How Big Business Can Fix the World

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Often perceived as acting in ways that harm the economy, society and the environment due to a short-term focus on profits, big business is now starting to use its power for long-term good, according to Lucy Parker and Jon Miller, authors of Everybody's Business: The Unlikely Story of How Big Business Can Fix the World.

In an interview with Wharton management professor Witold Henisz, Parker and Miller explain why a new norm is evolving and why some of the very companies that have been singled out for "crimes and misdemeanors" are leading the way in creating a focus where doing good is at the core, rather than at the periphery, of their businesses.

Read the full story: knlg.net/1eumocX 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. vitold hennis professor of management here at the wharton school with lucy parker and john miller it's a
  2. real pleasure to have this opportunity to talk with both of you i really enjoyed reading your book
  3. recently on the topic the unlikely story about how big business can fix the world
  4. um can you speak a bit about the origins of the book uh i mean in this time of skepticism
  5. hostility towards big business uh where the profession of management has fallen even below lawyers
  6. in terms of its reputation according to a long-standing pube research poll what inspired you both
  7. individually and together to come together and write this book well i think the clues in the subtitle
  8. in a way the unlikely story of how big business can fix the world because you talk about big business to
  9. most people out there in the world and you get kind of a quite instant sort of allergic reaction
  10. often there's a very very deep-seated sort of suspicion and hostility towards big business and it's kind of easy to
  11. understand why i mean these big companies have a long history of crimes and misdemeanors which are
  12. well documented and everybody knows and it's great that people are holding them to account
  13. but i think for both of us in in different ways we had seen in our in our histories it's not the only story
  14. actually that big businesses can also be really powerful positive engines for social
  15. change and and it's a kind of missed opportunity for the world actually if the only story
  16. around is that big businesses are the bad guys and we missed the opportunity to harness
  17. that power and and direct it at some some positive change so the book is really targeted at the skeptics the the
  18. the activists the those who are critical uh or is it the sympathetic managers who
  19. are trying to affect this change who are you trying to reach both i think that um
  20. again going back to the title of the book everybody is the short answer but actually uh i think that the fact is
  21. that there's a world outside business that doesn't understand it that doesn't get it
  22. and as john was saying it felt to us as though there are a lot of things to describe a lot of
  23. things to see that businesses do that a lot of people never get to see and our working lives
  24. had given us the opportunity to see them so it felt as though we needed to tell those stories so that people who are not
  25. familiar with business could see them but there was also running in our heads i think the feeling that if you are in a
  26. big business and either doing this stuff or asking yourself the question how how does our business relate to this
  27. skepticism on the outside that it would be good if those people found themselves nodding for once and
  28. going yes that that is how we look at it that is how we act and that you wanted to show people on the inside of business
  29. how much they could do well the book follows the structure of bringing the reader along on a journey
  30. a personal journey a corporate journey in which executives from a number of leading multinationals coca-cola pepsi
  31. sab miller ibm unilever mahindra mtn so many companies um even mining companies which which people may
  32. be surprised at such as bhp and anglo-american um go on a journey of trying to affect
  33. social change in a profitable manner you referenced your own personal backgrounds and how did you meet these
  34. individuals how did you choose the protagonists for the chapters and where did you first learn about their
  35. journeys well i think that both of us have worked for a long time in the corporate
  36. universe and so we've for a long time known of some of these companies and i think that um there's also a
  37. leading pack of corporates really showing the way on this and we were turning to them and wanting to
  38. say when they're doing it well what does it look like when in no way arguing that all
  39. businesses act like this in fact part of the reason for writing it is to say if we could see more clearly
  40. what the ones who are doing it effectively are doing would it help make more of it happen
  41. so we were definitely turning to the leading corporates and then we were also asking can we be sure we've gone
  42. really across the sectors to show that this isn't something unique to any sector you mentioned mining
  43. a lot of people even said to us how can you have mining in a book about how business does good
  44. on the other hand virtually everything you know the equipment around us counts on mining so the question isn't
  45. do we need the industry or not the question is how can the industry act in a way that's
  46. positive for the world around it so that was the question we were asking of every single sector really
  47. but you're absolutely right to say it's uh it's a journey and i think we were very keen
  48. from the outset to to make sure that the the heroes of this book are the people in the companies
  49. actually because that's where the the real energy is and so often it's really easy to think
  50. of these big companies as these faceless monolithic kind of entities whereas they are just collections of of
  51. people and organizational structures and you know relationships and and that's that's
  52. where the change happens actually so we wanted to go and see what does it look like at the front line when
  53. these big companies are interacting with the communities around them when they're
  54. really tangling with the issues that are confronting them what is that actually like and what are
  55. those people going through what's their experiences and to bring that to life is what we've
  56. tried to do were you drawing on prior experience in the field with these companies or did you actually embark on
  57. your own journey around the world to some of these sites and communities to draw very much both uh i mean lucy and i
  58. both have seen this kind of independently in in our in our own histories i spent a lot of time out i was working
  59. for brands like coca-cola and spent a lot of time out in africa where i would almost expect to you know
  60. people would see coke as the as the bad guys actually you know these big massive global multinational um whereas
  61. actually you see i remember meeting a whole bunch of people at one point in ethiopia
  62. who were absolutely clear that you take a company like coca-cola that at that point had been in africa for about 80
  63. years very few institutions have invested over such a long time frame in africa have done more in terms of creating
  64. wealth through the supply chains through the working with the farmers through the
  65. distribution networks through training people in their their operations and i remember having
  66. some of these guys who worked for like the unicefs and save the childrens of this world saying
  67. these big companies can achieve more in a place like africa than many of the ngos actually
  68. and that was a shock to me at the time to to hear that and and that creating that loop in a way is
  69. partly why we've written the book to close that and interestingly one of the things that
  70. really comes across and i hope it comes across in the stories is that one of the startling things when
  71. you see it from inside a company is how detailed the work is this isn't conceptual theoretical work at the
  72. senior levels it needs senior endorsement but what actually happens is very detailed very on the ground
  73. very skilled and it takes people a long time and they're learning lessons as they go all the time
  74. so when you meet the people who are doing this you find yourself sort of just warming warming to the fact that
  75. they're working so hard at this and they're really trying to make change happen and
  76. you don't often hear that story told and you don't even hear it in books about social change which are very often
  77. conceptual so that's why we wanted to draw on the people i think i think that's a really interesting
  78. point i think it's amazing to think how few employees of the companies you're studying
  79. and how few customers actually know about the stories you're telling exactly why do you think the story
  80. hasn't been effectively told either by the protagonists you've interviewed and featured
  81. or more broadly by the external affairs the media affairs companies of the companies you're working with
  82. it's it's very powerful again both to customers and to employees and yet it's a largely untold story to
  83. some extent it's a news story i mean there's no doubt that you know business has got a long history of
  84. interacting with communities and there are lots of examples of you know self enlightened self-interest
  85. stretching back decades but actually what we're looking at with this book are very much a leading bunch of
  86. companies on a new edge of figuring out how do we really deal with society deal with
  87. all our relationships in the world to create the broadest possible set of positive outcomes
  88. and and that is is really a new story and i think the the headlines have been dominated by
  89. you know leaks and spills and uh you know tax avoidance and there's absolute litany
  90. of corporate you know wrongdoing and that's the story that people have that's what's in the public imagination
  91. this is an antidote to that but it's nascent um and i think the you know the reason for writing the
  92. book really is to try and and give that energy to try and put you know wind in the sails of that
  93. of that nascent movement and interestingly when we began to write it and you talk to people we're talking to
  94. loads of people because as you say we're working across sectors and right from the boardroom right out to the
  95. front line so we're talking about it all the time and one of the questions that would come
  96. from the skeptics as to use your language would be oh yes i know businesses do some
  97. good things but usually they're just on the side aren't they they're just peripheral
  98. and so the thing that's particularly new i think is the dialogue about how does a
  99. business take this way of interacting with the world into its core how do we reconnect the core of business
  100. to wider society and when john refers to them as leaders what makes them leaders is those are the
  101. companies experimenting with that so um then actually it's hardly a story to be told
  102. and a lot of companies who don't get this theme at all they may be in the headlines for the
  103. very drastic breaking of some kind of social contract and the historical methodology would
  104. have been to say but we are doing some good things over here almost like they're a trade-off
  105. and one of the things we're trying to write about is suppose we didn't buy that trade-off anymore suppose you
  106. actually asked yourself as a company why would we all of us look at you and go well broadly speaking that's that's a
  107. good thing that company is working in a positive way so we're trying to get beyond a sort of narrative
  108. that goes they're good they're evil they're good they're evil and go what direction of
  109. travel are they that's another of the images about journey really it doesn't happen all at once
  110. you have to start and then you have to keep moving so that this is a journey for the companies as well
  111. and we're trying to show that i think one of the constraints that many companies face is
  112. time horizons the different time horizons of investors of analysts and even of managers who are
  113. looking for their next promotion or their next lateral move and the payoffs from the strategies you're describing by
  114. bringing society into the core are often 5 10 maybe 20 years out creating an african middle class
  115. india rising new customers new products new services new technologies what what tools what
  116. processes have you seen in place to to focus attention on the longer term and avoid the short-term pressures at
  117. the individual or at the corporate level i think it's another reason that it's a new story
  118. because i think one of the reasons it's shaping up in the way it is is that the crash and all the fallout from that
  119. is actually opening a new conversation about long-term capitalism long-term shareholder value
  120. and it's not an accident that some of the industries that are leading in this are some of the
  121. most problematical industries that have had to forge an answer and also if you are a mining company or a
  122. big engineering company or a pharmaceutical company your horizon is longer so actually for
  123. the leading ceos there's quite um an opportunity in being able to talk to your shareholders about the long term
  124. again and about saying that some of these issues are about delivering strategic long-term value not short-term quarterly
  125. value you could think of it as think about license to operate and you look at an issue like water for example
  126. and you see the long term and the kind of immediate term collide completely so okay water's clearly a very long-term
  127. issue and managing water stewardship is a long-term question however then you get
  128. likes of coca-cola and pepsico almost kicked out of india overnight for their you know
  129. behaviour around water and the issues surrounded surrounding that so it wasn't a question
  130. of short-term long-term is this is a big issue that we need to address now and shareholders often understand it as
  131. risk management so in a mining company it'll be actually the non-technical risk social
  132. and political risk is maybe what's stopping your project so there is a marriage of these two themes
  133. but it will take a while well i noted that many of the stories many of the journeys
  134. begin with a crisis or a billion dollar loss uh do you think the companies who want
  135. to follow in the footsteps of these leaders who want to start their own journeys
  136. need a jolt that big do we really need a crisis a billion dollar loss deaths to to focus attention
  137. on broader societal issues if not what else separates the companies uh that are engaged in more superficial philanthropy
  138. on the side from those that are bringing it into the core it seems like crises and shocks are
  139. a big motivator yeah i mean there's no no doubt that a lot of the companies that we talk
  140. about who really are breaking new grounds in terms of the way they deal with environmental issues or in
  141. social relationships have been through i really think it's like a dark night of the soul they've had some terrible times
  142. and they've had to dig really deep and figure out who are we actually and how actually do
  143. we do do we do business um but i you know if if other companies want to wait until they have that moment fine i mean
  144. in the way we think of it in a way is what business is good at is changing actually and adapting
  145. and you know businesses that don't do that go extinct that's the nature of business actually and you know those
  146. companies are the leaders now are leaders because they had to adapt to some extreme situations that they found
  147. themselves in other businesses may learn from that and may get ahead of the game
  148. or they may wait until their own dark knight comes and visits them they'd be smarter to get ahead of it i
  149. think there's a new paradigm emerging though because short-term shareholder value is being so
  150. heavily questioned so if you what you're saying is does it need a jolt but like people sometimes a jolt is what
  151. it takes but actually there is a new paradigm emerging it when i started to advise corporates long
  152. time ago it was quite natural for a ceo to say the purpose of this company is to
  153. deliver shareholder value there are not many ceos that say that now and it's because actually people are
  154. beginning to realize that it does have to work for everybody shorthand for all stakeholders
  155. and so there is a new norm being created which is that you're really derelict in your
  156. duty unless you're understanding the long term and unless you're understanding the breadth of shareholder
  157. value uh stakeholder value so i think that there is a new norm arriving that may
  158. mean that not everybody has to go through that jolt to get that thought in their heads well so to give
  159. people a flavor of these kind of journeys but without diminishing the incentives to buy the book and read them
  160. in their full depth uh could you tell us about one journey and company that you contemplated
  161. including but maybe got left out that that had to be cut uh before the final version of the book
  162. wow what a good question gosh how can that stop us in our tracks because there's so much to say
  163. um there are lots of companies i think that we did wonder about walmart um because um that's
  164. an amazing company in sense of its sheer scale and that for so many people it's the villain of the piece and a
  165. picture of the problem and for many people who begin to understand how companies change
  166. a lot of people step back quite surprised at the degree to which they've taken this
  167. whole approach on and so they're right at the center of the debate about how much can this be at the heart of
  168. uh modern capitalism and i think one of the other reasons they're so interesting
  169. is they're so big and a lot of the argument we're making is the reason big business is such a
  170. powerful act of a change is that they have the scale to make change so we would have been interested to
  171. continue the story with walmart i think so if individual managers or students want to get their companies to embrace
  172. this sort of change what should they do for students what skills are important for them to acquire
  173. or build within a company how do you press an influence strategy to embrace these kind of initiatives or if
  174. contemplating a career shift uh what sort of companies should people be choosing to work for
  175. i think um i mean we we have a uh a couple of sort of frames of reference if you like
  176. that for people starting to think about this area um i think provide a really useful way
  177. of thinking what are we actually talking about when we're talking about the role of a business in society and
  178. in the book we uh we have this model we call the prism uh which essentially is when you're talking
  179. about a business in the world and the effects it can have what you're talking about generally is
  180. one of five things so you're talking about the purpose that a company has the sense
  181. of purposefulness that it acts with you're talking about the products you know what does it actually
  182. sell and you're talking about the practices that it has to that it uses to you know
  183. take those products to market to manufacture them to distribute them and any philanthropy that a company
  184. chooses to undertake and and then we've got um the point of view of a company so what does it
  185. actually think about the big issues that are that are really relevant to it and and we've suggested that
  186. really because it can be a kind of daunting and kind of complex and slightly vague area with all of these
  187. terms kind of you know hitting into each other and this model via the prism we think is just a quite
  188. simple way of looking at what are we actually talking about when we're talking about
  189. the role of a business in society there is a um there is a allegedness actually still in the language around
  190. this so a lot of the time for the mainstream sort of world of business you talk about
  191. the words like sustainability and responsibility and citizenship and and you know important great these these
  192. all come from very good places but there's a large amount of the business world that just switches off
  193. when they hear those words and what they hear is this is about trade-off this is about
  194. this a cost center basically um and what we're trying to say really is that this is an opportunity
  195. actually for business um and for the world and that's a different way of looking at
  196. it so to get out of that mentality and so to think of the role a business plays in society
  197. is is really the the key i think to getting started and if you're saying what should you do
  198. either as a manager or somebody wondering whether to join a business one of the other things we talk a lot
  199. about is get outside the business you know this is about reconnecting business to society against that
  200. prejudice against that stereotype that business is the problem not the solution so actually for a lot
  201. of people trying to make change in their businesses almost the simplest thing is get some of
  202. your people outside the business and one of the really common themes of the great stories is that somebody in
  203. there has had the imagination to take people at all levels of the business right outside it
  204. and look at the way it acts in the world and look at the big challenges that bother everybody in the world
  205. and ask themselves what is our business to that can we help and if you put together the
  206. prison with the question can we help you get pretty close to a way of acting so another component of
  207. the book is these 11 conversations um that you you draw upon a number of different reports from the united
  208. nations the world economic forum and look at 11 areas of sort of issued areas in which companies can contribute almost
  209. every company you examine though touches on multiple areas if not all of them so how do they choose which
  210. one is core to them which one should they focus on in their initiatives and embrace
  211. and which stakeholders should they listen to in making those difficult choices because at some level there is
  212. still a trade-off that you can't have dozens of initiatives you need to bring this into the core and
  213. focus and each company seems to have made a choice on one two or three of the conversations
  214. but if again if i'm a manager how do i choose which one the extraordinary thing is that it
  215. almost makes itself if you're asking where can we be most helpful where are we most relevant and
  216. uh certainly the 11 conversations are for us like a sort of landscape of the problems
  217. in the world that people really worry about and if you show that to any top figure in business they'll look at
  218. it and like you said they'll kind of go here here here and if you go but if you really could make the biggest difference
  219. i've never known anybody not go it's here and here and then actually you you aim the
  220. resources the skills the expertise the imagination of your business at those areas where you have
  221. greatest relevance and greatest power to change and it's a fun conversation to have with
  222. with businesses actually people get really into oh we're relevant to that one and to that one answer and before
  223. you know it as you say they're relevant to all of them but actually something rises to the
  224. top really that gets the energy but actually the really important thing about the 11 conversations
  225. is not playing that game but actually the attitude shift that underlies it because really what
  226. we're saying is you know the old model of the way a big business interacted with
  227. the world was very much you know messaging focus it's like what do we have to say and what are the issues that
  228. we need to manage and it was a really defensive crouch basically and what the 11 conversations is saying
  229. is get outside of it you know what are the what are the issues in the world that everybody is
  230. worried about you know what are the the challenges that we're all facing and what do we have as a
  231. business that could be relevant to that that could make us part of that solution so it's more more
  232. than anything else it's just about shifting the perspective well thank you both for for taking the
  233. time and uh i really enjoyed reading the journeys i really enjoyed the time to discuss
  234. them and learning more about how the book came together it's really been a pleasure
  235. thank you you

Brief Summary

Lucy Parker and John Miller discuss how big businesses can positively impact society despite skepticism and challenges.

Key points

  • The Unlikely Story of Business. Exploring how big business can be a force for good in the world.
  • A New Narrative for Corporations. The book aims to shift the focus from corporate wrongdoing to positive contributions.
  • Transformative Journeys of Companies. Many companies have undergone significant changes after facing crises.
  • The Role of Business in Society. Exploring how businesses can shift their perspective to become part of the solution.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes