Social Activism and Political Clout
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
New Wharton research examines the delicate balancing act among corporations, politicians and social activists. More: http://knlg.net/1XuBXY8 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- we're here today with Wharton professor mary hunter mcdonald to talk about her latest research which focuses on how
- social activists can affect impact the relationships between companies and politicians Mary thanks for being with
- us today thanks Finch now please give us to start off can you give us sort of a brief summary of your research oh sure
- so the paper is about a timely topic today with the election around the corner about corporations involvement in
- the political process and their influence over politicians they're spent of course increasing attention to this
- question in business schools in the field of non-market strategy but most of the research to date on these issues has
- tended to focus on supply-side questions so what what kinds of businesses tend to
- use tactics to try to access an influence political constituencies in this paper we try to flip the the deck a
- little bit and look at the demand side factors that play a role in this process specifically when are politicians more
- or less willing to engage with particular corporations and how does a company's reputation affect their
- ability to access political constituencies and so our precise research question in the paper is
- whether large-scale social activist protests affect or disrupt corporations ability to access and influence
- political stakeholders now tell us a little bit about so what were some of your key takeaways from this research so
- in the paper we are exploring different proxies for corporate influence and access to politicians and so we look at
- three separate proxies we look at the number of a the amount of a company's campaign contributions that are refunded
- by politicians I know this is a surprising proxy to many people because many people think politicians will just
- take any money that that you'll give to them but what we find is that many politicians actually will reject and
- refund problematic contributions from corporate PACs the second proxy we look at is corporate
- appearances and congressional hearings so oftentimes Congress will actually bring companies into a congressional
- hearing to share information about a given regulation and companies really seek out lists
- of influence because it allows them a real-time way to try to engage with politicians on key regulatory problems
- and the third proxy that we look at it are assigned procurement contracts when the government actually hires companies
- to provide goods or services so we look in the paper at how a boycott affects these three different proxies for access
- and influence and we find that it disrupts all three so we have a database of all boycotts and we find that being
- boycotts boycotted is associated with increased refunded campaign contributions decreased congressional
- appearances and decreased contracts assigned by the government now were there any conclusions of this paper that
- came as a surprise to you I mean when you started out that you didn't expect to find when you started really digging
- into the data I think what perhaps surprised me the most was well I was honestly surprised that we had the
- finding were related to corporate campaign contributions just idea of refunding campaign contributions as
- seemed a bit bizarre to me going into this project but but the finding was real is there and boycotts lead to to
- almost a doubling of the amount of campaign contributions that are refunded I also thought that the amount of real
- money that companies can lose as a fact of this disruption was fairly staggering
- so just looking at the contract example for example let me see after look at my notes but so when a company is boycotted
- it leads to a reduction of contracts that's equivalent to a roughly a hundred and sixty-seven million dollar loss in
- one quarter that's pretty significant I mean that could be a pretty big part of somebody's budget absolutely now
- specifically so if I am I'm a company or even if I'm a politician or even if I'm
- social activist if I'm looking at this research I mean how could I apply this how do you how would you apply this
- research in in real life uh-huh well I think it's the way that it is applicable of course differs
- depending on if you're a company or social activists for companies I think in a non-market strategy we tend to talk
- both about how companies can access political constituencies and about how they can me and
- contentious social activist and these are both seen as important parts of the company's control of their non market
- environment I don't think anyone has ever suggested that these two domains are connected in this way and then
- actually engaging with your social activist stakeholders may be important as a part of trying to manage your
- ability to access and influence your political constituencies and to control the threat of regulation and I think
- this one so there is there any particular I know a lot of these end up in the news so is there any particular
- though boycott in the news or thing in the news that you think really directly relates to this research Oh so the
- research had a sample of all boycotts and so you know some of them are things you would recognize like the boycotts
- against Nike for their use of child labor and their supply chain for example and some of them are boycotts you've
- probably never heard of like the NRA boycotted a company for starting to to to for disallowing its employees from
- bringing guns onto their parking lot for example so they're kind of all different
- kinds of issues and if you start looking out for boycotts in the media and outlets like the New York Times or The
- Wall Street Journal you'll see them almost every day now see what you're saying though is that it doesn't
- necessarily matter how widespread the boycott is or I mean it doesn't matter like how widespread the Brooke boycott
- is or how much press attention that it gets I mean does that exacerbate the it impacts if it's something that intends
- you know that really spreads with people or just gets a lot of attention it does
- so we actually find two key moderators of the effects in our paper one of these is the amount of media attention that a
- boycott gets now to be in our sample of like I already had to receive attention and one of the six major media outlets
- in the United States so these are already fairly large-scale boycotts but some boycotts get quite a bit more
- attention than others and we find those that are drawing media attention are much more disruptive because the media
- attention is the lifeblood of activism the other key moderator we find is the salience of the issue that the what
- cutters are bringing so issues vary in terms of the extent to which the public thinks that the issue is something that
- ought to be top of mind to politicians at the moment and so you know even in a world where we tend to think of things
- like environmental issues as being very important during the recession for example even if you were an
- environmental activist it was hard to get politicians to attend to your issue because people were at the moment more
- interested in employment and so at different periods of time in a year different issues are salient and for
- activists it's important to have the right issue at the right time right and so I guess for a company it's almost
- like having that perfect store happen to them so are there other misperceptions that you feel like this research kind of
- dispels um I think so I think that we tend to have a perception that politicians will just take any corporate
- money that they're sort of indefatigably open-palm to when it comes to corporate
- access and so our paper is suggesting that politicians have standards which I think a lot of people don't tend to get
- politicians credit for these days what one interesting side note about the paper is that we find that these
- standards are held primarily among Democrats so the disruption we observe in campaign contributions for example is
- primarily coming from liberals we see less disruption among Republican except ease of contributions do you have any I
- mean did the paper show any particular reason for that or I think the reason is that we primarily think that disruption
- occurs because politicians worry about their reputation being tarnished if they're associated with a problematic
- firm and because among conservatives there's already a general acceptance that conservatives are aligned with the
- corporate sector that those associations aren't as scary and problematic to those
- politicians as they are to progressives and so how do you plan to follow up this
- research what's next for you so my co-author and I now are working on a second paper to follow up on this paper
- where we're where we are exploring what exactly companies do to counter this disruption because we don't think they
- sort of sit idly by right and wait for it to pass so what we find in this paper is that
- the types of political tactics that are disrupted are tactics that are overt and
- public that are easily traceable and these are the type of tactics that would carry reputational risk for politicians
- because you could point to an instance where the politician had been associated with a problematic company so what we're
- arguing in this follow-up paper is that because only that type of tactic is disrupted by social activist protest
- companies that are protested will turn to more covert tactics and more indirect tactics so they're more likely to do
- things that are subject to less disclosure like lobbying they're more likely to work indirectly through their
- managers rather than at the company level so after a protest you might see companies PAC contributions fall but you
- should see managers package managers direct contributions to politicians increase and and we're looking at
- whether firms start to use more cooperative measures of political influence like trying to bring political
- operatives onto their corporate boards for example so it's interesting because I think you know probably from the
- activist standpoint they would prefer things be done more in the public eye and what's happening is their efforts
- are actually creating the opposite effect like they're it's creating less transparency as far as what companies
- are doing absolutely so I my primary research interest is how firms and social activists interact and activism
- really thrives in high disclosure environments where activists are able to easily monitor corporate behavior so
- isn't an interesting in to some extent I think frustrating a side effect of activism that they are pushing companies
- into darker channels of political influence thank you so much for being with us today
- oh thank you so it's fun you
Brief Summary
Mary Hunter McDonald discusses how social activism disrupts corporate influence on politicians, revealing significant financial impacts and the role of media attention.
Key points
- Surprising Findings on Campaign Contributions. Mary shares unexpected results regarding politicians refunding campaign contributions from corporations.
- The Impact of Boycotts on Corporations. Mary's research reveals that boycotts significantly disrupt corporate access to political influence.
- The Role of Media Attention in Activism. The research finds that media attention amplifies the impact of boycotts on corporations.
Episode highlights
- Surprising Findings on Campaign ContributionsMary shares unexpected results regarding politicians refunding campaign contributions from corporations.“Many politicians actually will reject and refund problematic contributions from corporate PACs.”1:46Jun 16, 2016
- The Impact of Boycotts on CorporationsMary's research reveals that boycotts significantly disrupt corporate access to political influence.“Being boycotted is associated with increased refunded campaign contributions.”2:46Jun 16, 2016
- The Role of Media Attention in ActivismThe research finds that media attention amplifies the impact of boycotts on corporations.“Media attention is the lifeblood of activism.”6:29Jun 16, 2016
Tension
50/ 100Some tension




