Data-Driven NFL Playoffs and College Football’s Shifting Power

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE ESPN national football analyst Seth Walder, and Steven Godfrey, college football writer for Yahoo Sports and The Washington Post and co-host of the College Football Enquirer podcast, join Cade and Shane to examine the NFL playoff landscape through advanced metrics and unpack the College Football Playoff’s surprises, transfer portal strategy, and evolving SEC–Big Ten balance of power.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#sportsanalytics #collegefootballplayoff #secfootball #footballstats ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to another full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
  2. network. This is Kate Massie hosting this week with my longtime friend, colleague, co-host, collaborator Shane
  3. Jensen. We too will be here for the whole hour. Our two other co-hosts, Eric Bradlo, Shane Jensen, they're off doing
  4. Eric and Shane, not Shane, Eric and Audi. Eric and Audi are not here with us. Eric and Audi are off doing Eric and
  5. Audi things. They will be back. Some combination, as you guys know, some combination of us are here almost every
  6. week of the year. We're talking 48, 49, sometimes 50 weeks of the year. Coming up on 12 years in just two short months
  7. from now, good to see you. Good to be back. >> How are things going? >> Good, good, good, good. I'm down here in
  8. um toasty warm. You know, you'd think it was South Florida. It's central Texas. You guys have had some proper winter up
  9. there in the Northeast. I feel like I've been away from the show. I've probably hit, I don't know, two shows in the last
  10. five weeks or some crazy thing between travel, holidays, teaching, craziness. Glad to be back. Going to slip in here
  11. to a regular routine. Catching the end of the football season and we'll transition and start paying attention to
  12. some other sports. You know, we've got the NFL bracket filled out. Tragically, as of Sunday night, tragically, the last
  13. slot got filled. So be it. It's set. These games will start being played. Meanwhile, college slate semiis coming
  14. up this week, bizarrely, Thursday, Friday night. We'll take we'll pick up that in the second half of the show.
  15. We've got Stephen Godfrey to come here and talk college football second half of the show. Truth is, we couldn't decide
  16. what we want to talk about this week. There's football, two flavors, peak season, got to cover them both. So,
  17. we're going to do college in the second half. First half, Seth Walder. Longtime friend of the show, Seth Walder,
  18. national football analyst for ESPN. I think of him as the gobetween between geeky quants like me and Shane and the
  19. rest of the world. He can speak quant, he can speak vibes, he translates between the two. He is a vital cog in
  20. the ESPN role. He writes there. He shows up in the studio productions. He's got some new gigs that we're going to hear
  21. about a little bit. Seth, always a pleasure. Thanks for making time for us. >> Thanks for having me. You know, you got
  22. to give yourself more credit. I've I've spoken to you off air. You're a normal person. You can talk. You can you can
  23. talk, you know, >> on good days. On good days. >> The most of us, Kate, though. So, you
  24. represent the upper bound on our connection, >> right? Well, I'm I'm also probably the lowest
  25. lower bound on the stats capabilities on this show. So, um I used to be kind of mid-range stats and the world just keeps
  26. on, you know, getting fancier, keeps on evolving, hanging on with both hands at this point. Um Seth, let's just tackle
  27. first the bracket. I I feel like Kate was launching into sort of talking about how the college slate was pretty wide
  28. open. I feel like the NFL seems the most wide open I've at least per personally anecdotally experienced at some time.
  29. Maybe that's just because Kansas City Chiefs aren't in it, but I don't know if you could kind of speak to sort of
  30. whether you sort of see it as wide open and like you know what the most kind of uh interesting kind of matchups you see
  31. are. >> I I do. We do and our numbers show that as well. So, it's not just a feeling,
  32. but our >> our projections do indicate that. I am disappointed because I thought for sure
  33. this was going to be the year that we had as the where the Super Bowl favorite who we have as the Seahawks would have
  34. the lowest chance to win the playoff or win the win the Super Bowl going into the year. But I'm pretty sure
  35. um you know what I take it back. I take it back because I was looking Yeah. So So I
  36. think we do have we have the Seahawks at 20% to win the Super Bowl. And I do believe that is the
  37. highest or lowest. I guess I have to go back. What I'm realizing I've done live on air
  38. here is that I looked at week eight through week 18 weeks and that that doesn't work the whole time.
  39. 20% is a really low number for a favorite to win the Super Bowl, which is what we have Seattle at. And I do think
  40. it speaks to this year where it really hasn't been a team, there hasn't been a single team that I think has jumped out
  41. and been a complete team the whole way. And then you have teams like Seattle and
  42. Denver who are great teams, but you can imagine their flaws being the the by-week teams. I think if if Los
  43. Angeles, if the Rams had been the by-week team, we certainly would have seen that number be higher. But
  44. >> yeah, I think with the Ram the Rams kind of recent like loss of Falcons I think
  45. kind of threw it all like they they were looking at as more kind of a contention
  46. sort of number one and I do think it's sort of like I I see the top teams just in terms of standings this year and
  47. there's a complete mismatch between them and sort of our pri I think our prior expectations which part of why there's a
  48. lot of uncertainty going on right now. Um do you kind of I mean Seattle you already mentioned as one really
  49. surprising team. Do you kind of feel like they're the sort of most surprising team's performance this year or I mean
  50. I'm a Pats fan so that I I've been kind of floored by what they've done. I mean it's it's it's been I guess predictable
  51. week to week but certainly not something a ceiling that I did not anticipate coming into this season.
  52. >> I do think Seattle is the most surprising team. They've been their defense has just been so unbelievable.
  53. It's hard to win that way. It's hard to week in week out have a defense that is that uh effective because we just know
  54. the stability on defense is just is just less week to week year to year. >> I think for New England at least our met
  55. metrics FBI is not as high on the Patriots. Uh it's for the obvious reasons train uh has been really has
  56. been really weak. And I'll tell you what's remarkable, and I didn't even notice this until right this moment, but
  57. another reason why it's sort of wide open. If you look at the top teams in FBI by pure quality, so just team
  58. rating, and I'm curious if Massie Peabody has it this way, too. Our f top five teams are all NFC teams. And our
  59. sixth team is the Ravens, who's not who weren't in the playoff. >> That's crazy.
  60. >> I mean, the Ravens honestly have made an art of like looking great on paper and
  61. then, you know, not not somehow like doing it on the grass field, but uh um that is that is interesting.
  62. >> Tragically, that's that's very college footballes that the best teams aren't in
  63. the playoffs. >> Little little little Longhorn Baltimore bitterness. Um but we have Buffalo
  64. Higher. Buffalo and Jacksonville, we have four and five. Um, so yeah, and then Green Bay down at seven. You
  65. probably got Green Bay higher. San Francisco down around 10 or something. >> Yes. Top five is all three of the West
  66. teams, I guess, in the NFC plus. >> Well, actually, no, we don't have San Francisco. We have San Francisco ninth.
  67. Uh, no, we have the Eagles third. >> Um, same. >> Uh, and it's really close. When I say,
  68. you know, I mean, we're talking a tenth of a point between Baltimore and Buffalo. Um, right. So, it's that. But,
  69. so, you know, if we're right, um, you know, I'll take credit and then if if we're wrong, uh, and Buffalo just blows
  70. up everybody and wins the Super Bowl, just blame Brian Burke. And, >> well, that that'd be so much fun. I
  71. mean, as far as I'm concerned, I mean, the uh the uh as open as it is, as the as different as the team names are this
  72. year, I mean, our numbers, we've had Seattle tops for weeks now, and we've got them a good, you know, point and a
  73. half stronger than LA, who's a point and a half, two and a half points stronger than Philly. So, there's a fair bit of
  74. separation at the top. I mean, back in the Pat's Chiefs heyday, that would be kind of typical separation, but it
  75. hasn't felt that way lately. I mean, when when we run our sim in the end, Seth, we have Seattle with like 31%
  76. or something. >> Wow. So, you're much much stronger than us on Seattle. And in fact, I remember
  77. that you the Massie P body had moved on Seattle earlier, which proved correct, but uh had they were you had them really
  78. high earlier in the season than than we did. It took us longer to catch up. I'll
  79. tell you what concerns me about Seattle. that's having worked on that game last week.
  80. I mean, the way they were Well, let's just say this. Going into that game since the Rams the first Rams game, week
  81. 11, uh, so that's yeah, week 11 on, Sam Darnold's been one of the worst quarterbacks in terms of UBR. And and
  82. and sometimes sometimes like I think it's very easy to fall into these like splits traps, right? We look at splits
  83. and we say, "Okay, but that's not an arbitrary end point." That's I think when teams started adapting to saying,
  84. "Hey, Seattle's run game isn't as effective as we thought. We can play more too high coverage. We can play
  85. lighter boxes. We don't have to match their we don't have to match their heavy personnel with base personnel." And
  86. Darnold has been worse from that moment forward. And in watching that game against the 49ers,
  87. for most of that game, it seemed like Seattle was trying to hide Darnold. They had a lot of third downs. They felt
  88. like, you know, that were sort of making easy throws, screen passes, things that
  89. where he didn't have to really rip it. Now, in the end, he did. He, you know, he made a he made an an absolutely
  90. killer play sort of on the move and avoided a sack and that that really won them the game. So, it's in there. But,
  91. man, a team who seems a little bit skittish about their own quarterback, that does worry me as good as their
  92. defense has been. >> Yeah. I mean, what happened with Minnesota last year would give you the
  93. same pause, right? And I I don't actually remember, maybe you guys do, kind of what his trajectory
  94. looked like going into that to the playoffs last year, but I feel like it was perhaps a similar thing where he was
  95. I do remember he came out gang busters at the start of last season and obviously he again won 14 games or
  96. something like that, but then it >> his last game prior to the playoffs was a disaster in Minnesota. Yeah, he
  97. actually lasted much longer playing better, but then he really fell. But then he had a horrible game going into
  98. the playoffs and then obviously horrible game in the playoffs. >> Seth, can you can you flip to the other
  99. side of the ball and give us any explanation, any any deeper insight into Seattle's defense? So, Mike McDonald has
  100. done with that defense, essentially what he did with the Ravens defense over their couple years, taking them to best
  101. in the league, more or less. I I thought for a moment there that the that the rest of the league, you know, he he was
  102. right at the it sounded like he was at the cutting edge when he first came on board. Then people start, you know,
  103. typically catching on. People start, you know, copying and so you don't typically
  104. maintain that kind of advantage for multiple years. You don't often get an entire second, you know, turn with it,
  105. but he seems to have gotten that. What What do you think the heart of McDonald's advantage is? He's a head
  106. coach obviously, but as a defensive guy. So when he was in Baltimore, he really effectively used simulated blitzes and
  107. and what we mean by that is sort of bringing maybe just bringing four players, but you don't know which four
  108. it's going to be. So that maybe maybe there's six or seven guys at the line and it's not just the four down players
  109. who come. It's four com four players and then you end up with one-on- ones even if they have six men blocking, but they
  110. now you still have seven seven back. And I think he still does some of that. And
  111. I I'm going to steal some analysis from uh some of my co-workers when we were I was working on the on that game where
  112. they mentioned two things. One, they felt like when he does blitz though, it's it's not just to blitz. It's like
  113. it is a it's like purely with design and so it's just he felt like more tactical.
  114. And then the other thing was just that the way that they in the run game felt like Leonard Williams has been so
  115. effective that they're able to essentially know that if the run goes to Leonard Williams, they have an advantage
  116. and if you if it goes away from Leonard Williams, you can send players in that direction in advance and and that
  117. Seattle is able to take advantage of that. Uh and so that's those are non quantity answers. The the sim the sim
  118. pressure stuff we certainly have seen um or or in the past have se or McDonald have success with. I think those are
  119. some of the reasons. I also think, and this is not like a great answer here, but I think it's important to like
  120. recognize that when we talk about schematic advantages in football, I think we have
  121. a long way to go in terms of quantifying them, which is the way that I understand
  122. football, and I I think to some some degree you you guys do, but I think that there's a lot more there that doesn't
  123. show up yet. We'll get there, not yet. You know, I had one conversation with an analyst who knew something about
  124. McDonald's system a couple years ago, and he he talked about the the communication, the internal
  125. communication around the schemes and the play calls and how much of advantage he
  126. had just because he made it easier to remember what the play was being that was being called as a family of other
  127. plays. And I think once you've simplified communication, you can then in some sense use more elaborate
  128. communication. you can you can call on more a wider range of plays if you can communicate them more simply. And that
  129. sounds like a bizarre thing to have an advantage with, but I do think that was something he deployed early on that may
  130. still probably still does, but gave him an advantage early on. Um, okay. Why don't we shift gears then? You Well,
  131. before we before we leave the playoffs all together, let's some team you like in the AFC or give us something not
  132. obvious that we've been talking about the kind of heavy favorites in the NFC. What's interesting on the AFC side?
  133. >> On the AFC side, I think I I kind of think I've been st staring at this all day trying to figure out I got to do
  134. some predictions and figure out who's underrated. The more I look at it, the more I think Denver might be underrated.
  135. And I I say this as a Boon Knicks someone who's been a Bon Knick skeptic for a long
  136. >> I was about to ask you, convince me on Bo Knicks. Well, he's played a lot better honestly,
  137. I think, over the last last few weeks. And I try not to, you know, hyperfixate on just a few games, but it is true. I
  138. do think he I do think he's played reasonably well in the second half here. But at the same time, it's like we know
  139. the recipe for winning without a great quarterback. You have to have great pieces elsewhere. And they really do
  140. have it. They have an excellent offensive line. They have, we've talked a lot about Seattle's defense, but
  141. Denver is can be right there as well. And then come back to what I said at the beginning of the show where I feel like
  142. the AFC is just weaker. They have an easier path than you might otherwise expect for a one se I mean like there's
  143. a world where they're playing Pittsburgh at home in round two. That's like not even a hard world to fathom and like
  144. that's all like where that's all they have to do to get to the AFC Championship game.
  145. >> Okay, hold on. Is there any is there anything to the narrative the the the the Steelers narrative that they were
  146. selling on Sunday night that Rogers and his receivers needed more time that they're beginning to understand each
  147. other better. They communicate better. They see the same things. They're coordinated better. Medaf will come off
  148. a suspension. Hell, they just beat the Ravens without Medaf. Is there anything to that story that there's a trajectory
  149. here at the end for this Steeler? And this is spoken as one of the diehard Steelers haters in the country.
  150. >> I highly doubt it. I mean, I don't like I don't think that we've seen that we have seen moments from Rogers, but I
  151. don't think that we're looking at I would think we're still looking at an average Shabbo average starter. I think
  152. that DK Metaf has been important for them, but he's not like a huge part of their offense. Like, I agree with the
  153. general narrative that they miss him and it gives him, you know, that that hurts.
  154. It's not like they were throwing down field a ton to Mechaf all season long. I think anyone who's had DK Mechaf in
  155. fantasy is like wait a second hang on we're talking about this and they're going like I think what if Pittsburgh is
  156. going to get through I think it's because they throw the ball they throw the ball really quickly and that is
  157. going to mitigate Houston's edge rushing advantage that they that they certainly
  158. have and so maybe that's one way where they're well suited against I don't think it's like he needs more
  159. time to mesh with his receivers I Okay. What about Josh Allen just picking up and carrying the Bills? What about
  160. the best quarterback left in the >> absolutely could happen? I mean, why why not? He's he's like the best remaining
  161. player. If we're talking about predict one player to be incredible, he's that now they like they have they have
  162. weaknesses. Could they be receiver? Yeah. I mean, yeah, but sometimes Allen can just especially if it's playoffs,
  163. he's willing to shoulder as much of the load on his legs as as he wants. Yeah, I think could could the Bills make
  164. a run 100%. >> Okay, so tell us about these these broadcasts that you've been involved
  165. with so far. You're doing something different for ESPN. >> Yeah, I'm I'm really excited about this.
  166. So, we have this thing called the Playbook broadcast. It's an alternate broadcast, right? So, we have the the
  167. main broadcast, sometimes there's a Manning cast, and then we have this playbook broadcast, which we started in
  168. week 16. The broadcast is is I would I think it's cool. I think it's cool if you like football. It's got an all 22
  169. view. So for a lot of people, no matter what your interest is otherwise, that is
  170. a great view and it's not the full zoomed out like coach's view cam. It's 22 players on the field but a little
  171. closer, which to me is kind of like the ideal view. >> Okay, >> we have some we're working with a
  172. company called Adrenaline, which is uh Shawn Sha Lee is a big player there. Shaun Lee the Cowboys linebacker if you
  173. remember. Um, and they're an analytics company. They've got real- time data coming in from NFL NextGen Stats. And
  174. what they use it for is to predict the probability of blitzes, uh, run pass and target probability, and it's dynamically
  175. updating. So, when a linebacker starts to creep forward, you'll see that blitz probability pop. I I found that to be
  176. really cool, especially if you look sort of just trends over game. We did the San
  177. Francisco game a few weeks ago, not this last week, but a few weeks ago. And in the first half, everything was
  178. singledigit blitz probability. They were just, you know, 8 9% blitzing. And I don't know if they blitzed at all in the
  179. first half. And then suddenly in the second half, you made they it was 40% or 45% or 50% and they they were blitzing
  180. more. And to me, that was that was cool as someone that >> had to see that. just I I I just need
  181. the numbers sometimes to highlight this predictive. It was clearly showing a shift in mentality that they had from
  182. early in the game to later win. So we >> real quickly being being an academic we
  183. believe in attributions and this is unnecessary but might as well call out s do we want to give Sam Schwarzman credit
  184. I think of the Amazon alt broadcast maybe two years ago being the kind of real time moment where these blitz
  185. probability started. >> Yeah. They have the sort of like identif the the >> yeah
  186. that's right it wasn't quantified but it was like this guy's more likely to come
  187. and it was they were discovering it they were discovering it real time which was
  188. just ridiculous and great fun. >> So that's been that's been great and then we we've had a sort of rotating
  189. analysts uh and and they've been and it's been ex players and then been incredible at breaking out x's nos's.
  190. we've been more focused on letting them try to sort of tell us about what's happening schematically
  191. over the course of the game. And then the last thing is that either Brian Burke or myself have been on the
  192. broadcast as decision analysts. So, kind of like the ref analyst when there's a >> right. It's it's it is it's like instead
  193. of Mike Pereira coming in to say like, "Yeah, the ch this challenge is going to be over is going to be upheld." Uh they
  194. bring on Brian or me to talk about fourth downs, two points, timeouts, any sort of game management or we were
  195. showing a lot more advanced metrics on this broadcast, too, so we can answer questions about that. And it's been it's
  196. been it's really fun. So, I did my first one last week in the Seattle 49ers game
  197. and I'll be on the broadcast on Monday on uh Texans Steelers. >> Great fun. Great fun. What's an example
  198. of a situation that you were called in to count to talk about? >> So, there were sort of like three
  199. moments that I thought were really or a bunch that were really exciting in the first in the game I did. So, in that
  200. game, Seattle went for it on at the four yard line. They went for it on fourth down. And I think this is kind of old
  201. hat to anyone listening to more money Moneyball, but like we talk about how the advantage here is you're trying to
  202. score a touchdown, but if you fail, you're putting the other team at the four. And it just, you know, they did
  203. fail and it ended up paying off so so well. And it doesn't always work this way, but then uh the 49ers get a three
  204. three and out and they had to punt and then they committed a penalty on the punt. So the Seattle started with a plus
  205. 35 their next drive and we got to come back and say hey see like wasn't so bad uh going for it. We had a great you know
  206. I think kind of a a clear the 49ers made a clear misstep misstep by not calling timeouts at the end. And then my
  207. favorite part was there was this wrinkle in this game where Seattle if it was a tie Seattle effectively won.
  208. It was equally equivalent to a win for Seattle. Uh it was not perfectly equivalent to a loss for 49ers. So it
  209. wasn't even a quite zero sum game which I also found quite fun. >> So obviously if it had gone to overtime
  210. that would have been re really impactful in terms of >> how you strategy. >> Yeah, for sure.
  211. >> But uh there was also wrinkles going into the into like in the fourth quarter
  212. where we were talking about this sort of down four strategy, right? uh if you're
  213. down if you're you're down four, go for two. For San Francisco, they were driving. This almost happened and I
  214. think everyone was in agreement. This wasn't just me, that they ought to go for two earlier with this was like 12
  215. minutes left in the game because overtime was a just a much worse proposition for them, right,
  216. >> as usual, >> right? Can I can I survey you guys for two two seconds real quick? Sure.
  217. This was a question I asked analytics people in the league going into this. If the Seahawks had had a down eight
  218. scenario, like a So, the Seahawks have been down eight and there were I don't know six minutes left in the game. Would
  219. they have gone should they have gone for two knowing that a tie is as good as a win for them? I want to know what your
  220. thoughts are and then I'll tell you what folks in the league said. I mean, I'm always skeptical when the
  221. intuitive answer seems so obvious, right? Because it sure does seem like the answer is yes since the tie is
  222. beneficial. Um, >> such a low probability. I think though the tie is still working it's still
  223. working out as a tie at that point, right? I think I I think so my intuition would be kind of just that the the the
  224. tie would almost be irrelevant to the calculation. You'd still be going for the >> Yeah. Sorry. Do you agree? You agree?
  225. Um, >> yeah, I am persuaded by Shane. Yes, absolutely. >> Yeah. So, I talked to punks in the
  226. league. They were they were mixed. I said some people who felt like you shouldn't u and then some people who
  227. felt like you should. When I did out the math, I came to the same conclusion that
  228. Shane did, which is like it all hinges on how how like given a tie, given overtime, how likely do you think a tie
  229. is, which is not necessarily an answerable question because we also have this unique state where Seattle is more
  230. motivated for a tie than >> Yeah, we haven't we haven't seen a setting like that, right? We we don't we
  231. don't know. It's the team's gonna are going to play differently. Super interesting. So,
  232. >> I if I if we use 20% if we say there's a 20% chance of a tie, which feels like
  233. sort of reasonable going in uh going into overtime, I don't think you could justify I think you still go for two
  234. down here. >> Okay. Okay. >> Um but close call. >> This is fun that they have you guys
  235. pulled in. Um it'll be it I need to watch this. It sounds like it's interesting to watch anyway, but to have
  236. you and Brian on the podcast on the actual broadcast, I mean, come on. This is good fun. Um, listen, Seth, a busy
  237. time of year for you. Appreciate you making time for us. Great to hear from you. Thanks for helping us understand
  238. the NFL playoffs better and good luck with the show. So, we could dial in and watch you on Monday. The text.
  239. >> Yes, I'll be on Monday. Brian will be back for the divisional round. >> Cool. Cool. All right. Have fun. All
  240. right. That's Seth Walder, national analyst for NFL on the ESPN network. We've had him on many times over the
  241. years. Always a pleasure, Seth. Take care. >> Thank you. That's the first half of Wharton
  242. Moneyball. We still have a half to go. Come back and join us after the break. Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton
  243. Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's show. A full hour of sports
  244. analytics here on the Wharton podcast network. Kade Massie hosting this week with my buddy Shane Jensen. This is
  245. Tuesday afternoon show will go up on Wednesday just off the line with Seth Walder talking NFL playoffs, new
  246. broadcast platforms. Good fun with Seth always. This was a week where we legit couldn't decide which way to go with our
  247. guest because we've got rich football at both the pro and college levels. So, we
  248. decided we didn't have to decide. We can go both ways. This half of the show, college football, bringing in Stephen
  249. Godfrey, longtime friend of the show, been with us for years now. Always a delight to get time with Stephen.
  250. Stephen writes for Yahoo and the Washington Post. He has his own production company. Has a podcast with
  251. Ryan Annie. Phantom Island podcast covers a wide range of football and even broader issues. And he is talent
  252. appearing three times a week with Andy Staples and Ross Dinger on Yahoo's College Football Inquirer podcast, which
  253. is one of the best ways to dive deep into college football out there. Stephen, always a pleasure. Thanks for
  254. making time. >> How are you guys? I thought of you recently. I think since the last time
  255. I've been on the show, I have an 8-year-old now who is two things. Obsessed with sports stats and wants to
  256. go to Texas. >> Hey, this is our person. Send him our way. Absolut Is this what you said?
  257. >> Yeah. Yeah, him. Yeah. Uh 8-year-old son. I have my I have three kids, the two the two eldest boys. Um
  258. >> Okay. >> He got into Texas. He still has not visited the state of Texas, but Bejan
  259. Robinson got him in cuz we're all Falcons fans in our house. >> Absolutely. >> And so he all things bej. But he has
  260. taken this pretty far. He has he has Texas apparel. Uh he got Texas he has like Texas uh like all the burnt orange
  261. which doesn't really go with anything or it goes with everything depending on your mantra. Um
  262. >> that's right. >> And he is starting to track stats. He's starting to I'm teaching him how to
  263. chart games. Um, and he's he's got like a he's like got like a 99 or 100 in math
  264. right now in the third grade. So I'm not sure he's my kid. Um, so because I failed business calculus twice in
  265. college. I failed a lot of classes in college, but calculus especially. So, uh, it's kind of amazing. It's kind, you
  266. know, >> it's important no matter what show you're on to encourage I I encourage my
  267. kids like my wife and I are graduates of Old Miss, but you know, because I work in the media, I maintain an objectivity
  268. and I'm not from Mississippi and we told our kids as they started to take interest in what I do, pick your teams.
  269. So, I've got a Georgia fan and a Texas fan now and and they're front running. I feel fine with this. like it's probably
  270. guaranteed more joy. I gave them Atlanta sports which is a little bit like having
  271. some sort of terminal disease. So like heavy I saw your hat and I thought about it and I was like, man, yeah, I have so
  272. much Texas paraphernalia in my house right now. >> Well, listen, that makes me kind of
  273. proud. You know, maybe Bill Connley has influenced him early on. Maybe he the podcast ain't played nobody got in there
  274. early on. But look, we we'll we take the kids pretty early. We have summer camps
  275. for them. As soon as he hits like, I don't know, late junior high, he can come up to Philadelphia and do Wharton
  276. Moneyball stuff. We are here for his >> You're not kidding, right? >> Not kidding. No, we have we have high
  277. school kids from all over the world who come for weeks during the summertime to do sports. Great program.
  278. >> Oh my god. He would love that. He would love that. Now, anything sports stats
  279. has been how he got into sports. Yeah. Or how sorry, how he got into math, you know. Well, that's that's that's Audi
  280. Winer, our co-host, is the big driver behind those programs. And his his motivation is not to talk sports with
  281. kids. His motivation is to pull them into stats via something that they're going to engage with.
  282. >> But also, Austin's a good town, Stephen, and so you can bring him around Austin
  283. anytime, and we'll set him up for some UT stuff. >> The plan is Oh, he would love that. The
  284. plan is right now he wants to go to Red River. So, >> even better. I mean, you can't beat
  285. that. I mean, tell me, look, here's you're as legit a person to ask this as anybody. What is a better sporting
  286. environment in North America than Texas? I'm sure they exist, but it's really, really, really tough to beat Texas. I
  287. >> I don't have a full breadth of experience in sporting events, but I can tell you in terms of American football,
  288. I've pretty much done it all. I've done multiple Super Bowls. I've done multiple
  289. NFL playoff games, that kind of thing. I've been pretty much everywhere in college. And Red River, like it gets a
  290. little semantic when you start ranking the top five, but it is 110% a top five experience because you know what's so
  291. funny? The the decrepitness of the cotton ball works in its favor on television. It's such a forced it's a
  292. forced visual. It's like a it's like a special effect because it's crowded. >> There's nowhere to go. There's nothing
  293. to distract you. You're basically in a cement sort of like enclave and then they jam it with one color and another
  294. color and they split it and on television it has such a beautiful aesthetic. I had a blast the year that I
  295. went. Also, the favorite always loses. It defies math. >> It's fun that way. I think the
  296. neutrality of the the site makes a probably the the biggest factor there. Um but it's so much fun. One last thing
  297. on on Bjan and Atlanta. I was pulling for Atlanta because I was pulling for the Panthers because of Eric Eager who
  298. is a PFF and number three now with Carolina. So, >> it's a very complicated calculus.
  299. >> It's a very complicated thing. So, because of eager loyalty, I had to pull for the Falcons. But but but I love
  300. excuses to watch them because Bjon is so ridiculous. I mean, it's just just the average fiveyard run is like a pleasure
  301. that you don't get from other >> it has a a sort of indescribable it's it's hard to quantify, but it has a Bo
  302. Jackson like Barry Sanders element to it in in my as a parent now to remember what it was like to see exceptional
  303. talent isolated at the NFL level, right? because we have such even competition in
  304. the NFL. It's very rare and I think that's what actually makes a star. You know, I think the first couple times
  305. Mahomes defied logic, you know, in his first or second season as a starter and, you know, maybe not so much the Saints
  306. game last weekend, but that Monday night game against the Rams recently where, you know, they were burning off the
  307. clock before I think they got the ball back with like under a minute left and he ripped a 95 yard uh run. It was it
  308. was the longest of his career, including college is what they said on the broadcast.
  309. that kind of stuff. That's how kids find superheroes in athletes and I think that's what's been so cool about this
  310. season. >> Yeah, definitely. >> It reminds me as my childhood Monday Night long run by a University of Texas
  311. running back was Earl Campbell. He ripped about a 80 80 plus yard against the Dolphins up the sidelines on Monday
  312. Night Football as probably a rookie. That's one of the great memories as a I don't know 11 year old kid.
  313. Stephen, you are of the South, I think, in so many ways. And I'd even forgotten that you were miss alum. And I thought
  314. about this particular Final Four. You live in Nashville. You talk about your Louisiana family all the time. One of
  315. the most influential articles you wrote early in your career was the Bagman article, which I believe was miss. And
  316. so had to talk. Old Miss is in the final four. I know >> they've got this ridiculous ridiculous
  317. morass of issues around them between quarterback eligibility next year between the coach having gone now
  318. recruiting players and restricting coaches. It's just absurd the craziness. H how does it feel? What's the sense
  319. from the miss people about what's going on with that team right now? >> Well, I just don't think Sanity is is
  320. not possible in Mississippi. Okay. Mississippi by nature tells a good story, but they don't necessarily end in
  321. a great place. Um, so it it the irony is not lost on me that they ascend to this
  322. point that they've never really seen in the modern game. They claim three national titles. One of those might be
  323. semi-legit as we all know that the uh the na the title claiming pre what 1970 is dubious at best. You often have six
  324. or seven in one season. >> Oh, absolutely. This is completely uncharted for them.
  325. Obviously, if you follow college football at all, you should be completely shocked to see Old Miss up
  326. there. Um, >> they are on It's house money. It's house money. that that that's the trope I'm gonna go with
  327. here because I think the even the most passionate Old Miss fan >> knows that >> Georgia had them dead to rights a couple
  328. times in that game and more than likely they shouldn't be here but because of some astronomical athletic play from
  329. their quarterback Trinidad Chamblas and some let's say suspicious decision-m on the play called on that that next to
  330. last drive for Georgia. They left some time on the clock. It allowed Old Miss to pull off those those big passes and
  331. get down in field goal range. Here we are. So, um it's, you know, I said all that without even mentioning the fact
  332. that their head coach is 2 and 0 in his career and those two games are in the playoff. Uh and there's this giant sort
  333. of unstoppable distraction in Baton Rouge in the form of Lane Keifin. The latest in that saga right now is that it
  334. uh it does not seem Look, this is early in the transfer portal window. I should clarify what I'm saying, but so far Miss
  335. has still continued to land really big names in the transfer portal. Uh LSU has gotten off to a quieter start and so um
  336. I'm not saying there's any buyer remorse yet with Lane Kein at LSU, but um every
  337. day is a new chapter in the saga. Uh I got a text from an official at Old Miss I don't know half hour after the game
  338. ended uh the Sugar Bowl and they I you know we're just kind of talking casually and the big fear was
  339. well today was all about Old Miss and since this whole thing with Lane has started any like like it's always about
  340. Lane and so there was this feeling after the game what's Lane going to do next and then sure enough now he's calling
  341. assistants back to Baton Rouge and it looks like the running back's coach Kevin Smith won't return to go coach in
  342. the Fiesta Bowl. And you can always kind of count on Lane to pick the pace of the
  343. story up, so to speak. Like, you know, he's like he's like the reality star on those Bravo shows where they're like,
  344. "Hey, can you go pick a fight with somebody just to make like that's that's Lane's essence, if you will."
  345. >> Okay. >> He's an accelerant. >> Extremely. Yes. Well, game. That game reminded me of a theory that
  346. I've been rooting over for a few years now. I enjoyed that game more than any Texas
  347. game I watched all year. I think I enjoy football games more when Texas is not involved. I so 100% thoroughly enjoyed.
  348. Now, I wanted Miss to win. So, I had a interest of kind some kind, but it wasn't strong. It was just an enjoyable
  349. football. It was a perfect football game if you for anybody, but especially if you were pulling for Miss. But it's just
  350. easier to watch those games where you don't care. You care, but not that much, you know?
  351. >> Well, I would I wholeheartedly endorse people to go experience sporting events
  352. where they don't have a dog, you know, a dog in the race. I like that's the trick
  353. of sports writing. I have a blast when I'm an objective party. When it's your team and your emotional investment and
  354. your stakes, it's terrible. I don't even like going to see my teams in games I think they could lose. You
  355. know, I I love I love finding that one game on the schedule where you're like, "This is going to be comfort." Whatever
  356. the sport is, just hey, this is going to be a comfortable margin. It's going to be fine. Like I used to tell parents of
  357. young kids all the time, if you want the experience and you take the photos and all that stuff of, "Hey, we're at the
  358. stadium. We're first dude preseason. Pre-season preseason tickets are easy to get. Kid
  359. wants to leave in the second quarter. Nobody cares because there's some third stringer out there." Um, no. I comp I'm
  360. 100% with you. objective viewing of great sports. Unless your team wins a championship,
  361. it's pretty hard to beat. >> Yeah. Yeah, that's right. And so unless you unless you're pulling you haven't
  362. been a Pats fan back at Pete Brady or Chiefs fan for the last five years. It's really tough in football. Okay, one last
  363. thing on Miss though, Chamblas, can can he do that again? Is it possible? You've
  364. watched him all year. You've watched him more than I have. Um, and does he need to to get past
  365. >> I think his touchdown interception ratio right now is 21-3 or 24-3, something
  366. like that. He has not been put in a situation where he's made a lot of decision errors. Just flat out
  367. misreading of coverage or forced into bad decisions. He does not tend to make bad decisions while mobile. and there's
  368. a very small list of quarterbacks that you could say that about at the college level, even the pro level where you run
  369. the risk if you're Miami, is that it presents a very different looking pocket than the teams that you've beaten
  370. so far. Marcel Reed and Texas A&M and then Julian Sean and Ohio State. And I think it's going to be Look, I I I I
  371. like Miami in the game because of the way their defense is playing. However, I think Charlie Weiss Jr. excels that
  372. that's the offensive coordinator at Old Miss in creating that annoyance. It's it's it's
  373. almost like being a defensive co coordinator in the fact that I think a lot of their schemes and routes are
  374. predicated on chaos and they're they're very sequence reliant and then you could
  375. have someone like Chamblas who can freelance if something breaks down. All this is to say Miami is very athletic,
  376. but there's a danger in over pursuit against a quarterback like this. And some of the stuff that I saw them bottle
  377. up Ohio State with some of the stuff that I saw that worked so well in that really lowscoring&m game, I don't think
  378. it's going to apply here. Um, so I think they've got to find a way. And maybe honestly, maybe it's something more
  379. similar to, you know, when mobile quarterback kind of came back as a concept in the as like Michael Vic for
  380. instance, there was this idea that you could solve it with cover two or Tampa 2 and you
  381. could box, you know, apply pressure, try and get home with four or five and then
  382. really start dropping and start creating problems there. that's anothetical to the way Miami's played this year, but no
  383. one's really made Chamblas get into a situation with multiple turnovers. Um, and what's funny is on the other side of
  384. the ball, you can say the same thing about Carson Beck has play has had a clean sheet for a while now, which is
  385. was the big knock on him going to Miami and the price tag associated with him. So, um, you know, it's probably cliche
  386. to say this, but I think the game is going to rely on turnovers from the quarterback position specifically. Um
  387. because these are I think in Miami you have so much raw talent and then in Miss I think really they're kind of the most
  388. creative team left in the in the final four. >> Yeah. He just hasn't given some of the
  389. concern that you get like you said decision making on the move. I mean there's plenty of mobile quarterbacks
  390. who you can't quite trust when they start making the decision out there. He hasn't given us that evidence yet. All
  391. right let's let's shift to the other game. Um, and what ought to be and will be if they win the whole thing, one of
  392. the great stories in sports really. I mean, really, it's I think it's it's hard to oversell what Signetti has done
  393. at Indiana. If they get this done, it's just remarkable. Somehow all the drama at Miss is staying level with Indiana so
  394. far. >> But talk a little bit about Indiana. Can you help us understand how this has
  395. happened in the two-year window? What is sign even where does for as lot many people don't know where signetti came
  396. from but to come as far as quickly as he has and this program the losingest program in the history of college
  397. football to come as far as quickly as I have how do you explain this deep there it's
  398. I often invoke a lot of sort of math vocabulary when I talk casually about this which is I talk about data sets and
  399. I talk about bias sampling I think that we so we're forced into referendum all the time in my industry,
  400. right? We want to know why something's happening, what the blueprint is, how is this going to change. The reality is
  401. this. We have about four and a half years worth of data on the portal. We have two years of data on a 12 team
  402. playoff. Okay, we have a couple years of ninegame conference structure in the Big
  403. 10. And then it's really hard to I think it's really hard to create any data from
  404. the selection committee because um I I shouldn't swear on this show but I have thoughts on the uh on the lack of
  405. consistency amongst the selection committee and just how foolish they are. >> So with all these mitigating factors in
  406. mind where we don't have 10 or 15 years worth of data to look at. I I think what
  407. stands out in a short period of time is that yes a lot of teams are hitting the portal. Okay, we know that and a lot of
  408. teams that are hitting the portal effectively have made it thus far. Like the athletic I think I don't and I don't
  409. know how they built the stat, but they compiled starts at every position by a transfer or by a science scholarship
  410. player out of high school. >> Miss had the highest percentage, Indiana had the second
  411. >> of transfer starts, >> transfer starts in the 2025 season. So any position start where they transfer
  412. where they, you know, native or whatever you want to call them. So miss and Indiana led the pack. Oregon
  413. was close. Um on the this this is just the playoff teams by the way. Um and then on the lower end you had Georgia
  414. and it it it roughly sused out to what you thought, right? So it's the teams that look like they don't belong here
  415. historically. So Texas Tech, Old Miss, Indiana, Oregon is trends a little bit more towards transfers, although no one
  416. really seems surprised by that. And then your stalwart high school recruiting, Tiffany Brands, Ohio State, Georgia,
  417. etc. They skewed lower. So, everybody's used the portal. And I swear I bet I was
  418. on here talking about how Florida State was doing it well two or three years ago. I probably was.
  419. >> Sure. >> But >> you had good company. >> Yeah. Well, I mean, we were we were all
  420. kind of trying this out for the first time. and we didn't really know what the methodology was, you know, and in the
  421. short amount of time, I keep trying to want to like add context to this or like put a giant asterisk around what I'm
  422. saying. The consistency that Indiana has had has been because they have almost a
  423. professional level, like NFL level of talent on evaluation. So, a lot of the key players and key contributors right
  424. now, standout guys, are James Madison transfers. And that's where, in case y'all don't,
  425. in case people listening don't know, that's where uh Signetti came from is James Madison.
  426. And so what that tells us is we've seen this trend now of coaches coming in, they'll take nine or 10 guys from their
  427. previous job and portal portal them in, but they usually they either wash out at
  428. the higher level or they're just not as effective. What I'm seeing from Indiana is something that shouldn't make sense,
  429. which is it is a portal-driven development culture. So that sentence should not make sense,
  430. >> right? >> But in a short amount of time, what I'm seeing is just as much consistency from
  431. guys they they transferred in from the smaller schools who were maybe two stars coming out of high school or less or not
  432. ranked at all who developed up and then continue to meet the expectation of playing a full Big 10 slate instead of a
  433. full Sunb Belt slate. while you're also seeing, you know, uh oh my god, my the name escapes me. He was on the podium at
  434. the Rose Bowl, the center, uh that transferred from Notre Dame, right? >> Okay. >> So, they're keen in their evaluation.
  435. They're sharp with it and they don't miss. So, how do I explain Indiana who's the best team left in this tournament
  436. and I think the odds on national title favorites. Very strange to say versus Florida State from a couple years ago
  437. where they hit on Jared Verse, they hit on Keon Coleman, right? These are NFL players now. And I think I'm talking
  438. about the year 2022 because the next two or three years, they had those same the
  439. methodology was in place, but two things happened. In a state like Florida, you have to you have to underpin everything
  440. with high school recruiting because I'll talk about Miami in a second. And then you have to continue to sort of hit 21,
  441. right? Everybody's hit blackjack if they sit at the table long enough, but it's not that's not a consistent money-making
  442. method. That's why the casinos are so nice. They took our money and built really nice buildings. And there was
  443. this casino-like logic early on with some of these premier programs that wanted to live topheavy with the portal
  444. without also doing the all of the unsexy stuff and the traditional scouting and high school methodology.
  445. Now, we have a theory on the Yahoo show. Andy Staples and I have talked about this.
  446. If we're right about this, it should start to move Indiana's pendulum a little bit towards high school as well.
  447. that percentage. I think it was like 64% of starts or something like that. Let's
  448. say it's somewhere in the 60s. I think you could see it closer to 45 one day. But if it lived in the 50s,
  449. that that would be the sign of a healthy program. Now, here's what's interesting.
  450. >> It is a lot. But here's what's interesting. Like you grew up on Texas, right? Florida State has the state of
  451. Florida. University of Georgia should never really be they should never really be flourishing in the portal because
  452. they have the state of Georgia at their back >> where they are. Right. Right. >> Indiana not so much.
  453. >> Yeah. Right. >> Miss under like high high amount of talent but still an underpop populated
  454. state. So I'm curious how long you can sustain with a portal dominant strategy. And
  455. unfortunately the answer is we don't know because we only have about four years worth of real data here. What I
  456. can tell you emphatically and like is that you can go far with a portal team. You can go very far with a portal team
  457. for sure. >> I asked a question that even less status based on just because I've been hearing
  458. with Signetti and and what he's done there and the fact that Moses is probably going to be the number one
  459. pick. >> Yeah. Would the Raiders would there be any intrigue or or or thought that like
  460. well let's keep this very successful kind of combo together. Would they ever consider him for a
  461. coaching position? >> I based again on the assumption that they are taking Mendoza with the number
  462. one pick is >> all indications tell me that Signetti doesn't want to go to the pros that he's
  463. happy where he is. Um I think Signetti is mindful enough that he's found a situation where they're going to build
  464. him a statue regardless. Um, he's now top five compensation, I think, currently. If you could just go
  465. by average annual value, like it's a hockey contract, like AAV, I think with bonuses and everything else, he's he's
  466. in the top five. I don't see him moving off of that position anytime soon. And if I'm an NFL
  467. GM, I would question the recency of it all. Like, I would need I would want to see more more information. The only
  468. person that agents talk to me about as the sort of uh how would I describe this? The only
  469. candidate right now on the co on the college side that agents have said would be a no-brainer on the NFL side is still
  470. Marcus Freeman. But he has taken his name out of this cycle and I think it'll be an annual thing from here on out
  471. where Freeman will probably have to speak on whether or not he's interested each cycle as long as they keep winning.
  472. So, um, Signetti, I feel like would probably stay in the college game. Um, and then, you know, I I could see maybe
  473. a Dan Lanning one day, but not anytime soon. >> Don't you wish Bobby Knight was still
  474. around so he could go rebel in the old schoolness of Kurt Signetti at his university?
  475. >> I think those two would get along great, >> wouldn't they, though? So, I I wasn't
  476. paying attention when they hired him. Can do you can you try to somehow get objectively back to that moment and talk
  477. about the cons consensus when it happened? I mean college football coaches I think that's one of the
  478. toughest hiring decisions possible. The different things they have to be good at. It's just absurd. It's it's it's
  479. really tough to get this right. How was that hire evaluated at the time? >> Forgive me for my Pennsylvania
  480. geography. Where is IUP at? IUP. Um, I don't even know. Indiana versus Pennsylvania. Shane, do you have
  481. any idea? I don't know. >> Not in the Philadelphia area. Not Not Not Eastern P. >> Yes.
  482. >> All right. I'm now looking it up because it is Oh, sorry. It's in Indiana, Pennsylvania.
  483. >> I couldn't tell you where that is. >> All right. I'm still Oh, okay. >> Indiana, I would think. Right.
  484. >> We're on the west side. I just I just found it. We're on the We're We're on the west side. We're We're much closer
  485. to Pittsburgh. Okay. We're in um yeah, that's the middle of nowhere. I know that. Um because as a sports writer
  486. going to Penn State for many years, I I was I've always people have described uh
  487. Pennsylvania as Pittsburgh on one side, Philadelphia on the other, and Arkansas in the middle. Um which is a Southerner.
  488. I can tell that joke. IUP is where he started his head coaching career. >> Okay.
  489. >> He was on the Sabbin, he was on the initial Sabin Alabama staff. Uh I want to say just for one season.
  490. Okay. >> So, it was Yeah, he's Sabin Tree, but I really wouldn't call him that. >> Yeah.
  491. >> Um, he doesn't have a lot in common structurally with with like, you know, he's daer.
  492. He makes, you know, he he sort of stares down media in a similar way. Um, structurally, he doesn't have a ton in
  493. common with Sabin, honestly. So I I I would be I I I would feel hesitant to call him a saving tree. But in 2011, he
  494. starts his head coaching career at IUP, which is why I asked that. Builds a a winner there, goes to Elon, which is a a
  495. CIA team in South Carolina, and then jumps up and gets the James Madison job as the transition head
  496. coach, meaning that James Madison was going from FCS to FBS. That is an First off, let me say this.
  497. Almost every coach I've ever known who was the sitting head coach of an FCS team when they move up knows that they
  498. are a dead man walking. It's incredibly hard to lead a transition and program. And we can get into it another time. He
  499. not only led it, but succeeded more so at JMU in the two years that they were a Sunbelt member at the FBS level. Of
  500. course, in 23 he goes 11 and one. They start to make kind of noise nationally. James Madison also to Sig's credit
  501. and I guess this is very similar to Sabin he's very mindful of where he jumps and resource he's not he has not
  502. chased helmets in the sense of looking for the just looking for a bigger job because James Madison saved for years
  503. and fundraised for years and almost became too big for the FCS. You ever gone down I 81 in Virginia and seen that
  504. football stadium from the interstate? It doesn't look like you're in the FCS. >> Okay.
  505. >> They were from a facilities fundraising, from an enrollment, from all the things
  506. standpoint, you know, a lot of teams move up to the FBS and kind of mortgage it. They kind of like kind of just like
  507. like lend it out and figure out how to pay for it later. This this was a program that was so ready that they
  508. dominated right away. And Signetti was again talent evaluating and recruiting inside the margins of the DMV zone in
  509. the Carolinas where you're you're not the first pig to that trough if you're at James Madison, but consistently
  510. evaluating at a high level. And so his last three years he's 12 wins and then eight wins on the transition, 11 wins.
  511. >> Absurd. It's absurd transition. >> Here's the deal though. So you're Indiana and you are historically awful.
  512. Morbent, right? just awful losing at one point the lossiest program in FBS history.
  513. What appealed to Indiana about Signetti was the development culture and the consistency.
  514. >> That's interesting. >> What appealed to Signetti about Indiana was that he saw it in the room. I know
  515. like I'm sure you guys get tired of hearing about like Michael Lewis references, but it was very much that he
  516. >> We're here for we're here for the Michael Lewis reference. >> Okay. He saw the market.
  517. He's I mean it is a little bit like the first act of the big short where he saw where the market was going and you know
  518. that the big short's not a great comp because that's more about betting against the market. He didn't bet
  519. against the market. He actually he actually got to the market so much faster than some of the Big 10 and SEC
  520. peers that he's now beating. That's a huge component of it. But there was an immediate
  521. >> saying what you're saying is the market is the portal the new world that we're
  522. living in. >> But also the ability to pay for it. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> So, there's this beautiful moment that
  523. happens where someone has correctly identified a coming trend and then they go and they find the they find the the
  524. right partnered undervalued asset that's going to be differently valued if it's >> Yeah.
  525. >> And what's and what's historically known about IU? Okay. Bad football. They have
  526. a great business school and they're chaka block with alumni looking to spend money. All right.
  527. >> Why is that? That part I didn't know. That's and I've heard that they're big spenders in the NIO world. But I
  528. wouldn't have known that even with the good business school. I wouldn't have kn I think first honestly basketball then I
  529. think music in business school probably third. >> My my co-host on Yahoo Ross Dinger he's
  530. reported this out before but basically the estimation of TV and TV's God to college is that basketball is worth
  531. something like 10 or 15% of your TV value. And so to go back to that that moment that great moment of kismet when
  532. signetti meet met Indiana's leadership had become increasingly aware of we're never going to be done with realignment
  533. we're going to find a super league one day and Indiana right now is a historic basketball power emphasis on the
  534. historic right what else did they offer and what where else is there is there value in the current market so there was
  535. this flood of emphasis to go into football from the university, from the donors who
  536. wrote the checks, from the athletic department, and then from a coach who said, "Hey, not only, keep in mind,
  537. guys, there were a lot of coaches that were protesting this concept." Dabau Sweeney, remember that?
  538. >> Yeah. >> How's Dabo doing? >> So, there were a lot of coaches that said, "I don't want any part of this."
  539. And what he said was, "If you can fund this at the highest level, I can work this system." Then they had
  540. the beautiful benefit of being a Trojan horse last year. And so that kind of takes us now to the
  541. season. You know, we talked about this on the show the other day. I don't think anybody took this team
  542. seriously until they probably until they beat Oregon the first time this year. Even last year,
  543. the way the the way in which they lost to a really hot, really talented Notre Dame team, everyone thought,
  544. >> "Yep, >> BS light schedule. Big 10 doesn't know what it's doing. They barfed up this
  545. undefeated team because they don't have enough quality middle class programs. There's one thing I'd actually like to
  546. talk to you guys about. And I don't know how you figure out how to do this with a number, but I would
  547. love to because Indiana is representing a change here, but I think the Big 10 is
  548. on the cusp of changing this entire overall narrative. And I think and I mean I'm changing the subject here a
  549. little bit, but I think Indiana if if Indiana's hoisting the national championship in two weeks, we're going
  550. to reverse engineer this season. And I think what we're going to see is we have terminally
  551. in our bias as a southern driven sport for 20 years given the benefit of the doubt to programs who no longer deserve
  552. it. And we're going to have to like admit this publicly and then work it back. And that's going to be really hard
  553. for some people in the media. So, what I'm talking about is the total dismantling of Alabama. All
  554. right. When selection >> That's a moment. That's a moment. >> When Selection Sunday came around,
  555. every pundant, even my guy, even my co-hosts who know a ton about the sport, and I just said, why? And I'm not trying
  556. to make myself out like I knew, but I just said, why do we have to we h we have to assume that the two teams that
  557. make the SEC championship must be included in the 12 team format. And everyone said, well, you can't punish
  558. them for going to Atlanta and losing. And I said, "Well, what if they suck? What if this is just another opportunity
  559. to show that their resume is weak?" And so Alabama gets the benefit of the doubt. They go in, they kind of squeak
  560. past an Oklahoma team that didn't look that great either. And then Indiana shows that they are a full world away
  561. from actual title contender. And what's interesting to me now is to look at this
  562. Final Four game and to look at the team that brought both of these two schools to their knees, which was Iowa. And that
  563. Iowa team was probably one win away. Now, they didn't get it. They didn't beat USC, but had that Iowa team been a
  564. true nine- win contender going into selection Sunday, I don't think that they could have beaten out an Alabama.
  565. We already know that Alabama beat out a Notre Dame team that they're not as good
  566. as. This SEC bias thing, and I'm talking to you from inside the Death Star, okay?
  567. uh this this SEC bias thing. I think some serious work needs to be done analytically in the in the numbers world
  568. in the in the world of the quantitives to somehow sus out and explain why I think it's baked into the preseason
  569. rankings. I think television plays a role in this and I think by the time we start with the selection committee in
  570. early November, we've already kind of kind of calcified our perception of some of these schools. And I think it's
  571. incorrect. And I like I think Illinois hurts for this. I think Iowa hurts for this. I think the Big 10 hurts.
  572. >> I I said it's a it's a worthy topic and and and we should take it up. We should
  573. take it up sometime over the next 12 months. Um I I push back on one particular dimension and that is the
  574. depth of the SEC versus the depth of the Big 10. And so whenever you start bringing Illinois into the conversation,
  575. I start >> start wanting to jump in because >> what's true is that the numbers this
  576. year, Stephen, and this is actually something you you were talking a minute ago about how people weren't buying
  577. Indiana until they beat Oregon this year because of the experience last year, the
  578. numbers were saying Indiana. And I was having the hardest time believing like Indiana was at the top from like
  579. mid-season on. It's like the number one team in college Indiana. And I was like,
  580. really, really, really? It's like that's it was one of these places where analytics, one of the good analytics
  581. show you things a few weeks before the rest of the world sees them. And power rankings were showing this. But let me
  582. just finish real quickly. Indiana and Ohio State have been top above the top of the SEC all season long, more or
  583. less, but then like the next eight teams are SEC teams and just the variance on the Big 10 is so much broader. And that
  584. means that making it through that nineame schedule, it's only been eight game, but it's about to be nine game in
  585. the SEC is going to be a loss generating proposition. And so I'm sympathetic. >> Oh, I like that terminology.
  586. >> I'm I'm an insider now being a long run person, but like I I I'm going to be sympathetic to the to the three loss SEC
  587. teams because of the rigor of the schedule that they >> Well, I I think it's it's a couple
  588. things. One, I just want to I was going to mention this. Anytime Connelly when he's putting the numbers together and it
  589. spits him back out and he's getting these weird when he's getting these results that the public won't accept
  590. yet. I always love it when Connor and I talking to him about it because you just
  591. get this exhausted sigh because he knows, you know, people still think quantitative that they think that like
  592. Bill sat up and made this. >> Yeah. >> You know, like he's like, I you know what, I'm putting Indiana number one
  593. this week. screw every and he'll have those weeks where he gets the numbers back and he's just like, "Oh god,
  594. >> I got to explain these numbers to the world." >> Um, which is why he's kind of started
  595. othering the ranking and like sort of turning the ranking sentient and just saying like the I don't agree with the
  596. rank, but this is what SP told me this week. Um, I had a really interesting conversation for an offseason piece I
  597. was doing a year ago with a recruiting analyst named Steve uh Wilfong. He works for Onree. He's been doing it for a
  598. really long time. And I think uh recruiting analyst is a dubious term. You know, it's got a kind of like a
  599. Vegas sheen about it. And I don't mean, you know, like it's just um >> it's really just a sports writing beat
  600. at this point, right? I mean, more >> No kidding. No kidding. Gosh. But I digress. Uh but but Steve is a really
  601. wellrespected guy. He's been doing it for a long time. And one of the sort of big futures bets in college football is
  602. that the Illinois, Ias, etc., and Indiana, which is just sort of way above schedule, way past schedule, ahead of
  603. schedule is what I should say. Um, are going to establish a more respectable Big 10 middle class. And so
  604. to see the Alabama results and to see some of the things that like, you know, to see
  605. last year's data set where it just felt like the SEC was going to lose their mind because SMU got in, but then South
  606. Carolina loses a bowl and Alabama loses a bowl. And I know everybody says, well,
  607. it's because of the optouts or whatever. We are we are continuing to see an SEC product that yes has the robust middle
  608. and week after week it's like the uh Bruce Feldman body blow theory right is like you know if you play that week
  609. after week after week you're going to start to sort of wear down or you know the cream rises
  610. but I don't know if they're ever like I I I don't know what's exceptional anymore in the SEC because I'm going to
  611. tell you this as an alumni of the one team left is that the best team in the SEC See
  612. >> right >> like >> right well I mean when Chand when he plays like he did last weekend I mean
  613. >> quite possibly >> Texas is going to be a great case study next year specifically it's funny to go
  614. back to my 8-year-old the worst thing is he's really math strong he's a Texas fan
  615. so he's incredibly literal and so it does not make sense to him everything is black and white and he goes wait Texas
  616. has a ton of money you told me that I was like oh yeah Texas yeah but Texas got a lot of alumni they spend a lot of
  617. money he goes Well, then they should be in the playoffs. And I go, "Hey, man." I
  618. said, "Welcome to the quandry that is Texas athletic sometimes." I was like, it it doesn't always sus out that way
  619. or&m would have 10 national titles. Texas is going to be a fascinating case study next year because we can now start
  620. to build a referendum on, all right, I know why the TV revenue side of this made sense for y'all in Austin. I get
  621. that, right? You're going to make a ton of money on TV, but think about all those years Oklahoma kind of got to like
  622. moonwalk into the 14 playoffs. 100% 100%. >> So, is this going to be a sustainable
  623. product if you jam these conferences filled with contenders and they eat each other alive?
  624. >> God knows it's going to I mean, we can argue this all night and then they're going to change it again in a couple of
  625. years. But what's what's true is that they felt like it was a necessary move because SEC was truly separating from
  626. the rest of the world and you were losing talent. If you look at what Texas A&M's recruiting rankings did in like
  627. the 10 years before they joined the SEC and then the 10 years after, it's just extraordinary. And Texas was at a
  628. disadvantage because players wanted to play in the SEC. But that was before NIL and Portal. And now it's really just
  629. leveled the playing field. people are willing to go to love or um >> I would love to combine
  630. >> like to to write a p to write a some like a dissertation or something on this
  631. that's half analytical and half social science because I think that Katrina in Texas
  632. >> backdoored an SEC expansion in the most miserable of human experiences obviously
  633. but the volume of relocation and the anecdotal evidence I have of the 10 years after Katrina
  634. >> of kids families that were from Louisiana and the Gulf Coast who migrated into Texas and then it allowed
  635. those brands to go into Texas and recruit with a little bit more familiarity. It almost made it mandatory
  636. like you're saying when the decision came for the Red River Schools that the world was moving east. It's very
  637. fascinating to me. Now financially you can't argue it but you know by the way as I say this and maybe the next time
  638. I'm on the show this will be settled. I think according to Ross it will be this playoff will expand. The next time we
  639. play this playoff there will be at least 14 teams. And if I'm betting right now,
  640. I'm saying that it's probably going to be 16. >> I don't love that either. >> Yeah, that's a that's a that's another
  641. whole frontier here that's moving. Um all right, let's save it for the next time, Steve. Yes, sir.
  642. >> Um greatly appreciate you. >> Got it. Got the deep dive we're hoping for on college football and come away.
  643. thinking about it a little bit differently. Greatly appreciate it. I hope for I have to tell you the two
  644. stories we've talked about. I mean, Miss and Indiana, it will be glorious if that's the matchup because as far as I'm
  645. concerned, like there's just either one of them is one of the most remarkable stories in decades. And so, we'll see.
  646. We'll probably end up with Miami or so depressing. >> I I would love for people to embrace
  647. parody. Like I I was at the FCS national title game last night here in Nashville,
  648. Montana State, Illinois State. It was an amazing game. There was no North Dakota
  649. State. There was no 62 to nothing win like we've seen for the last 15 years at that level.
  650. >> Okay. >> The portal has created so much parody at every level of the sport that I think
  651. parody is like the NFL tells us, right? We we what what do we >> right? >> We like parody. We like it. So, I'm
  652. hoping college football learns to embrace it. >> I I I I think they will. I think this is
  653. this this final four alone is a great case for it. All right, guys. You can catch Stephen Godfrey many places. Um he
  654. is a writer for Yahoo Sports and the Washington Post. You can catch his production company's podcast, Phantom
  655. Island. You can catch him on the College Football Inquirer podcast with Staples and Dinger. One of the great writers on
  656. college football. Thanks for the time, Stephen. Always good to visit with you. >> Thank you guys so much.
  657. >> Absolutely. Take care for the whole team here. We've lost Shane Jensen there at
  658. the very end for Eric Bradlo and Audi Winer and Absentia for Dion Simpkins making this thing happen. Marissa,
  659. Raina, D Patel, the whole team. And for you guys, the listeners, thanks for being here. Come back and join us next
  660. time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Seth Walder and Stephen Godfrey discuss NFL playoffs and college football dynamics, focusing on unpredictability and the impact of the transfer portal.

Key points

  • NFL Playoff Bracket Set. Discussion on the filled NFL playoff bracket and its implications.
  • Seattle's Surprising Performance. Seth Walder highlights Seattle as the most surprising team this season.
  • Dynamic Blitz Predictions. Adrenaline uses real-time data to predict blitz probabilities in NFL games.
  • Decision Analysts on Broadcasts. Seth Walder discusses the role of decision analysts during NFL broadcasts.
  • Ole Miss's Surprising Success. Ole Miss reaches the Final Four amidst chaos and uncertainty in college football.
  • Lane's Essence. Lane is like a reality star, always stirring up drama.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes