, high-variance golfers should be, I think
  596. we'd say, should be more successful in match play format. You would think, but just remember, the thing
  597. there... It's one of those interesting design questions. Let's forget the one tournament that is match
  598. play during the year. Um, they're playing stroke play. So it's not clear you're getting a clear
  599. estimate of variance. You're getting a clear estimate. You're getting an estimate of variance, but under
  600. a stroke play format. So that's another... Just an interesting statistical question.
  601. You're not... You don't have any data on variance under a different format. Yeah, that's...
  602. That's right. That's a very good... That's a very good analyst observation. We can't say...
  603. Strictly speaking, we can't infer very well. The only other thing I'd like to talk
  604. about with regards to golf was... They asked... It was very interesting. They asked Rory McIlroy who he thought should
  605. be player of the year. And they said, well, you know, Wyndham Clark just won his third tournament.
  606. And McIlroy almost... He didn't say it this way. He said it almost... He didn't say it exactly the way I'm
  607. going to say it, but he almost said it this way. He goes, don't you guys realize that it's
  608. not about wins? Like he basically was doing a money ball argument. He goes, who has the best stroke play?
  609. Scheffler. Who has the best, you know, greens and regulation? Scheffler. Who's got the best?
  610. He goes, why don't you, you know? Yeah. All right. So he's won twice instead of three times.
  611. How about his five second place finishes? How about he leads in every advanced metric
  612. on tour? He says, now, if Wyndham Clark wins this week, okay, then we'll have a different discussion.
  613. But he was... It was so beautiful. I wanted to cry. He was making... He goes, why, you know, two wins, three
  614. wins, you know? Okay. Yeah. But Scott, he's the best golfer. Well, that's great.
  615. But it was nice that he put a limit on this. Like, okay, if it's a two-win difference
  616. or a three-win difference across the players, now we'll start talking about it. But if it's almost a tie, then come
  617. on. Or even a one-win deficit. That's great. We should track that down. Oddie could use that in some of his
  618. classes. I think that would be a good way. It was just great to hear Roy McIlroy
  619. talk about that. And also he didn't give up some fake argument like, well, hasn't he won enough of
  620. them? He's like, what does that have to do with anything? Right. That's awesome.
  621. Roy is impressive. Let me give you one more. And it's kind of in the same spirit.
  622. I think we should celebrate Bill Barnwell's annual columns on teams most likely to improve in
  623. the NFL and teams most likely to regress. He's been doing this for a while now, like 10 or 12 years, I think.
  624. And, you know, Bill doesn't write a column that's not 3,000 words. And so you got to saddle up if
  625. you're going to read these things. And I haven't read this year's. But I saw that they came out and
  626. I want to name a couple of things. Just the teams. Well, it's just the premise is what I
  627. want to celebrate because he's fundamentally going at regression to the meat. He's saying before we dive into finer details
  628. about whose offensive line has a better scheme for the left tackle, let's talk about high
  629. level statistical tendencies. You got to start with regression to the meat. So he looks at factors.
  630. We should have these more wrote than I do. But, you know, close wins, for example, close
  631. wins, close losses, injury luck, fumbles, recover, turnover, luck, that kind of thing.
  632. And he stacks this up and he says, these are the teams that got the worst of those draws last year.
  633. And therefore conditional on everything else, holding over the L-Sequel, we expect them to come
  634. up. And these are the teams that got the best of those draws last year, holding over
  635. the L-Sequel. We expect these to come down. I think Bill has made college NFL conversations
  636. smarter because he's been doing this column every year. This is now in the conversations at all
  637. levels, which is where it ought to be. But also good fun, a good place to start as we start thinking about NFL.
  638. Bill's expected followers. That was today's column, I think. Carolina Panthers, I'm sorry to hear that for
  639. our friend, Eric Eager. The Chicago Bears, Denver Broncos, for some reason I don't like Sean Payton.
  640. I'm happy to see Broncos not list. Jags and Pats, I'm sorry. Pats have to be number one.
  641. I mean, how many close games did they win? They had the weakest schedule. I mean, yeah.
  642. I have to believe that Pats, I don't know how many, what the win-loss projection
  643. is for them. If it's, it's gotta be something, 10 and a half or something, nine and a half,
  644. 10 and a half. I'm with you. By the way, I should have said with Barnwell that he tracks his performance, like of
  645. these teams, how many actually improve each year and how many regress. He's got a record.
  646. It's a very impressive record that his column is accurate on average. Okay, the Risers, the more fun list.
  647. The Risers, I'm happy to report that the Baltimore Ravens are on this list. Kansas City Chiefs, how can the Chiefs not
  648. be there at six and 10 or some crazy thing with six and 11 last year. Detroit Lions, who remember took a big and
  649. surprising step back last year. The New York teams, the Giants and the Jets. He doesn't say they're going to the Superbowl.
  650. He just says they're gonna rise. That's right, we're gonna rise. But this is like an annual celebration of
  651. regression to the mean. And you just can't, this is a boring topic, but you just can't pay enough attention
  652. to regression to the mean if you want to understand the world. Look, all I'll say is, I think it
  653. was you or Adi said this stat a few years ago. Roughly, you should expect half the teams that
  654. made the playoffs last year to not make it this year. I think that's beautiful about the NFL.
  655. I really do. And by the way, I'm pretty sure that's not true in the NBA. I'm pretty sure that's not true in, maybe
  656. it's true in hockey. I don't know, that seems too much. I think the NFL, the amount of mixing
  657. you get is just tremendous. And the fact that it's half, you know, it gives hope.
  658. I don't know if I'm the Panthers, you know, Panthers weren't that far off. The whole NFC South stinks.
  659. So why can't the Panthers win the division? Sure they can, of course. All right, man, why don't we leave it
  660. there? It's fun to be talking football again and we will do so again next week. For the whole team here, Eric Bradlow's been
  661. here for the whole show. Shane Jensen, in absentia. Audie Weiner, in absentia. For our guests this week, Stephen Godfrey, our
  662. producer. Jacob Krodnick, the boss lady, Dee Patel. Thank you guys for listening.
  663. Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Stephen Godfrey discusses college football analytics, team dynamics, and the evolving landscape of college athletics with hosts Cade Massey and Eric Bradlow.

Key points

  • Numbers and Words Podcast. Stephen discusses his new podcast focusing on intelligent football conversations.
  • The Evolution of Podcasting. Cade and Stephen discuss the changing landscape of journalism and podcasting.
  • College Football's Changing Landscape. Cade and Stephen discuss the implications of professional players returning to college football.
  • Lane Kiffin's Personality. Kiffin is described as a megalomaniac and textbook sociopath.
  • Dante Moore's Decision. Dante Moore turned down a top draft pick to stay at Oregon for financial reasons.
  • Coaching Changes in the Big 10. The discussion revolves around the coaching changes and their implications for teams like Michigan and Penn State.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes