Why the Best Teams Don’t Always Win

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE If the best team does not always win, how much of sports success comes down to skill, strategy, or randomness?

Eric Eager, Vice President of Football Analytics for the Carolina Panthers, explains how analytics can help make sense of unpredictable outcomes. The conversation examines the Home Run Derby, tournament design, World Cup win probabilities, competitive balance, and the outsized influence of superstar players.

The discussion also explores how salary caps shape roster construction, why baseball may be approaching the end of the 200-game winner, and whether momentum can explain the performance cycles of elite golfers.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome Welcome to wharton money ball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics
  2. Here on the wharton podcast network. This is kade massey hosting this july week With the whole crew and it has been
  3. a while since we've had the whole crew in here Even shane jensen is back in country in office Ready to go eric bradlow
  4. is here from points afar Audie weiner In the office as well audie's working. He's doing like doing the teacher thing at
  5. this moment Doing doing doing the lord's work on campus in philadelphia. I am not I am distant as well
  6. But we're all here together glad to be with the crew. We're going to run an hour This summer
  7. show as we typically do we're recording on tuesday In fact, we're recording as france and
  8. spain are playing the world cup semifinal in dallas, I believe is that right and Eric,
  9. bradlow tells us that spain has scored on a penalty kick early in the match to take a 1-0 lead We'll keep that
  10. posted as we go along because we are interested We will have a guest in the first half hour as we typically do these
  11. days and then we'll roll into what we somewhat Crazily call open lines in the second
  12. half of the show and see what is on everyone else's mind But in the first half we're going to take as a guide
  13. A good friend long time friend of the show one of the Absolute leaders in sports
  14. analytics that we know of anywhere Eric eager is here to join us. Eric is also in philadelphia helping oddy with
  15. that good work on campus working with the students taking a break from his Day job
  16. with the carolina panthers where he is the vice president of football analytics Eric, I may
  17. be rolling into his third season. Let's see if I have that right He of course was with pff.
  18. He really kind of helped build out the research program there at pff um And before
  19. that somewhere along the line, he picked up a math phd Kids got a few things going on and we always it was a
  20. tenured math professor. We can't forget that tenured math professor Not just a math phd.
  21. He's done a few things eric. Good to see you. Thanks for joining Okay. Thank you so much.
  22. Uh shane oddy eric. It's uh, it's a pleasure. I um, I can't remember what I was telling this to Maybe it was at lunch.
  23. Uh, you know, this was one of the shows that um, you know When I when I got onto the show for the first
  24. time it was like one of the like the fun You know, you do so many radio hits you do so many of these
  25. like content things uh for sports and this was a show that I had admired, you know for years and years and years and
  26. it was Fun to finally be a guest and now Uh, it was fun to hear my boss, uh, brant tillis be a guest
  27. a few months ago. I thought he did a great job. So Um, it's uh, yeah, it's it's really
  28. fun to be back on and even though I can't really talk football Uh, there's there's
  29. more than enough things that are going on. That'll be fun to talk about Well, I told kade that you would be wearing your
  30. math professor hat And joining us as an analyst and someone who just thinks about sports
  31. and that's what we do each week That's that's fine. That'll be enjoyable. Of course It's coming up on football season
  32. and so the the desire to ask you questions even on college football I was in the gym this morning and I was getting
  33. a replay of like Oklahoma south carolina and I was just eating it up because i'm
  34. so desperate for college football But we're gonna set that aside For the next half hour
  35. and just find out what else you've been thinking about eric What's cut your eye and
  36. why don't we start i'll start and then you go from there Start with the home run competition you and oddy at least maybe
  37. others you and oddy were at the ballpark last night at the home run competition you
  38. guys I know we're talking about it, so What cut your eye about that? Yeah, it was it was a lot of
  39. fun. I mean, I think uh, what's been cool, you know when you when you are You know kind of working for a vendor, right?
  40. You have to be kind of on call all the time and you know since joining carolina i've had a decent amount of like
  41. free time as far as um, you know this time of year and also, you know certain certain nights and weekends are sort of
  42. uh walled off thanks to some of the The graces of my bosses so i've been watching a lot more baseball with my daughter
  43. madeline and she's a she's a big-time milwaukee brewer fan and I I remember texting
  44. uh oddy and saying like hey, why are they are they stealing more bases? It's like just being so curious about a
  45. game that you sort of like grow up with and um, and you know, you know, you obviously read moneyball and all that stuff
  46. But then like as as I grew in one sport, I let sort of my interests and others wane a little bit And it's
  47. been fun to kind of reconnect with baseball a little bit and then last night, you
  48. know um being able to go and see uh You know, I remember there was a one of the batters, um, you know, uh
  49. oddy turns to me He's like yeah, you know of these batters his like exit velocity
  50. is not as good as the rest of them I don't predict that he'll do particularly well tonight And and sure enough that happened
  51. and it was it was just kind of fun like the amount of information that some of these Uh that some of these events
  52. give us and and um Can I ask you a follow-up question on that? Did why did you do you have some
  53. empirical data that suggests that exit velocity is strongly predictive Of the number of home runs
  54. like maybe you could also imagine i'll make us up Someone has only a finite amount
  55. of power to put into swings Maybe hitting 12 home runs each of 370 feet at a 95 exit velocity is better than hitting
  56. six of them At a 115 where you're swinging through the fences. All right, that's a great question and i'm
  57. gonna uh, I'll answer that and turn it back to eric as well. So the player in question actually was ben
  58. rice Um who has by far the lowest exit velocity among the players last night But
  59. he I think is second to schwarber and in numbers of home runs at this point in the season So what makes a home
  60. run hitter is not just exit velocity It's picking the right pitches, but ben writes clearly
  61. picked the wrong pitcher. He picked his dad and he couldn't throw it over Um, so and and he didn't
  62. seem to want to wait it out until the ball was right over him But it made a difference.
  63. I mean the the fact was is that the titanic home runs being hit Uh at the game last night that um, you know,
  64. jr Um caminero was hitting that uh, the red socks guy whose name i'm blanking on.
  65. Uh, remind me shane. Um was Unbelievable home runs. Oh, uh, you mean, um Wilson Yeah, sorry
  66. I mean I can tell you that When you don't get all of it or at the right angle having those extra five miles
  67. per hour Makes a difference being a home run and a fly out. There was quite a few balls that went
  68. off the wall well, and one thing that was really really interesting that you pointed out
  69. was the first two hitters got to hit with a wind that Was significantly or not. I don't know significantly, but like There and
  70. then the middle hitters To the end of the the group didn't get nearly as much wind with them and then The difference last
  71. night between the left-handed batters and the right-handed batters was interesting like the right
  72. -handed batters Seemed to have had a much better time of it. Um, and you know even schwarber like You
  73. know in his first set of you know First set of um pitches was not as impressive maybe as a second set of pitches
  74. And yeah, it was it was it was fun. Just looking at like the heterogeneity of the
  75. situations that even all the batters within the same uh competition had to face so I
  76. did a little bit of a pre pre uh Home run derby homework. Well, I actually did an analysis and um,
  77. i'll put the question to you So what I did was for every home run derby participant in the last 25 years I gave
  78. them a a score on what type of player their career has been or will has ended up A couple of them are on
  79. the edge like like last year cal raleigh isn't really kind of beginning and and uh,
  80. I rated The players by the group so the winners the runner-ups and everybody else
  81. I compared their average kind of quality rating on a scale of one to five um What do you think?
  82. I observed how career career runner-ups compared to the losers career post like career quality
  83. Over the entire their entire career So one number and i'm a little bit sketchy on
  84. guys like raleigh who have a very I tried my best Clear audio you want us to make a prediction of the average one
  85. to five rating of the winner the second place person and then everyone else Okay, I
  86. will guess an inverted you Okay Anyone else? No, no hypothesis. No. No. Yeah, great one shane.
  87. Yeah uniform. These are all like Already so he knows the answer no and this is the answer
  88. is not The winners are better than the runner-ups who are better than everybody else
  89. get out. Yeah, really And if you go look at the winners, I was looking for winners.
  90. You look at them and you're like, oh my god Those guys were great. Um Winning the home run derby.
  91. This is why this guy will walker. Was it whoever won last night? Um, it turns out it's not just it's
  92. not losing doesn't mean anything tons and tons of losers But the winners there's only maybe
  93. so to oscar hernandez who won last year I don't know what that guy's gonna be in by the time his career is over.
  94. There's only one guy Historian last 25 years who's clearly was not really a star who
  95. won Does anyone make a guess? I mean he played for the yankees for a while He was todd frazier.
  96. I'm like who the hell todd frazier, but if you look at everybody else, it's it's
  97. you know, they're big names and uh And and that's gets Big names, too. I I guess i'm more just sort of
  98. surprised that somehow the winner of this Seemingly it's it's I it's it seems to me
  99. like a fairly random competition Yeah, but it's not right additional i'm being a home run
  100. big home run hitter And I feel like all the big home run hitters. Yeah, I mean you're selecting for big home
  101. run hitters, but Beyond that it seems random. I don't know what to make of it I'm looking here at the list and I
  102. agree with you. Yeah, we could argue that justin mourneau. I mean, okay Yeah, but he wouldn't have
  103. ryan howard vlad guerrero prince fielder big poppy. Are you looking at a similar list of
  104. the second? Runners up. No, I have that list too. So that's why you have to norm it
  105. I have that so I have that list also I can show you that if you look at the runners up and then They
  106. just aren't as impressive as the winners. It's not that big a drop by the way, but All the winners I think what's
  107. notable is all the winners are stars and not all the runner-ups are I mean not even okay guys What about the new
  108. format? We talk a lot about tournament design This is a small tournament design and people made
  109. a fuss about it ahead of time 20 pitches No, no, no time limit. It's just 20 pitches and then this neat
  110. thing where if they hit a home run on the last pitch They get it make it take it keep on going What were
  111. your assessments ex ante and ex post of the tournament design eric? I I felt like it, you know, there
  112. was I felt like it was very clean Um the way that it was and then obviously the the cool thing that you have
  113. that mimics baseball Is sort of the infinite game if you stay alive, um, which is
  114. which is what the the winner took advantage of at the end uh, which I thought was a was a cool was a cool
  115. add to it, but yeah, those events are tough because You know, there's probably no one
  116. Optimal answer and you're you're basically you're going for entertainment probably more so than you're going
  117. for fairness in many cases So I found it entertaining. I thought that the the show moved on
  118. pretty well Um, and then obviously at the end it added the it added the anything
  119. is possible-ness to it That you really wanted sporting events. So I thought it was I thought it
  120. was a good addition good a good I always hated the timer. So i'm glad they got rid of that
  121. because I feel like I mean it's already a a bit of a synthetic environment, but uh It makes it even less like baseball
  122. I feel like if it's like you're on kind of this like continuous clock and I mean I I feel like it really Led
  123. the players to kind of exhaust themselves a lot more In the old service system. I don't know also I think also part
  124. of the skill that oddy talked about is picking the right pitches for you to swing
  125. at And so no one forced you to swing at that pitch. There's no clock running You could have let
  126. that ball go and you chose not to okay. That's an important refinement. It's 20 swings not 20 pitches 20 swings
  127. Okay, okay I like the refinement. I love the fact that the top round was was best four out of eight So
  128. you didn't have to get eliminated because you've happened to have faced the unbelievable monstrosity that
  129. somebody You know had uh, I like that. Um The you know, the real question to me we talked about this last year.
  130. Um, are they juicing the balls? Which is only I mean, it's obviously only entertainment, right?
  131. So it doesn't really matter. I hope so. Yeah You argue is if they can juice the balls for the Home run derby they
  132. can juice the balls at will for wherever and that's something that that is a little
  133. uncomfortable. Um, and Are you uncomfortable with the notion that they have the ability to juice the
  134. balls? Okay Oddie wants the ball to be the same ball as it was in 1950. Come on.
  135. Well, I do I what do you mean oddie? Don't leave me out of that It's an uncomfortable reality, I guess yeah, and I will
  136. say every player last night. I mean I didn't check Exactly, but but I think at least at least to first
  137. order every player hit a ball Last night further than they've had all season and maybe
  138. their career No But it's but but they're being thrown to it like a totally different
  139. speed that like it's right and by the way But velocity adds to distance and they're
  140. being lobbed at at 50 miles an hour Yeah But they it's easier. It's easier easier to hit exactly the way
  141. they want to hit it, right? But but you have a you have your career to hit, you know, and and a
  142. 95 mile an hour fastball goes further than a 50 mile Okay, interesting. Yeah. All right.
  143. All right guys Question let me ask you one of the questions as a measurement guy
  144. What do you think? Let's start with eric eager. Let's imagine they reran the home run derby
  145. a large number of times What's the probability that the guy who won in your estimation
  146. would win again? Great question eric Yeah, it's sort of like these questions you get in the world cup
  147. It's like with a pre-flop probability of the team winning and then what happens after
  148. a goal? Like how do you update you update game state and then do you update the your
  149. your your posteriors on the players? um, yep, okay, so there's eight of them, um, I thought that Walker the guy that
  150. won had one of the the smoothest swings I think like relative to the rest of the field like I think that that would
  151. play more so i'm going to update from you know, my hold on eric Hold on eric. You're a quant you work in a sport
  152. with great skepticism about the eye test Have you just updated your posterior because of your
  153. expert ability? I didn't buy good baseball The areas are that you work with the tools you have
  154. I don't I don't have great Like I don't have like these these models for these these these baseball players plus I do think
  155. some players have a sweet swing man. Some players just have a sweet swing Yeah, so when I when I looked at when
  156. I watched him swing I felt like he was using well and there was the other part of he did he did he have
  157. the fortune of Playing in the first or in the second round where he didn't have to play out the whole string Which we
  158. talked about oddy on the way back. Um That I think that helped. I mean i'll probably say like 17 and
  159. a half percent That was the the only thing I was interested in was how far off 12 and a half you were going
  160. to move um Well, I mean, let me can I respond because I watched the same context.
  161. Um, I will say that The I mean walker was consistent all three rounds um, and so Schwarber was pretty consistent as well the
  162. others were more random, I mean we didn't see four of them around two, but I would argue that it's probably a little higher
  163. 20. Um, 25 percent And you might give schwarber the other. Oh, I would give schwarber.
  164. I would give um I would definitely give um Uh, who else um junior caminero a good chunk.
  165. He was eliminated Um contraris looked pretty impressive contraris looked really good in the first first
  166. round He was crazy good in the first round But looked much more, uh, much less convincing in the second and that's where you
  167. get the the correlation, right? So the fact that walker went through three great And the others were schwarb schwarber had
  168. a way a very tough first half his first 10 swings Were pretty weak in the first round and he basically just just squeaked
  169. through In round one So, yeah The first two hitters were so prolific oddy that you
  170. and I were look look to each other after they went 13 13 And I want to say the third one went 12 And
  171. then we we said to ourselves what's the likelihood that 13's enough to make it to
  172. the second round? And then 13 ended up leading the first round not only just making it through All
  173. right, guys, let's let's leave that should as an outsider Should I think about the home
  174. run derby as I mean audience just told us that it's a little more diagnostic than
  175. I might Have thought but mostly it strikes me as Genius entertainment way to get more
  176. eyeballs on baseball. Maybe boost popularity a little bit. They keep on tweaking the Format, which is
  177. fantastic. We want to see experimentation, but it's kind of the baseball's version of the draft I
  178. mean the nfl has created eric eager has to shut up now for a second But the nfl has created this event in april
  179. that just you know Unbelievably increases attention to the league and that's actually meaningful that means
  180. something for future teams This is pretty meaningless and yet it seems to have done a
  181. similar thing But just also to be clear remember It's a self-selected process to get
  182. into the home run derby And then it's talking about winners of this self-selected process
  183. So the fact is if I put a bunch of first and second year players Let me oddy you could clarify your statement some
  184. of the like if someone won the let's imagine you had a first year player That won got into the home run derby somehow
  185. and won the home run derby You're not going to predict they're having a career like
  186. vlad guerrero. You're not saying it has Predictability. Well, I mean i'm i'm i'm don't know
  187. it But I actually am saying that that's a possibility I'm, not not saying it Is that what you say it's more would you
  188. say it's more just a a rat like you're basically just stamping of approval on a player Yeah, that's where People gonna pay attention
  189. to him in a way that they'd never paid attention to him at all I mean, I have to say I I emailed high
  190. and bloom. He's at the cardinals. I said, where'd you find this guy? you know and because I never heard of
  191. him and I'm gonna watch his career going forward. Um, you know, but the thing is about
  192. About the home run derby it's entertainment but it sells the game because it's not Not
  193. in the game and one of the things that's so beautiful about Baseball and two things
  194. i'll point out that you notice live. First of all, they hit it an Unbelievable long way and that is just gorgeous If
  195. you if you grew up around baseball watching guys hit a ball nearly 500 people Disappearing
  196. into the nether reaches of the fan. It's just gorgeous The other thing is they put all these amateurs kids out there trying
  197. to catch the balls They're hopeless at it And it gives you a measure We need the analytics on that.
  198. Yeah. Well also the philly fans were ruthless with them Like any time one of those kids
  199. in the pink shirt dropped the ball Yeah, let me ask let me ask audie. Let me ask a question both to you.
  200. Let me ask more to kate Because it comes back to motivation and stuff Is there any possibility?
  201. That winning the home run derby early in your career Could be bad for your career
  202. Because you start to believe you're a hitter that you're not and or to audie's point
  203. No one was paying attention to this guy walker before they are now And now all of a sudden he gets tougher pitches.
  204. Maybe they spend more time studying his video I'm, just arguing is there a possibility that
  205. this could have hurt your career I mean, you know i'm going to be skeptical of that but but I also want to articulate
  206. the alternative possibility Which is this changes your conception of yourself? It changes what you think is possible But
  207. mostly these are things that I don't want to take too seriously Let us stop there
  208. for a second because eager is going to have to leave And he hasn't had a chance yet to direct our attention.
  209. I want to just say eric eager Where would you take us? We can't talk about pro football or college
  210. football presumably even friggin high school football, but of the other Topics available to you.
  211. Where would you take us? You could make us talk about anything you want Where are you gonna go?
  212. I i've been interested in obviously the world cup because it's you know In my my
  213. former like in my former field of of like mathematical biology There was this there's always
  214. there's a this theorem that says like in competitive environments The only way that you get
  215. coexistence is through stochasticity, right? And like that's basically like all of sports
  216. and I feel like Eric Eric, you have to say that in english before we go on So so in competitive environments where there's
  217. like a clear ranking and and that's not even true in most sports But but in when there's a clear ranking between species, let's
  218. say the only way that you have coexistence is through is through stochastic like randomness, right?
  219. and I feel like otherwise just the top that the the higher fitness species would just
  220. dominate and take over Will just dominate because they're better at everything and so, you know,
  221. you need you need you need either heterogeneous rankings so like one team's great at defense
  222. one team's great at offense or you need Randomness, right? You need you need you know days where
  223. the better team loses and and and so on and or the better species loses because of environmental factors that were unpredictable and I
  224. think that um This world cup while having the top four clubs Be make the the semifinals Obviously is unprecedented And and in many
  225. ways feels chalky having watched a decent amount of these matches I I have not felt
  226. that that has been the intermatch five absolutely and so that has been kind of I
  227. was at the congo versus england game where congo scored in the first 10 minutes of
  228. the game of the match And you know we got until you know minutes 75 before england scored i'm telling you in it in
  229. that stadium in atlanta Almost all the fans were either neutral or england fans and the
  230. tense how tense it was for those 65 minutes where it was thought of that england
  231. could bow out to to the the To the conganese was like was was was exhilarating And so I I want you know, obviously
  232. to throw it out to you guys What has been your impression of the world cup both from like a competitive Competitive balance but
  233. also a gameplay standpoint Um, I I have found it as somebody who is just kind of a soccer fan Not not like a
  234. full-fledged one Uh and somebody who yeah, obviously because i'm on a team. I don't like gamble or anything Uh like
  235. that, so I don't really have any skin in the game other than you know, wanting the u.s to do well um I
  236. have found it as a neutral observer to be incredibly Uh entertaining and I I found
  237. that the the gameplay has been has been fun to watch. What have you guys thought?
  238. It it does seem I I'll just kind of echo um, it's almost like the world cup seems to have this incredible ability to
  239. like regress to chalk like it'll like It'll tease and upset Like crazy and you'll get
  240. all excited. You're like no this this would really be one and then it'll It's still just the
  241. same four teams at the end that we knew was gonna be at the end so I I just yeah, I I I guess
  242. I I feel like it's it's it's always amazing to me um Given the inherent stochasticity
  243. or randomness I see in the in in the gameplay itself And the chances back and forth that it does end up being kind
  244. of so chalky um And uh, but but you know, maybe maybe maybe worse maybe that's maybe i'm reading too much into the chalkiness
  245. this time around too A couple things that stuck out to me eric were first of all like argentina to date Has not been
  246. good Like they should have been beaten. I think they I forget it was egypt. They were down to nothing I think they
  247. scored three goals in the last 13 minutes Um, and I think as I remember there was either a penalty or one called back
  248. because of a foul away from the ball It went it went both it went both ways. Um, Egypt has one call back and argentina
  249. didn't have one call back, right? And there was one in um as I remember when I guess it was norway was
  250. playing was it england? Where there was a foul like three thousand feet behind the ball or something like that
  251. that got another one called back So all i'm coming i'm not saying the teams that
  252. are there don't deserve to be there All i'm saying is that we could be talking about an entirely different narrative in other words
  253. If they play these games, i'll just go back to the same question. I asked about the home run derby If
  254. they play this tournament all over again What fraction of times are these the four teams
  255. that make it to the semi-finals? And i'm not that and and again, we're not going to talk about college football But
  256. every beginning of every college football season kate asks us the same damn question which is
  257. Pick the top four teams you want Assign the probability that these teams are going to
  258. be like in the last four when it was only four teams in the tournament Kind of thing and i'd say oh, I don't
  259. know 40 50 percent He'd run his stem the massey peabody said maybe like three percent
  260. or something like that We always overestimate the amount of chalk and i'm not convinced after
  261. watching these games That if we played this tournament a thousand times that there'd be more
  262. than Oh, I don't know at most 10 percent of the time that these four teams would be the final four Yeah, but but
  263. but but it would be I'm, just going to point out that eric is taking a different position than eric eager and shane started
  264. with which was there's something It seems like there's something about the inevitability despite the Stochasticity
  265. it seems inevitable that the better team emerges and shane's like maybe i'm misremembering it eric's
  266. like I don't believe that at all One quick anecdote to throw into this on the norway england bit just because I need to
  267. lament it a bit more Was that two for one that norway had with holland and their other player when they were up one
  268. nil And it was late in the first half and the guy didn't pass the ball to holland And ended up not making a
  269. play at all and it's like that would have been 2-0 And it would have been a different deal altogether It's like that's
  270. another one to fold fold into eric's if you played this again thing But i'm i'm at a bit of a loss for what
  271. the model is And we have a mathematician here to help us. What's the model of a game that feels
  272. that random and yet? There's this inexorability about the better teams emerging or do we have it wrong audie was
  273. going to try to get in Yeah I want to get eric to have the last word But i'm just going to get in
  274. is that this is the first time that there's been one two, three Four in the seedings making it to the finals So that
  275. suggests if you look at the rankings of the top four historically, there's typically One or
  276. two of the top teams there and then two others that are quite distant So I think when we say the inevitability, it's almost
  277. inevitably the winner um, and I think that that's ultimately what we're observing and in fact
  278. We talked about on the show that that I thought that the the probability of a new winner Was way too high in the
  279. betting markets I think it was like 30 and of course, it's not going to be a new winner all four are yeah, and
  280. just to try to Put the record i'd personally cost audie weiner money because he was
  281. no it's it's it's not you It's your it's it's my star student. Um, my one of my best of all
  282. time. Zach bradlow He's the one who said he gave me the reason why it should be 30 And I got spooked out of it
  283. and I ended up i'm not betting i'm responsible I think if you want to go all the way back to the causality eric
  284. is the reason but yeah Yes, that's what I was saying. Eric. I'm the reason i'm That does work that
  285. way shane was going to jump in shane Well, I just want to point out that I think eric when you were talking about
  286. oh these same four repeated over That's too restrictive a definition of chalk Really I I
  287. like kind of more Audi like if we really want to say about going chalk, it's No, no new winners basically because I mean,
  288. yeah, I I mean this time england happened to be in the final four Maybe in like half the repetitions brazil's in the final
  289. four instead. I'm good It's always the same. I was intentionally using restrictive definition.
  290. I like your definition better. I agree with that. Yeah Yeah I think That you know make
  291. it up as as eric eager was saying, you know, maybe the congo beats england could
  292. very well be But let's see them beat three other teams pain and then france or their path Guys, I have a question.
  293. I have a question for y'all. We've all paid more Maybe I don't know. Maybe audi hasn't audi has some hater tendencies
  294. on this sport. We all have watched more soccer Over the last six weeks than we have on the
  295. previous four years Um, what is one thing that you appreciate about the sport now That
  296. you've learned or learned to appreciate over the last six weeks something new about the sport
  297. eric eager first Yeah, I to me there's two things. Sorry. I the the one is how non-monotone
  298. the win probabilities like if you just look at either the you know, the markets or
  299. the the if you look at the um, like the the models The the the extra time and the and the penalty kicks especially
  300. in this knockout round Uh, like the the the fact that there's like and and one of my friends alerted me to this So
  301. it's not it's not necessarily original but I noticed I I cannot not notice it now
  302. Um where it's you know, once you're getting in a minute 80 You know the the the probability of the favorite winning it, you
  303. know Grows quite a bit because there's no time for an answer and then all of a sudden this new third of a game
  304. opens up where There's an opportunity for the underdog to match if if there were to
  305. be a goal scored by the favorite And so like that, you know in in you know in in games that are a little
  306. bit more sudden death, you know in overtime uh, like like american football or at least
  307. like or In some ways, you know the historical version of it you would have win probabilities that were a little bit more monotone
  308. as the game was finishing um, so that that's one that I I I really you know, and then the other part that I
  309. just don't think eric Let me just real quickly Eric real quickly because you're making a
  310. very interesting point, but you're using technical language that some of our listeners won't with be
  311. with Monotonicity means it's always either increasing or staying the same and never starts decreasing and
  312. eric is pointing out that these probabilities Go up and come down over the late at
  313. different points in the game, especially with extra time and that's odd for sports And that's
  314. an interesting observation Yeah, just because you you have the you have these different sticking points
  315. in the game that are that are interesting and and so it was just it was fun to watch that and to kind of
  316. and think about it and then I just didn't grow up watching this or watching or playing the sport.
  317. It's much more physical than I thought it was and Um that that part of it like I was why I forget which I
  318. think was belgium I mean belgium had a guy in the I think I was center back or some some position I'd say this
  319. is how little I know still but one of the guys like literally just like bach bodying other players in the middle of the
  320. pitch for like the whole game and And that guy could play fullback for a team It felt like at the end of the
  321. at the end of the game how physical he was And that's just something that I think it was fun to be introduced to
  322. Yeah, that's great. Somebody else. Let's hear something from everybody on something You
  323. appreciate and oddy yours can be negative if you want it to be negative eric bradlow.
  324. No, actually, I I don't have negativity um I've enjoyed watching quite a bit of soccer.
  325. I would say that it's much more fun to have a rooting interest and um And I know lots of people have talked about
  326. loving to watch soccer just to watch soccer that part I haven't quite figured out yet,
  327. but if you're Have a rooting interest that game is unbeatable Because you're just literally at
  328. the edge of your seat for 90 minutes and you just don't come off it. There's no relaxation because there's no I mean
  329. now they have hydration breaks. But other than that, it's just You know what? I don't get I don't want to be
  330. negative what I don't get but i'm gonna be What I don't get is when you don't care.
  331. I mean really what the hell? Um, it's uh, okay Okay, you know some of the rest of us might chime in
  332. on that one I mine will chime in on that one a little bit shane or eric bradlow I'll just say a couple things
  333. one is I realize Obviously we were more excited after the group stage in the first
  334. game the u.s is very far away I mean they lost badly to belgium who would not is not really competitive against the
  335. top teams Um, even just their skill level and passing It's like it's a totally different
  336. game watching them play forget the outcome of the game Just watch the passing and the
  337. movement and everything else. That was one thing the second thing was I I think It's crucially important to have
  338. someone that Remind me oddy xg plus Remind me that that you guys were talking about
  339. last week on the show. Um, which is again some guys Just help create goals and I understand like That's part
  340. of the reason they've advanced but I mean Mbappe is special Messi is special Harry kane
  341. is special Bellingham special so all i'm commenting on is is that to win Without one
  342. of these i'll call them all-time greats. I'm in my opinion Is very very hard to do because when it comes down to
  343. it You're going to need someone that either scores really efficiently or creates goals for other
  344. people When it's not really there and I think having super super stars really matters, that's
  345. just my opinion and credit to the u .s Oh, go ahead. Okay. Well, I was gonna say this just noting
  346. the difference. We just saw the carolina hurricanes When uh stanley cup with a different philosophy their philosophy
  347. was depth And we're not going to worry about going at the trade deadline to get a big star We're gonna we're gonna win
  348. through having four great lines. It's very counter for hockey Just proved out this year than eric is suggesting for soccer,
  349. but shane, please jump in well, no, and I mean, I guess I was going to make the glib comment that we've at least
  350. advanced such that The u.s has recognized that when they have one of those stars
  351. available, but they're not available for the game in question They just need they they need
  352. to go that extra step and make the call Make the call. Okay. Shane. What else you got?
  353. What else you got on the sport? I I unfortunately I have to go a little negative in that I I was I
  354. continue to be frustrated by The offsides and the the way you saw in offsides is
  355. implemented in soccer and I feel like a lot of kind of really cool goals Are called back kind of against the spirit of
  356. I mean, I understand the spirit of the rule but I I i'm dreaming big of a future where We have like kind of
  357. more like an end zone kind of structure And I want you guys to think or maybe push back on this if you think
  358. it's a stupid idea There would still be a boundary somewhere that could be violated by
  359. a by a there's still a line but it would be more like in hockey where all you have to do is make sure
  360. that You know one thing there's not there's nobody in that zone Okay before the ball
  361. is in that zone, which is easier to kind of enforce and and and kind of You're saying you it's okay to be off
  362. sides as long as you're not in some zone Yeah, like changing exactly and so like
  363. I mean, I understand the intent of offsides Like so you don't have cherry picking and
  364. all these kind of like, you know type of behavior. I I get that but changing it to
  365. a point where it's like You know, you can have a little bit more back and forth because essentially it just works to suppress
  366. goals And a lot of cool, you know Essentially legitimate looking goals are suppressed especially now
  367. with var aided kind of like You know by microns offside kind of calls All right guys i'll give mine we need to wrap
  368. up and cut eric eager loose here But just to close the loop i'll say two real quick ones one the the diving is
  369. just horrendous and possibly disqualifying for the sport if you if you could if you You
  370. can decide you don't like soccer just because the diving I think that's utterly a reasonable
  371. position to take I mean, that's just like it's absurd. We're training new kids every year into the
  372. culture of Lie about what happened in order to advance your team But more what I
  373. do appreciate and I think I appreciated more this time than ever before was And this
  374. is my answer to you adi It feels to me like almost every moment of the entire match.
  375. There's a contest of skill going on like can the player Keep the ball. Can the player keep it away from this
  376. other guy? Can the player connect a pass like almost every moment? There's something that I couldn't do that's playing
  377. out there and it's a contest of one or two guys And I think that's a neat um a neat feature of the sport
  378. Why don't we stop there? We've kept eric eager longer than we expected to eric. We could go on for a long time
  379. with you We hope to see you back again soon um, and um, we wish you the best with everything that's going to come
  380. this season for the carolina panthers Well, thanks for having me guys. It's it's a pleasure and honor and like
  381. like you said go panthers Go panthers eric eager vp of football analytics that the carolina
  382. panthers rolling into what I believe is his third season in that position Which happens to
  383. track he and brent tillis got there at the same time And that happens to track the progress of their one loss record go
  384. track it go look at it That's analytics for you. Welcome to the second half of this week's
  385. show We are just off the line with eric eager vp of football analytics with the carolina panthers long time front of the show
  386. helped create the r and d group at Pff kind of turned it into what it became before leaving there um, he was also
  387. with um sumer We missed that in the introduction. He was with super sports for a couple
  388. years between pff and the carolina um panthers Eric always fun to talk to um, we
  389. just oddy rolled off the show as well. Oddy is mid teaching and is wearing down vocally So in order to preserve his best
  390. for his students He's going to take the second half of the show off eric Bradlow
  391. shane jensen and I will be in here through the balance from about 15 20 minutes here second half of the show We got
  392. a lot of sports going on. It's a good time of year. I'm curious we talked A lot of baseball
  393. home run derby in particular. We talked world cup. What else fellas world cup It just flashed
  394. up on my phone. So there's now it's 60 minutes into the game It's now two to nothing spain and
  395. I just want to point out by the way that prior to this game france had twice the win probability Essentially of any other
  396. team they were almost at 40 percent. It wasn't exactly 40 20 20 20, but it was close enough Um, and they're down
  397. to nothing with 30 minutes to play Yeah, they've been the most impressive club Everybody has
  398. said they the ex-ante odds were highest and then everybody's been more impressed with them
  399. than anybody else So so here we get to see some of eric eager Stochasticity that
  400. we were talking about and more the eric bradlow model of soccer than what we were
  401. talking about Well, let's see. Let's see how it plays out. Um Okay, that's on the world cup front
  402. what else what else fellas So I i'd love to talk wimbledon But i'm going to skip that for a second.
  403. I'd love to talk Scotty scheffler and him missing his first cut in like 86 years,
  404. but i'm not going to talk about that either Um, although if we go a second round, this is more for shane so Turns
  405. out my son zach who eric you already mentioned his uh, you know girlfriend who's serious
  406. with about to move in She's a big and i'm ducks fan and Leo carlson is on the ducks and Someone has to explain
  407. to me how leo carlson Who I just i'm not an expert in hockey as you know, I just looked up his stats for
  408. last season He scored 67 points in 70 games, which is very good Um, he was plus four.
  409. His plus minus was plus four, which I don't know doesn't seem great to me How is this man the highest paid player?
  410. in hockey I mean, it's it's kind of I mean I guess I can explain kind of the concept of like restricted free agency
  411. in hockey um Where a hockey player has basically gotten I think to the end of their first contract But has not gotten enough
  412. service time essentially gotten enough service time or has not been around long enough to be
  413. an unrestricted free agent um so The kind of during that kind of period other teams
  414. can basically essentially extend offers to the players Which the flyers did you know, and then
  415. the the the home team kind of has you know The option to pick uh to essentially match or not and if they don't
  416. match then the player moves and there's draft picks that come across in compensation So the
  417. anaheim so this is a case where you've got like a young Incredibly good center like
  418. I mean a a top player for the future, I think But like not, you know kind of certainly at a superstar level yet
  419. but um that Anaheim was essentially forced to lock up They didn't want to let let
  420. go but was forced to lock up. I think at like kind of a higher offer Than they otherwise would have because of
  421. the philadelphia offer Yeah, so that's what I thought happened. So just to let you know, so he's
  422. getting five years and 90 million First of all, I wasn't even aware that the highest
  423. played players in hockey weren't at a higher level Like I didn't realize like I even
  424. if you had told me 18 million about that I think it's the highest by 3 million, but if you had told me I
  425. would have been shocked that that's the highest number Let's just start with that.
  426. So hold on eric. Hold on. Hold on I mean i'm almost shocked in the other direction that there is somebody making
  427. 18 a year now hockey has been Categorically below everything else for a while. I see.
  428. Well, this guy leo carlson is making 18 million a year okay, so real quickly the
  429. by my base rate Explanation without knowing anything but not an explanation hypothesis would have been
  430. an increased salary cap So I don't I don't know what the salary cap did this year, but the best way to get around
  431. the highest This is this does I think set a new high water Though the cap is going up this does set I think
  432. a new high water mark For percentage of cap taken percent of cap. Okay, at least Yeah, I I I you
  433. know, I'm again we're kind of comparing aav and I I don't know exactly how the contracts uh, Structure and stuff like that.
  434. But yes, I I do believe that this might be a new high water mark But it's going to quickly get passed.
  435. So connor bedard is a big winner out of this Yeah, because he's kind of entering
  436. that same kind of phase now um, and and some of the you know, it's sort of like I I think kind of um
  437. Team team stuff obviously like in hockey like anything else want to kind of lock up
  438. their young stars But I think those young stars are kind of getting expensive now Let
  439. me build on what kade said earlier You remember when I was talking about and we were talking with eric eager about the superstar
  440. model in soccer But we're talking about the the hurricanes who who won with depth and
  441. all that So let's I make an assumption. I'm not an expert that there is a hard cap potentially in hockey There's a salary
  442. cap in hockey, right? Yeah So, um, they were they were planning on paying carlson 13 million and now he
  443. got 40 percent above that number That has to impact The team's ability to build the
  444. kind of depth you're talking about So what impact will if the top end goes up? What like you could build a statistical model
  445. that would say number one You know, you better build much more accurate models of superstardom
  446. number two you better have a model then where you can't have that kind of depth because the salary cap is going to restrict
  447. you because This guy's now eating up. I don't know what the salary cap is in hockey But this guy might be eating
  448. up 30 percent of the salary cap. I don't know if it's no no, it's not that much It's more like is it
  449. a hundred million? What's the salary cap in hockey? Is it a hundred million? I think I saw somewhere that I think
  450. he's gonna be eating up like 17 to 18 percent of the load mean roughly 100 million It's a hundred million, but that's one
  451. player who's eating up. How many players are on a hockey team? Is it 20? Yeah, 25 I think 25.
  452. So this guy's eating up four and a half x The salary cap. Yeah, but again, it's it's the new high
  453. watermark, but I think the highest before was like 15 60 and like it's not It's this is not a dramatic jump in that
  454. percentage of the cap taken up by one player I agree It obviously does, you know,
  455. just like we talk about, you know If you're going to have patrick mahomes on your
  456. team making whatever percent of the salary cap You better draft really well because you're not
  457. going to have as much flexibility I I think it does it does have say that same sort of effect.
  458. It's just you know, I guess hockey doesn't usually have it Quite attributed as much to
  459. one. It also doesn't have the ability of like a patrick mahomes to say You know what
  460. or tom brady to say, you know what i'll don't worry Just pay me 40 million. I don't need 60 million in hockey.
  461. These guys are grabbing every dollar they can and they should Yeah, well, I just I
  462. want to I want to note that uh, eric is bringing hockey into the conversation Which
  463. is not usually what he does so shane you and I should be really happy that brad.
  464. No, that's amazing Tennis and golf i'm if it gets back to me, I will don't worry.
  465. So shane you're you're up next buddy What do you got? Well, i'll go. Yeah, I mean, I guess i'll i'll do
  466. a Baseball one just because you know, I think it was within this past week That justin verlander announced that he's going to retire
  467. at the end of this season and Essentially, I I kind of see him and max scherzer once those both retires the past varon
  468. In fact, it'll be I I think somebody calculated this out It'll be the first once
  469. max scherzer retires once verlander and scherzer are both retired. It'll be the first time since 1879 That
  470. there's not a 200 game winner in major league baseball And you could ask if there's
  471. ever going to be another 200 game winner again But it'll certainly be do you know
  472. who's third shane? I just looked it up while you were speaking. Do you know who's third?
  473. Like right now cole probably gary cole. Yeah, gary cole 156 Yeah, it's not close
  474. Yeah, no, he's I mean can chris sales. Uh, I think chris sales in that kind of range too but both I mean Getting
  475. another 50 wins out of either of those two guys that they're staging careers. I mean chancey at best we may be
  476. looking at the last of the Scherzer and verlander may be the last of the 200 game winners So this absolutely stunning and one
  477. of the fun things about baseball is that you can go back 150 years and that's just extraordinary But when we grew up the
  478. 20 game winner was kind of a benchmark essentially. Am I thinking about that correctly?
  479. What is the benchmark these days for good good starting pitchers and the number like a
  480. good starting pitcher might win how many games a year 18 17, I think we I mean probably That's the probably the top wins
  481. among pitchers not necessarily the Yeah, okay. I think the max still often gets to
  482. 17 18 in a season So, you know, we've got christopher sanchez. I think already has 11 or 12 11.
  483. He won. I think at least 11 I saw him win 11. Yeah yeah, but shane what you're pointing out
  484. is a couple things one is we talk about this like wins Are not just an individual statistic So first the phillies have to
  485. be a good team for a long period of time assuming sanchez stays in the phillies You have to have a good team around
  486. you because you could have a you know And then you have to pitch probably to win even 200 you probably have to have
  487. A very very very good 10-year stretch Even in today's days to win 15 plus a year for 10 plus years And they
  488. say, you know, you say well just win 17 a year for 10 years Oh, come on No, we're not Not when not when
  489. 17 is closer to the max across all baseball in the year as opposed to something that Even the elite pitchers can consistently replicate
  490. Also, I want to observe I heard in passing I caught some news bit a week or so ago um Paul skeen said he
  491. had started like seven or eight games without a win with the pirates, right? I mean, he's like one of the best
  492. pitchers in baseball goes seven or eight starts without a win Felix hernandez was obviously had
  493. a near hall of fame career, but was never really on good teams Right. Yeah, I think he should be in the
  494. hall of fame, but we'll talk about that another day All right, let's go with one
  495. more and eric eric, come on give me something i'm i'm going but it's going to be in service Of eric as well.
  496. It's what I would have picked but you'll be happy with it eric and that is uh, The british open the open as they
  497. say it's a cognizant. I call it the open is this weekend It is the last of the majors we
  498. end in july now, don't we because the pga got forward? So this is the last of four majors.
  499. It's at royal burkdale which is one on the rotation, um and and the notable thing
  500. is that sheffler is still the Odds on not the odds on favorite. He's the he's the favorite but um Barely
  501. and mackleroy basically is just right there behind him and the question that eric raised before
  502. the show was You know, we think that there's a lot of momentum in golf not that we think we know this We know
  503. the sports betters map it the quants map it they know this Sheffler missed his first
  504. cut last weekend at the scottish open first time. I think 78 starts. Yep Which is it's a long way from
  505. the record, but it's still a very it's like the fifth or sixth longest I think and a very good run, obviously Eric asked
  506. why is he still the favorite if we know that cyclicality matters momentum matters in golf
  507. and he seems to have been drifting down in recent tournaments, yeah, so What do you
  508. expect out of sheffler coming into world royal burkdale this weekend I expect sheffler to play.
  509. Well, I do not expect him to win I mean he hasn't won on the pga tour since his uh, he's won once early
  510. in the season He played he's played extremely well. I told you about his kind of he's
  511. been riddled with horrible second place finishes So it's not like a couple of them were
  512. backdoor But I mean the guy still had a streak of 30 something top 25s in a row I I predict sheffler will be
  513. in the top 25 Um, I will put him in 10th plus or minus five That would be my confidence interval for his performance,
  514. but I do not expect him to win I don't know why anybody would i'm not saying anybody he I just given the momentum
  515. right now There's a number of golfers top golfers playing better than him. So I I do not expect him to
  516. and i'll stand by my interval real quickly Real quickly, let's just note also that scotty
  517. is the defending champ I'm having one last year, but he's at 15 to 2 rory's at 17 to 2 Matt fitzpatrick comes in
  518. number 3 at 16 to 1 tommy fleetwood Still searching searching for his first major 18
  519. to 1 john rom Former dominant john rom he is fifth at 22 to 1 and then just running through the next few names
  520. Chris gotterup who's been a new guy on the on the on the scene the last one again Um, colin morikawa is back to
  521. playing good golf ludevig oberg the texas tech red raider um scandinavian xander shoffley Justin rose
  522. wyndham clark cameron young robert mcintyre tyrell happy any of these guys could win these guys
  523. will be open Yeah, this is a it's a good it's a good little run But I one of the things this reminds me
  524. of we've I think we speculated on the last couple of years How many different this
  525. is a modeling question for y'all just help me understand how you statisticians would think
  526. about it There's multiple arcs That we might imagine is this a reasonable way to think
  527. about here's here's here's the question How many arcs could we give a golfer to capture?
  528. momentum in a in a chronological Performance as a function of chronological time and i'm going
  529. to say like on three different frequencies. Obviously, there's a life curve There's a career
  530. age curve to a golfer we observe this kind of um I don't know There seem there is momentum Like in and out of
  531. the zone kind of thing There's this zone thing but then there's something kind of in
  532. the middle which is like golfers seem to kind of go through these longer term ups
  533. and Downs like more account was down for a couple years. It wasn't that he was down for a
  534. month or a summer He was down for a couple years So how many curves how reasonable is it to model golfers this way
  535. is to say let's throw an age curve in there Let's throw a heater. He's on a heater right now curve and
  536. then let's throw kind of a medium frequency curve That just captures what seems to be
  537. the truth about golfers that their games kind of ebb and flow Over a medium term.
  538. Is that reasonable? And if shuffler entering is shuffler entering an ebb on that middle frequency.
  539. Is he ebbing now in that middle frequency? What what it kind of struck me as you were kind of describing these three different
  540. kind of Frequencies is it was kind of remind me a little bit about baseball hitters,
  541. you know baseball hitters Certainly, they have the overall career arc they have The kind of
  542. like within a season a lot of ups and downs kind of of like, you know, maybe like they're uh, Mechanics change or something
  543. like that. There's kind of ups and downs that frequency. I think they're prevented a little bit Less
  544. because it's a team sport and they'll get selected out They're those kind of like two
  545. or three year period ups and downs are probably more present in golf Compared to a
  546. team sport because they're just not tolerated basically in more of a team, right?
  547. You don't observe them, right? All right. Yeah, I like it Okay, I think that's an excellent way to think about it.
  548. You know, I remember you know Shane's too young as a statistician, but you well not
  549. that you don't remember know who mike west is But I remember when they were doing
  550. these time series types of wavelet decompositions like you observe some High, you know frequency types
  551. of series and it's exactly what you're saying cade Which is you need you know, how
  552. many different curve types or what frequency are you going to analyze the data? You're going to do some sort of spectral
  553. or other form of decomposition of a time series And I think that is what you would find for golf.
  554. I think you would find some long-term age curve or trend I think you'd find some short-term But I think there would
  555. be some medium one which could last a couple of seasons and look let's remember Scotty
  556. shuffler's last four years four years ago roughly he had won zero tournaments Okay, he's won
  557. four majors. I think it is and 20 or 21 tournaments in the last four years If he
  558. did that for the next four years You would have to put him in the top 10 golfers of all time just on his
  559. record I mean 40 wins and eight majors would put you at tom watson greatness and
  560. i'm not saying shuffler won't get there But okay, so maybe over the next four years
  561. he wins one or two majors and only 10 tournaments, okay Well, then he's still as
  562. great as nick faldo and phil mickelson and he'll be 33 years old and then he'll still have 15 years to do stuff So
  563. yeah, I I think it's just we have forgotten that this man was 25 years old and had won nothing Nothing And now all
  564. of a sudden he's a hall of famer. He's a hall of famer right now so I don't know if this is an ebb
  565. and flow maybe it's just like It's not fair to come The only comparison you could
  566. say is is he gonna have like the 12 10 15 year heater that tiger woods had that's a benchmark Yeah, it's an unfair
  567. benchmark. He's had one of the great four-year runs In all of golf history and for
  568. that to continue I mean Well, that I love it. I love god. He's shuffler about it's not gonna happen Right,
  569. it's not but that that the inevitability of it not is interesting It's just interesting like
  570. what's going on that they cycle in and out like what happened with jordan speith.
  571. I mean, what I mean Spieth is a great example because speith I think won three majors and he's stuck on three, but he
  572. had a 15 minutes Yeah We could make an argument that if we erase the last two years what i've been talking about in
  573. our show for 12 years That was roy mcelroy Roy mcelroy had a four-year heater between age 21 and 25 People thought he
  574. was going to win 15 majors and then for 11 or 12 years He won zero and actually didn't and and he won a
  575. bunch of tournaments but not majors now all of a sudden of course He's vindicated because
  576. he's got six majors and two back-to -back masters, but I agree with you speith had this incredible speech a great example And
  577. by the way, I think most golf experts would be a question for rufus p buddy I don't think most people think speith's ever
  578. getting back I know exactly. I I mean it's it's interesting because I feel like golf especially is such a Mix
  579. of athleticism. It's both athletic and mechanics But it's also psychologically So mental right and so it's you
  580. know, it's kind of I think I think it is more fascinating like something like tennis
  581. I think maybe Their trajectories are a little bit more just athleticism based or whatever.
  582. I think or maybe maybe hold on Let's on that note. Let's throw eric one more bone.
  583. I watched the third set tie break that coca golf played against machova again in the
  584. semifinals Where um, she she had a volley on match point She had a volley at the net on match point that she just
  585. completely choked It was as bad a stroke as you'll see a player take in major. She tried to hit a touch drop shot
  586. When she rockets the ball down the line the match is over. It was a bad shot choice forget just
  587. that she didn't execute it It was the wrong shot. You just hate to see sports decided like
  588. that You just hate to see those kinds of moments, but you worry about the athlete
  589. in those situations Like when do they come over that i'm that's going to stay with
  590. her. She has to somehow overcome it It was a really it was a bad moment Um, why don't we wrap there guys?
  591. We've gone the full hour now Um for the whole team for eric eager our guests this week and for audie weiner Who is
  592. working on campus with eric eager this week and has been in absentia this second half
  593. of the show for shane jensen back From point points far abroad for eric bradlow here
  594. despite being far abroad for the whole team Um for um d patel the boss lady for the grodd squad who is running the
  595. show these days and jacob grodnick Who's on the board today many things and many thanks
  596. to you guys for listening Come back and join us next time between now and then Enjoy your sports

Brief Summary

Eric Eager discusses sports analytics, the Home Run Derby, and the World Cup's unpredictability in this episode of Wharton Moneyball.

Key points

  • Welcome to Wharton Moneyball. The crew gathers for a summer show filled with sports analytics.
  • Home Run Derby Insights. A deep dive into the home run derby and its unpredictability.
  • The Beauty of Baseball. The home run derby showcases the beauty of baseball, with stunning hits and fan interactions.
  • Winning the Home Run Derby. Could winning early in your career hurt your future? A deep dive into player psychology.
  • Intensity of Soccer. Watching soccer with a rooting interest is an exhilarating experience, keeping fans on the edge of their seats.
  • Diving in Soccer. The culture of diving in soccer is frustrating and could disqualify the sport for some fans.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes