The Biggest World Cup Ever

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE What should fans expect from the largest FIFA World Cup in history? Ryan O’Hanlon, ESPN Staff Writer, author of Net Gains, and Syracuse University instructor, joins the Wharton Moneyball team to analyze the expanded 2026 FIFA World Cup, assess the favorites and dark horses, evaluate the outlook for the U.S. Men’s National Team, and explain how analytics-driven innovations such as set pieces and long throw-ins are transforming soccer. The conversation also explores playoff unpredictability, tournament design, and the growing influence of analytics across sports.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#WorldCup2026 #SoccerAnalytics #SportsAnalytics #USMNT ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome Welcome to wharton moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics
  2. Here on the wharton podcast network. This is cade massey Hosting this week with two of my long-time collaborators and good
  3. friends oddy weiner And shane jensen our fourth co-host eric bradley out this week.
  4. He'll be back We're going to run a normal These days normal schedule this week. We're going to guest here in the first
  5. half hour. We'll open it up open lines in the second half of the show plenty to talk
  6. about god knows but to open we're going to also kind of open our soccer coverage
  7. and I would like to say for the year, but truthfully it's for the what the biennial the quadrennial coverage of soccer We're going
  8. to open we're going to have a few guests over the next month or month and a half As would be appropriate given world
  9. cup and not only world cup but us hosting world cup And our number one draft pick for soccer coverage Ryan o'hanlon ryan
  10. o'hanlon is back on the show. It's been a little bit Um, we love ryan o'hanlon And we think you guys
  11. should love ryan o'hanlon. He's a staff writer at espn Um, he's also the author of a book called net
  12. gains inside the beautiful games revolution net gains inside the beautiful games revolution It's about soccer
  13. and innovations, especially analytics based innovation. Ryan comes back Honestly, he played soccer in
  14. college if I remember correctly, maybe even dabbled at higher levels I don't frankly love this
  15. genre of book and I quite like ryan's and that's my endorsement to you Is that it's a great read and interesting go read
  16. it and you can also see ryan's stuff on Espn all the time ryan is coming to us from syracuse.
  17. He's in syracuse these days He's also teaching at syracuse in the new house school the
  18. journalism school there ryan. Good to see you You too, I was going to complain about not being on the
  19. show more often But if you give me an intro like that, you can you know, wait a couple years have two years between
  20. each appearance well, the complaint should be I mean if we're if If we talk about
  21. soccer, we really we bring you around. We just don't talk about soccer enough and
  22. um, It's not because we don't like soccer. There's just a lot else to talk about
  23. we used to get complaints from our friend sam vincera who Who is in the nhl about not covering hockey enough and it basically
  24. called out I've gotten called out by sam on several occasions and I exactly sam if
  25. you're still listening, I've raised my game. We're doing it We're gonna fix that.
  26. Can I just point out? We just said earlier We just said earlier. I don't think it was actually on the
  27. air that we're base rate people that explains it There you go we're base rate people,
  28. but we're also I mean, I think you're over rationalizing it audie because we're subject to
  29. our own, um twims, of course and Like when you're from west texas Didn't spend a
  30. lot of time thinking about hockey and soccer growing up so we could just do college
  31. football all year round but ryan, you know, uh We we even talk in the euros. We don't wait every four years We we
  32. talk about euros when they float around as well. But look we gotta what's true. What's true for sure Is that we have
  33. been distracted right? It's been a very interesting season around american sports We're in the middle of it.
  34. We're in the thick of finals still. I mean, this is it for basketball and hockey We're in intense final series.
  35. Um, I I I realized coming into this interview i'm like i'm a little bit like the guy Who landed at the family reunion?
  36. And I love these people. I really care about these people But truthfully I haven't been in touch with these people
  37. and now I'm, like sequestered with my brother You know in his hotel room. I just landed he's been there for a
  38. couple days He's got the scoop and i'm like tell me everything i'm about to see these folks Attention a little further.
  39. Not only are you back at a family reunion? But like there's double the number of family
  40. members than you're used to having to catch up on. That's right in this case Right.
  41. Yeah, I mean cutter cutter Is here exactly who's my is becky cousin again? Tell me ryan I will say it's not
  42. like there's a couple things here We don't actually follow and cover soccer all that rigorously
  43. throughout The years in between the world cup and a little bit we do think about
  44. soccer you know, we think about it from an analytic perspective and Some of our research
  45. has been in soccer. So i'm a little bit referee. We referee papers So i'm actually a little
  46. bit more up on the the analytical side of what's going on on the on the pitch But much less up on what's actually
  47. happening in terms of results well, I want to do both of those things because I understand that that that the phrase set piece
  48. revolution is not an overstatement But so that's an analytics kind of approach. But first ryan first just like top of
  49. mind for you How are you feeling? We're two days away. We're recording tuesday the show will go up
  50. wednesday We're the week of launching this thing that's been talked about for years on us
  51. soil. How do you feel about the world cup? How are you feeling about your your role?
  52. Like how are you going to take it in like what level of excitement you have? Yeah, I feel like you're asking the wrong
  53. person because I Within the last like five days i've ranked all the teams in the
  54. world cup I've predicted every single game They had me write an article where I predicted
  55. every game in the world cup Which as fifa is saying this is the biggest world cup ever and then I had to rank
  56. the top 50 players, which You know doing that in any honest way is a pretty much impossible exercise for reasons.
  57. We've talked about on this show before Yeah, so i've thought about the world cup, uh
  58. Way more often than basically anyone else in a very strange and idiosyncratic way.
  59. Um, so in some ways I feel like it's over already and then in other ways like i'm excited to actually just See the
  60. games happen let a lot of the randomness take hold and just let it all wash over me You got your editor taking care
  61. of your past all that and now you get to watch soccer I feel like the last world cup you were over there.
  62. We were we were communicating Do I have that right? Were you overseas covering it in some way
  63. or am I making that up? No, I think my apartment in los angeles. What am I thinking about like a qatari
  64. hotel? Okay, my book had just come out in uh, 2022 right before the world cup. So okay.
  65. I don't know Maybe that that was the landmark Well, let's start at the top and ask since you did a week ago write
  66. a write a piece ranking all 48 teams Um, and I saw that cutter was last and that uh, hold on france was first
  67. spain after that england third germany Shockingly low fourth or something like that.
  68. I saw that brazil was above argentina. So maybe brazil is back Portugal must be in there somewhere.
  69. So here's here's one question for you How deep can you go down that list before?
  70. What's the last team on that list working down from the top? That could legitimately win the thing I think
  71. it's a good question because one i've often felt like it's kind of crazy that we've
  72. had so few world cup winners given how Random soccer is and how few games there are in the world cup And you guys
  73. probably can answer this better than me. But to me the 48 team world cup In the past it was 32 half the
  74. teams would get chopped off at the group stages this time 32 teams will advance to
  75. the knockout rounds So essentially we're like playing the old world cups in pure knockout fashion
  76. Because 32 teams will be in the knockout rounds. I would think that that will introduce more
  77. randomness If for no other reason than like the draw is going to be very bizarre
  78. and the permutations are almost impossible to comprehend um So I think that there's like I
  79. think that there's a chance that we get. Uh Like a weird first time winner this time but I would say there's like Well,
  80. hold on. Let's stop right there because now you you know, there's very more There's few obscure topics
  81. that we like better than than tournament design. And so there It feels like for sure
  82. this the final 16 the swede 16 will be more random than they have been historically
  83. because historically that's what's come out of the Pool rounds, which is like a group rounds
  84. So now you've got this thing where you're like that's coming out of this random event
  85. called the match of soccer So the 16 has to be more random, but does that necessarily translate?
  86. What's the translation from that to a different champion? right And I guess before we get to
  87. that final 16 Is there less? Because before I feel like in in the old round robin stages we would always talk
  88. about the group that the randomness that was there was partly the Is your whole national
  89. team in the group of death? is there because we've kind of Added a bunch of I mean slop is not the
  90. right term, but like a lot about a bunch of like Lesser teams into the mix. Is there less of a group of debt?
  91. Like is there less variation? Kind of between groups or so or less very like variation that matters like quality variation
  92. between groups. I don't I don't know Yeah, I you're speaking to someone who wrote an article called
  93. the group of death is dead back in uh, december when They announced the groups I
  94. just went back and looked at like the elo ratings for and figured them out for every group in world cup history and this
  95. Pretty much all of the worst groups in world cup history just by average rating Elo
  96. rating are in this world cup. I think the hardest group is by elo is france norway senegal and iraq um, which
  97. I think you could make a case norway and senegal are two of the like Under dark horses that things bounce, right?
  98. They could actually make a really deep run But it might not even matter in the group because iraq is a very weak team
  99. And if you win a game, you're probably going to advance out of the group So the groups are not uh anywhere near as
  100. difficult as they were but then you also have the added wrinkle of there's three hosts
  101. and the host teams are all quite weak compared to Sort of the top level teams and hosts get treated as Pot a so
  102. the highest ranked teams in their group so mexico canada and the u.s are the quote unquote best teams in three of the
  103. world cup groups while You know when the world cup is in france france is a host and but they would be a top
  104. uh seated team as well so that mixes things up and then the way that It's very arbitrary whether you get to play a
  105. second place team or a third place team in the knockout round and I think you know, for example if Everything goes chalk germany
  106. and france will play in the round of 16 Which is something that would have just not happened in the past and there's a
  107. handful of other situations like that, too Okay Can you give us a quick primer on?
  108. What advancing looks like you're basically just eliminating 16 teams. So maybe it's easier to say what gets
  109. eliminated Yeah, so it's top two automatically advance and then the eight best third place teams
  110. advance um And that's based on points first and I was gonna say is there like a long list of like tiebreakers?
  111. I know there is absolutely no schedule adjustment scenarios There is a chance that the tiebreaker
  112. will be uh Fair play rating or whatever fifa calls it, which is essentially a point
  113. system based on yellow cards and red cards um, if you're tied in goal difference points
  114. goals scored and goals against so but then it also is like There's a matrix on wikipedia that you can look up based on
  115. what groups the third place teams come from will then determine who gets put where because
  116. Fifa doesn't want teams that are in the same group playing each other in the knockout
  117. round So if it's like group a b c d e f g h, whatever up to eight, then it's a certain way But
  118. then any other permutation it's a different distribution of the team. So it's like Very difficult modeling problem even
  119. for people like you guys I would assume okay, so I interrupted you as you were walking us through on how deep you can
  120. go down your top teams before you think you Who's the last team that could legitimately
  121. win and you're saying well Let's start with the fact that it's a different tournament this
  122. year than it has been in the past But I but I stopped you Can you before you answer?
  123. Can you make it a little bit more specific? You say legitimately win? Yeah, I know He indulged me without requiring
  124. a specific it was a poorly I know but i'm a nerd and I want to know let's say capture 90 percent of the
  125. chance Yeah, okay. Whatever teams do you need to capture 90? And it's funny because I feel like I
  126. want to guess this ahead of time before I get an answer from you In my head and I think I want to i've
  127. got it I'm, i'm gonna save it for after you give me your answer. Hold on. Hold on if we if we gave a
  128. uniform over 16 that's 16 i'm trying to what what what how low would a percentage
  129. have to be before it was surprising the prior would have to be 10 isn't that surprising in this kind of a tournament?
  130. Maybe it make 10 10 percent what's the team that has a 10 percent chance somewhere
  131. between five and ten percent chance? What's the best team that has a five to ten?
  132. Yeah, it's just if you formed an empirical estimate based on who's won the last say
  133. 10 of these Or 20 of these then it'd probably only be like four or five or something like that.
  134. That seems small I mean, I think it's no it doesn't go back to yeah, it's argentina.
  135. Italy western, you know, germany brazil france and spain Okay, six That gets us back to
  136. like the 60s or something like that as far as unique winners well Yeah, uruguay is
  137. the only sort of non heavy so I mean so really the question is the answer going to be like six Or is the
  138. answer? Bigger than that and that's yeah The netherlands used to have a good club and you've
  139. got them like eight or something like can the netherlands win this thing? Like what's the chance of the netherlands?
  140. We're in croatia. Can they win nine? You have them? You have an eight you have an eight
  141. argentina seven forget argentina beautiful messy argentina Brazil six like these teams what chances do they
  142. have? yeah, so I would like even without putting specific numbers on it, I would say there's
  143. like there's like a Top tier of if you try to like model the team strength using talent and performance uh england france and
  144. spain are sort of the top top three teams because They have crazy amounts of talent.
  145. They've all been quite successful recently Argentina if you pull in performance would be there as
  146. well. But the issue with argentina is Uh, they had the essentially the exact same team as
  147. the last world cup They had no turnover and we see this all the time at the world cup where a team wins the
  148. world cup They don't turn the team over and then they just get like blown off the face of the earth in the group
  149. stages It's happened to germany happened to spain so I think there's some questions there, but
  150. if in doing these Models like it looks like argentina could actually end up with a
  151. quite an easy path if they win their group So I think you know, so you have those top three i'd add in argentina
  152. and brazil who I don't think are as strong as We historically expect those countries to
  153. be but they could also win and then you throw in germany netherlands and portugal as
  154. kind of the Next tier european teams and I feel like that's getting you pretty far.
  155. Um Like down the list of probability, uh, like total cumulative championship probability and then I
  156. think from there it's like can I convince myself that like home field advantage in mexico
  157. is worth a lot of uh value and then they have an easy group and maybe things go their way or Like norway has
  158. two of the best players in the world. Can they you know, is that gonna lead to something?
  159. so I I would say that kind of top eight is sort of the like In a vacuum if you had to sort of
  160. garner most of the championship probability i'd probably put it there I would say okay While
  161. we're thinking of it at this level Give us one or two teams that you're most intrigued by off of that topic You just
  162. named mexico nor mexico and norway. Maybe that covers it but like who below those top eight are most intriguing to you
  163. Yeah, I I think mexico is intriguing. They're not anywhere near as talented as they've
  164. been. Um But they've been very good like results wise over the past sort of four years
  165. They've been way less chaotic not firing their managers left and right like they usually do
  166. They have one of the easiest groups like in the history of the world cup like they should win their group quite easily And
  167. they're going to be playing all those games at home and I you know I don't know how you would even figure this out
  168. exactly but I have to imagine like home field advantage playing in mexico city Is like
  169. among the more extreme home field advantages possible in All of sports is part of that
  170. in the world elevation altitude Altitude and then also just kind of the environment in the
  171. stadium if you know You like getting bags of urine thrown at you. Um, it's a good place to go um
  172. And then combine that with the altitude sickness and you got a party right there That
  173. I they might be top throw them in the top eight. Um And then like doing these permutations looking
  174. through them like they're they might have a quite an easy path to Make it to the quarterfinals you get to the quarterfinals.
  175. Maybe something happens there. But with norway, I would say they're like I don't know It's I don't know if
  176. you guys talked about norway's success during the winter olympics and how everyone was talking about
  177. like what makes this country um You know, so this small country so good. It's as jane is pointing out.
  178. They're very rich Um, but they also they also create a bunch of their own sports
  179. essentially in the winter olympics But soccer they didn't and they have the best Like goal
  180. scorer erling holland plays for manchester city in the world and they have one of the
  181. best attacking midfielders martin odegaard who's Uh a creative sort of passer and then they have
  182. a bunch of other guys that play in europe And international soccer is just like a
  183. much more simplified version of the sport So having like an organized team with a great
  184. goal scorer and a great creator um it feels like it could work and I think some of like Looking at modeling this stuff
  185. out or the data for it. Like norway just don't have a long track record of being very good They didn't even
  186. qualify Uh for the most recent euros, but in world cup qualifying they were like absolutely
  187. dominant So it would be like a historical outlier that a team would suddenly get this
  188. good But also I think it's a historically weird world cup Have they thought about asking
  189. that guy who skis so well to play for them because it seems like he could do Kind of actually can't run without skis.
  190. I don't know if you've seen this. No, i'm kidding can I actually ask kind of a kind of Almost the flip side
  191. of this question Which is you named a bunch of the kind of I guess the blue chip sort of like to those top
  192. eight kind of countries um Are there's a couple that stand out to you is kind of most likely to under maybe perform that
  193. blue chip status Either I mean it could just be number seven and number eight. That's the obvious one or but maybe again
  194. It sounds like you've been kind of doing Permutations respecting the structure of the tournament and
  195. how it's set up is like, you know, I know there's no group of death But are there?
  196. Do some of those blue chips have a tougher road than others? Yeah, I want to i'll shout out.
  197. There's uh, this group that does really great soccer analytics analytics stuff at uh university uh
  198. In leuven in belgium. They're actually led by this american guy. Jesse davis They do a lot of really
  199. cool stuff and they have Their uh, you know their table out with all you can sort of click a team and see all
  200. the different paths they could take So that's how I know this stuff. Not uh, my own uh computing abilities.
  201. Okay, but so France, I think has the most talent. They just have the most talent every year
  202. now just because paris is such a dense center for Uh soccer talent and france is
  203. a large rich country where everyone plays soccer. That's not seven foot four um But they
  204. play germany in the round of 16 and then they would also end up on spain's side of the bracket They would have to
  205. play spain in the semis They might also get a tough matchup in the quarterfinals.
  206. So like I might think spain is the best team we're playing this Everyone has the
  207. same schedule, but they they just have a tough schedule Then they also have quite a
  208. difficult group So maybe they get bounced to the second spot or the third spot and
  209. they end up playing One of the favorites, uh in the round of 32 like I could see that happening But I think portugal
  210. is probably the one that I would pick to underperform uh for two reasons, I mean
  211. Can you really say it's underperforming portugal is like not doesn't have the same structural advantages
  212. of any of the other countries We've talked about by by underperforming. You really mean they'd kind of punch their
  213. weight as opposed to above their weight Which they usually do at this thing basically exactly
  214. but for two two reasons They rate out as like a very very weak defensive team And I think if you look at these
  215. things defense, you know I think weights out a little bit stronger in world cup performance
  216. than attacking strength Just because it's hard to be a good attacking team because you just
  217. don't practice together um They give up a lot of goals in world cup qualifying just
  218. like way more than pretty much any team Obviously you can control for talent, uh in
  219. the various regions, but they're like among the highest Goal scores goals allowed and then they're
  220. they're they're relying on cristiano ronaldo to be their starting center forward He's 41 He's been
  221. playing in the saudi league for four years It's amazing that he's still able to play
  222. professional soccer But he does nothing other than shoot and he's not as good at getting
  223. into those positions as he used to be He doesn't add anything to sort of build up play or add any other attacking value
  224. And then he's just a zero on the defensive side of things. Wow, and there's just a huge Question mark
  225. over like how good he actually is. Uh, Because I don't know how to do the saudi league translation for performance so I
  226. think they're There's a bunch of question marks there and their group is like the worst
  227. team in their group is not as bad as you would think which I think that's the new group of death is like No,
  228. terrible teams in your group rather than like any juggernauts So I think if like there's
  229. a favorite that might get knocked out Could be portugal. So that would be my choice Ryan, we're
  230. 22 minutes into a world cup conversation and we haven't talked about the u.s national
  231. team What does that mean? Should we? Well the u.s it's interesting like their group is uh australia paraguay and turkey, um
  232. as the country now goes by Uh, and when this happened, I think the initial reaction
  233. was oh my god Like they got australia as the the tier two team and it's probably the worst tier two team.
  234. They got paraguay and then I think turkey is probably the best this was like from
  235. the As yet qualified teams turkey was the best team. Um That could have qualified that the u
  236. .s could have played But I think it was viewed as like there's no powerhouse teams
  237. in this group. No teams that have um um won the world cup No teams that have won, uh
  238. their confederation championships other than australia But actually like all the teams are just decent which
  239. I think is the worst possible case for this situation so like if you look at leuven's projections like the A team like australia
  240. has like almost like a 25 chance of finishing first second third and fourth The u
  241. .s' odds of advancing are only like 73 percent Um or winning the group are only 73 percent, which you'd think would be higher
  242. So, uh, no, it's advancing is 73 percent winning. They're not 73 percent. Um, so the group is a little tricky
  243. and then The draw just looks like it isn't gonna be great for them. I think if everything goes chalk They'll play
  244. belgium in the round of 16 Which would be a fun kind of redux of the I remember that classic game when the u
  245. .s Got absolutely pummeled and tim howard made a million saves and we all treated it
  246. like it was some amazing achievement Uh, i'm, sorry if you could sense the sarcasm uh
  247. belgium like they're way beyond like that golden generation, but they still have a ton of
  248. talent and then if a couple things Don't go chalk like the u.s might actually have a harder draw So I think to
  249. me it's round of 16 Is a good achievement for the u.s quarterfinals is like that's awesome.
  250. Um, I think the thing with the u .s is like They have the most talent they've ever had But also if you just
  251. look at all the other teams in a similar tier like japan switzerland These teams also
  252. have the more talent than they've ever had because it seems like there's like a situation
  253. where Like france Can't increase its share of the world's talent, you know So like that's
  254. kind of just like stuck if anything they can lose it because there's so many players
  255. that can play for other countries But it seems like the rest of the world is started Starting to fill sort of the population
  256. of professional soccer players um Like the bottom half of it and some of the top
  257. half of it more than it ever had in the past And so it's like right all these all the teams that are like
  258. in that You know, we said eight eight or nine teams, right? Then I would say the gap between like
  259. nine and like 25 is very small And it seems like all of those teams have more talent so I think that's how you
  260. get to this situation where it's like equally like The u.s has multiple guys starting
  261. in the champions league almost their entire lineup is players based in europe and yet like
  262. We shouldn't expect them to do any better than Like the 2002 world cup where they
  263. made the quarterfinals make sure I understand what you're saying You're saying that if we looked
  264. at say the top is it five european soccer leagues? And we looked at the at the player
  265. level that nations they come from historically They probably mostly came from european nations or maybe
  266. european and african nations And you're saying that has changed that the countries around the world
  267. make up a greater percentage of those top international clubs In a way that didn't in
  268. the past. Is that yeah Like just throwing this off the top of my head like let's say
  269. the premier league uh had 400 English players 15 years ago now It's probably like 150
  270. or something like that or 100 which like has no effect on the quality of the english national team But also can lead to
  271. like these other countries all getting better but not getting to the level of england or
  272. france still Okay, super interesting. Got it. Give us something Um about the u.s
  273. squad to keep our eyes on like what what are you most interested to see in terms of Actual on the on the pitch
  274. and something we might keep an eye out for Yeah, I think the interesting thing is
  275. so Speaking of what a little bit of what we were just saying The u.s has a lot of people that have u
  276. .s citizenship because of military bases across the world various things like that and so some
  277. players will play for the u.s when they Feel like they're not going to get a shot for bigger country.
  278. So the u.s has this striker fuller and belligan who Came up through the arsenal academy Uh played for england's youth teams, but
  279. was eligible for the u.s because of one of his parents a couple years ago He decided to play for the u.s
  280. Um, and he is like by far the most accomplished Center forward goal scorer in europe
  281. that the u.s has ever had. Um, but he's also like the perfect Player for u.s fans to think is terrible
  282. because he is like a Star at the thing that matters which is getting lots of really good shots But he he like if
  283. you look at his conversion rates compared to expected goals He's like right in line with
  284. his expected goals while most of the better Most attackers in the world are like around,
  285. you know, 10 better than that So belligan is like he does he scores a lot of goals, but he also misses a lot
  286. of chances which I think for novice fans will be a thing that he could miss like two huge chances and they Will be
  287. like he needs to be benched when it's more like no like another guy's going to come in and not get those chances so
  288. I think like given his sort of history as a player I think like His ability to convert one or two chances could be
  289. like the difference between Third round of 32 exit quarterfinal appearance. So i'm very interested to see how he
  290. does. Can you can you put a little perspective here for me? Hold on real quick. I'm just gonna play a game real quick
  291. is an equivalent statement If he's lucky on some of those chances, that's enough to make
  292. a difference at all. You said his ability to convert I mean do we that's we probably believe that to
  293. be mostly a chance like performance above expected given a chance is With very few exceptions
  294. like messy apparently is sufficiently So it's basically like if he gets he's going to get
  295. chances If some of those break his way the u.s might advance one round further. Is that an equivalent statement basically?
  296. Yeah. Yeah, I it's lucky like or like I don't know I bristle against using lucky even
  297. though I use it sometimes because it's like you still have to like Do the physical
  298. act that converts the chance? That's right we get we get philosophical this is philosophy we can argue about this all
  299. day is there actually any luck in in soccer At all, right? There's obviously luck Audie go ahead.
  300. So yeah, I mean I guess to put it in perspective and we actually talked about this We do as we do talk about
  301. soccer. We actually talked about this in terms of how you estimate uh talent above expectation in
  302. in goals relative to xg And there was a there's been a lot of work in the statistical community saying that mostly there isn't
  303. A very very very rare exception is to someone to just consistently score more than they're
  304. expected to um, but now taking about this american player, um, uh Just to put it
  305. in perspective. He's by far the best player. We probably have ever had right? Um, How does he rate?
  306. internationally Internationally Don't hide it just let us have it did he make your top 50,
  307. right? Uh, no, I would say christian flessick is the best american player ever Uh, but he's
  308. more of like a winger creator ball mover and goal scorer while balligan is kind of
  309. just like your pure Center forward he's good at like linking up play a little bit,
  310. but he's a goal scorer But yeah, I think he's added about like 0.5 goals per 90 which is like fantastic that's like
  311. one every other game But that's gonna you know, give or take That probably makes him
  312. Let's say he's like the 15th to 20th best striker in the world. Let alone. We're not talking about all positions.
  313. So But he's very young and he could develop into something better still. Okay I'm, just trying to perspective united states
  314. talent relative to I mean that which brings back a kind of a general statistical question
  315. Which is how do we assert? probabilistically, I know or even odds on all these teams given their Construction and I always
  316. wondered how we just seem to know that based on base rates the six teams have won almost I think all world cups only
  317. six teams have won since the 70s add england um, maybe you get uh Back to the 60s.
  318. Are we just doing this by base rates? Are we or do we actually have more more data that really helps us separate?
  319. I I think it's it's just a really hard thing to predict for the reasons you said because These teams just like barely play
  320. soccer, uh, right to start then they barely play any games that have real stakes world
  321. cup qualifying has stakes but How important are they and the games are also happening while
  322. All of these guys are playing for club teams that pay them way more money than their national teams so like You go to
  323. macedonia for a world cup qualifier. You're playing for bayern munich. Do you want to like pull your hamstring?
  324. On a messed up field or do you like hold off a little bit? Um, so there's that aspect then it's like
  325. the players are changing all the time because of who's available who the coach is picking
  326. Um, the players are also aging a lot because they don't play games that often so
  327. it's like we're using games from three years ago, so I think like most of the models I see you try to find some
  328. way to uh, Figure out talent and the ways you do that are usually like transfer value or like wages which are not Necessarily
  329. super accurate for a number of reasons and then you look at performance and you do
  330. like a million different adjustments for like Figuring out what does it mean to beat paraguay
  331. and paraguay versus what does it mean to beat sweden and england? you know, so I think I think it's
  332. mostly Base rate stuff going off of that But when you even if you just like took elo ratings and like found the transfer
  333. values of each team And mash them together, which is essentially what I did with the
  334. rankings. I came up with it still produces the same uh, eight or nine teams that are
  335. going to be the betting favorites and are going to be uh, we're That we talked about earlier.
  336. Okay Shane were you trying to jump in? Well, I just because you I you you kind of brought up.
  337. Uh, I another thing that probably we don't have enough data to estimate but do players
  338. get injured more often at the world cup than they do kind of as their base rates through like a season because you're their
  339. Routine is totally off as you sort of said like at least in this case they're gonna some of the fields are pretty suspect
  340. like they have to play at met life which is like death to football and like American football teams and I i've seen articles
  341. about the tampa bay field for example and stuff like that So, I don't know if I mean that's obviously specific to this world
  342. cup, but in general because it's kind of out of their regular routine and you know,
  343. not the regular team like dude, do you actually tend to see a Agree to the base rate entry level at these things Yeah,
  344. I don't think so or at least it seems like something I would have seen and know about if that was true um The
  345. world cup games are not happening. I guess like that there's a decent amount of space between them but I think one
  346. interesting thing is like Basically after covid happened the soccer schedule got really screwed up They
  347. had to move the euros the year the season got bumped around Then we had the 2022 world cup was in the winter And
  348. then we've also added a ton of games to the schedule based on the proliferation of
  349. all these tournaments that fifa And other federations are creating so players are playing more games
  350. than they ever have before And this is the first world cup of that era that is at the end of the season as
  351. opposed to 2022 Was the middle of the season? um And it's going to be super hot.
  352. So you would think that there would be Prop if there was going to be a world cup where injury risk was high or
  353. like physical output was low It would be a world cup like this one Um, ryan, we have kept you long and longer than
  354. we expected, but I just ask you one more question. You've noted that the premier league has seen
  355. the set piece revolution meaning Scoring rates off of corners free kicks throw-ins have blown
  356. up while open play scoring has declined historically low So we'd love to dive into that
  357. but maybe we don't have time right now to do all that but it's easy to ask To what extent is that going to
  358. transfer you've referenced multiple times just in the last half hour How simplified the international game
  359. is versus the club game and some of the reasons for that Well, does that mean that we won't see the same?
  360. Difference between open play and set pieces in the world cup as we're seeing in the
  361. premier league Yeah, I I think there's a good chance that it's an even bigger difference
  362. this summer. Um, Because set pieces don't require a lot of practice It's it was what's happened in
  363. the premier league is like it was just a strategy change which the strategy, you know
  364. We could do a whole another podcast on this and we should because I think you guys would like it that's not me begging
  365. to be invited back, but basically teams are crowding the goalkeeper with Extra players more players
  366. than ever before and then they're playing in swinging corners So a righty from the left
  367. side, so it's curving in toward the goal basically into the six-yard box like the
  368. rates I think it's It was like 20 percent of historically free kicks were put into
  369. the six-yard box and it was up to 50 percent this season If you look at it, it just skyrockets And tracking the
  370. number of players The you can just see a massive change and so goal scoring I think 3.5 percent of corner kicks led
  371. to goals And this year it was five percent um And you see it directly connected to this strategy change and it's become such
  372. a big story in the premier league that people are like talking about maybe we should
  373. change the rules because This is not why people love soccer. We don't want this to take up a
  374. higher portion of the game but it's also become such a big story that I Any team that wants to win the world cup?
  375. They should be good at set pieces. They should be creating what one analyst called
  376. a meat wall in front of the keeper and then there's hitting an Inswinger into that
  377. area because this one of the things that makes it work, which is interesting players are
  378. so physical in those areas that basically resembles american football and The issue there is like
  379. if a defender is physical and gets called for a foul It's a penalty kick and it's in 0.8 percent, you know an
  380. 80 percent chance of a goal While if an attacker gets called for a foul, it's like whatever it was.
  381. This was a five percent chance of a scoring It's worth doing so like the incentives
  382. are for the attackers should just be way more aggressive than defenders And I think I
  383. was gonna say it was all it's almost like adopting the hockey like to you know so much a hockey goal scoring is like
  384. deflections and stuff like that, but I didn't even think of the asymmetry of Kind of
  385. the punishment of the physicality in that in that region, you know Yeah, so it's it's
  386. led to like you can kind of see it in the data with The percentage of balls played into the six-yard box that
  387. are claimed by keepers are also lower than ever before despite their you know being a
  388. massive increase in it's To what extent is it going for like throw-ins as well and throw-ins catches Our eye because we
  389. had thomas grunemark on here a number of years ago Thomas has been a consultant to
  390. a bunch of these clubs part of the revolution on making throw-ins A thing as opposed to just getting the ball back on
  391. the field. Are we seeing that impact as well? yeah, so the Season before this 20 percent
  392. of attacking throw-ins and the attacking third were thrown directly into the penalty area and
  393. this season it was up to 45 percent Yeah, so like two things that just clearly change and there's like tactical things that we
  394. can tease out it's not just random variation of converting chances um and I think thomas
  395. worked for fc mitchell and in denmark who are owned by the same Uh guy that owns brentford in the premier league and brentford
  396. other ones that started this and then everyone copied them and the big Thing there have
  397. been teams that have taken long throws in the past But the big change is teams realize you're not supposed to score off the
  398. throw-in You're supposed to have someone flick the ball on with their head and then
  399. the next person scores Because the ball's like not you almost can't throw it far enough
  400. and then it's not moving fast enough to get enough power On like a direct header
  401. as you would on a corner kick, but with a throw-in Launch it have a guy flick it on then another person comes
  402. runs and heads it in and kicks it in and both of these plays are just It's different from soccer because there's no offsides
  403. on corner kicks or throw-ins. So That aspect of the game is gone, too. Right, right, right Um, so can you just
  404. to finish this off here? What what changed? People must have known that getting throwing the
  405. ball into the penalty was probably good But what changed is that they learned how to
  406. throw far farther that they invest in something Or did they really just not know that?
  407. uh, I think it was One it was an aesthetic thing and it was sort of viewed as like the underdog like lesser Strategy
  408. to try to rely on throw-ins like that while teams not real soccer Yeah, we have all these possession players we're just going
  409. to do a short throw-in and restart it but brentford were so good at it the team's like basically Like you play brentford
  410. enough times. You're kind of like why why would I not do this? um, and then with corners arsenal the Won
  411. the premier league because they scored the most goals on corner kicks that a team ever
  412. has they had a historically low Open play goal scoring for a winner and everyone copied
  413. them. You can literally see like mid-season west ham and liverpool They were playing no balls
  414. into the six-yard box on corners and that changed mid-season so you can it's really interesting I mean it's making the sport
  415. worse to watch but you can see like these arsenal being the best team in the league with corners and then Brentford just being
  416. successful for long enough teams were Like had no choice essentially to adopt what they were
  417. doing Super interesting we talk about how these things proliferate. Um Propagate in different sports that happens differently.
  418. This is quick. This is interesting Last question tying these things together. Do you think there are any coaching staffs
  419. or teams? Is there much variation in the international teams on their willingness to deploy these tactics?
  420. So that some otherwise good teams might be disadvantaged or some otherwise medium teams might be
  421. advantaged by saying hell We're going to go full-on brentford on this thing yeah, so
  422. the u.s. Has a Set piece coach who used to work for brentford. He's Uh, kind of one of the progenitors
  423. of this movement, but they're terrible at set pieces It doesn't seem like mauricio pochettino cares
  424. about set pieces at all That's the one issue of hiring hiring an elite coach who's
  425. has the sort of snobbish attitude toward them um, and then I think the netherlands also
  426. have been very critical of their coach ronald koeman has been critical of England because england
  427. is essentially going to try to copy what arsenal was doing Even though the netherlands have
  428. a bunch of gigantic players So those are the two teams that stand out and I think will uh, I think england are like
  429. very much in on set plays, so Uh, okay. They're the ones to watch out for in terms of the big teams that are like
  430. fully into it Okay, cool. We kept you too long. Ryan. Thanks, man Hugely helpful wish you the best
  431. with the next few weeks Enjoy it and good luck to you with everything out there in syracuse Appreciate it guys.
  432. Absolutely ryan o'handlin staff writer at espn author of net gains inside the beautiful games
  433. revolution Fantastic book on soccer and soccer analytics long time friend of the show, man Oh,
  434. man, I could not have asked for a better primer on the world cup I mean literally you give me 45 minutes and like
  435. already I went from scratch to ready to go Even that like set piece business. Yeah All got led me to believe that
  436. the u.s is going all the way One of the things that I thought was so interesting was a discussion about How it
  437. just got picked up and in some ways it's kind of a high speed version of the three-point revolution in basketball And I
  438. always ask like why defensive shifts is like defensive shifts I think that happened within one
  439. season essentially that was for like defensive shifts that happened very quickly but you know, it's
  440. it's like how do you miss these things and one of the answers is Culture, it's just not what we do And and we
  441. don't like a tipping point where it's once it becomes acceptable all of a sudden then
  442. everybody goes Somewhat fast. I mean like defensive and this went fast three points took a while Those are two
  443. different cultures you're talking baseball versus basketball And also, I mean, you know both the defensive
  444. shifting as well as these set pieces are like kind of strategic Plays pause kind of
  445. You know things you can easily implement Changing yourself into a three-point shooting team.
  446. There's like a multi-season like you got to find the talent, you know, like, you
  447. know All this type of thing, you know well I tried to research this and the answer that kept coming up was Players just
  448. weren't taught or they weren't raised to do that And if you're not growing up, I
  449. mean remember becoming an elite level athlete It's not something you just fall upon at age
  450. 18 or 19 or 25. It's something you've been basically preparing your whole life for and if you're not Doing it.
  451. You don't just can't change that. It has to be something that is I think that's that's that's the That's the obvious
  452. narrative that actually doesn't explain things very much I think well I mean, it's it's like
  453. in the the analog here is you don't have to retrain soccer players to just kick it towards the net And get more penalties.
  454. That's like, you know, I actually i'm going to press kate on what do you mean? This is what I hear.
  455. I have no idea. You don't think the three-point shooting I don't think the three-point shooting was I
  456. think people have studied it I think I could have this wrong. Somebody let me know if i've got this
  457. wrong. I don't think the It's not like performance at three-point shooting got better and that
  458. led no it hasn't it hasn't it hasn't exactly So it wasn't about a player growing
  459. up shooting a bunch of threes and getting better at it. It was about culture Adapt accepting it and
  460. the game adapting to a different way of playing because it was so slow. I mean like Shockingly slow.
  461. I mean decades slow Um guys, let's let's let's hit some other sports in the short
  462. window. We have here in the second half of the show Basketball where you get he's like,
  463. come on. We got a new york team. What are you doing here? You know, i've waited my entire life for
  464. the knicks to get to where they are And you know, I feel bad about it because I feel like i've completely abandoned them
  465. all these years Because they've been abandonable abandonable Is that the right word dreadful ownership?
  466. I mean come on dreadful ownership and i've essentially, you know Started to follow the sixers
  467. so much as I follow professional basketball, but i'm excited, you know And apparently new york
  468. is manhattan. I mean the city is going bonkers, right? And it's uh, it's it's certainly exciting.
  469. They did they did lose at home, but an ultra close game Um, but so i've been i've been i'm not being able to
  470. watch it live. They happen overnight Um, but I can get up in the morning I get to get
  471. to watch what happened um, you know what you should look at how to just You should if you if you haven't done it,
  472. I just want a quick advertisement for our our sometime guest nate duncan Who calls games
  473. and it's a dunk dunked on prime you can you can you can you can listen to him call games on youtube and then
  474. the next day You can get like clutch calls from him. And for for me, there's nobody i'd rather
  475. listen call a game than nate for me, it's like It's like he's packing. He's like his whole objective is to pack
  476. more information per syllable Than anybody else in announcing basketball, it's like informative everything's informative and
  477. he's willing to call bullshit Like he's doing play by play, but he'll call bullshit.
  478. He'll say that's a bad decision That was why did he do that? Like at the same time he's but he's
  479. also telling you what's happening and why he's happening and it's just wildly more informative especially
  480. to someone who Despite having played basketball and watched basketball all my life Feels more than
  481. ever like I don't really understand what's going on at a basketball court So I just
  482. I mean i'm encouraging you to chase down nick nate's Dunked on prime stuff on youtube
  483. as a great way to consume this stuff. Shane Audie's on basketball. What do you have to say about?
  484. Yeah, i'm hockey. Come on I'm morally required to ignore at least New york team's doing well, so I
  485. have not been paying attention uh To basketball as well. No hockey's got me occupied.
  486. Certainly. Obviously, I think it's been yet another uh classic edition of nhl playoffs where we had
  487. all these like Absolutely historically great teams going in and then Hit walls and everything like
  488. that. So, you know, I mean, uh Avalanche coming off their regular season, uh, you know, not
  489. even making it to the finals The hurricane's looking absolutely dominant going into the finals, but
  490. you know down to one now to the to vegas So, uh, yeah, I guess it's sort of i've been enjoying especially with the
  491. oilers not involved I've been enjoying kind of the randomness Of the playoffs and hockey yet
  492. again this year but shane this year Right now being in the middle of the final series the bigger story seems to me The
  493. drunkenness of these games. I mean have we ever I would like to capture something about how ridiculous these three
  494. games have been And I would put them up against any first three games of any stanley cup final.
  495. I mean, yeah, no, it's been crazy I go to bed at a four four nothing game late second And then before I turn
  496. off the lights I see the scores four four, yeah, like what the hell where no and I Much less than the final it
  497. has been nice Like, you know I kind of feel like the hurricanes versus canadian series
  498. as much as I was kind of a little bit prone for the canadians That was a that was kind of on ice, you
  499. know I mean Every one of those games is the hurricane score like shooting about two
  500. or three times as much as the canadians And you were just kind of waiting for the puss on Realizations to catch up on
  501. to the puss on that's exactly right. That's exactly right Which this one is much
  502. more back and forth and and and I do kind of think you know It's it's a more even match.
  503. I really do kind of you know, I think you know um, I thought I think mccurdy's got uh, I think vegas at 62
  504. percent or something like that now maybe a little bit higher. Um, But I mean they're a game ahead.
  505. So I I think you know at this point game by game. It's basically a point. Yeah once one Random stat that I saw
  506. coming out of game. Was it game three game three where mitch marner? Has a natural hat trick in one period
  507. plus an assist So he had four points in a single period the second period this is game three when they went out for
  508. nothing before before being died Um, so marner scores four points in the second period in
  509. a final in a single cup final it had been since some player for the seattle metropolitans in 1919 since somebody had scored four
  510. points in a stanley cup final period Um, that's a anytime. This is like a good heuristic for how
  511. impressive a record breaking moment is how long has the record stood just a real simple
  512. heuristic How long has the record been there if gretzky couldn't break it? What are you doing breaking it?
  513. Exactly. Well, you're saying four goals in one period four points in one period four points three
  514. goals and assists of four points Okay, so what is it is it is it was specifically in the finals or in the playoffs
  515. or it's not overall No, it was in the finals in a period of the finals is my understanding What it would be the
  516. expected number of points in a in a period for any one player Just to show how many standard deviations out we're talking about
  517. Well, how many we might like the baseline goal a goal per team per period a goal per team per period maybe?
  518. I mean gretzky and his playoff crew is probably scoring like a goal per game or something like that Just to kind of norm
  519. it a little bit Where so you're looking quite honestly, you're looking at something like a
  520. six standard deviation event for a single player Yes, probably Four yeah Hundreds of players and
  521. and they play many many games and there are many many periods and that does add up but This is super unlikely That's unlikely
  522. it's unlikely. Um, it was it was good fun. He's a fun player. We've talked about him before He's a fun
  523. player to watch He can't he's one of those players He's like a player the martians
  524. like and i'm one of marshall you come in and you don't have to know a lot about hockey To see that he's different
  525. from everyone liberated from that cursed franchise in toronto. That's right Once he got off of the
  526. leafs, it's all better now um I want to I want to I want to say one thing about college sports the the men's
  527. college world series back to baseball guys Back to baseball. This is closer to your loves the field
  528. is set. That's the elite eight, of course so now they'll play Double elimination on both sides of
  529. the bracket to figure out the two finalists and then the two finalists will play best
  530. Two out of three. Um, I think there's five five of the eight are sec teams and then a couple
  531. of it. Um, Acc teams and then troy and in ken massey's power rankings, you know All these
  532. teams are like one four five eight in the country and then choice 53 Which is a little hard to believe but choice not
  533. like the others I will just add a gloss on this which is that historically Isn't
  534. much interest nationally in the college, uh world series In men's in baseball if oh basically
  535. because the best players in baseball typically went to the draft And they were playing major
  536. leagues, but now with nil money You can lure to college probably the majority of the
  537. top players With big big salaries interestingly You said lure because you're not talking about just
  538. about retention to keep them in college You're saying getting them to go to college when
  539. they get drafted out of high school They have a choice and you're saying losing the
  540. college with nil. That's interesting And what means that in a relatively short time once this thing kind of
  541. shakes out and a lot more money will go to baseball um I think that we're going to be seeing the college world series
  542. Nationally as a much bigger draw because you're looking at the the world's best american talent
  543. um, even national international talent playing essentially at that stage, which is one of the reasons
  544. why I think Potentially one of the reasons why college football has always been so much
  545. more interesting interesting You're really looking at next year's professionals and you're going to be playing
  546. for Does that does that have effects like does that does that how what does that
  547. do to like the single a And double a market baseball teams because now you know,
  548. yeah, that's right. I was going to say like you're just basically Reconstituting the college kind of farm system
  549. for like the that the nfl has and that the nba has well This is already are you saying this hasn't fully flowered yet?
  550. Because we've only had nil for a few years and it takes you know Four for a guy to go from a senior in
  551. high school to a senior in college that hasn't really fully flowered yet That's interesting.
  552. Um oddy we see this with the frozen four in college hockey this year You watch the frozen four and as they're calling the
  553. play they'll say you know, there's the number two pick the penguins first round pick and
  554. there's the red wings first round pick and like all these Recent draft picks on the
  555. ice in these college games and it definitely elevates the interest in the whole thing No
  556. question and that's 100 because of the well, that's because they changed the rules and allowed
  557. They allowed these guys to bounce That real quickly just to be clear because I was
  558. mistaken. That's not an nil thing. They used to you couldn't You couldn't play college hockey if you'd been Drafted or if
  559. you'd ever received money or whatever and they'd loosen that up and now you can do
  560. that. Sorry oddy jump in No, I mean that's that's that's in hockey But I think what
  561. you're seeing what's so exciting say about watching college football is, you know Those quarterbacks are
  562. going to be next year's quarterbacks in the nfl Or uh, not, you know, the four or five of them are going to do
  563. that If not next year the year after it's so exciting to watch that Knowing and the running backs and the wide receivers and
  564. the offensive linemen and and the pass rushers They're just important players in your future and
  565. you can see that and you care about it What's going to happen in baseball is you're going to be starting to see The
  566. starting pitchers for the yankees for playing for texas and you're like I need to watch
  567. that guy This makes me this makes me want to go and and like we should have a list of the highest rated Prospects
  568. in the world series this year. Like who are the top rated prospects across all eight teams?
  569. And you know, so that that's fun. That's a fun wrinkle We should add over the next but if you think historically college
  570. world series just didn't have that many top talent because yeah They were to be in
  571. college and and play those few years. Remember an 18 year old isn't going to be great at all typically Um, so in
  572. your so you're 21, you're you're you're not a top player. I mean Mostly not a top player, right?
  573. But I have to say I I actually cut my teeth when I when I started my phd I would sit and i've talked
  574. about in the show. I would sit in the sunken diamond at stanford And watch the ball players and paul
  575. carrey was their superstar hitter He had broken all records for home runs in uh in
  576. the pac-10 or whatever it is or college, uh baseball Nowhere didn't get got drafted
  577. went nowhere. He was so far down the line Um to you can't appreciate and stanford was the
  578. national champion They were led by one of the greatest pitchers of all time in college
  579. in college baseball mike messina But he but at that time you were like who is this guy?
  580. I mean, yeah, no idea where you're coming to because I do remember watching the 2007
  581. world series. No, it was maybe 2004 And the matchup was jason marquee was pitching for the cardinals
  582. Against jason veritech for the boston red sox and I remember them in the telecast making
  583. a huge deal about the fact that they had played each other In the college world series.
  584. Oh, that's amazing. Okay, and I think veritech was a shortstop at the time I don't I think they
  585. were both Players or something like that at a time or certainly veritech was um, and
  586. so yeah, I I mean that's obviously the exception But I I think it is an incredibly rare thing for that to happen Guys,
  587. let me give you one more detail on this and this is a term a tournament design a tournament design Issue and this is
  588. really subtle one. Okay, so this is about as in the weeds as i'm ever going to go But
  589. i'm asking i'm gonna get your quick reactions and uh men's college world series eight teams
  590. two distinct brackets play Round a double elimination and then they play two of three So
  591. there are four teams playing double elimination In the women's world series same setup eight teams
  592. go to oklahoma city two brackets with four but instead of having complete double elimination tournaments
  593. on each side The losers of the second round the winners of both of the games play each other and the losers of that
  594. Get sent to the other sides So it's not a a pure double elimination still double
  595. elimination Not not series by series That's right. Well, it's not it's not an enclosed it's
  596. still double elimination And they still kind of have bracket sides But the losers of the
  597. second round One loser in the second round between the games of the losers the first
  598. round is eliminated But between the games of the first round winners that loser goes to
  599. the other side Okay, i'll stop there Why would they do what's the implication and why
  600. would they do such a thing and baseball? I don't know how long women have been doing that.
  601. I think it's relatively new But men don't yeah yeah, I I I I'm, not sure why I think there's a there's a intellectual
  602. reason for it. Maybe there's some entertainment reason to do it Is it spread it around more?
  603. Yeah, I mean the reasons against doing it would be that you're hosting these things kind
  604. of regionally and it would involve moving teams Like physically around a much more than like
  605. you would otherwise. No, no, they're they're they're no No, they're all based in the final eight are all
  606. yeah in omaha or in oklahoma city. So they're set in one place Okay, one thing it does the obvious thing it does
  607. is it delays the potential for a rematch and reduces the probability of a rematch Right
  608. because you're not going to see one of the teams that already beats you once In the third or the fourth round now, you
  609. do have a chance of rematching in the fifth But by that time the odds are pretty low.
  610. So that's I mean yeah, it's We we typically in the playoffs we we we seize on the rematch as as more signal, right?
  611. Or at least we hope you know, like the reason we don't do Best of one and do best of seven or something like
  612. that is that we want to have rematches to make sure that you'd Actually the correct,
  613. you know the the quote-unquote best team and that's interesting seven, you know You're not
  614. going to necessarily like at baseball. You're not going to necessarily get that but
  615. but you know The concept that you would avoid a rematch when a rematch just gives
  616. you kind of to a certain extent more signal Well, does it actually that'd be a good sim question because or does it give
  617. you more signal to put them against somebody else? Because you still have a second loss.
  618. You're still doing double elimination But would it be better when you're starting to separate out
  619. the series? I mean obviously at the series level where you want to decide these two teams who
  620. goes on you kind of want rematches of That right. I don't know. I don't I don't know if that's true
  621. I thought I think it one of the things it does is it mutes the impact of who showed up on each side of
  622. the bracket to begin with So if there happens to be one really strong bracket by
  623. chance and one weak bracket by chance Because the brackets don't they don't get reshuffled they
  624. don't get re Um, what's the right word in playoff? They don't get reseated So whatever happens at
  625. the regionals bubbles all the way up And if there's no seated teams that happen to
  626. come from those eight regions And so you might have a really strong bracket and a
  627. weak bracket and this would dilute the impact of those differences Yeah, yeah, right.
  628. And so I think that might be a positive thing Okay, i'll stop there, but that's like pretty subtle tournament design and an interesting
  629. difference between the men's And the women's game. All right, guys, why don't we wrap the
  630. show there? um For the whole team here shane jensen oddie weiner eric bradlow in absentia Jacob grodnik
  631. holding down the production board behind the scenes d patel the boss lady and marissa reyna
  632. our producer Many thanks to you guys the listeners come back and join us next time
  633. between now and then Oh, and thanks to oddie for dialing in from israel late at night Thanks for you guys listening come back
  634. and join us next time between now and then Enjoy your sports

Brief Summary

Ryan O'Hanlon discusses World Cup predictions, U.S. team prospects, and the importance of set pieces in soccer analytics.

Key points

  • Ryan O'Hanlon Returns. Ryan O'Hanlon, a staff writer at ESPN, joins the show to discuss soccer analytics and the upcoming World Cup.
  • Soccer Coverage Expansion. The hosts acknowledge the need to increase their soccer coverage ahead of the World Cup.
  • World Cup Predictions. Ryan shares his insights on the World Cup, including team rankings and potential surprises.
  • Portugal's Underperformance Prediction. The speaker predicts Portugal may underperform in the World Cup due to structural disadvantages.
  • U.S. National Team's Group Dynamics. The U.S. faces a tricky group in the World Cup with no powerhouse teams.
  • Set Piece Revolution in Soccer. The Premier League has seen a scoring surge from set pieces, impacting the World Cup.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes