Why Competition Can Ruin Workplace Collaboration

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Can competing against a colleague change your relationship with them long after the competition ends?

Henning Piezunka, Wharton Associate Professor of Management, examines how competition can make people see collaborators as rivals. His research follows professional soccer players who compete against their club teammates during the World Cup, then return to playing alongside them. The results suggest that simply thinking of someone as a competitor can have lasting effects on collaboration.

The conversation explores what this means for promotions, bonuses, office politics and managing teams where people have to compete and collaborate at the same time.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, there was certainly lots of excitement with the World Cup being here in the United States
  2. this past summer, but it did bring us a unique dynamic in terms of the players involved in the
  3. tournament. See, many of them were playing for their home countries this past summer, but
  4. throughout the course of the remainder of the year, they played for club teams. And what this allowed us to see was players who normally play with one another in a club situation
  5. playing against each other while playing and wearing the badge of their home country.
  6. And that brings up a unique dynamic of how do colleagues compete against each other
  7. when they normally work with each other throughout the course of the week. Pleasure to be joined by Henning Piezunka, professor at the Wharton School who joins
  8. us right now. Henning, great to talk to you. How are you, sir? Thanks for having me. And look, it's always great, but talking about soccer and the World
  9. Cup particularly. Exactly. We are both lovers of the sport. So the dynamic here is an interesting premise, and I'll let you kind of dig deeper into it
  10. because there are probably situations, and we're using it in the scope of the World Cup,
  11. but in the real world where people work with each other during the week, but maybe are competing against each other on the weekend, whether it's in a race or
  12. they're coaches of their kids' little leagues or whatever it might be. So you have that interesting dynamic that comes into play from time to time.
  13. So you're absolutely spot on. So here's my favorite example. But I could literally give you hundreds, but let me just kind of share one with you.
  14. So at Home Depot, there were two C-level executives, and one of those C-level executives
  15. was also on the board of UPS. Well, this makes a lot of sense. If you think about retail,
  16. you think a lot about logistics, so it makes total sense why UPS would like to have a senior
  17. person like this. Now, another C-level executive at Home Depot was on the board of FedEx. Now,
  18. same reasoning. This makes a lot of sense, right? Like, again, knowledge about logistics,
  19. retail, and so on. But now you basically have two C-level executives who need to work in
  20. everyday life together to make Home Depot a successful company. But at the same time,
  21. they're actually representing companies that are really competing directly with one another,
  22. right? So the funny thing about it is, yeah, yeah, yeah, we're collaborating. We're supposed
  23. to make this company better. But at the same time, we are somewhat competing. And you see,
  24. that is kind of really a setting that we were interested in more broadly than I would say,
  25. like, look, people tend to think that you either compete or collaborate. In fact, what lots of
  26. my research shows is you tend to do very often the same thing at the same time. You tend to compete
  27. and collaborate very often. Meaning what exactly? Like, look, lots of examples. So you're collaborating
  28. with your colleagues in everyday life, but when it comes to promotion time, when it comes to bonus,
  29. you are actually competing for the same bonus pool. You might be competing for the same promotion,
  30. right? Like, look, you're working with your classmates on like homework projects, right?
  31. You see, like, but at the same time, there's only going to be one valedictorian, right?
  32. So it's really like, hey, yeah, we are collaborating in everyday life. But at the
  33. same time, we're really competing for this particular spot for this particular bonus.
  34. And this is a very common thing that people also tend to compete at the same time.
  35. And I guess it brings up the question of which relationship is stronger. I'll use your example.
  36. Is one C-suites executive's relationship with the company they actually work for
  37. stronger than the one they work on the board of? Or is the board an actual stronger relationship
  38. than their company? So Dan, what you bring up is absolutely spot on, right? But you see, like,
  39. I think what makes it even more interesting is that what may be the stronger relationship for
  40. one person may not be the stronger relationship for the other person. So this is actually what
  41. we could explore in the soccer setting you attribute to. So let's kind of talk a little
  42. bit through the soccer case. So what would we do? We actually look at the soccer season in the year
  43. 2017-2018, okay? And we basically look at players who played for the same club, okay? So we only
  44. look at teammates, people who play together for Real Madrid, people who play together for
  45. Manchester City, or I have to plug this in, my favorite club, the VfB Stuttgart in Germany.
  46. So now some of these teammates go towards the World Cup, but very often at the World Cup,
  47. they then play not for the same nation. They represent different nations, okay? So one of my
  48. favorite examples in that particular year is Manchester City, okay? So Manchester City,
  49. absolute top-notch club, who plays for Manchester City? Kevin De Bruyne and Kyle Walker, okay?
  50. But Kevin De Bruyne is Belgian, Kyle Walker is English. Now, when Belgium plays against England,
  51. the two obviously face each other, but now they face each other as opponents, all right?
  52. The question we then ask in the paper, what happens after the World Cup, okay? When they come back
  53. to Manchester City? Because they've all collaborated before, now they're competing
  54. against one another, and will they collaborate afterwards? Now, the beauty about it is, from a
  55. research standpoint, Kevin De Bruyne and Kyle Walker have never chosen to play against one
  56. another, right? But we're always looking for some kind of a natural experiment, right? We always
  57. want an exogenous treatment. And because you see, the two have no influence whether the coach
  58. recruits them, whether the coach actually uses them, and then the World Cup is in part random,
  59. right? Because it's a lottery who plays against one another. And so we can actually see what
  60. does the treatment of playing against one another do to their collaboration afterwards.
  61. And what we find is their collaboration really suffers. Now, in many ways, you should say,
  62. but this makes no sense. Sure, you competed at the World Cup, but afterwards, the World Cup's
  63. over and you collaborate again on behalf of your team. You're not competing anymore.
  64. But here's the thing, it seems to be very difficult for people to get rid of this. So
  65. once they've thought of each other as competitors, they really think of each other as competitors.
  66. And the passing quota goes down by 11%, which is tremendous if you think about it,
  67. right? Because you're really supposed to enact the strategy of the coach and so on.
  68. Right. And so the dynamic of what, using the example of Zocker and De Bruyne and Kyle Walker,
  69. when those two countries play, the dynamic of what transpired in the game itself
  70. doesn't have that much impact? So that was a little bit our expectation. Interestingly,
  71. it doesn't. What has more of an effect then is what you alluded to before, is how important is that relationship with that other team to them? So yes, I give you two
  72. examples, which were kind of mind-blowing for me, but the results are significant. So what we find
  73. is that players who have two passports actually identify less with their nation, which makes sense.
  74. And as a result, the effect is also less strong. You see, let's say Kevin De Bruyne,
  75. to the best of my knowledge, Kevin De Bruyne is only Belgian, but let's imagine he would also
  76. be French. Well, then he may care less about playing for Belgium. And so he may not actually
  77. kind of, his identity is now not anchored in this competition with Kyle Walker. He mostly thinks of
  78. him as a teammate. The second aspect we found is that male players who actually had a son,
  79. okay? Because what happens is when you have a son, you start like, this is like research on children,
  80. like this is out of my expertise. So we draw like completely on this kind of external research,
  81. tend to worry more about their legacy and legacy tends to be anchored more on a national level
  82. than on a club level, because, you know, like clubs change, they go up and down. You may change
  83. your club and stuff like this, but you remain Belgium, you remain German, you remain American
  84. and so on. Right. And so you suddenly care more about this and people who had a son actually
  85. kind of competed then or like more fiercely and collaborated less strongly afterwards.
  86. And I guess that to a degree, that's probably not totally a surprise when you think about the fact
  87. that what eight months, nine months out of the year, those players are playing using the example
  88. you did in Manchester, in England, the players live there. They've kind of adjusted to the
  89. lifestyle there. They're connected to the community. They have that stronger connection
  90. now than maybe they did to their home country. It'd be like, you know, me moving to California
  91. and living there for 10 years and eventually my connection here to Philadelphia might wane a
  92. little bit. Yeah. You see, like, I think what's so remarkable about this is you really go for this
  93. World Cup, then like for like, I mean, the World Cup takes like four or five weeks, right? Like
  94. include prep, it's like five to seven weeks or something like that. Yeah. But nevertheless,
  95. it then hurts this long term collaboration. Right. So it's almost like a refresher to a certain degree.
  96. You see, then there's one thing which I think about these effects, which is really interesting.
  97. So you'll see it because you play the World Cup obviously in the summer. There was one exception
  98. where it was played in the winter, but generally the World Cup is played in the summer. And so,
  99. but you know what? The group stage is already announced in December of the prior year.
  100. Sure. So you actually know like your opponents for the first three games in early December.
  101. And the funny thing about it is for those players who already know their opponents,
  102. we see an effect before the World Cup has started. So they do not even have to encounter each other
  103. on the field. The effect actually starts earlier. They immediately start thinking of the other person
  104. as an opponent. So let's go back to Kevin De Bruyne and Kyle Walker. The moment they hear,
  105. oh wait, seven months from now, we will play against one another. Now I need to think of
  106. you more as an opponent and not so much as a collaborator. So imagine that. Let's bring this
  107. closer to home here. Let's make this awkward. Imagine the dean comes in and says, okay, you
  108. both have done a great job, but 10 months from now, only one of you will be on this podcast.
  109. Well, the next 10 months are going to be interesting because we want to collaborate,
  110. but we also kind of competing whoever the dean will eventually pick for the spot.
  111. So this is a little bit so, and you say like, we are collaborating, but we already have this
  112. competition in mind and that actually hinders the competition. Yeah. So what do you take from
  113. looking at this research to maybe put it in a larger scale for the work world and how we
  114. collaborate with people in our office and what it should mean when that level of competition comes
  115. into our lives? A few things, Dan. So I'll tell you the most interesting that happened to me
  116. afterwards. Like a hedge fund manager called me up and said, can you do this analysis for me
  117. for the following companies? And I was like, what are you talking about? And he was like, well,
  118. I completely believe your findings. What you're telling me is people who also have a competitive
  119. relationship collaborate less. So I actually now get an inside view on how good the collaboration
  120. is actually across a large set of companies. And I will shorten those companies because that's an
  121. information which is typically hard to see, or it's actually very hard to analyze. It's nothing
  122. you kind of see at first spot. So you actually need to do some analysis. Okay. And then actually
  123. like a bunch of companies actually contacted me and said like, okay, can you actually check that
  124. this is the case? Right. Like for whom is this the case? And so I got a little bit involved in like
  125. due diligence and stuff like this, which was very interesting. So companies actually like,
  126. well, they actually became very sensitive to this idea. Okay. You see, like, it's not only what
  127. helps collaboration, what actually hinders collaboration, what actually takes collaboration
  128. down. And that is what they really wanted to hear about it. So do not just think about what makes
  129. competition better, but think about what potentially eliminates it and then address
  130. those kinds of factors. The other thing you can do, and like, you see, like the first thing I
  131. would always say, like, is be aware of it. You don't just kind of know that these kinds of things
  132. exist. And then the other thing is, you see, then you can also manage it. What you basically need to
  133. do is you need to create boundaries. Okay. So there was, um, the, um, Steve Kerr, right? Like
  134. managed their, managed the U.S. basketball team at the, at the last Olympics, if I recall this
  135. correctly. Yep. And, and he gave a speech, um, at the very beginning, um, when he comes, he comes
  136. into the dressing room and he points out like, look, half of you are Hall of Famers, the rest of you
  137. will be Hall of Famers. Um, and we have 12 Hall of Famers here, but to the best of his knowledge,
  138. I can only play five guys on the field. So you will compete for these kinds of spots, but we need
  139. to leave all this NBA crap behind. It doesn't matter if you play for the Knicks, for the Lakers,
  140. for the Bulls, let's get rid of all of that. Okay. Now we all playing for the U.S. right.
  141. And in the same way, right? Like, you see, like, imagine you're a club coach, imagine you manage
  142. the Lakers and then like the Olympics over, then you need to come back and say like, okay, I know
  143. some of you have actually competed against one another at the Olympics. Now we need to forget
  144. about all of this and really just focus on the Lakers. So you need to manage these kind of
  145. boundaries very, very carefully. Yeah. Henning, great to research and great to talk to you again. And thank you for giving us a little
  146. fun conversation on the World Cup. Wonderful. Great to talk to you, Dan. Thank you. Henning Piezunka of the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Henning Piezunka discusses competition and collaboration among athletes during the World Cup and its impact on team dynamics.

Key points

  • The World Cup Dynamic. Exploring how players balance club loyalty and national pride during the World Cup.
  • Collaboration vs Competition. Research shows that competition can hinder collaboration even after the competitive event.
  • Impact of Dual Nationality. Players with dual nationality may prioritize club identity over national identity.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes