Will Robot Journalists Replace Human Ones?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Innovation

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guest today is noam lemastricht lattar dean of the sami ofer school of communication
  2. at the interdisciplinary center in herzeglia israel we are going to speak to him about what
  3. the robot journalists will replace human ones noam thank you so much for speaking with us today it's
  4. a pleasure to be here again with you marco what a provocative topic you have written about
  5. in your paper what what exactly is robot journalism well you know that the computers have
  6. helped journalists to write story to write to find facts since the since the middle of last
  7. century there was what we call data mining and analytics data analytics which helped journalists to find find
  8. the facts and do investigative journalism so this is not new what is now developing is that there are new
  9. programs artificial intelligence programs who actually get the facts and within fraction of a second write
  10. the story instead of the human journalists so this is the second part of the puzzle which really today uh
  11. there are stories uh written in forbes in in other news magazines that are untouched by
  12. human human journalists we have in a very freak very quickly once there is an event or facts and
  13. effects are being found the program the artificial program writes the story and the the name of the journalist is
  14. really the name of a robot there's a company called narrative science in illinois who
  15. actually already doing it and collected quite a lot of money for their as investors so is this a new
  16. phenomenon or has this been around for a while didn't your research at mit in the 1970s
  17. actually predict some of this no i in my research predicted the use of touch screens
  18. uh which were later used by steve jobs and i did the first really studies on interactive television
  19. where we studied how providing people in the television studio providing them with
  20. devices similar to what today you can use the touch phones and they provide feedback and i studied
  21. how allowing publics to to feedback during to provide feedback during the discussion
  22. how it affected the group dynamics and the discussion dynamics we did not predict at the time robot
  23. journalism at all actually data mining is quite quite uh it has developed in the past
  24. 20 years so how pervasive is robot journalism it's still it's still in the initial
  25. stages uh because the the programs are really starting in 2010 but they are they're doing
  26. very quick penetration and because the robot journalist has some real advantages
  27. first of all he never forgets facts he can do research very quickly he never asked for a day off and he can
  28. write a story with within seconds so that the event that the facts have been they don't discovered deadlines and if
  29. you write the program correctly he doesn't he's not even biased as you know most journalists are biased about about
  30. the stories but the robot journalist if he programmed correctly can be completely
  31. unbiased so he never forgets anything for example there was an earthquake in california
  32. and a robot journalist wrote the story when the name of the journalist that appeared in the story was already asleep
  33. los angeles times by the way is using this kind of robotic storage writers for quite a while
  34. how fast is it growing and what are the factors driving the growth this is a good question the the echo the
  35. ecosystem which really promotes this uh this uh robotic journalism is of course the uh the new the
  36. multimedia uh type of the development of multimedia multi-platforms the the slow disappearance of the print
  37. it you really basically a question of costs you know that advertising money today shifts towards
  38. from the print media to the to the internet and because the the robotic journalists
  39. are very very cheap very efficient very quick and because of the economics considerations
  40. i i trust that the robotic journalism will grow very fast you know there's a next next
  41. month there's a big convention uh a journalist convention in the city of philadelphia in israel
  42. about 2000 journalists come down to a lot and i wrote the story that it's a future
  43. story for this convention about robot journalism and the editor of the booklet that it is this printing for this
  44. convention wrote me you know norm this is great because now the journalists will have to start
  45. working when they will see the threat of this robotic journalist that they can really
  46. analyze facts very quickly and write the story very quickly it will force them into becoming innovative to do more
  47. in-depth thinking more in-depth research so the the optimists view this entry of
  48. robotic journalism as a new era where where really good zonialist will not disappear but they will be
  49. forced to really think again how they can be innovative how can they be more in-depth
  50. analysis so it depends how you see the cuff how full of empty uh i think it will improve
  51. the threat of robotic journalism it will be there i i guarantee that in any newspaper electronic
  52. newspaper or print newspaper that you will purchase in the coming years a major part of the stories will be
  53. written by robotic journalists but still people will seek human journalists because they always
  54. have hopefully you will have this added added value added innovation added perspective
  55. so i don't i see it as a positive force in improving future journalism so since you mentioned costs
  56. i wonder what sort of a sort of business model uh can be uh put around this kind of
  57. journalism well you know that i wrote in the paper and it's a good question because i foresee
  58. the new the new leaders of the newsrooms will not be the experienced journalists
  59. with the pipe but will be the the the computer engineers and just the other day on october 17th
  60. salzburg salzburger i hope i say it correctly the the publisher of new york times was
  61. asked with insight what what do you have done in light of this digital development in media and he said i would
  62. hire more engineers so i do see uh tremendous saving in costs in future newsrooms that are going to be
  63. fully automatic uh but and really the leaders will be those journalists geeks who will
  64. understand in media and will know how to use data mining and will know how to add value to what
  65. the robot journalists can do but it's going to be very efficient in another another aspect of it today we are going
  66. into in targeted advertising so the robot journalist will be able not only to write a story
  67. but it will be able to immediately send it to mochal if he knows that mogul is interested
  68. in certain type of information so we we have here a complete automation of news gathering news
  69. analysis news writing story writing and targeting of of the information uh that's fascinating to what extent do
  70. social media platforms like facebook or twitter or linkedin factor into this phenomenon
  71. well the social media social networks uh help spread the word uh of these all these new developments
  72. today you know with especially with twitter uh once there are good efficient robotic
  73. journalists in operation the these social networks will spread the word very very quickly so it will expedite
  74. the development of these processes with a via facebook i think i'm a more pessimistic about facebook
  75. because i think it will probably if it will not change uh the way it is today it will probably
  76. disappear in fair in favor of the twittering the twitter kind of systems which also developed
  77. into the video uh today i i i think i'm i'm on facebook i haven't looked at my facebook
  78. page i think for the past two weeks because it's always loaded with information loaded with dogs and friends
  79. and everybody is helping traveling all over europe and all over america and i'm the
  80. only one who's working and so so i think the the present the present structure of facebook
  81. will have to change but twitter is in the right direction quick to the point so social networks will spread the word of
  82. of robotic journalism very quickly how much of robot journalism do you see in israel today the israeli
  83. media not much because the writing of the the software the to write the stories and to do the data mining is quite an
  84. expensive israeli more is in the direction of developing startups which uh point the direction to this new
  85. new software new new artificial intelligence techniques but then this the startups
  86. are being sold to american companies or european so israel is in more in developing the the seed
  87. of these innovations but to make it into a large scale so far israel has not been very
  88. successful in taking small ideas and really making them large scale so the media the media in the media and
  89. israel is a very very sad situation it's controlled by government controlled by politics
  90. by by by rich people by capital and the israeli media today is uh nothing to to write home about
  91. it's quite sad yeah i agree uh well i'm going to ask two or three questions wearing the hat
  92. of a human journalist okay so i'll try i'll try to answer as a human as a human professor
  93. so one of the things that i think a lot of successful journalists share is i think they have three qualities
  94. the first is they have relentless curiosity the second is they have an innate skepticism
  95. especially about pr and the third is that they have the ability to tell stories simply and clearly in a way that
  96. it can be understood by a large number of people do you think these are functions that can be
  97. automated sorry to say but yes all right so a curiosity what the first one was innate skepticism
  98. curiosity skepticism and storytelling curiosity uh data mining and and software which
  99. does data mining on huge data silos uh is really the ultimate expression of curiosity
  100. you know in my article i tell about this young ladies from israel who is declared by the mit
  101. technology review as a one of the future scientists who discovered that if in the
  102. rural area in a poor area if you have one year you have drought to be followed the
  103. following year with a flood then the third year probably will be an outbreak of cholera okay a journalist
  104. with a high curiosity and she accomplished that by looking over huge amount of data
  105. a human journalist cannot cannot have this ability to scan over huge amounts of data
  106. but it was a human researcher who made those connections she wrote the program now this program can go to other data
  107. sealers and discover other things i think i said before i don't see the the best human
  108. journalists disappear but the robots journalists will force people uh like you mochal
  109. to be on the toes and to be more curious and to do more skepticism is one value which
  110. uh it can be translated to statistics and even a good program can be skeptic about the results and
  111. study it but i see i don't i go back what i said before i don't see good journalists disappear
  112. but i see good journalists doing better job in in line of what you have described
  113. as skepticism curiosity i see it i see fewer journalists but better ones in light of robotic journalism and this
  114. is what wrote me the guy who who wrote the who's the publisher of the booklet for
  115. the conference he said norm i'm glad you wrote this article it will force journalists
  116. to start becoming alive again you vocal i'm sorry to say represent a minority of journalists who write today
  117. journalists today most journalists and i'm saying it is the dean of school of communication
  118. most journalists are quite lazy you have to provide them with a story you have to buy them with
  119. information and they they publish it under their name and they don't even go out to do
  120. investigative journalism investigative journalism is risky it's costly it's dangerous and fewer and
  121. fewer people are doing it robotic journalings where robotic journalism i hope will bring this to life again
  122. right the the other one quality and this is more for editors and for reporters uh is the is that editors
  123. exercise editorial judgment uh and i wonder how robot journalists fit into that category also well you
  124. know google news google news were the first in i think 2002 uh have developed this uh google news
  125. that crawled today over 27 000 news sources and they say they have pro they wrote the program a how to exercise
  126. judgment they take an event for example and they can study what is the the probability of this event or caring
  127. they they bring they take the criteria that good editors are exercising and they put
  128. it into the programs it's like a good chess player the a good chess program will never study
  129. and will never improve itself by by by gaming against a weak a weak partner so what the people who write these programs
  130. go to the best editors they they follow their best practices and interview them and they they tried
  131. to write the program to ask the same questions that a good editor would ask so in conclusion let's end with the
  132. question that we asked at the beginning can robot journalists replace human journalists
  133. what the answer i'm getting from you is yes but not completely yes but not completely but there is one
  134. pessimistic angle to this robotic journalism from point of view of economics is very efficient
  135. and a very good journalist would be quite quite expensive and i fear that economic considerations
  136. among in the news media board of directors could force more and more the new media organization to go into
  137. robotics because of the cost advantages uh as a human being i i hope that at least a certain portion of every
  138. media in the future will be run by by high quality journalists that will will make sure that the human
  139. journalist is always better than the robot journalist but it is a hope well maybe someday uh both human
  140. journalists and human professors uh will become better and robot journalists and robot professors
  141. will do the work that humans don't want to do norm thank you so much for joining
  142. us today thank you it's a pleasure michael thank you very much and i hope you continue with your good journalistic
  143. work thank you the human journalistic work thank you you

Brief Summary

Noam Lemastriht Lattar discusses the rise of robot journalism and its impact on human journalists.

Key points

  • The Rise of Robot Journalism. Noam Lemastricht discusses how AI is transforming journalism, making it faster and more efficient.
  • Impact on Human Journalists. Robotic journalism is seen as a force that will push human journalists to innovate and improve.
  • Future of Newsrooms. The future of newsrooms may see computer engineers leading the way instead of traditional journalists.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes