Baseball’s Hall of Fame Debate Is Changing

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE How should baseball evaluate greatness in the modern analytics era?

Jay Jaffe, Senior Writer for FanGraphs, discusses how analytics have changed Hall of Fame debates, why certain legendary pitchers remain overlooked, and how evolving player usage is reshaping Cooperstown standards. The conversation also explores MLB season storylines, the Dodgers’ long-term strategy, baseball analytics, and the future of player evaluation.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#MLB #BaseballAnalytics #HallOfFame #FanGraphs #SportsAnalytics #WhartonMoneyball #Baseball ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome Welcome to wharton money ball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics
  2. Here on the wharton podcast network. This is kate massey hosting this week With two of my longtime collaborators and good friends
  3. eric bradlow and shane jensen Our fourth co -host oddy weiner Is away this week doing
  4. oddy weiner. Thanks. He'll be back As you guys know some combination of us are here almost every week
  5. of the year Pushing 49 50 weeks of the year have been for more than 12 years now delighted To roll in here and
  6. get a little time Talking sports analytics with these guys It's tuesday afternoon The show will
  7. go up sometime wednesday. This is our usual slot. We're going to flip it this week We
  8. usually do guests in the first half hour this week. We're going to do guests in the second
  9. half hour that guest jay jaffe One of the best sports analytics oriented baseball writers out
  10. there for fangraphs We'll talk with jay in the second half of the show talk more
  11. baseball in the second half of the show Um till then open lines as we used to say when we were running this thing
  12. live Gentlemen afternoon to you. How are things eric from points unknown shane? I think from home and i'm coming in
  13. from austin. What's up guys? All good great time to great sports time of the year a lot going on with
  14. nba NHL mlb's in full swing. We have the french open tennis going on right now Of course the world cup's about
  15. to start so a lot of good things going on Well shane shane and I need to talk about hockey shane.
  16. I this back to adult adulting. Um, I don't know if this is adulting or not, but I I had this exchange.
  17. I have a buddy in uh, Durham who's a hurricanes guy. Um, he's kind of a come to it
  18. lately hockey guy like me He's a hick like me grew up playing football and basketball
  19. and not hockey now he's into it It's not the most natural sport for that particular
  20. region No, it's not nor is it for west texas? But we love it now and we were talking last night because he was suffering through
  21. this game as carolina Couldn't quite get it past the canadians until late and i'm like
  22. totally enjoying it because I only marginally care about the outcome and the thing is here's
  23. the weird I I 100 no question enjoyed that game more than every sabers game or penguins game I watched this season like this
  24. this playoffs like yeah, you know, I cared about the pins in round one I cared about the sabers in round and you feel
  25. like that degrades kind of yeah It's the worst viewing experience. Yeah I mean this is what i've suffered
  26. through as a patriots fan for the last 20 years No sympathy from you guys, by the way that i've had to watch all
  27. these super bowls that have really mattered to me Another way. Yeah. Yeah Audie weiner has arrived.
  28. Let's say a little unexpectedly sliding in here from god knows where I think he's way
  29. overseas But audie good to see you good to be here Hey, we're gonna have jay in the second half of the show.
  30. So we're talking a little hockey to top to top the show Sorry to follow up on what you were saying.
  31. I I have found uh, I found like this this hockey uh playoffs has been Extra delightful for me and I don't know if
  32. it's it's partly the level play which I think has been excellent I've really enjoyed the
  33. games themselves, but it's also, you know, I I don't dislike any of the teams remaining,
  34. you know like I could I would be kind of fine, I mean, I guess I i'd sort of uh Built in my mind
  35. this like carolina colorado finals, which it doesn't look like we're gonna get after all but
  36. uh, but you know I'm, i'm fairly I i'm fine with everything now that the oilers are out of it You've had two bad
  37. seasons because the oilers have been there to the finals I I don't you know, it's
  38. like, you know, it's kind of I kind of celebrate oilers elimination day in the same
  39. way. I celebrate yankees elimination day every year Unfortunately with both those teams it often is very
  40. late in the game that I celebrate that right? Okay, eric's been trying to jump. No.
  41. No, I was just going to point out that I find it interesting That you're as excited as you are about hockey, but you
  42. also made another statement, which I wouldn't make about most sports I find it extremely difficult
  43. to watch most sports, but maybe hockey less so when I don't actually care about the
  44. outcome of the game So there's something I agree with you. There is something exciting about hockey, especially two
  45. two games late in it, etc where Like except for the super bowl, like if you just show me some random nfl game I
  46. don't know. The texans are playing the panthers or something like that. I love football I mean, it's probably my
  47. favorite sport, but I don't know I'm, not that excited to flip on the texans and
  48. the panthers or you know, some random nba game in the middle Hey, don't be so harsh.
  49. Don't harshen our boy. Eric eager. Come on. You care about the panthers now now you
  50. care about Now we do now. Can I ask you a question because i've always had a hard time watching hockey on
  51. television And found it just a delightful game to go to more than delightful. It's super exciting to be at it's actually
  52. easier to follow it on You know, like I feel like unlike some sports it's easier
  53. to follow it in person like you can track the puck better Yeah, it's just it's a huge gap.
  54. It's hard on tv for some of that Yeah, it's a very big gap and I think it's interesting because you know One of
  55. the things about football the ascendance in america of football as the national sport Basically parallels
  56. the growth of television because it is ideal I mean i've been offered tickets to go
  57. see the eagles games and i'm like no I think i'm gonna watch at home on my big screen and not have to worry
  58. about two hours of leaving the stadium and It's just like i'm gonna watch it We have to get you to a college football
  59. game because the atmosphere of a college football game is an entirely different thing And that's
  60. back to hockey the the game last night. The carolina montreal game was in montreal.
  61. It was the first Montreal game of this round and they have been incredible throughout the
  62. playoffs whenever they play at home. I mean Obviously the montreal folks Quebecois or
  63. whatever they're called are like phenomenal for hockey and that atmosphere is just unbelievable So oddy
  64. every now and then it's worth going forget about the view or whatever It's just the
  65. atmosphere of the game and that happens with college football Well, I have to say i've
  66. been to college football not big college football But as a student I used to go to the yale games, of course I would
  67. sit there and discuss math problems with my friends. That's what we would do. But when we went True, it's a true
  68. story Um, but when we went to the hockey games, which were which were we did not do that those were super exciting Um
  69. the hockey the yale hockey game. Yeah at the whale at the whale Fantastic. I think it also helps that the ivies
  70. are kind of more Um, they're competitive in hockey. Um, well last night one one thing that
  71. jumped out last night carolina won it was the third game of the series carolina supposed
  72. to you know be the big favorite montreal goes down to raleigh and takes the takes
  73. the first game takes the first game and um, and uh They go so carolina. They outplayed them last night.
  74. Remember they had a 10-day rest and we talked about what the impact would be and they Seriously outplayed them last night by
  75. the end of the game. The expected goals was like 5.1 to one point something. Yeah Think about yeah, the game was tied
  76. 2-2 deep into the first period of overtime and carolina wins at 3-2 The expected goals by the end of the game
  77. was 5-1 That's how badly the hurricanes outplayed the canadians but just barely squeaked by
  78. No, it's I it's made me because I feel like carolina in general has been I mean, they're on a dominant looking run if
  79. you just look at outcome 10 and 1 in the playoffs. Yeah, but for those It's like they're like
  80. that's based on a 4-0 record in overtime Yeah, and you'd kind of think like in part of you know, most of me
  81. i'm like, oh well overtime is just completely random It's a coin flip right but maybe
  82. carolina montreal like it's like carolina if you're like a lopsidedly good team And you're having
  83. trouble getting ahead Maybe you just need more time in the game to kind of for that like those Difference if we saw that's
  84. a nice realize, you know, it's a nice point. Yep, right just i'm gonna jump in I
  85. know eric has had his hand up, but i'm learning more about hockey and there's this
  86. and the depth and the differences in the lines does suggest that maybe there's There's less
  87. of a coin to flip in overtime because Because of that you can basically have your
  88. top lines play more often Maybe they don't I don't I don't I don't know enough to know exactly how the details go But
  89. that would be my hypothesis. Yeah, I don't I don't know if that's true because This is something tolsky told us
  90. whenever we talked to him a couple of months ago We were talking about that what
  91. seems like special, you know playoff overtime hockey feels special and he's like I don't know
  92. guy basically these are my words. I don't know guys The players are so tired by that.
  93. Yeah, they can't be working as hard as you think They're just worn out lines more
  94. exclusively in overtime. You better you better end that overtime quick, I guess, you know, exactly But both teams
  95. are kind of going through that same exhaustion kind of level. Uh, You know kind of performance to grade
  96. I guess Eric, yeah, you're um, you're five to one expected goals question asked made me
  97. think of something metric statistically So I assume expected goals in hockey are based on location
  98. and shots taken correct Yes, assuming that's true Is there any reason we would need another
  99. metric to measure goalie performance than the difference between expected goals and actual goals?
  100. Well, yes Because I don't think expected goals Takes into consideration the position of other players
  101. and the position of other players has a lot to do with goalie performance So guys
  102. get guys get blocked all the time. Do you think if we got more sophisticated in measuring expected goals?
  103. Then the answer like in the limit would be no Yeah, right. It seems like in the limit if you
  104. could traject like track the trajectory of the puck And kind of have like a real
  105. value. Yes, I think then you'd probably get almost all the Residual outbated like that would that
  106. would I think be basically well as long as you have to have some sense of what the goalie Can see and what he
  107. can't see so if he's got a clean unobstructed view, that's one thing but if he's
  108. got The other team's got a big guy in front and he and some one of their guys is trying to lean on him
  109. And he can barely look around or the puck comes over his right shoulder to even see it that happens all the time Yeah,
  110. I guess i'm thinking of a 3d model of all Players and puck right like like if that's kind of the limit Kind of
  111. of both on the data and kind of modeling side. I feel like that would get Essentially all
  112. of it, but you're right. That's a good point eric I think you've basically defined, you know you have the perfect
  113. uh expected goals model whenever you can take the residual against actual goals as the mark
  114. of goalie performance and I think we're some distance. Well, I don't know about some that was
  115. my point You said it much better than I did. I like how you said that can I just interject about some of the talks i've
  116. seen about expected goal in um Soccer professional highest level soccer is it doesn't seem to
  117. be much residual Value attributable to the shooter In other words, if you look at expected
  118. goals versus expect actual goals and look at it from the offensive side you'd expect some
  119. players to consistently outperform their expected goals and the bottom line is conditional on location Yeah,
  120. everything you would put in stuff like that the kind of random effect of player is
  121. not there's no players that really see So in soccer, I wouldn't say no. I didn't i'm about to make my one
  122. exception Um, okay after controlling for everything. Basically, there is no player except for one
  123. and he sticks out like a sore thumb and that's messy So he's just great and everybody else is great at taking shots.
  124. I mean getting to make them That's where their genius is, but they don't seem to
  125. score them more frequently Guys, you're the statisticians. How well can we say something like that?
  126. We can say there aren't reliable individual differences and that's a population level conclusion That's different
  127. than saying there are no individuals. It's much harder to say Right these guys fall so far outside.
  128. They're beyond what we'd expect I mean, there is a statistical test that we can use
  129. to say that but that's what it would take, right? That's a great it was exactly what I
  130. was we're done eight because let's let's imagine we had However, many let's I don't know
  131. 15 20 15 players on a hockey team whatever times 30 So let's imagine we had roughly 450 to 500 players each with a
  132. low power effect Because it's there's low maybe low statistical power to assess this or even
  133. in soccer And the problem is every one of them shows this effect to a small degree So there's a population level effect, but
  134. it's hard to detect any single player with that effect And that's what you would expect
  135. matter of fact, my guess is there are most phenomenon in life where individual Individual level
  136. measurement is hard to say This player or this person is so extraordinary But there is
  137. an effect when I look at the population distribution. Well, adi's saying something else.
  138. Adi's saying population level. There's no effect Well, there's a random distribution
  139. Population is so let's start be clear here. This is the top players Oh, I thought
  140. he was talking about players I thought he was talking about there were no players that
  141. show and observe goals more than they're expected except for lino messi He was talking about
  142. a player level effect. I'm looking at a player to get more. I mean, I assume Plenty there's plenty who
  143. have positive plenty of negative and i'm actually just repeating. I haven't done this analysis myself I should
  144. be making that quite clear. Um, this was a talk given at nessus Which is a new england sports conference that
  145. takes place every other year at harvard And this was one of the featured talks And
  146. um, it was using a lot of bayesian statistics as you might expect to do this kind of problem It's the this the the
  147. standard approach. Um, yeah, that was the conclusion that was uh, that was presented to the at the
  148. conference No, it sounds like methodologically the right thing. I would kind of feel like that and
  149. this is coming back to hockey I think the similar problem hockey is that once you
  150. start conditioning on shot Location and a lot of the other type of stuff you'd like
  151. to resize lights out even for players like messy that play a lot I feel like you all the time you're really reducing your
  152. your sample size if you're then going to be like Here's sort of like a rat, you know looking for player Random effects on
  153. top of that already complicated model So I I just don't know how powerful with the
  154. amount of data We have we how much power we really have to detect that kind of you know, sort of In other words
  155. you're saying that there's so much noise because the model is so So is not so perfect by any stretch.
  156. We don't know what xg is. We only have xg up to the Factors that we're putting in it and that introduces
  157. an enormous amount of residual Independent noise and that makes whatever signal you're trying to find
  158. just that much harder to spot and detect But he's also i'm also hearing or at least i'm projecting onto what he's saying another
  159. consideration, which is the ability to create xg itself Is a skill can be an is an individual difference and let's not condition out
  160. xg without knowing that that's happening because That could be what is reliable is the ability
  161. to create more xg Um, by the way, this question about the population doesn't seem to
  162. have any reliable differences, but maybe one individual or two Does is something that comes up
  163. with nfl draft? So this is goes back to one of the first papers I submitted to the mit
  164. conference It doesn't seem like teams are better and if you take it down to the general manager level That people aren't better than
  165. each other at the nfl draft That doesn't mean that there's not one or two who outperform but you have it's a different statistical
  166. test to ask whether one or two Hey, if I just be since we're a business school, my guess would be the same would
  167. be true of people picking stocks, right? I mean, this is the classic thing. It doesn't mean there's nobody that's better It's
  168. hard to be systematically better also from year to year I think what adi's also pointing
  169. out potentially is that messy maybe has repeatedly done this It's not it's not a one.
  170. My guess is it may not be a one-year statistic that he's talking about and you know, that's another possibility is that Lionel
  171. messy could stick out this year, but not for the previous 10 years. That's not what you're saying.
  172. I think no, I doubt it But the thing is, I mean, this is where you you touch on statistical techniques So everyone in
  173. statistics is trained to try to do what we call family-wise control So that when
  174. we do have positives, we know that we're controlling the false positive rate at whatever what
  175. level we call that in statistics now we typically use um false discovery rates and those
  176. are Better ways to look at a population level um characteristic because you don't have to
  177. have the stringencies of family-wide, um Error rates which are which basically take away most
  178. of your power So when I did like the hockey putting I couldn't find the one the one putter golf Sorry, i'm getting mixing
  179. my sports the golf putting I couldn't find putting is even more Yeah, hockey pucking.
  180. Um the uh, I couldn't find the the the actual three or four putters who were better and name them I could give you
  181. a group of five or six and tell you Of these five or six four of them are are are going to be better
  182. than everybody else with a control of the error rate Of about five percent. So in other words, it's kind of a
  183. funny statistics It's like looking at stock pickers and saying here's a bunch of people One
  184. or two of them might actually just be lucky but on this group most of them That's exactly we want to be able to
  185. say things that we can actually say and no more And so you're saying we can say this and no more which is fantastic
  186. and I remember that about your putting paper Um guys one last thing on hockey. I just want to say we had a
  187. note I had a note from a longtime listener and good friend. You've all wrote in strike He really ought
  188. to get associate producer credit on this show He gives us so much feedback and so
  189. many good ideas But and i'm gonna probably misrepresent what he said, but i'm gonna i'm
  190. gonna use it to ask a question I said last week that hockey had this quality seems to me hockey has this quality Because
  191. scoring is rare And that it can turn on a dime guys can go from behind the net to scoring a goal It happened
  192. this in this past week in like four seconds That there's there's there's higher frequency changes
  193. in win probability than in other sports And I I said that as a positive thing It is something that keeps me kind of
  194. it's hard to not pay if you care about the game at all It's hard to turn your attention to anything else because of
  195. that quality And you've all wrote and said yeah, I I said basically said I I think that may be true And that's why
  196. I don't like it as much as I it's not it's like I I want I don't want it to be as As like
  197. a constant hazard rate that the wind problem is going to change I want to see it build up like you see it happens
  198. in football or basketball It's interesting because I you know, I can we group can we
  199. group sports that way and it's it's and and do people have preferences for the type
  200. of Sport on that dimension that well, I I think the most popular sport in the world is definitely more like hockey in this
  201. I mean, I think the hockey just because it's even more end to end and like deflections and stuff probably has an even greater
  202. instantaneous rate of change but soccer is like that too like one penalty or one like
  203. kind of like I mean, I feel like the probability can really change a lot in soccer Uh kind of in like you're describing
  204. but it does have a build soccer Soccer does have this you see guys build up over the course of a field now.
  205. It doesn't always happen Continually, but when it does like oh, they're getting closer.
  206. There's something happening, but it's slower build than a you know American football drive down the
  207. field I mean do y'all find I think it's less predictive. I mean, maybe I that shows my soccer
  208. naivete, but I feel like During a drive down the field soccer wise because it's back
  209. and forth like i'm I I can less understand Understand. Oh, something's really building here versus not.
  210. It seems more random He wears it like football because it's stop and start and because
  211. there's underlying fundament like, you know How much garbage they're getting and stuff?
  212. I feel like you can kind of get like a lot more sort of like how this is going Information before the outcome is
  213. realized necessarily. Yeah All right, so i'm no big reactions from oddy or eric on that dimension it's
  214. not resonating real strongly one way or the other All right. Um, well, they're baseball guys.
  215. I mean What is baseball? How would you characterize baseball in this respect? I mean Unless the score is tied or
  216. you know, you're you're within a you know Distance that you can and late in the game and late in the game.
  217. It doesn't have that at all It has a sobriety about it So no, yeah, I feel like it's probably gone it's got the
  218. most bimodal bimodal, uh kind of distribution of these rates of win probability where For for
  219. for many game states, you know, you can turn it off in the fifth inning and you you know It's over type of thing
  220. For like what does this what does this say about me and oddy that? Hockey and baseball differ in the degree of
  221. sobriety Hockey as this example is just completely off the rails I think both oddy and
  222. change point is if you have baseball How what how hard is it? Let's say in the first seven innings of
  223. a game for a baseball game to be Considerably beyond 90 win probability pretty hard.
  224. I'm just saying, you know I don't think baseball games get that like another way to
  225. think of it. Kate is like almost like a control chart You put some error bounds and then you
  226. we can I mean this would be easy to do right? Especially with things like speaking of jay jaffe
  227. and fan graphs coming up Imagine you had win probability charts over time for various sports.
  228. You could talk about first time to hit the boundary The number of times to hit the boundary all kinds of things I want
  229. to make just maybe a technical distinction here We're talking about change in win probability not
  230. necessarily win probability exceeding like 95 But like we're not talking about like kind of the
  231. game bearing guaranteed or not because I still think baseball though. It's true that Probably there's very rare kind
  232. of game states where one team has more than like a 95 Chance of winning at the seventh inning to go from that like,
  233. you know, 95 You know to actually kind of build in the other direction is still going to be probably pretty incremental They got
  234. to get guys on base and you know It's like they can't just hit like three grand slams in like a row or something
  235. like that, right? so so I I think I I think you know sort of I still think baseball
  236. is kind of on the slower in terms at least like kind of the Instantaneous rate of change in that that that win probability
  237. Unless you are all you know It's except for those kind of really close games at the end where it can swing like crazy
  238. based on one at bat, you know Yeah, you got to take yourself time. You got to get that walk.
  239. You got to get that bloop You got to get that error. You got to get that i'm describing the
  240. 2001 world series. I'm sorry right now but It's a series of events Yeah I mean or we could
  241. you know, you got you you got you got to get that walk You got to get that stolen base.
  242. You got to get that hit off. Mariano. I feel like we're also describing the 2004
  243. So, hold on hold on eric, let me jump in real quick because oddy just used the term crescendo Yeah, and it reminds me
  244. that our friend and former dean. Jeff garrett had a whole theory of crescendo sports Do you remember this?
  245. This is like going back to our very first year in operation 2014 So jeff is now the big dean at the marshall school
  246. of business at usc and we need to be reminded of what jeff's crescendo theory of
  247. sports was because he definitely had a Notion, he's a political scientist. We had this notion about crescendo nature of
  248. sports. I hadn't thought about it in a while um, okay, eric, you were gonna jump in
  249. no, no, I was just gonna build on shane's point that Is the following seems mathematically
  250. plausible, but I don't know if it's true which is Since baseball, which we all agree
  251. has lower incremental change in probability It probably is not uncorrelated with the fact that it's
  252. hard to get outside certain bounds within a short period of time And so that was
  253. going to be my point is that those facts are related to each other in some way And if you think in the limit,
  254. this is what I if assuming you agree This is what I tell students all the time. Let's imagine that the increment at any particular
  255. time was really tiny Then by definition you couldn't get outside the bounds And so it
  256. helps to build intuition if we think about in the limit if baseball has slower increments
  257. or smaller increments It probably also means It will have less It'll take longer to hit
  258. the boundary. Maybe it's hard to get farther out of the boundary, etc It's the summary of it
  259. is that it has greater sobriety. I think I think that's I know Quantitative term a measure It might be though it
  260. might be why people I don't know that this is directly true or not might be why people Stay at baseball games longer.
  261. Yes, because you know, the win probability is never totally out of reach and You know
  262. in some sense. I don't know. I'm just saying I think there's lots of things that are implications of small increments That's
  263. okay. Okay. So one of these days We'll have a bunch of win probability charts over the course
  264. of a game within game changes in win probability And we can compare these things and
  265. see whether they match our intuitions in the meantime. Jay Jaffe Is joining us jay's based in
  266. brooklyn. He's a senior writer for fangraphs You baseball guys know what fangraphs is if you're not
  267. a baseball guy, but you love sports and likes you I don't know what fangraphs is.
  268. It's a terrific site. It's exactly where I go if I want to find out what's going on in baseball
  269. Jay's been there for a while. He's also written before for the baseball prospectus,
  270. of course And a contributing writer for si he's a recurring guest on the mlb network
  271. He's a member of the bbwaa And he's been a hall of fame voter since 2021 notably and it's going to come up.
  272. He's the creator of jaws That sounds like war the jaffe war score as you've heard
  273. us talk over the years There's multiple ways to do war. There's not one way and there's apparently a
  274. jay jaffe way The boys are going to be interested in that jay welcome back good to see you.
  275. Hey, thanks. Great to be back Love having you. Um My challenge in this half hour is
  276. to see how long I can keep the conversation going on topic other than hall of fame We want to talk hall of fame,
  277. but before we get there Can you give us a little bit of your perspective on the season so far?
  278. We're far enough in to have some thoughts on things. I know you wrote about the phillies I
  279. think last week or earlier this week the philly is experiencing a nice little turnaround with
  280. mattingly. Um Um, i'd be curious about the braves or the braves. What do you what do you what chances
  281. do you give them against the dodgers? Um, so yeah, what else you see? Yeah, we've seen you know, as with every
  282. season I think we've you know We've seen some surprisingly strong starts and some surprisingly weak
  283. ones. I mean the strong ones this year. Uh, the braves are obviously uh, one of them, um the uh, uh The phillies, uh
  284. turn around after a Atypically, uh weak start we're firing the manager and then suddenly going
  285. on a roll with don mattingly Uh big story, uh, the red sox stumbling out of the gate and then firing.
  286. Alex. Cora. Um, Maybe we should have already lowered our expectations for for boston Uh given what's transpired
  287. there over the last half decade, but they did make the playoffs last year Um still
  288. this feels more like an extension of what we've seen Uh in what i'll call the post mookie bets era than uh, uh, you
  289. know, then the uh, uh the the powerhouse, uh uh al east rivalry era Um that preceded it.
  290. Um Uh dodgers off to another strong start although again being given a chase by the
  291. padres um You know, it sets up a I think a very Compelling, you know continues a very compelling rivalry that has so far
  292. withstood Uh the padres instability over the last few years when it comes to managerial changes
  293. and now a pending ownership change um That's that's interesting there. Uh At times we've had everybody in the
  294. nl central above 500 and everybody but the leader in the al central below 500 We
  295. seem to be witnessing a changing of the guard in the al west where the astros Uh are looked like they've reached the end
  296. of their uh long run atop the division Uh, but the mariners have stumbled out of
  297. the gate as well. Um, and the you know, so it's uh, Uh a bit interesting what's going on there.
  298. Um And uh, I guess the mets, uh struggles, uh this year Uh being an extension of uh, the struggles they had after june
  299. the start of june last year. Um I think uh, uh, you know, we're seeing a lot of things go wrong there.
  300. Um Those are some those are some of the stories that i'm that i'm following isn't
  301. the cardinals the biggest The cardals, I think the car. I think the cardals are a nice surprise.
  302. Yes Um, you know, we thought this would be a a year of rebuilding for them Uh as as well, but uh, you know
  303. They've had they've produced a lot of young talent in recent years that just had not
  304. hit its stride and suddenly you know jordan things are coming together for jordan walker, for
  305. example, and uh, um, you know, they are looking like uh, Uh a reasonably strong team
  306. in a division where I think you know one of the expected leaders the cubs have had uh, pitching injuries galore and uh, A
  307. lot of problems on the offensive side as well So let me jump in with one follow-up before eric jumps in here On
  308. the phillies you mentioned in the article. This is one of the best stats i've come across in a while You mentioned the
  309. don mattingly start whenever he came in as a replacement Manager ran 16 for like the
  310. first 20 games 16 and 4 This is the best first 20 games for a replacement manager since 1880 It's almost 150 years It's
  311. absolutely unbelievable that baseball goes back that we have a stat. We have a first time since 1880 almost
  312. 150 years Jay, we talked about this a little bit on the show last week. Can you tell us from your?
  313. wise baseball history perspective What happens when a guy comes in and The club responds this
  314. way like how much of it is the manager effect? And why does the manager have an effect?
  315. We thought the baseball managers didn't do that much. They just turn in a lineup card Yeah,
  316. I don't put a ton of stock into the idea that this is sudden you know that that maddenley is suddenly doing things that
  317. are different than uh, Uh than what rob thompson were doing was doing. I mean maddenley was the bench coach there
  318. He should have been a better bench coach, uh for this first, uh uh 28 games of the season or whatever it was, um
  319. But you know, I think Managers wear out their welcomes and sometimes I think there's a
  320. tendency, you know to tune guys out uh, and you know for there to be I think Small fissures in the clubhouse where you
  321. know, you're just not connecting the same way that you did Uh, we know that there
  322. was at least one personnel conflict, uh that rob thompson had with nick castellanos uh who
  323. uh uh the phillies let go at the beginning of spring training or just before he reported to spring training because they couldn't find
  324. anybody to Take his 19 million dollar salary uh, but there may you know, there may
  325. have been other stuff going on behind the scenes that we haven't heard about and um
  326. You know, but the reality is is that the phillies did very well under thompson 158
  327. percent of the time since he took over in early 22 Uh won a pennant under him Um looked like they were bound for
  328. yet another playoff berth. Um And just weren't up weren't playing up to their potential and so a lot of
  329. what's happened since mattingly took over It's just positive regression and it's maybe guys, you know,
  330. uh Hearing a different voice or just you know, not thinking about the the conflict they
  331. have with the last guy or not thinking about you know, uh this shit again, you know, whatever you're just the way, you know,
  332. you're You you tune somebody out when you're just kind of sick of hearing What they
  333. have to say even when even when you know that they're right. Um You know, so I think that's part
  334. of it Uh, I I think the other thing that and we really should not overlook this Uh with regards to the turnaround is
  335. that the phillies right around, you know, just before thompson was fired Uh, zach wheeler returned,
  336. uh from a recovery from thoracic outlets Syndrome surgery and he replaced taiwan walker who had
  337. a nine plus era Uh, and wheeler has pitched like an ace with a 167 era. I mean that's a huge swing Uh once
  338. every five days and it has downstream effects because of the way, you know, you're getting
  339. you know You're you're you're getting better relievers in there. Um, you know, you're pitching beeper into games
  340. You're not using your bullpen as much with that And so, you know your bullpen is
  341. able to cover some more, you know, some more more ground You've also got christopher sanchez
  342. suddenly on a on a roll 37 and two-thirds scoreless innings. Um You know, so just the phillies suddenly
  343. are getting great pitching and and that's the real difference. Okay, great Eric wants to jump in i'm
  344. just gonna have a comment on what jay said by the way Um the binomial probability
  345. back to your regression issue of a 9 and 19 team if their true strength is roughly around 500 That's only 3.8. It's
  346. not that rare. Let's just say so nine and it's not like they were 2 and 26 Right all
  347. of a sudden so that's just one comment But the second thing I was going to ask you is you going back to the
  348. dodgers? Did they have a luxury as two-time defending champions in the sense of all right?
  349. So the padres beat us in the regular season who really cares like as long as we're healthy And our lineup is set for
  350. the postseason. That's what we should care about Should they be maximizing a different objective function maybe than
  351. other teams that aren't sitting there with both the quality of the team they have And
  352. two championships in the bank Yeah, I think we saw that last year I mean the dodgers were not nearly as strong a regular
  353. season team last year as they were in 2024 and they didn't they didn't push themselves
  354. as hard their focus was on getting their starting pitching Healthy for the playoffs and you
  355. know, they they really slow walked the rehabs of both. Tyler glasnow and blake snell um, and they
  356. wanted they wanted to make sure those guys were available down the stretch and they were
  357. um, they actually had such a surplus of starting pitching, uh by the end of the season with shohei otani also rehabbing from his
  358. uh, elbow reconstruction that uh, they were sending starters to the bullpen, um, you know, I
  359. think they They are I feel like the dodgers. I don't know if it's an organizational strategy
  360. or if it's just the way it is But I think they are more tolerant That they'll sign 14 guys that like seven of
  361. which have real injury like histories instead of just avoiding those and You'll have those seasons
  362. like a couple years ago where they barely made it to the postseason within these starters
  363. and then last year it ended up the luck was better with them and they had a surplus but with even in signing people
  364. like glass now snell you're kind of You're signing up for that like, you know, only
  365. half these guys are going to be Because they because they have uh Because they can
  366. spend so much money and they're not afraid to spend so much money because they're practically
  367. printing it over in japan um, you know with uh, uh the benefits of otani and yamamoto and sasaki Um, you know, they can
  368. take on more risk and they've done that and you know at the same time they've also continued to produce Uh useful major league
  369. pitchers from their farm system from their drafts, uh and to trade for some as well
  370. And so, you know, they've they've got decent filler guys to you know to help them
  371. ride out the leaner spots um You know last year we saw the padres give them chase for for most of the season And
  372. you know the dodgers they didn't go out and make a huge deadline deal. Um, they didn't go out and You know,
  373. they didn't panic and they you know, it ended up being that they had to win an extra round Of playoffs, you know, they
  374. they you know waxed the reds in the wild card series but I think they got kind of lucky with the with with the
  375. draw with the phillies who didn't have wheeler who were suddenly without Wheeler and who had
  376. some other built-in flaws and you know had never figured out how to get a productive outfield on that team uh last year
  377. and then of course you've got um, you know the the the kerkering play and the uh, the great wheel play that uh defensive
  378. play that they put in and And you know that series was closer than the final three games to one outcome um, and from
  379. there the dodgers just rolled, you know, I mean they just they just didn't look like
  380. they they had uh, uh much trouble in the uh Excuse me the nlscs the world series was you know, one of the all
  381. -time Uh classics and that one, you know could have gone either way down to the final pitch.
  382. So You know, it just worked out for them odd okay, so, um, you know, we united did a nice overview of the season
  383. but one of the things that that and We always ask ourselves is why what makes a team a perpetual winner?
  384. And uh caden, uh, you talked about you know Maybe the general manager the manager the
  385. manager doesn't count who does this but the the theme for me right now is Something
  386. that I that I point out every year when I teach this to my students where we do a payroll adjusted Team quality score
  387. over the last 25 years And if you do that, there are three teams that just stick out leading starting with the a's Followed
  388. by the braves and the cardinals and there they are again Doing it again. You didn't mention the a's you I reminded
  389. you about the cardinals. What do you think about these teams? you were talking about I mean There's so
  390. many years of not every year, of course, but but just on aggregates so frequently I
  391. thought the guardians were in there as well. Are they not the guardians? The guardians are not quite for 25 years
  392. They're more recent So if you go back to the start of my my my data set goes back to um after the last
  393. strike So 95 said the rays I might have said the rays and the rays are also and but the rays are also much
  394. more recent They were horrible for the first you know, so those those are and so
  395. what is it about these teams? Is it analytics? Is it farm system? Is it ownership?
  396. What what I think it's I think it's different I think it's different in the in in in those cases.
  397. I mean, I think the a's You know the name of your podcast I think is still a reminder of what of the a's
  398. got Uh a huge advantage from being early adopters, uh when it came to analytics in
  399. the so-called moneyball era um, and they have you know, they have uh, always Done
  400. their best to try to get uh, you know as much of an edge as they can despite being underfinanced and despite now You
  401. know being nomadic um, you know and they've and they've uh, They've had to invest in
  402. you know, you know perpetually turn over the roster and invest in young talent And right
  403. now they've got some of the best young talent they've had in a while um, you know, there's there's still only 27 and 27
  404. in an al west where um, the astros and Mariners are having you know, serious problems.
  405. Um But uh, you know, they've done well for themselves. I mean the cardinals I think are are
  406. Maybe less analytically inclined Uh more farm system oriented. Um, we've seen that farm system.
  407. I think Dry up somewhat in recent years. Um, you know, uh, jordan walker and nolan
  408. gorman and uh, uh, you know, I think we're until this year pretty much busts in terms of what they'd given to the cardinals
  409. at the major league level the last few years and uh, That really held the team back um you know in the the free
  410. agent investments they made or the the uh, veteran acquisitions that they uh, uh stuck stuck
  411. out for like, um, yeah paul goldschmidt and nolan arenado Uh kind of went south, uh
  412. a little bit more quickly than than we would have expected um Braves though. They're a great example.
  413. I mean they've they've done a magnificent job of uh growing Uh, you know through the
  414. farm system they always seem to come up with more pitching Uh, they've done they made
  415. some great trades. I mean, you know, it was a shock when they let freddie freeman, uh jumped to
  416. the dodgers um But the uh, the braves made a great trade for matt olsen. Who's a guy who?
  417. um You know can it can hit 50 bombs in a season and plays better defense than any other first baseman in the majors
  418. probably Um, you know, they gave up talent for that including the a's uh, uh, shay
  419. langoliers, uh the catcher Um, but uh, they came up with another catcher of their own
  420. in in drake baldwin last year's nl rookie of the year um You know and they they had a bad year last year.
  421. Uh, but they are you know, right back, uh in contention this year and uh, uh, despite uh, uh some injuries to the pitching
  422. staff they've been without uh, Uh spencer schwellenbach, uh, they've had uh, you know, they were
  423. they were without spencer strider for a while Uh, they had some other injuries in there.
  424. Um, yeah, they look uh Like they're back to being you know, the professional contenders that
  425. we assumed they were coming into last year Jay, let's chat a little bit. I know the boys want to ask you
  426. hall of fame questions And let me just start with a simple question for the least
  427. hall of fame oriented person here What is different about your war model? So the jaffe war model jaws, what yeah
  428. So it's not just it's not just war war is the war is the currency that I use but I measure players uh using
  429. both their career war Uh and their peak war which I define as a player's best seven seasons at large not necessarily consecutive um
  430. because uh Peak ability and peak, you know peak performance Uh really is I think what
  431. separates the goods from the greats? Um, you know those those those huge seasons
  432. that that help propel a team towards a pennant Can I react real quickly? Why seven?
  433. I might have thought peak would be more peaked than seven Well, you know, I I it's a it was basically a sweet spot
  434. that I that I kind of found Uh, I originally when I when I started with jaws, um back in 2003 when I was
  435. at baseball prospectus Or early 2004, I guess I should say. Um I was using best five years consecutively
  436. Uh with some minor adjustments for injuries and military service because you got a lot of
  437. guys who missed a few key prime years there Uh, I changed that to best of seven Uh, I moved on from baseball prospectus
  438. and switched to baseball references version of war. Um Seven seemed to be a good spot
  439. early on Uh when it came to differentiating Differentiating between career value and and the peak
  440. value Um, you know, you've got a lot of guys who had a few great seasons um, and you've got um A lot of
  441. guys who had great careers, you know You you want to try to find a a measure that gives you a slightly different answer
  442. from just going by career war Yeah that helps to explain You know your short career
  443. high peak guys like some of the ones who are you know Like sandy koufax is a good example and the system doesn't work
  444. quite as well now um Because the baseline for replacement level changed when I moved from
  445. bp to baseball reference Um, but i've stuck with seven because it still works pretty well
  446. Um, the more years you add to peak The more it tends to resemble Your career measure anyway, like if you're going 10 years,
  447. for example, you might as well You might as well just be measuring by 10 years. Um And if you go five you don't
  448. differentiate enough seven is just a convenient sweet spot, okay Okay, very good.
  449. Uh, shane has a question here Well, I guess I guess I mean since we're talking about hall of fame Now anyway, my I
  450. have a general question How many current hall of famers are or how many hall how
  451. many hall of famers are currently playing? And is that number kind of small or big relative to historically?
  452. What it's been I mean Though that's kind of lead into maybe talking about pitching.
  453. Yeah, so okay. So the long long if you look at the 150 plus years of major league baseball
  454. uh, what we see is Roughly when it's all said and done you get about one and a half to two major league hall
  455. of famers per team per season um just in in terms of like It could be as little as a few as one appearance,
  456. uh, or as many as playing 162 games, but That's the long-term average and in the 20s to the 40s um, you've got
  457. uh well above two and briefly above three, um what you see when you get to the 1990s and onward is uh, that level
  458. dips below one and well below one and a lot of that just has to do with the fact that you know that uh,
  459. uh the post bbwa eligibility format, uh, by which I mean the era committee and before
  460. that the veterans committee, uh, Just has not had its chance to admit all the players
  461. that it's going to uh at any given point So these are not settled numbers yet. Um But it's also true that they're just
  462. not and they're even with the writers electing more players than ever In in their history
  463. over a longer term, uh, the era committees are not electing as many players um and
  464. we're missing a whole bunch of players because of uh, steroid related uh, uh, you know
  465. performance and infractions and so we've lost some so my assumption generally is that we're probably
  466. looking at uh, Roughly one to 1.3 hall of famers per team uh So we should be looking at about 40 future hall
  467. of famers at any given time now I don't think we're actually going to get to that number Um, I think you're probably looking
  468. at somewhere closer to 25 or so future hall of famers and many of whom we can name off the top of our heads
  469. and some of whom I think will come out of the pack and uh, uh surprise us with their you know, incredible resilience or
  470. or or whatever and and Um, just so you know shane I had a feeling you might ask this question Only reason I say
  471. that is because I literally have up on my screen because I was thinking someone might
  472. ask this because I was Going to ask j related question. There are currently 15 major league players with
  473. a war Of 53 and above and by the way that 15th right now is jose altuve Who I think most of us think
  474. is likely to be a hall of famer Um, yeah, but then you have guys Yeah, for sure, but then you have guys like
  475. oh as this is jay's other point like juan soto who's not there yet But he's very obviously very likely to get there But
  476. i'd say for me I was gonna ask j a similar question shane I think there's a lot more hall of famers right now
  477. than i've seen in the last 10 years I mean, I think there's easily I would have thought i'm glad you told me her
  478. historical numbers I would have said the fact that there's 20 to 25 guys now playing
  479. that are Very likely to make the whole of them. I thought that was a big number, but
  480. you're saying that's not wouldn't be a historic Historically speaking. It's not I mean, I I don't know
  481. how it compares exactly to recent years because again, you know, we're working with uh, uh
  482. about a 30 year lag, uh when it comes to that stuff even for You know for to get a I think a usable
  483. number. Um and uh You know even so, you know when you're talking about, you know, a
  484. five-year waiting period and a 10-year eligibility period You've got a minimum of a
  485. 15-year lag for for some of this stuff to resolve itself um So it's a it's it's tough, you know, I think I
  486. think we have changed the way that the bbwa functions in terms of recognizing Good candidates
  487. soon, you know for the hall of fame sooner. We had a swell. It was something like 22 Players elected over
  488. a six or seven year period there Which was the largest surge in recent history and
  489. that was even with um, you know so many candidates being rejected for their ped connections,
  490. um You know, we saw guys we saw guys get in on the strength of War instead of just their career offensive totals, uh
  491. guys who maybe did not Get to play until they're 40 and approach 3 000 hits guys like larry walker and scott roland and
  492. todd helton who put up elite numbers Uh in part because they were very good defensively
  493. as well um You know, they didn't necessarily reach the major offensive milestones that would have
  494. put them into the hall, but the error committees You know function differently and and largely
  495. outside of the bbwa is uh, uh purview that we contribute um, you know a few voters per cycle, but uh, the hall of
  496. fame itself is who's choosing that voting body and its behaviors as i've documented before are
  497. quirky to say the least and Uh subject to the hall's heavy hand when it comes to picking who actually serves on those committees.
  498. So You know, I don't think everything, you know things have changed, uh quite as much
  499. there in in that way, okay odd All right So I have a a bunch of things to talk about Um, i'm going to
  500. go backwards in time and point out that I I also think seven is too long But I would also say that I think
  501. it probably needs to differ by position so that that um, particularly say starting pitchers, I
  502. would imagine a shorter period of dominance is is It could define the the peak as
  503. opposed to maybe a hitter where you might want to have a little bit longer um, I built my own hall of fame metric
  504. for starting pitchers, um, And we call it based on grid war which is a a war calculated on a per game basis It's
  505. only for starting pitchers and the couple curiosities that come out of it is Um, well,
  506. i'll just say i've talked about this in our show. Um, There's one pitcher that is so firmly
  507. in the top group. I mean in the deserving pile that's not in it And it's not roger clemens because
  508. of other reasons That's kevin brown and I always I want to ask you about that because people will say the pde usage Yes,
  509. he was in the mitchell report but he's certainly not in that top tier or even second tier of known kind of abusers of
  510. of um of performance enhancing drugs so He was blown away on his first round and
  511. most people point to the fact that he never won. Cy young's he's He's so good because of
  512. modern analytics. It goes back and looks what he did at the time He did it and say
  513. my god I mean, he's not pedro But but he's he's not that far behind at least in terms of his peak in the
  514. late 90s And he had a wonderfully long career. He was terrific Put together a huge career.
  515. I enjoyed him immensely on the o4 yankees. Yeah, you did that was past his priority
  516. past his prime But what what do you so I guess I want to reflect on kevin brown and then my guess my next
  517. question would be Um, what which starting pitcher is most deserving that uh, that is not
  518. in the hall of fame Yeah, well let me preface that by saying that starting pitching
  519. is an area that is kind of in a crisis when it comes to the hall of fame stuff and that's why I think
  520. one more reason why we're going to fall short of the historic averages is because The
  521. way that pitcher workloads have changed these guys. I mean we're seeing the disappearance of the
  522. 200 inning guy uh to say nothing of the 20 win guy, um And so we're getting shorter careers.
  523. These guys are throwing harder. They're more susceptible to injury There's all kinds
  524. of stuff going on there. Uh, and traditional, uh, my even my traditional jaws, uh Does not do a great job
  525. because it's kind of over balanced towards these heavy workload guys. Um I've sort of adjusted for that.
  526. Um by capping Uh each player's peak season at 250 innings and scaling down for that
  527. and even then after uh after clayton kershaw Uh, justin verlander mack scherzer and zach granke
  528. disappear from the scene It's not obvious who the next hall of fame starting pitcher is
  529. going to be um And I chris sale Chris sale chris sale is probably yeah, I would have said garrett cole before the tommy
  530. john surgery now I think chris sales probably surpassed him but sales probably not going to
  531. get to 200 wins And we haven't had a starting pitcher elected with fewer than 200
  532. wins, you know pitcher wins are not a great measure of value and and Excellence, but
  533. uh just as a common benchmark Um, I think we're seeing we're seeing a big change
  534. there now back to kevin brown uh brown had The mitchell report working against him.
  535. He also had um Kind of a crash and burn with that seven-year 105 million dollar contract Um because he was injured so
  536. often Um before that yeah, he was one of the top pitchers in the game. The other thing though.
  537. I mean, you know besides the uh, uh Turning his hand into a morocca during the uh, the the 2004, uh, alcs collapsed by
  538. the yankees um is brown Loathed the media and vice versa and wasn't going to get
  539. an inch of slack from the voters um And so it really wasn't that surprising uh Particularly just because of the mitchell report that
  540. he went one and done um andy pettit on the other hand perceived as a nice guy also in the mitchell report nowhere near
  541. as good a pitcher as Uh as kevin brown was at his peak but you know had uh longevity had a lot of postseason,
  542. uh accomplishments to his name and has stuck around long enough that You know, I don't
  543. I wouldn't predict him for the hall based on the fact that uh, he does have still have the ped I would put I
  544. for me, but don't listen to me. I would put jacob degrom And I would put king felix in the hall of fame
  545. Yeah, you know, those are shorter career guys and it's gonna it's it's going to take
  546. that i'm it's it's good It's you know, it's it's going to I mean we saw felix get above 50 this year It's going
  547. to take you know It's taking a change in the electorate's thinking to start to come
  548. around to these shorter career guys And I think we're seeing the the the the tip
  549. of it here I don't know that it gets down to jacob degrom and fewer than 100 wins But it may well get down
  550. to felix hernandez and what is you know? 150 wins give or take with you know, the excellence that he had I think I
  551. think the thing is though is you have to go back is is once you get once you start Electing those guys you have
  552. to rethink all the guys From the last 40 years who came and went who were every bit as dominant as felix um and
  553. didn't have as long of careers as The 300 game winners who did get elected i'm thinking about guys like johan santana.
  554. Yeah Who went one and done come on? Dave steve. There it is. That's the man steve who was you know
  555. It was probably the best pitcher of the 1980s But never even won a cy young, uh, david cone Uh, even dwight gooden ups
  556. and downs, uh all in there, right? Um, these are all there are a lot of great pitch and and there and the
  557. way that the error committees are set up There is really no way that we can equitably reconcile that lost generation or two of
  558. pitchers, uh, and whether they're fit for the hall with Whether we're talking about andy pennant
  559. or felix hernandez or jacob de grum You got guys that are that are clearly superior
  560. to them that we're never going to get a chance to vote for Because they went one and done on the error committee on
  561. the bbwa ballots and those guys Generally don't get reconsidered by the error committee and when
  562. they do it's they're long shots. They're rounding out the ballots. Um, you know ted simmons is the only
  563. one to go that route and get in the hall of fame and he had uh, a significant booster on the error committee in
  564. rick hummel the uh, uh long time, uh, Uh beat writer for the cardinals and it takes it.
  565. It takes almost a miracle to get in But you have to you have to present it as like a rethinking like so Oh,
  566. yeah No, we are you have to present it like like kevin brown was was not considered obviously He was an he didn't like
  567. the media and mitchell report but he didn't I mean you look at his career and He he was never considered the dominant pitcher
  568. of his era until you recognized that he had no run support and that all of a Sudden wins wasn't the only way to
  569. judge a pitcher Um, and it's like a reflection on how we actually think of pitcher
  570. quality has to be retroactively moved backwards I mean you can't I mean you can't think
  571. of jacob degrom as good as he is Santana was better. I mean, I mean, yeah, but I think
  572. It's not that we didn't recognize that kevin brown was not a great pitcher I mean,
  573. you know, he had won two era titles uh was second third And Second and third and a bunch of sixth in the cy
  574. young award led, uh led the league in war twice, uh b war that is um You know, he was in those conversations he
  575. just you know, it was there were also there were other great pitchers at the time
  576. like randy johnson and uh, uh and mike messina and Whoever that you know that helped
  577. steal the thunder. Um But I do think that some of it just still comes down unfortunately to personality
  578. And Because the error committee can be selective or because the committee that makes the ballot
  579. for the error committee to be to to process Can be as selective as they want I don't see that they're going to cut
  580. kevin. I don't see that they're going to give kevin brown a shot That's the problem.
  581. Um, you know, they they can look at kevin brown and say yeah, he's a mitchell report guy He's never going to get in
  582. because we keep voting down all these all these guys You know who who tested positive
  583. or who were in the mitchell report or whatever? They have every excuse to not put him
  584. on there and just recycle somebody else and it's i'm not saying that's fair I'm, just
  585. saying that's the reality that i'm up against. We'll let jay go We've got him up
  586. here longer than we expected to have him and it was great talking to you Jay, appreciate you making time for us.
  587. Jay jaffe senior writer for fangraphs author of the cooperstown case book creator of jaws the
  588. jaffe war score um hall of fame voter member of bbwaa Often guest on mlb network
  589. great gotta follow if you're interested in baseball and baseball analytics That's been the show that's
  590. been this week's show appreciate your being here for the whole crew. How do you want her?
  591. Shane jensen eric randall This has been kade massey for aaron tran running the board today
  592. for us d patel The boss lady in here in the studio with us appreciate it and marissa reyna our producer Thanks to you
  593. guys the listeners come back and join us next time between now and then enjoy your
  594. sports

Brief Summary

Hosts discuss NHL playoffs and MLB season updates with guest Jay Jaffe from FanGraphs.

Key points

  • Welcome to Wharton Moneyball. The hosts introduce the show and set the stage for sports analytics discussions.
  • Guest Jay Jaffe Joins the Show. Jay Jaffe, a renowned sports analytics writer, will join in the second half.
  • Excitement in Sports. The hosts discuss the current sports landscape, including NBA, NHL, and World Cup.
  • Hockey Playoffs Discussion. The hosts reflect on their enjoyment of the hockey playoffs and specific games.
  • Expected Goals in Hockey. A discussion on the concept of expected goals and its implications for goalie performance.
  • Hockey's Unique Scoring Dynamics. Hockey's scoring is rare and can change win probability dramatically in seconds.

Episode highlights

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes