Breaking Down the College Football Playoff With Advanced Metrics
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Bill Connelly, ESPN college football analyst and creator of SP+, Bill Connelly, joins Cade, Eric, Shane, and Adi to break down first-round playoff games, assess championship probabilities, and explain how analytics shape expectations in the expanded College Football Playoff. The Moneyball team also discusses the end of AFC quarterback dominance, and what today’s parity means for teams, windows, and dynasties across football.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#footballplayoffs #sportsanalytics #collegefootball #collegefootballplayoff ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
- network. This is Kade Massie hosting today with the whole crew. Eric Bradlo is here. Audi Winer here is here. Shane
- Jensen's here. All of us from our home offices. That may be No, no, Audi's at work. Audi's at work. He's at work. The
- rest of us at home offices. We also have a guest. We're introducing him in just a
- minute. We are recording on Tuesday afternoon as we typically do a little earlier in the day. It'll go up on
- Wednesday. We are going to run a regular show today. Going to have a guest in the
- first half hour and open lines in the second half hour. This week, well, we have the college football playoff on us.
- Now, this is playoff week round one week and we it's been a little while since we've done this. We want to talk college
- football. Who do we want to talk college football with? Like everybody else, we want to talk it with Bill Connley. Bill
- Connley gracious enough to join us. Bill, welcome in. Good to see you. >> Yeah, absolutely.
- >> Bill, and you've got to be busier than usual this week. You said coming on 7,000word
- round one preview. Is that right? That's a lot of words, Bill. >> I think it's going to come in at about
- eight and then I'm going to try to cut it to six, I think, is the goal here. Um, all right. It can't all be 8,000
- words. Like, sure, some people might want to read that, but I got to get it down a little bit. Hey, Bill. Is there
- more than about 30 or 40 words to say about two of the games? >> Yes. Yes. >> That's that's what Bill's that's his
- mission in life is to make us care about somebody other than Georgia and Ohio State.
- >> Actually, the the game that might be the hardest is um nobody not even my OU fan
- friends wanted to see an Alabama Oklahoma rematch. >> Um that was ugly ugly football and it
- will be ugly football again. So, that one was the hardest. Do you think the committee gave any
- consideration to matches? And do you think they should? >> Because they were locked in to this
- absurd process where if there's a team separating Notre Dame and Miami, Miami will get in. And if there's not a team
- separating Notre Dame, or sorry, if there's a team separating Notre Dame and Miami, Notre Dame will get in. And if
- there's not a team separating Notre Dame and Miami, Miami will get in. They couldn't move Alabama because that would
- impact who gets in between Notre Dame and Miami. And this was the dumbest process imaginable. It just exposed to
- every single flaw in the current system. So I don't think they could have moved them because if they moved Alabama to
- give them a different matchup, suddenly Notre Dame's in instead of Miami because
- that's what we want out of this. >> Okay. So we we are not going to relitigate the playoff.
- >> I want to reitigate. I want to reitigate it forever. >> Well, you know, there they did tweak
- things uh between year one and two of the 12 team format. Perhaps they'll tweak it again.
- Maybe something about the process. I don't think anybody's ever been as unhappy about it as it's been a long
- time. It's been almost a generation before we've been since we've been this unhappy. But let's not for the time
- being, let's not. Let's go forward. Let's go forward looking and talk about actual football. And I've been away from
- the show for a couple of weeks and we've been away from college football the whole world has except for, you know,
- Army Navy and that riveting Washington Boise State game this weekend. What do we need to Let's get back into the frame
- of mind, Bill. We've got some playoff football. This is only the second year that we've had, you know, four round one
- games on We have playoff games on home campuses. I mean, let let's get back into that mindset. Tell us tell us what
- you're excited about this weekend. Give us like three big ideas or three things you're excited about to get us back in
- this frame of mind. >> Well, I guess the most me answer I could give would be Montana, Montana State for
- a spot in the FCS finals. That's what I'm most excited about. But We here are interested of course in Villanova.
- That's right. That's right. >> Gale played Montana in the second round of that. >> Montana State. Get it right. Montana
- State. >> Montana State. Right. [laughter] >> I I have many opinions about that, but
- uh I I guess I'll focus on the what we're actually supposed to talk about. No, I you know, this is you're right.
- This was you know, last year we got three four bad games. Technically, not not any of them were close, but they
- were still pretty incredible in that they unlocked this new substance for college football called playoff home
- field advantage. Like watching SMU's quarterback have to cover his ears because things were so loud, they call a
- timeout, they come back from the timeout and it's louder and he immediately throws a pick six. That was just that
- that was kind of amazing. You know, college football's always kind of known for the the atmospheres and whatnot, and
- we unlocked a whole new thing. Uh, and now we got four new home stadiums to kind of show off here with with Owen
- Field with uh, you know, uh, Cal College Station, Oxford, Norman, and Eugene. Um,
- that's going to be that's going to be cool in and of itself. It's it is a spectacle in that regard. So hopefully,
- you know, if we get one amazing game, that'll be one more than last year. will just be continuing to trend upward and
- and we'll see if we get that one. >> Can I get a quick answer and uh tell me what is the point spread differential
- for a home game currently estimated in college? >> So, I've always the thing that's always
- worked best to me is about two and a half points. I've fiddled with less than that at times. I think there have been a
- couple years where maybe it should have been less and of course, you know, 20 and 21 got all weird, but I still use
- two and a half. >> It's a very new dynamic for playoff games. Well, I mean, playoff games
- obviously are a new dynamic themselves, but having the home field, is there a much of a movement towards I know cuz
- the next >> is this the only round that's actually in home stadium then they start moving
- into the Bulls and everything like that. Is there >> much energy towards additional home, you
- know, put it like it would be >> there's extreme energy for it. There's a lot of energy for it. Everybody wants
- quarterfinal home games as well. The problem is the bowls had to be kind of, you know, placated to get the system we
- got. And therefore, you know, I'm personally I wrote about this last year and I I still think I'm right. Um, you
- know, they basically they wanted those quarterfinals in major bowl slots because that would, you know, make the
- major bowls still feel like major bowls and whatnot. I don't think that's true. Like if you basically put the
- quarterfinals in home sites, uh, but then took like just basically the top eight teams that didn't make the field,
- stick them in those four major bowls, among other things, we would have gotten a USC Texas Rose Bowl this year on the
- 20th anniversary of the US USC Texas Rose Bowl that we all still talk about. That would have been a lot better than
- Indiana versus Oklahoma or something where it's just basically using Pasadena as a neutral site quarterfinal. Oh,
- >> and in fact, you could argue it's probably more competitive because the distance between say like 13, 14, 15th
- best team in the nation, you know, and the 20th is much smaller than what we're doing with like, you
- know, one and >> right. Well, Bill, give us a give us a couple words on age and let's work up
- let's work up kind of from the bottom maybe. So, g give us something on J Madison, James Madison versus Oregon.
- Like, what could we learn? Oregon presumably is an actual national title contender, but can we learn anything
- about them from their game against James Madison? >> Well, JMU's defense really is pretty
- solid. You know, it's not going to be Big 10 solid. I'm sure they're a little lighter here and there. Um, but they
- held Louisville like beginning of the year, Louisville was kind of banged up all year, but they were about as healthy
- as they'd been all season. They held Louisville to like 285 yards. Um, they're first in my success rate
- measure. Success rate allowed. JMU is uh I think I think Oregon's going to this is going to be kind of your typical mid-
- major upset approach I think from JMU where you know give them whatever they want between the 30s, let them run the
- ball, whatever, and then try to stop them on third downs and and limit the pass and things like that. Oregon hasn't
- always passed very well this year. The receiving core has been all over the place in terms of injuries. Um and I
- think Jam have a chance at least to do the third downs, red zone, no big plays kind of approach and I think they have
- enough talent to do that. Um, where I'm more concerned, I think is JMU's offense. Like when they the better
- defenses they played, it was pretty much big plays or nothing for them. They they
- beat, you know, Washington State had the weirdest year ever. Almost beat two playoff teams in Old Miss and James
- Madison. And JMU got like a 70 yard run late that that basically took that game for them. Had they were struggling
- against Troy and Snow and all this stuff and Wayne Knight rips off another big run and kind of opens things up for
- them. I don't think they're going to pull that off. you're you're going to have to get to at least 20 points
- against Oregon. I'm not sure they can, but I think it can absolutely be a competitive game. Problem is, two years
- ago, we watched Oregon play Liberty in a in a major bowl game, that G5 thing again, and they acted like they were
- offended they even had to share the field with Liberty and just absolutely erased them from the opening snap. So, I
- need to if it's tied after if it's still scoreless after like 10 minutes, then I'm confident, Jim, you can put together
- a really good game. But I do still have that memory in the back of my head that they're just going to come out and be up
- 21 nothing immediately. >> So Bill, what do you see maybe to uh Cad's point, what do you see that the
- betting market's not seeing? You think you it could be it could be a competitive game, but the line's 21.
- >> Yeah, I mean SP plus NFBI have it around 15, I think. Um, and that's just because
- JMU with the schedule they have faced, which of course only included one power conference team. Um, in against
- Louisville, team that also beat Miami, and it was tied midway through the fourth quarter till a fumble basically.
- Um, you know, they are JMU graded out great on paper. Their defense has been awesome all year. Their offense has been
- awesome the back half of the season. Um, and they're a good team. Like that's again, I think Oregon has a gear that
- only four or five teams have. I would say there are five teams I think that could compete for the title and they're
- they're the only one that doesn't get a buy. Um and so yeah, I would expect Oregon to look great and and win, but
- for the season as a whole, they've only apparently been about 15 points better than JMU.
- >> All right, that's the last game of the weekend. That's Saturday night. The game
- before that is the other G5 game. That's Tain going to miss. It's a Southern Southern game. It's also a coaching
- change coaching change situation. What which is very odd for two playoff teams. So give us something that we should keep
- an eye on or why we should be interested in two lane miss. >> Um the the major thing and I'm I'm going
- to lean on this in the in the preview just so I can try to make it sound as interesting as possible. We saw this
- game in September as well and and uh Miss won by 35 which is never great uh heading in. But also, we've had six
- rematches this season, five conference title games, and the whole Oregon State, Washington State playing twice thing.
- And in five of the six, the team that lost the first game won the second, and they were huge, like 27 point swing in
- one game, 24-point swing in another. Uh, Tain played its worst game imaginable early in the season. Jake Rzleaf, their
- quarterback. He showed up on campus in August. He was booted from BYU over the summer. Uh, we're kind of mutually
- whatever that situation ended up being. Weird stuff. look it up. Um, but he shows up in August. He, um, you know,
- first two games of the year, they were able to run well enough that he didn't even really have to have chemistry with
- his receivers. Then suddenly he had to have chemistry because they couldn't run all that well. Had no chemistry with his
- receivers. Had the worst game of his life. The uh, Old Miss, meanwhile, had just uh, transitioned to Trinidad
- Chambles at quarterback. Uh, the F State go D2 the Fair State transfer. Um, and he had only started one game at that
- point. So, Twain thought, "Hey, new guy. Let's attack as much as possible. let's
- blitz and make him uncomfortable. And he crushed them. Just absolutely obliterated them because you can't do
- that to him as other teams have found out. So I think basically we're going to get a much better performance from Tain
- here. Both because Rleaf knows his receivers names and because they understand what Chamblas can and can't
- do. That's probably not enough to make up 35 points and miss is the better team. But again, I do think we're going
- to get a we could get a much more entertaining game out of it. aside from all the unknowns of yeah Lane Keifin's
- already gone, John Summer's leaving all that stuff is going to you know that that's a a weird thing to itself I
- guess. >> So Bill, how much does the change in coaching that K just brought up affect
- like the way you're thinking? Like how much does does it move the spread in your mind or the win probability?
- >> So it's different in that John Suml is still at two lane. Um, but you can't when when Lane Keifin leaves for one of
- Miss's rivals, you can't let him stay at Old Miss and continue to make everybody feel like he's recruiting
- all Miss's best players to LSU. So, if it impacts anybody, you would think it would impact Miss negatively, but it is
- such a a nebulous thing. I mean, they played so well down the stretch despite all the the rumors and the winds blowing
- about Kein leaving and all that. So they are clearly their own team and they still have you Golden the defensive
- coordinator has now taken over. So really it's only one person who's really changed. Um so I don't I don't really
- anticipate any specific change. If there's a change I figure it's negative for Old Miss but I'm doubting.
- >> Well that I'm you could tell a story that they're now galvanized and they're pissed at Ke
- they like they feel like abandoned and we're going to show him and it would be one hell of a story if they made a run
- in the playoffs after he left. >> We can pick that up. >> They're they're a strong team. there. I
- you know, we're gonna once we do the first round games before we leave, we'll get a little bit of a thought from you
- on the rest of the bracket. But you already gave away that you think there are five real contenders. That means
- Miss is not one of them. Um which is which is reasonable, but let's come back to it. Okay. The Friday night game is
- the 89 game. That's Alabama going to Oklahoma for a rematch. I believe the first game was at Alabama that Oklahoma
- managed to win somehow. Um so you said this was going to be ugly. Um, neither one of these teams is gonna make a long
- run in the playoffs, right? They're going to run up against Indiana the next time, but what what's interesting to you
- about Alabama? >> Well, I think I mean, you know, there were two games. I looked it up. I have
- my postgame win expectancy number. Um, which basically which I always tweet out and and it's reasonably popular on on
- social where I look at like here are all the stats from this given game. Toss them up in the air and it says that team
- A would have won this game x% of the time based on success rates and blah blah blah. U this was the fifth least
- likely result of the season according to postgame win expectancy Alabama almost doubled Oklahoma's yardage almost
- doubled their success rate um basically from the stats the game produced oh you had a 5% chance of winning but they
- returned a pick 87 yards for a touchdown they blocked a field goal at the end of
- the first half they recovered three I think it was three turnovers for Alabama one was a muff punt uh OU scored points
- on three drives that didn't gain more than like 30 yards uh it was just the basically the strategy that the uh Super
- Bowl champion Eagles are using this season as well to win games. I think >> like an extreme version of that. Yes.
- >> Outcome not at all agreeing with the peripherals. >> No, it was um it was a really super ugly
- game. And from that standpoint alone, you figure I mean all all Alabama has to do is play like they did last time and
- not muff a punch or not get a field goal blocked or lose two other turnovers and
- they're fine. Um but they haven't looked like a playoff team since October. Um they they they handled Tennessee really
- well. They finished that four grand stretch where they won four straight ranked games. They they had the best
- resume in the country and then they were out of gas. They they didn't look great
- against South tried to blow it against South Carolina. Didn't look great against LSU. Looked downright bad
- against Auburn and still rose in the playoff rankings after that game and then got crushed by Georgia and somehow
- didn't fall in the playoff rankings. So they're very lucky to be here and you know now that they're here and they've
- heard they spent the last two weeks being told they're lucky to be here. So that you know you never know the whole
- galvanizing thing but Ty Simpson's like timing is gone. He's been battling without a run game all year and suddenly
- he just looked horrific against George. Didn't look very good against Auburn either. So if that doesn't change it
- doesn't matter. U will still win. But, uh, they can at least take heart in the fact that they were on paper they were
- demonstraably superior the first time around. >> I feel like the rhetoric around
- Oklahoma's defense just got stronger and stronger over the course of the year. Maybe because their defense did venibles
- of course has that reputation. Matier the wild card at the end of the season that he seemed at the beginning of the
- season. I would say overall you sound a little bit optimistic about Oklahoma. >> Yeah. I mean basically because of
- Alabama well and and the fact that oh you you know to the extent that identity really matters in these things. They
- know exactly what they have to do to win a football game. Um Alabama's kind of lost in the winds right now. They don't
- know how they're going to move the ball or anything like that. But you know we're going to play defense. We're going
- to force turnovers. We're gonna pounce on every single Our offense may stink, but we're great in the red zone. So, any
- chance we get, we're getting seven points out of it. Uh, and we're gonna hope to hit one big pass play at some
- point in the game. Missouri completely controlled the first half against Oklahoma, but could only get up like
- three nothing cuz OU's defense was really good and they missed a field goal and then suddenly won I think it was
- like an 87 yard pass to Isaiah Satenia and poof, they were ahead and they went on to win like 176.
- one big pass play to Satania against LSU as well and and that was it. So >> that's their formula and they know it
- really well and and to the extent that that matters like I'd rather just have a great overall team that probably would
- matter more but they are very confident in their formula and that could end up mattering here.
- >> Okay. Well, so can can Simpson get his mojo back? That's an interesting question especially against Venable's
- defense. Can Satena can they continue to hit hit this Satena button? you know that and can they get any defensive
- turnovers? Okay, fine. Okay, the surely the most interesting game of week one is
- Miami at&m. It's the first game on Saturday. Um you know Kyle Field is a one of the great places to see football
- in America and this is going to be a playoff game there. Are you kidding me? They should have put this the night
- game. I can't believe they didn't. But 11 o'clock still central time. Miami I mean you you've you've you've said
- there's only five contenders of the others. I mean, Miss must have some kind of remote chance. And Miami, surely I'm
- a little short on&m because of Marcel Reed, but Miami maybe, maybe. What do you think about this game?
- >> I This is And I'm This is what I've set it up in the preview. If you tell me either one of these teams won by 28
- points, I'll believe you immediately. Um they are both extremely just up and down and and kind of frantic
- teams at time especially&m &m you can basically guarantee that Marcel Reed's going to look terrible for one quarter
- and great for one and then the other two quarters are going to basically decide the game
- >> and and so that can go in any number of directions. Miami is just man they just
- don't so number one their defense is very good um secondary completely recrafted in in the transfer portal kind
- of underrated almost uh because we talk a lot about Ruben Bane up front and Ake Mezador up front secondary's been
- awesome the whole defense is good not necessarily I mean&m's played other good defenses so they're not going to be
- surprised by that or the athleticism or anything but really good unit Miami's offense however is just you know six
- yards at a and um very efficient. Fewest big plays by far of anybody in this field. Um they really are just kind of
- measured and didn't conduct down the field, which is fine except that means you need like 11 plays to score a
- touchdown. And there have been a couple games where Carson Beck can't go 11 plays without throwing an interception.
- So um they looked spectacular at the beginning of the year. They they really did look strong late. Once I once they
- started climbing somehow catching up to Notre Dame in the playoff rankings, they
- started playing well again. Uh in between they were extremely mediocre and um more mediocre than I think&m's been
- at any stretch this season. So that's really Yeah, I I I this is a it's really hard to get a read on this game because
- you could really talk yourself into a huge advantage either way. If it's close&M
- uh because a they're they they they're experienced in that this year. They're the four and01 score games and Miami
- just can't escape the Mario Crystal Ball allegations when it comes to being too tight, too conservative, uh just too
- cautious down the stretch. It c it cost them twice and almost cost them two more
- times. >> Okay. Is it fair to characterize&m's a some defenses and&m seems to be one of
- these defenses this year is it's really kind of an explosive play defense. It's a it's a high havoc defense. They get a
- lot not for losses, but they get these big blowing planes against them. Um, okay. So, I saw that against South
- Carolina big time. Saw it against Texas big time. It seems to be the philosophy.
- Um, how does that match up with how you characterize Miami's six yards in a cloud of dust kind?
- >> Yeah, that's that that's one of the reasons why like if you tell me Miami just, you know, number one was remained
- efficient but also made big plays because&m always gives up big plays, then they're set. They're going to
- they're going to roll. But if they can't be efficient because&M renders you inefficient, they they force the longest
- third downs in the country. They have the best third down conversion rate allowed in the country. They have the
- best pass rush numbers in the country. Um if Miami isn't able if if they're in second and eight or third and seven a
- lot that favors&m dramatically. So it is one of those kind of strength versus weakness weakness versus strength kind
- of situations that you can you can really talk yourself into seeing anything. >> Eric's going to jump in.
- >> You Bill, I was just going to ask you the length of time between when they last played. Have you have you or others
- have they ever looked at does it tend to favor the stronger team, the weaker team, the offense, the defense? Has
- there been any studies of this and like what should we expect? Because I'm like,
- you know, the standard I have six days to prepare for this other team. I've had four weeks to prepare for this other
- team. >> This specific gap is kind of a new one. Um, and that basically everybody's had
- two weeks off now, maybe three. Um, and last year, so basically last year was the first time we saw everybody with
- this this exact gap of time. And it turned out the favorites rolled in all the games. So maybe that's maybe that's
- the answer, but it is like we're used to bowl breaks where everybody's off for like six weeks. This one's right in
- between. It's it's like two by weeks instead of an actual huge gap. And so I don't know. I think we need we need more
- data on this one. But last year it sure seemed to well last year I guess it favored all the favorites in the first
- round and then it favored all the teams that had just played in the first round in the quarterfinals because all those
- other teams have been off a month in the quarterfinals and all the teams that had
- buys struggled. >> Well, there's even one more wrinkle. Some of these teams played in conference
- championships. Um in fact, well, and some didn't. No, all of them. All of them did. The second round hosts all
- played in conference championships. So, it dampens that that time off. But it's an open question, Eric. And people have
- been people argue about like, is it an advantage to have the buyer or not? Because it buys you this extra time, but
- it also might slow things down. Audi's been trying to get in as well. >> Odd. >> Nope.
- >> Your hand is up, buddy. Your hand is up. I'm trying to >> Oh, that was from before and forgot to
- take it down. >> All right. My bad. All right, Bill. Before we go, you've given us a
- fantastic preview of the first round, but we don't want to neglect the guys that are waiting on the other side of
- the first round. We've got Texas Tech in the fourth seed taking the JMU Oregon winner. We have we have um Georgia in
- the third seed waiting for yet another Southern team, Tain or Old Miss. We have Ohio State in the second seed waiting
- for that winner, that game we we're just kind of getting excited about in College
- Station, the the&m Miami game. And then Indiana, number one seed, Indiana. My god, we could have done the whole
- episode on them waiting for yet another red team, Alabama or Oklahoma. What are your thoughts on the second round and
- and what are your thoughts about those four teams? Um, how uniform are your are your
- probabilities over championships across those four teams? >> Uh, so the the probabilities on the SP
- plus side right now is basically let's see 29% Ohio State, 24% Indiana, 21% Texas Tech. My numbers love Texas Tech
- and they love Texas Tech despite the fact that >> I mean they're they're that they're much
- higher on Texas Tech than others and every single week Tech overachieves against projections by like two
- touchdowns. So it can't it can't ra raise that number high enough for to catch Tech. So I think they're pretty
- fantastic. They're going to obviously have by far the hardest challenge in the in the quarterfinals if all the
- favorites win here and they have to play Oregon because I do think I think Tech is third in SP plus but Oregon
- is longer, all those kinds of the things that those matter. Uh so I think that's
- a really really tough game for them. But but from a numbers standpoint, those three stand out and then you've got
- Georgia at 10%. Georgia really >> surpris I test from afar I wouldn't have put them at like a third of Ohio State and
- half of Georgia at Texas Tech, you Well, it depends on if you watched early in the season when they looked like they
- were just going playing games unprepared um and just like, "Oh, we'll figure it out." And then not looking good until
- the fourth quarter and figuring it out and winning. Um >> but how relevant is early in the season
- at this point? >> Yeah. No, that's I mean Georgia has figured out the the formula here. They
- basically their second national title year with the four-game playoff, they basically did the same thing. They
- looked very just mediocre for stretches at a time, but they always brawled their
- way to a win and then looked great at the end. So, >> and Ohio State last year. >> Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean it's I, you know,
- I would have them I have them at 10%. I would have them closer to the pack than that, but from a number standpoint, I
- get it because SP saw the first half of the season and doesn't trust them all that much. Also, their offense is like
- Miami in that they don't make big plays at all. Um, as the defense really rounded into form late in the year, you
- could really start to question that the Georgia offense against Georgia Tech. Uh, terrible Georgia Tech defense. They
- really didn't do a single thing against them. Um, Alabama has a good defense, but they didn't do much against Alabama
- either. It was just Bama's offense wasn't doing anything. So, I don't completely trust Georgia, but you just
- have to to some degree say that Kirby Smart knows how to win these games and they're just going to brawl their way
- in. >> Bill receeding happen in college football. >> I I like I like when brackets take on
- their own personality like in the like in March Madness where some years you have a bunch of chalk and other years
- the bracket w opens wide open for the eight seat or something like that. like I that's that's what I enjoy. And um so
- I I don't think so. I think um you know if we have a situation where you know whatever we're talking about
- here, Alabama suddenly becomes Alabama again and rolls through Oklahoma and Indiana um you know their reward should
- be an easier semi-final game, not necessarily having to play like Ohio State or something in the semis.
- >> Guys, I'm curious your response to the probabilities that Bill gave. He gave S
- sp SP plus probabilities and he said 29, 24, 21 and 10 among the top four seeds and then we kind of fudged the 10 back
- up because we think George has probably got some non-stationity that's working in his favor now. So make him 15 maybe
- take some of that from everybody. But spreading from 27 to 15 the top four seeds that feels relatively flat to me.
- You're talking about just right at two to one between >> and nobody has a one in three chance. So
- >> yeah. >> Um which is exciting. I mean, you're saying Texas Tech, a G a G5 team, has a
- >> Not exactly. Not exactly. >> They're just not an SEC or Big 10 team. >> Oh, I'm sorry. Not Yeah, of course. Of
- course. Oh, look what I've done. Look what I've done to the fans. >> My goodness gracious. I should Oh, hope
- my family doesn't listen to that. >> Entitlement superiority comes in quick as it turns. [laughter]
- You got a nice natural experiment here. There's lots of ways to summarize the quote unquote flatness. The first thing
- that struck me is that the highest team is quote unquote only 29%. That's one way to look at it. Another is the
- difference between the first and the fourth, right? That's another way to look at it kind of being pretty flat.
- Um, another way is also just looking at the total probability of the top four versus everyone else. So, Bill, with
- just roughly, I would have to give you somewhere in the 8 to N to1 odds to take anybody outside the top four.
- >> 74. Yeah, it's about 84 85% for the top four. And last year when they gave buys
- to the conference champions and we had kind of a weird bracket >> where Ohio State was the best team in
- the country and the eight seed. That was certainly a different situation, which I
- didn't I didn't mind. I don't mind weird. I think that should be very obvious. Uh, but it's definitely true
- this year where the top four teams are probably unless you want to make a case for Oregon and I think you could. They
- were the top they were the four best teams as well and therefore it kind of played out like it should and Oregon if
- they do handle JMU they're at 7% right now. Nobody else is above well miss is at four and a half% everybody else is at
- two or lower. Um, >> but that's but as soon as you get one and six one and six and you get Oregon
- and then the chance that Matier actually plays well Simpson gets his mojo back. Miss is galvanized in the absence of
- Lane Keifin or Miami, you know, Beck lifts the offense somehow ultimately like you get one in six chance you get
- all those possibilities. Does that appeal to anybody? Aie, you always like the field. You want the field on this
- one? >> And just to clarify, they don't >> outside the top four. I don't think I
- do. >> Not Not if Bill's numbers are accurate. Not even close. >> I'm told they're not. If that helps you
- at all. I'm told a lot on your numbers are accurate. It makes this point moot. But they don't do receding. No.
- >> Right in this. >> No, that's what I said. Yeah. No receding. >> I think one and six is not I think one
- and six would be fun. It be It'd be fun card to have, but you're running against
- four very good teams sitting there at the top of the bracket. >> What's interesting, Bill?
- >> No, wait, hold on a minute. Al, are you asking me whether I would take the field
- at one and one and six? >> Yeah, that's what of course I am. >> That's a I I mean, yeah, for sure.
- >> But why? That's fair odds. It's fair odds. Why are you so excited now? >> No. No. Oh, I thought you meant the
- 50/50 mark, right? Usually >> No, no, no, no. Even at 8515, that's fair odds, Audi, according to FBI.
- >> Right. Right. Right. So, I would probably take the field at that. Give if I if you gave me those odds.
- >> Okay. All right. Um All right, Bill, we should let you go. Um, what is the single thing you're most excited about
- seeing this weekend other than just football again? And you can say Montana State. That's fine.
- >> Well, yeah. I mean, I am Brawl of the Wild and and the F the Fair State Harding D2 title game are both going to
- be really fun split screen viewing. I got the YouTube multi- view going on and uh that's going to be really fun to have
- on there. But no, I I really the one thing we'll have going for us for sure is that four new stadiums get to light
- themselves on fire basically and be as as fun as those stadiums have ever been. I do think we'll get at least one good
- game. mods suggests that we we should especially with two games with tight spreads, but it should just be a really
- fun kind of spectacle again at the very least. >> Wonderful. All right, thanks for making
- time for us. Enjoy it. Good luck with your cutting your 8,000 down to six and we look forward to reading it, Bill.
- Thank you. >> Sounds good. >> Bill Connley, you can read him many places. ESPN in particular, founder,
- creator of SP Plus, fantastic follow on Twitter and probably Blue Sky, I'm guessing. Billc ESPN. At least that used
- to be it. Bill Connley. Long time from the show. That has been the first half of Wharton Moneyball. Come back and join
- us after the break. Welcome back. Welcome back to the second half of Wharton Moneyball. Just off the
- lines with Bill Connley. Thankful always for time with Bill. We're just going to
- open things up here in the second half. But before we do that, on the way out, guys, on the way leave that
- conversation, Shane was saying there at the break that it had him fired up about
- college football playoff. We got him back from Europe and he had to get back into football mindset, American sport
- mindset. And that was a good pep talk for you, Shane. >> It was. It was. I got to say, yeah, I
- was over in uh Switzerland for a week and so I wasn't really uh keeping up with kind of I heard the angst about the
- college football playoffs, but it's nice to actually dive into the matchups that
- are as opposed to the matchups that could have been. >> That's right. That's exactly right. You
- skipped the right season. Skipped the angst season. Now you got back for the actual games.
- >> I love angst in general. I wish I could have been around. >> There's a time and place to litigate
- that, but but now it's time to pay attention to football. Um, we are nearing NFL playoffs. We're not that far
- away. We're down to is it four weeks? Four, three weeks. >> Three weeks. >> Three weeks of games left. That's it.
- Um, let's do uh what caught your eye, but I know somebody's got who put this on the board. This is the most
- remarkable thing I've read in a while. I'll give it to Shane because Shane's probably made this observation.
- >> Is this the 15 year? It's that it's been 15 years since the AFC Championship game
- has not involved either Tom Brady or Patrick Mahomes. 2010 was the last time it happened. And Audi, do you remember
- who uh the AFC Championship game was in 2010? Just for a throwback. >> It wasn't the Jets.
- >> It was It was the Jets. >> It was the Jets. It was against the Jets. >> No kidding. Isn't that amazing?
- >> I did not blanked that out. That's >> Yeah, the Jets I mean it's so it's been
- like over a decade of mediocrity since then, but the Jets make the AFC Championship two years in a row.
- >> Yeah, that was Mark Sanchez, right? >> Yes. Mark that. >> My goodness. Okay. >> It was a humble or two ago. It was it I
- mean it was honestly the fact that we have to go back. I mean this is more just about obviously you know kind of
- the the dynasty nature of the AFC the last like this millennia I guess. Um, and the fact that Mahomes specifically,
- I mean Brady was very consistent obviously in this, but Mahomes just so consistently making I mean before this
- year the um the earliest the Chiefs were um eliminated um in the Mahomes era was
- the overtime of the AFC Championship game, >> right? [laughter] >> That's unbelievable. Okay. Um, is there
- any is there anything close to I mean what would even come close to rivaling that in terms of two players dominance
- over half of the sport? I mean there's there's not quarterbacks are kind of a unique thing and these dynasties are
- also relatively unique and they've >> I think basketball the dynastic name basketball I think you'd have to kind of
- turn to um and I you know it would only be kind of something like where you know I mean
- if we' been went right from essentially be 2,000 acres without anything in between maybe that would be the closest
- analog. >> Hold on hold on y'all went different places. Let's let's do one at a time.
- Eric said bird and magic. So, how many how many finals in a row had either Bird or Magic in
- Well, I do know in the 80s the Lakers won five. Um, the Celtics won three. So, that's eight. The Sixers won one in the
- 80s. And I think maybe the Houston Rockets may have won one or something. >> There might have been a streak of like
- eight or nine there because I know the Sixers one was really early in the 80s. And so,
- >> 82 83 >> the Mahomes the Mahomes uh Brady is the is the >> Yeah. But anything
- >> anything close anything structurally close to that is what we're kind of fishing around for.
- >> Well, the Yankees and the Yankees in the 50s won of course five straight championships and they would have gone
- to the World Series. I mean, Yogi Barrow won 11 championships in however many years he played.
- >> Matt played 13 seasons. I think he won he went to the World Series in 10. I mean, we're if we're allowed to go back
- to when there was like eight teams in the league also won like 11 championships in a row or something like
- that in the NBA, right? >> Thank you, Shane. I was going to go to that like remind me honestly now I need
- to be reminded how many teams were there >> when the Yankees were dominating >> and also you went you went straight from
- winning the league to playing the World Series. There was just like you win your
- pennant, you go to the World Series. Is that the way it was? Yes, that's right. That's all there was was a World Series.
- >> Okay. >> Yeah. Bring up in tennis. >> I was just going to bring up in tennis now.
- >> There you go. Yeah. >> Between S and Alcarez. >> Um I know they've won the last I'm going
- to say eight or nine. And I mean they haven't been around that long, but it's probably been three years at least since
- like the two of at least one of them hasn't been in the final. >> Okay. Wow. predicting just my own belief
- unless one of them gets injured which could obviously happen this could be the greatest twoperson run unless a third
- person joins him that's the problem is you guys remember there was a stretch between Nadal Federer and Djokovic where
- they won something like well they have 66 combined between the three of them they won something like 66 out of 71 or
- two like Delpatro won one andy Murray won three. So maybe it's 66 out of 75 cuz Murray won three, Winker won three,
- and the um there's another guy that won the US Open. I just forget his name um that beats Verb in the finals, but like
- those might be the only people with championships in the last 20 years except for those three players.
- >> So Eric, remind me on that again. Um for it feels like Feteran Nadal got going
- before Djokovic joined that three. Am I right? Was there a moment where veteran Nadal kind of dominated? There's a
- twoperson domination. >> There is there is abs there's absolutely a period where they dominated and
- >> and you don't even have to look at ch like really to kind of make this analogous, you just expand out to like
- making the semifinals essentially in tennis, right? Because we're talking about just going to the AFC Championship
- game. >> Well, the interesting thing is in football they they have to come out of
- the same conference. So, one of those guys was coming out of the same side every time.
- >> Yeah. >> Um this but okay, those are good. Those are good analoges. That's interesting.
- All right. So, that was Shane's caught his eye as a starting point. >> Let me build on Shane's since it
- directly builds on it. So, I'm sitting here thinking, especially given what happened in the NFL this last week where
- the Bills made a pretty impressive comeback against a very good New England team, by the way, somehow someway you
- say if Josh Allen So, Mahomes is not there now. >> Oh, it's not the Ravens are not making the playoffs
- either. >> So, Don't we're not giving up the fight yet. >> But they're likely not making the
- playoffs. They could still They could win the division. Absolutely. I I I don't remember what their tiebreaker.
- >> No, they're basically I mean the division is their only path I think to the playoffs at this point, but they
- >> it's not I mean they're I guess probably below 50%, but I mean they've still got
- a game against Pittsburgh, right? So >> yeah, they win out they'll they'll they'll win they'll go to the playoffs,
- I believe. >> Oh, did they win the first game against Pittsburgh? Do they have >> They just lost it. They just lost it.
- >> So I don't know whether Either way, they let's assume they win out, they catch up the game, they win
- the tie break. All right. No, then they can absolutely go. Um, this seems to be a year there's even more pressure on
- Josh Allen to get it done. And if he doesn't get it done, then you have to start wondering, look, not that he's old
- or anything like that, but you have to start wondering, does the Bills window start to shut a little bit? And now you
- start think maybe it's the Patriots window, maybe it's the Broncos window, maybe it's No, I'm just saying there are
- teams in the that are strong. >> Well, I mean I certainly I think just to generalize your point, it seems as sex
- more wide open at least on the AFC side than it ever has or has been in years. >> But you just went to something bigger
- than just the season. You talk about the Bills window closing. How many different
- windows did Brady get? >> Two. >> Two big windows, right? two distinct big windows and
- >> there's at least three there's actually three retoolings like like what we're
- really kind of asking what I think Eric's implying is that you know typically for a team a window is only
- like four five six years then you got a cop like almost all teams you have to have a down year or two and actually
- even the Patriots did have you know that 2010 the one of the you know 2010 2011 the Jets made the championship a couple
- times those were the Patriots down years >> look the most amazing thing to me about
- all all the great things Tom Brady accomplished. He went 11 years without winning the Super Bowl. But I just want
- to say that again. If his career had ended, if his career ends at age 36, 37, which is where many quarterbacks career
- ends, Tom Brady, I could argue, is not the GOAT. He's one of the goats, but he had three Super Bowl wins, right? And
- then he went on to win four more. That's what's remark. but with an 11-year stretch in between.
- >> It's funny you said it ambiguously. You said he went 11 years without winning
- the Super Bowl. I'm like, well, how many years did Marino go? [laughter] >> No, but I meant after having won three
- and four years, then he went 11 years. >> No, you're you're 100% right. Marino had
- an interesting case study too of like you know I mean didn't he play like in his rookies like one of his first couple
- seasons he went to the Super Bowl second year >> and I'm sure at the time people were
- like well this is going to be a semiannual occurrence and I don't think he ever made it back
- >> he never made it back and they got blown out in that Super Bowl and actually I
- don't even remember if they played in an AFC Championship game maybe one like he
- didn't come close really to winning the to even getting back to the Super Bowl in the rest of
- >> Okay, but we we got to get Josh Allen in the Super Bowl. We have to. It's a crime
- against humanity if he doesn't get into the Super Bowl. And this is just his first window. And this is my only point.
- I think you you probably meant it that way. >> I meant that's the end the closing of
- this window. >> This window. This window. Very very good. Well, I mean, where are you on the
- AFC having seen that? Like the Ravens could get on a run, the Bills could get on a run. Neither one of these teams
- has, you know, done that great so far in the regular season, but they have these quarterbacks
- where when they're on, they're really tough to beat. I mean, you don't want to bet against either one of those teams.
- >> I can speak for my Sorry. Go ahead, Shane. I'm >> dreaming of a 1985 Super Bowl rematch.
- >> Come on. >> Bears against the Patriots, baby. >> Let's do it. >> Do you want the outcome? Same outcome,
- Shane? >> No. No. No. Revenge rev. Revenge rematch. Revenge rematch. >> That was one of the most lopsided of all
- time. >> I can't if you It's Ed a Priori. Is it better to get blown out in the Super
- Bowl than not make the Super Bowl? No. Actually, >> I'll tell you which team I think I would
- not want to play the most right now in the AFC and that's the Houston Texans. That team has come off the mat and they
- look incredibly strong and you know, all the concerns about Straoud now seem to have gone away. Their defense is
- certainly one of the top three or four in the league. I'm just saying that's a tough out.
- >> You know who else has a great defense and their quarterback's playing out of his mind right now is Jacksonville.
- >> Well, that's another op that's like 10 and four. Like look at Lawrence's last
- few games. He's actually >> that's that was going to be my uh command. >> Oh, I didn't mean to steal your thunder.
- It's not much of a thunder, but just as a little history, Kade likes to bring up
- that when I built this model for predicting um NFL draft rank based on high school statistics, Lawrence had the
- highest number ever. Um so based on his high school, he was predicted to be and he did go first in the draft after
- college. Um but he hasn't had that great a career, but my my algorithm never said
- anything about that. That that's that that I didn't check. Um, >> well, you know, it's
- >> it would be great if, you know, we have more of these examples of guys who it
- takes a few years and and they have to overcome lots of doubts. I mean, Stout has this unbelievable rookie season and
- oh, imagine this, guys. His second season isn't as good as his first. A shocking. And so, let's not completely
- get off the bus. But what most strikes me about this conversation is that we're talking about all these exciting AFC
- teams, and we haven't even gotten to the AFC West yet. I mean, the Broncos are ridiculous. I still don't believe in
- them somehow, but they're ridiculous. And the Chargers, who I want to be great, are actually doing reasonably
- well. We're talking about six teams that we think could reasonably represent or maybe seven.
- >> Yeah, I think it is that I I think there's uh >> I mean, you know, again, if if uh it
- depends how it really kind of goes out. If if Pittsburgh sneaks into the playoffs, I'm going to I'm going to rule
- them out of the Super Bowl automatically. that's that's just their usual like 10 and seven magic or
- whatever. Um, but other than that, like I do think any one of those teams are legit kind of Super Bowl contenders. I
- think the NFC is pretty wide open as well. Uh, certainly not the teams that necessarily expected to be strong on
- that side, but you know, there's like five or six teams I could talk into the Super Bowl, I think, at least on the NFC
- side as well. >> Not the NFC South winner. I can promise you that cuz I've seen >> they are not one of the teams
- unfortunately that I >> not one of the teams. Whoever makes it from that will uh well they could win
- maybe. Let's be generous and say maybe they could win the first round game at home against maybe against Seattle.
- Maybe you know if you don't trust Darnold. No, I'm just saying. >> Yeah. Yeah. Make it I but that's it.
- They're not beating the Rams. They're not beating the Eagles. They're not beating the Lions. Whoever else up
- there. They're not beating any of those teams. What are you I was just gonna ask like Eric like kind
- of what your thoughts on like why they've been I mean I've checked in on them many times during the season
- because you know I I follow them but they seem again like um they're a frustrating team almost like the Eagles
- where I feel like even though they've had some injuries the talent is is way greater than the the outcome like I
- don't know if it's a coaching thing >> I think right now the team is uh the fans the team everybody the coaching
- that they're down on the coaching despite the fact that Todd BS has won the division This could be his fourth
- straight year winning the division, which is unheard of in the NFC South. Uh secondly, um the thing that I've been
- concerned about for the last seven weeks, as I watch every obviously every snap of all of their games, I I think
- either he's injured or he's just not playing well, Baker Mayfield is not playing well. He's missing receivers. I
- mean, he was I'm pretty sure for the first half of the season, he was the most accurate quarterback in the NFL and
- he was completing over 70% of his >> We were standing MVP at the time. I remember
- >> correct. He's not been playing well. He's been overthrowing receivers, missing open receivers, and also, by the
- way, their three most accomplished offensive players, by the way, were out for six games. I mean, Mike Evans, Chris
- Godwin, and their running back, Bucky Irving. So, let me just say let me to give him some credit. They are still
- leading the division for whatever that's worth and for literally they've I mean he's been throwing to nobody. The rookie
- Ibuka and a bunch of other guys you've never heard of for seven or eight games of the season, but no, I don't think
- Baker Mayfield is playing well. >> Yeah, I was just kind of looking at the PFF grades and he's he he does not have
- a good report there. I have to >> um anything else in the NFC that is exciting to you? I feel like there's no
- people teams just keep on not they they get a chance to really pull ahead. They don't they get knocked down. They they
- get up there and they get knocked down again. The Rams are moving again. The Seahawks are moving again. They've both
- had bad losses, but they're sitting there at 11 and three. >> I got to ask my my question all over the
- I got to ask my question again and again and again. How much is it worth to you?
- I'll ask a Starks. He's going to tell me nothing. How much is it worth to you that the Eagles are the defending Super
- Bowl champion? A number of players in their team have been to two Super Bowls. They have a
- history of success in the playoffs. They got a winning coach, etc., etc. Does that worth anything to you if the Eagles
- are playing, I don't know, the Lions, the Rams, whoever it is in the playoffs, does that move the point spread at all
- for you, you or it's not worth a thing? >> Nope. Buddy, if you had to if you had to
- >> if you had to take a side, one side or the other you had to. >> Okay. Which is the direction? Um I don't
- think it hurts. So I would I clearly would have to take the side of the the experience.
- >> I don't know. I I don't know if it's clearly or not. I think you conditional.
- One second. Conditional. >> No, you asked me clearly. You said if I had to pick a side. That's not clear in
- that you said. >> You said clearly that. >> No, I said that if I had to. No, no, no.
- The decision is clear. I didn't say that the effect size is is is >> I agree. I'd disagree with what you said
- which is that the decision is clear because >> Okay. You think I think the downside
- there's downsides to championships as well. You get complacency and cockiness and maybe a little less fire, all of
- those things. Now, if you're going to condition it on having gotten deep into the playoffs, you've obviously overcome
- some of those risks. So maybe I don't care at that point. But if you had to just if I had to pick a direction in
- general for the success of the team the next year, I would pick the short. I would pick the other side.
- >> Not to further complicate the mix, but in this uh hypothetical exercise, we're
- supposed to remember that the Eagles have won the Super Bowl twice in the last few years, but are we also supposed
- to remember that 2023 collapse that looks a lot like this one? >> Or uh can can we are we can can we
- condition on that as well? [laughter] We've got the Eagles have three games to kind of get things right. um you know if
- they're going to win the division. It looks like they're going to win the division.
- >> Well, you might even be cheering for this 2023 analogy because if I remember how that ended is they like limped into
- the playoffs and got annihilated by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. >> That is true. >> Do they do they have injuries like they
- have in 2023? >> Not as much. Well, I mean, no. No. Here it seems like the story is
- >> the weakest part of the team right now, Shane, I think you would agree, is the
- offensive line. They're not creating holes for the running back. They're not protecting Herz that well. The offensive
- line, Audi, has been banged up for the Eagles this year. But if players, I think Saquon's played almost every game.
- I think Jaylen Herz has played every game. I think >> Devontto Smith has played most games. I
- think uh AJ Brown maybe was out a game or two, but nothing lengthy. So, the answer is skilled players know, but the
- big linemen, I think that's where the injuries have happened. >> Yeah. And I mean, Go ahead, Kate. Well,
- I'm I was just No, I was just going to say that the field seems more open to me at this point than in memory. I mean, I
- think than anytime since we've been doing the show, let's put I would claim that like
- >> we still had the Mahomes cloud hanging over us this time last year. >> It opens it up. It opens it really does
- >> and the fact that the Ravens are down and the Eagles look you know less >> so many of the top like if you take the
- top eight teams say from last year and you look at how or like you know I mean are none of the AFC championship
- contenders are going to well I guess the Buffalo could still be in it but like I
- mean you know I I I feel like it's going to it's a fresh group of uh kind of teams that
- >> which makes it fun >> makes it fun. All right let's change sports. Odd, you haven't given us a
- caught your eye yet. We've got a few minutes left. What What would What do you want to claim here?
- >> Well, I what had caught my eye was the performance of Trevor Lawrence in this
- last game. I think best game is an entire career. Um, but I can move on. What's catching my eye in baseball is
- some of the new contracts. Lonzo going to the Orioles. Um, and uh, and the question that that it was that that I
- was ruminating on is how do we decide whether or not someone's getting is being over underpaid in their in their
- in their free agent contract? There's a rule of thumb that suggests that you should be paying somewhere around 8 to9
- million per war, but nobody knows how to is comfortable defining what they mean.
- Is that your past war that you should be paying or are you paying for your future
- war? And how do you determine that? >> I mean, my own opinion is it should, I guess, be some kind of future war, but
- it shouldn't be war, right? Because war again is good for comparing all players because it's compared to like a
- replacement player compared to who they could kind of bring in for from like out
- of the league, I guess, or like whatever. >> I bring that up, but hold on, Shane. I
- bring it up only because we're trying to I'm trying to answer a specific question
- which is determine whether someone's being over or underpaid. >> Yeah. No, no, no. And I'm I guess I you
- know I'm I'm I'm all for that exercise. I just you know you'd have to kind of somehow in my mind I feel like you'd
- want to look at you know what you're trying to estimate is kind of future wins above who they had or like wins
- above who they could have got. like it's wins above replacement, but it's a specific kind of when when you're
- talking about free agency signings. It's a different replace, you know, the it's
- still a concept of replacement player because it's free agent, but but you know, you have to define it very
- differently. Let me ask you, is there any reason why that's the I understand wins is sort of the goal, but isn't
- winning the World Series the goal? So, what I mean by that is let's imagine I told you right now the Colorado Rockies,
- they had the worst record, the White Socks. I just forget which one. It was the White Socks this last year. So if I
- told you the White Socks could sign Aaron Judge and you're saying it's based on Warat 8 or N million. So 90 million a
- year they're going to pay Aaron Judge for the next 5 years. They're going to pay him $450 million for 5 years. But we
- know there's no chance they're winning the or not no chance very low. >> You you can't use probability winning
- the World Series for evaluating a single player transaction because even Aaron Judge on a bad team isn't going to move
- the needle. So my my point was is that the value of a player economically should relate to to what team is he
- going to? >> Yeah. Yeah. >> That's what I was kind of getting. >> Premium that you that the rich that the
- good teams have to pay to get those extra value and they'll pay it because they need it to get over that hump.
- Exactly. >> I think 538 back in Neil Payne when he was doing his uh his uh hot uh takedown
- show, I don't know if you ever listened to that back then. um they had this metric where they would you'd pay this
- extra penalty that you'd have to in dollars in order to secure the players um at the top. Um and it's a it's a it's
- well you know you can calibrate it and calculate it and it's it is a bonus. Um >> by the way when you say um judge if you
- were to pay jud judge for the next five years you wouldn't do it at nine war. That might be I wouldn't say he's going
- to deliver nine war for five years. I' I'd say five or six would be a good average for the next five years. As a
- statistician, as a Yankee fan, of course, it's nine. >> Yeah. Well, that's getting to the future
- versus retrospective aspect of >> Guys, I want to I want to I had a conversation this past week that is is
- on point here and I I want and y'all y'all will find it interesting and and it's also um
- I'm curious your thoughts on it. So, the Cubs World Series year, >> remind me of the closer they traded for
- at the deadline. His name Cubs. Was that when they got Chapman? >> Yeah. >> Okay. Okay. So, that was an analytically
- savvy staff. And let's just say that let's say that they were calculating the change in win
- probability with that signing and they had a very specific sense of what that was. What do you think their starting
- win probability was without that? And we don't we don't we don't need all the details. They were having a good season,
- but they're like trying to take a good season to just a little more likely because because of what Eric says. What
- we care about is winning the championship. So, what do you think they're starting? What do you think they
- had their internally estimated when the win the World Series probability before and after that signing?
- If you just had to guess, just ballpark. There's no like um I'm going to guess like a 5% difference or something like
- that in the >> No, it couldn't be that big. Must be smaller than that. That was an internal
- measurement. Do you know the answer to this? This is >> Let's say I know the answer. Let's just
- assume. >> Let's say he knows the answer. Um I would say that the increment is probably in the realm of 2% or so.
- That would be my guess. >> I would have guessed. I was my intuition would have told me. Let me ask you a
- question to calibrate us all. Let's suppose I go back to the late 90s and I tell you I'm going to take Mariano
- Rivera off the Yankees >> and I'm going to put in some good but not above average but not exceptional
- closure. I would think that would have affected the Yankees winning by at least 5%. I I I agree.
- >> Well, no. Chapman for short periods can be as good as Mariano was for 15 consecutive years.
- >> Somehow for the consistency that's what cost you the money. That's what gives you that probability that the
- Ram >> he was that was that was good Chapman era. Remember he was he >> 5%. >> I mean Audi you guys you guys got the
- worst of Chapman. He's actually been a very consistent pitcher over most of his career. Um
- >> I'm traumatized by Chapman. >> [laughter] >> He doesn't pitch as well when they know
- what's coming, bro. >> Okay, so >> anyway, I could imagine something like that. >> Come on, give us the answer. Yeah,
- >> this is an internal question, not the right answer. It's what they thought. >> Let's say they thought it was 4%. Uh,
- and it was from 21 to 25. >> Yeah. >> And I think it's >> You say 20 to 25. And I I think the
- analogy here is is the what the Dodgers did this very recently which is basically took a team that already has
- probably a pretty high comfort chance to win the World Series as high as it can already be um and added the top closer
- in the game which was their team weakness which was their team weakness >> in the PL previous season and the
- playoffs. So my actual now I don't remember the season in all its details but I would have suggested the same
- percentage change in the win probability 20%. And uh but I had it down at much lower.
- I would have guessed that the Cubs lower season at half that. Yeah. >> Well it was a very good team and I I to
- me it's it I had I had zero calibration for any of these numbers and it's about these front office decisions because
- they make this major trade decision. They already got a strong team. The question is when you've got a strong
- team, is that the time to kind of push in your chips a little further to increase the chance of actually winning
- the championship? Yes. >> But if you do that, what are you actually doing? You're only moving at
- 4%. It's like, wow, that that the big move to really capitalize on the momentum is to move it from 21 to 25.
- >> Wow. >> And that's about right. >> Paid off. In this case, it paid off. All right. Good fun, guys. Why don't we wrap
- it there then? We will come back and do another show next week. Oh, we're moving
- into the 23rd. Are we going to do a show on the 23rd? That's an open question. We
- will revisit that offline and come back. We'll probably do something next week in
- some form, but we're nearing the end of the year, which is stunning. Um, thanks for the whole team here. On behalf of
- Shane Jensen, on behalf of Audi Wer, on behalf of Eric Bradlo, many thanks to Dion Simpkins, to Dion Patel, to Marissa
- Raina, to the whole team who supports us. We appreciate it. And to you guys for listening, come back and join us
- next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Bill Connley discusses college football playoffs, team matchups, and analytics on Wharton Moneyball.
Key points
- Introduction to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics on the Wharton podcast.
- Bill Connley Joins the Show. Bill Connley joins to discuss college football playoffs and preview upcoming games.
- JMU vs. Oregon Preview. Bill discusses the potential for JMU to compete against Oregon in the playoffs.
- Alabama vs. Oklahoma Rematch. Analyzing the rematch between Alabama and Oklahoma and the stakes involved.
- Alabama's Struggles. Alabama is currently lost and unsure about their offensive strategy.
- Miami vs. A&M Preview. The first game of Saturday is a must-watch playoff matchup at Kyle Field.
Episode highlights
- Bill Connley Joins the ShowBill Connley joins to discuss college football playoffs and preview upcoming games.“Bill, welcome in. Good to see you.”0:56Dec 18, 2025
- JMU vs. Oregon PreviewBill discusses the potential for JMU to compete against Oregon in the playoffs.“I think it can absolutely be a competitive game.”8:21Dec 18, 2025
- Alabama vs. Oklahoma RematchAnalyzing the rematch between Alabama and Oklahoma and the stakes involved.“Neither one of these teams is gonna make a long run in the playoffs.”13:35Dec 18, 2025
- Alabama's StrugglesAlabama is currently lost and unsure about their offensive strategy.“They don’t know how they’re going to move the ball.”16:22Dec 18, 2025
- Miami vs. A&M PreviewThe first game of Saturday is a must-watch playoff matchup at Kyle Field.“This is going to be a playoff game there. Are you kidding me?”17:40Dec 18, 2025
- Unpredictable TeamsBoth Miami and A&M are inconsistent, making their matchup unpredictable.“If you tell me either team won by 28 points, I’ll believe you immediately.”18:04Dec 18, 2025
- 15 Years Without Brady or MahomesThe AFC Championship game hasn't featured either star quarterback in 15 years.“Is this the 15 year?”32:21Dec 18, 2025
- Josh Allen's Pressure to PerformWith Mahomes absent, the pressure mounts on Josh Allen to lead the Bills to success.“It’s a crime against humanity if he doesn’t get into the Super Bowl.”41:11Dec 18, 2025





