Baseball Analytics, NFL Parity, and College Football Playoff Odds
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Professors and Moneyball hosts Cade Massey, Adi Wyner, Eric Bradlow, and Shane Jensen dig into baseball’s offseason, new defensive metrics like outs above average, and what analytics reveal about fielding and player value. They talk about the growing sense of parity across the NFL, how uncertainty shapes power rankings, and whether analytics are making teams more alike. Towards the end of the episode, they discuss college football, debating playoff odds, strength of schedule, and which programs still have a path to the title.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#SportsAnalytics #BaseballAnalytics #FootballAnalytics #FootballStats #SportsScience #CollegeFootballPlayoff ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
- network. This is Kade Massie hosting today with the whole crew. Audi Winer is here, Eric Bradlo is here, Shane Jensen
- is here, and to add a little flavor, we are sitting in person in the Wharton podcast network studio. Our longtime
- home for years, our home for this show, and we're delighted to be not only in studio, but in person. something we only
- get to pull off, I don't know, once or twice a year for the last couple years since CO hit. It's been only once or
- twice a year. I would say we're looking out onto Penn's famous Locust Walk, but the studio is now kind of a video
- studio. So, we've got lights and the windows pulled and we could be anywhere really, but we have good sound, good
- video, and most importantly, we are all together. We are recording on Tuesday afternoon as we typically do. The show
- will go up on Wednesday. In this week's show, we are just gonna roll tape and talk about what caught our eye around
- the world of sports. We're gonna take advantage of being together and not have a guest, just find out where people are,
- what they're listening to, what they're paying attention to. >> Gentlemen, good to see you in person.
- >> Good to see you as well. How about that? >> It's been too long being uh kind of in
- the same physical space with each other. >> We, you know, we cross paths. We do every now and then see each other, but
- we don't get to record the show together. And in fact, Dion Simpkins, our longtime technical producer,
- associate producer of the show, is in house with us, which is also a delight. The whole crew is actually here. D
- Patel, the big boss. Aaron, the video producer. We've got more team members out there. It kind of takes a village,
- as D says, it takes a village surprisingly so to make this thing run. Gentlemen, where are we in the sports
- calendar? We are football season's getting mature. >> It feels like football weather out
- there. Certainly here in Philadelphia. Yeah. >> Phillyy's finally feeling like 12.
- >> I have to announce it's hot stove season. >> Oh gosh. >> Oh yeah. >> Which I just recently learned what what
- it refers to. It was it was the cold weather. Everyone would gather around a hot stove in the off season and talk
- baseball. >> Okay. >> And around and so we called hot stove season because there was no other
- sports. Historically baseball was the only substantive professional sport in America until about the 60s really. And
- then hot stove season was just what you do. gather around the hot stove in the cold winter months and talk baseball.
- >> You know, I I associate it with trades and front office transactions, but you're saying it's just like people
- >> anything that happens in the offseason is called the hot stove season. >> Okay. I haven't heard that phrase in a
- while. >> Where does Canada come from? Do you know that? Cuz that would that's a baseball
- one. I think it's like Yeah. Something I mean as far as these like you know, you
- know, I feel like >> so much of baseball's contributions to society sound like they came from like
- the 50s or something like that. But I think this is like >> 1950s. Yeah. But like I think this is one where it's
- like um I don't know. I I actually don't know. Somebody described to me it's like
- based on like you know how the stock boys used to like stalk the corn. It would fall off the sh like a can of corn
- and it's like kind of an easy fly ball or whatever. >> Yeah. Easy ground ball something easy
- that you know somehow it was based on like how the cans of corn fell off the I don't know. Somebody should look this up
- for us. >> Anyway, so I have my hot stove uh analyses to talk about. >> Oh. All right. Well, we let's just pitch
- it around and see where people are. Maybe we can do a few rounds of this. We'll go to the bottom of the hour, take
- a break, come back and wrap up with the second half of the show, but let's start
- off. Who's got something? Who's cut what's cut your eye in the world of sports? Audi W.
- >> I will I will do uh the the gold gloves came out. So, I don't need to dissect
- who won the gold glove here and there. That's all fun and but I want I want to get into that. What struck me is they're
- using now combination of analytics with basically the usual people's opinions. I
- think it's still 75% opinions and 25% the numbers. What numbers they use are outs above average and defensive run
- saves. >> Like is it is it kind of a public formula or is it kind of average out
- above average is not a public underlying formula. >> So you're saying it's not only 75 25 but
- of the 25 there are known weights component. >> Well and it depends on on the position.
- So catchers did not use outs above average they use a variety of pass ball saved. uh um runners caught above
- expectation, but it's the usual statistical stuff that's now really made its way into the Golden Glove um metric.
- So, I guess Derek Jeter probably would never have gotten one at the at, you know,
- >> the fans would have been so well. I mean, I get it 75% like humans still voting on it. He probably still Jeter
- outs above expected. My memory of the knock on his fielding was that he made easy plays look hard because he didn't
- have much range, >> right? So he he not only made easy pays look hard, >> uh he didn't have he wasn't prone for
- error. So he's can of corn he was fine with um he just didn't get to the center very well up the middle and this was
- before they would move the the player. So >> and the analytics would pick up on that
- now. Yes, >> they would recognize his limited range. I mean the average Shorstop would have
- gotten to that. >> Absolutely. I think he he was one that kind of he was an example. Mike L also
- in Boston I think was like this as well where he was very sure hand like he like
- on the plays where you saw him made he made an excellent play on. I see. He just didn't.
- >> It's just that there's this hidden denominator of plays that he couldn't make that he didn't, you know, wasn't
- two feet from in the factor and another player would have. >> Let me ask you a question then.
- >> Discretion is the better part of Valor. He's just living out the practical philos.
- So, let's assume he knows this at some level because he is a professional player. Did he for example, this would
- be a natural reaction. You move farther back on the field to give you more angle
- and you strengthen your arm. So that did he does anybody know cuz if I was talking to him those would be the things
- I know. >> I mean unfortunately he like you know I mean I I if if he played now we'd have
- the date on this and I because I mean he played most of his career kind of pre the big shifting crazy
- >> right way before the shift crazy. So which is interesting because today I still my reaction to a hard shot up the
- middle is a hit and I'm still not converted that to an out which is almost it's almost always an out now. It's it's
- it's it's terrifying because those were were hits. >> Let me ask another question. Do you know
- did the Yankees do whether it was cashman during most of that time did the Yankees do any I'll call it portfolio
- optimization which is look they can see that Jeter can't do that well moving to I guess his left get balls up the middle
- we got to get a second basement with range and maybe we'll trade that off for a little bit of
- >> back we we saw we saw what they they got a third they got a one of the best shorts stops in the field they actually
- traded for >> Yeah and they made him at third base >> but then they put him at third base I
- mean so they I mean they brought they actually brought in the personel how to correct the issue.
- >> You know, I'm not going to get all this, but Yankees were never known for particularly emphasizing fielding. So,
- what the other thing that I wanted to point out about the gold gloves now that they have these numbers, announce them.
- So, the the major one is outs above average, which is an MLB creation using their proprietary data, which knows
- where the fielders are standing at the time of the hit and how far exactly the trajectory of the ball. So, what they
- essentially calculate is the probability of an average player making that play and with what probability.
- >> Okay, but hold on. that doesn't give the player credit or debits for positioning.
- >> It does not. As far as I know, it does not. Okay? >> And this isn't this is a So, in other
- words, it doesn't do that. And that's a major concern. There's also I have other
- major concerns. For one thing, outfielders are all treated as in one bucket. So, outfielders are all the same
- in terms of their ability to to make plays. And so, center fielders are fantastic and right and left tend to be
- pretty weak because >> the center fields are much faster. So an average outfielder, some mixture of a
- corner outfield and center. >> And I assume they do that structurally on the other side of things cuz like you
- know if you know a particular outfield is like moving around the out like you know differentiate you have to be tough
- to kind of grade them. >> So I've actually dealt and played around with this model and it's hard to you
- can't reconstruct it yourself because I don't have the starting position of the player. Now we could do what what we
- used to do which was we never would take that into account and we would just what
- when Shane and I we wrote a paper years ago uh using much more coarse data. We just look at the trajectory of the ball
- and we would say what's the average probability or what's the distribution. >> So either positioning or range would
- kind of confound those two together. >> Well, let me build on Kad's point though, which is if I'm trying to
- evaluate a player, you could argue it's a combination of positioning plus range.
- The reason only reason I'd want to decompose it is if I want to improve the player or to possibly manage the player
- in some way. But from a pure evaluation point of view, I don't know that that confound matters. Well, before the team
- got involved with positioning, it didn't matter. But now it matters. >> The team does you can see them out there
- with >> the positioning. You can apply across any players, right? >> I didn't say it doesn't matter for
- improving team outcome. I said it might not matter for evaluation. Meaning if I'm a player and I illosition myself, I
- should get knocked for that as part of the total value of fielding >> back in the day. For sure.
- >> Yeah. Yeah. And I mean I I totally agree. I feel like even even now if you kind of wanted an omnibus idea of their
- fielding, it would be fine to confound those two together. That's my >> point. And it must be the case also that
- the team when it's choosing optimum positioning >> knows the range of the players. So now
- we've got another little wrinkle in there like even they're going to prescribe different ranges for different
- people. They should and they'll give the more talented players more range to cover.
- >> Yeah. This is by this is this is historical. I mean, if you look, um, the in the old days, the center fielder had
- a lot of stature. The the other corner outfielders would back off and he'd get all these extra plays because he was the
- the star. >> Is that right? >> And not not so much anymore. Now they work about work at much more
- collectively. I mean, this is a big big daily task of the analytic staff to tell
- their outfielders how to be positioned for every player on the opposition. Produc optimally position the center
- fielder without knowing the optimal center, >> right? They do this for all the and this
- is a major task of the of the staff that travels with the team to produce a report tell them where to stand not only
- where to stand I mean how to like find landmarks in the ballpark to help them find their spot because there's no grid
- right so they have to like say you have to be here by the way the coaches do this too I just found this out from
- >> yeah you can see them kind of shoeing people over >> they move them over and you have to find
- sight lines and you can do this really well at your home ballpark because you're used to it you have a much harder
- time at the away >> ball park you get any sense cuz we all know fielders reposition themselves
- based on the batter. Do we have any ability to know that batters have the ability to hit differentially depending
- on who's fielding? Do we have any knowledge of whether they're able to? >> So, this is a big deal. Most most people
- would say no. We'd have to bring in a player or a coach to to tell us that some of the absolute best players were
- able to do that. It was no question um that the tremendous hitters of yester year were had that ability. I mean, one
- tool I think that even current players are underutilizing is the bunt. I would like to see the bunt make a big comeback
- because I do feel like >> you like an article. >> I mean, no, I mean, you know, you can
- personalize the bunt strategy, you know, if you wanted to. Manny Ramirez isn't doing it or something like that. But no,
- I mean, I I when I was over in Japan watching baseball games, bunting is just a way bigger part of the game because
- they it's I think there's more of a focus just on kind of run generation and stuff like that and and moving people
- over and stuff like that. But it's also like I I think against some of these more extreme shifts, I mean, you can
- kind of see if if if you could just put a a bunt down the third baseline, often the third baseman's like, you know,
- halfway to second or something like that. It's like an easy if if you can execute that. Yeah.
- >> Then it's basically an Let me get to my my point. They have this thing called
- outs above average. >> And what struck me is they calculate this. It's all relative to your predict
- position, but the outfield is thought of as one position. What struck me as the the Gold Glove leaders at the corner out
- outfields are smaller than centerfield and smaller than and centerfield is about the same size as shortstop. But
- I'm going to ask a question. How many outs above average do you think the gold glove winners are are making or earning
- whatever the statistics per what? >> It's over the course of the season. It's not on a per basis. It's outs above
- average. I'm not sure what the magnitude is, but I bet you it's about a quarter of what the you like the the top 10%
- fielder is about a quarter like away like in terms of runs I think adding to his team compared to hitting.
- >> All right. So >> that that would be my I'm giving you a relative you're you're on the right
- ballpark but what and I was actually struck by it. I thought I'll give you my hint. I thought it was fairly low.
- >> Um I thought fielding would matter. >> Yeah. What do you think out? So, it's outs above average AC across the season.
- Okay. >> For which which group that >> So, start with center field. Center I'll give you a hint. Centerfield and
- shortstop are about the same. And the leaders are um the center fielders are uh uh Armstrong um what's his name? Um
- Peter Armstrong um what's his last name? Uh >> PR Prow. >> Pico Armstrong. He was he he won the
- gold glove in center. Um Bobby Witer didn't win it, but he was right up there second. I mean, roughly I'm expecting
- this to be two standard deviations or something. I mean, just >> Well, it's remember it's it's it's it's
- not a rate stat. It's it's a total stat. >> Yeah. So, I'm going to guess >> I mean, you can just throw out numbers.
- I can just tell you. We can end our suspense. >> My my initial guess was some total outs,
- right? >> Total outs above average. >> I was going to guess somewhere around eight. Eight to 10
- >> over a season. >> I'll tell you why I came up with that number. So, this is just bad math, but
- but it's rough math. Give us No, I'm going to tell you how I thought about it. So there's 27 outs in a game. Y okay
- let's pret. It's a bad assumption. Let's just say you uniformly distribute that amongst the nine players. That means
- each player makes three outs, >> which is not true. >> I didn't say it was true. And now I'm
- thinking of a percentage of that number of outs that I think they're going to make an incremental play. And then when
- they do make one, how many outs do they actually save in terms of a probability or expectation? That was the calculation
- that got me to somewhere around 8 to 10. >> All right. So, corner outfield. That's
- exactly right. The leaders corner outfield uh short stop. Uh no, sorry. Corner outfield, first base are right around
- that mark. Nine, eight, eight to 10. >> Out, uh center fielders are 20 to 24 and
- short stops around the same amount. >> By the way, they get more. It's fascinating. That was my upper bound. I
- would have I was thinking my two numbers were in 8 to 10 or in the low 20s. >> Good job. Good job. What what I was
- talking about is like, you know, you take like like the 90th percentile fielder versus the median fielder. That
- difference, I think, is about a quarter what the difference would be for the 90th hitter versus the I think fielding
- is maybe like a good way of thinking. We can work it out. So, so here's the problem. How do you convert outs into
- runs and then runs we convert into wins? The usual number for runs into runs into
- war would be 10. 10 runs above replacement, but these are outs above average. But anyway, but Fielding is
- roughly is fine. We don't have this this I think the average replacement. >> By the way, this is the wonderful thing
- about this show for 11 plus years is that I know in the instantaneous second I had to think about it. I was thinking
- about that route. The problem is I didn't know how to compute go outs to runs runs to war. I could have asked you
- and you would have told me. I didn't know how to do that first step. So I abandoned that route just cuz I don't
- know how to do that. >> The thing is I don't never thought about outs to runs. So, I'm just kind of
- guessing that an outs to runs is something like a quarter maybe of of each out is about a quarter.
- >> Well, we know the following, Audi. We know how many runs are scored in a game,
- which is about four and a half, right? And so, 27 outs. So, maybe it's about 0.15.
- >> So, that's that. So, the thing is an extra out. It all depends on where it is
- in the inning, right? So, the first outro, >> yeah, you're doing if you want to do a
- context, I would go for 0.15. 0.15. And so if you do that then you then you're 20 times point you're you're not looking
- at very many runs. What are we looking at? We're looking at five tops. No less than that. Three to four runs. We're
- looking at we're looking at about not even a third of a win >> and added by the best fielder seemed
- low. Yeah, that does seem low because again like you know I'm thinking of like you know somebody like the best heel
- hitters are giving you like say like six wins above replacement or something like
- that. >> This was a very long critique of their criteria >> but not their defensive war. Their
- defensive war is typically around two, right? >> Yeah. No, I'm kind of like I'm saying
- like somebody like you know like like let's assume it's almost all offensive at the same
- the best would be like this is above average. So average is effectively the me the middle and war is above the
- replacement. >> But I think your logic is like for fielding at least >> replacement but no but I think
- replacement fielders are average close up to average. But you this is a long way of saying you don't love the
- sophistication of their defensive metric. Okay fine. Let me add some more superficial evaluations to this. I
- somewhere in my social media feed in the last couple weeks I saw a clip on Greg Maddox as a fielder.
- >> Y'all know these things. I don't know these things. 14 gold gloves or something.
- >> 14 gold gloves as a fielder and they they were showing highlights of him fielding and he was like wildly athletic
- as a pitcher making all these plays. It was really spectacular. I had no idea. I
- don't think of Maddox as seeming like that athletic of a guy, but apparently >> you might also think not necessarily
- correlate, but someone that's wildly athletic might be able to pitch more than 90 miles an hour. But but I'm
- saying it turns out there might not be I mean >> well >> I'm just saying you would think he
- therefore might have pitched harder than >> I don't Well, he's an averagesized guy.
- Maybe he's a great athlete with an average size. >> Pedro and Pedro threw real hard.
- >> Right. By the way, on this topic, who are some of the canonical great center fielders from a defensive perspective?
- >> Andrew Jones kind of when I was sort of paying attention in the early 2000s, I
- think was like that. Andrew Jones, Andrew Jones, especially moving in >> ridiculous.
- >> Well, we talking about historically like Willie Mays was thought of as one of the
- great center fielders. >> Is that not because of the one catch? I mean, there were other things that he
- did. I mean that's I you know we that's very so salient. So that's the first verse I come up with.
- >> But who else? Just give me >> without a question. >> Was considered also extraordinarily uh
- graceful. He made things look incredibly easy. Okay. >> Um >> Ken Griffy >> Ken um and when he was in the original
- >> Well, Trout was a great centerfielder when he first came up. And >> Jim Edmonds was also great early career.
- >> Yeah, Jim Edmonds was really great. >> I don't even know Jim Edmonds. >> Paul Blair was the name I was thinking.
- >> Paul Blair was crazy. I remember. Who did Edmonds and Blair play? Well, Edwards played for the Cardinals mostly
- >> and Angels for part of his career and Paul Blair played for the Yankees like Yankees 2000 to 2015. I guess
- >> I think there was a time between a little earlier maybe between grad school and arriving here. I didn't pay
- attention to baseball in grad school. My adviser George Woo had me paying some attention to baseball and when I got
- here I got around you guys. I started paying attention again. But I think there was like a 12 year window where I
- didn't Okay, let's that's a good one. Odd, but let's keep going. Who's got another caught your eye? Shane Jensen.
- Well, uh, I guess I I should talk about the fact that the Patriots are eight and
- two. >> Well, just a surp We do we do have to talk about we we've been putting it off
- because we've been keep saying, "Oh, they're not they haven't been playing any good teams. They haven't been doing
- and now they they finally mean they played two good teams now. Um, and they've won it both." So, and they beat
- the entire NFC South this season. Isn't that fun? >> That's >> And the two teams they beat, by the way,
- they beat on the road. >> Yeah. >> So, that is not easy. They beat the Bills and the Bucks both on the road.
- >> Although, hold on a second. Hasn't homefield advantage become a lesser thing over the years?
- >> It has become a lesser thing. The gamblers have pointed this out that it's just monotonically decreased over the
- last 10 15 years. And it used to be three points. Everyone thought it was three points and then we started
- thinking maybe it's 2.25 but actually it's lower than that. It's less than two is the there obviously is differential
- home field advantage. I know it's not that much. >> No, a differential home field advantage
- is overrated, >> right? No, but I was going to ask very little predictive value. Well, what I
- was going to ask was if you for worse teams, is it harder for them? Like for example, the fact that the Patriots have
- won two road games against two really strong teams. Is that worth more than let's say a weaker team going on the
- road? >> Yeah. In our conversation is that a worse team would struggle more on the
- road. >> Correct. >> I think or at least that's kind of the hypothesis. >> Why I'm not following this for some
- reason. What's the hypothesis >> that to the extent that there is heterogeneity in terms across teams in
- terms of how they would play on the road that a worse teams would be >> you talking about interaction between
- being on the road and quality? I don't think that exists. No. >> Do you think I mean you would agree that
- an intera like a weather stadium interaction exists or something like that that or a stad a weather home team
- interaction exists? >> Uh there that's been studied and there may be some. It's not as much as you
- think. There's an east coast, west coast thing and there's a division thing and this is something that jumps out to me
- like the Dolphins beat the Bills this time. >> Yeah, >> it's surely the case. I think that I
- know that home field is less for division games, >> which is interesting. >> Is it because they travel less on
- average? >> No, but I think it's because they just every every year they're there. Um, and
- that's not the case at all. This is football. This is football. But I wonder if there's not more than that. If it's
- more than just homefield, like in general, power rankings matter less among division rivals.
- >> Yeah. >> Does anybody know, did you look how much did the Pats go up in the power
- rankings? My guess is not a lot for winning this game. >> I haven't actually checked as of
- yesterday, but but before this one in the Bucks game, I was marveling that they were kind of they were in like
- still like around the median basically and they had the for a while there up until last week FBI had I think the
- Giants above the Patriots. >> The Giants were above the Patriots. We talked about this on the show. But
- again, the New York Giants are talking above the New York Giants. Correct. We're above FBI, I think, has a big
- correction for strength of schedule, which the pads do have again on where they need.
- >> I don't know if FBI FBI is not the end all be all, but historically it's been
- decent, but they are right now number four in FBI >> and they've moved a lot. >> So, they might have moved a lot, but
- they're sitting. Let me just review these for you because it is interesting and and it's hard for me to keep track
- of the NFL this year. It just seems wonky. Eagles number one, Rams, Colts, Pats, Colts, Pats, three, four, Seahawks
- five. The three the middle three, four, five is Colts, Pats, Seahawks. Then Lions, Bills, Bucks. Those not
- surprising, but Colts, Pat, Seahawks. >> That's very throwback power rank. >> And by the way, you still you still
- haven't mentioned the Chiefs. >> The Chiefs are below that. I don't care who they're going to be
- much better. >> I don't care where they are in the power rankings. They're going to be in the AFC
- Championship. >> Well, that's a different matter. And if you want to talk about it, I did run a
- sim off of unabated and I used inpredictables power rankings which are marketbased and they decay and they
- estimate the decay optimal for predictive power. So >> supposed quarterback and all that other
- stuff. >> So and injured quarterbacks and this is this is so this is marketbased power
- rankings run through the unabated sim which has a lot of >> question. You're just going to tell us
- the results. >> Well, let's do some questions. That's a good idea. Who do you who do you think's
- top in both conferences for winning the conference? And what do you think the what do you think the highest Super Bowl
- probability is here after what is it 10 weeks of play? >> I think it's probably the Chiefs. I
- think I'm cheating because I think I saw that they're still the Super Bowl favorites on most of the
- >> They are top AFC. >> They are top AFC. I was going to say that's >> but not the Super Bowl faves at this
- point. >> Oh, is it the Eagles? >> Eagles number one right now. So, but oh, I just told you the numbers. So, it's
- 13.8% 14% likely to win the Super Bowl is tops. The Rams, another NFC team, >> is right behind them at 12.
- >> And what I'm a little surprised by is that they're given, you know, between the two, they're given half the
- probability of winning the NFC. So, does that how does that feel? The Eagles and
- Rams 50, who do you want, Eagles and Rams or the rest of the NFC to make the Super Bowl?
- >> Oh, to make the Super Bowl? >> To make the Super Bowl. Eagles and Rams or everybody else?
- >> I think there's I think I would probably take the Eagles and the Rams because the
- only other teams that I think are highly highly competitive in the NFC. I think the Lions definitely have to be
- considered a serious threat. >> Yeah. >> Other than that, I don't see any >> The Bucks I think can belong in that
- conversation. I mean, with a little bit more health, you know. >> Well, that's >> I mean I mean I don't know. I I I guess
- an optimistic view of the Bucks would have them in that conversation. If you're telling me that by the end of the
- season, >> Mike Evans, Chris Godwin, >> Bucky Irving, all of their and they've got Igbuka who's turned out is going to
- be the rookie of the year probably. If they have all of that offensive power, then they have an opportunity, but
- they're not better than those other three teams. >> And I think I I might be with Eric. I
- think I might. Rams Eagles, I think I might. >> Okay. So, the model gives them 47%
- total. So, it's about >> I was going to go with the with the field only because I love the field.
- >> We always bet. always make a field. So just cuz I feel overestimate >> say 50 years from now will you hope when
- you're dead on your tombstone >> it says no we'll be looking at the results be like a the field one finally won the
- Super Bowl audi's happy >> so Eric's intuition was very good the next NFC team is Detroit and it's at 17%
- to make the uh to make the Super Bowl and then a big drop and after that so who you're missing between the Lions and
- the Bucks because there's a bunch of them who you're missing is Seahawks at 13% % to make the Super Bowl. Packers
- who didn't look great last night, 11% to make the Super Bowl. >> And I think I think we're questioning
- like I mean you react to the Seahawks and I think we're reacting like I would say react to the Pats and Colts the same
- way. It's like we have a lot of teams where I think there's higher uncertainty because they really are kind of
- mismatching our priors coming into the season. Like the Colts are are look like I mean if you just looked at this season
- you're like oh these guys are like you know a powerhouse or whatever. But you know it's like you knew where they were.
- Same with the stats and you're unabated. You use power ranks that you've estimated somehow.
- >> We grab them from anywhere. So you can load in, you can put your own grab somebody else,
- >> right? Do you add a probability distribution on the power ranks, a posterior probability?
- >> No, but we we put uncertainty into the Sims. >> And how do you do that? Specifically, we
- simulate the outcome of a game >> and then you add that into and we update the >> I should at a future date I will we'll
- report the results of a study that one of my students did to compare >> putting a posterior on the on the
- parameters which you don't do versus adding the the noise into the through the simulation.
- It's it's an interesting result and it is as I expected >> but the trick is you need the the the
- course to be to to match and so you want to update as you go. So you need find to
- put a poster I mean >> you should take a draw you should have a you should have a prior
- >> you have to draw the next observation and add that simulation error. Yeah. >> The each week has to build on the
- outcome. have to put the outcome of the well the answer is techically no if you simulated an infinite number of
- games in any given week then in theory the theta the parameter and y would give the same amount of information. The
- problem is most sims aren't doing it that way but if you did it that way you should get the same answer. In other
- words whether you're doing >> well >> infinite simul not the same thing and not even close. Well, let's we I'll be
- interested in the paper to see how how often it is, but often when you're running sims like that, you want to know
- a lot of internal metrics like what happened, how often it happens, that kind of thing. And so, you need a
- realistic path through the sim. >> But let's just be clear, what I'm separating out is taking no at
- >> there's two forms of infinity I'm talking about. One is I do your forward simulation an infinite number of times,
- but that's not the one I'm talking about. I'm talking about between week t and t plus one. I do an infinite number
- and then average that to even move on. >> You can't run those sims. So you're not
- can theoretic theoretically can but you're like you like unabated is anybody can log on here and get a 10,000 SIM
- while they wait for it and you just can't you can't do that with that. Anyway, let's at least celebrate that
- there is uncertainty baked in because you you baked it in. Most of the problems are that people don't and by
- the way to be clear there's a >> I don't know how this one's done but in general when Massie Peabody does it we
- have a prior and we we're going to draw from that prior initially. >> Yes. >> Right. So that you're not going to get
- you're not going to say everybody starts at this number. It's like we we that's the expectation but they might get a
- different number even. >> So the reason why I brought it up is that NFL this year does seem to have
- more uncertainty in the rankings the power rankings than traditionally. I mean, in other words, if you put in
- typically what you do is you put in two power ranks and outcomes a probability of victory. That's usually a logistic
- function of some kind. What's happening this year is it seems to be that that spread in the power ranking is not
- matching the usual probability that comes out of it. >> Yeah. I mean, I mean, >> it's a scale factor.
- >> I I don't know. I mean, you could you could see right my hypothesis is that like there's more of a truncation in
- that. I think most power rankings when we think about park power ranking consistency, we're really thinking about
- like the top 10. I mean, who really cares about the 10th team versus the 20th team or something like that? And
- the top 10, I think because I think things have kind of truncated, we don't have enough like I I I think there's not
- a lot of standout. >> And so I think our we've got let me draw an analogy between what AI
- is saying and my you know what I spent 20 years on in an educational testing. So I've got a ability parameter of a
- person and I've got a difficulty parameter of an item. There's a distance between the two. If you want in your
- language, there's two teams and I take the difference between the two. But there's another parameter which is a
- slope parameter that multiplies that difference. That's called an item discrimination parameter. Some items
- have a steeper slope or what we might call in statistics factor loading on true ability than others. What Audi's
- saying is if my guess is if you did a time series of that that discrimination is going down, which means the ability
- of strength parameters to predict outcomes is getting worse. Why would that be going down?
- >> There's not as much. So that's a different question about as to why, but I'm guessing the empirical result. Well,
- a couple reason. I'll give you a couple reasons. One reason is there's error in the estimates
- of those. So that could be one possible reason. >> Of course raises the question of why
- that would be. >> Another possibility is that's possible, but the error, the stochastic error that
- I'm drawing on each game is going up. So that's flattening the distribution of probabilities. That's another possible
- reason. So it's not that measured. It's not that your game itself has changed. >> You can you can argue this and there are
- new rule changes and it does look like it makes an impact. I watched so many punts yesterday. I'm sick of it. But
- they land in different spots. >> I assume by the way in Elo models or the type of paired comparison models I know
- in marketing we can do this. You can estimate that scale factor. And so >> you could probably answer it
- empirically. Does it appear that the stochasticity of games is going >> but we would have to see it over
- multiple years of course just to put it straight straight in front of you. Let's
- put it in football language. An 8-2 team with a certain win differential might not be the same and from year to year
- >> possibly but Shane but Shane that's underlying both of the whole thing >> but Shane has a more parsimmonious
- explanation I think or at least hypothesis. >> Sure that there's Go ahead. Well, no,
- that well think >> that yeah, that that I think we we tend to when we think about consistency
- across year to year, we're really kind of thinking about the top teams. And I do think that there's this year it seems
- like, you know, the top teams don't seem to stand out as much in my mind as as you know the other ones. I I I think
- there's more parody I think like say 1 to 10. I know that usual. I think this is my thought is
- that conceptually this scale factor is meant to be invariant to the locations of the teams on that scale. Conceptually
- it's meant to be. >> Okay. Interesting. All right. Well, estimate the scale factors please and
- report to us. >> It just has to do with these this distribution of the probabilities and
- why but but but Eric has offer Eric has asked the question is it changing over time systematically in one direction? I
- think that's fair. >> And I'm wondering if there's a mechanism and just you more afficados of the game.
- I I notice the game looks different. >> Just there's more >> a hell of a lot more gambling on it than
- there used to be. I don't want to be like cynical, but maybe that's the stoastic element we're looking for is
- gambling. >> Clearly more uh kick returns. I mean, that's a huge >> I'll give you two I'll give it one you
- gave, which is rule changes could change that. Here's another one. This is the classic uh parody argument. Everyone I'm
- making this up, but not entirely. Everyone's using analytics today and what that's causing it's causing a
- compression >> and that compression is actually going to cause this scale. I'm just coming up
- with theory. I like the theory. I like it's possible that theories the style of play has homogenized. Correct.
- >> That's another possibility. >> Maybe analytics related. It was very entertaining last night when they were
- when they were going for it at midfield at fourth and 20 or fourth and whatever.
- And uh and that's an obvious I mean not that's such an it's an obvious analytics
- move and and the the playby-play announcers saying I can't believe they're doing this but that's what they
- all do today and what who are we >> those teams that want to win games that's what they all do today. We we we
- need to wrap up and take a break, but I just want to push it one step further and make sure I understand is it true
- that so let's just take that hypothesis and say let's say this is true that something about the game has homogenized
- whether it's analytics base or just you know wisdom or whatever that everyone's playing more similarly now are you still
- going to get this result where you for the same difference in power rankings it'll be less diagnostic you would get
- more similar power rankings >> correct yes it's a different it's a different thing
- >> it's a different dynamic that the locations are getting scrunched, but that doesn't mean that the differences
- are less predictive of outcome. >> Okay, so we need we need more we need more evidence on. Um, but great
- question. All right, guys. That's the first half of Wharton Moneyball. We still have a half to go. Come back and
- join us. >> Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome back to a very
- special episode in that we are in person. We are in studio and all four of us are here. This happens about once a
- year these days. We always enjoy it. We're playing a little What caught your eye? We're going guest free this week.
- Give us a more chance. Give us more of a chance to kick things around. Um, we made it through two in the first half of
- the show. Two. And it was going to be a shorter second half of the show. We're going to kick it off with Eric Bradlo.
- If we have any time left, I'll add one at the end. Eric Bradlo. >> Well, ours might be the same one. So,
- you know, I was looking at college football and I was thinking about the number of teams that are essentially,
- you call it in the playoffs now. And I don't mean the teams that are in the playoffs. I mean, let's take our friend
- Cade Massiey's team, Texas. Like, the playoffs have started for them. Like, they have two losses. Like, they have to
- win now and every game left to make the playoffs. >> Oh, you're talking your define play like
- teams that are like in like have to win out. >> Have to win out to make it. And I was
- thinking, you know, Texas is playing Georgia this week. I think it's at Georgia. And I'm thinking, wow, what sim
- is going to have Texas right now having any significant probability of like they've got to win at Georgia? My guess
- is they're not favored at Georgia. >> Six and a half point underdog. >> Okay. So, but they have to win that
- game. Like if they get there's there's no way this year the way it's going, I don't think the three loss Texas is
- making >> speaking with too much confidence. And one of our missions on this show, you
- think if Texas loses the game, they have a chance to make the playoffs >> if they Yes. depends on what happens
- >> because well one it heavily depends on what happens to other teams >> but they can't they're in the I forget
- what they're in the SEC they can't win the SEC if they lose this game to Georgia
- >> they have a hard time winning it even as it is but they but Eric they would have
- still in front of them&m who's a top three team in the country so if they beat them they'll be Arkansas if they
- lose Georgia beat Arkansas beat&m they >> be nine and three >> and they would have beaten an undefeated
- number three team in the country on the last week of the year and their two two of their three losses would be to Ohio
- state and Georgia who would probably be top five teams. So, I'm not saying they're in. I'm not saying they're in,
- but it's not zero. >> I guess a follow up empirical question. The extent that anybody's sim
- forward, how many times does like a three win or three loss team get in? I mean, I guess it sounds improbable to me
- under the old rules, but you know, we're all still getting used to kind of what what I guess what bubble this kind of 12
- team structure >> provides. I wasn't putting just Texas in that bucket. I personally think I mean K
- to correctly I think Notre Dame's in that bucket. I think Notre Dame has two losses. They have to win out.
- >> Oh, that that people take that as a given. >> Okay. I think Oklahoma >> almost certainly would have to win out.
- >> Georgia Tech. >> Yeah. >> Okay. Utah. >> Oh, yeah. For sure. >> Okay. Well, so
- >> but they don't have they don't have the I'm Look, I'm not I would defend >> they don't have the degrees of freedom
- that they don't have the schedule. All I'm commenting on is I'm fascinated by this bucket of teams that with three
- games remaining essentially to win the national title, >> they have to start winning now. Every
- game now >> they're essentially elimination. >> Every game is an elimination game for
- them. And for some reason this week I was looking through this more than normal.
- >> Well, I mean in the old days every game was like an elimination game. It was like one loss and you're out of the
- playoff out of the two game playoff. >> That is my point. Yeah, >> I'm loving the fact that there's more
- teams now. Like I I just I'm finding games exciting because I mean obviously I would probably watch the Texas Georgia
- game anyway, but the fact that it's in my mind an elimination game, not with certainty for Texas makes it even a
- stronger game to watch. The same thing for Notre Dame and this whole set of teams now.
- >> No, and I mean your observation is true that that game would be essentially meaningless in the old scheme because
- Texas would definitely be out of like a two team Georgia would still be in the mix, you
- know, long shot kind of thing. But I mean, we've gone from two teams >> at the end to four teams at the end to
- now 12 teams at the end. Of course, that just broadens the number of meaningful games late in the season and and you're
- talking about something that I think is exactly right and fun. Um, that there's still that many in the mix. Um, and that
- we're looking at, you know, early round playoffs kind of already. Certainly many
- many people, by the way. So, I mean, I I'll I'll kibbitz on yours in the same way I kibbist on Shane's and maybe we'll
- skip any actual what caught my eye, but I ran the I looked at the athletics college sim and this is the first time
- I've ever looked at it and you know the athletics part of the New York Times now. So, this is what they everyone
- points them to and you know they're doing the same thing. They're grabbing power rankings and putting them in and I
- think it's an example of a sim that doesn't have enough uncertainty into it. They have it's just they're I feel way
- too sure about teams making playoffs and and way too sure teams aren't going to make playoffs and they give for what for
- example what do you think Eric you're paying some attention to college football this year. What do you think is
- the highest probability any one team has or should have for winning the national
- championship. Right now there's three regular season >> a champion point. Three regular season
- games left a conference championship round and then depending on how many times you have to play whether you get a
- buy or not three or four games in the >> Okay. So I'll I'll do my I'll go around
- the room here. Okay. >> What's the maximum? >> You want me to give a number or do you
- want me to tell you how I'm thinking about it? >> Both. >> Okay. So I'll tell you how I'm thinking
- about it and that will lead me to a number. So there's going to be some set of teams that win the power conferences
- that get a buy in the first round. There'll be another set of teams 9 through 12 that have to play five
- through eight. But let's get to the final eight at. So there's 12 and a half% on average probability given to
- each of those eight teams. Okay. Let's assume a team is the favorite in that round. How much pro what's the most
- probability I'd give to any of those final eight teams? I would say I I was going to say 25%.
- >> I'd jump to the same place >> somewhere like that. So that's my prediction. >> Double double. But so you think but that
- >> but that's giving by the way very low probability to the five through eights.
- It's not giving zero probability because I actually I'm not going to count Ohio State at one the same I'm going to
- count. >> But but but but Eric you're but you're giving them a pass to that point. I
- don't think that's fair. I don't think there's any team you can say right now is guaranteed to be final eight. I mean
- happens. >> Well Ohio State just has to win the Big 10, right? because then if >> to get a to get a pass that's true they
- so that's that's true >> four teams four teams will get it we'll get you I'm just catch I'm catching up
- with you >> I think they'll be one of the top four remaining >> so you are they guaranteed I mean no
- they have to beat Indiana in the Big 10 championship >> and then maybe maybe in some world both
- of those teams get a buy but some that's not given >> can't happen now right it's not based on
- rankings like I think the top It can happen now. Yes. It's it's based on rankings. Last year it was it was
- conference champions. >> Oh, it's the opposite. >> The only the only wrinkle they changed
- in the college football playoff setup is that they went away. The top four teams
- get buys and they're the top four ranked. >> Oh, there's no guarantee then that Ohio
- State's the top four. No, definitely not. Now that I thought it was the other way around. You're right. They switch it
- from conference ranking. >> But that improves your chances. It doesn't hurt your chances because some
- there's some chance that the Big 10 loser still gets a buy and there was no chance before. Either way, I watched
- Indiana since my wife's a Penn Stater. >> That's not a good football team. Come on,
- >> Eric. No, you're Eric, you're speaking with too much confidence on these college football.
- >> They're not a great football team. How about that? >> They've got They've got possibly the
- best quarterback in the country. And in college football, the best quarterback is going to go along.
- >> If they played Ohio State right now, what would be the point spread in that game?
- >> On a neutral field, I'm not looking at anything, but their power rankings are
- close. Um, no more than three and possibly less. Wow. >> No more than three. >> We don't have the the
- >> I'm certain of that, >> Kate. We don't have the distance that we used to have back in the day
- >> when Alabama would be like six points above somebody else. >> That is correct. And also, it's the
- thing that Shane was saying a minute ago about the about the Colts. We can't get
- it into our head that the Colts are decent. They may not be decent, but it's the same thing with college football. We
- can't get same state, by the way. Same state. We can't get our head around these Indiana football teams.
- >> They don't even do the time difference uh the time change. It's very confusing.
- But I mean, this is a >> What are they doing over there? >> I mean, it's a big deal because
- historically, I I don't know the ins and outs of the tournament structures and leagues and the power conferences the
- way you guys do cuz I don't watch college football. But what I would have done was looked historically at how
- often the, you know, the top ranked team in the season was categorically different.
- >> I just think I can't do that. >> Categorically different. And I think it's and and because of this diffuseness
- of talent, you don't have this this elomeration in just a couple teams who just walk all over everyone because
- everyone has to be at that team because you're not getting paid to be somewhere else and a lot too.
- >> Is Indiana too >> in the power rankings? They're the closest to >> they were going into the games last
- weekend, I think. >> So, it's possible that uh&m will jump them. Um Ohio State be one and then
- it'll be Indiana or&M because Indiana struggled with Penn State. Um which was an that Did y'all see the catch?
- That's >> I heard about that. >> I think it's the best catch. It's It's certainly one of the best catches. It's
- a that I've seen in my lifetime of watching C of football, period. I mean, name me a better catch. It would have to
- be a diving thing. This wasn't a diving thing. This was a foot in the back of the endzone thing. But between the
- quality of the catch and the moment because it was a game-winning catch, I think I made the
- >> There's no greater combination. >> The greatest catch I've ever seen is the Giants against the Patriots. What was
- the guy's name that the helmet? Tyrie. Well, that was the That was the flu. That was given the moment
- >> that was the biggest catch of all time maybe like like I think like Julio's catch in the Atlanta Super Bowl where
- ended up not actually changing the outcome but like was a better actual catch >> or that OBJ one from way back when he
- like I I mean I can think of a lot I can think of a lot of catches in ter like that kind of hit the spectacle part of
- it but in terms of content >> what about what about the one at the end of the Super Bowl was
- >> the Edelman one no I I know was it Steelers Rams or >> Steelers Cowboys there a toe tap catch
- in the uh in the end zone to win the Super Bowl for it was um Antonio I don't know it wasn't Antonio Brown it was
- somebody >> but it was the Steelers beating >> it was the Seahawks >> Steelers Cardinals was a great game
- >> maybe yeah whatever Kurt Warner >> we're also not we're not also not The Cardinals were ahead late and the
- Steelers went down and that catch at the end like 5 seconds left. A touchdown catch. I don't remember that catch.
- Okay, >> it wasn't as spectacular, but in terms of consequence, the game-winning catch
- by Malcolm Butler and for the Patriots against the Seattle Seahawks was also one of the most consequential catches of
- all time. >> Consequential, but not. So, was my 25% even close? >> What's the number
- around the room? >> I wanted to chip it a chip. I wanted to chip it down. I think it's a reasonable
- way thing you did, but then I don't want to give him a pass into the final eight.
- And so I want to I want to knock that down by some >> I was going to be naive. >> You didn't ask me for which team. I just
- said one team. So you asked me the maximum probability. You didn't say which team it was.
- >> But you have to apply it to same some specific. >> No, no, no. But some team is going to be
- in the final four and some team is going to be the top ranked team. And I think the top ranked team, whoever that might
- be, is going to be >> It's a big difference. >> It is a big difference. But but I'm
- asking the question, I'm going to give every team a probability right now. What is a reasonable maximum probability?
- >> That's not what he's asking. That's not the question he's asking. >> Well, he did up to that point.
- >> No, he's saying at the time of the playoffs. >> No, no, no. But ask or I mean I I I
- could get I can even say now out of some team I don't know who it's going to be,
- >> but he's not asking. He's saying we're not interested in that version of the question.
- >> No, it's the same question. >> No, it's not. >> I'm sitting here now. some team has a
- there's a maximum probability. No, he's supposed to know what it is. >> That's not interesting.
- >> Yeah, >> we want we want to know of the specific teams that we're observing right now can
- place bets on or >> you didn't say which one. You just said the maximum probability.
- >> We don't have to. We're going to we're going to we didn't he's not asking about
- Ohio. He's saying if you take all the teams out there and and calculate whatever system as of today, what are
- their probability of winning the college football championship? What is the maximum of those numbers? He's not
- asking what Ohio's number is or what Oklahoma's number is. He said when we once we rank them, find the max.
- >> Yeah. I mean, my naive much more naive version of that that answer would be like, you know, cap like
- >> you know, the the best team's going to make it to the to the final eight and then flat from there.
- >> Okay. >> So, that would that would give you like what like 8% or something like that or
- >> Well, which team has the highest probability of getting a buy at the final eight? I'm giving a very naive my
- He's given him buys there, but then his coin flips. So, it's going to end up some somewhere between these two guys is
- my is my guess. >> So, my my my guess is there be there's a there's one or two teams that are almost
- certainly to get a buy uh right now. >> Well, if you believe that, then you got to go towards my number.
- >> That's right. It's it's close to your number, right? >> Okay. So, >> but it's going to be a little less
- because there isn't any team that has that and that has a little smaller factor and you got to multiply that. So,
- you're going with 25. I'm gonna probably go with their 18. >> Yeah, I'm with odd because I don't I'm
- not giving anybody a pass to the final eight right now. Um I'm going to go with odd. go 20 and the top one's 29 which I
- think is absurdly high. >> Yeah. >> Oh, by the gambling metrics >> by by the athletic sim
- >> sim and that's not the only that's not the only sim. >> And what does the gambling I bet you the
- gambling metrics would go would be what does Vegas do? >> Great question. I don't have that in
- front of me right now. So we can we can find it but I don't know. >> So the question is
- >> I bet it's lower than 29%. So the question is what's Ohio State >> better than plus 300? They have to be
- more than plus three. Plus 300 plus 25% on well there's a vig in that. So we take but it's not that high. Why don't
- you look? >> Okay, we'll get it. In the meantime, let me say give you one other bit on college
- football just in terms of updating everybody. Um that that people think people started talking about like this
- week is the split on the playoff bids between the Big 10 and the and the SEC, >> right?
- >> So there, think of it as being basically there are four teams that were going to
- be in from some other conference. Notre Dame's going to get in as long as they win out. Um, there's probably a group of
- five, maybe. Well, there's should be the conference winners from the from the ACC
- and the Big 12 and the top rated group of five. Right. >> By the way, you want a fun wrinkle? The
- ACC is so bloody awful this year. >> Yeah, they're awful. >> So, the the the the playoff format isn't
- >> the champions of the best four conferences and then the best fifth one from one of the group of fives. The
- playoff format is the highest rated top five conference champions. And so it's possible if the ACC champ is so bad that
- there could be two group of five champs that are higher rated and the ACC could theoretically miss the playoffs
- altogether and two group of five champions would be it. Would that not be spectacular? You want chaos, Eric?
- >> That would be great. I'm all right with that. >> Two group of fives. >> You want to know the answer?
- >> Yeah. >> Below 29%. >> No. Vegas. Well, the Vegas odds are slightly above it, but when you subtract
- the Vegas, it's 29%. >> Oh my goodness. So Austin something >> uh plus two plus 200. It's about right.
- >> I want to short theid. I want to short the Buckeyes winning. >> And it's the Buckeyes by the way.
- >> Yeah, it is. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> I I Okay. I I would short that. I'll take I'll take I'll I'll give those
- odds. I'll I'll >> way that's a good bet. >> So 185 is what is the worst bet you can
- get. Now 225 is currently the best you can find right now. And that's 225 is right around uh 31%. Subtract the VIG,
- you're right around 29%. Interesting. Okay. Well, I can believe that they have a lot of attention. I don't think that's
- smart money. >> Let me ask you a different question. I mean, related though, it's the same
- topic. So, I gave an answer of 25%. And then you guys, it's fine. I I understand
- the logic behind that number is even too high. But like I always find it interesting when people try to move you
- off like you wanted to go lower and the answer is actually higher. So, what's then wrong in your logic? Because that
- sim, it's not even just the betting odds. This is a sim. So why are you guys all with reasonable arguments saying 18
- 19%? >> I don't think they have enough 29%. >> Yeah. And I think the market is too sure
- the I mean >> market will bet up the favorites. >> Yeah. We we know that >> I wasn't worried about the market bet
- but the sim >> there's not enough uncertainty in the sim and I see that from other 25 to 18
- that degree. >> That's the problem with sims don't have enough uncertainty. No, no, no. I I give
- you you look you look at more than just that number and you just they're too sure they know what teams are going to
- make it. Look at the probabilities. They like they're certain they know like >> I don't know 10 of the 12 playoff teams
- and there's just no way with four rounds four games ahead left in the schedule that they can be that sure. You just see
- that there's too much uncertainty, too little uncertainty in the >> Ohio State by I think you would agree
- with this. For Ohio State not to be a top four, they would probably have to lose two games. No, they could. They It
- depends on what else happens, but if they don't look great in the Big 10 final against Indiana, that could
- happen. >> But you said it was the top ranked teams. >> Yeah. >> You're saying they could fall to number
- five even with just one loss? >> Well, it's a fair question. Could that happen? What what has to happen is that
- three SEC teams have to jump them because it's not they're not going to come from I mean in if tech Texas Tech
- goes in and blows somebody out in the Big 12 final are they going to jump Ohio State? So it would be have to be Texas
- Tech, Alabama, and Georgia potentially, but they're probably playing each other.
- And so two, yes. >> Or what if there's a greatl looking SEC team that just misses the SEC final
- because they are lose some tiebreaker. >> Say this could happen. And so you you have two strong SEC teams in the SEC
- final. You have a third one floating around that lost a tiebreaker and they're just as good as the other ones.
- Maybe they even like them better. The the markets like them better. And then you have a really strong tech. So I've
- given you now four possible teams that could >> I just don't see them passing Ohio State
- with only one loss. I just don't see it. >> It's possible. It's I I it's got to be
- something. But you've talked me into believing that it it's higher probability than
- >> and just to kind of calibrate in in in the Houseion days of like when Alabama
- was like 10 points above the next highest team. What would be the max like Alabama you you would ever given ma talk
- if we were in one of those seasons what's what's the m what's the probability you would have assigned the
- max in one of those season like would you for what winning the championship >> yeah the same one you're arguing is way
- too high at Ohio State at 29 >> at this point in the season yeah >> but we have a very different playoff
- system now >> right >> yeah I guess I'm trying to say like you know pretend like the we had the same
- kind of team separation we we had back when Alabama was so dominant Oh, I see. But current structure
- >> current structure, but you know, Alabama is it would be interesting to see what the
- upper bound essentially is on that probability logic. We'll give him a pass. We'll give him a pass into the
- final four >> and then we're just going to do something more strong with the Eric's.
- Eric started out saying one over eight and then he went double that for the better teams. Correct. And we would just
- it would be less than because their their lead was about 10 points higher than the next best team.
- >> No, that's too much. >> Is it too much? No, it was pretty high. Was it 33? >> This is the kind of intuition I'm
- getting at. The fact that you instantly reacted to that being too much. So if you use my rule of thumb, which is not
- accurate for college, >> seven was big. Like I would say five or six was a typical
- >> each point multiply by two and a half. >> 17 and a half. So 67 to 2/3 over the second best team. and a lot
- more over >> over the next one. So I see. So you'd say something like 75% over the second
- best team, maybe 80. >> Got in the in the extreme years. >> Yeah, in the extreme years.
- >> Yeah, that's what I'm trying to get at is kind of almost the upper bound on what you'd ever want to give the max or
- you know, type of thing. >> How it depends on what you think of one versus four. What's one versus four?
- >> Yeah, I mean they catch up pretty quick those they start sacking up pretty quick. So there's not as much obviously
- not as much of a spread as you go. So, but so I'm gonna answer Shane's directly by saying I don't know 35%.
- >> Okay. >> That's again why I think 29 is way too high. >> Yeah. >> But Eric's talking me out.
- >> So Ohio State is twice as dominant in your mind as Alabama was back in the day
- >> because you you you had him down more like 17% or something. >> You mean Alabama's twice as dominant?
- >> Yeah. D Yeah. Half as dominant. Yeah. >> Yeah. that the this the talent that was
- stacked up by the even Ohio State back in the day, but especially Alabama and Georgia for those years. It was just I
- mean everybody talks about it's just it was just >> And by the way, do the final four teams
- when when let's let's just pretend that five, six, seven, eight all beat. Do one
- through four play on their home field? >> No. Um the first round is in the home stadiums.
- >> So 5 through eight and 9 through 12 is home, but the next one are the bowl are
- bowl games. >> Yeah. Yeah. And that's a some people think that's a knock on the system that
- they don't they take away a home game from the teams that got the buy and they'd like another round of home
- fields. >> I think I would too. >> I I think it's reasonable. >> Is it because of money? Did they lose
- the home game or >> I think I mean I I feel like Exactly. Exactly. It's maybe an intermediary
- state to kind of like keep the bowl legacy thing. >> They may lose it eventually. Um people
- people loved the home field playoff games last year. People were euphoric about them. It's like a really big deal
- these late season playoff games at a home state. I know friends who went in Austin and it's just a whole different
- deal >> and I mean and you heard in the media as well just real quickly and then we'll do
- maybe a real quick round. >> Okay. >> Um the questions whether the Big 10 can get a fourth team in and hold off a
- fifth SEC team or whether SEC can pull in this fifth team and hold off >> the four big there's Indiana Ohio State
- >> Oregon looking pretty good that win they had a last minute win right after um yes
- Indiana's last minute win two back-to-back unbelievable Big 10 games. So people are thinking Oregon's pretty
- good, but then they're like SC is still kind of in the mix. If Michigan made a run, they're kind of in the mix. And
- then in Texas, in SEC, there's a few teams buying for a fifth spot. Texas, for example, Oklahoma, for example. All
- right. Why don't we do in the last four minutes, can you do it a really quick? What caught your eye? Just
- >> Okay, I'll just go quickly. Um, there's been lots of stories out there that the
- Sixers are actually better without Joel Embiid. There's been similar stories that the Lakers are intentionally
- sitting LeBron even though he's got a sciatic issue. So the question is, is it possible now at this point in the career
- that the Sixers Lakers are the are a better team without it? Now I say in the last 10 seconds I have for my one minute
- Embiid's plus minus on the court is horrific. The team is negative with him on the court right now. So, I'm just
- wondering, is it possible that at the end of careers, even superstar players who demand the ball, if you just used
- him as a part-time player, but coaches won't do it? So, that caught my eye. >> Interesting, Adi.
- >> Well, I have to say what caught my eye was the gambling in Major League Baseball.
- >> Oh, yeah. Right. >> I mean, the idea that these multi-million dollar players would risk
- their careers >> like 12,000 >> for just tens of thousands of dollars. >> Baseball or basketball? Baseball? No,
- I'm talking about the baseball. They were throwing the baseball announced that they're no longer going to that
- they don't want the the gambling companies to and the gambling companies agreed not to allow bets in game on the
- outcome of a pitch. >> Um because individual players found it too easy and too attractive to collude
- with a gambler to throw a strike or to throw a ball when when certain part and and there were there were parlayies.
- eight. One of the guys had bet eight successive um balls and one of the accused pitchers, I can't remember which
- of the two, throwing it in the dirt and then finally he throws the eighth one again in the dirt. Pitcher hit her swung
- at it. >> That's great. >> That's hilarious. >> Amazing. >> That's why I call it gambling.
- >> Yeah. No, that's that's downright charming right there. >> And this is I mean this is tragic. I
- mean, because it seems, you have to argue that the reason why the protection, the integrity of the game is
- protected based on the fact that they're already rich and to scale up to a to size that would make a money that
- matters to them would be noticeable. >> You know, these little $50,000 bets here
- and there are okay, people shouldn't you can pull them off without noticing, but
- they shouldn't care about them. Look, there's a general thing here about gambling, getting away from these
- in-game individual plays like the and so it's possible that we get away from that
- alto together. Shane, >> well, I'll just mention I I just saw the uh it's probably going to they're
- probably going to get back on top, but the Oilers are playing terribly right now. And I'll just point out that they
- just lost 91 to the Avalanche a couple nights ago. And the kind of unique thing about this particular game, 9-1, they
- lost one. >> Four guys scored two goals. >> Four guys go. Not only that, the Avalanche went 0 for seven on the power
- play despite scoring nine goals. >> Is that amaz I don't know. I don't know if you know the headline that four guys
- had scored two goals which is quite rare apparently in hockey. >> Absurd. I mean how many minutes do they
- have a regular wonder like how did it even >> Why is that that rare? If if the other
- team's if I'm really down I'm going to start taking it out on the other team. Once I'm down 617 I'm going to start
- hacking the other team. Just Yeah, why not? >> Jeez. Wow. >> I'm already going to lose the game.
- Yeah, but I mean if you're already giving up goals at that rate, why how are you suddenly like not doing it on
- power? Like Yeah, it's >> just remind me what what fraction of goals are on power play.
- >> Oh, like maybe a third or something like that. >> Is there any argument changes quickly
- for 10 more seconds on your topic that you're ahead by so much that you just kill time on the power play? In other
- words, if you're up seven to one, what do you need to >> Yeah. No, I mean, it's true. You don't
- kind of get a sense of the load management that probably went in the second half of this game. Like I mean
- certainly they took out the Edmonton took out their goalender after like four or five you that that we can assume but
- like otherwise the load management of what the Avalanche were doing and what the Oilers were doing in the second half
- that's that would merit further study. >> Why would they take out their goalender?
- >> Well well I mean well he let in four goals and like 13 shots like that. When you look at a score like 91 you're like
- well there was definitely a goalender replacement probably somewhere in there but how much they took out their other
- we need to curve probability of scoring on the power play versus goal differential. And what we're going to
- see is maybe in the far right tail teams don't even try to score. >> They're just resting, hanging out.
- >> But but let's not >> because the other opponent can't score on you pretty much.
- >> Don't bury the lead. The Oilers suck apparently >> for now. For now, let's enjoy it for
- now. You know, come play. Yeah, I mean the Flames are even more. >> They're my adopted NHL team.
- >> They're going to build momentum. >> What happened to Canada? I thought they used to be able to play uh to hockey.
- >> They would they focus on baseball now. >> And they got so close. >> They got so close.
- Why don't we leave it there? That's a perfect way to end. Why don't we wrap it up for the whole team here? This has
- been Kate Massie, Shane Jensen, Audi Winer, and Eric Bradlo coming to you in person in the Wharton studios. Thank you
- for being here. Big shout out thanks to D Patel and the whole team. It does take
- a whole team and we appreciate it. Dion Sipkins in particular in the house back where he belongs with us over the last
- 11 plus years. Thank you guys for listening. Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your
- sports.
Brief Summary
Hosts discuss sports analytics, NFL updates, and college football playoff scenarios without a guest.
Key points
- Understanding Hot Stove Season. The hosts discuss the meaning and history behind the term 'hot stove season' in baseball.
- The Case for Bunting. One host argues for the strategic use of bunting in modern baseball.
- Greg Maddox's Athleticism. A surprising revelation about the legendary pitcher's fielding skills.
- Willie Mays' Legacy. A debate on whether Mays' fame is due to one iconic catch.
- NFL Power Rankings Uncertainty. Discussion on the unpredictability of this NFL season's power rankings.
- Texas Football's Playoff Pressure. Texas must win every game to make the playoffs, facing tough opponents ahead.
Episode highlights
- Understanding Hot Stove SeasonThe hosts discuss the meaning and history behind the term 'hot stove season' in baseball.“I associate it with trades and front office transactions.”2:20Nov 16, 2025
- The Case for BuntingOne host argues for the strategic use of bunting in modern baseball.“I think the bunt should make a big comeback.”10:42Nov 16, 2025
- Greg Maddox's AthleticismA surprising revelation about the legendary pitcher's fielding skills.“I had no idea.”16:54Nov 16, 2025
- Willie Mays' LegacyA debate on whether Mays' fame is due to one iconic catch.“Is that not because of the one catch?”17:40Nov 16, 2025
- NFL Power Rankings UncertaintyDiscussion on the unpredictability of this NFL season's power rankings.“I think there’s not as much.”29:48Nov 16, 2025
- Texas Football's Playoff PressureTexas must win every game to make the playoffs, facing tough opponents ahead.“They have to win now and every game left to make the playoffs.”34:31Nov 16, 2025
- The Evolution of College Football PlayoffsThe playoff structure has expanded, making more games meaningful late in the season.“We’ve gone from two teams at the end to four teams at the end to now 12 teams.”37:40Nov 16, 2025
- The Greatest Catch DebateA discussion on the best catches in football history, highlighting memorable moments.“I think it’s the best catch I’ve seen in my lifetime of watching college football.”42:52Nov 16, 2025





