Building Bridges with Her Feet

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi this is Mike you same I'm on the faculty here at the Wharton School and I have the privilege today of sitting down
  2. with Mary McVeigh who is the co-founder of soccer Without Borders and we're going to be talking next few minutes
  3. about that sport and Mary's building of a worldwide network of people who work with young people with women in some
  4. countries those who are refugees to help them through soccer keep their feet on the ground and get forward in life so
  5. Mary great to have you here in the studio thanks for having me look forward to our dialogue let's just start there
  6. maybe a little bit with you I think you went to Dartmouth College played soccer there even turn pro for a while so
  7. you've got a soccer career behind you yourself I do I've played soccer since I was four I still play very
  8. recreationally ambassador but I've just been very fortunate to have had the chance to you know have that be a part
  9. of my life and opportunities just kept kept coming I guess and I've I've built a network of friendships and great
  10. coaches that have really shaped me and reshaped the outcome of my life well that's great and most people when they
  11. play a collegiate sport that at that time in their lives when college is finished they are finished with the
  12. sport those who turn pro usually by age 22 or 23 or they're out of the NBA or NFL but you've managed to keep your your
  13. feet in the sport so to speak even as you left professional playing yourself and in forming this organization it's
  14. got a great title a great name for its soccer without borders this really is a cause driven agenda here so give us the
  15. a little bit about the mission of your organization and why you got it going you're the co-founder so why did you do
  16. this so soccer is one of the world's few universal languages and that that can be
  17. really powerful I mean you think about a world cup and how many people that brings together how many people watch
  18. how many people are passionate about it and so the idea is how do you use that to influence positive change how do you
  19. use that to motivate kids to reach their potential how do you use that to build bridges across racial economic
  20. cultural religious divides and really bring people together and build something positive so that was kind of
  21. the idea when we set out was it was how do we use this sport that has has a lot of really important interpersonal
  22. lessons that you can draw on to build character to build skills but then also to build community and you know we've
  23. been exploring that now for 10 years and and wouldn't say we've got it perfectly
  24. right but we're doing something good and you know the model has been working it's
  25. been applied in a lot of different contexts and we're excited to keep innovating and and keep finding a way to
  26. use this universal language for positive outcomes where I know you've got an office in Cambridge Massachusetts that's
  27. where it all kind of comes from these days and you got four or five hundred volunteers around the world working with
  28. you on this but let's make it more personal fly with you down to Nicaragua maybe
  29. drive an hour outside of the capital there to a small town that's called Granada
  30. after the Spanish town by the same name different from the island of Grenada which has a certain history that we're
  31. probably mostly familiar with you're you arrived you probably got there by bus and just let's make it a start okay not
  32. even if I said you wish it had been a bus so you're you pop out of the back of a pickup truck and then what you know
  33. our goal when I first went to Grenada was to find a way to to give access to this amazing sport to girls and that's
  34. something that was really not done there was there were so many levels of boys soccer and boys sports particularly
  35. baseball and soccer that had been built at the time there was boys leagues from under ten all the way up to premier
  36. league professional but on the women's side it was it was virtually non-existent and there's a lot of
  37. cultural economic reasons why that was so so the first I would say the first memory that I have of really seeing what
  38. this could do is you know we started doing soccer clinics and schools around Grenada and I was joined by my friend
  39. and cook who's now the associate head coach Penn State and we on our way home from
  40. from work that day we came across a pickup game there were six men playing three versus three literally under like
  41. a streetlight and it was nine or ten o'clock at night maybe a little later and you couldn't resist and we couldn't
  42. resist so it was - two of us women and then our friendship a who was Nicaraguan who had been helping us build the
  43. program and so we had three we had enough to play and so he you know he asked could we could we play winner and
  44. they literally just looked at us and and laughed and yeah they had no idea that an cook was a Hermann Trophy finalist
  45. played in the WUSA she's she's amazing you were all-american yourself I could try to hold my own and so we played in
  46. and it was a typical style you know you score you stay and we won nine games in a row and you could see at first it was
  47. you know who are these women and then it was you know they're there they're joking with each other oh she beat you
  48. and they were embarrassed and then by the end it was just we were just another team common ground and that that was
  49. when I knew that you know this this could change people's perspective they didn't need to be embarrassed about
  50. losing to women it was just they're good players and they could see us that way really interesting point too because in
  51. this case you're playing against them but nonetheless you bridged across a divide by playing against them the
  52. common ground was the game of soccer and it's about getting people to see each other for their for who they are for
  53. their talents not by you know some stereotype or some perception of what their limits are and getting people
  54. themselves to see that to you know have hoping the girls see you can be anything
  55. you want to be you know it's not just what society tells you your limits are so merry when you are there maybe the
  56. next day after this game you are a startup that you've arrived you might have a few contacts there but you don't
  57. have a team you don't have women out there girls out there playing yeah so take us through the first couple months
  58. when you had literally nothing and you had to build something it's really about making contacts and figuring out who who
  59. are champions on the ground so it wasn't about us being able you know me being able to go home and do
  60. from afar it was who are people here that believe in the same mission so the one of the first things we did was a
  61. joined men's team since there was no women's team and a lot of the men on that team are became coaches of ours we
  62. also managed to find the handful of women that had kind of challenged tradition and we're playing and roped
  63. them in to become coaches and then literally went door to door or school to school to school inviting girls to play
  64. and you know you do little clinics and show them they think they can't play you you watch them go through this
  65. transformation of I can't do that that's not for me and then oh I can you know I
  66. can get to juggles or I can make that pass um and and they get hooked because it's something exciting it's new there's
  67. an adult that's interested in me and and my skills and I feel positive and and we
  68. were able to to bring girls into the fold that way and get something started that could sustain all people doing
  69. startups say they have some great days and they have some really tough ones so what we're one or two your setbacks
  70. along the way there there have been many I think one that stands out since we're
  71. talking about Nicaragua finding finding your own limits of what you can and can't do you know these the challenges
  72. of of poverty and of equality that they're very complex and you can only provide so many services and so many
  73. resources so we had this one girl yelled uh who lived right next to the one soccer field in town so she was one of
  74. those women she had grown up playing with boys and she came out to our practice and she was talented and you
  75. know we are lies lit up and saying you know we're not here to be professional players but you know this girl clearly
  76. has a passion for it I'm so through the program she ended up playing for the under-21 national team which was very
  77. disorganized at the time but you know existed a huge breakthrough resource but just the complexity of the need she had
  78. you know her parents were really upset that she made the national team it was a Managua meant she she couldn't do as
  79. many chores around the house you know who's gonna pick up that slack the the national team was paying for her
  80. bus fare which they would oftentimes steal you know if you're gonna have this resource why should it be used for sport
  81. that's crazy it was just very complicated health issues you know somebody who's coming from a background
  82. that that she had her nutritional needs hadn't been met so playing at a higher level could her body handle that so it
  83. just sort of took us down a road of you know can we be a school and a hospital and a counselor and all of these things
  84. you know what's the limits of what we can do and the answer was yes and the answer was was actually no you know she
  85. ended up not being able to to bridge that for her at times it took up you know all of our focus was on this one
  86. girl we realized when there were so many others that were in the program you can't you how many resources can you
  87. devote to one person so it was really a gut check of what can we do what can we do well what are the limits and when
  88. when do you need to let someone go if you can't meet the needs that that they have I think that lesson always replays
  89. for me it's recognizing what you can and can't do and making sure the things you
  90. do you do choose to do that you can sustain them and do them well you know it's like a lot of people getting
  91. anything going they've got a vision or where they want to go but the actual model of how to do it you gotta kind of
  92. event by doing and learning and two steps forward and one step back so that was you you ready to reference the title
  93. of your organization no soccer Without Borders so help us understand what you mean by Without Borders I'm you know I
  94. think it speaks to the universality of the game and it also speaks to breaking down barriers it's it's about how do we
  95. erase some barriers that that exist in in the world for based on different circumstances so one of our major focus
  96. areas right now is on the newcomer population refugees asylees immigrants and you know literally borders comes to
  97. mind when you think about that and you think about people who have our stateless have lost their home have been
  98. you know forced to flee war persecution violence and you know how can you help them rebuild home
  99. in a new place and soccer can soccer is a pretty powerful tool in that in that effort make make the connections so we
  100. let's take refugees and maybe Turkey these days or Greece or or Nicaragua there are a couple million people
  101. traveling by foot today as we speak as we well know and as they come into a team they build at least a relationship
  102. with the coaches and parents and so on but then how does this bridge into something bigger than soccer itself so I
  103. mean you you hit the nail on the head there the family and support of team is incredibly powerful and the the mentor
  104. mentee relationship that's formed with the coach but then there's there's other concrete skills and resources that kids
  105. need in order to access opportunities and pathways particularly in the u.s. you know how do you fill out a FAFSA
  106. form how do you do you know to take the SAT are you prepared for the SAT what sort of interview skills do you have are
  107. you comfortable talking you know talking with somebody in presenting presenting yourself in a way that could help get
  108. you a job you know these are all very hard skills that kids need to practice and coming from a number of different
  109. cultural backgrounds interrupted schooling you know they may not have had sort of a pathway that's very consistent
  110. that builds up to a job or school higher education so we're you know trying to fill in those gaps I bet one of our one
  111. of my peers in this work I just thought had a great analogy the other day said it's like Swiss cheese
  112. there's a lot of holes and they're not all in the same place and so you're trying to plug them it's not about a a
  113. consistent model that's going to work for everybody it's about the model that's flexible enough to identify the
  114. holes and provide the resources to fill them you know I think historically the US Peace Corps often sent people who
  115. would become coaches and developing areas as well and the model that you're doing or offering up now is not unlike I
  116. think what the Peace Corps has done historically which is to help people through an initial engagement in a
  117. sporting activity could be badminton could be soccer could be baseball in some areas
  118. but it's baseball plus or it's soccer plus let's think about the plus and how do you after you've got a team maybe
  119. even a winning team yeah how do you help say the girls and Nicaragua then take the next step and putting their future
  120. together so one thing we do is is try to identify what are what are the obstacles are the
  121. pitfalls that exist what are the challenges that they're gonna face you know in Nicaragua some of the research
  122. would tell you that you're twenty eight percent of girls are pregnant by the time they're 18 that's a challenge
  123. fifty-two percent of kids don't make it on to secondary school that's a challenge so you can identify what are
  124. sort of the common pitfalls and how can we shape our program to address this so one thing in Nicaragua we offer is in
  125. sixth grade we want to bridge that transition into secondary school so starting in sixth grade we offer we call
  126. half scholarships public school in Nicaragua is not free there's there's uniforms
  127. there's a small matriculation fee so can we provide that the girls come when they
  128. come to an activity they are at a point they can use those points to purchase school uniforms and school supplies and
  129. then in secondary school we offer full scholarships which they can actually if they earn it through the program
  130. positive participation there's an application that we help with they can actually choose any secondary school
  131. they want and and we pay for it so we're identifying that this is this is a period of life where they can go
  132. one of two directions how can we intervene and make sure it's a positive path so it's I think that's how you know
  133. the Peace Corps has some very concrete areas that they focus on and people are trained for and I think what we try to
  134. do is similarly understand the culture and context that we're working in and make sure that we shape the program to
  135. meet those specific needs as I think about the girls say who are hopefully heading towards high school or beyond
  136. and Nicaragua I'm thinking they're residential that are there their families live there when it comes to
  137. people on the immigrant trail they're often not there that long families have been broken up so a much more difficult
  138. population to work with how do you go about even creating a team that's sustainable and and able to
  139. repeatedly play if people are on the move as they often are as immigrants I mean that is that is a significant
  140. challenge so one is you want to catch them early and be a resource early so we work directly with resettlement agencies
  141. with schools with community partners that would know when people arrive you know that they're here and immediately
  142. try to get them into something positive so we don't have a closed door policy with with our teams sometimes our teams
  143. can swell 245 kids over the course of a season or more you know it's not what people traditionally think of as a team
  144. but then we do you know kids want to play games and and in the United States playing games means pass cards and
  145. paperwork and so bridging that you know how do you get a kid ready to be able to
  146. play on the team that's that's something that there's a lot of problem-solving that our coaches do and it's also
  147. motivation for the kids they arrive they play in they'd get to know the community
  148. they immediately have access to all the academic support language support but to
  149. play on that team they got to stick with it and you know they can vote with their
  150. feet they can kind of control their own fate in that regard I will say we had we
  151. had one family that was in our program in Oakland that then moved to Greeley Colorado where we have another program
  152. and ended up captaining our middle school team and Greeley I think it would be so amazing if that could happen more
  153. often because families do they do move and migrate in order to pursue opportunities where there's jobs we are
  154. seeing a huge migration to the Midwest central plains a Colorado program tends to be a second
  155. resettlement type of city and so you do start to see the differences and where people move and where opportunities are
  156. so married to put my words on it you've got a a moment where people can be drawn
  157. in for the love of the sport but with that you open up opportunities and channels to help them take the next step
  158. in life whether it's school or maybe a securing unemployment or who knows maybe even playing professionally for a year
  159. or two thinking of it way it reminds me again of organizations to start out with a particular focus and
  160. it works but then those who are the creators are one of the two co-founders you begin to think well what about
  161. taking that that basic model soccer now initially but why just soccer why not basketball why not badminton so to use
  162. the language what about the adjacencies you only thought about that so far you're not into that maybe you would be
  163. well I was bathroom a player in high school so I have a good start on that too but we are part of a network of
  164. several networks but one that comes to mind that kind of speaks to what you're talking about is called up to us sports
  165. and they are a coalition of what we call sport-based youth development organization so organizations that are
  166. that Sport Plus or that are doing more than sport and it's all different kinds of sports it's I can't remember the
  167. number off the top of my head but it's more sports than I knew existed you know basketball lacrosse football golf
  168. there's so many great lessons that you can pull out of different sports it's ray Youth Olympics just about everything
  169. yeah it's just you know and each sport has has different lessons that are inherent yeah I really appreciate those
  170. of soccer and think in terms of building bridges across culture and and across divides soccer is uniquely suited for
  171. that I think but I can also see so much value in in each and every sport and the
  172. skills that it can teach thinking about outcome when you look at the end of the day of what you've done what would be a
  173. a metric of when you've succeeded with let's make that make it the team down in Nicaragua how do you know when that
  174. particular setting and that particular investment of your time was paying off you know I think measuring impact with
  175. kids is is incredibly challenging for the same reason that you know when you're a parent you you know you're
  176. planting seeds and you don't know exactly what's what's gonna grow but we have boiled down what we try to measure
  177. into five things one is academic advancement and you know are they are they able to gain access to those
  178. credentials that are meaningful that are going to open one is language development particularly
  179. with newcomers can you acquire the language skills you need to participate in the economy and access opportunities
  180. one is social capital so how well are we connecting the kids to networks and and
  181. safety nets I'm one is healthy lifestyles which is you know being a happy healthy active person who is able
  182. to avoid risky behaviors and you know value their body and the last one is personal development which is I think a
  183. little bit more abstract but we want to develop happy confident competent compassionate people people who are good
  184. people I think too often kids have a lot of external expectations that are put on
  185. them you know other people define success for them you know it looks like pen or her it looks like that job and we
  186. want to equip the kids with the skills they need to reach their full potential whatever that is for them and I think
  187. that's for me if they're happy healthy individuals who are reaching their goals and and aspiring towards that that's
  188. good that's good enough for me scale here is your opportunity but also your challenge you're active and I think
  189. it's some 50 countries you've got programs and Central America Africa and Beyond if we think of it that way there
  190. are probably a billion people out there that are in need of this kind of transitional moment as they leave early
  191. childhood and get into later childhood and then on so in terms of the number of people you're reaching right now and the
  192. number of young people you'd like to reach ten or fifteen years out what kind of skill are we looking at
  193. so just to I don't want to overstate our our reach right now but we we've worked
  194. with kids from more than 50 countries of origin but we haven't actually programmed in 50 countries do I think
  195. the model could be relevant to really any country absolutely do we have a goal of being a behemoths nonprofit not no we
  196. want to make sure that the model is effective that we're being true to the communities where we are and
  197. that we're doing the best we can to meet the overwhelming need I've we get approached every single week to open a
  198. new program in some city I know the need is there the demand is there so right now we're really focused on the places
  199. where we are how do we maximize that infrastructure what are the next few places that that really have a need that
  200. we could replicate but also how do we package this tool so that other people like us could take it and run with it
  201. and adapt it to their community we don't need to be experts in every culture and
  202. language across the world but I think if we have a tool that works then yeah we need to find a way to share it and
  203. you're probably eminently eminently scalable because you do depend on volunteers you don't have to raise a lot
  204. of money to put a field staff out there and in that sense as a as volunteers are
  205. your fundamental building blocks here in principle 10 years out you could be reaching any number of communities any
  206. number of groups around the world the volunteers are actually not our building block anymore we do have staff
  207. everywhere yes we leverage volunteers for a number of different roles but it's led by trained staff I mean when you're
  208. working with kids I think there's a really strong and necessary vetting process and training process
  209. particularly kids of experienced trauma to make sure that the people we put in the field are trained so volunteers
  210. serve a very crucial supporting role but tend to not be in a leading role and that is a limiting factor in terms of
  211. scale so what we are looking at is who are the community organizations that we could partner with and that are already
  212. there that already have that infrastructure have that leadership see what they're missing like one thing
  213. that a lot of organizations are missing is women in in sport it's we have an unbelievable supply of women athletes
  214. that is incredibly uncommon around the world everywhere I go it's it's men who are coaching and so it's not surprising
  215. that women make up less than 10 and of soccer players in the world's global sport when they have nobody to
  216. see and look to so I think there's a there's some opportunity areas for things that that we as an American
  217. organization could export but there's also a lot of work to be done here in our communities here with newcomers
  218. arriving and girls here who aren't accessing sport in the way that they could thank goodness for many things including
  219. title nine that's probably had certain many factors that contributed to women in sports but
  220. title nine going way back in our history part of the u.s. Civil Rights Act has probably been vital for helping you now
  221. have the flow of women who want to work with you it was a game-changing moment in into to mandate equity and is is an
  222. incredible statement and you know right now I'm following what's going on in FIFA very closely in terms of mandating
  223. not quite equity but participation by women at every level you know that's gonna trickle down it's gonna open doors
  224. for girls in sport we're already seeing it in Nicaragua but I think those who've
  225. had the opportunity and that privilege from my perspective have an obligation to pay it forward and I think that is
  226. something that really resonates with women in the u.s. that you know can we create an avenue that they can step up
  227. and try to find a way to pay it forward got a couple more personal closing questions here number one what really
  228. drew you into this what was the I don't know triggering moment or the epiphany that led you to do what you're doing um
  229. I think one moment that stands out is when I was coaching at Lehigh it was a grad student there which is how I met
  230. the founder Ben Gucci Rd he he launched this out of Lehigh entrepreneurship program I had the chance to travel to
  231. South America to see the World Cup qualifiers for South America and I had never been really exposed to the
  232. inequality that that can exist for women elsewhere and I saw it it was empty stadiums it was there was no program
  233. there was coaches who were sitting in the corner in the shade you know not you know they were they were being punished
  234. to be the women's coach and that just really didn't I don't know it's just stuck with me it didn't it didn't sit
  235. well and you know what can I do about this and then I met Ben and he had this phenomenal idea to to try to address
  236. some of these inequities to try to really build a a microcosm of a better world through soccer and you know it
  237. just went from there and maybe last query here as you reflect on who you are now and how you became what you're doing
  238. and think about the the moments that did make a difference in your own life course here for those who might be
  239. watching this particular dialogue who are thinking gee I might want to do something like that yeah what advice
  240. would you have for somebody who's maybe involved in athletics or something equivalent who would like to think about
  241. working with the youth of the world to help them get from point A to point B the way you've been doing yeah I think
  242. there's a there's a lot of ways that people can get involved I think the first thing they should do is is really
  243. think about the skills they have and what they can bring and I think one sort of misconception is that passion is
  244. enough that you know I like soccer or I like working with kids you know there's got to be a way I can help you know
  245. ultimately running an organization is business and and businesses need skills you know we need you need marketing you
  246. need an IT person you need legal help you need you need skills and I think that that moment when somebody says you
  247. know I can connect something that I do well to to a greater good you know that's magical and we are very
  248. fortunate to have found people who are willing to help and lend their talents and skills and resources to what we're
  249. doing at different moments you know one of my former players at Lehigh helped us
  250. build a website that was prepared for you know the new mobile world that the fact that she would apply her talent and
  251. skill for that to to this work is amazing it's opened all kinds of doors for us I think really reckon you know dialing
  252. in on what what talent you have to offer and if it is coaching or teaching oh my
  253. gosh you are a Saints because then people who work with kids they they are so undervalued and it is it is a skill
  254. so if that's your skill please apply it to something to an organization that's doing this work but if you have other
  255. skills you can that can be really useful too it's great Mary thank you for your great guidance on that and thank you for
  256. joining a program today thank you so much for having me is what an amazing community and we are so excited to be a
  257. part of it and it'll have you as part of our community thank you very much thank
  258. you you

Brief Summary

Mary McVeigh discusses Soccer Without Borders' mission to empower youth through soccer and address social challenges in communities worldwide.

Key points

  • Soccer Without Borders: A Universal Language. Mary McVeigh discusses how soccer can bridge divides and foster community.
  • Empowering Girls Through Soccer. Mary shares her mission to provide access to soccer for girls in Nicaragua.
  • Overcoming Challenges in Soccer Development. Mary reflects on the complexities of supporting talented girls in soccer amidst societal challenges.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes