When Analytics Meet Chaos in Football Playoffs

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Neil Payne, sports analytics writer and creator of a leading sports Substack, discusses playoff parity, coaching impact, home-field advantage, and how analytics can—and can’t—explain who ultimately wins in today’s NFL and college football postseason. Cade, Eric, Shane & Adi also analyze hockey plus-minus limitations, Grand Slam betting dominance, Baseball Hall of Fame probabilities, and how NIL deals and the transfer portal are transforming competitive balance in college football.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#nflplayoffs #footballanalytics #grandslam #halloffame #collegefootball ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
  2. network. This is Kade Massie hosting this week with twothirds of my colleagues, but the third third is on
  3. the way. Eric Bradlo is here already. He's on the seventh floor of Huntsman Hall Wharton campus. I can tell Shane's
  4. at home. I'm at home. Audi is on his way home at the moment. We'll be in here for
  5. the next hour talking sports analytics. We usually are most weeks of the year coming up on 12 years. We are a mayor I
  6. don't know less than two months now from our 12-year anniversary hitting probably
  7. average of 48 or 49 weeks a year. We got sports. We're going to talk about sports. We got some analytics. We're
  8. going to talk about analytics right now. We're going to do a regular show. We've
  9. got a guest here in the first half hour. We'll go open lines in the second half hour. Here peak football. Really peak
  10. football. We've got college football going to culminate a week from now, a week from last night. This is Tuesday.
  11. Show will go up Wednesday. Next Monday, college football championship. We'll talk about that in a sec. And of course,
  12. we trimmed the NFL playoff field a little bit over the weekend. Three days of NFL games. Good fun. Got it down to
  13. the quarterfinals. Who can talk to us about both college football and professional football? And any other
  14. lingering things we want to talk about, who better than our old friend Neil Payne. Neil Payne, good afternoon to
  15. you. Welcome to the show. >> Thanks for having me back, guys. >> Always delighted to have you. Neil,
  16. looks like he's calling from home, which is Arkansas. Bentonville. I want to say
  17. Bentonville, Arkansas. Is that right? Close. Almost. >> Good memory. >> Yeah. No, I'm always calling from home
  18. these days. Home is the office. >> Home is the office. Neil's Neil's blending. Um Neil, what are you thinking
  19. about this Monday? not Monday, this Tuesday morning when you know for our show, but also kind of in general. Neil,
  20. we should say, is runs one of the best Substacks in sports. You should subscribe to Neil's daily Substack. He's
  21. going to do something interesting every day. He from the first time we met Neil back in the beginning of the show, it
  22. was like, hold on, this it's not fair. This guy, he's good with numbers and words, and he still does that on a
  23. regular basis. Neil writes for ESPN. He writes for NASCAR. He writes for the Washington Post. He was one of the
  24. originals. He's an OG 538er. So, he's he's he's done the work and he's still doing the work. And you
  25. should sign up and listen to him. Neil, what are you thinking about today? >> Well, I had uh something up uh on
  26. Tuesday morning just about the what we could take away from the wild card round. I usually try to do those uh
  27. little editorial uh behind the curtain. Look, would love to do those on Monday coming out of a weekend because it gives
  28. me chance to kind of write digest things on a Sunday. Uh, and the Monday night wildcard extra thing that they added a
  29. few years ago uh messes with that a little. So, I had to find something else to to put on the docket for Monday. But
  30. then Tuesday got your traditional uh coming out of the weekend takeaways. And I think uh one of the big things on my
  31. mind and a lot of people's mind, it got spoiled a little bit by the fourth quarter of that uh Texans Steelers game,
  32. but just how close the games were, how many comebacks there were and just sort of back and forth uh battles. And I saw,
  33. you know, most people were happy about this and I was as a fan just, you know, thought it was amazing um television.
  34. I'm sure you guys uh would agree as well. Uh, but I saw some people being like, man, when it comes down to this,
  35. like, can we really say that the best team won in these games? Because if it's just going to be a coin flip, if it's
  36. just going to be about who kind of has the last possession or if it's sort of a 50/50 at the end, are we really getting
  37. uh the the the results that tell us who the best teams are? I think that presumes a lot about what the purpose of
  38. playoffs are. They're there to entertain us. And are we not entertained uh by what we saw? But I thought that was
  39. interesting. I thought I'd kind of pose it to you guys. Uh what you think about that argument almost sort of like was it
  40. too much of a good thing in terms of the excitement? >> Well, does it speak a little bit to the
  41. parody? I think I mean I think we do have there I mean I I I I I keep thinking about the fact that there's
  42. really kind of not teams that seem particularly dominant right now. um roll rolling into the playoffs like the I
  43. mean the obviously the Eagles and the Chiefs were kind of both uh um rolled in with crazy winning streaks and I guess
  44. the Texans technically have a big winning streak but don't really seem like an insurmountable force. So I it
  45. speaks to me kind of to the parody of both the wild card round and even now that we're to the divisionals and the
  46. number one seeds are in it. I still think the games are very, you know, like I I I I would put I wouldn't put that
  47. many uh games far off 50/50 in my mind. >> Yeah. Maybe I'll just jump just jumping
  48. in here. When I reflect back on all of the games, I'm not convinced the better team didn't win. I guess the one you
  49. could argue with, Neil, maybe you would have a different opinion, would be the Packers Bears game. You could argue that
  50. the Packers led for such a long period of time. But on the other hand, it wasn't like they committed three
  51. turnovers in the last 10 minutes of the game either. They just went three and out and they played 60-minute games in
  52. pro football, not shorter games than that. Um, nothing surprised me. I was at the Eagles game. I do think the better
  53. team won that game. And that's even a injured 49er team. I think the better team won that game. So, I don't look at
  54. any of the only one I would potentially make an argument for was the Packers potentially being a better team than the
  55. Bears. Like, and and what does it even mean, by the way? Like, from a statistical sense, do you mean if we
  56. could replay the game a large number of times, how many times would the other team win under, you know, some scenario
  57. like that? I don't think any of the games maybe to Shane's point also if that's the replication we're talking
  58. about except for Houston Pittsburgh which I think that game would end up the same 85% of the time
  59. >> the same outcome not the same score the same winner >> same outcome yeah same outcome I think
  60. the other five games were all within that band of margin of error >> I think by the way I think I think that
  61. the postgame win expectancy that The team that won was positive on that except for Buffalo. These vary of
  62. course. The one I saw, I forget whose it was. Buffalo was just below 50%. So they
  63. were the one team who won who didn't play in a way that would have suggested they won, but even they were almost that
  64. close. Audi was trying to get in. >> Yeah. I mean, one of the things that I think comes to mind as analysts in in
  65. some level, we've added a dimension to sports that has pulled it down by analyzing it through the lens of
  66. probability models, which forces you to ask, is this an estimation question? Are
  67. we inferring from the season and then the playoffs who has the highest parameter? And we're just trying to get
  68. that decision correct like like we're decision theorists. And I think Neil, you're pointing it out that that's not
  69. exactly the point. This is an athletic competition and we give the prize to the team that actually won. It's an
  70. interesting question that we can ask ourselves going forward. Who would win if they got to do this repeatedly as
  71. Eric just did, but is there even randomness in sports the way we like to we analyze it that way because it's the
  72. only tool that we have at our disposal. But does a team win because that there was an under or there was an underdog or
  73. a favorite lose because of just bad luck or did they lose because they didn't execute when it needed to get done and
  74. they should lose because of that. I'm not saying that and if we had to do it again they wouldn't they would be more
  75. likely to do the right thing. But they didn't get it done when it needed to get done and there's got to be some reward
  76. for that. And we I think we as anali an analysts have have turned people's attention away from that with measures
  77. like war for example in in various sports that use it which takes away from doing it when it counts.
  78. >> Just to be clear what you're talked about hypothetically and Neil's I assume jump in on this too is a memoryless
  79. replication. So it's not like the pack the the Packers get to say well we blew that 21 point lead or whatever. Let's
  80. play it differently this time. No, you're talking about >> memories memories tier, right? Um there's the randomness
  81. of like kind of the within team heterogeneity like I guess if we are kind of thinking about this as a
  82. parameter is it like a fixed parameter or is it like something where a team's kind of performance latent performance
  83. is a random draw from its distribution and what we're really interested in if the two teams are better is is there a
  84. difference in those two distributions of the team's performance but then even if
  85. you kind of were able to observe that there's on top of it the kind of in-game random ness of
  86. >> That's right. >> how things happen. >> That's right. >> But let let's let's I take Neil's
  87. question. Y'all dove in kind of the middle. I'm going to go high and low. At the at the at a high level, it's like
  88. hell no. There's no there's not too much randomness and too much chance. And there hell no is is let's real decidedly
  89. answer that. Hell no. We'll take that all day long. But there's also a a tournament design question. And of
  90. course, we also like we we love to turn to tournament design when we can. And we're watching college football play it
  91. out in front of us and we have over our lifetimes where they used to just vote. They just watched 11 games played and
  92. then voted on who they thought was the best. That was just who's got the highest alpha or the whatever parameter
  93. you want to say. Who's highest theta? Um and then they no that's that's too much
  94. of us deciding let's let let's let one game decide it. And they did that for a few years and then no no let's let three
  95. games decide. Let's choose four teams. And they're they're they're slowly expanding and they're saying we're more
  96. and more gonna let the this thing be decided on the field. And I think the more you do that, the more you allow
  97. chance to come into play, obviously because you're not just going to sit back as analysts and say who's the
  98. highest theta and let these two high thetas play each other. You're saying anything can happen. And here's Miami
  99. the last team in the field playing for the national championship. And two years ago, Ohio State or was it
  100. last year? Ohio State comes in as whatever they eight and won the next >> they were an eight seed. In fact, it was
  101. an eight versus a seven in the championship last year with Notre Dame and Ohio State. This year it's kind of
  102. the the the the two extremes of the spectrum, the 10 seed uh in Miami, which was really kind of the last uh quote
  103. unquote real team. And no offense to Tulain, no offense to James Madison, but they got in through maybe different
  104. means. and then Indiana, who of course seems like this just unstoppable uh juggernaut. Uh we we'll kind of see what
  105. happens in that game. But uh to your point, yes, it does introduce randomness and similar to the NFL. Uh but I think
  106. the college playoff, it feels a little less random just because we've seen the margins be, you know, it wasn't down to
  107. the wire. Some of the games were uh all the Old Miss games I feel like um you know uh were at on different levels, but
  108. then uh many of the games were very lopsided to which point you might be able to make a case that a smaller
  109. playoff than the 12 uh was justified because you had a lot of teams that were just sort of not competitive. Not just
  110. two lane uh and James Madison, but also some of the other teams just came out, you know, uh Oregon uh beat Texas Tech
  111. 23- nothing and then they turn around and get blown out by Indiana. Alabama, of course, loses 38-3, which is one of
  112. the most ridiculously lopsided games Alabama's ever been on the receiving end of. So, I think in some ways, uh you
  113. look at that, that's a little bit different than the NFL, right? Where it's like anybody could win. Here, it's
  114. like, h there's really only a core group of teams. We just didn't necessarily know who that core group was. Like you
  115. would have put Texas Tech ahead of Miami in any kind of ranking going into the playoff, but it's pretty clear that they
  116. belong, you know, where they are more so than than some of the teams that got knocked out.
  117. >> That's right. That's right. Well, so two quick things here. You're right. No question. College
  118. versus pro, especially this year, the parody is stronger. The matches are closer on the NFL side. But the other
  119. thing that's going on with this tournament design with college is you're deciding how much is deservingness
  120. versus how much is the best team. And best team is just, you know, um you're going to you're going to take a team
  121. like Ohio State who had two losses and put them in eight seed and if they play their way through, they're the best
  122. team. And if Miami plays their way to the championship, that's the best team. They weren't the most deserving teams in
  123. the field, but by broadening the field, you go deeper and you're so you're you're necessarily pushing it from
  124. deserving to the best. Um where they used to just pick two teams, they're picking the two most deserving at the
  125. time. >> So they broad they've broadened it over time. >> I also think for the tournament design
  126. part of it is, you know, you're trying to like like took Neil's kind of comment that like maybe we didn't need an you
  127. know, maybe it's almost like too big or whatever. We don't need that extra round. What you're trying to do is on
  128. average ex >> in the future project on average what the dispare how what the distribution of
  129. of talented teams at the top is going to be. >> Yeah. Shane some years it's like one or two. You got
  130. it. That's definitely those teams. Other years it's like eight that you >> Shane. That's what that's what the guys
  131. who run college football are doing. They're they're modeling distributions of talent and they're trying to pick the
  132. number of playoff teams. They're trying to pick the number of playoff teams that
  133. would extract the most entertainment from those district. That's exactly how they're deciding how to do this. Audi,
  134. >> I just want to add a little comment here. You you you use the word best as if the purpose of the tournament is to
  135. find out who's the best. Is that really true? I asked >> I said best versus deserving. There's
  136. always this tension in college football, best versus deserving. >> Who do what is the who do we call the
  137. the ch we call the winner of the tournament the champion? We don't call them the best. We call them agree 100%
  138. >> and we have to conclude on that that the purpose the team that wins is the championships is not necessarily the
  139. most deserving on the field or whatever it is >> every sport every sport every season
  140. develop I mean there's all sports are littered with great great great teams that didn't win their national
  141. championships by the way one last note on differencing this and play and and tournament design there's a fundamental
  142. difference and now this is being debated in college on how the tournament is seated or how the tournament is
  143. populated did and let let's just know the general in play in tournament design. You've got a qualifying stage
  144. and then you've got the knockout stage and we know this from that's the language we use in World Cup. But the
  145. same thing happens baseball. It'sund freaking 62 games of qualifying and then a few weeks of knockouts. And in in in
  146. NFL, the qualifying happens by divisions and the champs go. Even if you're a eight and nine or whatever the hell
  147. Carolina was this year, you're going to play. And you know, the wild cards are a
  148. way to take the edge off of that, but it's this automatic qualifying. Col in college, there's a little bit of
  149. automatic qualifying, but there's debates on that's exactly what they're debating right now. Next week is the
  150. meeting. We're going to expand the tournament probably. Are we gonna put in more automatic qualifiers or just a few
  151. and let people come in the other way? This NFL solved this problem years ago and we don't debate who should be in the
  152. playoffs or not. It's like it's a it's agreed upon. This is how it happens. You play divisional divisions matter and
  153. it's kind of nice in that way really. There's no committee deciding which of the NFL teams should everyone plays.
  154. Yeah. Roughly equivalent schedules which I think helps in the NFL compared with college.
  155. >> Hugely so. Hugely so. Okay. Neil, you're wearing a Buffalo Bills hat. So, so those of you not watching the video
  156. don't see this. Neil has one million sports hats, most of which we can view in his background. And today he's
  157. wearing the Bills hat. So, tell us about >> Well, I just uh you know, some of a few
  158. of my best friends are Bills fans and I just want them to get one. Uh you know, I think uh them surviving that
  159. Jacksonville game. I kind of uh circled that and I'm sure you guys talked about this last week as well as being like a
  160. game between two teams that probably should have been meeting like later in the playoffs than uh the the wild card
  161. round. And so the the survival of that is almost sort of like a test. Uh it's it's like a natural selection process I
  162. feel like where you get through that one. Uh it's it's certainly not going to be easy from there. uh and there's
  163. plenty left to do, but uh it almost gets uh weirdly uh less stressful I feel once
  164. you get that out of the way and you're kind of on equal footing like now every team has to play the same number of
  165. games uh and win the same number of games going forward to win the championship. And I kind of think
  166. Denver, like of all the different teams that the Bills could have drawn uh coming in, uh they got the tough one
  167. with Jacksonville, but now Denver, and I'm curious what you guys are are thinking on them, but they feel a little
  168. bit more like the paper tiger uh of uh in an AFC where it's really wide open. Anybody really at this point, you could
  169. envision them winning, but to be the number one seed in that kind of conference is not necessarily really a
  170. ringing endorsement the way it would be. And I wrote about this in my takeaways.
  171. Uh home field in general, home field was down this year uh in the past couple years versus what we kind of think of as
  172. being like oh two two and a half points per game. It's not quite that high anymore. And there have been years where
  173. it was lower for sure. Uh I think about the COVID year um which really across all sports exposed how valuable it was
  174. to have those fans in the stands. Uh but uh in the wild card the road teams went
  175. two and four. They had a a minus three point per game differential. Some of that was because what we were just
  176. talking about the the division winners in Carolina and Pittsburgh getting those home games. They were kind of plainly
  177. like the worst division winner is always going to be worse than the best wildard
  178. team. And so they were underdogs and they got beat. Uh Carolina to their credit actually kept it a lot closer
  179. than I thought they were going to against the Rams. But um that played a little bit of a role and uh but I even
  180. adjusted for what we would expect uh the road teams to do and it was still one of
  181. the worst performances by by home teams in a wildcard round uh since the merger I want to say which is again you know
  182. not the worst it's not historic uh and and some of that was a little bit less bad than you would expect based on who
  183. was playing but it just tells me again like playing at home not necessarily really the um huge boost that we have
  184. come to think of it as being over the years. >> Is the actually historically is the four
  185. seed usually an underdog compared to the five seed? You'd kind of think >> No, but I think their quality just if
  186. they were playing in a neutral sight I think almost always they would be worse. >> Like I feel like the five seed almost
  187. always has a better record than the four seed. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Yeah. Because it's easier to beat three
  188. other teams than it is to beat, you know, however many non-division winners there are in the conference. uh out.
  189. >> So, does anyone here is anyone here a Denver or Bonex believer? Looking at Massie Peabody rankings through last
  190. week, so they Denver sat out anyway, so it shouldn't matter, but we had them like
  191. >> ninth in the league. And you know, there's a lot of smashing up there together.
  192. >> There's not that much separation, but ninth is >> is weird for the number one seed in the
  193. AFC, right? >> I mean, they won so many close games. I I expect that that's probably part of
  194. it. They got a little bit of that 2024 Chiefs syndrome where it's like, you know, how much do they keep winning, but
  195. how much do we really believe in them going forward? So, I think that's probably playing into
  196. >> I'll tell you what I am a fan of. I'm a fan of Shawn Payeyton and I think if anyone can figure out a way I think
  197. Buffalo is the better team in that game, I would much rather have Josh Allen than
  198. Bon Knicks. It's not even I mean I don't even want to talk about the same planet
  199. here but I just have a feeling that's the game I know everyone's saying I think you even knew was the word Neil
  200. maybe paper tiger or whatever it is. I just think Denver's going to figure out a way to win that game and I most if
  201. they do most of that credit and I'm I want Buffalo to win the game. Let me just be clear. I give most of the credit
  202. to Shawn Peyton because I don't think they have a great offensive team. I think Shawn Peyton's going to figure out
  203. a way to win that game. I think he's going to potentially when maybe using Audi's words when it comes down to the
  204. key moment of the game, who do I trust more as a coach, Shawn Payeyton or do I trust? Was it McDermott? Is that the
  205. coach of the Bills? Who do I trust more? I trust Shawn Payeyton. >> And I I also think defense is uh I I
  206. mean I I view this, you know, very much through a lens covered by what what what
  207. could hurt Drake May in the playoffs. Uh my golden boy. and and and what scares me is Denver Broncos's defense. Houston
  208. Tech I I mean basically I think pass rush um is the way you know that that's the way I talk myself into Denver you
  209. know being able I I do think the Bills are a bigger challenge actually to Denver than whoever comes out of the
  210. Pats versus Texans. But I you know I I think both the Texans and Broncos have these very very good defenses. And I
  211. mean I I know it's not predictive, you know, season to season, game to game and the same, but I do think it kind of it
  212. can carry a team in the playoffs and we've seen it before. >> Let me ask given what you saw yesterday,
  213. how do you feel about Houston New England? Like is there anything to learn Neil from the 30 to whatever three
  214. thrashing of the Steelers? Is there anything to learn from New England playing so well, not offensively
  215. particularly, they didn't play well offensively, but defensively? Like do you how much I asked the same thing last
  216. week. How much do you basianly update your beliefs about these team strengths given what you observed in these playoff
  217. games? Anything more than a regular season game or no? It's just it's a game's a game and there it is.
  218. >> Well, uh you know, I think there's also there's the recency factor. You know, I
  219. have something in my model on uh my substack that weights more recent games more except for week 18 where we filter
  220. out those pesky games where they're not uh playing starters. But so I think that
  221. that matters just saying like what kind of form is a team in now. I think if you're going to uh try your hardest and
  222. kind of show your best uh level of yourself, you're going to do that in the playoffs. But uh to those games, you
  223. know, I think point differential might be a little misleading about the Texans Steelers game cuz that was a 9 to7 game
  224. going into the fourth quarter. It was sort of, >> you know, a little scary uh for Houston
  225. until uh Aaron Rodgers turned into a pumpkin in front of us. You know, he had he's had an amazing career, but that was
  226. >> and wasn't his fault. Wasn't his fault. That receiver went the wrong way. >> Yeah. I mean, it's just uh was was kind
  227. of a disastrous ending there and they kind of ran up the uh the the score at the end. Uh so I don't know that I would
  228. kind of classify that as being different in kind than >> the Patriots, you know, their offense
  229. was really, you know, not as good as we've seen it be certainly, but the defense was amazing and they really uh
  230. shut down Herbert. How much of that was also like if they're going to get the pass rush in there against the Chargers,
  231. like what team would be better and what quarterback in Herbert would be better to to be able to kind of unleash the the
  232. pass rush against? Uh so that could have also been matchups. Uh we kind of hinted
  233. at this earlier when we were talking about the meaning of the best team. How much do you take away from certain
  234. games? I mean, the matchups seem to be also as important as sort of the the overall quality of the teams from like a
  235. power rating perspective when we're talking about who wins and loses these playoff games. When I updated my basian
  236. uh dist posterior after watching uh the Patriots game, I noted it was heavily it
  237. was heavily updated by the fact that Drake May five sacked five times. I mean, we lose sight lost a little sight
  238. of it because the Patriots were doing even more to Herbert, but Drake May was sacked five times. two fumbles, you
  239. know, and I mean that's against the Chargers and now they're going up against the Texans, which have the best
  240. pass rush I think in all of football. I mean, Neil, you could probably give more
  241. sophisticated insight than that, but >> that sounds right to me. >> Well, the Texans and Broncos, you know,
  242. the the Bills are like scarily the worst defense the Patriots like kind of left that the Patriots would face on on that
  243. side. So yeah, I mean I I uh I was cheering hard for the Steelers. As much as that it's hard to kind of based on
  244. historical reasons, I was cheering hard for the Steelers last night. Too bad. >> Bet you were just noting that the Texans
  245. are an underdog. They're going to to New England, of course, but they're a three-point underdog. The way y'all are
  246. talking about it, you're making a good case for that not being the case. Ai was trying to get in earlier.
  247. >> Yeah. I uh I just Eric says something that I wanted to react to about Shawn Payton. Um this is a interesting
  248. question. We all have our opinions about coaches and their ability to win. Is there a data analytical tool in football
  249. that allows us to measure the quality of a coach? Obviously, not very accurately,
  250. but at least as with some reasonable expectation. I mean, you're the king of the the the metrics, right? So, what do
  251. we got out there for coaches? Anything? >> Uh, well, I mean, certainly the the stuff around decision- making in
  252. particular moments. I think you can go through and kind of say like how often have coaches made the optimal decision,
  253. how much how much have they helped or hurt their team going? Um >> we do fourth downs of course, but beyond
  254. that, how about others? >> Uh some of it is also like the tactical stuff, you know, I know that PFF uh like
  255. all of the kind of X's and O's measures that we have. Football is very interesting. I I was even looking at
  256. this in the context of Justin Herbert where they were saying uh stat you know analytics nerds can't shield Justin
  257. Herbert uh from criticism after this loss or whatever and I was like well who are the analytics nerds that are sort of
  258. supporting Justin Herbert. It's really more of the kind of tape grinder types which I think have become synonymous
  259. with analytics nerds in football but only football and I find that I mean that's way beyond the scope of this
  260. conversation but I find that endlessly uh interesting that in every other sport the people that use numbers and yes we
  261. watch games but we don't have that trained expertise of the kind of watching tape are the the analytics
  262. nerds and then in football somehow the people that watch the tape religiously uh more so than even rely relying on the
  263. numbers are regarded as the kind of nerds desour of the sport. So they would have things to say about um you know
  264. tactically what coaches are doing in particular situations maybe on defense in ways that the numbers are kind of
  265. blind to. Famously football you know very difficult to quantify and only over the course of you know a large sample
  266. can we really get a sense of coaches that bring maybe a certain amount of stability or kind of improve their teams
  267. chances uh in in some small amount. and and it's very ironic that we saw two of the best at that uh John Harbaugh and
  268. Mike Tomlin leaving their teams uh you know over this off season uh whether by choice or by um non-choice. So I think
  269. that that's really interesting that um coaching in the NFL is so opaque even to the people making the decisions that you
  270. can have a coach who is currently regarded as one of the best coaches. You can fire that coach or let them go. they
  271. will immediately become the most sought-after coach to the point that if if it was a blind resume, you would hire
  272. that coach for your open position despite just firing that coach. And so, it's just a very interesting uh decision
  273. process because we're all trying to make these decisions about ultimately people
  274. that are uh leading 53 plus uh people and even larger groups than that if you include the assistant
  275. coaches and the support staff. And uh they're doing it in 17game increments and a lot can happen. Most of those
  276. games are decided by one score or less as increasingly so. And we're trying to make sweeping judgments about their
  277. performance in the context of what are ultimately pretty small samples to act off of.
  278. >> A lot of people want to get in. No new questions, just observations riffing on
  279. this thing that we just we've just been talking about. >> Yeah. So what would be wrong, Neil, with
  280. doing the following? Like let's imagine we treat each game obviously as two teams playing so a paired comparison
  281. model right and so whether you do something more sophisticated may offensive defensive team strengths
  282. whatever you want to put in there why not why can't you just put in a coaching dummy variable you observe a large
  283. number of games in some sense you'll get some sort of statistically shrunken residual estimate that can be attributed
  284. to the coach of the game and there you get an estimate you would get on a line let's say Right now, you could put all
  285. the coaches on a line. Um, there you go. What would be wrong with >> contributing the entire team effect to
  286. the coach? Is your estimate? >> Well, that's So, all right. So, that might be one problem. Sounds like you're
  287. estimating. >> But, but let me just say it. So, the answer is at the moment, yes. But I
  288. haven't told you also what I'm going to condition on. I'm conditioning on offensive team strength, defensive team
  289. strength. >> Okay. But now, now you're making the opposite problem, which is you're you're
  290. some of the coaching values going to show up. Those aren't exog index. >> Well, you could have variables for
  291. individual players for instance like the starting quarterback or you know other key players and sort it's the Brady
  292. Bellich problem, right? Even there you you don't have you can't get them uh you know the two indicators are like
  293. hopelessly confounded. Well >> yeah and I think the biggest problem there you could totally do that Eric. I
  294. actually uh you know I don't have a problem with that but I think uh it would be if you're doing shrinkage it
  295. would most coaches would be shrunk down to basically zero and the sample size that it would take to kind of
  296. distinguish them is probably well longer than the average coach's tenure. Uh and
  297. so you end up with basically this uh selection effect as well where like the only coaches that we would have any
  298. sense of whether they were actually good or not are the ones who are allowed to keep coaching long enough which then
  299. biases it toward being the best coaches anyway. >> So and so my view is just my own
  300. personal view is um I'm okay with that like in the sense of that is what we can say. We can say something about that. As
  301. you said, great coaches get to stay longer. Successful coaches get to stay longer. There's other big mass of
  302. coaches that we can't really distinguish from zero. And that's our jobs as statistitians. We're going to tell the
  303. public like, I'll make it up. You think, I don't know, pick Demo Ryan, by the way, right now seems pretty good. He's
  304. won more playoff games than a lot of coaches already, you know, but we don't have enough evidence to say Deique
  305. Ryan's right now is a great coach. He might be, but it's hard to know. I I think that's an accurate reflection of
  306. uncertainty is my only comment. >> That's I think that's that'd be great, right? That's a that's that's a that's a
  307. service actually, but it also reflects the limits of our models. And um one question is just like those old, you
  308. know, essays every people do every now and then like they ask scientists, what do you believe that you can't prove? you
  309. know, it's like you can't you can't publish this stuff, but like given the chance to opine, who would you say is a
  310. good coach even though you don't have the data? One of the problems is that there are so many different elements of
  311. coaching that contribute and they're not necessarily related. So guys, Eric asked
  312. for a study. I'll give you a study. This is a athletic study. So their quant these days is Austin Mock and he looked
  313. at fourth down decisions this season by the coaches in on with teams in the playoffs and asked how often the
  314. decision the coach made matches the decision of some model presumably the athletics model. So the sample sizes are
  315. small that they must have conditioned to a small group of fourth down decisions but they range from like 12 to 25. So,
  316. we can kind of dismiss it on that ground alone. But then he ranks the coaches top
  317. to bottom. And Demo Ryan, who I just heard lauded here, is third from bottom. By the way, Harbaugh, Jim Harbaugh,
  318. bottom. Tomlin next to bottom. I think we knew that one. Demo Ryan's third from bottom. Who's the top? Matt
  319. Laflur who just got roasted for his second half management. Right. Nick Serani who's out. Vrabel, Shane's new
  320. favorite guy, Vrabel, number three. So that's just but that's just one dimension and coaching's coaches
  321. contribute across many many many dimensions. >> By the way, just to your point, just to
  322. build on what you're saying, Kate, and it was same sort of criticism Shane just made of me, it's not a criticism. I
  323. think the Brill Winer model, if that's what you guys call it, by the way, would say that right wrong is not even the
  324. right metric. If someone if it's 5149 and someone chooses the 51 like I'm gonna say yeah you made the right
  325. decision or you made the wrongest and why don't we use those probabilities and add those up in some way.
  326. >> Yeah they don't do it right. The analysis that we showed is the vast majority of fourth down decisions are
  327. either obvious and we they generally exclude those or and this is a good indeterminate as in we don't have enough
  328. cases know the right move. So if you do that generally in a game, you don't really have too many across even a
  329. season of of really tough I'm not saying not I say tough calls decisions that the
  330. c that the coach made that were really obviously wrong. Right. and and and then you have to throw in the level of costly
  331. because one of the things that we discovered was that there are lots of u decisions that are obviously wrong in
  332. the first quarter but they don't cost you that much because decision bad fourth down decisions in the first
  333. quarter aren't going to throw the game by 10%. They just a little bit because the game is barely started. So whatever
  334. the bad decision can but they but they're knowable and they're measurable. So in other words, you could cost
  335. yourself one and a half% of win probability with a with a uncertainty that's that's minimous. We know that's
  336. the right move and you blew it, but it didn't cost you that much. And most of the people who go through this, they
  337. don't look at that that effect size. Um, and that of course is very dependent on
  338. the quarter that you're making that bad decision. Fourth quarter bad decisions are horrendous because they're levered.
  339. >> Okay. Well, let's let's just wrap this conversation by going back to Eric and
  340. asking, okay, then what is it about Shawn Peyton, Eric? Is it the is it the academic essay? What do you believe that
  341. you can't prove or is there something specific about his coaching that you like that gives you confidence in him?
  342. >> Yeah, I just have I I'll look at this. I'll actually do the analysis off air.
  343. I'll post it on WMoney Mo. I just have a sense if one used whether it's Massiepuddy,
  344. PFF, uh could be Neil's prediction model that Shawn Payton's teams over a long period
  345. of time if we computed residual wins, I I would think he's going to have a significant number of residual wins
  346. above and beyond. If I looked at that histogram of residual wins divided by let's I'll norm it by the sample size.
  347. So, it's the residual wins per game played that I think Shawn Payton would be out in the right tail of that
  348. distribution. >> Yeah. And I this one we actually can fit because you need to throw in Drew Brees
  349. as an indicator and we do actually have separation because Drew Brees played a few years in San Diego, right? And so
  350. you could try and separate out like I'm just, you know, the just kind of thinking about this model here. Again,
  351. one of the things you'd probably want to condition on his quarterback. And for so
  352. much of Shawn Pton's very successful career, he's had Drew Brees as his quarterback. And so that would be kind
  353. of, you know, you'd have to be kind of a portioning out those wins between Drew Brees and Shawn Payeyton. And you'd have
  354. to kind of their relative record without each other is kind of where you'd end up
  355. separating out that partial credit. And kind of >> Breeze is an example of how you you
  356. probably could play with heterogeneity within quarterback. I don't know if anyone ever did this with with Brady. I
  357. >> mean, Bichc early years of Brady were not as good as the middle and late years
  358. of Brady. The late years of Breeze were a negative. That was a drag on Shawn Pay
  359. at the end. >> Was like Tom Roth the late years of Rothllessberger, you know, I mean, that
  360. was a big part of Tomlin's kind of time in Pittsburgh. >> Interesting. Okay. Well, why don't we
  361. we're keeping Neil longer than we expected to. So, why don't we wrap and let's give Neil give give him a moment
  362. to say something about the college football. Between now and our next show, next Monday night, Indiana and Miami
  363. will play for the national championship in Miami. But we're looking at, what are
  364. we looking at here, guys? We're looking at a 8 and a half point line. Indiana's favored by eight and a half. If you
  365. listen to the pundits, Miami might as well not show up. It's ridiculous the rhetoric around this thing. Any thoughts
  366. on this game, Neil? >> Yeah, I I think these types of games always tend to uh be closer than maybe
  367. it seems based on a team coming in. And you have to think no uh no further back than the Miami in a championship game
  368. against Ohio State in 2002 when they had a potential to be considered the best team of all time. The Hurricanes did. Uh
  369. and they ended up losing that game. Questionable call in overtime, but they still lost. Uh to our point earlier,
  370. it's about who wins and loses. Um, and so with Indiana now, the chatter is about them potentially being the best
  371. team of all time. Certainly the way they've gone through the playoffs. And I think that's kind of an interesting uh
  372. wrinkle that the playoff adds to these kind of GOAT conversations because in the past you would play your regular
  373. season, you play your conference championship, so you'd get some good teams in there and then you play like
  374. one extra game. Uh, if it was Miami, you know, in 2001, they played that championship game against who was it?
  375. Nebraska that they just absolutely destroyed. Uh, and it's just, okay, that's it. You really beat the the the
  376. brakes off of another good team here. And I looked at this last year for Ohio State. They beat the most number of good
  377. teams in a single season of any team in the history of college football. Now, they played more games than anyone else
  378. also by virtue of the expanded playoff, but it forces you to prove it over this sequence of pretty tough opponents. And
  379. what Indiana has done, I mean, they beat uh Oregon by 30 plus points. They beat Alabama by 30 plus points. They have
  380. kind of gone and laid waste to the teams that they have. So, they blow out Miami
  381. in this one. I think you could make a case. It's It reminded me so I was having this conversation um the other
  382. day on Substack with someone that I was thinking about Yukon a couple years ago where uh Yukon had a great team. They
  383. were the defending national champs actually. And uh during the regular season, it wasn't like best of all time.
  384. we wouldn't put it up there with, you know, the the the great like UCLA teams or Indiana in the 70s or whatever, but
  385. you look at what they did in the NCAA tournament and I think they didn't have a single game that they didn't win by
  386. double digits and they were just blowing the doors off of people all tournament long. So, I think we might with the
  387. expansions of these playoffs in all the different sports, we might have like a different category where instead of
  388. saying like, okay, greatest team of all time, you could carve out a little space
  389. for like greatest team in the playoffs specifically, what was the greatest performance? And I think Yukon 2024, I
  390. think it was, was arguably the greatest college B men's college basketball single tournament performance of all
  391. time, even if they weren't the greatest team across the whole season. And you could say that about Indiana as well.
  392. Now, they've had a great season in general. I know the metrics are not quite as high on them as some of the
  393. other great teams of the past, but if they end up again blowing out Miami in this championship game, which is
  394. possible. I don't think it's going to happen, but it it could certainly happen the way that they've been doing it, you
  395. got to kind of give them their flowers as potentially being the best in these games that we've decided count a lot
  396. more, and there's more of them than ever. The the the greatest playoff team of all time. people beingware the hubris
  397. of that inevitability. Eli Manning want to stop that. >> Yeah. No, no question the inevitability
  398. thing is is is is relevant this week, but I love Neil's distinction and actually it takes us all the way back to
  399. the beginning of our conversation between the team with the best parameter value
  400. >> versus the team that does the most on the field. And whenever like so we I just saw this uh we just got this um the
  401. the Twitter Andrew Persal our our friend who does fantastic college football analytics looked at the best teams of
  402. like the last 10 years because everyone's making this fuss about Indiana and Indiana's like or maybe the
  403. last 20. Indiana's like eighth and they're almost a half a standard deviation off the top which is you know
  404. like maybe it's a point4 so it's like four or five points off the top but that was the stacked air that was the
  405. unbelievable Alabama Georgia three deep going to the NFL era and they don't rival that and Neil's saying yeah yeah
  406. that's one question that's the theta question the who's got the best parameter the different question now
  407. that we're playing these long playoffs is who does the best and that's now it's more like March Madness and it's a whole
  408. different standard. That's cool. Very cool. And now Indiana has a chance. Let's see Indiana has a chance. Neil, we
  409. should let you go. Thanks for making time for us. It's always a delight to talk to you.
  410. >> Yeah, always a pleasure. Thanks for having me, guys. Love to talk football and other sports with you.
  411. >> Absolutely. Neil Payne, get on his Substack daily. Substack from Neil. We'll cover you across a wide range of
  412. sports, giving you both good analytics and good writing. Neil Payne. That's the first half of Wharton Moneyball. Come
  413. back and join us after the break for the second half. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of
  414. this week's show. Just off the phones with Neil Payne. Neil calling in from his home office in Bentonville,
  415. Arkansas. Long time friend of the show. Probably original. He probably gets to count as the original friend of the
  416. show. He kind of helped back in the day. He goes back as far as Deion Simkins, our associate producer, goes back um
  417. talking mostly NFL liberty college football with Neil. Good stuff as usual. Gentlemen, um why don't we take the
  418. moment? We've got 15 20 minutes here. Curious what you guys been thinking about. We've got the big sports. We can
  419. stay there if that's what's on your mind. We've got other sports if that's what's on your mind. We're just before h
  420. uh we're just before the Olympics. We're mid hockey. We're midNBA. There's golf controversy going on.
  421. There's all kinds of stuff. So, I'm curious, gentlemen, in the world of sports, what has caught your eye?
  422. I've got a kind of a fun hockey one. Um, I would I just kind of noticed I was checking out kind of the current points
  423. leaders in the NHL. And not not surprisingly, Nate Mc Nathan McKinnon and Conor McDavid are number one, number
  424. two. They're currently tied both at 78 points. But if you look at plus minus, which is, you know, something people
  425. commonly look at for uh for comparing these two, Nate McKinnon's at plus 48. Conor McDavid's at plus two.
  426. >> Wow. >> Yeah. >> Now, hold on. Is that >> he's he's tied for the league lead in
  427. points, but his plus minus is barely above zero. >> But maybe Edmonton sucks. Maybe their
  428. defense sucks. Maybe it's his linemates. >> Yes. No, I mean I think it's such a nice
  429. stark illustration of kind of the problems with just looking at some aggregate thing like plus minus where
  430. you're not adjusting for the kind of context of of what the players are doing with and in his case he's an incredible
  431. goal scorer on a poorest team that allows a ton of goals too. So he's on the ice for a lot of goals and I mean he
  432. does bear some responsibilities to that but trying to partial that out that's why you need to adjust these types of
  433. things. I just think it I thought it was kind of a a cool cool comparison between
  434. us. >> That's it's a great example, Shane. I I I used to think that hockey plus minus
  435. was this great measure and then I was going to use it for something and I wrote Namita, our old friend Namita
  436. Nandukumar who's um >> a student of Shane's and then has gone on was with the Eagles briefly and has
  437. been with the >> Kraken since their beginning. They're Kraken a year before they even started.
  438. So Nimid is like don't do anything with this. It's like plus you need the sample
  439. size you need is more or less what she said. The sample size you need to say anything about plus minus at the
  440. individual level is in the multiple seasons. You just you can't you can't begin to do something with. So you've
  441. get given us a great illustration of that. Um what else gentlemen? Aie Eric. >> So so I obviously am a huge tennis fan
  442. that Australian Open's coming up. Um, I would be surprised if like I'm trying to decide at this
  443. point. Would I take center against the field? I know I would take center and Alcarz
  444. against the field easily. Easily on the men's side. The women's side, it's hard to know. I mean, Sabalanka is having
  445. such a great start to the season and is such a strong player, but the women's game has proven that, you know, I forget
  446. there was one stretch of like four straight years where there were literally 16 different Grand Slam
  447. champions. So, I think that's hard to do on the women's side, but I think it would hard to find any legitimate
  448. betting odds any that wouldn't say matter of fact, I'd have to give you odds if I took center
  449. and Alcarez and you got the field. >> Oh, yeah. Yeah, that's not interesting. The center thing though is interesting.
  450. Like Doug, what what do you think peak odds were among the big three? Like any given grand slam,
  451. >> who what was the peak? Any one of them had >> doll at the French. >> That's not close. And
  452. >> but how high did that get? >> Is this kind of peak for a single person? >> That's what I'm asking.
  453. >> Like kind of over I mean because obviously the big three kind of sucked from each other.
  454. >> Okay. So you want to go back to like the Borg Mess Wimbletons or something. I don't I don't
  455. I mean that that would interesting empirical question. I do kind of feel like I mean or or there there was the
  456. Australian that won like everything in the 50s. >> Labor >> people wanted to go far back.
  457. >> So uh but there's but Eric's introducing this interesting threshold. Has anybody
  458. ever crossed the you know odds on favorite threshold? a single player in a mass in a professional grand slam. A
  459. grand slam. >> Crazy to think in like a four round tournament that you would ever get to
  460. that point to be honest. >> Right. Right. Is it only four rounds? Is it I thought it was like
  461. >> six seven rounds. Sorry. Seven. Seven. Seven. >> Yeah. I guess maybe relevant rounds.
  462. Probabilistically relevant rounds. I mean >> 3.7. Um. >> All right. Eric's Eric's working with
  463. his friend chat GPT to answer our question. And while he's doing that an answer, we just made it up.
  464. >> No, this question. >> Do I get Should I do a caught my eye before we wait? >> No. No. Eric's got the answer, I think.
  465. >> No, I don't have it yet, but it's looking. >> Okay. >> But I'm predicting it's going to be
  466. Nadal at the French in sometime where Djokovic wasn't as great yet on Clay, but was never great. I'm going to guess
  467. Nadal in 2016 or 17 on >> what what was the max probability pre-turn? >> I'm going to guess
  468. 60%. >> My goodness. Well into odds on favorite. Interesting. Okay. >> On the dollar ranch over those years.
  469. >> Hey, by the way, Eric, on the tennis front, by >> the way, as it's doing thinking, by the
  470. way, in 2006, it just said Federer was minus 250 at Wimbledon. >> What? Really? That's incredible. Did he win?
  471. Not of >> It's now checking. Let's not tax sport GPT with that. >> It's checking Borg 1980 at Wimbledon.
  472. Remember, he was the four-time defending champion at that point. >> So, it's checking that. So, well, let me
  473. just say regardless of whether it finds the maximum or the minimum, however you want to phrase it, we have now evidence
  474. of someone that's been what, 625, something like that, minus 250. >> Yeah. Yeah. That's that's that's
  475. impressive. That's a good thing to to know about. I would not have known. By the way, I haven't read the article yet,
  476. but a friend sent it. The New Yorker has a big article on Alcarez and Center. The
  477. budding rivalry of Carlos Alcarez and Yanik Center. Um, sounds like it might be interesting reading. Audi Winer, what
  478. caught your eye, buddy? >> All right. Well, actually, I was on I was on in Puerto Rico celebrating my
  479. wife's uh big birthday with the with the family. So, I didn't watch very much for
  480. it was a terrible time to go. We were in the air while the Eagles were playing. In fact, we flew into Philadelphia
  481. airport watching the end of the game and and we had black news blackout. I predicted I I didn't expect them to win,
  482. but I that was not what caught my eye. What catches my eye is that January 20th is coming up and Eric knows that that's
  483. the date the announcement of the Hall of Fame. So before we have next show, so we
  484. should make some forecast, guys. We always do this. Who who's going to get in? >> It's g it's going to be on it. It'll be
  485. the day of our recording next week, the 20th. Um >> could be after before. I'm not sure
  486. where they're going to. >> It's after. It's usually what 700 p.m. 6 or 7 between 6:00 and 7 p.m. on the MLB
  487. network. >> All right. So that gives you some time to research it. So they I'll just give
  488. you the a rundown and we'll make our our predictions. >> Isn't it Is there any uncertainty, Audi?
  489. Isn't it Carlos Beltron and Andrew Jones and no one else? >> So Okay. So, Belran is going to make
  490. >> Andrew Jones um he's around 83%. And you could have a substantial fall back when
  491. you when the publicly announced ballots and what actually happens. But I think Jones is going to make it. Um so those
  492. are the two obvious ones. I don't think anyone else is going to make it. What's actually interesting is where where the
  493. rest of them are going to lie, right? So the big jumps this year were really surprising. Um, uh, Chase Utley is in
  494. pushing 70 right now. So, he's only in his what, his third year. That I'd have to forecast he's going to be a Hall of
  495. Famer before this is >> he will be for sure. >> You'd argue that he'd has to be as well.
  496. Here's another one that surprised me because I thought I mean his final tally last year was in the 20s. Right now,
  497. Pettit is approaching 60%. Andy Pettit thought that is a surprise and he's in his eighth. Um, will he make it or not?
  498. No, certainly not this year. There's nobody else who's any is anywhere close to just the Beltran and Jones, which may
  499. be the reason why some of the other guys are bumping up just because there's just
  500. not that many. >> Yeah, I guess it could be both a light year just specifically this year. It
  501. could also be I mean maybe Hul you know we we have to start reappraising starting pitchers and maybe you know
  502. like somebody like Addy Pett's career looks extra I think you know like like maybe like like as as a starting pitcher
  503. kind of dies out as a as as an ent like may maybe there's some kind of you know a renewed appreciation from some of the
  504. for some of the recent starters that like were on the margins. But here's a here's a that of all the first time
  505. ballot people none of them is going to stay >> what does it take >> five% I think
  506. >> remind remind us what the first time >> oh interesting >> so there's nobody who came up this year
  507. who of really any substantial quality and that makes it was kind of wide open so the group is Ryan Braun uh Sinshu Chu
  508. Edwin Carnosion Gonzalez Alex Gordon Cole Hamills Oh. Uh, no. Sorry. Cole Hamls is up. Sorry, I missed that. He's
  509. going to stay. >> I was I going to say Cole Hamls will probably get >> Yeah, Cole Hamls is going to stay. I
  510. missed him. >> What's the base rate of staying? What's the base rate of first year guys
  511. sticking around? >> That's a great question. I don't know the answer. I would imagine it's higher
  512. than this one out of 15, right? This year it's probably >> What does it do to get what do you have
  513. to do to qualify? Yeah, I was going to say that we need to know more about the selection process of how the builds like
  514. like is is it something where they just like somebody's added to the to the ballot?
  515. >> It's 10 years. I believe it's 10 years. >> Yeah. So, there's a there's a time
  516. eligibility, but there's a lot of player lot. >> There's not it's not a deterministic
  517. process that gets on the ballot, right? It's like some kind of opaque selection.
  518. >> Committee nominates. >> I don't know. Rick Pcell is on it. He's got no votes.
  519. >> No, no, but it's a good question. I don't actually know how someone gets on the ballot. I know how long they how
  520. they stay on the ballot. I know how the maximum time, but how they get there. >> They should be has the answer. And I was
  521. correct. >> One one second there. Stay with this for just a quick sec. They should contract
  522. with people like Audi who have models for who's going to win. And they should it's just higher in the funnel. It's
  523. earlier in the pipeline. The same model would be great for nominating players, right? I mean, you could argue we don't
  524. know what the consideration set was, but maybe they did a bad job of nominating players this year, if only one. I don't
  525. know. You could certainly you could quantify that process if you wanted to through through Audi's models.
  526. >> Okay, Eric was going to answer his. >> It was it was extremely close. It's Nadal at the 2018 French Open. He was
  527. minus 255, which has an implied odds of 71.8%. Then Nadal at the 2010 French, Federer
  528. at the 2006 Australian, and Federer at the 2007 Wimbledon were all minus 250. >> I would never have thought that a single
  529. player. I would never I would I was so wrong on that. That's amazing. >> Okay. Um All right. So, let's let's And
  530. where do you have Do you know centers market odds right now for the Australian? >> I can find that quickly.
  531. >> Um All right. When does the tournament start, Eric? It starts I think it's got
  532. to be next week. He's minus Well, I mean I know there's the vague in it, but he's
  533. minus 110. >> Okay. So, he's right at it. Right at it. >> He's right at it. >> Um All right. So, has the Estrian gained
  534. uh um respect in recent time? >> Is it dropped respect? I mean, when when did it become the fourth major and why
  535. does it get to be the fourth major? I think it's been the fourth major since about 1970s, the '7s. But you understand
  536. like I think if you look at this another thing you could say is impressive about
  537. the you know we it it's hard to compare across eras like most of the great players in the 70s didn't play the
  538. Australia and so like I don't remember how many times Mackenroe played it but let's say he was a professional for 15
  539. years I'm making that up age 18 to 32 33 I I'm guessing he played it no more than
  540. four times five times. So, I think there's a deflation of these guys who have like 7 to 10 majors. I'm not saying
  541. they'd be up at the big three, but you wouldn't surprise me if they were in the closer to the 10 to 14 bracket had they
  542. played most of the majors. I think it's also true for the women on the women's side as well. You know, you have Chris
  543. Everett and Alberta with 18 majors. I don't I have to look at Stephie Grath who's got like 22 or 23. I'm not
  544. convinced she played the Australian that long. And by the way, she retired at like age 32 also.
  545. That's interesting. That's >> Yeah. Where did we decide along the way that there was four majors in tennis and
  546. four majors in golf? Because it's kind of a weak one in both sets, >> right? And now there are claim now
  547. claims for >> a clear there there's a clear fourth one in >> but why is why is four the s you would
  548. have thought everything else is in threes. Why is why are those four? >> Why are there four majors?
  549. Historically it's I I fascinating. >> All right guys, let me give you Yeah, I want to go back to what also you
  550. talked about with Neil Payne. >> I just don't I really don't think I mean I I hope I'm wrong because I want to see
  551. a competitive game. I don't think Miami should show up. >> Like I really think like I it's I find
  552. it hard to argue >> that you're a stronger team than Oregon or Alabama. I'm not saying on any given
  553. day. I'm just saying if let's go back to what we talked about with Neil. >> If I think I I'm just going to make the
  554. following statement. >> If >> Indiana played a thousand memoryless games against Oregon, Alabama,
  555. Miami, I think the spread would be the highest in against Miami. >> Yeah, possible. Now, what what's
  556. different here is if Carson Beck I mean I'm just going to tell some stories, all
  557. right? They're just stories and we should short these stories in general, but Carson Beck is a seventh year
  558. quarterback. He was he was quite good in his fifth year. He was good enough in his fifth year to be offered a $4
  559. million contract to go play a sixth year and now he's in his seventh year and he's playing what looks to be some of
  560. his best football. Miami is so that's something that seems to have changed over time. They've got, everybody
  561. recognizes they have great line play. Mario Crystal is known for his emphasis on line play and it allows them to do
  562. some things some colleges just can't do. They can just move. They they don't lose
  563. yardage. For example, I think probably have the lowest number of tackles for loss on the offensive side of anybody in
  564. the NCAA. And they are disruptive on the defensive line. So they've got athletes
  565. at at receivers. So they've you you can tell a story, but it's going to it's going to depend on Beck really being a
  566. good Carson Beck and those guys being real dis disruptive on the front lines. You know, anytime sports starts being
  567. talked about as inevitably as the Hoosers have been talked about and I mean you couldn't even you could even
  568. listen to that game the other night. I mean it's like they've turned this Cinderella into the New York Yankees.
  569. It's like they've somehow now we're pulling against Indiana that they've done that. The media has done that to us
  570. in about 15 seconds because they're making it so inevitable. I I have no flavor and taste at all for the Miami
  571. Hurricanes. But I think it'd be kind of fun if they went up there and and upset the Hooers. Okay, let me let me related
  572. to college football. Let me give you my what caught my eye. Y'all probably don't
  573. know what's going on in the portal right now. This is the second full year of portal. They've limited the number of
  574. portal windows to one. So, we're in the portal window. It's a two-eek window. The guys playing the championship have a
  575. few extra days when that championship game is over. But here's the main portal window. Two two weeks.
  576. How many players do you think the teams that are losing the most players are losing
  577. on an 85 scholarship team? What do you think? How many players do you think have been left announced? Join the
  578. portal for the team who's lost the most players. 10 to 15. >> That's I was going to guess slightly
  579. higher, but 15 to 20. But Shane's number doesn't bother me. >> I'm making that out really out of thin
  580. air, but I think that's the exercise anyway. Right. >> What What did you say, Shane?
  581. >> I'm making that completely up, but that's >> What' you say? >> 10 to 15. Sorry.
  582. >> Okay, guys. I may have never asked a question of you that you're more wrong on than this. D2.
  583. D2. Oklahoma State, who lost their coach, 62 of the 85 players. Now, Iowa State, their coach goes to Penn State.
  584. How many of their players left? Nine. Go down to teams. Now, here's the thing that's unbelievable. Maybe it's not
  585. surprising since they lost their coaches. Here's what's new this year. the the blueb blood teams that have
  586. stacked years of five-star recruits that have been crushing high school recruiting rankings for years have these
  587. guys that are third string. They've been they're sophomores. They're still not playing, but they're really highly
  588. recruited. They're being raided. Ohio State has lost 29 players. Ohio State 29 players. Notre Dame 29 players.
  589. Texas more than 20 players. It's a whole new world. Like we're we're watching college football change right in front
  590. of us this month with the portal. It's a whole new world. It's going to change high school recruiting. It's going to
  591. change the number of scholarships these teams offer. They're not going to keep 105 players because they can't pay 105
  592. players. So, they're going to have smaller rosters. They're flat out letting they're letting they have to let
  593. some guys go because they can't keep up with BYU wants to hire. they want to get
  594. somebody or Kansas State wants to get somebody and they can't. It is transformational.
  595. >> So Kade, what to you is the implications of that for I'll call it I mean obviously it's don't count on anyone
  596. being there a second year which means like maybe you should do a pulsing strategy which I'm making a number up.
  597. Let's say you have 20 million to spend on recruits. Maybe you should spend 40 million zero 40 million hero because you
  598. you might as well try to maximize years that have a down year etc etc. >> Well, ironically
  599. people were doing just the opposite when we were growing up the teams that won national championships were senior heavy
  600. teams and then they would all graduate and they'd go through this cycle. that was cyclical. And then about 20 years
  601. ago, 15 years ago, the Alabama of the world figure out a way to like stack talent and not ever have the rebuild.
  602. They just quit having rebuild years. And now with the portal, teams feel like they can always just go get they lose
  603. their best quarterback, they'll go get the best the next best quarterback in on the market. And so I think it's kind of
  604. the psychology is the opposite of that, Eric. Like we never have to rebuild. We'll just go buy a new team.
  605. >> You're not I mean they have to compete with people. So it's we'll see. I mean,
  606. everybody can't buy a new team. Doesn't work for everybody. I'm sorry, Shane. Go
  607. ahead. >> No, I was just going to say like if you did this kind of calculation of a
  608. mobility like conditioning more on like the top like the start like like they say the top 50 on a team or something
  609. like that because you you said it was like the number of scholarships they give out. So I don't I don't know how
  610. many of these are getting into like kind of the third stringer like is this mostly third stringers moving around or
  611. is it like like obviously there's a lot more fluidity in the market but like how
  612. much of the top talent is kind of moving around? top talent moves. But what's different this year is that top talent
  613. hasn't historically left the top teams. In fact, talent they've been they've been they've let their bottom people go
  614. and they've retracted. But this year, for the first time, teams are getting rated the first year and second year
  615. players who are sit on the bench, but they're the they used to they're the future of the team. They're the high
  616. school recruits that won the high school recruiting classes. They're the guys we're excited about. They're being
  617. poached, and that's a that's a whole new thing. It's a whole new world. um that yeah the optim the equilibrium
  618. here is not obvious the optimization isn't obvious and they're having to try to figure it out real time. So wait, so
  619. what does this mean >> in terms of why would you give someone a lot of money in an NIL deal or whatever
  620. that deal that payment is for a for a freshman who's going to sit because he's not good enough to start yet and he's
  621. going to go to >> he's going to go to BYU and start he wouldn't have started at Notre Dame.
  622. >> I see. >> But he's he's going to go start at a team that's lesser. That's that's
  623. analogy. >> It sounds like we're we're dividing college sports into AAA, double A, and
  624. single A. And you're going to move up >> the way you're doing it. >> That's what we thought. That's what we
  625. thought. That's what we thought at this year's challenge. >> Well, with the fluidity to move between
  626. organizations, which is not something you have in baseball. >> Well, and that but Indiana, Texas Tech,
  627. BYU, they're showing us that money can level the playing field. And one way to get there faster is to go steal guys
  628. that aren't yet on the field for these other teams. And they do other things as well. They compete for talent
  629. everywhere. But this particular dynamic is new. >> That's how Indiana is, right? I mean, we
  630. talk about let me give me let me explain this. If you get someone who's like a top four
  631. star recruit and offensive lineman, not gonna be able to start for the best teams, aren't they likely now to go to a
  632. weaker team, never not going to compete for a championship team, but will get a lot of money and will play and then a
  633. second year will move up to a a better team for probably more money, but likely to start and then maybe their third or
  634. fourth year go to a competitive team and then and then get the most money. That sounds to me like it's it's double
  635. single A double A triple A more more teams are competitive viable than they used to be. So when Indiana's playing
  636. for the national championship and Texas Tech was in the final eight um you've just got a lot you've got dozens of
  637. teams that could do it. >> Kate, can teams not sign players to multi-year NIL enforcable contracts?
  638. >> Um that's a I don't know the answer definitively. It's ask enough that we believe the answer is no. Not enforcable
  639. because if they could they would and you don't see it >> right. Okay. >> Something something you are seeing now.
  640. So Texas Tech got the top quarterback by most people's account. The Cincinnati quarterback went to Texas Tech and he my
  641. my understanding is he had a clause in his contract that if another team signed him, they had to pay a like a
  642. million dollars to Cincinnati. And I believe Tech had to honor that and paid them. And now what does that feel like?
  643. That feels like world soccer. That feels like transfer fee. >> Transfer payment.
  644. >> Freaking transfer fee. So that may be the world that we get into. So it's a different way of
  645. enforcing it, right, Eric? It's not that the that the players accountable that the guy who hires them has to pay the
  646. team, right? Maybe that's the world we're going to be in. >> Yeah. And obviously if you make that fee
  647. large enough, then people aren't going to transfer in a multi-year way. There is a cost by which you wouldn't pay it.
  648. >> There there is they won't they won't they won't take you. But it's I mean they won't be able to give you money.
  649. They can get you to come and and play for the team, but they won't be able to pay you, right? How can the player not
  650. be able to transfer a school? >> No, the player can. Player can. >> Absolutely. Yeah,
  651. >> that you just have to. He's restricted. I We'll find out what those kind of contracts will will stand up in in
  652. court. But let me tell you from a from a fan from a fans perspective, it's rough
  653. to have this much turnover. I mean, college triple historically, you see, you hear about the guys when they're in
  654. high school being recruited. You look forward to seeing them like play it when games are out of control. You get to see
  655. that guy play when he's young and then you watch him grow into a player and that's just being blown up right now
  656. just completely. >> I think it's Don't you think that has tremendous uh possibility potential
  657. being incredibly detrimental to the sport? >> Yes. I I I mean it's it's everyone kind of knows it's out of
  658. >> what's that Shane? >> Did they say that too and free agency came into baseball? Yeah, that's a fair
  659. question and it's like will the fans really lose interest and um can coaches I mean coaches now have to recruit their
  660. entire roster again every year like every year they not only are recruiting people to come in they have to
  661. re-recruit their own players and they have to decide which players to let go. I cannot imagine the job of these
  662. coaches. >> Okay. >> How long do you think it'll take just quickly on the same topic? How long do
  663. you think it'll take for us to assess your point earlier Kade that maybe this is leading to a good outcome at the team
  664. level that there's more of a opportunity a distribution of teams that can win and
  665. maybe and the other related question to me is with play people changing around all the time will this affect
  666. performance early performance in the NFL because players have now played under a
  667. bunch of different systems they're not thinking about the NFL as their objective they are, but they can make so
  668. much money in college that maybe they can sacrifice. I'm just wondering when will when we'll be able to make a
  669. statement other than we don't know >> on those two issues. >> Well, you two very different issues. Of
  670. course, I think un unquestionably the first one is true that we have more parody now than we've had in a long time
  671. in college football and has to be a great thing. Indiana, Texas Tech, Miami in there for the first time in forever.
  672. I mean, everyone recognized that's a good thing. That second question, I thought you were going to go a different
  673. direction was like, does this hurt play? Like early season gonna be a little rougher because everybody's on a new
  674. team, but you went a different direction, which is how does this affect NFL prep? No question that some players
  675. are sticking around longer because of that contract that's available now. They they some players do better with their
  676. fifth or sixth year of college instead of going to pros. And so maybe that leaves some of those guys better
  677. developed for the NFL, but also it could be that mostly those are guys that aren't going to have much of an NFL. be
  678. interesting to see when you know since many of us have connections with teams do teams start using measures of the
  679. >> how variable someone's whether it's coaching staff how many teams they've played for etc in their predictive
  680. models I'm sure they I'm sure they do I would just be interested to see what those predictive models say about
  681. someone's NFL performance as a function of how many different teams they've been
  682. on the size of their NIL contracts etc etc >> well you have an interesting intuition
  683. here that working under different systems, multiple systems is good for your learning and learning is a trait
  684. that people want. That's an interesting intuition. Okay, fellas, why don't we wrap it there? Remember, we do have
  685. between now and the next show, the quarterfinals in the NFL and the finals in college football and the Hall of Fame
  686. announcement one week from today. All right, guys. Why don't we why don't we let it go? Thanks for the full show for
  687. the whole crew here on behalf of Derek Bradley, Audi Winer, Shane Jensen, for Dion Simpkins, the boss man keeping us
  688. on track. Marissa Raina, our producer D Patel, the boss lady. Appreciate you guys. Thanks y'all for listening. Come
  689. back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Neil Payne joins to discuss NFL playoffs, college football dynamics, coaching strategies, and the impact of the transfer portal on college sports.

Key points

  • The Parody of Playoffs. A discussion on whether the best teams truly win in playoff scenarios.
  • Randomness in Sports Outcomes. Debate on the role of randomness in determining playoff results.
  • Home Field Advantage Diminished. Home field advantage isn't the significant factor it once was in playoffs.
  • Shawn Payton's Coaching Trust. Discussion on the trust in coaches like Shawn Payton over others.
  • The Complexity of Coaching. Exploration of the difficulties in measuring coaching quality in the NFL.
  • Shawn Payton's Coaching Confidence. Discussion on Shawn Payton's coaching and potential residual wins analysis.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes