How Immigration Policy Is Reshaping Corporate Mergers and Acquisitions

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Immigration policy changes are reshaping how companies find and keep talent. Exequiel (Zeke) Hernandez explores new research showing that visa limits, especially on H-1B workers, are driving more mergers and acquisitions as firms look for alternative ways to fill skill gaps and stay competitive in a tightening labor market.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#Immigration #GlobalTalent #H1B #EconomicResearch #InnovationEconomy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The topic of immigration policy has really heated up in the last few years, but we also know that it is having an
  2. impact on the labor force. In fact, a new paper looks at how it is impacting companies. The paper partly by Wharton
  3. professors Britta Glennon and Ezekiel Hernandez suggests that it is leading to a higher level of M&A activity using the
  4. corporate deal making as a way to mitigate maybe not being able to fill some of the labor gaps. Ezekiel
  5. Hernandez joins us right now. He is a professor of management here at the Wharton School. Ezekiel, great to talk
  6. to you again. How are you? >> Good, Dan. How are you? Thanks for having me on. >> I'm doing well. All right. So, I guess
  7. let's start. What was it that piqu your interest in looking at this connection between what we're seeing going on
  8. around immigration policy and how companies are having to react to it? >> Yeah. Yeah, I mean nothing could be more
  9. current, right, with everything that's in the headlines and all the politics around immigration and and you know, I
  10. think we can all agree we're in an environment where uh there's a a move to restrict uh the arrival of of foreignb
  11. born talent to the United States and and many other countries. We wanted to know
  12. how companies react. Uh what what are they going to do in the face of those shortages? That was really the the
  13. motivation is just to understand that this is not just an issue that affects the economy as a whole, but it affects
  14. companies very specifically. >> So, take us through the dynamics of what it is that companies are doing and why
  15. they see the move to go the M&A route to be able to clear up some of these issues
  16. around being able to have uh some very important labor components, people that would probably be coming in through the
  17. H-1B visa program. >> Yeah. Yeah. So that's important. This paper is specifically uh using data from
  18. the H-1B program. Uh and also I should emphasize that the data we looked at is from before sort of the current uh
  19. presidential administration, right? Uh the the unique feature of the H1B program, of course, is that there's a
  20. limit on how many visas are available to firms. That's 85,000 per year. uh and because firms demand a lot more than
  21. that number, these visas are allocated through a lottery. And so that gives us a unique opportunity to see what happens
  22. when firms either miss out on the lottery or you know uh several years ago when the number of visas available went
  23. down significantly. How did the firms most affected by that react? And what we found, as you noted, is that there
  24. really is a scarcity of of talent and and of skilled talent in this case in particular, that is firms make more
  25. acquisitions when they miss out on that talent. Uh now, this is a really notable
  26. finding for a lot of reasons. There's a lot of things that firms could do. One of them could be do nothing, right? Just
  27. wait it out. Uh, another one could be if you really believe that there's enough uh US-born talent or or other talent
  28. already in the labor market, you might think, well then firms don't have to find a workaround to this. And so what
  29. our results are saying is that there really is a shortage. That is firms are not crying wolf. Uh, and they're using
  30. acquisitions as a way to either get the talent that they wanted from a firm that
  31. already has it or get the result of what that talent was going to do, say build a
  32. certain technology or product. And so it makes it that much easier, at least with
  33. some of the dynamics in play right now, to kind of work around the concept of the H-1B visa program, the numbers as
  34. you alluded to, and just go ahead and buy the company that already maybe has that talent.
  35. >> Yeah. I mean, if you can't hire, you buy right now. Of course, I think it's very
  36. important to say that this is second best, right? This is not what firms wanted to do as their first option. they
  37. wanted to hire a set limited number of people, incorporate them into their current teams and maintain the workflow
  38. that they already had. So, you know, it's very possible that that uh firms might have chosen to do nothing because
  39. it's very disruptive to go out, buy a firm, go through the process of post merger integration, which just again
  40. highlights how very important this talent is for firms that they're willing to take on all the risks entailed in in
  41. a merger or acquisition. There are quite a few dynamics that that you and your cohorts uh look at. One that I wanted to
  42. bring up was the dynamic of the size of the company in terms of the acquisition,
  43. small versus large, and how that plays into maybe the decision to make that purchase, to make that M&A move.
  44. >> Yeah. And this is an important finding, right? Obviously, these acquisitions, if
  45. they're really a response to talent shortage or missing out on hiring, anywhere from a handful to maybe several
  46. dozen, maybe at most if it if you're a big firm, a few hundred workers. You know, these acquisitions have to be can
  47. measure it in size, right? You you know, like a talent shortage is not going to apply is not going to explain Disney
  48. buying Fox, right? That has a totally different strategic purpose. And so being sort of like an aqua hire or or a
  49. workaround to talent shortages, yeah, we tend to find that these deals tend to be
  50. small, right? Somewhere in the five to 10 up to maybe 20 million range. After that, um, you know, we're not seeing the
  51. effect. So, you know, that again is consistent with a talent substitution mechanism as opposed to another
  52. motivation for the deal. But the importance of having these employees especially to a company's bottom line we
  53. are learning is becoming that much more important to have that value and in many
  54. cases to be able to either expand you know current success that a firm has already had or maybe even expand new
  55. pipelines that they're looking to add in in the years ahead. >> Yeah. I mean, look, we we know a lot of
  56. uh things from other studies uh done by other scholars uh on on the importance of these H-1B workers. And I know this
  57. is a very political subject in terms of the visa program specifically, but you know, the H-1B program is the main
  58. vehicle or one of the main vehicles by which US companies can hire skilled people with bachelor's degrees or
  59. higher. We know, for example, that immigrants in the United States are responsible for over a third of all
  60. patents, and many of those immigrants enter through programs like the H-1B. We also know that startups, right, that
  61. that that miss out on hiring H-1B workers, uh, they're less innovative. They're less likely to grow to to end up
  62. with an IPO or or to have a successful exit. That means they're not creating as many jobs. And so, these are really
  63. important outcomes for firms. And and the good news is that it's not a zero- sum game between like hiring these
  64. workers on H-1Bs versus hiring native workers is that this the unique skills these workers bring enable firms to do
  65. other things that actually create jobs for other workers, right? They have a multiplier effect. So, you know, the
  66. fact that we're seeing this acquisition effect, again, I emphasize is a really strong indicator of how critical these
  67. workers are. >> What do you think then from this research are are the most important
  68. takeaways? Uh, I think the takeaway is, uh, firms are not crying wolf when they say they
  69. need these workers, right? They really do. And not being able to get them makes US-based firms, uh, less competitive,
  70. right? Uh, now, we can't prove this in the paper, but it would be interesting to ask as a follow-up to what we're
  71. doing. Is this causing consolidation in the market? Right? Is that consolidation
  72. affecting innovation? Is it affecting the ability to create other jobs? Is it affecting the ability of firms to uh
  73. create products that customers need? Right? Those are all implications that we need to talk about in a very serious
  74. way if we're going to get immigration policy right and keep firms competitive. >> But seemingly this is an area that
  75. because of the importance of the topic right now is going to be probably something that's going to be on your
  76. mind and your colleagues mind to see how this continues to develop down the road
  77. in the years ahead. Yeah, I mean we have other research ongoing looking at other
  78. other outcomes, right? For example, the ability of firms to uh create products for markets, right? Uh that are relevant
  79. for those markets and you know, lots of other research and it's only getting stronger. Remember, the research we did
  80. was based on immigration restrictions that are much weaker than what we're seeing right now. For example, the
  81. $100,000 tax on every H-1B worker is a much stronger restriction than what we study. So, it's presumably going to have
  82. an even stronger effect than what we found in our research. >> Ezekiel, great to talk to you again.
  83. Thanks very much for your time. All the best. >> Thank you. Ezekiel Hernandez, who's a
  84. management professor here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Ezekiel Hernandez discusses how immigration policy impacts labor shortages and drives M&A activity among companies.

Key points

  • The Impact of Immigration Policy. A new paper reveals how immigration policy affects corporate mergers and acquisitions.
  • M&A as a Solution. Companies are turning to mergers and acquisitions to fill labor gaps caused by immigration restrictions.
  • The H-1B Visa Program. The H-1B visa program is crucial for hiring skilled workers, impacting innovation and job creation.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes