Inside College Football’s Data-Driven Evolution and Decision-Making

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Ty Hildenbrandt, co-host of The Solid Verbal college football podcast, joins Cade Massey, Adi Wyner, and Eric Bradlow to explore how sports analytics—from evaluating Indiana’s national championship run to in-game decision-making, quarterback development, coaching philosophy, and the transfer portal—are reshaping the future of college football.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#footballanalytics #footballcoaching #collegefootball #secfootball ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
  2. network. This is Kade Massie hosting this week with my two two of my three co-host, Audi Winer and Eric Bradlo.
  3. Shane Jensen is in the classroom. I believe we're going to be juggling recording between Audi and Shane classes
  4. for the next few weeks. Eric on his off days from recording with us is doing like 14 sections of NBAs as he always
  5. does this >> all mornings. But I 8:30 to noon, >> but he bills around the show. That's
  6. real commitment right there, Eric Bradlo. Um, so I'm the only schmuck here not teaching. I'm I'm reing in that
  7. right now. This is a month without teaching. Good for I don't know, watching football and thinking about
  8. sports analytics. Let's do some of that. We're at the very end of the football season. We're going to we're recording
  9. on Tuesday afternoon as we usually do. The show will go up on Wednesday. Last night was the national championship game
  10. for the end of the college football season. And we're going to have a friend of the show, an an oldtime guest, an
  11. in-person guest, one of the few repeat in-person guests we had back in the day. Ty Hildenbrandt, co-host of the Solid
  12. Verbal, wildly popular College Football podcast, Solid Verbal. Ty is joining us at the top of the hour, which is about a
  13. half an hour from now. We're going to talk college football then, so we'll hold off a little bit, though. I am
  14. curious whether my guys here watched any of the game. Hey you baseball people, you watched any college football last
  15. night? >> I did. >> Both of them saying >> shockingly that I did by the way cuz I'm
  16. not a you know you know I'm not a college football but I watched the championship.
  17. >> Well, we're bringing you around when we first started doing the show 14 years
  18. ago. You weren't that much of a pro football guy and we brought you deep into that and so college is just around
  19. the corner from that. >> You know fun game. >> It's uh there's a lot of great research
  20. questions in football. Yes. Right. >> It really does cross over what I consider like the big four pillars of of
  21. analytics and football really can tackle all of them. >> Give us the four pillars of analytics.
  22. >> Well, um the four I call the four pillars. So historical evaluation. So why people won and who, what, where,
  23. why, and what's happened in the past. Um and then future evaluation. So who will
  24. win and and what drives what predicts future winning. That's kind of the big innovation of analytics is to get away
  25. from the history and move to prediction. But I do think they've overstepped. They've gone too far away to forecasting
  26. and not enough kind of contemplation of the past. I think that's just as equally
  27. interesting. >> That that fits your baseball conservatism. That fits you very well.
  28. Contemplate the past. Contemplate the past, people. >> Indeed. And and then of course um uh
  29. decision game analytics and football is just abundant in that just why the why you make the decisions you make and
  30. which are the right ones. Um and there's more analytics. It's hard. What's the last one? Uh the last one is training
  31. analytics. How do you get players to become better? >> I was going to say it's hard to do three
  32. or four without two. >> Uh yeah. Well, you know, true. True is sort two is sort of the big one, right?
  33. The future, but is the predictive two is the predictive predictive. But decision
  34. analytics are fascinating. And I think spaceball is is is much more meager on that score. um in terms of like in-game
  35. decision- making. Not not that there's nothing. There's plenty of like stolen bases and um sort of strategic things in
  36. key situations, but football's got that in spades over really any other. >> Can you say more about that because I
  37. I'm I honestly get a little tired of fourth down and two-point discussions because that that's what people obsess
  38. about. >> Sure. Because that that I think there's been a huge huge uh improvement and and
  39. noticeable on the field. In fact, yesterday's final game was essentially decided by a
  40. >> Oh, Aie, you blanked out there for a second. It was decided by the what? >> The game yesterday, wasn't it decided on
  41. a fourth and five conversion? >> I mean, that was one of the crucial plays in the game. You could argue
  42. Parson Beck's >> interception was decided >> by wide open if he throws it seven yards
  43. farther could have also decided the game. But do you think for a moment if it hadn't been for analytics they would
  44. have ever have contemplated a fourth and five conversion? >> That's an interesting question. I mean
  45. it's not like signetti is this major analytics guy but it may maybe that whole discussion has just has has
  46. lowered the threshold for going for it on fourth down and he clearly debated it. He was he had the field goal team on
  47. there for a moment. >> Um phenomenal phenomenal. You know, there was this there is this an aspect
  48. of that decision that that wasn't talked about on the broadcast I was watching anyway, but is we've talked about it a
  49. few years ago. People raised this. If he had kicked a field goal, they've been up
  50. six and so they a touchdown would have lost. If if they didn't get it and they were just three, the other team might
  51. have settled for a field goal. There's this idea that when a team's down by more than three, they play more
  52. aggressively and it actually can hurt the team that's leading because the aggressive play leads them to score more
  53. and six is kind of a precarious position to sit in if that's true. >> Well, that's strategic right there. And
  54. you were talking about other ones. There's of course there's two-point conversions. It's not fourth down
  55. conversion. That's also a big one. But the mixture of play calling, I mean, isn't that the most important and most
  56. fascinating? >> I I was hoping you were going to go there because I don't think there's been
  57. enough on that. And um it's but it's really really hard and you know fans are basically just fans want them to call
  58. the touchdown play. And so if it only goes for one yard they didn't call the touchdown play. They did the wrong
  59. thing. Fans don't reason about this in a very sophisticated way and it's hard to
  60. reason about it in a sophisticated way because it's super game game theoretic. Right.
  61. >> Right. And even so I'll mention some uh um a paper written by our our our friends and colleagues out in CMU. They
  62. they analyze using big datable the entropy of the count to of the quarterback, right? So they count in
  63. until they decide to to to snap the ball. And they had that data and they they argued, I think, fairly
  64. persuasively that the more entropy, meaning the more unpredictable your your snap, the much more
  65. >> the cadence, you're talking about the quarterback's cadence, as he calls the snap. Right. Right. This was this year's
  66. research. >> What was the outcome of that? It leads to more what? I assume better outcomes.
  67. better outcomes, more unpredictable play calling and and um there's just a fundamental game theory of it is um in
  68. football is so rich and I think probably thing that that's an obstacle is that we
  69. don't really have the the data per perhaps and um and and no one really runs experiments. Experiments would
  70. would help us really start to solve some of these questions, but it's impossible
  71. to get >> Well, it's a little bit like Audi or are there is there anybody I think would you
  72. would you agree that in baseball is this true? Is this true in baseball that the
  73. pitcher couldn't could probably not do better? Could they do better than just truly randomizing their pitch selection?
  74. >> They probably do randomizing. I mean, you have to be careful with that because
  75. certain combinations are really really overwhelming in one direction, right? So, you can't just so conditional on a
  76. >> okay on a distribution like you this this hitter needs to see the slider because he's really weak against the
  77. slider and hits fast balls more. But given that absolute randomization, full randomization is is is much better than
  78. anything. >> And and with tennis, same thing like on down the down the middle line versus the
  79. outside, whatever the right terminology for those things is. Aren't they haven't
  80. studies been done that showed that high-end tennis players more or less do randomize that? I mean, they're really
  81. good at that, right? >> Actually was reading an article on this very recently. I don't know how it came
  82. across my desk that that showed that the top players are excellent at this and the best college players are also good
  83. at they're just as good. >> Well, Audi, what they're it's not just randomization. The hardest shot to hit
  84. in tennis is what's called the redirect. So, for example, Cade hits his we're both right-handed. Kades hits his
  85. forehand crosscourt to my forehand. And then for me to redirect that ball straight down the line, whether it's on
  86. the forehand or backhand side, that's always been the winning shot in tennis. And whoever can redirect the ball down
  87. the line first, that's the winning shot in tennis. And that's what you need to do. But unfortunately, it's really hard
  88. to do. And also, this the the sides of the net are higher than the B than the center of the net. The net goes like
  89. this. And so it's also harder to hit the ball over the sides of the net. >> Okay. So hold on. So you're saying now
  90. forget but forget about the serve. When you're playing baseline just returning shots with the other side, you have to
  91. decide whether to stay across court or take it down the line. And that that is a randomization choice as well.
  92. Interesting. Super. Okay. So this was a bit of a digression, but let's let's stop it there. This AI gave us Audi's
  93. four pillars of sports analytics. If you missed it, it was descriptive, predictive, in-game decision-making, and
  94. training. So, we often talk about the first two in one bin, and they're kind of being we often talk about there being
  95. three. Audi has parsed that first one because descriptive merits its own land. Audi thinks we should contemplate the
  96. past more. We'll leave it there for now. Odd. Um, okay. Let's talk about NFL. So,
  97. the the divisional round was this weekend. We had some a couple of phenomenal games and a couple of less
  98. phenomenal games. Any responses? We got the championship lineup here. The Pats made it through against the Broncos who
  99. were quarterbackless or not completely quarterbackless, but practically. And the Rams made it through against
  100. Seattle. I've seen Well, before we talk about those games, anything from the weekend, what stood out to you from the
  101. weekend other than Caleb Friaking Williams at the end of regulation, which is one of the most dramatic moments I
  102. can remember in football? >> Well, just a couple quick things on that. So, first, um, at least according
  103. to, uh, you know, I I don't know if I'm going to make this a segment for me, but
  104. what the heck, um, I'm going to ask Chat GPT every week to give me the top five most improbable things that happened in
  105. sports this week. I'm going to ask it for that. What the hell? Maybe it's interesting, maybe it's not interesting.
  106. >> You think it's going to be good at finding those? >> No, not that great. Um, but it did, but
  107. the third one it did list was the they called it the past of the century. Someone must have called it that. And
  108. that was the Caleb Williams uh 51 yard completion, running backwards, all kinds of things. Yeah, that was just an
  109. incredible. >> So, just let's note hilariously, as the commenter said on at real time, it went
  110. down as a 14 yard completion even though it traveled 50 yards in the air. >> Yeah. Just just so everyone knows, I
  111. mean, I I was talking about it with a bunch of people afterwards. I think there's probably only three
  112. quarterbacks, maybe four in the NFL that could have even made that play. Forget whether, you know, I think Josh Allen
  113. could make that play, could like run around enough and then throw it. I think >> you're saying that the two qualities are
  114. he has to have some escapability and a huge arm. >> Correct. I think Josh Allen could make
  115. that play. I think Lamar Jackson could make that play. Um I'm not convinced of anybody else in the NFL. Rogers has the
  116. arm and earlier in his career >> earlier in his career I would have and matter of fact he made plays similar to
  117. that I would have put him in that bin but that's a that's about it but the thing you know a couple things one is um
  118. did they consider going for two cuz remember they scored that touchdown with 18 seconds left that put them down
  119. one they kicked the extra point to go into overtime and I actually liked um Ben Johnson, the Bears coach answer, and
  120. I agreed with him in this case. So, you'll find I think you'll like his answer, too. I don't know if you know,
  121. but they were horrific on fourth down in that game. Like, I'm pretty sure they were stopped every single time. Maybe
  122. they made it once, maybe. And his comment was, "We weren't doing that well on short yardage plays. What makes me
  123. think that all of a sudden with the game on the line, we're going to be able to get two yards when we've tried it a
  124. bunch of times in this game and didn't get it? >> I mean, >> what what's the motivation in general?
  125. Because in you like that you like that decision if your team is disadvantaged in some way, like marketkedly
  126. disadvantaged, I guess, is when you would plan to do that. But Chicago one, they're the home team. Yes, they were
  127. the underdog, but they're the home team. And they'd played LA relatively comparably to that point, have they not?
  128. It wasn't obvious to me that they needed to, you know, strike when they had the opportunity or or go out swing it. That
  129. just the the the commenter suggested it on the show and I was I was surprised by
  130. it. So, give me your thinking. >> Aren't the baseline probabilities roughly a wash?
  131. >> The conversion probability is roughly 50%. >> And then the overtime probability is
  132. roughly 50%, and the the three the obviously the conver the one the extra point is nearly it's 97%.
  133. >> It's close. this close to work. >> So, so I in situations like this when you're on the edge of a of a knife, this
  134. is when you're supposed to say we haven't been doing it at fourth down that matters.
  135. >> So, this but so Audi but Audi's importing Brill Winer wisdom here that says >> when I was listening to him I was
  136. thinking Audi would agree with that. Audi would agree with this kind of I'll call it localized information. Maybe
  137. localized and current information. >> Okay. I want I want to say this is a I mean this is what I loved about that
  138. paper is that this is basically humility for modelers. It's like recognize that so it's easy for us to say oh here comes
  139. the coach talking about the wind you know it's like overriding the model because of the wind or whatever but
  140. that's not what's going on here. The model is so knife edge as odd says that you have to consider contextual stuff.
  141. So sometimes that all that context which some people get buried in to get kind of
  142. swamped by isn't appropriate and sometimes it is and it depends on how definitive the model is. That's really
  143. >> by design it also makes it to go for the extra point. Let me say why. It used to
  144. be as you guys remember it used to be in pro football that in overtime if you got
  145. the ball first and scored a touchdown the game was over. But that's no longer true. you score a touchdown and the
  146. other team still gets the ball. As a matter of fact, you should always defer because always because now you know what
  147. you need to do. Matter of fact, if they get six and one, you could decide to go for six and two. If they get three, you
  148. know, you need at least three. So the the overtime rules have changed to make it even more favorable to even if you're
  149. the unlucky coin toss loser. Like they've made it so that there's it's more equitable in overtime is all I'm
  150. saying. Cuz otherwise if you didn't get the coin toss, you might as well forget about overtime. You typically lost game.
  151. >> Well, in seasons of in Bills just got knocked out for the sixth year in a row
  152. and one of their being knocked out was because of those early. In fact, the reason they changed the rules is because
  153. they were knocked out without having a chance to even touch the ball in overtime. Let's talk about the Bills.
  154. They lost again and again in heartbreaking fashion, controversial fashion in overtime with a a hard to
  155. fathom interception decision and then probably equally hard to fathom pass interference call. Um they go down uh
  156. the Broncos in the process lose their quarterback Boon next in the next last play which is unbelievable and then the
  157. Bills fired their coach and this was a coach there's some stats that came up in the in the days after this game even
  158. before they fired the coach. The Bills have the most points scored in the NFL over the last six years and the least
  159. points allowed in the NFL over the last six years. They have by far the greatest
  160. point differential in the NFL. They've been to >> playoff wins maybe >> most playoff wins surely. They've been
  161. to the divisional round every year, the championship round a couple of years in that run and they fired their coach. Um,
  162. so that's the main thing that I'm stuck with coming out of this other than just the heartbreak. I should read out one of
  163. the texts on from one of these Buffalo text threads. I I I'll I'll dig this up, but the pain and anguish is just so so
  164. bad. Eric, what were your thoughts on the Bills? Well, I hate to say it because I love him as a
  165. player. Josh Allen cost them that game. >> He did. Well, he might have. I mean, who
  166. knows what they would have done without him, but no, his his mistakes. I mean, that
  167. >> his mistakes his his fumble at the end of the first half, giving up three points is inexcusable. Um,
  168. >> did Eric, did anybody talk to him about why he was running the ball? Any He can't run in that situation. They didn't
  169. have timeouts. They didn't have you can't break the line of scrimmage. So, what the heck was he doing? Right. And
  170. forget the fact they tried to l it or whatever he did there. Just what is he doing? And that three points made a huge
  171. difference in the game. The other thing was that I know you saw this Cade. I don't I don't I don't want to put up I'd
  172. have to watch it again cuz I've only seen it like twice or three times, but he missed a wideopen receiver for a
  173. touchdown with 15 seconds left in the game. That ends the game. I mean, the game's over and the guy it it has to be.
  174. I don't say it has to be, but it sort of if you're Josh Allen and you're supposedly the MVP and the best
  175. quarterback in the NFL, you must make that throw. >> And he missed him. Look, it reminded me
  176. of Baker Mayfield the entire season. That throw was Baker Mayfield cuz I watched every Bucks game the entire
  177. season. Guys are open deep and he's overthrowing them. >> Okay, but there's a I there there's a
  178. difference here and this is something Brian Burke worked on when motion trucking first came out. Brian worked on
  179. this. I don't know what's come of it, but I'm sure some cool stuff has come of it where you can begin to evaluate did
  180. the quarterback go to the highest value added place. And that's going to be some
  181. combination of the probability of completing the pass and then the value of the play if you do complete the pass.
  182. And so for the first time, we're beginning to be, you know, kind of backseat drivers on did the quarterback
  183. go in the right place. I don't know what the baseline base rate for that is, Eric. I the base rate is not 100%. the
  184. best quarterbacks in the history of the game. >> I didn't say I I know, but this is what
  185. my reservation about that critique is. It's inevitable that sometimes the QB is going to miss the obvious guy and and if
  186. it happens in a >> key moment. Well, you know, who's to know why that happened? It could the guy
  187. can't see everything on the field, but I'm curious. I don't know the answer. It seems to me that the base rate, I don't
  188. know, among the very top quarterbacks is probably quite high, but substantially short of one. Like I would guess
  189. threequarters of the time. >> Yeah. >> Or the very best quarterbacks. >> Okay. But here's the question. I mean
  190. here and this is this is a when I'm teaching this is one of my favorite examples. It's what I call the
  191. uncontrolled comparison. >> In other words, you make a statement that sounds very plausible. He should
  192. have missed. He's a great quarterback. He should not miss an open receiver. The implication is we know that the the that
  193. this is usually done three quarters, but I'm not sure we do. And I think it would
  194. be quite surprising to me if it's that high. uh being a quarterback is and what I'm really actually intrigued
  195. >> I said I said among the very best >> yes and what I'd be curious to know is how compact it is from you know the 90th
  196. percentile to the 10th percentile what's the difference in and I'm curious and this is I guess what Brian's metric
  197. might help us figure out and that would be great how often >> this was I he presented this at a preMIT
  198. conference when Google used to host that preMIT conference for for a few years my
  199. memory is a Brian that's probably been five six years now but somebody's got the answer to this someone has those
  200. models someone has some sense of the base rate and the compactness of that. >> Yeah.
  201. >> Um it's a terrific question. >> Let me just say why also I I I I sort of support firing McDermott, but for a it's
  202. just I guess you could call it a strategy type reason, which is given the talent of Josh Allen, maybe
  203. the strategy of the team to put so much on him to give him as much flexibility as you've given him is not a winning
  204. strategy. Like for example, you know, uh he turned the ball over four times in the game. Now, that's not exactly the
  205. coach's fault, but maybe the structure to have Josh Allen more freewheeling, maybe to allow him more chances to throw
  206. the ball down the field, maybe running the ball less. I mean, I'm saying by construction, he may have the thought of
  207. we're going to get great Josh Allen and we're going to get sometimes not as great Josh Allen, but that tradeoff is
  208. worth it. And maybe that structure is just wrong in the NFL. Maybe empirically, you know, can't win playoff
  209. games. I have I'll say it the following way. Let's say you have to win four playoff games to win the Super Bowl.
  210. Generally, it's four, three or four. Eventually, Josh Allen's going to have a Josh Allen game under the Shawn
  211. McDermott structure. And therefore, that's why >> hypothesis question. That's all it is. It's a
  212. hypothesis. >> That's it's interesting. Um, we're we're gonna roll off of this in
  213. just a few minutes. So, what else on the NFL? What's prominent to you guys on the
  214. NFL right now? Either from the divisional round or the upcoming conference championship round. I'll give
  215. you one thing. I believe this is I think this is an Aaron Shots number. He looked
  216. at DVOA of the conference finalists and this year's matchup in the NFC between the Rams and the Seahawks is not
  217. only the highest in the history of the DVOA, but like by a long shot the highest. So the
  218. >> these these two teams are at the top of most people's power rankings and not by
  219. a little bit and they happen to be playing in the in the NFC champ. I had Aaron on, as you guys remember, a couple
  220. weeks ago and he was mentioning that in the last like 10 years based on DVOA, uh
  221. Seattle and the Rams were the two best teams like in the last 10 years or in the top five of the last 10 years.
  222. >> Remind me guys, what's the D stand for? It's value of of average. Is it? What's
  223. the D? >> That's a good question that I don't know the answer to right off the end.
  224. Let's keep going though, Eric. So on the other side though, you've got New England against a completely hamstrung
  225. Denver Broncos. And so it's it's really unfortunate that we don't get to see the
  226. Bon Knicks version of the Broncos make this kind of four strong teams. Drake May and the and the Pats continue to
  227. kind of surprise I suppose. Um and it looks like in all odds unless STDM can do something that Nick Fos has done
  228. before. So you've evaluated this I know in Massie Peab buddy. Is it surprising to you that the quarterback is worth
  229. seven points? >> Top quarterbacks I believe we've kind of you know back back of the envelope
  230. estimated around their top. >> That is right. Okay. So that doesn't surprise you then because I
  231. >> Is Boone a top quarterback? I don't I don't know. I mean that's a lot of value. Seven points is 20.
  232. >> It's a lot of it's a lot of value%. >> I would not have thought Bon Knicks was
  233. worth seven >> but >> that's what it is. I mean, that's what the betting lines are saying because I
  234. think Denver would have been favored by one and a half and now they're underdog by five and a half.
  235. >> It's a big move. It's a big move. It depends on the It depends on the backup quarterback, of
  236. course. I mean, STDM has like three starts in his life, three professional starts.
  237. So, super disappointing on that front. We are going to shift gears now because we've got our guest for the second half
  238. of the show rolling in. We're talking football, but we've been talking pro football. We want to shift gears and
  239. talk a little bit of college football here in the second half of the show. Guest this half and it's been a while
  240. since we've seen Ty, but Ty Hildenbrand is joining us. Ty is the co-host of Solid Verbal. We think we've been around
  241. a while. We're hitting our 12th anniversary this year. hitting their, you know, 18th sometime this year.
  242. They've been around since ' 08. He and Dan Rubenstein do a terrific show on college football. Independent. They're
  243. independent of everybody else and they probably got the largest audience out there. Ty is from around the corner here
  244. in Pennsylvania. I say here even though I'm not in the moment, Pennsylvania around the corner from Penn. He's up in
  245. Allentown. Ty has been with us in studio multiple times. It's a pleasure always to get time with you, Ty. Welcome to the
  246. show. Okay, gentlemen, it is a pleasure as always. Thank you for the invite. >> Yes, glad to have you. We've missed your
  247. your dulit tones, your this gorgeous radio voice that Ty Hillbrandt brings. We we should have him on every quarter
  248. or so just to like improve the sound quality of our show. Give us some more, Ty. What are you doing this morning? How
  249. you feeling after last night? >> I will take that as a compliment. Thank you. >> How tell us what's on your mind. You you
  250. you had a big the you know, your season culminated last night. Um, y'all did a a
  251. a a real time show and then you did your usual recap afterwards. So, I know you did a lot of talking. I'm curious as you
  252. woke up this morning and thought about that game, what what aspects of the game stood out to you? Like, what's on your
  253. mind about that game? Was >> Well, I mean, I think a couple things. I mean, first off, as you know, I'm sure
  254. Indiana came in uh a touchdown touchdown and a half, eight, eight and a half point favorite, depending on where you
  255. looked. And so, there was an expectation that they were going to win the game. I
  256. think what stood out to me just sort of in the flow of things is even though there were plenty of instances
  257. throughout the course of that one where Miami could have wilted and maybe could have gone the way of say Oregon or
  258. Alabama as we saw earlier in the playoff. Miami adjusted and that's not something that they get a lot of credit
  259. for. Often we're making jokes about Crystal Ball and how he goes into a shell and plays very conservatively but
  260. we didn't really see that in the second half. We saw Miami answer in a really meaningful way. They damn nearly won the
  261. game. So I think to their credit, they acquitted themselves really, really well. And on the Indiana side of things,
  262. I mean, it really was just moments. I saw our friend Bill Connelly from ESPN.com posted his postgame win
  263. expectancy was at 14.1% in favor of Miami. Like overwhelmingly in favor of Miami given the way that the
  264. game and the stats all shaked out. But the fact that Indiana will still able to win that game is I think a testament to
  265. the process that Curt Signetti has in place and really just this mindset of winning moments. You don't have to be
  266. perfect, but just winning on the margins largely is what we saw them do on Monday
  267. night. And uh as such, they get their first national championship and the sport's first ever 16-0
  268. uh record. So congratulations to the Hooers. >> No doubt. >> Yale in 1894 went 16 and0. Are you
  269. selling us short here? Yeah. Come on, Ty. Let's say modern era. Okay. Modern era.
  270. >> Audi, leave it to Audi. We were just talking about where, you know, focus focus on the past. Dwell focus.
  271. >> Ty, just to name some of the moments, I I the block punt kind of doesn't count.
  272. Block punt is a separate thing, but like those two fourth down conversions on the
  273. touchdown that there wasn't quite there. Was it? Yeah, it was their last. It was
  274. their last touchdown. And then later when they're trying to burn clock that third down conversion, this vital third
  275. down conversion like another another back shoulder fade. Um those are the moments that I think of. Is that what
  276. you're thinking about when you say the key moments those offensive conversions? >> Yeah. Offensive conversions. I mean even
  277. if you want to boil it down to the more fundamental stuff like for the most part
  278. tackling Malachi Tony when they try to get him in space on a quick throw or something of that nature. I mean that
  279. that was very much how Miami made hay this year. Wasn't the most explosive team in college football, but they had a
  280. bunch of guys who were just really good in space and they were ultimately pretty
  281. good at finding ways to get them the ball and let them do what they do. We have seen that work to some effect here
  282. throughout the course of the playoffs. Even though Miami has tended to play a little bit more of a slugfest variety of
  283. football, but clearly the game against Old Miss went a little bit of a different direction. Nonetheless, we
  284. they've done that a lot this year. And so for me coming into this one it was at can Indiana tackle can Indiana tackle
  285. these guys who are just raw athletes in space and uh they did a pretty good job of it. They weren't perfect again but um
  286. just moments like that finding a way to get a guy on the ground being very disciplined. The zone coverage scheme
  287. that they play is one that requires a lot of discipline and really good communication. So, it's not necessarily
  288. a team comprised of first round talent, though there will be some first round players on that roster, but probably not
  289. to the same extent as Miami. They're just really good as a team together. And so, when you've got that type of
  290. synergy, when you've got that culture, that shared sort of philosophy for how to play defensive football and offensive
  291. football to an extent, um you you tend to see your team excel in some of those margin moments. and uh we saw it on
  292. display last night. >> Eric, >> yeah, I was just wondering, it's really a two-part question, but it's the same
  293. question. If if yesterday's game were the only game you saw are Fernando Mendoza,
  294. would you say he's the number one pick in the draft? And number two, is it obvious to you if we project out three
  295. or four years who's going to be the better pro quarterback, Carson Beck or Mendoza?
  296. It's so I have some thoughts, but I'd love to hear your thoughts on that. >> All right, part one. The answer is no.
  297. Based on what we saw from Mendoza last night, I I would not be inclined to say he looks like he is going to be a slam
  298. dunk in the NFL. Now, if that again to your point, if that's only the only game I saw, I I'm not going to go on a limb
  299. and say that uh he projects as the surefire number one overall pick given the course of the season and what we saw
  300. from him over the course of the year and what I think we know about him as both a
  301. student of the game, as somebody who studies this stuff and has an innate working knowledge of pre-nap, postnap
  302. processing, that type of thing. I I think all of that is far and away very appealing to somebody that you're
  303. thinking about picking at the next level in the NFL. So, I I think he'll be fine
  304. at the next level, but that was not the best game of his that we saw last night.
  305. He had moments again, but certainly not the best version of Fernando Mendoza that we saw. And it's no coincidence
  306. that it probably was against one of the best, if not the best defensive lines that he saw here.
  307. >> That was my point. and that you may see a lot more of that in the NFL and therefore
  308. >> but also he'll have a better offensive line in the NFL too. >> That's right. That's right.
  309. >> What about him versus Carson Beck only in the sense of if you look Well, I I think I I haven't seen any stats on it.
  310. Maybe you have. I think we could argue Carson Beck just who's got the stronger arm. Beck probably has the stronger arm.
  311. That doesn't mean he's going to be a better NFL quarterback at all. I'm just asking you,
  312. you know, how much uncertain, put a I don't want to say this. Why not? We're a stats show. If you had to put a
  313. probability that Mendoza is going to be a better NFL quarterback than Beck, what probability
  314. would you give on that? >> That's good, good question, Audi, we want your answer as well.
  315. >> I'd say I' I'd say about 70%. Um, and you know, one of one of the biggest issues I think you see in guys going
  316. from college to pro ball and uh, you know, I know you guys again care a lot about the stats, how these things change
  317. over time. I know it's something that you all study probably a lot closer than I do, but you know, the game has changed
  318. and that processing step going from college to pro. It's like a completely different stratosphere with the types of
  319. things that they're doing at the pro game. And even though we didn't see it so much last night from Carson Beck, I
  320. think his most recent track record, let's just say over the last two seasons of college football,
  321. when they had to lean on him a little bit more at Georgia, when they didn't have the ground game
  322. that we're accustomed to seeing in Athens from Kirby Smart. >> Yeah. >> Carson Beck wasn't as good.
  323. >> Yep. >> And I think we saw it again at moments this year. He had a pretty good cast
  324. around him. He did have a running game. They weren't asking him to go out there and throw for 350 yards per game. But
  325. again, we saw it moments this season, notably in that Louisville game earlier in the year where you can confuse them.
  326. He threw four interceptions. It could have been more in that game. So, I just think the ability to confuse Beck is is
  327. a very real thing that needs to be taken into account when we have this conversation. And not to say he can't
  328. confuse any quarterback, but I just think Mendoza is a little bit quicker when it comes to processing post snaps.
  329. So, I'm I tend to come down on the Mendoza side of this one a lot more definitively.
  330. >> The 70 is a strong number. And I love what he did there, Eric. He said, "I see
  331. your stronger arm." Like, we can argue it, but let's just grant back the stronger arm, and I'm going to give you
  332. better processing speed. And this is something I think the NFL has learned. They have a hard time with it every time
  333. because every year because you fall in love with arms, but I think they've learned that processing speed matters
  334. more than AR. >> Can I ask if there's any data on have we looked maybe even just narratives? Have
  335. we looked at the the every year lots of quarterbacks get their opportunities coming out of college. Is there any
  336. consistent story that people tell about why those who don't make it don't make it? And if it has to do with processing
  337. >> there processing go ahead. >> Yeah. I I mean I I was just going to say I think processing is one of the things
  338. that they they try to get a handle on. Uh they'll look at stats like time to throw versus completion percentage
  339. versus just some of the stuff that you could find if you go on some of the advanced analytical sites. Um you know,
  340. as as you know, this is a big business, so they'll go all the way down to hand size and things of that nature. Um my my
  341. hunch is just knowing, you know, h how these things tend to go, they they tend to factor in as much as they can and
  342. then tell whatever story makes the most sense. To your point, Cade, given that the Raiders are drafting first, that to
  343. me is interesting because even though it seems like Mendoza will be the overall surefire pick,
  344. the Raiders are a franchise throughout their storyried past that tend to get really romantic over a guy who's quick
  345. or a guy who can throw the ball a country mile. They're not always focused on the full package. Um, which I to a
  346. large extent Mendoza has. I don't think he's a perfect prospect, but I'm I'm curious to see nonetheless, though I
  347. think he will be the number one pick, what they surround him with and how they try to bring him along with a new coach
  348. because um there's not a great recent track record right now for uh them turning, you know, uh college prospects
  349. into all pros. >> Well, of course, Tom Brady is advising them and so that should be interesting,
  350. right? Um but I just want to ask you another question about to's point. I think Cade mentioned earlier on the
  351. show, which was I would imagine one thing you could do, like I was lamenting Josh Allen, but not so the four
  352. turnovers, yes, but more so him missing the tight end. But at least I'll go I want to talk about what Cade said there.
  353. At least he went to the right guy. He didn't complete it. Like there's two sources of error. One is I went to the
  354. wrong receiver in the sense of expected points or expected yards or I missed that receiver. Those are two different
  355. errors. Couldn't that be measured? Couldn't we look at whether Carson Beck goes to the given where everybody is on
  356. the field and the situation? Couldn't we look at the correctness of choice for quarterbacks and score people that way
  357. and then separate that out from the error? I miss that person. >> Well, so two points on that, right? The
  358. the first thing is I don't know if I've found a way yet to to quantify that. At least that's in some sort of public
  359. arena that I can digest it. But my hunch is that that type of thing is already going on when they're scouting in
  360. advance of making these picks. Um there's a ton of tape on all these guys. I'm sure that there are people going
  361. through that with a fine tooth comb. But then there are other things, and I think
  362. this is something that flies a little bit more in the face of somebody like Beck. Um, PFF is an example of some
  363. place that tracks turnover worthy throws and things of that nature. So, it's not
  364. necessarily saying that he's going to the right place, but it is some sort of gauge over the accuracy of the throw. Is
  365. he throwing into traffic? Is he taking risks that don't need to be there? Those types of stats. And I don't have that
  366. one in front of me, unfortunately, but I could get it. I know that's something that Beck has struggled with here over
  367. the last two seasons of college ball. It's making sure not only he's going to the right spot, but that it's an
  368. accurate throw. And so that I think is one area where my hunch is if we looked at the numbers comparing Mendoza to back
  369. in that capacity, that's an area where it would be a clear advantage for Mendoza.
  370. >> Of course, I'm sitting here just one last thing on this exact point. I'm just
  371. wondering which one's more teachable. Can you which one would you rather like if I told you you could have someone
  372. with great making great choices but weaker accuracy or someone with greater accuracy but weaker choices which would
  373. you which do you think is more coachable? I want both but if it and yeah that's my question. I have no idea
  374. but it's an interesting question because that has implications for who you draft.
  375. I I want the more coachable guy. I want the more coachable guy who wants to be a
  376. student of the game and you know can can understand. I mean look I nobody Fernando Mendoza is a deceptively good
  377. athlete and we have seen him use his legs. We have seen him have a real innate sense of the pocket around him.
  378. He is clearly a good athlete. He is not a statue back there. You're not going to
  379. confuse him with Lamar Jackson. That is just not his game. He also doesn't have the strongest arm in the world. It's not
  380. a bad arm. he's going to be the first overall pick, but let's not act like he's Brett Favre. The fact that the fact
  381. of the matter is his processing and his ability to digest tape and recognize before the snap and after the snap what
  382. is what's going on that has propelled him now to new heights to win the Heisman Trophy and to be in this
  383. conversation for the number one overall pick. I would almost always rather provided we're not talking about like a
  384. full-on pop gun arm. I would always rather the guy who knows where to go with the ball, can digest what's
  385. happening around him, but can play quick. So, I would probably go Mendoza in that in that.
  386. >> All right, Ty, I want to ask you one other Indiana question, then we want to move to some more general college
  387. football topics. The other Indiana question I have for you sounds absurd, but I think this is actually what I what
  388. I'm curious about. Signetti, overrated or underrated? And it's absurd because he's been praised to the moon lately.
  389. They praise Indiana so much over the last month that I started pulling from Miami just to get over it. It's just
  390. ridiculous how much praise. But in the end, I wonder in the end I wonder whether we're undervaluing what Signiti
  391. did here and we're talking about the Portal and Indiana and James Madison transfers and all that stuff. And I
  392. mean, so maybe it's replicable because other schools do, but maybe he's just this unicorn of a coach that you're
  393. never going to replicate because we had Sabin in front of us for all those years
  394. and nobody could replicate Sabin. So Signetti, overrated or underrated? I think he's underrated. And it's it's
  395. >> it's crazy to even say it, but consider the context here for Indiana. This is a program with 715 losses in its
  396. program history. I believe that is the most in the 156 years or the last 156 years of college football. So, it's not
  397. like he was hitting the ground running at a place like a Georgia or even a place like a Texas Tech where there was
  398. something of a football tradition. >> They had three Big 10 wins in the previous three seasons before you got
  399. there. Three in conference wins in years. >> Exactly. So, not all situations are
  400. created equal. And also, as you know, college football has changed very quickly. Everybody is
  401. taking a boatload of transfers at this point. Not everyone's taking 40, but most are taking anywhere between 5 to 10
  402. to plug some holes depending on what you need. So, everybody is doing the same thing in the transfer portal. Everybody
  403. is going out there. Everyone's trying to boost their roster in whichever way they
  404. see fit. And Signetti was able to take a program that was dead, completely boot it up from scratch,
  405. basically install a new operating system, and get this thing running at optimum efficiency
  406. in 26 months. He's got 27 wins in 26 months, and now a national championship. So for him to
  407. turn this around as quickly as he did and get them playing at this level with guys in both seasons that were cobbled
  408. together from other programs, whether they were castoffs or just guys he wanted to bring with him from his
  409. previous stop. Whatever the case, for him to do this as quickly as he has done it, to me that indicates you can't
  410. handwave this thing and just say, "Oh, it's the it's the transfer portal." He got lucky with his guys. He won 11 games
  411. in year one. He obviously went 16 and0 this year. Whatever he is doing, whatever his process looks like, and
  412. there's been much written about, they practice a little bit less. They're a little bit more focused on communication
  413. and discipline, and it's a little bit of a different setup, but it's very process
  414. driven. Whatever that is is clearly working to a degree that nobody saw coming. So, I just I don't know how you
  415. can look at what he's done over the last two years and feel like he's he's overrated at this point. I mean, maybe
  416. he's not underrated, but he's certainly not overrated given what we have seen now over the last two seasons.
  417. >> Yeah, I was just wondering, so I actually just looked quickly. It's easy to find. I just looked at their record
  418. this year. I don't know if this is worth anything to evaluate coaching, but I did
  419. just look at their record against the spread. And so they're about the 30th team in
  420. the in the college football this year against the spread. Now maybe it's because him as a coach is already built
  421. into the line. So that could be one explanation for it. Or it could be, you know, he has really good talent. He's
  422. performing well compared to that talent, but not extraordinarily well. Is that worth anything to you? I mean, I'm not
  423. saying that's the right way to measure it. I'm just asking your question. They were 10 and six this year against the
  424. spread. Yeah, I mean, and there was a crazy stat before and I'm going to blank on it a
  425. little bit now before the game where his record when he is a touchdown or more favorite is just off the charts. And I I
  426. think what has >> in a good way in a good way >> and what I think has very much defined
  427. his early tenure now as Indiana coach is something we can't really quantify and maybe this is as close as we'll get to
  428. it but killer instinct. Killer instinct. It's the thing that Mario Crystalall has
  429. been criticized for not having at times but signetti goes for the throat. He will try to take you out. He put up 63
  430. points at Illinois, right? He obviously destroyed both Alabama and Oregon. The guy knows how to keep playing and keep
  431. his foot on the gas when his teams get up. >> So, we can talk a lot about him winning
  432. on the margins. >> Go ahead. >> I just want to add one element to that because I I think you're raising
  433. something interesting and true, but it may be underappreciated yet. It's not just it's not just keeping your foot in
  434. the grass, even though it is that. And there are plenty of coaches, we've all had coaches of our teams who got too
  435. conservative with the lead because there's a little risk. The the key to making that interesting is that there's
  436. risk involved. It's like his going for the touchdown last night on fourth and five instead of the field goal. He's
  437. like, I'm going for the kill. And it's only interesting because there's downside risk to this choice. And it
  438. made me as a Texas fan, it made me think immediately of Kirby Smart's onside kick
  439. after they went up whatever they went up 10 or something um over Texas in the regular season game this past year and
  440. then shocking everybody onside kicked recovered and scored the game that put scored the there's risk there. It's not
  441. it's not interesting to just say it's not as interesting to say killer instinct. I kick them when I'm down.
  442. It's like no I take extra risk to put them away. I'm willing to do that because most coaches get conservative in
  443. those situations opposed to even dialing up the risk in order to get it done. >> Yeah. And the the other thing that I was
  444. going to add to the question about Indiana versus the spread, you're right, 30th in their win percentage versus the
  445. spread. They were first in terms of their covering points per game, right? So, they were covering by a larger
  446. margin when they covered than almost every other team than than in fact every other team in college football. So, you
  447. know, that that sort of underscores the point of Signetti, as you said, K just doing whatever he can to put teams away.
  448. It might be worth the risk. If it works out for you, great. You're going to get a win. You're going to put the game on
  449. ice. If not, then that's a conversation. But, um, he he has just had a really innate sense for when to push a little
  450. bit harder, when to roll the dice. We saw it on fourth and five in the national championship game on that
  451. quarterback draw for Fernando Mendoza. just they have a really good sense right now when they've got the wind at their
  452. back for when they should push a little bit harder and take those chances. I just love that call cuz as Kate brought
  453. up earlier, there's so many things about that situation. You're up three, you could go up six up six, you know, oh,
  454. you don't get it. Oh, then the other team is not as aggressive because they try to kick the field. There's so much
  455. about that that that will be talked about from an analytics but even a psychology perspective and a you know go
  456. for the kill perspective for years that's almost was like the perfect storm of even if the quote unquote as Audi
  457. said earlier too the analytics had it even you know there's so much other stuff that suggests going for it there
  458. and the the only other point that I would add on that play all the things that we're talking about here with
  459. Signetti. I mean, what it amounts to is the right players in the right scheme in
  460. the right process at the right time. That play was, I think, something that signifies what the entire Curt Signetti
  461. experience has been about so far. You've got this quarterback in Fernando Mendoza
  462. who's a good enough athlete, but knows how to process. You've got the preparation, which is what told them
  463. that's why they called the timeout. and the preparation is what told them what type of defense to expect. Fernando
  464. Mendoza and his ability to process is what told him at the line of scrimmage that Miami was in fact not in that
  465. defense that they were in something of a hybrid coverage and he made the call on
  466. his own after they snapped the ball. It was if it was man coverage, they were throwing it. If it was zone coverage, he
  467. was supposed to run it. They played half man, half zone. He decides to run it. He
  468. trusts in his own process. He puts a move on a guy, kind of sidesteps him and ends up takes a shot, but ends up diving
  469. into the end zone to give them that 10-point cushion. So, that play in and of itself, I think, was a really
  470. interesting microcosm for the Signetti experience so far, and how it really is just the right process, the right
  471. players, knowing what to do, doing the the little things on the margin a little bit better than the opponent.
  472. >> Do we get to do I get to ask Tai Cade what would be a successful season for Indiana next year? So, what does So,
  473. what now? So, they went to 11 wins. Obviously, a great season. I just don't remember. Did they make the playoffs
  474. last season? >> Yes. And they got smoked. >> They did. They They made the playoffs
  475. with 11 wins. Um, lost to Notre Dame in the playoff, but uh that was sort of Kurt Signetti's coming out party. It It
  476. was a very big deal. >> What's the expectation now? Like, is it Let me think about it. Let's They're
  477. thinking about expanding to 16 teams, but let's pretend they stay at 12 for now. Um, is it like anything worse than
  478. I'll call it final four a bad season? Now, >> I think you got to get back to the
  479. playoff. I think I think if you lose in the playoff, um, you know, that's that's
  480. understandable. You're not going to be able to replicate this every year. Most most recent fans understand that. But
  481. there is a there is an element here of like once you fly in first class once or fly on the private jet that's just sort
  482. of who you want to be, you know, and uh I I'm Indiana's a very big institution as I'm sure sure you gentlemen know.
  483. It's got a huge alumni base, the largest living alumni base in the country. This
  484. is a program that uh is going to want to reinvest in this football program and they're going to want to try and
  485. replicate the success as much as they can. So, I we were looking at their schedule a little bit last night. I
  486. mean, they've got a really strong portal class again coming in next year. It's going to be much of the same
  487. conversation, even though there'll be some new faces. Um, I I would expect 10 wins. I I think it the expectation
  488. starts at 10 wins. Of course, you get an injury. I mean, a lot can happen over the course of a year, but uh if I'm an
  489. Indiana fan, knowing that they've got this train rolling now with Signetti and that talent is is seemingly a little bit
  490. more apt to go there, uh you If I were a fan, I would expect I would want 10 wins to get into the playoff and
  491. give themselves another shot. >> All right. Um, Mendoza's little brother, who was a backup quarterback this year,
  492. announced for the portal this morning. So, that's because they've pulled in uh Josh Hoover from TCU.
  493. Unless you're a real football college football guy, you may not know Hoover TCU quarterback. One of the highest
  494. regarded prospects in the in the college football right now. So, he's got his supposed Mendoza lined up. Ty, talking
  495. about the portal, I one of the things I want to talk about with you a little bit
  496. here, and I want the guys to get at least a little bit of this before they have to roll off is the portal itself.
  497. And I think of you as being in touch as in touch with college football fandom as
  498. anybody out there. I can't think of anybody better than you and Dan asked this question to. like what is the
  499. current vibe on the portal and and therefore what do you think the consequences are
  500. going to be of the portal world we live in now and of course it may change but where and on our current trajectory what
  501. are the consequences pro and con of the portal and I want to say one thing about
  502. it before I give it to you last year which is the first full year of the portal being a fan of a big school you
  503. and Dan are fan of fans of big schools so Ty went to Penn State he was raised in a nerd family. Those are his schools.
  504. Dan Rubenstein, his partner, Oregon guy. So, we we're kind of the alpha schools.
  505. I'm a UT guy. So, it's like, yes, the portal. Give me all your players. You know, that's kind of the initial vibe.
  506. And then 2025 rolls around and all of a sudden tide turns and other programs start stealing all our young players.
  507. And you realize it doesn't it's not it's not a one-way street here that the that
  508. the Blueb Bloods just can't sit on top of it and be fed. they're actually going to get robbed as well. So, it's more of
  509. an equilibrium than we thought and it's a new experience for some of us. And I could use a little therapy about it. But
  510. more generally, I'm just curious. It's a no 3,000 4,000 something like that players change teams. I think 4,000 went
  511. in maybe 3,000 changed teams. I It's unbelievable. I'm curious you, Ty, from your
  512. perspective, what's the vibe? What are the consequences? Uh fans are exhausted from the transfer portal. Um college
  513. football, if it weren't enough that college football changes the rules like every two years and they make people
  514. relearn the playoff system, the conferences, whether guys can get money. I mean,
  515. think of all the things that have changed just in the last 5 years. The portal is only accelerating. It is
  516. basically non-stop free agency. If you root for pro sports, you know how dizzying free agency can be. Whether
  517. you're a baseball, a basketball, football fan, I mean, it's it's a lot. So, the fact that this is always going
  518. on all the time, I think has left fans, at least people that write into us, tired of it, exhausted by it. Now, that
  519. being said, a we make content, so from our standpoint, it's a lot to talk about, and it's interesting. It's
  520. interesting to have guys kind of find themselves in new situations. Josh Hoover who wanted to go to to Indiana
  521. initially ends up at TCU now he's going back to India. Like you get these really
  522. odd pairings that you wouldn't have thought otherwise. And there's a little bit of like mystique to it now with how
  523. much is so and so getting paid. Is he really worth all that much? You have that whole component to it which I think
  524. is is an interesting conversation. But the pros and cons side of this is very intriguing. The pros, I think, from
  525. a fan standpoint is stories like we saw with Indiana are now possible. This was a gigantic proof of concept that a team
  526. that started from the bottom is now here. >> Give me a break. That doesn't happen.
  527. That wouldn't have happened 10 years ago. Not in a million years. >> Well, can it happen? Could it have
  528. happened just over a very long period of time as opposed to you know it's a two-year turnaround from I don't know
  529. how many you guys probably know what they win three games the year before Signetti got there. So they went from 3
  530. to 11 to the 16 and0 national champion. Yeah. Yeah, I mean it I'm not sure I don't even have the number in front of
  531. me what he was the year what they were the year before he got there, but like yeah, I I suspect and and we've seen
  532. this, right? I mean, there there have been some of those moments throughout the course of college football history
  533. where a team out of nowhere has sort of bubbled up, right? TCU is a fairly recent example of a team a couple years
  534. back played against Georgia, got creamed, but they got there. They got there. And among the TCU people I talked
  535. to in that moment, they were just sort of happy. They were happy to be there. They felt like they were playing with
  536. house money. There was no expectation that that would carry on, that they could replicate that anytime soon. But I
  537. think that part of it has changed on the fan side of things. To the earlier point
  538. about what's a realistic expectation for Indiana, they did it once, now there's no reason to think in this climate where
  539. people want to go to Indiana that they can't do it again. So, I think just this fact that some of the talent has now
  540. been spread around college football, it's really tough to hoard talent the way that the SEC was doing five, six,
  541. seven years ago. That makes it, I think, a better fan experience. And I also think from the player side of things,
  542. it's good that they have some agency that they can move around if they want to, much like coaches can. That's all
  543. good stuff. What's bad is that none of this is sustainable right now, right? So, we're all in a bit of a sugar rush.
  544. At least the players and some of the teams are that are heavily involved in the transfer portal. But on some level,
  545. there has to be guard rails put up to kind of rein this thing in to enforce contracts to make sure that we don't
  546. have just just constant revolving door. Um, on on some level, there will be a question of return on investment. If
  547. you're putting millions upon millions of dollars into your chosen college football team,
  548. how is that worth it for you? Uh will guys stop investing if suddenly the bottom falls out one year and there are
  549. a bunch of injuries and it it goes south. So that whole side of it, the financial component and just the
  550. constant instability of things, I think is a is a really like that is a blinking
  551. red light that I know a lot of people know about. I don't know what solves it. Maybe it's making players officially
  552. employees and giving them more binding agreements once they're once they're at a given institution. But um you know,
  553. it's it's a really interesting push pull right now between wanting to give the players more power, which is how this
  554. all started, but at the same time not wanting to put college football in a position where it's even more unstable
  555. than it's been in the past. >> Ty, you began that last part by saying it's unsustainable. And I think that's a
  556. word that many of us feel, but it could be unsustainable for any number of reasons. And if you had to put your
  557. chips on what breaks, like what will break that causes reform because something has to break or come close to
  558. breaking. So flashing red lights are not enough. Someone has to like go through the intersection and get hit before
  559. something gets done about this thing. What's going to break that's going to lead to some kind of change? Well, we're
  560. we're having a really interesting example of that right now because amid this national championship run or
  561. playoff run, I guess I should say, for Miami, uh Miami came to the realization that they weren't going to get any of
  562. the other portal quarterbacks and they needed somebody for next year because they want to keep this going too. And so
  563. they turned their sights on Darien Mensah, the quarterback from Duke, who just resigned an agreement with Duke and
  564. is now trying to throw his name in the portal and take his talents to South Beach. So, we're going to find out here
  565. in relatively short order what happens to that agreement. Duke has announced as of earlier today that they're going to
  566. sue Mensah. They're going to try and enforce that agreement. And it'll be really interesting to see what the
  567. result of that suit ends up being. That's the type of thing that could have far-reaching ramifications in terms of
  568. NIL and the transfer portal and just in general, I would say player movement. If
  569. in fact a court or whoever finds that these contracts are enforcable and he can't leave because they won't let him
  570. and he signs something, then I I think guys will be a little bit more apprehensive about putting themselves in
  571. a bad situation. Right now there is this culture of well if I go somewhere and sign an agreement I don't got to worry
  572. about I don't got to worry about it I can just go somewhere else next year. But certainly when we're talking about
  573. this higher price talent where we're talking about multi-year agreements and things of that nature, um I it's not
  574. often that I'm rooting against the players, I would say, in general, but I think this is one area that they could
  575. definitely have a positive impact uh if Duke were to win this case and find that
  576. these contracts are enforcable and guys can't just pick up and leave willy-nilly. So that that's a really
  577. obvious one that I think we're going to play out here in relatively short order.
  578. The other thing that I would throw out, Kade, is, you know, the college football
  579. calendar is still kind of screwed up. Uh it maybe was a little bit better this year. They did away with two transfer
  580. portal windows. Previously, there was one in the winter, one in the spring. Now they combined them both, but it
  581. opened during the playoffs, which is still weird, even though teams in the playoffs got a little bit more of a
  582. grace period. So, I I feel like that puts college football in a really uncomfortable bind sometimes depending
  583. on where guys want to go and when they want to do it. And so, I think some combination of the lawsuits with maybe
  584. trying to make the calendar a little bit better if that's at all possible. That's
  585. a start. But there the the whole money side of this is like its own podcast episode completely. That's that's going
  586. to be a longer conversation. >> Yeah, it's a podcast series probably more than anything. Well, I like I I
  587. like your answer a lot actually. It's very practical. It says probably going to be a contractual thing, probably
  588. going to be court as opposed to the fans who retired or the coaches who are retired. That's a real issue for
  589. long-term sustainability. But that's that that could wither away for a long time before it was enough of a crash for
  590. them to do something about. But how these contracts get enforced or don't get enforced is a big one. And then, you
  591. know, depending on how that goes, you get schools learning that the portal isn't the answer to every need. And so,
  592. you end up in seasons without a quarterback. You know, it's so funny, Ty, though, like it's such a change.
  593. When we were growing up, teams of course went through cycles where you're starting a sophomore, you're starting a
  594. freshman or whatever. That's just what happens. You're sometimes you don't have a good middle linebacker, but now the
  595. expectation is you have to fill every hole on your roster in full and by God, you can do it because there's a portal.
  596. It still seems unrealistic. >> It It is. And look, I mean, uh, not to go too far down the path of of the money
  597. conversation, but there there were already talks um, just this week about right now there's a cap on how much of
  598. the revenue schools can share with their athletes. There there's a talk about wanting to get rid of that cap
  599. altogether, wanting to give schools the right to pay guys as much as they want. So, you know, it college football has
  600. always been >> this battle of David versus Goliath. It's part of what makes it such a charm
  601. sport and what gets people fired up to watch every Saturday is that constant thrill of a potential upset. Um, we are
  602. what's going on right now though it I think has allowed a little bit more parody at the power conference level and
  603. has definitely spread talent out a little bit more. We're seeing a lot of this halves versus have nots thing on
  604. the financial side. And so longer term, this mindset of we have to fill every hole in the roster with high price
  605. talent with the best guys that are available to us, the best guys money can buy. Uh eventually eventually I think
  606. that prices a lot of the smaller schools out of the competitive market and that's
  607. a problem. I I don't personally want to see that even though, you know, we're sort of used to the blueb bloodoods
  608. driving the sport. Um I I would prefer a sport that is not that lopsided in terms
  609. of resources. So, we'll see. I you know, we're we're still at the tip of the iceberg with this whole thing.
  610. >> Okay. Helpful helpful reports from uh from your perspective, your your rich perspective. Um, one one more report
  611. from you, Ty, before we go and we just we'll try to wrap up quick because we're kept you overtime already. But, um, Penn
  612. State has, you know, if not for all the craziness of the intervening two months,
  613. it's even been longer since they fired their coach. Penn State was the story early in the season. I mean, Penn State
  614. and my team Texas, these were one and two in the year coming in and both fell pretty hard, but Franklin lost the job
  615. as a process. Didn't sign anybody. Then they [ __ ] around through most of the coaching carousel before landing on what
  616. at some years has been the hottest coach available. But Matt Campbell, Iowa State, he brings a lot of his players,
  617. including his quarterback at, you know, Penn State. It's like it's our that's our state institution. It's the local
  618. big college program. You're you went there. What what's the what's the sense right now now that
  619. they've come through all that craziness? Is there optimism? Is there hope? How do
  620. you think they're going to do right off the bat? like what what's your take? >> I think there's a lot of optimism to be
  621. honest with you and it it's kind of like a natural segue to go from talking about
  622. the transfer portal to talking about Penn State >> because >> for as much of the conversation right
  623. now is about who can we get to move from program A to program B, >> there is a much bigger conversation that
  624. takes place when coaches move. And addendum to those co coach conversations is now how many of your
  625. other guys can you bring with you? not just your assistants, but how many of your players can you bring with you? And
  626. uh to the point, Matt Campbell has very much been a name in demand. He's not done a great job of advertising what
  627. he's done at Iowa State, even though he's done a remarkable job. And he has been in the running for some really big
  628. jobs, but he has waited. He has been picky. Penn State totally botched the process to try and hire a new coach. I
  629. think that's been well documented at this point. But the fact that Matt Campbell fell off the back of a truck
  630. and into their waiting arms with all of these guys from an otherwise pretty good
  631. Iowa State team, it doesn't need to be pretty, it just needs to work. And in that sense, I I think it worked. So much
  632. of what he has done in the early going in State College has, I think, been very very exciting. He did bring a lot of
  633. guys with him from Iowa State, including his quarterback, Rock Obeck, who will probably already be the best quarterback
  634. Penn State's had in the last 10 years. Um I I think he has done a really good job piecing this thing together kind of
  635. on the fly and very very quickly, not just with his own guys, but uh we're also now seeing like some guys who were
  636. interested in Penn State previously in the high school recruiting game throw their name back in the in the ring,
  637. maybe be interested in Penn State again. It seems like they're able to ratchet that up a little bit more. So, I think
  638. the combination of the talent that he's going to have on hand, which for all intents and purposes is a hybrid of the
  639. best of Penn State and the best of Iowa State, combined with what their schedule
  640. looks like next year, which to my eye looks very advantageous. I'm not saying they're making the playoff, I don't want
  641. to go that far, but I think this is a team that's going to be competitive right away. And given the way this all
  642. went down after those losses this season, if you're a Penn Stater, you got to take that and and be pretty damn
  643. happy with it, right? You you will take that a million times over. It's a different mentality. It's a different
  644. philosophy. It's obviously a different coach altogether. Um, but the thing with James Franklin had definitely run its
  645. course. Not crazy about the way he was fired, but I think it was time to move on and
  646. and kind of change the landscape a little bit. And uh I'm excited to see what Matt Campbell can do.
  647. >> To an outsider, it feels like it must feel very different to think about football under somebody other than
  648. Franklin, other than James Franklin. It felt like over the years couldn't get over the hump. Lots of It's like almost
  649. RC Slokum from a previous era with the Ais 10 and two, 10 and 10 and two. It's like they can't beat the the two teams
  650. they need to beat. And it just got a heavier heavier heavier cloud. And it sounds like even inside the program, it
  651. just got so weighty. Y'all must feel like a whole new day. like Meadows and Flowers and here's Matt Campbell and a
  652. new coach and it just it h I'm just guessing it feels very different. >> It well it it does and I mean we're
  653. talking about two guys that have been successful in their own right with very different philosophies and you know even
  654. if we want to bring it back to the transfer portal and bring it back to compensation and things of that nature.
  655. very different philosophies between James Franklin who basically paid everybody the same amount and how most
  656. other places are doing it where you're paid a little bit more based on your production and that I think was a
  657. sticking point in some of the leaked audio that came out from Pat Craft. It appears as if that very much was an
  658. issue that he had with the way that Franklin ran things. I think that's going to change now. I I think Matt
  659. Campbell just has a fundamentally different philosophy. He's never been in a place like this that has these kinds
  660. of resources to throw at football, right? >> And so that in and of itself, I think,
  661. makes this a really exciting opportunity. Taking a guy like that who was he built his career on making more
  662. out of less to now give a guy like that more doesn't mean he's going to make the
  663. playoff, win a conference championship, even win a playoff game. But I I like your chances of putting a guy like that
  664. in a situation like this. >> It's fun for college football, I think. I mean, you're right. It's no guarantee,
  665. but it's a good experiment to run. Let's see this guy who's been the darling of kind of the underresourced program tier
  666. and see how he does with Let's play that game like a It's like a It's like a freaking uh
  667. TV show that making like let's put the small town guy in the big on the big city. Um, okay. Last question that it
  668. seems relevant to me. Can is do we feel bad? Should we feel hypocritical about kind of implicitly praising Campbell for
  669. bringing all his players with him while having probably just railed on Lane Keifin for trying to get his guys to
  670. come from Miss to LSU? Kein created a dog and pony show though, you know, and that's that's been the rub
  671. on Kein. He's a good coach. He's obviously been very successful. He knows how to work the transfer portal. We're
  672. already seeing that they've got the top portal class given this most recent cycle. But um you know this constant
  673. will he won't he leave some of what I think we heard about them sort of either overtly or under the radar recruiting
  674. Old Miss players to kind of jump in the portal as Old Miss was getting set to play in its playoff game. Um the college
  675. football is a shady business. There's no denying that across the board. But Lane
  676. Keifin definitely engaged in his fair share of shadiness with the way things went down at Old
  677. Miss, both with leaving with his coaching staff and uh with the players that he may have wanted to come with
  678. him. We didn't really see that from Campbell. I mean, first and foremost, it's not like Iowa State was in the
  679. playoff. Iowa State, >> that's a big difference. >> Was not in the playoff. It was it was a
  680. much cleaner break. He also wasn't out there in the media tweeting about it and making a big deal about it. I mean, uh,
  681. we didn't find out until very late in the game that Campbell was even a possibility. He never spoke about it
  682. until the ink had dried. So, it I I think ultimately we're talking about two guys with very very different
  683. personalities, which is is the biggest difference. But, um, you know, I to me it doesn't feel quite as underhanded
  684. given the timing of when Campbell left to go to Penn State and certainly the situation that Iowa State was in, uh,
  685. the one that he left behind in Ames. >> Okay. All right. Well, listen, uh, thank
  686. you for the time, Ty. This is our last official college football podcast of the season. You were a perfect person to
  687. wrap it up with. Wish you the best with all you have going on over at the Solid Verbal. encourage our listeners to pick
  688. up Tai and Dan wherever you can. Solid verbal really the college football OG of podcast for sure been around since ' 08
  689. and we're delighted to have Ty with us periodically. Ty H and Brett, >> thank you.
  690. >> Many thanks to um Eric Bradlo and Audi Winer who were here for most of the show
  691. before having to roll off to other responsibilities here this afternoon. for Shane Jensen in Absentia in the
  692. classroom as well. For Dion Simpkins, always here doing the real work for the whole team. Thank you, Dion. Marissa
  693. Raina, our producer, D Patel, the boss lady. Many thanks to the whole crew and thanks to you guys for listening. Come
  694. back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Ty Hildenbrandt discusses Indiana's championship win and the impact of analytics and the transfer portal on college football.

Key points

  • The Four Pillars of Analytics. Audi Winer discusses the four pillars of sports analytics: descriptive, predictive, decision-making, and training.
  • Dramatic Championship Moment. A discussion on a dramatic play that defined a recent college football game.
  • Bills' Heartbreak. Despite having the best point differential, the Bills fired their coach after another playoff loss.
  • The Value of Quarterbacks. Discussion on how much a top quarterback is worth in points, revealing surprising insights.
  • Miami's Resilience. Despite being heavy underdogs, Miami adjusts and nearly wins against Indiana, showcasing their determination.
  • NFL Draft Predictions. Insights into the potential of quarterbacks in the upcoming NFL draft, focusing on processing speed.

Episode highlights

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes