Corporations Are People Too - or Are They?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Corporations should not have all of the rights accorded to people, says Eric W. Orts, Wharton professor of ethics and legal studies.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1pGbpPy 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're speaking today with eric ortz a professor of legal studies and business ethics at wharton
  2. about his new book released in september here uh titled business persons a legal
  3. theory of the firm thanks for joining us today eric you're welcome i'm happy to be here
  4. um a book covers a lot of ground but i think today i'd like to focus on a couple of
  5. specific ideas in the book that were very interesting one has to do with executive compensation
  6. and the second has to do with the citizens united supreme court case which uh gave corporations the right to spend
  7. i think unlimited amounts in on political groups and campaigns and candidates and that kind of thing
  8. um so based on the citizen united decision um corporations are people too right or or are they well that's one of
  9. the uh that's one of the main questions that i try to answer in the book or at least
  10. lucidate so the title of the book is called business persons and what i mainly argue in much of the
  11. book is that corporations are persons but that doesn't mean that they're people and therefore as the majority of the
  12. supreme court said they have all of the rights apparently that people do persons not people
  13. yeah so now it's interesting because actually people are persons in legal terms as well and so we don't treat all
  14. people equally either so infants are treated differently than adults aliens are treated differently than
  15. citizens slavery was a big issue for many years until rights were accorded to uh to every
  16. person without without any discrimination so so the idea of legal persons is quite a
  17. deep and difficult idea in the law in general and what i try to talk about in the book
  18. is how businesses are persons and really it wouldn't make any sense to think of them not as persons or it
  19. would cause a radical revolution in how we how we act every day so businesses own
  20. property and they have rights to protect that property businesses are constructed and have legal rights to
  21. of standing to uh protect those who are working in the business so in that sense
  22. uh businesses can be said to represent people and people represent businesses uh there's some things they can't do
  23. right they can't they can't vote that's correct there's some there are some rights that we clear
  24. that clearly corporations do not have uh it's not possible to put a business in jail though it's possible to put people
  25. who are acting on behalf of businesses in jail and there's a debate in the law about
  26. whether companies uh and other businesses should be criminally uh criminally culpable so some countries
  27. say it doesn't make any sense to put it to say a company could be uh committing a crime
  28. the united states that's different and we uh currently have the sac capital case
  29. or the sac company uh uh case where uh your uh that rate that cut that that issue is being raised
  30. so uh so yeah the so there are many different kinds of questions and with respect
  31. to the citizens united case what i argue is uh that the court really both sides of
  32. the opinion both both sides of the supreme court uh decision in citizens united i think do not go
  33. deeply enough into the question of what does it mean to say that corporations are persons and
  34. then once you start thinking about that you might come to a better answer than either yes they do have all these rights
  35. or no they don't have any rights so you disagree with the supreme court's decision
  36. and um actually i disagree with both both the majority decision and the minority decision so i'm
  37. sure we have popular a popular argument let's start with the majority decision um they went too far they gave away too
  38. many rights to i think the majority decision basically doesn't go into the question
  39. very carefully by saying well look here are all these cases in which we have found corporations to have
  40. rights as persons therefore they have rights for political speech now it might make sense to give
  41. corporations rights for political speech in some some context but on the other hand it
  42. might not and so uh there are questions that are raised in the descent for example that for many
  43. years have been a question of if companies get too involved in politics isn't there going to be a corruption
  44. problem where companies are only going to be supporting issues and candidates that are going to
  45. benefit them is that really is the public interest really going to result in the best laws
  46. that way restrictions is that because they would have an outsized amount of um money to well it's partly
  47. that's another argument another argument is that uh and justice stevens and dissent raises this
  48. argument as well is that there will be too much influence if you allow companies into politics
  49. the other argument though is a corruption argument and that is it's clear that there are some
  50. limitations so almost everyone agrees that bribery should not be allowed you shouldn't be allowed to go to congress
  51. and say hey i'll give you this much money if you vote in this way that's clearly
  52. illegal what's not so clear is what about these grayer areas where you have campaign financing and other
  53. and campaigns in general where you have to various organizations active in trying to inform public opinion
  54. and what is the legitimate role of business in that process my god my my feeling is
  55. that there's probably a gray area where sometimes you want to have the public informed about issues that
  56. business is going to be closest at knowing about and they should have a right to be talking about those issues
  57. on the other hand when it's sliding over into a question of potential corruption
  58. or potential uh distortion of the process then i think justice stevens has a good
  59. argument now on the other hand i think the dissent goes too far by saying corporations are not people therefore
  60. they're not persons therefore we can do any kind of regulation whatsoever if we follow that argument to its
  61. logical extreme we'd have a lot of problems also for example can a company protect its own property
  62. that a lot of property in the united states and the western world in general is uh is in corporations is technically
  63. and legally owned by those corporations so this is so to say that they would have no constitutional right of property
  64. uh or to protect that their property would seem to override all the individual people's interests in that
  65. property i mean do you think that's what the dissent was suggesting or you're simply saying that's the logic well i
  66. think that's the logic of the dissent doesn't really uh parse where you're going to draw a
  67. line here and i think that that was a weakness of the dissenting opinion so you're going
  68. to see this issue i think it's not going to be disappearing after citizens united
  69. you're going to continue to have this kind of question raised so there's a lot of um i mean
  70. you could imagine a lot of different kinds of cases that would that would be in the middle is there any sort of
  71. practical way to think about this what makes sense what doesn't just as a you know
  72. an average person looking at what seems fair um well one suggestion i make in the book
  73. is that maybe both sides can come to what president gutman has called a spirit of
  74. compromise and uh her recent book she talks about there are cases that people remember cases
  75. where democrats and republicans actually agree on things in past legislation president guttmann being
  76. the president of the university of diversity right but i but i argue that one example here should be although it isn't
  77. presently that everyone should i think agree that if companies are contributing money uh to
  78. political campaigns or uh or or making political advertisement advertisements it should be disclosed that that's
  79. happening now some people's uh there are there are people who argue against that but i think that would be
  80. uh at least one step in the right direction of having some transparency in the process and there are privately
  81. there are some groups that are arguing for political accountability there are shareholder groups who are
  82. trying to get companies to do this many companies do this on their own and many companies actually have decided
  83. just to opt out of this whole process so just because the supreme court says companies have a right to be involved in
  84. politics a lot of companies don't decide not to get involved in politics because you might just
  85. get everyone angry at you and that's no way to sell your products requiring companies to disclose how much
  86. they're giving and who they're giving it to seems like a reasonable thing but that's actually
  87. not required under the current law what what are the arguments against that well i think someone who takes a very
  88. strong view that corporations have political rights and they're the same as any individual
  89. adult might say well individual adults don't have to have to disclose this sort of thing so
  90. you can vote in its secret for example but i think that the reasons that we allow that sort of nondisclosure for
  91. example secret balloting don't apply when you're when you are talking about problems of potential corruption or
  92. distortion of the political process i think at the end of the day most political scientists or others who
  93. look at what democracy is about would say that mainly it's voters that should decide and that means individual
  94. human beings no one is arguing that corporations have a right to vote for example
  95. stevens makes a lot of that in his dissent so clearly we have to some kinds of restrictions are obviously
  96. appropriate and this seems to me to be one that might start to put the put the put some balance into
  97. the system you

Brief Summary

Eric Ortz discusses corporate personhood and the implications of the Citizens United decision on politics and executive compensation.

Key points

  • Business Persons: A Legal Theory. Eric Ort discusses his book exploring the legal status of corporations as persons.
  • The Citizens United Case. Ort critiques the Supreme Court's decision on corporate political spending rights.
  • Transparency in Political Contributions. A call for companies to disclose political donations to enhance accountability.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes