The Rebirth of U.S. Manufacturing

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

πŸ“‚ Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Hal thank you so much for joining us today a pleasure to be with you
  2. mle so would love to talk to you about uh your research in the area of the Renaissance of uh American
  3. manufacturing uh but before we get into that I wanted to ask you about the conventional view the conventional view
  4. is that Manufacturing in the US is on a long-term decline services are going up what's wrong with that picture well it's
  5. just not true uh that the fundamental uh perspective that people have on manufacturing is changing and and we've
  6. seen this prediction of us manufacturing's death many many times uh if you go back to the 1970s when I was
  7. here at wardon um we're reading articles all the time about how Japan Inc was going to take over the world uh they're
  8. going to bring over televisions cars radios and they were going to manufacture just about
  9. everything at that point in time parents were literally sending their kids to school to learn Japanese because that
  10. was going to be the new language of the world you know Japan which had lost the war in 1945 by 1975 was going to
  11. dominate the world again uh and of course what we've seen is that didn't happen that didn't happen because the US
  12. responds as an economy we saw it again in the 1980s when and '90s when uh the Asian tigers were going
  13. to dominate the world uh the lowcost production facilities in Korea and Taiwan and Hong Kong uh and Singapore
  14. were going to dominate uh manufacturing uh there was a going to be a huge cost advantage and US manufacturing was going
  15. to go away but of course everybody knows that didn't happen either and in the current situation
  16. starting in 2001 with China's entering the WTO the conventional wisdom is the same that China was going to roll up us
  17. manufacturing and that we were basically going to become the farmers and bankers
  18. of the world and that was what was left uh but of course in many ways as we're starting to see now that hasn't happened
  19. and it's not going to happen it's because the US economy responds tremendously well to threats we have a
  20. system where our people want to work uh and they find ways to do this we have a system in which our companies are forced
  21. to get more productive uh because it's do or die there is state-owned companies in this country uh we don't subsidize
  22. companies in many ways in this country and therefore it's the free market at work and it does some amazing things so
  23. between 1972 we and and 2010 we manufactured 2.5 times as much manufactured goods um at
  24. that over that period we do that with 30% less labor which is an amazing increase in productivity our society has
  25. gotten incredibly productive we use our resources very efficiently and that makes all the difference
  26. and that's what's going to cause the change uh as we start to move from offshoring to China to insourcing around
  27. the world the uh come back to the point about ins sourcing in a bit uh but let's
  28. talk about your point about productivity first um uh as as you said we are able to produce as productivity goes up we
  29. able to produce more with fewer people but at the same time there are some recent reports that manufacturing jobs
  30. in the US have actually gone up 300,000 new manufactur uring jobs in the past two years what's driving this trend it's
  31. basic economics it's now becoming more effective to produce in the US than is to Bruce in a lot of different countries
  32. between the shift in the dollar and the incredibly rapid rise in wages in China uh people are starting to do this now in
  33. a report we predicted that this would not happen until 2015 uh we're surprised in a very good way because we're
  34. starting to see it happen in 2010 2011 and 2012 um now we think this is just the
  35. tip of the iceberg that we're that we're going to see a whole lot more because the economics continue to shift in favor
  36. of the US the fundamentals are the tide has turned as it did with Japan as it did with the Asian tigers we're seeing a
  37. repeat of this with China uh what are some of the factors that have driven the Turning of the tide what it's very
  38. simple economics it's the things I learned in my uh intro economics class of warten just applied for uh just
  39. applied for overall business uh it is wages are rising very quickly in China somewhere on the order of 15 to 20% a
  40. year and maybe even higher um wages uh the R&B of course uh which is still a controlled currency is rising at 4% a
  41. year uh and uh many economists believe if it was left to float it would be double its in value but even with the 4%
  42. it makes a difference and China while it's getting very productive and it's increasing productivity at 8% a year
  43. that's being swamped by the wage increases in the shift in the R&B and so when it was uh in in 2001 when China
  44. entered the WTO you could get uh workers for 58 cents an hour it was a very simple decision for most companies to
  45. Offshore to China wages have risen a lot uh there's all sorts of other issues that uh are that people call the
  46. intangibles that go there uh things like uh you don't want to just compare manufacturing cost to manufacturing cost
  47. because you have to ship it from China and uh in 2001 oil prices were in the $230 a barrel now it's around $100 a
  48. barrel so Transportation costs have gone up people are understanding the risks of
  49. intellect ual property theft and valuing them in their equations and then there just the fundamentals of being far away
  50. from the customer it's hard to manufacture when you're 6,000 miles away and you have to interact with people who
  51. don't speak your language natively and so companies are starting to realize that there are a whole bunch of costs
  52. and our predictions are that by 2015 the the manufactured cost in China will be about 10% lower than the manufactured
  53. cost in the US for a whole lot of goods that doesn't mean all the goods it's not
  54. it's not for clothing and shoes but it's for wide range of goods about 70% of the
  55. goods that we with that we the United States imports from China and because of that uh we're going to see a shift
  56. because that 10% is going to be eaten down by things like the transportation costs and the other risks and it'll just
  57. make more sense to produce in the US and companies are starting to turn on to this uh speaking about uh the wage cost
  58. increase in China uh at least a few years ago it was widely believed that even though in some Urban centers or a
  59. strong Manufacturing centers like sanzhen uh the wage costs are going up that there was a large rural uh
  60. Workforce in China that would continue to migrate uh and that would keep the the ultimately bring uh wage cost down
  61. in China there was a common view uh do you still see that happening or are there changes that have taken place that
  62. takes that away wages are rising very rapidly and China actually was extremely smart in how it set up its economy uh it
  63. was brilliant um and in fact I would have to call it like the reverse Perfect Storm everything was done right uh they
  64. set up these clusters of companies so that you can you know if you're in making shoes and you're we would be
  65. located in one city if you're making Electronics you may be located in a different city and then what they put in
  66. those clusters was everything the businesses needed to produce for export so there were universities that would
  67. produce Engineers that were trained specifically in your kind of business there are worker training centers where
  68. they train workers for production in your kind of business they set up incredible ports and amazing um ability
  69. to produce you know high quality ports that they could export from and all the infrastructure that's necessary to get
  70. it from the ports in these clusters which were of course designed for export and therefore all along the coastline
  71. wages Rose a lot there a lot of uh uh of the rural people moved into the cities but now it's getting pretty crowded when
  72. you go further out into China there are some disadvantages of production the infrastructure isn't the same as you see
  73. on the coast which is what one of the reasons that China has been so productive so the workforce in the rural
  74. areas aren't as productive uh and the transportation times get long and you've already starting with a long
  75. Transportation time to export to the us so that that raises a lot of issues as well as to how long you want your supply
  76. chain what are some of the other factors that you think are are are making it possible for us companies to become more
  77. competitive in manufacturing well I think that we continue to focus on productivity of our Workforce uh we are
  78. growing productivity quite nicely uh not at 8% year but at a substantial rate um
  79. and and US companies are beginning to realize there's some problems with producing far away that there are actual
  80. costs to that I remember one CEO when he worked out the economics said the best thing it was for him was that his wife
  81. wouldn't bother him at 2 o'clock in the morning because he was on the phone and he didn't have to fly 6,000 mil to go
  82. see his Factory uh and that's a intangible but it's real and it points out you know the value of being close
  83. when wages were 58 cents an hour when China entered the WTO uh it was a very simple decision to go to China cuz they
  84. were so low but those wages have gone up dramatically and they continue to go up
  85. dramatically and now it's not such a simple decision uh and companies are beginning to rethink it and we expect
  86. over the next few years there'll be a lot of rethinking because manufacturing the US is becoming very
  87. competitive uh are could you uh give any examples of companies that are you know
  88. driving this Renaissance in manufacturing and what are some of the kinds of jobs that are coming back well
  89. there there's a lot of companies that are doing it again I think we're still in the early stages you see big
  90. companies like National Cash Register NCR uh that was manufacturing their ATMs in China for the US is now Manufacturing
  91. in Columbus Georgia you see Ford uh adding jobs into uh its plants I think they committed to 12,000 jobs uh and you
  92. see companies like U uh General Electric uh adding uh capacity uh to produce water heaters in their Louisville
  93. Kentucky plant and it's also smaller company so Farooq uh systems which makes hair dryers has moved to I think 1500
  94. jobs back from China to the US uh you see uh Coleman the manufacturer of water coolers starting to build water coolers
  95. in the US and I can go on and on and on with a list um and every day we seem to find more and more companies that have
  96. made the decision because they're realizing the total cost of manufacturing in China with the wages
  97. being higher and all the other intangible issues are starting to make it just far more economic for more more
  98. logical to do this now some people may think that means factories will close in China and that's not going to happen
  99. that's not going to happen because of the way the Chinese economy is structured China's growing 8 10 12% a
  100. year China actually needs to build more factories just to support the domestic demand so it's not about companies
  101. making decisions to close a plant in China ironically it's the fact that the Chinese economy is growing so rapidly
  102. that makes a possible for us companies to very quickly build plants in the US because they need to put another plant
  103. in their system and they can just convert their domestic Chinese their plant that they used to ship from uh
  104. China to the the stuff they used to ship from China to the US to domestic consumption in China and then just build
  105. the plant in the United States so ironically China's success is what's causing this manufacturing Renaissance
  106. that's very very interesting now as we know the IMF predicted some time ago by 2016 China will overtake the us as the
  107. world's largest economy uh in purchasing power parity terms uh do you see that having a significant
  108. impact on this trend or do you think uh uh the rise of manufacturing would continue regardless of which economy is
  109. larger I mean the US is still a very big economy and and you know even if China is is bigger in purchasing parody in
  110. absolute terms the US will be bigger for even longer period of time but I don't think it it matters whether the US is
  111. bigger or China is bigger uh they're both huge economies uh and both significant portions of the total world
  112. GDP uh and so they both will have scale and the ability to produce and I think that's what's really
  113. required as as I'm listening to you H I was very counterintuitive kind of ideas how did you figure this all out so this
  114. came to me from a a a wide set of areas uh the first thing that uh we I figured out was in discussions with some of my
  115. colleagues in China was they were talking about the wage increases in China being 15 to 20% a year and that
  116. made no sense to me didn't make it it didn't feel right but we looked into it of course they were right uh wages are
  117. rising at 15 to 20% a year um it came to me uh when my wife said the US doesn't manufacture anything anymore my wife has
  118. a also a degree from the University of Pennsylvania and a PhD molecular genetics so she's a very smart woman but
  119. she um looked at the conventional wisdom and it's easy to believe that if you look at things like clothing and shoes
  120. but the US manufactures 75% of everything that it consumes and that's a pretty high number uh considering what
  121. the conventional wisdom is that we don't make anything anymore and it came to me
  122. sitting in a board meeting one of my clients in which they have around 80% of their Manufacturing in China and they
  123. needed to do build build a new plant so they decided they would make it 85% of their manufacturing would be in China
  124. and I just raised the question what is it that do you really want to have all that Manufacturing in
  125. China aren't their Alternatives and so we looked at lots of other countries we looked at Vietnam we looked at Indonesia
  126. uh we looked at many different countries and for a lar I put in a plant in in the
  127. unit southern part of the United States just to see if it would work and we did the math in 2010 of course it didn't
  128. work because the wages have haven't sort of reached their full potential uh in China of rising but we then did the math
  129. and said what does it look like in 2015 because plants are going to last for 20 30 40 50 years so deciding now on
  130. today's economics doesn't make a lot of sense so we just said let's pick 2015 what does it look like and we did the
  131. math and the difference was less than 10% at the manufacturing Gates of a US plant or of a Chinese Plant and then the
  132. decision was to say let's understand what the transportation costs and all the intangibles when they looked at it
  133. they said you know it does make more sense to produce in the United States that that's really interesting
  134. now coming back to your earlier point about being trying to be close to where your customers are uh it's also a
  135. reality that consumption is growing very rapidly in the Emerging Markets uh from that perspective uh do you think
  136. that uh it makes sense for companies not just to set up manufacturing the us but
  137. also to where those emerging customers are and and have Manufacturing in different parts of the world yeah I I I
  138. think what we're talking about is more localized manufacturing if you're going to consume the product or you're going
  139. to sell the product in the US you want to produce more of it in the US if you're going to produce if you're going
  140. to sell the product in China or an Emerging Market you probably want to produce there because some of the
  141. factors that make the difference are the transportation costs and if you're selling in China it's probably better to
  142. have your plant in China because you're closer to the customer for the same reason the US would be the case or
  143. Europe would be the case to do that it's just the economics of China and the US are getting a lot closer well that
  144. hasn't happened in Europe yet which Industries do you think are the best positioned to benefit from the
  145. manufacturing Renaissance so it's things like computers and electronics um it's Furniture right which is becoming a you
  146. know obviously a lot of wood produced in the US so it's a great thing uh it's things like Plastics and rubber and
  147. Machinery uh its appliances and electronic equipment uh there's about 70% of what we import from China uh that
  148. is in the area that we call the Tipping Zone that are the kinds of products that
  149. you need to think carefully about where you put your next Plant because the US might be a very good place to put it for
  150. us consumption right uh I wonder if we could speak a little bit about the public policy implications uh what can
  151. the government do to accelerate this trend of manufacturing jobs coming back sure well the government can play an
  152. important role uh hopefully we can get the the Democrats and the Republicans and Congress to actually unite around
  153. creating more jobs for Americans um because it will require legislation to do this and uh if they decide to
  154. continue to fight a war amongst themselves and not look after the American people that's going to be a
  155. problem but assuming that happens you know we can accelerate the trend that we predicted by several years which means a
  156. whole lot more jobs sooner and a whole lot more strengthen the American economy and it's going to take several things
  157. obviously there's tax policy implications uh we may want to look at you know all those funds that the that
  158. us companies aren't repatriating to the US uh and potentially you know give those in in essence let them take bring
  159. them back as a in a in in a non-t taxable or low tax form if they create new jobs in manufacturing plants to tie
  160. them over to that point in 2015 where the numbers start to cross over uh we can look at you know trying to make sure
  161. the playing field is leveled for us manufacturing it isn't right now um and there you know are clearly predatory
  162. practices that take place we're seeing a step up in the government from anti anti- dumping and other sorts of things
  163. which is there there's a lot of things that can be done including you know increas in training um you know we can
  164. think about uh both uh subsidization of training for new workers because if you build a new manufacturing plant you have
  165. to train the workers that goes on in China we could do that in the US and we could think about actually expanding our
  166. educational system um we all you know tell our children and it's the right thing to do that you should get a
  167. college education um but you know you can also learn a trade in a college education I believe at Borton I not only
  168. got a great liberal arts education but I also got learned a very important trade
  169. that stood me well in life uh but we can think about a vocational version of that
  170. in which you have a four-year college that you know as as I did at Warden I did basically two years of liberal arts
  171. and two years of business uh that was the way the program works uh we can do do the same thing but it could be two
  172. years of liberal arts and two years of Plumbing or welding or other skills that would be appropriate for the new
  173. manufacturing era that we're entering does the US need a a new industrial policy do you think I think what the US
  174. needs is a job policy um we can talk about industrial policy and that's something that we may want to focus on
  175. but there are there's a jobs policy and we should be thinking about where uh where we want to place our bets in terms
  176. of jobs uh the kinds of things that we want to do the industries that we want to make sure Industries for the future
  177. to make sure that the US is not locked out of those um clearly green energy is an issue it has its ups and downs uh but
  178. fundamentally at some point in time the world's got to move to Green energy because we're going to run out of fossil
  179. fuels we've continued to find more but uh it gets more and more expensive and that means green energy will be
  180. important whether it's in two years or 5 years or 10 years or 20 years uh we don't want to be left out of Industries
  181. like that uh I remember from our past conversations that you've done a great of work on uh
  182. globalization uh can you help uh situate this uh what's going on within the broader trend of where do you see the
  183. global economy itself evolving to and what are some of the long-term implications of the manufacturing Gren s
  184. we're seeing in the US well I've spent a lot of time as you as you know um thinking about globalization and how the
  185. world's evolving and I think this is just another piece in the puzzle that that uh fell on my doorstep so the
  186. initial wave of globalization uh was uh in Western companies looking at the lowcost markets setting up manufacturing
  187. or Outsourcing manufacturing eventually to companies in those markets to produce
  188. and to sell the product back into the the Western markets or the developed World
  189. Markets um the second wave was this growth of what we called the challengers uh companies that were saying hey I can
  190. manufacture this stuff but I don't want to be just doing it and putting your name on it I want to manufacture it and
  191. have my name on it I want to be the big player I don't want to be just a supplier uh I want to get the big
  192. margins and I want to have my own brand uh and that was the second wave and we saw many Global Challengers emerge and
  193. do incredibly well but what's taking place is the next step in economics because economics as I learned here at
  194. Warden are all about the evolution of them they're never permanent they change all the time and what's taking place is
  195. with the wage rising in China and all the other uh wage all the other costs that are rising overall in China um the
  196. e ecomics are now shifting back towards the logic of us production and that's the third wave of globalization we're
  197. reaching a new equilibrium at least with China it's not happened yet with a lot of the other countries and it may over
  198. time we'll see how it plays out but we're seeing a new equilibrium of globalization which would be more of a
  199. steady state until there's some perturbation that would change that but we're seeing the fundamentals of the
  200. economics equilibrating between the US and China now as that happens we're seeing some second order effects too
  201. because the system that we have here in the US is very different than the European system the European system for
  202. most of the countries have very high exit barriers and of course High exit barriers mean that you're more reluctant
  203. to build a new plant because once you have a plant there the costs to get out are are very low will in the US we could
  204. debate Which social system is better but in the US the facts are just different it's a lot easier to get out of being in
  205. a plant if you don't need it and so the fundamentals are starting to shift and what we see is European companies not
  206. just us companies looking at produc ing in the US first for domestic consumption
  207. and we see the car companies have been doing this for a long time but other companies are thinking about it as well
  208. as Japanese companies who are are doing the same thing uh but also to think about the us as an export platform so
  209. one company zans uh set up a a a power turbine uh plant in I believe it's in Georgia uh where they make Power
  210. turbines uh and they've just signed an order with Saudi Arabia to ship from Georgia six major power tur
  211. um quite an interesting thing that we see uh we see announcements by some of the Japanese automakers as thinking
  212. about the us as an export platform now that's why jobs are going to be rising in the US and that's the real sign that
  213. what we're talking about in the shift in economics is really happening because people are putting their money down
  214. making some very important decisions and realizing that the US has a very high highly productive Workforce a very
  215. flexible Workforce uh and the ability to be a very lowcost manufacturing platform
  216. for some very important industries which areas in the US do you think will benefit most from this well
  217. we used to think it would be the southern part of the us for the most part um but actually our thinking has
  218. evolved on that um as we begin to understand the wage differential is a lot lower than we might have thought
  219. because the averages are misleading um we got to look at wages for the startup of new plants not for uh existing plants
  220. and so uh our new thinking is that it's going to happen in most States and interestingly enough we're seeing things
  221. in places that we never thought we'd see we're seeing plants of this nature open
  222. in places like Ohio we're seeing it in California we're seeing it in the rest of the Pacific Northwest it's very
  223. interesting it isn't it isn't an issue of um right to work states It's actually an issue of where it makes sense to
  224. produce great hell thanks so much for speaking with us today you're [Music] welcome
  225. [Music]

Brief Summary

Hal Sirkin discusses the resurgence of American manufacturing and factors driving job growth, challenging the notion of its decline.

Key points

  • The Resilience of US Manufacturing. Despite popular belief, US manufacturing is not in decline but evolving with economic shifts.
  • Rising Wages in China. Wage increases in China are reshaping global manufacturing dynamics, making US production more viable.
  • Manufacturing Renaissance in the US. Companies are increasingly bringing manufacturing jobs back to the US due to changing economics.
  • The Shift to Green Energy. The world must transition to green energy to avoid running out of fossil fuels.
  • Globalization's Next Wave. The third wave of globalization is shifting economics back towards US production.
  • Manufacturing in Unexpected Places. New manufacturing plants are opening in states like Ohio and California, defying expectations.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes