Why the Transfer Portal Makes College Football Harder to Predict
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE College football rosters can now change dramatically from one season to the next. That is making forecasts, player evaluation, and even award races more complicated.
Ron Yurko, Director of the Carnegie Mellon Sports Analytics Center, explains how analytics can better account for roster turnover in the transfer portal era. He also discusses the Heisman Hopefuls platform, the challenge of comparing players across positions, and why sports betting and prediction markets require more statistical literacy.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Money Ball, welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on
- the Wharton Podcast Network. This is Cade Massey hosting this week with two of my three colleagues in for the
- next hour, Eric Bradlow, professor of marketing statistics, and Shane Jensen, professor of statistics, two of
- the three colleagues I'm usually on here with. Audie Weiner in the classroom at the moment.
- Sadly, we will not have Audie today. We're going to run the normal format, meaning
- we're going to go an hour. We're going to do guests in the first half hour. Given the guest and the number of topics
- we could talk about, I suspect it's going to go more than half an hour, and we'll round out the show once our guest
- leaves with some open lines, open topics. Our guest this week, Ron Yurko, longtime friend
- of the show. I feel like we've known him since he was a pup. He's still a little bit of a pup,
- but not as much of a pup as he was. Ron Yurko is a teaching professor at Carnegie
- Mellon. He helps run the Carnegie Mellon, and they're in the SDS department, statistics and decision sciences.
- He helps run the famous and fantastic Carnegie Mellon Sports Analytics Center, which includes lots of
- efforts, but notably their conference, which is in just a couple of weeks here. They run an October conference, which is about
- as good as it gets in the world of sports analytics. I'm always delighted to have Ron.
- He's done teaching for us. We've been over there. He's helped out in lots of ways.
- He got his Ph.D. there at Carnegie Mellon. Heck, he went to undergrad at Carnegie Mellon.
- I think he is as Pittsburgh as it gets, as can be seen with the terrible towel in the background.
- Ron, welcome to the show. Thanks for the introduction, Ted. And, you know, you have a little bit
- of a CMU run going on right now. You had Sam Ventura on, another Pittsburgher, you
- know, another CMU, you know, integral part of our sports analytics center. And so, I don't know, maybe we can
- get a third person here at some point. Now, give us this. Well, we got we have Karim Kassam coming
- through to talk to Adi's lab group in just a couple of weeks. And so it is quite the fall, the
- fall of Carnegie Mellon here. Well, Ron, we just want to know how much it's going to be a little differently
- than that. Ron, how much, how much? Let's let's talk. Let's talk brass tacks here.
- How much of the three billion dollars is the Sports Analytics Center getting? Come on, Ron.
- That's got to be at least. I mean, I know as much, I know as much as you just put it, but
- yeah, it's been exciting times. And yeah, they had a big event on campus, CMU Miami.
- The yeah, I have no idea what to expect. I'm just I'm just along for the ride. I feel like Carnegie Mellon's like MIT, the
- world has kind of come to you over time. I mean, the STEM tech world that we live in has migrated towards our great STEM
- tech universities, one of which is clearly Carnegie Mellon. So it's a good time to be in
- Pittsburgh where you are. Yeah, no, it's been it's been a blast, honestly. Like it's amazing.
- I just think of fifth year now as faculty, which is just crazy. I remember when I was PhD student out
- in the studio with you guys. And it's just kind of crazy to reflect on at times that it's like how much
- time has passed. And I just get I just get to be part of this whole big thing all
- at once. Well, one of the things that y'all have going on this year that is super
- cool is this Heisman collaboration that you have. So some folks who are listening will have
- seen it. Some folks won't. So tell us about the partnership that you guys have and what it involves with the
- Heisman. Yeah, so really, you know, big thanks to the leadership over at Heisman, Jeff Price, Tim
- Henning, Brendan Baumgartner, amongst others, where Heisman is sort of reimagining themselves as an organization.
- You know, it's probably the most prestigious award in American sports, I would argue.
- You know, this is the award given to the most outstanding college football player in whatever
- way you want to go about defining that. And, you know, they they're taking this approach
- of like, how do they modernize this? How do they put the Heisman in the conversation all year?
- And they reached out to fans and, you know, they were hearing perception that, you know,
- fans viewed this as effectively a QB or a running back award. And, you know, they wanted more data.
- They wanted more analytics. And fortunately, the folks at the Heisman came out when the NFL draft was in town
- in the spring and they connected with us and, you know, figuring out about ways in
- which they could create this new Heisman hopefuls platform where the idea is literally every position
- in every program at the start of the year, every single player, you know, regardless of
- what position the vision is, they are a Heisman hopeful. And so for someone like me, who's been
- working on problems in football analytics for a decent amount of time now, you know, this
- is this is this is the holy grail of football, right, is how do we actually evaluate objectively every single position right on the
- field? How do we go about doing this? And, you know, they want to tap into this for college.
- Your your goal then is to you'll know you succeed when an offensive guard wins the
- Heisman trophy. Is that kind of the mark? Yeah, I don't know if they're going to
- win, but like if we see, you know, a lineman there, you know, in the in the in the final, you know, whatnot on
- the final day, that could be pretty neat. Just to be clear, Ron, are you looking
- at cross position value or value of players within position or both? Yeah, great question.
- So I will say this, like we're just getting started on it this year of like what gets provided, because obviously when we think
- about like how do we actually get data on evaluating offensive linemen, right, or data evaluating
- on cornerbacks, even right, things are very limited, right? You know, we talk a lot about like
- having access to tracking data to get new types of metrics. And I would still argue, you know, what
- research that we've done with tracking data, I can't give you a good number to say
- how much more valuable this linebacker was compared to this corner compared to the safety like
- on any given play. All right. So I would what I'm going to say right now is we are taking advantage of
- their relationship with EA Sports and such that EA Sports ratings for every single player in
- college football and FBS are being provided so that fans when they go to the Heisman
- Copal's website, they could see, hey, what are the ratings for players within a position?
- And so every single lineman, you know, actually has some number giving some way similar to
- how folks use Madden ratings where, you know, there's objective information that's going into that, what
- data they have access to at EA Sports and also their team of scouts that they rely on for subjective evaluation.
- And it's dynamic, right? They get to update that over the course of the year. So that's surprising.
- That's surprising to me. I think of the Madden ratings as things that came out in the beginning of the
- year. And that's a big deal when you find out what the number is. And then that's kind of fixed.
- Maybe I was wrong about that. But PFF is an organization that updates their numbers continually.
- They'll rate every play and they give a season level running, running score. So you're saying that EA Sports numbers that
- you're working with are dynamic. They're updating on a weekly basis. Yeah. EA Sports this year for the first time
- in college football, they're updating it weekly. They're not just frozen at the beginning of
- the year. And they've been doing that with Madden ratings, actually, as well. And I think, you know, college, you know,
- is a very, you know, it's a very different space compared to professional football, right, of
- how do you actually go about this evaluation of players subject to the wide range of
- talent that you see and how talent gets matched up between each other. You know, it's much more difficult, right?
- It's much more difficult to infer how good is the linebacker at New Mexico versus, you
- know, within the NFL comparing linebackers between the different teams, right? Ron, have you been asked to provide just,
- I'll call it, measures of performance as opposed to some sort of weighted score that gives
- some overall, like you'll let the consumer of this information decide what they want to do
- with it. But in some sense, they're not asking you for, like, you can imagine using, treating this
- like a supervised learning problem. You take last, you take the previous highs and winters, you see what things are predictive
- of that. And so you're not trying to predict the winner. You're trying, you're an information provider of what
- you think are useful statistics. Or do I not have that right? Yeah, you're absolutely right.
- You know, what we're, what we're working on with them is figuring out, like, what are
- the right types of metrics to bring over that hopefully give fans and also give their
- voters, right? And those voters are past Heisman winners, members of this electorate, sports journalist reporters, what information
- that can help them gauge what's going on. A big part of this then, especially in
- this first year of what we're working on with them is this fan vote. And so folks didn't realize, I think that,
- you know, Heisman's had this fan vote that it actually counts as an official ballot in
- the final Heisman vote that's cast. Now it's one vote of many that they have, but one of the coolest things they're
- doing this year is it's going to get announced on a conference championship Saturday to sort
- of be the first ballot that's officially cast. And, you know, they want it to be
- like a signal of what the fans are saying. And part of the motivation is last year,
- Jacob Rodriguez, this linebacker at Texas Tech won the fan vote. And that didn't get reported until after the
- Heisman, when Mendoza officially won it. And that's when it came out. But there was a little bit of a
- campaign. I think his girlfriend or wife was tweeting about it all the time, trying to build
- up like fans to vote for him. But he had a fantastic college football season and maybe could make a case for being
- in the Heisman race. And so one of the things that we're doing this year that it created was, you
- know, they're very much interested in having fans vote the entire year. But if you think about that, you know,
- a vote after just one week of games, right, is based on a single week of information.
- And then, you know, fans are going to keep voting every day throughout the entire year.
- So how much weight should you give to a vote in week one versus a weight to a vote at the end of the
- year? And, you know, you can think of like a naive way of doing that, of going, oh, one week of games, it's worth one,
- two weeks of games worth two. But, you know, I'm a statistician. So I took some time and was reading,
- of course, classic work by Mark Glickman and also Shane. There's this cool paper thinking about, you know,
- how much they were looking, I think it was like for design of matchups and selecting,
- like how much information in a game. Yeah. And the pair comparison test, right, and pair
- comparison modeling. And so what I decided to do was, you know, in college football, there is very
- limited, I would say, like public available college football staffs to work with, right?
- I don't have statistics yet on every single position to say, like, how much information have
- I learned about every player in college football? But what I do have is I have game outcomes.
- And so I can model head to head outcomes of games. And this is going back to classic Mark
- Glickman, how Stern model for football outcomes. And I have strength parameters that I learned
- for each team. And I can allow that to evolve from week to week, as well as from season
- to season. And what I what I ended up doing was I was curious about, like, OK, how
- much information am I gaining? How much information am I observing from week to week?
- And so what I decided to set up is if I viewed the the ratings I effectively learned from this state space model at
- the end of the year as sort of the anchor, I could see how far away are we from that end of the year
- at week 12, at week 11, at week 10, and so on, all the way back to week one. And for statisticians, just do this with KL
- divergence. And I could get, OK, a notion of this distance. And I scale it then in such a
- way that, all right, the the ratings, the weeks that are closest to the end of the year have higher weight.
- And one of the things that I thought was actually kind of cool about this was I did this over the past five years
- of what I call the NIL era. Things behave differently in the NIL era compared to before.
- And what I actually observed, because I allowed this model to take information from the year
- before as the prior entering the following year, you would actually see weeks two and three
- that could be further away from the end of the year than week one. And so it was this interesting period that
- kind of matches, I think, with intuition. We think about in the college football season
- where the first few weeks of the college football season, they can be kind of noisy.
- All right. You can have roster shakeups going on. You have weird, you know, Penn State looked
- amazing playing Marshall and Buffalo and Temple. Right. And then, you know, conference games kick in.
- Right. We don't have too many of these great matchups at the very beginning of the year.
- And how much information are we really gaining in those first few weeks? And so what this leads to is this
- curve that at the end of the day, as a statistician, I was thrilled. It was like, all right, I feel like
- I did real statistics. And then I got a very intuitive looking line that basically says, you know, weeks one
- through four, it's like a slow increase in weight. And then once you get into week five,
- it's just this really steady increase until the end of the year. And that's and we end up getting this
- this chart that basically says, like, hey, at the end of the season, your vote after
- all the weeks that have been observed, every single game that's been observed, it's worth 18
- times the amount of a vote from week one. Right. Because you've observed all of these weeks and
- it's not just 13 times more. Right. It's relative to what we're actually observing over
- the progression of the year. So that was that's the biggest contribution that I have for this platform this year.
- And it's for for fans, it's, hey, this Heisman fan vote race isn't going to be over in this week or week six or
- whatnot. Like Trinidad Chambliss, I think, is currently leading. Jeremiah Smith's probably going to take over in
- the next week. But every week moving forward, their vote is going to give more and more weight.
- Yeah. And so it's all based on this idea of how much information are we actually observing
- that's translating across the season. That's awesome. And it's awesome that the Heisman guys were
- willing to give you say in that matter. And we're willing to go with such a sophisticated and, you know, opaque, probably to most
- people methodologically approach. But it's really, really cool. Let me ask you a different question.
- This is just kind of a stepping away from the Heisman thing in particular, the Heisman
- Hopefuls platform, though we'd encourage people, Heisman Hopefuls, easy to Google, easy to vote.
- They have a running leaderboard of the EA scores by position. So it's fun that way.
- Let me just ask Ron, the analyst, Ron, the football fan, Ron, the cutting edge football
- analytics guy to weigh in on Jeremiah Smith versus Chambliss. And there's no right answer to this question.
- But we often bemoan that the Heisman always goes to the QB. We've had a couple of examples recently where
- there are exceptions. But over the over the history, hold on, didn't did Hugh Green win it as a
- defensive guy for Pittsburgh or I'm making that up? Way back when, that's before my time, come
- on, Pittsburgh, famous Pittsburgh Panther, there have there. I mean, Charles Woodson, I mean, we've had
- defensive, we've had defensive backs when it. OK, but it's rare in recent. Travis Hunter won it, but he played Travis,
- but he was a two way player, really kind of exceptional in that respect. I'm asking for kind of an analytics.
- Perspective on how exceptional would a wide receiver need to be if we take we have
- to define what we're looking for, like like let's say most valuable player by advanced analytics,
- how good would a wide receiver have to be to top the best quarterback? You know, now I'm not saying this is
- what the actual criterion is, because there's an eye test, there's a specialness that Jeremiah Smith
- seems to be hitting right now. But if you were to approach it analytically, just give us a sense.
- What do you think? How exceptional would a wide receiver have to be to top the most valuable position on
- the field by any measure? Yeah, it's a great question. I mean, it gets at the heart of
- this problem of how do I actually get a sense for how good any single individual
- player is on the football field, right, while controlling for the fact of who is their
- quarterback, who are they facing, who could be going up against them, right? And I still don't think we have good
- numbers on that, right, to say, like, you know, is Jeremiah Smith the same value as
- a QB? And I don't think I've seen a good way of doing that in college football yet,
- partly because publicly, right, we don't have the information on who who's on the field for
- every play, right? I can't just straight up adjust for that. But that being said, right, when you have
- a wide receiver that is putting up, you know, record like numbers, and if I think
- we go back to the examples of wide receivers that were putting up these ridiculous numbers
- in the past, you know, they're getting themselves elevated into the Heisman race, right?
- DeMonte Smith, right, he won the Heisman, being someone that was putting up these incredible numbers
- at Alabama. And right now, if I had to like make my vote of who is the leader of this Heisman race, I would I would
- say Jeremiah Smith, just given the consistency to, right, if you know, that's my fan hat
- coming on of like, how do I think about someone that is like Heisman deserving, you
- know, it's not just single moments, it's like a level of consistency that goes through the
- entire thing. And so, you know, I think like this question of how much does, you know, someone
- need to elevate at a certain position to, you know, exceed what we just think of
- as, hey, the most important position in football is the quarterback, right? And there's no doubt about that.
- But where is someone within position so many like standard deviations away? And is that the signal for us that,
- hey, this is this is a generational wide receiver or what they're doing is good?
- I was going to say, with regard to the decision making, like, is it is it just about whether that like wide receiver stands
- out historically or relative to his peers? Or do you also need that? It's just not an exciting quarterback year or
- whatever, like like like like if there's a quarterback that stands out, I think they they
- can just kind of have the you know, that's that type of thing. I can so like, you know, do you
- kind of need this combination like for like a defensive player or a wide receiver or
- some skill position player that's not a quarterback to be elevated into that conversation?
- Do you also kind of need to not be kind of on the top end of the of the of the quarterback position?
- And the QBs, I feel like will also get hit a little bit more by their record than other positions, too.
- Yeah, right. The Trinidad Chambliss will take a little bit of a drop because it's, well, oh, Ole
- Miss lost, right? They lost the Florida. It's the flip side of being able to basically having your hands on the ball like
- every other player. Yeah, it's interesting. So, Ron, if they're going to have you
- work on the Heisman, why not have you work then on the Unitas Award and the Bolitnikoff Award?
- And, you know, there are awards, Butkus Award. There are awards for high profile awards for
- people at other positions. Like, if you're going to provide metrics, why don't we provide metrics to help support those
- other awards? And it's a great question. You know, Heisman is its own single organization
- for just this single trophy at the end of the day, right? And, you know, the winners of the Heisman
- get brought into the Heisman fraternity. And but yeah, you're absolutely right. You know, we could see it across other
- sports. You know, Major League Baseball kind of took an initiative of bringing advanced defensive metrics into
- your Gold Glove winners. And they were trying to take a step in that direction, too.
- So hopefully, you know, we see more efforts in that way and people make more of a contribution from that sense.
- It would be great. Let's change gears, but on the way out, I want to say just a touch of
- research reveals that Hugh Green was the runner up in 1980 to George Rogers. I remember George Rogers being a very not
- exciting Heisman trophy win, but he was running up to it with the highest ever. What's that?
- I was going to give you another pit player that got snubbed, Larry Fitzgerald. Yeah, that's a good example of a wide
- receiver. But what about Tony Dorsett? Did Tony Dorsett win the Heisman? He did.
- And that's actually I think it's the 50th anniversary of Tony Dorsett winning the Heisman.
- I was going to say 76. If you had me guess, I was going to guess 76 for Dorsett, another pit player.
- Hugh Green won the Lombardi, the Maxwell and the Walter camp. And he was the highest finishing at the
- time defensive player in 1980. Okay. You mentioned NIL era. Shane saw you give a talk about NIL.
- In Japan of all places. Yeah, in Japan. Y'all saw each other in Japan. Okay. I was going to say, tell us where
- it was. I go to Japan to get my NIL content as everybody should. That's where you naturally pick up for college
- football is Japan. But yeah, this is something I've been kind of hooked on is thinking about, you know,
- modeling college football in this very dynamic era that we're in. So team, team, team, like power rankings, essentially
- team ratings. Well, and also, yeah, yeah. Thinking about the team dynamics and then hopefully
- getting more into the player level, right. With, especially with the partnership with Heisman, but
- yeah. So like, you know, folks don't realize this, the transfer portal itself before 2021, when the
- floodgates opened with NIL and then also when you could just transfer without having to sit
- out a year, you know, the transfer portal is literally like the software is a database
- that was created to make it easier to communicate between, you know, prospective coaches and players
- about like, Hey, someone moving between schools. And so that led to a little bit
- higher number of transfers that can happen. I think it was like 2018 or whatnot when like that software was created, then COVID
- happens, right. And then we get some sweeping changes in terms of, all right, because of this, can
- players now get to switch between the schools without having to sit out a year? Right.
- And they initially, they only got to do that once. Right. And then at the same time as this,
- of course, the NIL floodgates takes place where endorsements payments. And, you know, more recently is like the
- formal payment from universities to players and universities managing their salary caps in this way across
- sports. But then also in 2024, we started to see they dropped, you know, you could transfer
- as many times as you want without having to sit out. It was actually, if you transferred a second
- time, you would have to sit out a year, but then in 2024, I don't know what caused this, but they dropped that completely.
- And so we're in this era now where I think we're around like 3000 or more transfers just within college football.
- Right. And just players within FBS moving around. And so one of the questions I had,
- and this honestly came from me teaching my sports analytics methods class, where I was teaching
- Mark Glickman's how stern state-based model for modeling team ratings. And when I was doing some, you know,
- literature review and whatnot, and he had these extensions about modeling the variances between seasons.
- So entering a year, like how much uncertainty do you have about a team rating entering
- the year? And he, he was doing things way back in like finance examples of potentially allowing that
- variance to blow up in some way, because of whatever could be volatile in the current
- environment. And from reading that and preparing for my class, I thought, huh, that's kind of funny
- because maybe that could work in college football right now, given dynamics that we have.
- And so what I ended up doing, and I'm still working on the writeup of this, hopefully it gets finished here soon, is I
- modeled then the variance describing the change from one year to the next for a given
- team as a function of their transfers, right? How much, how many transfers do they have
- entering into the season? Is it purely just the number or do you look at other features of that transfer?
- So right now I'm just doing literally the number of transfers and I explored like trying
- to do it like by positional groups as well, but there's some weird selection bias you
- observed there. Uh, but then the other thing I tried to account for was like, all right, I'm
- doing this over this playoff era. So let's also see in addition to just regular temporal dynamics, what happens in 2021 in
- this NIL era? And one of the things that really is interesting. And so intuitively more transfers blows up uncertainty
- about what you have about a team. I don't think that's necessarily surprising. Just to be clear, just for our listeners,
- um, I guess would the intuition be that if you do not allow the variance to be a function of the number of transfers,
- what you'll probably end up with is too low a variance between seasons. Therefore, you'll have so many unexplainable events early
- on in the season, which could potentially be explained by allowing the variance to be larger.
- Is that for our listeners? Is that the essentially the intuition? Yeah. And Indiana is a great example of this,
- right? So Indiana in 2024, when Kurt Zignetti takes over, right, it's a completely different team, completely
- different roster. And so if you were going into that year, uh, in these classic models where you
- just said, Hey, the between variance is not a function of everything. Everybody gets the same variance, right?
- You would have this basically a forecast. And what I did in this version of this work is like, given the information we
- have about transfers entering the year, let's forecast, uh, how, you know, the, the distribution for
- their number of wins that we would see across all these head to head matchups that
- they would have. And if you don't allow for that variance to potentially blow up in the end, it
- would have been heavily concentrated around like three to four wins that year, but it's a
- completely different team. Right. And, and one of the reasons why I did this at like the variance level is
- because I don't know what the public college football data, you know, who's, who's playing right.
- You know, if I had more information about, Oh, they got this particular transfer and he's
- playing X number of snaps at this position. Maybe that actually goes into like the mean
- rating for the team of like, Oh, this is the skill of this team directly, but I don't know that.
- So I decided let's just chuck it into the variance and see what happens. Right. Well, that's, you're underselling, you're underselling that strategy,
- given what you don't know. It's like, but you, what the situation is, you don't have information on the means of
- these players. The best thing you can do in that situation is to widen your forecast, meaning the
- extent of variance. It's like, you're literally recognizing the uncertainty in the data.
- Now, the other thing is, of course, as you said, if you do that at the team level, then of course, it'll say how
- much the mean ability estimate will update and how quickly it will update as a function
- of the observations in the season, because a tighter prior variance will obviously hold weight for
- longer as opposed to a wider variance. And so it not only has implications as you're saying, Ron, for the distribution over the
- season, but even let's call it the Bayesian learning that's going on within the season.
- Exactly, exactly. Ron, would you ever do this? It seems like you would do this for,
- you could, you could do this for coaches. Have you, have you bottled just coaching changes?
- I would think that variance would increase with a coaching change or even the degree of
- coaching. So it's, yeah, it's a great question. And you know, these, these things are definitely
- related to each other, right? When you have a coaching change now, it comes with transfers, right?
- And so, and like teasing it apart is difficult, I would say. Now you also do have coaches though, that
- their strategy is transfers, right? Dion Sanders is averaging a high number of transfers every year.
- Kurt Cignetti, he's averaging a high number of transfers still at Indiana. Now, one of the things though, that was
- really interesting of doing this is, you know, controlling for these transfers and still actually getting
- a sense of what is going on over this period of time. And is there something unique about in the
- NIL era of itself? And what, so I just basically threw it like an indicator variable and those, okay, are
- we in post 2021? And what you actually see from that is, you know, holding number of transfers fixed, the
- between year variance shrinks in the post 2021 era. And now this is within FBS and people
- sometimes forget that the FBS is pretty big, you know, it's over a hundred programs of
- the FBS. And so what that kind of is saying is, all right, if your transfers doesn't change,
- we have a pretty good idea of where you probably going to be at from year to year now, but if you flip the
- roster in some way, all right, now I have a lot of uncertainty about what could be taking place.
- And, you know, I, I kind of think of this as sort of in this era, is it a little bit of the rich
- getting richer, the poor getting poorer in college football, right? Where maybe there's more variance at the top
- of FBS, but, you know, are we really going to see the type of leaps that we might've saw 20 years ago of the,
- you know, a Boise state coming into the Fiesta bowl and making a big upset? You know, are we going to see that
- type of leap from, you know, a non power for conference team, you know, jumping in
- and making a run of the playoff? I'm skeptical of that right now. Given the lines with resources, right?
- That's right. I mean, the spread between, um, Power four and G six has never been higher and
- people think it's kind of done now that now we are, the positive is on the top of the market is much flatter than
- it was for a long time. It was very peaked with one, two, three teams. Now we've got this kind of flatter Maxima
- up there, but they just hoovered up all the talent from every stage, just to pipeline
- up, you know, and that means Bill, I think Bill Connolly, like he he's done some,
- you know, he's one of the best college football writers to follow and the work he's
- done with data. And I think he's talked about this of like seeing recruiting mattering less and less now
- from year to year of seeing just, and that these teams that could take these strategies,
- like Ohio state doesn't need to get many transfers, but they can be very selective in
- the transfers that they get, right. They could get the top. All right. So Ron, we're going to run out of
- time with you. We want to hear about your work on sports betting as well. Let me give just the slightest introduction.
- Ron created a new elective at Carnegie Mellon in the last year. I think he taught it in the last
- year for the first time on sports betting. And he did this because he wanted to educate these young people who are, you know,
- front and center in the sports betting world. And one of his innovations was to build
- and run a sports betting market in his course where they earn extra credit points based
- on their performance. And then he did some fascinating things that I'll leave for him to describe, but it's
- really the, the top line narrative that comes out of this is spectacular. But the most important thing is out there
- educating these folks about sports betting directly. Yeah, it's yeah. Thank you.
- It's a, I honestly think it's probably like the most important thing I'm doing because you
- know, sports betting is, it's pervasive. You can't watch a single sports sporting event
- of any kind without being bombarded by advertising. And fortunately this is part of, we have
- this grand challenge seminar program here in Dietrich College at Carnegie Mellon where it promotes faculty
- from different departments to work together, to bring, you know, create new classes to, to take,
- you know, big problems head on. And fortunately co-teaching this class with Linda
- Moya over in decision sciences. She's a cognitive neuroscience expert. And, you know, I'm bringing the stats data
- science perspective and she's teaching like the pathway to addiction while I'm, you know, teaching both.
- This is an intro level course. So I've, I've had students in that class last year where this was their first stats
- class. So I'm teaching them statistics and probability and building models through the avenue of sports betting
- while also teaching them about this industry. Right. And very early on getting them exposed to
- the fact that if you are a successful better, you'll get shut out. You'll get limited, right?
- You're not going to be able to, you know, continue to place bets. You're going to be, you're allowed to place
- bets. It'll be very limited amounts. And so I ran this, this sports book called the Tartan Bet.
- And no official affiliation. But yeah. Tell us, most of the audience doesn't know
- where Tartan comes from. Yeah. So that's our, the Carnegie Mellon mascot. And Tartans are, a Tartan is actually like
- a piece of cloth. It's not, it's not a weird mascot. Yeah. You know, it's CMU and our mascots, the
- Scotty dog. Yeah. But yeah, it's, it's one, it's one of the cutest, uh, mascots out there.
- Well done, Shane. All right. Unplanned. But yeah, we have, uh, in that. So I have these students where they start
- with a, what I call a thousand Tartan bet credits at the beginning of the year, that's equal to 1% extra credit.
- And they'll bet over the course of the semester. And I gave them assignments about this and,
- you know, Oh, I want you to place so many bets this week. And, you know, eventually we get to the
- point where they're, they're learning building models and okay. Now what I want you to do is
- you're going to build this NBA linear regression model of score difference based on number of
- things, and then I want you to make a decision. I want you to use your model and
- the associated uncertainty from that model to decide whether or not you place a bet.
- All right. And I got, I had students, their mind was blown. I'm like, wait a second.
- So I have to fit this model, but I'm not just like telling you what the coefficient is.
- No, I don't care. What I want you to do is using this model, make a decision and tell me
- how you made your decision compared to real bets that, and this was the most, I think I've ever worked for a class of
- every morning and evening. I'm checking real sports book lines, updating my sports book, putting these bets in and students
- are placing bets the entire time. I had students that they placed over 400 bets over the course of this semester.
- The, uh, using these fake credits that they had. And I would give them like class level
- updates every week. All right. Where are we at as a class? And they were, they were hovering around basically
- the break even percentage, uh, the, the typical lines follow at the beginning. And then after spring break, I introduced the
- parlay builder. And then that's where things really fell off because then, and this is the, one of
- the fun things is as a statistician and teaching statistics and teaching probability theory, betting is
- this really interesting kind of fun way to teach these concepts, right? Cause they have to directly think about uncertainty,
- right? I'm not teaching them hypothesis testing and you guys, no, I don't have to worry about
- that. I'm teaching instead for them to think about it. You're not just giving me a single number.
- You're going to be a probability of how you think this could happen. Right. And that's, and conveying that when you go
- to the sports book and knowing this whole American odd system, how they price things, don't
- even read any of that. Convert into probabilities. Think about it in terms of probabilities.
- Right. And them understanding how hard this is, right. Understanding how hard someone like Rufus Peabody has
- to work and the logistics he has to manage to handle all of this. The, uh, and we fortunately we had bill
- Benter who lives just a few minutes away from CMU, famous horse reading, horse racing, betting,
- uh, expert who's a billionaire in terms of, you know, the coverage of how much he's
- won. Uh, he came and spoke to the class and he also talked about, you know, I don't bet at traditional sports books.
- I've been a pair of mutual betting system where I'm not getting limited. It's, I get, uh, you know, the, the
- racetracks take just a cut of how much is bet in this pot. So I don't get thrown out.
- I can't, I can't do baseball bets. So he talked about the difference in what he asked to do.
- Now the monkey wrench in this whole thing is prediction markets. And that's something that.
- Well, this is obviously that, that, that, when you talk about getting limited, this is where
- we wanted to go. So you, you conceived of this course and started building this course.
- Probably about the time somebody can see the call sheet and the way around all the
- regulations. And the world has, I don't know what the volumes have been, but it's, it must
- be the case that prediction markets have taken much of the volume away from sports books.
- But my question to you is like, you know, setting aside implications for the direct logistical
- implications for your class, how do we feel about prediction markets to what extent does it
- lessen your mission because they're less parasitic, they're, they're, they're less, um, you know, they're more
- straightforward, people don't get limited. It's a, it's a cut, you know, in the same way that the para mutual market
- is that kind of thing. So I still think, you know, when we talk about what can lead to addiction and
- these downward spirals that especially young men are, we're, we're observing, right, we still have to
- be educating them about this and, you know, does it maybe look more fair on the surface potentially, right.
- But then. Teaching these students the difference between Ron DraftKings and, and the, in FanDuel, these guys are
- running these promotions that are targeting people at the right people at the right time to
- induce as much gambling as possible. And they're limiting the people who are going
- to win. It's like, it's a very different game. I'm not shilling. Oh yeah. I agree that they're actively selecting, right.
- Now prediction markets don't actively do that, but when you're making a trade on a prediction
- market, right. And an 18 year old college student here, they're, they have no idea that, you know,
- the market maker that has a lower fee or potentially no fee compared to them, you
- know, cause that's how the prediction markets are making money or fees on transactions.
- Right. And they're just taking a price that's available. They're just the, the naive market taker that's
- going up against trading firms. Right. They're going up against these organizations that are
- operating on a whole different scale from a watcher. Just looking at ads, Cal, she is no
- different to me than draft Kings and all these other ones. They're just another odds maker.
- So showing me ads, I mean, I know there are differences, but I mean, just because
- they advertise doesn't mean their behavior is the same. And there's like, I mean, if you, if
- you look at the behavior of the fan duels and the, and the sports books, they are so much more aggressive.
- On, on, on, on exploiting exactly the most addicted, the most vulnerable, but aggressively so programs.
- Yeah. And then, but now the caveat also to prediction markets is the scale at which we
- have these markets now. Right. And you know, we had the, these incidents last year, that's a great Superbowl example of
- did Cardi B perform at the halftime show. And one of those was both on call. She and Polly market and Cardi B was
- on this stage at the halftime show, but she didn't sing. And so one of the markets said, you
- know what, we'll, we'll kind of split the money both ways. Uh, we don't know what happened.
- And the other took a stance, right? She was there. How do you define this outcome?
- Right. And then you, of course you have the insider trading scandals. Are you, we have insider information.
- So I, I think there's still the value in both teaching this, communicating this, and, you
- know, and I have to figure out a way of like, yeah, conveying lessons for prediction
- markets more directly too, because when I, yeah, when I pitched the idea for this class,
- there were no sports event contracts that didn't exist. Now the caveat to that too, is this
- could all change, you know, depending on what nine people decide at some point. So, you know, I, I have no idea
- what's going to happen from like the legality of it and these years ahead. Okay.
- Why don't we leave it there? Give us one thing you're thinking about on the field right now.
- Like either from last weekend or this coming weekend, give us one thing. Top of mind, Ron Yurko, the analyst and
- or a football fan. College or Crow? Either. One thing. Where's your heart? Where's your head?
- I, I, one of the things I'm thinking about is because I talked about the between
- year transfer portal dynamics. I kind of want to extend that to within the year, right?
- Like, okay. And this cohesiveness of a roster and I'll use Penn state as an example.
- You have like Penn state and Iowa state kind of getting thrown together into this single
- roster. And in these years ahead, you know, what can we learn about? Like, how long does that process really take?
- Can I can, and like, how does it differ between if you have more offensive transfers
- versus defensive transfers and coaches from the different systems, you know, how do we model that?
- And how did that move together? That's something I've been thinking about at a high level that I don't have an answer
- to though. I thought I was going to get something about Aaron Rodgers. I don't want to talk about that.
- Yeah. Okay. All right, Ron, thanks, man, for being here. Always a pleasure. Best of luck to you on all the
- work you're doing and especially the Carnegie Mellon sports analytics conference is coming up in just
- a couple of weeks. Yeah. Thank you guys. Thanks. Thanks for having me. And yeah, hope people can register.
- Attend the conference is coming up here, October 23rd, 24th. Great lineup, variety of sports.
- It should be, should be a great time. So thank you. Thank you. Ron Yurko, long time in front of the
- show, professor, teaching professor at the Carnegie Mellon statistics and decision sciences group helps run the
- sports analytics group over there. Data science, data science. Statistics and data science.
- The SDS is confusing at Carnegie Mellon because there's a very famous, very famous group, also
- SDS, social and decision sciences. All right, guys, that's been the first half. Of this week's show.
- We have another half to go. Come back and join us after the break. Welcome back.
- Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's show.
- Cade Massey hosting with Eric Bradlow and Shane Jensen. Adi Weiner is away in the classroom at
- this hour. Sadly for us. Good for his students. Good for the university. Just off the line with Ron Yurko, long
- time in front of the show collaborator in many ways, Ron and the Carnegie Mellon world,
- as he pointed out, it is a bit of a Carnegie Mellon run. We're on, which is a good thing.
- We talked a fair bit about their conference, or at least we mentioned it multiple times.
- They have a big annual conference. We have a sports business conference every fall.
- That's coming up this weekend. The Wharton Sports Business Summit this Friday. No, that's not this Friday.
- I'm talking about Wharton People Analytics is this Friday. The Wharton Business Summit is another week out.
- So coming up soon. Wharton Business Summit, lots of interesting speakers. Keep an eye on that.
- Join us in Philadelphia if you can. All right, guys, we've got a little time to talk about current events.
- Some of you, neither of you look very happy about current events. My observation about baseball, when it hits the
- postseason, man, it is going fast. Those wildcard series, bam, bam. I think three of the four were done
- in two games. It's like, don't mess around with the wildcard series. And now you blink and the Yankees are
- down to nothing. What do you think about the last week? It's been an active one.
- They blinked a lot while fielding last night. I feel like again, again. I don't know what was up with this.
- It's so interesting to me. And this is again, not really a very analytical statement, but I feel like when I
- first came up as a baseball fan in the early 2000s, late nineties, early 2000s, the
- Yankees were obviously very, very good at that time. But part of it was they just, you
- know, they were, they were locked in defensively. Like, you know, that team was like kind
- of famous for always making the big defensive play and all this stuff. And I just feel like this is such
- a weird ethos that the Yankees can seem to shake over the last few years. I don't know what it's all about, whether
- it is just mostly bad luck or whether there's something cultural. I don't know, Eric, if you've got any
- thoughts. Yeah, I mean, I don't remember ever seeing, in my view, there were at least five
- errors in that first sitting. They counted three, but there was a double play ball.
- It should have been a double play ball. There was a missed throw, which the guy advanced, which they didn't call an error.
- I mean, I don't ever remember seeing such a horrific defensive set of plays that actually,
- I don't want to say it costs them the game, but it, you know, they've been behind.
- I mean, you don't remember two years ago in the World Series when they had a very similar type of, like, like I do
- feel like it's, I mean, it's true. Last night, I do think said almost like a, you know, like was historic just for
- the number of miscues that just kind of kept coming time after time. I do kind of, I don't know.
- Yeah, but it also, it also shows you the value of pitching in the postseason because
- look, the Yankees look like world beaters. Okay. Well, the Red Sox starting pitching's not that
- great. And you know what? The Rays on the other hand, and by the way, it's not like Garrett called it
- anything wrong. What'd he give up? He gave up one run. How much did Slitler give up earned?
- Was it one? I don't know what he gave up. It was tiny. So, I mean, it's not like the Yankees
- starting pitching hasn't, has done anything particularly wrong, just that they're up against a team that
- makes rarely defensive mistakes, runs the bases well, uh, takes a lot of pitches.
- Even if Slitler had the Yankees were winning, he wouldn't go on more than five innings.
- He was pitching 20 to 25 pitches an inning and they were doing a good job of staying away from bad pitches.
- And so I think the Razor, you know, I think they're the better team and especially
- without Judge and basically no Stanton. I mean, he hasn't played yet. Um, maybe pinch hit once in the, uh,
- Do you think, um, like, I mean, this is kind of, obviously we're just talking counterfactuals
- here. Do you think somehow, like, uh, like this, this team with a healthy judge, is that
- enough to kind of, cause he does seem to have that super additive or kind of interactive effect where it's like, not just his
- great bat that you're adding in, but like somehow the people around him get better.
- I don't know. Yeah. I think, I think it's possible that if Aaron judge were fully healthy, Aaron judge, and,
- you know, I don't know, maybe Stanton were healthier or healthy. Uh, Stanton, you throw those two guys in
- the lineup. You got Ben Rice, you got Goldschmidt. Uh, all of a sudden now you've got,
- I forget who the other guy, the guy, uh, whose father was also a baby, the guy that second for the Yankees.
- I forget who his name, but, uh, also another really good player. Oh, Garcia. No, no, no, no, no.
- Um, I'll think of it in a second. But all of a sudden the top five, six players on the Yankees can actually play,
- but you take out judge, you take out Stanton and, you know, they have one or two guys that can hit well in the,
- uh, this is what Adi and I've been talking about for the last 10 years. They have a couple of guys in the
- lineup that can hit the other seven. Not particularly, no one scares you in that
- lineup. And as opposed to the, to the Rays who have a bunch of guys that are basically all contact hitters and they just, you
- know, make pictures pitch. I mean, Garrett Cole talked about, he was exhausted after five minutes.
- He was exhausted because he's like, they weren't, they weren't going after bad pitches.
- Uh, he was having to throw everything on the corners. He was just saying he was just physically
- exhausted. And I thought that was a pretty telling type of situation. It's not over for the Yankees.
- I mean, look, you've got, look, the part that's a little surprised me. If you told me at the beginning of
- the series, you know, I know the Yankees Cole, Schlittler, Freed, and Rodan. It's hard to imagine that team getting swept,
- but they may get swept. But on the other hand, Freed and Rodan could also win at home at Yankee stadium
- and it could go to game five and then Schlittler's pitching again, or Cole's pitching again,
- and then anything can happen. Yeah, no, I think it's, you know, it's, it's, it's definitely not over.
- I just, you know, I guess maybe I'm, I'm, I'm kind of, uh, channeling a little bit of what Cade started out to talking
- about that these, these early playoff series, they can, they, they can get, they can really
- slip away from you quick. They go, they go fast. So it's kind of certainly, uh, you know,
- uh, um, I guess it'll tell over the next couple of days, but it's, uh, I'll be willing to, I look, even the Yankees,
- I don't know if they're coming back or not, but I would also be happy if the Dodgers got eliminated.
- It looks like the Braves have a shot. I mean, there's no, that's been by far, I think the most competitive division series so
- far. I mean, it's the only one that's not, you know, already had elimination games.
- Um, yeah, no, that is a fascinating one. I, you know, I, I, and I can't help, but feel like whoever makes it out
- of the NL is going to be a pretty strong favorite. I think in the world series, all, you
- know, the top two, y'all, all three of the three or four, the three, all the remaining teams, basically in the NL would
- be playing better baseball. It looks stronger than at least three out of the four teams in the AL.
- How do y'all feel about a five game series at this point? It's surprising to me that it's a five
- game series. Hockey is like nothing but seven game series. Right. And here we are already, I mean, we're
- still, we're still with the short series, essentially, even though we're at the division series level.
- I mean, Kate, eventually they have to stop playing baseball. Right. I mean, you know, maybe we should get
- rid of 162 games and then we, then we could show, then we could lengthen the playoffs.
- Look, I mean, yeah, it goes three, then five, it's three, five, seven, seven. Given how long the season is already.
- I don't think I have a problem with five versus seven. Yeah. And I wouldn't, I would, I would, I
- would sack, I would go down to like 156 games, like regular season games. If we ended up and just have like
- a more, you know, if they're going to expand the number of teams in the playoffs,
- expand it to like best of best of seven kind of series, like they do. It just feels, it feels so, it feels
- so. Go back to one 54 Shane. So we can go back to 1930. Yeah. 1930. Why not? Yeah.
- Okay guys, quick question. You might know the answer. 93 times a team has been down two
- games, oh, and two in a division series or five game division series. How many of those teams came back to
- win the series? Well, let's just do some base rates here. So if they were equal, which they're not,
- so there's no way any sane person would guess more than one eighth of the time, which would be a half to the third.
- Right? That's equal on independent. But let's just say, let's say a base rate. So that's the upper upper bound and no
- one would ever guess that. Um, let's just say that team is a 60 40 dog. So that's point once that would be 6
- % of the time, 6.4% of the time. So I would say an expectation, the answer should be somewhere around six.
- Um, with a standard deviation of somewhere around pretty small. So I'd say my confidence interval somewhere between
- three and eight. This man just did a real time full analysis, right? Well, I'm doing a binomial calculation.
- NP square root NP one minus P. Shane's got a more parsimonious answer. Shane, I'm pulling the string on the back,
- on your back. I'm pulling, I've pulled your string. What's, what's your answer? Oh, uh, the one eight, one eighth, one
- eighth. 12.5, 12.5. Right? So that's one eighth is 12.5 and the answer is like 11.
- And so it's much closer to the coin flip than you might've thought, Eric. And it's very, it's a nice little affirmation.
- It's consistent with Shane's model of baseball playoff. Well, I forgot my most important theorem of
- all of sports is momentum. Cause then by, I shouldn't have done 0 .3 to the third.
- I should have done 0.3, 0.3, 0.9. Cause we know after winning the next two, that team has got momentum.
- Um, okay. Um, any thoughts on who's going to come out of the, I guess we're just flipping
- coins, so who knows, but the Brewers, they got that, Oh my God, that luck off the roof on the, on game one against
- the Braves hit. That is unbelievable. You have to feel so bad race. I'm sorry. Yeah.
- Padres. Right. Yeah. That's a home run and they're going to lose that game and all that.
- That's terrible. But look, I think we deserve a Dodgers Brewer series, right? I think I really want to see that
- series. And, um, but I wouldn't mind as long as it's more competitive than the last time
- we did this, cause that was like a snooze fest, right? I mean, I would love, I would love,
- I'm kind of pulling for the Brewers kind of to go, go all the way through at this point on the NL side, but
- they got to obviously give the next series, you know, they got to get to the next series and have it be more competitive.
- I think there's a good chance that they'll, they'll face the Braves instead of the Dodgers
- though. Certainly. It's not about momentum. Do we, don't we agree though, on the
- American league side that the white Sox have, you know, some, let's call it non-stationary
- period going on. You don't, you just think they're playing mediocre teams and I'm not paying enough attention to
- know. I'm just shocked that they're still here. And one game away from the ALCS.
- Are you kidding me? I'm going to, I'm going to move. People shouldn't listen. I still believe in the coin flip model,
- but that central team is going to get destroyed by whoever wins the AL East and the, and the ALCS.
- That is, that is my, that's my non -coin flip little admission right there. Okay.
- He's not impressed cause they still haven't beaten anybody. Got it. Unimpressed.
- Yeah, they still, you know. Guys, let's talk a little, let's talk a little NFL four games in, you start feeling
- like you might know what teams are about. Where are you on what's going on in the NFL?
- And our Phillies, our Phillies, our Eagles dropped a stunner to the Rams. I mean, Rams are a big team, but
- they were up big late in that game and somehow managed to lose it. Eric, how much were you suffering on Sunday?
- I was suffering. I mean, they were up 20 to 10 with nine minutes left first and goal at
- the two. And so they were 0 for 12 on third downs in the game. Oh, for 12 on third down.
- Yeah. And I don't agree. I don't agree with the pundits were saying they should have kicked the field goal.
- No, they shouldn't have kicked the field goal. They should have gotten it in from the
- two yard line for four chances. Is this team like, how is this team not automatic?
- Like that's their like, right. Name of fame is they're automatic from two yards.
- And by the way, they're in real trouble. I don't know if you guys, so while we've been on the air talking to Ron,
- Lane Johnson announced his retirement today. Yeah. And so probably the best offensive lineman they
- have. Matter of fact, their record is markedly worse. Like they're a sub 500 team without Lane
- Johnson playing. Why is he retiring mid season? I didn't see it. Just, I just saw, you know, Adam Schefter
- reports, Lane Johnson. He missed the game for personal reasons. I assume it has something to do with
- some personal reason, which I don't know. But you think about it. Um, Saquon Barkley's injured, right.
- And there his backup tank Bigsby is injured and Devante Smith is out. And like, literally I could start naming 10,
- 15 players on the team. The vibes are just absolutely terrible around. Yeah. And so they're, they're struggling.
- And if you remember the end of last season, that sucked too. And so, you know, you can look at
- overall record and say they won the super look. Ron talked about this. There's a lot of season to season variants.
- They're very far away from the team that won the Superbowl just two years ago. It does seem like kind of a, of
- a long lost dream. Now that 20, so they're, they're going to, they're playing Jacksonville this weekend in London.
- So neutral side game and the line on that game, the line of that game is six and a half Jacksonville.
- Jacksonville is favored by six. It's stunning to me. Um, yeah, I mean, they just absolutely destroyed
- the Patriots a couple of weeks ago. I mean, they've been kind of rolling through
- everybody. So. I mean, I guess Denver and them played a very close game, but they've been sneaky,
- very good. It'll be an interesting test. That's a Sunday morning game. Fun, fun.
- Sunday morning, wake up to Philadelphia and Jacksonville. 9.30 AM Eastern. I think the one team that's probably surprised
- me the most, I know I should not even say this. Wasn't Kansas city not that good last year,
- even when Mahomes was playing. And now all of a sudden you added, what's that Kenneth Walker, the, you know, all
- of a sudden you add him and now the offense looks like the old chiefs offense and, you know, they seem to, as before
- they seem to know how to win every close game and, you know, I just, I'm not saying they're going to win the Superbowl,
- but what I'm saying is it looks like the AFC is going to go through Arrowhead again.
- No, I think they're my pick for the, for the Superbowl. At least there's a particular point just because,
- you know, some, most of the other kind of, you know, and AFC teams look, look weaker, you know, like seem to have, uh,
- have got more weakness. The team that's kind of surprised me. Well, one second, one second before you, Shane,
- before you go, I just want to say we talked prediction markets with, um, Ron in the first half of the show.
- Quick and easy to go to prediction markets on Superbowl winner this year. Are you surprised that the Ravens are tied
- for fourth? Essentially? I agree. I agree. They've been one kind of a surprising and
- impressive team so far, but the markets have the Rams at the top at 11 bills, 10 Niners, 10, and then Ravens chiefs and
- Seahawks at eight with the Jags. We were just talking about at six behind that. What do you think about that?
- How does that not include the bears in there? Bears are five. Oh, did it was the, okay.
- I was going to say like, cause that's the team that's impressed me the most. I mean, I, I think, um, yeah, I
- mean, I, I, I don't, how fast do prediction markets kind of like the Rams kind of being the top pick seems to me.
- Increasingly questionable as time goes on. I realized they did just have a victory.
- They did win last week, but it was, you know, not, not, not a reassure, not the type of win that reassures the market.
- I feel like, um, and so like, you know, I, I kind of feel like how much are we dealing there with kind of
- preseason that preseason prediction versus like what's happening week to week. And I mean, I'm not saying we should
- be reacting too much week to week, but it's probably, you don't have faith. You don't have faith in the markets.
- What's your level of faith in the markets is one question. Like, can you do better?
- Can you do better than call? She, um, no, I don't, I'm not sure I can. I just, when, when, when the market, when
- you're telling me the market still, the Rams is the Superbowl favorite. Is that still like, kind of like, and
- is that the instantaneous market or is there like a lot of volume, you know, like
- this is, this is high, this is high volume. This is, it's a, it's a, it's a good market read.
- Um, I w I would say it's a good market read. I mean, the volume of this market is
- 165 million. Just hilarious. Um, by the way, what do we have on Monday night? Buffalo at Los Angeles Rams, the top two
- teams in the call sheet market. The line right now Rams by two and a half, which is essentially home field.
- I feel like that's the whole NFL. I feel like all the lines are between two. I'm not, yeah, the majority of lines are
- like two and a half to three and a half, which is approximately home field. I mean, it's basically saying, yeah, these guys
- are roughly equal. I mean, it's just, it's amazing how smashed up and then you see it play out
- teams win who you'd wouldn't think would win. Here's the way I would frame it. Maybe in the language that Ron used in
- our first, you know, 30, 40 minutes. I feel the chiefs are beatable, but they're
- extraordinarily consistent. I think what could happen is it wouldn't shock me if the Rams in the playoffs
- played a bad game and lost. Wouldn't shock me if the Ravens had a bad game and loss.
- Wouldn't shock me if the Bills had a bad game and loss. Wouldn't shock me if the Bears had a
- bad game and loss. It would shock me if the chiefs had a bad game and lost. It would not shock me if they lost.
- I mean, the last, the last time we saw them, the last playoff game we watched, they had a real bad game in the
- playoffs. So you're kind of, you're, you're, you're, you're kind of making a projection from this season,
- I think there, right? Yeah, making a projection from this season. I think their level of play appears to
- be quite consistently good. To have added one of the best running backs in the league, if not the best
- running back in the league, to that offense is a great way to get some consistency,
- right? I mean, that's a whole nother dimension that they've not had in the time we've watched
- Mahomes. Guys, um, other, another game that really has my eye next weekend is the Sunday night
- game. Baltimore's going to Atlanta, Atlanta. One of the surprises so far, Pennix is
- kind of taking hold of that position and Bijan, my boy, my Longhorn has been just
- so much fun, his first carry, first carry last night. Anyway, um, Baltimore, MVP leader, in my opinion
- right now, what's that? MVP leader. Yeah. Um, what did the amazingly, well, Lamar is
- expected to be out. And so that's the big thing. Cause the line on this game is Atlanta
- by three, who would have thought that the Baltimore Atlanta line would be three, but a
- lot of that is Lamar. It's a real shame. We don't get to see the Ravens. Is it still a Hundley?
- Is that the backup for the Ravens? I believe so. Yeah. So yeah. That's, I mean, that's one of those games
- where we're, you know, let me say the only good news for Baltimore, obviously they want
- Lamar in there. We're going to see how good the rest of the team is in the sense of
- if their defense is strong, running game's good, special teams is good, et cetera.
- They can win that game, but we're going to find out if the rest of the team can kind of, in some sense, compensate
- for the loss of a multi-time MVP. Cause let me just say, let me give an example.
- This shows you, I think right now, to me, the coach of the year, the coach of the year right now is Jim Harbaugh.
- Because what John, John, John, John, John, John Harbaugh, sorry, John. No, Jim's getting fired, Jim's getting fired.
- John Harbaugh, because Jackson Dart went out, they've lost all kinds of players and he's found
- a ways to win games. They're three in one. They're leading the division. I'm not saying they're going to win the
- Superbowl or anything like that, but he's found a way to win with the players he
- has playing right now and let's see. Who do they beat the last couple of weeks? Titans and Cardinals?
- I think what Chicago has been doing, I think is even more impressive. In the face of being their quarterback, I
- think what Chicago has been doing is kind of more impressive because they haven't just been
- kind of winning, but they've been getting, you know, elite looking performances that, well, maybe not
- as much last week, but whatever case Keenum did like a couple of weeks ago. I was incredible.
- That was the most incredible thing I ever, they made him look like a Pro Bowl quarterback and he looked.
- And, and I guess, you know, I think the part that makes me kind of put, put Chicago higher than New York, the Giants
- in my mind is that, you know, the, the prospect of Caleb Williams still coming back
- this season, I don't think that's still like a, a season ending injury in the same
- way that Jackson Dart was. So, you know, the Giants. Well, we know of course the Giants have
- my guy, Jameis. So they'll be fine. Well, it'll be exciting. It'll be exciting. I think, didn't he have another like.
- Oh, 400 yards, three touchdowns, three picks. That's classic Jameis. Classic Jameis.
- You're going to, he's going to score you, he's going to score 30 for you and 20 for the other team.
- The variance machine, that guy, the variance machine. Okay, guys, before we go, I have to
- call out a pretty good slate on the college football side, including one of the games
- of the year. So the night game, one of the two big night games is Georgia at Alabama.
- Alabama has been a bit of a revelation in recent weeks, had a big win this past week, all of a sudden we're finding
- them at the top. I think they're at the top. They are at the top of Andrew Percival's
- metrics consensus, which is 10 different power ranking regarded, highly regarded power ranking systems.
- They, they are, it's the first time in a couple of years, we've had an SEC team back at number one.
- So Alabama is hosting Georgia. They're one and a half point favorite. So just spectacular lineup at the top of
- the, at the top of the country, top of the SEC. Texas OU is this weekend. This is one of the great rivalry games.
- It's in Dallas, always on a neutral field. That neutral field is probably the reason more,
- as much, if not more than any other rivalry is one of these chuck the record books out.
- Texas is an eight and a half point favorite, but Texas has won so many of these games over the years.
- They didn't deserve to win. They were not the better team. I can't help it. Be scared about being an eight and a
- half point favorite. Is that like karmic, karmic retribution in store or something like that?
- Not a night game also? Night game also? No, that's a 2.30 game, which is better than, for years it's been a 2
- .30. 2.30 for you. I think 3.30 for us. 3.30 game. Usually it's noon, but they've bumped it into
- that prime spot in the middle. A couple of the games, keep your eyes on, sticking with good teams, UCLA is going
- to Oregon and UCLA has been a surprise this year too. So UCLA has been down for a while.
- They're playing entirely decent ball. They're rated number 21. They're going to Oregon, big dog, 11 and
- a half point dog, but it'll be a good proving ground for UCLA and Oregon's still
- trying to get traction after a rough start. We've also talked about, you know, the college
- football, isn't the standard deviation, something like, I forget, is it 14 or something?
- It's at least 14. So even if you're an 11 and a half point dog, it's not like you're a
- 10% chance to win the game. You're more than that. Oh, yeah, that's right. Substantially more than that, I would say, because
- that's well, well, less than one standard deviation. Let me give you one more. And it's a sad game, but it's like,
- okay, somebody's going to lead in bad shape. And it's USC at Penn State. Penn State this past weekend had one of
- the biggest losses of the season. They went to Northwestern. Northwestern kicked off their new stadium.
- They did this thing where they built on top of, they raised the other one. They're up there in Evanston on the banks
- of Lake Michigan. They built a smaller stadium. And this is a movement in college football.
- Like SMU did this, they built a stadium on campus, small, a few years ago, 35 ,000 people, they kicked it off against Penn
- State last weekend and beat the hell out of Penn State. And all of a sudden Penn State has
- two losses. They lost to Wisconsin the weekend before. So Penn State is suffering under new coach,
- Matt Campbell, and things are unhappy, but here comes USC who are definitely suffering under hot
- seat coach. And we're going to find out whether, which of these two teams can survive.
- It's the whiteout. It's a night game. Oh, that'd be a lot of fun. The whiteout at Happy Valley.
- Yeah. So that's some good stuff to keep your eye on, on Saturday as well. So great weekend.
- That was a great weekend of football, Saturday, Sunday, and Monday. Guys, that has been a full show here
- on Wharton Moneyball for the whole crew, for our guest, Ron Yurko, for Audie Weiner in
- absentia, Shane Jensen, Eric Bradlow, and Cade Massey. Thank you guys for listening.
- Many thanks to our producer, Jacob Grodnick, and the boss lady, Dee Patel. Wish you guys the best.
- Enjoy the weekend between now and next show. Enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Ron Yurko discusses sports analytics, the Heisman collaboration, and current sports events on Wharton Moneyball.
Key points
- Heisman Collaboration. Carnegie Mellon partners with Heisman to modernize the award and include analytics.
- Fan Vote Impact. The Heisman fan vote now officially counts, influencing the final decision.
- The Importance of Metrics in Awards. Discussion on why metrics should be applied to awards beyond the Heisman Trophy.
- NIL Era Changes College Football. Exploration of how the NIL era has transformed college football dynamics and player transfers.
- Innovative Sports Betting Education. Ron created a new course on sports betting to educate students about the industry and its complexities.
- Prediction Markets and Gambling. Discussion on how prediction markets differ from traditional sports betting and their implications.
Episode highlights
- Heisman CollaborationCarnegie Mellon partners with Heisman to modernize the award and include analytics.“How do they modernize this?”3:43Oct 7, 2026
- Fan Vote ImpactThe Heisman fan vote now officially counts, influencing the final decision.“One of the coolest things they're doing this year is fan voting.”9:16Oct 7, 2026
- The Importance of Metrics in AwardsDiscussion on why metrics should be applied to awards beyond the Heisman Trophy.“If you're going to provide metrics, why don't we provide metrics to help support those other awards?”20:08Oct 7, 2026
- NIL Era Changes College FootballExploration of how the NIL era has transformed college football dynamics and player transfers.“We're in this era now where I think we're around like 3000 or more transfers just within college football.”23:57Oct 7, 2026
- Innovative Sports Betting EducationRon created a new course on sports betting to educate students about the industry and its complexities.“I honestly think it's probably like the most important thing I'm doing because sports betting is pervasive.”32:34Oct 7, 2026
- Prediction Markets and GamblingDiscussion on how prediction markets differ from traditional sports betting and their implications.“Prediction markets have taken much of the volume away from sports books.”37:53Oct 7, 2026
- Upcoming Sports Analytics ConferenceRon Yurko discusses the Carnegie Mellon sports analytics conference happening soon.“Hope people can register for the conference coming up here, October 23rd, 24th.”42:58Oct 7, 2026
- Yankees' Postseason StrugglesAnalysis of the Yankees' defensive errors and their impact on the postseason.“I don't ever remember seeing such a horrific defensive set of plays.”45:51Oct 7, 2026





